16 ms·
Portugal treats addiction as a disease, not a crime
- anythingnonidin 9y agoGreat to see this in the NYT. Drug use should be treated as a health issue, not a criminal issue.
- crispinb 9y agoThis has been understood in policy circles for decades, with the WoD incontestably the most egregiously failed policy driver in modern times. It's hard to imagine even a fairly prominent NYT article extending discussion very far in the US public sphere, given that nation's current subjection to tribal and atavistic affiliation rather than rationality.
- RhysU 9y agoAddiction is a health issue. Experimenting prior to addiction is clearly not.
- hfourm 9y agoNot sure if you are trying to distinguish a difference but, surely you aren't suggesting that drug experimentation or recreational usage should be criminal?
- vkou 9y agoThe parent poster is explicitly saying that smoking a few joints in college, or taking some LSD once at a rave is not a health issue. They are right. Saying that does not imply that they endorse criminalization.
- RhysU 9y agoNot taking a stand on that, just pointing out that not all users of illicit drugs are addicts.
- simonh 9y agoThis thread is full of smartasses 'well actualy'-ing irrelevant picky distinctions of no particular substance. I'm not going to go at all of them, but lucky you! Medical problems associated with drugs go way beyond just addiction. Kids can die on their first use of a drug, even on a dose that would normally be forced be harmless, due to other factors such as dehydration, alcohol consumption or overheating. Even without becoming addicted, drugs can have other harmful medical effects. The sheer scale of the simpleminded ignorance of this comment is staggering.
- empath75 9y ago10s of thousands of people go to the hospital every year for Tylenol overdoses and hundreds die. That doesn’t mean any use of Tylenol is abuse.
- simonh 9y agoOf course not. Lots of controlled substances have legitimate medical uses. I don't get your point.
- zanny 9y agoLife is dangerous, and it is more valuable to work to educate people on the danger around them than to try banning it by rewriting reality to treat dangers like they don't exist by outlawing them. It is why kids think "that cannot happen to me". Because its criminal. Because its the plight of the "other". Because its told like a monster in a fable rather than a fact of life and an emergent property of our society and biology.
- simonh 9y agoI agree I'm pro-decriminalisation of drug use and for regulated legal distribution.
- tpm 9y agoKids can die on their first use of a horse or a bicycle. Or any subsequent. With higher probability than lots of illegal drugs.
- anythingnonidin 9y agoThanks, yes. I should've said 'drug abuse is a health issue.'
- worik 9y agoDrugs are a social justice issue. Not a health issue. Drug abuse is a health issue. Most drug use is not abuse.
- anythingnonidin 9y agoYes, good correction, thank you.
- rodolphoarruda 9y agoHow does it treat the international drug dealing cartels (root cause of the disease)?
- nebabyte 9y agoAs a crime capitalizing on perpetuating a disease? How else do you think they would.
- kobeya 9y agoDrug use is decriminalized. Drug distribution is not.
- enjo 9y agoThe root cause of the disease is that people like drugs. The cartels are a symptom of the larger problem, not the other way around.
- rodolphoarruda 9y agoIf you eliminate the cartels, would people continue to use/like drugs? Would they look for other forms of addiction?
- dfischer 9y agoYes
- hfourm 9y agoFurther, even if you did "eliminate" the cartels, more would pop up. If there is a demand, someone will find a way to make money off of it.
- dalore 9y agoIf you eliminate one two more pop up in its place. The demand it there. If you cut off supply it will go somewhere else. If you treat it as a disease then you look at why the demand. Reduce the demand (or give a legal supply) and drug cartels can't operate.
- wnevets 9y agoI kinda dislike calling addiction a disease. You can't just decide to stop having cancer unlike addiction. Even tho addiction is all about a person's brain chemistry being completely out of whack, alcoholics and other addicts will often have a so called "moment of clarity". No such "moment of clarity" exist for other diseases.
- pstuart 9y agoLet's just call it a "health issue"
- kjsnvksdjfn 9y agoFor most you can't just "decide" to stop being addicted either.
- jonex 9y agoThe fact that someone, in 2017, would imply that addicted people could just decide to stop being addicted seems to me as reason enough to keep calling it a disease. Just to fight that notion.
