11 ms·
Subscriptions are just the wrong model for news publishers. There's NO way I could possibly afford to subscribe to every news output I occasionally read news f
by mindcrime 9y ago
Subscriptions are just the wrong model for news publishers. There's NO way I could possibly afford to subscribe to every news output I occasionally read news from, unless the subscriptions were so close to free as to be useless as a revenue source for the publisher. It's just not going to happen.
What we desperately need is a real, useful micro-payments model where you can pay per-article. I'd be happy to pay you a few cents, or a dollar, or whatever, for each of the 3 or 4 articles I read on your site per month. But I'm not buying a subscription just to read 3 or 4 articles. The economics just don't work.
- visarga 9y ago> What we desperately need is a real, useful micro payments model where you can pay per-article. That would incentivize hit-and-run articles that cause sensation to milk micropayments, leading to a spiral of clickbait even worse than that caused by advertising.
- sp332 9y agoI don't see it. Clickbait headlines just need to get you to the page even if the article is crap. Microtransactions would require articles to be worth something to the reader.
- davidcbc 9y agoHow will the reader know that the article is worth something unless they pay?
- infinityplus1 9y agoWon't they pay after reading the article and decide if it's worth it?
- sp332 9y agoThat's what I was thinking. And if not, they'll have to convince people like any other kind of media: reviews, previews, or even refunds.
- dragonwriter 9y agoHeadlines are previews, and clickbait is just making the preview oversell the content, and is the natural result of pay-per-view micropayments, which a what web advertising is.
- davidcbc 9y agoWhy would they pay after they already read the article? If it is on the honor system people just aren't going to pay.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoIf you pay a fixed access fee either way, then it's just the matter of you deciding who gets the money. Since the money is already "spent", you may as well vote on the articles you like.
- davidcbc 9y agoMicropayments and a fixed access fee are completely different models in my opinion. With micropayments you are making small payments for articles as you go and not paying a fixed fee, the problem with that is that you end up with click bait headlines that people will pay for and garbage for actual content.
- dredmorbius 9y agoMicropayments don't scale either. Public funding for information. It's a public good. Treat it as one. https://www.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/2vm2da/why_information_goods_and_markets_are_a_poor_match/ https://www.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/2vm2da/why_inf... See GC Presents, "At the Graduate Center, we believe knowledge is a public good. This idea inspires our research, teaching, and public events. We invite you to join us for timely discussions, diverse cultural perspectives, and thought-provoking ideas.". https://www.gc.cuny.edu/Public-Programming/GC-Presents https://www.gc.cuny.edu/Public-Programming/GC-Presents See GC President Chase F. Robinson, introducing a conversation between Paul Krugman and Olivier Blanchard. A rare moment where the introduction itself contains some provocative thoughts. At about 50s into the video. (The remaining 72 minutes and 20 seconds aren't bad either if you're interested in discussions of global economics.) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zndOEQnMC44 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zndOEQnMC44 Joseph Stiglitz, "Knowledge as a Global Public Good," in Global Public Goods: International Cooperation in the 21st Century, Inge Kaul, Isabelle Grunberg, Marc A. Stern (eds.), United Nations Development Programme, New York: Oxford University Press, 1999, pp. 308-325. http://s1.downloadmienphi.net/file/downloadfile6/151/1384343.pdf http://s1.downloadmienphi.net/file/downloadfile6/151/1384343...
- eachro 9y agoThis seemslike a reasonable idea but then you get into the hairy situation of government endorsing different biases. You can bet that a conservative pres/congress is going to push public funding towards more conservative sources and likewise for more liberal pres/congress. State funded news sources is not where we want to go.
- dredmorbius 9y agoWe already have a system in which those who pay the piper instill biases. Government is, at least, answerable (in theory) to the people in a way that no other alternative I'm aware of is: advertising, patronage, religious sponsorship. Media are inherently propagandistic -- there is always an exceptionally strong incentive to manipulating, diverting, distracting, or otherwise controlling the public or oligarchical discussion.
- s3r3nity 9y agoIf you think about it and abstract a bit, this is sort of the point of ads. Seeing an ad or two on display is like a micropayment of X cents to the content owner.
- dredmorbius 9y agoExcept that advertising itself sets up perverse incentives and numerous negative externalities. It's also not free -- the world collectively pays over $600 billion for it, much of that from the advanced industrial nations, numbering roughly 1 billion people, so about $600 per person. Contrast that with direct media expenditures of about $125 to $150 or so per person.
- NeutronBoy 9y ago> What we desperately need is a real, useful micro-payments model where you can pay per-article The other side of the coin is that if you're a news organisation, "the economics just don't work" with micro payments. You can't fund a month long investigative report based on micropayments, even if it produces a prize-winning piece, if you don't have guaranteed income to support it. What happens if you spend the month investigating and don't find anything? Micro-payment per-article will only encourage "safe" journalism - articles that you know will resonate with your readers, rather than controversial pieces or in-depth, resource intensive research.