- gozur88 9y agoYou can, with sufficient motivation. The problem is people with that kind of motivation tend not to become junkies in the first place.
- flachsechs 9y agothere are plenty of rich, workaholic, yuppie addicts. professional drive is oftentimes counterbalanced with substance abuse. makes me wonder what kind of crazy bubble you grew up in. what a strange belief to have.
- wellboy 9y agoHe still has a point. Often, addicts quit cold turkey after a moment of clarity. That doesn't mean that it is not an illness.
- sulizilxia 9y agoI've often thought that substance access needs to be completely deregulated, for drugs of abuse as well as other medications. This would increase access and competition among providers, and avoid rent-seeking kinds of economic problems in the health care market. It would also lead to better treatment of substance use problems, and kill cartels by decreasing their monopoly on production and distribution. In doing so, you could move to a kind of competency-based system akin to what happens with people who have dementia or cognitive impairments. Basically, you're legally entitled to buy whatever meds you want, until you're deemed incompetent to make that decision. Processes could be set up whereby mental health professionals (psychiatrists, psychologists), ethicists, and the judicial system could make determinations that an individual is not competent to make decisions about the substance use purchasing due to addiction. This might sound kind of draconian, but decisions about competency could be make pretty thorough, requiring a petition, stringent evaluation criteria involving panels and a judicial decision. It would also be dramatically less restrictive than the current system, that basically assumes everyone is incompetent to make drug-related decisions based on the specific drug. It would also emphasize that the lack of competency is a health-related problem, and not a criminal problem.
- emmab 9y ago> Processes could be set up whereby mental health professionals (psychiatrists, psychologists), ethicists, and the judicial system could make determinations that an individual is not competent to make decisions about the substance use purchasing due to addiction. These would be abused. People would be told that they're categorically unable to consent for being LGBT.
- sulizilxia 9y agoWithout meaning to be dismissive, I doubt that would happen in the US at least at this point in time. And to the extent it did happen, there would be bigger problems to worry about. Determinations of competency already happen in the US for all sorts of reasons. I'm not saying it's perfect by any means, and that it doesn't get abused, but the abuse of that system pales in comparison to abuses under the current drug enforcement and regulation system. Personally, I am for complete unrestricted deregulation, but I can see issues around liability for providers, arguments about actual competency to decide, etc., and treating it like other forms of competency decision seems like one mechanism to address that. Medically speaking it seems like the same situation to me as competency issues due to other forms of neuropsychological incapacitation.
- notadoc 9y agoAddiction is a chemical dependency. It is neither a disease or a crime, it's usually a symptom of something else. Substance abuse and addiction tends to originate from either a variety of sociological factors, or treatment (self or prescribed). A very large number of addicts are simply self medicating for one reason or another. Or at least they started off that way. Even if society determines addiction and substance usage to be criminal, it's a victimless crime and a waste of resources.
- miles 9y ago"Addiction is a chemical dependency. It is neither a disease or a crime [...]" Apparently the AMA and others disagree: https://www.centeronaddiction.org/what-addiction/addiction-disease https://www.centeronaddiction.org/what-addiction/addiction-d... "Addiction is defined as a disease by most medical associations, including the American Medical Association and the American Society of Addiction Medicine. Like diabetes, cancer and heart disease, addiction is caused by a combination of behavioral, environmental and biological factors. Genetic risks factors account for about half of the likelihood that an individual will develop addiction. Addiction involves changes in the functioning of the brain and body. These changes may be brought on by risky substance use or may pre-exist."
- notadoc 9y agoThat's OK, not everyone has to agree about a particular description. If medicine gets to the point where a single substance or chemical can be easily avoided to entirely prevent diabetes, cancer, or heart disease, the same way that someone can entirely avoid alcoholism by simply not drinking alcohol, that will be quite an achievement. But this ignores the strong sociological component of addiction and substance abuse. Nobody is choosing to try cancer to self medicate depression, nobody is testing out heart disease to treat their pain or torment, and nobody is giving diabetes a whirl to address a sociological condition.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- 9y ago
- purplezooey 9y agoWonder what Ayn Rand would have to say on the subject. That will tell us where our country is headed. She was also a user of amphetamines, btw.