- jellicle 9y agoThat ship sailed a long time ago. The current status quo IS micro-payment per article, only it comes from advertisers instead of readers.
- stefco_ 9y agoYes, but unlike clickbait advertising, microtransactions actually encourage a positive publisher-reader relationship. If you trust a news source to do good journalism and if you don't have to jump through hoops to pay for an article, my bet is that most people would happily throw down ¢10 or something for a good short read (or more for a better read). Conversely, I would be even more reluctant to read click bait if I was asked to pay to view it. So I think that micropayments is similar from a maximizing clicks perspective, but the incentive is actually to build a great relationship with readers.
- Cleisthenes 9y agoMy bet is you are overly optimistic and instead will have click bait for people with disposable income seeking articles that they can use to prove their point.
- smsm42 9y agoTo prove their point, other people must be able to read this article. Which means somebody has to pay for it. Maybe they should make sponsored links - if you have disposable income, finance 1000 people reading this article, in hope they get convinced by it. That'd be putting your money where your mouth is!
- codemac 9y agoHere's what bothers me about micro-payments: How does a consumer actually evaluate the price of the good? How do I not browse to nytimes.com, because the subcent per scroll price has gone up? I don't actually have an answer, but it's one that bothers me.
- Shivetya 9y agowe are seeing/going to see a replay of such with streaming services as well. everyone wants their piece of a pie that isn't large enough for them. the news has it harder as its content is not necessarily as unique as individual tv shows. the editorial content is unique per paper and a valid revenue stream provided the paper can assemble a valuable enough team with broad appeal. however charging for national and international news? too much competition, this is the last place to bet the paper on
- ripdog 9y agoMicropayments for most major US news outlets already exists - check out Blendle.com. It's in closed beta right now, but works great, and invites are easy to come by. It does require you to read articles on its own website and not the original publisher's, but it's a nice clean layout. You own (a license for) articles once you pay for them. There's also fast, automated refunds if you don't like an article.
- Theodores 9y agoThanks for that, not heard of them, sounds like a good business model, I wish them the best but I won't be investing.
- ripdog 9y agoUh, invest? Why not just use them and recommend them to friends? They need users most of all.
- bluetwo 9y agoI've been using them for a couple months and like the service. They send a daily email with a summary of the news and links and I have found they do a good job of curating news. Only gripe would be the price per article, which I assume they negotiate with each publisher, since it varies widely. As more people us e it I would hope this comes down a bit.
- chatmasta 9y agoUnfortunately, what we will get is a model where you pay Google some amount of money, and they divvy it up amongst the publishers. AdWords/AdSense solved micro payments by bundling $0.01 clicks into monthly segments and. I expect google to try the same model with publishers, especially since a) adblockers are increasing, and b) google has already proved it can bully publishers into signing up for any "service" it offers.
- ehsankia 9y agoIsn't that more or less what Google Contributor program was trying to do?
- sgk284 9y agoUnfortunately, micropayments encourage click-bait and pop-news (but that's not to say that advertising doesn't either). We've also have seen other failure modes with payment-per-article in academic journals, though payment is much larger there, so may not be a fair comparison. In general a la carte payments usually lead to overall higher costs (e.g. Classic Blockbuster vs. Netflix). My ideal system would be a Spotify-like system. I'd pay a flat rate for access to all news and then each organization gets a percentage of my payment proportional to the number of articles I read by them. That is, if I pay $10/mo and 50% of the things I read are on the New York Times, then they'd get $5 (ignoring margin for whatever entity manages this exchange). I can't ever imagine news orgs opt-ing into this model though. Perhaps Apple could pull an iTunes-equivalent with Apple News?
- always_good 9y agoThat model effectively shuts down all news sites that don't make it into the News-Spotify program. Kinda of like how my telcom gives everyone "free Messenger/Whatsapp" so nobody is going to use anything but Messenger/Whatsapp. Centralization is just going to get worse and worse until the internet feels like AOL back in 2000.
- tpeo 9y agoActually, I think the opposite might happen. If click-bait works by obfuscating the real headline of the article, then readers might choose not to click on a link due to uncertainty aversion. To put it simply, if click-bait works when you don't know what the article is about and it costs nothing to know, charging a fee (no matter how small) could kill it.
- dragonwriter 9y agoWith modern web payment models and analytics, advertising is basically third-party micropayments, so it has all the adverse impacts of micropayments plus all the adverse impacts of the bill being paid by third parties whose interests are different from and often adverse to the news consumer.
- 1123581321 9y agoChances are that you're not willing to spend enough per month. The music industry is (according to googling) about $25BB a year for live events and $15BB a year for retail (streaming, downloads, discs, etc.) Spotify's revenue is about $3BB/year, ballpark 10% of the revenue needed to support the music industry. (Spotify has its own expenses, which we are ignoring.) News media can't command live event revenue the way music can, and their physical sales are disappearing faster than music's. That suggests, to use the music analogy, that subscribers to a Spotify-like system would have to support most of the approximately $25BB that this industry commands. Depending on how many news readers there are compared to music listeners, that's possibly $50-150/mo that would need to be asked of subscribers. Outside of Financial Times subscribers (even that $600/year is ad-subsidized), most people aren't willing to spend this much on a newspaper. You can quibble with the numbers, but ultimately the news industry is more reliant on individual subscribers than the music industry.