- astronautjones 9y agoI hope this is in jest
- purplezooey 9y ago;-) At least somebody got the joke.
- jacquesm 9y agoAyn Rand had lots to say on many subjects but hardly any of it was useful or constructive. Though that doesn't stop a whole pile of people from worshiping her every word because it plays into their own wishes for how they'd like the world to work.
- andai 9y agoI haven't read much Ayn Rand but what I've read so far seems pretty straightforward. I'm curious to learn more, could you tell me about some of the problems you've found with her ideas?
- smsm42 9y agoThe headline reads eerie, almost as a quote from some anti-utopian novel. "This weird place treats diabetes as a disease, not a crime!". "That weird country over there treats depression as a disease, not a crime!". I mean, how messed up should we be to not see this as the only way to treat it?
- Swizec 9y agoWell technically everyone treats addiction as disease. It’s the possession buying and selling part that’s a crime. You’re free to be addicted to anything you want as long as you’re not buying keeping or selling prohibited substances.
- unlmtd1 9y agoIt isn't a crime; it is punished by the ruling warlords. And it isn't the buying/possession of narcotics which is forbidden. What they forbid is to buy narcotics which have been grown/made by the warlords enemies (free independent people)
- mistercow 9y agoThis is an aggressively unproductive way to frame the situation.
- smsm42 9y agoThat's like saying "you are free to require food and feel hungry, it's just actual eating that is a crime" and then calling people criminals when they still try to eat.
- omegaham 9y agoThe difference is that addicts are actively malicious to their family members and broader society. Depressed people and diabetics are hurting themselves either through action or inaction, but I've never been threatened by a diabetic or depressive outside a Circle K. I have been threatened by a criddler outside a Circle K. Similarly, few people get all of their stuff stolen out of their house by a diabetic or depressive. They do all the time when their son is addicted to heroin. Depressives don't prostitute their kids to drug dealers for crack, etc. Drug addiction is one of the few diseases where the patient actively attacks all of the people who are in a position to help him. That generally alienates people who tend to be otherwise generous toward the down-and-out. The laws reflect that, and it takes a superhuman effort of rationality to say, "Yes, addicts do terrible things. Other solutions produce better results than the natural impulse of doing terrible things back to them." Edit: We see this in the nastier forms of mental illness, too. People are generally compassionate toward those with OCD, eating disorders, and so on. Those with borderline personality disorder or bipolar disorder tend to be relegated to "batshit insane" and viewed with utter contempt. Again, the difference is that someone with anorexia nervosa isn't going to pull a Carrie Underwood[1] on your car, but someone with BPD might. [1]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WaSy8yy-mr8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WaSy8yy-mr8
- teabee89 9y agoI'm not sure the graph entitled "A Stark Difference: Drug-Related Deaths" proves any point: Portugal has indeed the best stats and the US the worst, but you cannot conclude that it results from Portugal's vs US's policy on drugs. In fact, France, right below Portugal on the graph, still has quite repressive policies.
- alexnewman 9y agoTell me about these policies. Why are the French policies repressive
- jacquesm 9y agoWell, they're repressive enough that the French come to NL and Portugal in droves to get their drugs.
- chrischen 9y agoI think if you polled American's on whether the legal drinking age should be lowered from 21, most people, if not a significant majority would probably be in favor of it. In fact, a majority have probably violated such a law. If it turns out true, then it means there's something fundamentally wrong with the legal and voting system where somehow it completely restricts itself from the ability to enact a change in the laws in this area. And if this can't be achieved, there's no hope for any progressive drug use laws.
- SOLAR_FIELDS 9y agoThe legal drinking age in the USA has a long and storied history that mainly has to do with MADD and the Reagan administration. The most straightforward and sensible opposition can be explained in a single sentence: “If I am old enough to die for my country and mandated by law to sign up to do so, why am I not legally allowed to have a beer before doing so?” Regarding your comments about the voting system: of course they are true. How long will the hypocrisy manifest itself before it is changed is the true question.
- KGIII 9y agoThey have done that poll. It's exactly opposite of what you think. They've done this poll lots of times. The results are rather consistent. Here is one such example: http://politicalticker.blogs.cnn.com/2014/07/24/do-you-want-the-drinking-age-lowered/ http://politicalticker.blogs.cnn.com/2014/07/24/do-you-want-... That was just the first result. Anyhow, we don't always want majority rule. At one time, the majority of people felt it was okay to own people. I suspect you can find areas where the majority of people don't think we should have equal rights for certain classes of people.
- Clubber 9y ago>Anyhow, we don't always want majority rule. You do in a democracy. >At one time, the majority of people felt it was okay to own people. Until they decided it wasn't ok, and an abolitionist president was elected. >I suspect you can find areas where the majority of people don't think we should have equal rights for certain classes of people. Like civil rights for gays. Also solved by voting. The problem I have with the 21 year old drinking age is it now allows police to jail college kids at will, essentially limiting their life's prospects. Again the punishment is worse than the crime.
- grondilu 9y agoThis article changed my view on the subject a bit. Lately, I had been watching various documentaries and YouTube videos about the opioid crisis in the USA and Canada. Often, the public policy seemed absurd to me, as it was just as if the first responder services were offering free customer support for the drug business. They used Naloxone to save the lives of customers who should normally have overdosed, and with no supervision afterwards, those addicts were soon back in the street where they keep buying and consuming. A drug that is too lethal has very little commercial viability. By decreasing the lethality of drugs, first responders support the drug business, which is absurd. I started reading this article expecting it to enforce my position, but I had to acknowledge the fact that apparently, this policy did indeed reduce drug usage in that country. That puzzled me a bit as I was struggling to see how making consumption easier could reduce consumption, but then they mentioned how they provide methadone, and that seemed like a sensible explanation. They don't provide customer support by just giving naloxone for instance, as I saw they do in US and Canada, they also provide an opioid substitute, which should hopefully reduce the likelihood of a relapse.
- jacquesm 9y agoMany countries take this approach. https://decorrespondent.nl/6562/het-zelden-vertelde-verhaal-over-het-nederlandse-drugsbeleid-dat-wel-slaagde/831216079738-b19faae6 https://decorrespondent.nl/6562/het-zelden-vertelde-verhaal-... Amsterdam, 1985, the government supplied methadone using an old city bus they transformed into a drug dispensary, they even supplied clean needles for free.
- grondilu 9y ago> Amsterdam, 1985, the government supplied methadone using an old city bus they transformed into a drug dispensary, they even supplied clean needles for free. In the documentary I was mentioning (sorry, can't find a link or remember the title), I saw something like that in Canada (IIRC). It was a room with needles, with a nurse or something to supervise and monitor injections. And of course there were doses of Narcan in case an OD happens. But no methadone whatsoever was offered. Or if there was, it wasn't mentioned. So basically the government was paying to provide an infrastructure for drug consumption. In other words : customer support. It's as if they were working for drug dealers. To me that's outrageous.
- newsmania 9y agoMake drugs legal. Impose a 15% tax on each sale with all money devoted to rehabbing addicts. Problem solved.
- KGIII 9y agoComplex problems don't usually have solutions that fit comfortably on bumper stickers.
- dingo_bat 9y agoAlthough I agree with your assessment, you could have tried to actually point out some problem in the parent's "solution". I can think of one: you would still have to incentivize people to go the legal way and pay 15% more. Which could be another intractable problem.
- KGIII 9y agoThe myriad problems with just getting the political willpower to legalize drugs, is a starter. Then, there is the mechanism to do so - like what do you do with those already convicted? How does one make it so that it's even a realistic discussion being had by the average citizen? What about individual States? Etc...
- newsmania 9y agoWhy would they pay more? First, convenience - it's right in the store, you can just buy it without having to do a shady deal where you might get killed. Second, big drug companies at scale will be able to manufacture for much less. Third, there is a premium you have to pay for anything illegal to compensate the seller for the risk. So they are paying higher than it's worth anyways.
- GordonS 9y ago> you would still have to incentivize people to go the legal way and pay 15% more It seems to work just fine for tobacco and alcohol - a black market certainly exists for these drugs, but it's tiny in comparison with legal sales. On top of this, the increase in safety - getting a pure product that is what it claims to be - would likely be a no-brainer for most users.