- silverbax88 9y agoThat exists. It's called Blendle, and it's awesome.
- jawns 9y ago> What we desperately need is a real, useful micro-payments model where you can pay per-article. Former news editor here. I have spent a loooong time thinking about how to help my beloved news industry find a payment model that works. I've become convinced that a "cable subscription" model has more promise than a micropayments model. Here's what's wrong with a micropayments model. Each microtransaction is an additional cost incurred by the user, and in many models that cost can vary based on the website visited and other factors. And so every single time you choose to engage in a microtransaction, you have to do some brief mental gymnastics to determine whether the transaction is valuable enough to you to proceed. It may be only a few cents, so for many people it's not a big deliberation, but the decision is always there, every time. The benefit of this approach is that there's very little economic waste involved; you pay only for what you buy. But it encourages stingy, penny-pinching behavior, and that's horrible for adoption. If you want broad, mass-market support, it's a big problem. Under the cable subscription model, you pay a fixed monthly fee for access to a large number of "channels," and in return you can access those channels as much as you want. Under the hood, that subscription fee can be doled out to each channel based on how much it's accessed, or divided equally, or by some other method in between. But to the end user, it's an all-you-can-eat buffet, and they just don't need to think about it. Part of the fee they're paying is for content itself and part of it is for the convenience of not having to regulate usage. The downside of this approach is that there's more economic waste involved; some light users won't get their money's worth and will end up subsidizing heavy users. But it discourages stingy behavior, and that's great for adoption. Later on down the line, once the cable-subscription model has been widely adopted, the market will eventually demand more a la carte payment models (we see this happening right now in the fairly mature cable television industry). But for right now, widespread adoption should be the primary focus of any online payment model. Ultimately, a good number of the major U.S. news publishers would need to get on board, and to date they have been relatively unwilling to cooperate (which may be due to regulatory hurdles). But I'm pretty sure that's what needs to happen. Less sure whether it will be enough to save the industry.
- tpeo 9y agoWhy not both?
- 9y ago
- jjcm 9y agoHere's the approach I've been working on: -Pay $~4/mo -Every upvote you give during that month (not just views, since I think views encourage clickbait) gives an equal slice of that $4 pie. -At the end of the month, a flat $1 goes to pay for server costs, then the rest is distributed evenly between every upvote. You can see a mini-demo here: http://syd.jjcm.org/soci/ http://syd.jjcm.org/soci/ The nice part of it is it ranks by quality while distributing payments. Since payouts happen at the end of the month, it gives a buffer zone to "unvote" something should it turn out to be fake/stolen/etc. The $1/mo for server costs should be more than enough per user to keep things running smoothly without the need for ads/selling user data. I'm working on it solo right now, if anyone is interested in helping out I'd be more than happy to share the project. Or if you're just inspired by it, go ahead and copy it. I think it's a solid model and is worth pursuing, though I'd also appreciate criticism on it.
- pavlov 9y agoThat's basically what Medium is doing now, right? They offer $5/month subscriptions, and the money from subscribers is distributed among those writers who published members-only content based on the amount of "claps" (likes) each subscriber gave.
- magic_beans 9y agoI'm surprised people pay for Medium. The quality of their brand seems to me a little diluted by the many half-baked, amateur articles published through their platform. It's basically thought catalog. Though I do of course enjoy the articles from reputable sources.
- jjcm 9y agoSimilar yea, though Medium is strictly blog posts. I feel like with the issues youtube is having with advertisers right now and things like imgur trying to monetize image hosting there needs to be a content platform that supports all media types.
- IanCal 9y agoCan you talk about how this compares to flattr?
- jimmaswell 9y agoI like the idea of browsers doing coin mining to use your electricity for micropayments, like a few sites already do.
- habosa 9y agoTry Blendle. It does exactly what you want.
- shinamee 9y agoI think you're talking about https://blendle.com/ https://blendle.com/
- smsm42 9y agoI probably won't pay a dollar per article, that'd be hundreds of bucks per month for me (if you count all articles I read, skim or glance at), but I'd pay a couple of cents. The problem is I don't see how to make pricing structure transparent, and how to avoid gateway problems like we have with cable TV - where to get 3 channels you need you have to subscribe to 200 channels of junk and pay for it all. There should be a model where it does not incur significant cognitive load when I want to read an article, and does not allow abuse by dishonest players. I imagine some billionaires could be made that way. Brave browser team seems to be working on something like that, no idea how good it would be...
- stevenwoo 9y agoThe Guardian lets do one time payments. You have to get past them asking for subscriptions but the option is there. I would like to give to The Atlantic without getting a paper subscription but they don't have that last time I looked.