- shasheene 9y ago"The [Portuguese] Health Ministry spends less than $10 per citizen per year on its successful drug policy. Meanwhile, the U.S. has spent some $10,000 per household (more than $1 trillion) over the decades on a failed drug policy that results in more than 1,000 deaths each week." That's a intellectually dishonest and misleading statement: it's comparing Portuguese annual cost per citizen to US cumulative multi-decade cost per household.
- dragonwriter 9y agoUnless the US has 10 citizens per household and the period in question is 10 decades, the point still stands that the Portuguese policy is cheaper per citizen as well as more successful. (The actual numbers are more like 2 and 4 than 10 and 10.)
- lgas 9y agoSo what's the average number of citizens per household? 3? 5? Even at 5 which seems high, that's $2,000/citizen with ~56k deaths vs $10/citizen and deaths in the low tens of people. I agree it would've been better off with a more apples-to-apples comparison, but let's not miss the forest for the trees here.
- rxhernandez 9y agoYou missed the part where the cost is split by decades not just household. It's not to say that I support US drug policy, because I don't, it's that this really is dishonest journalism.
- bonzini 9y ago$2000/40 years is still five times as much.
- aoeusnth1 9y agoWhen you hear: - ..spends less than $10 per citizen per year - Meanwhile, the U.S. has spent some $10,000 per household... Do you think to yourself, "yeah, that sounds like about 5x"? The presentation of the data is clearly cherry-picked to make it sound as bad as possible for the US.
- mherrmann 9y agoAn acquaintance of mine runs a rehab center for addicts. I really like his view on addiction. It's that addicts often had traumatic experiences, eg during childhood, and that drug abuse is a way of "self medication" to cope with them.
- jacquesm 9y agoI've known quite a few addicts (> 10, this is a direct consequence of living in Amsterdam and the attraction the city has on drug users and the fact that pushers would hand drugs to school children when I was in high school, though fortunately it seems - to me at least - as if the Heroin epidemic is past its peak). Not a single one of them would fit that category. Most of them were perfectly ordinary people before sliding into addiction. It was a series of smaller steps or thrill seeking behavior in all of those cases. Some of the addicts were actually amongst the smartest people I knew before they got addicted. I'm sure there are those who use drugs as an escape route from some miserable experience early on in life but I've yet to meet them. The life expectancy of addicts is such that I only know of two people that managed to effectively beat their addiction, both are family members and even though they got out of it they never fully recovered from their encounter with hard drugs. Ugly stuff.
- mherrmann 9y agoInteresting. Thank you very much for sharing. I don't know a single addict, so really have no insight. Probably that acquaintance's institution simply focuses on such patients. I don't know.
- andai 9y agoHave you heard of Rat Park? https://imgur.com/gallery/pI8Nm https://imgur.com/gallery/pI8Nm TL;DR rats trapped in cages will self-administer drugs, often to the point of death. Rats which explore freely have a much lower (order of magnitude) rate of addiction.
- mattbgates 9y agoHaving lost several friends to the opioid epidemic, I wrote an article about it on decriminalization. I wish we would help addicts instead of treating them like criminals. The war on drugs has failed. We must not be a part of the suncost fallacy, but just embrace another way. http://www.confessionsoftheprofessions.com/drug-user-decriminalization/ http://www.confessionsoftheprofessions.com/drug-user-decrimi...
- gotthemwmds 9y agoIf you think any of those stock images "accurately represent the life and death of drug users", you are delusional. Normies like yourself tend to out themselves as 90% ignorant of drug addiction within the first paragraph. You follow that trait.
- mattbgates 9y agoGood sir, please note that I was not about to seek stock images that were worse off than what I could present without presenting images that may have disgusted my visitors, though I know the situation could definitely be presented much worse and it certainly is. I do not seek to argue with you, or pretend I know everything. I only know that I lost two my of best friends to the opiate epidemic, one of whom was a veteran marine, and I also lost a cousin who happened to be an army veteran due to overdosing on prescription pain killers. I have even more Facebook friends, who happened to be acquaintances in my life, whose profiles are no longer active because they no longer are alive. I do feel that if they were able to seek the help they needed, they would've done so. If you wish to argue, than argue with logic and facts, not calling people "normies" as if they don't know what drug addicts go through. I myself was getting addicted to oxycontin before I was able to ween off of it. My condolences to you for those you have lost in your life, good sir. Or might I add, I hope you are able to deal with your own demons in an appropriate manner.
- Pica_soO 9y agoThe real interesting thing is not whether opiod addiction is a disease or not- it clearly is - but why the behavior-controll-fraction trys so violently to clamp down on drug-behaviour with the law. It just doesn't sound rational. And its not. Many oxy-addicts of today, where former - "The police should get them" conservatives. So what compels a human being to want the state to go after his fellow being, which irony- might be his/her future self. My guess, at the motivation is a mixture of envy (on a perceived decadent lifestyle) without hard work, a fear for ones offspring and finally grievances caused by known addicts (small time theft and crockery). As long as these emotions are not respected, taken care off and defused, as long as this is the case, the disease that is drugs can not be handled.
- chicob 9y agoI used to live not far away from Casal Ventoso, in the 80's. Anyone crossing that neighborhood in those days would easily see hordes of alienated people, in soiled clothes, gazing idly, sitting in the sidewalk and sometimes even injecting right there. Whenever you saw them running in one direction, you'd know some drug dealer had arrived. There is a cemetery nearby, and so it looked like death ruled the place. Today it is still a poor neighborhood, but you don't see that kind of thing anymore. Taking the bus there is no longer a gamble. You still see a couple of people looking somewhat emaciated, but nothing like the walking cadavers of 30 years ago. There were some slums outside Lisbon, like Pedreira dos Húngaros, where the police (other than SWAT teams) simply wouldn't go. It was just too dangerous. One would occasionally hear the blasts of fireworks, telling people drugs had arrived, or gunshots, warning drug dealers an intervention squad was near. This slum no longer exists, and many others are simply gone. It's nice to see this article in HN, for many reasons. António Guterres is an engineer, and when he graduated he was the best student of his year. From what I know, he considered a PhD in Physics before taking his chances in politics. Back in those days, his university (Instituto Superior Técnico) didn't have a Physics course, so many of its first faculty members came from IST's Electrical Engineering course or Physics courses from other universities. He lectured Theory of Systems and Telecommunication Signals. Guterres is an intelligent man, and he would've probably become a great physicist, an excellent teacher, or a renowned engineer. Instead he chose politics, and now he's Secretary-general of the UN. His drug policy from his Prime-minister days saved thousands of lives and definitely changed Portugal for the better. I think that was a really nice hack.
- galfarragem 9y agoAs a Portuguese, I have to add: Guterres is a worldclass facilitator full of good will. That's his edge - not intelligence - and how he got his position in UN. In 2001, Guterres was forced to resign from his job as Prime Minister of Portugal. Not the best indicator of great leadership or management skills.
- epmaybe 9y agoFrom Wikipedia: > In December 2001, following a disastrous result for the Socialist Party in the local elections, Guterres resigned, stating, "I am resigning to prevent the country from falling into a political swamp". Could you clarify why you believe resignation implies a lack of leadership or management skills?
- guilhermepontes 9y agowho the fuck cares about this xenophonic country anyway?
- nunobrito 9y agoI'm Portuguese too. Maybe a bit older than you because many years ago I thought the same way as you until I lived in other lands. I've lived across the US, West Europe, East Europe, UK and even Switzerland just to find them far more xenophobic than what I would ever imagine. And with some more years you might realize that the large majority of nations are indeed that way. Then going back to Portugal and looking at history, you might find that existed a long time effort for integration of different people in a very different way than say, the British empire. So, we're not xenophobic. You likely didn't had to live through the epidemic of drug in 2000 and watch the majority of your friends getting hooked. It was sad, there was no hope. Portugal just legalized those drugs because everyone had lost someone to them and nothing else tried before had worked. Even today in my own family, two of my younger brothers never fully recovered. They don't consume any more drugs since a decade and still it has permanently affected their brain capacity, one of them is still inside an hospital.
- rbanffy 9y agoAre we really, seriously, debating the success of a proven successful program?