13 ms·
If they can't or won't reform then excellent, let's be rid of them. I don't want to give any business to a company that are seeking to become a worldwide cab m
by Nursie 9y ago
If they can't or won't reform then excellent, let's be rid of them.
I don't want to give any business to a company that are seeking to become a worldwide cab monopoly, and squirrel away any profits to the US. We have a perfectly healthy cab ecosystem in my city, app-driven and with fare competition and city regulation. Which I suppose is why Uber, though present, hasn't really taken off here.
That said, talk of profits may be a little early and AFAICT they're losing money by the fistful. Which kinda says that they're engaging in some dodgy market distortion to me...
- dandare 9y agoHowever, the article would greatly benefit from more factual information. What "threat to Londoners' safety and security"? Be specific please.
- Nursie 9y agoThis does appear just to be a summary article and a bit more background would be good. A click on the subject tag gives me some recent political criticism from the Chairman of the All Party Parliamentary Group on taxis (who knew such a thing existed?) - "It stands accused by the police of failing to properly handle serious allegations of rape and sexual assault of passengers. It had to be dragged through the courts to recognise its responsibility to provide even the most basic rights and protections to Uber drivers. Its business model is based on saturating London's taxi and private hire market to drive its competition off the road."
- mino 9y ago> What "threat to Londoners' safety and security"? https://broadly.vice.com/en_us/article/vv598m/uber-drivers-are-at-the-center-of-another-rape-allegation-storm https://broadly.vice.com/en_us/article/vv598m/uber-drivers-a...
- onion2k 9y agoFailure to report serious crimes and allowing the driver to continue driving for Uber: https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2017/aug/13/uber-failing-to-report-sex-attacks-by-drivers-says-met-police https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2017/aug/13/uber-fail... http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/uber-drivers-accused-of-32-rapes-and-sex-attacks-on-london-passengers-a7037926.html http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/uber-drivers-accused-of... Failure to properly check medical certifications: https://www.thesun.co.uk/news/1897962/investigation-reveals-dodgy-gps-getting-cash-to-help-minicab-and-uber-drivers-fake-medical-test-over-fitness-to-drive/ https://www.thesun.co.uk/news/1897962/investigation-reveals-... Failure to follow up DBS (criminal records) checks (can't find an article about that one). Use of Greyball to dodge regulators checking on the service: https://www.ft.com/content/2ab3c0e8-0076-11e7-96f8-3700c5664d30 https://www.ft.com/content/2ab3c0e8-0076-11e7-96f8-3700c5664... (not specific to London but they're being sued all over the place for it) TfL's statement about the ban - https://tfl.gov.uk/info-for/media/press-releases/2017/september/licensing-decision-on-uber-london-limited?intcmp=50167 https://tfl.gov.uk/info-for/media/press-releases/2017/septem...
- bko 9y agoMore than 400 London cab drivers charged with crimes last year [0]. Not sure if this includes Uber, but from your comment, Uber doesn't report to DBS, so it doesn't. When you judge a service, you should really ask "compared to what". I prefer knowing the name and track record of my driver, not to mention an easy way to report mis-behavior, a history of my ride and ability to share my location. I don't have any stats, but from my experience, these factors greatly increase safety and comfort [0] https://www.standard.co.uk/news/crime/over-400-london-cab-drivers-charged-with-crimes-last-year-a3226396.html https://www.standard.co.uk/news/crime/over-400-london-cab-dr...
- Brakenshire 9y ago> Enhanced DBS checks are carried out on drivers every three years when they renew their taxi or private hire driver's licence, and every individual's fitness to become a licensed taxi or private hire driver is considered on a case-by-case basis. And failure to properly conduct DBS checks is one of the four reasons given by TfL for suspending Uber's license.
- cjrp 9y ago> The FOI showed the number of people charged who gave their occupation as a taxi driver or minicab driver. That would include Uber drivers. > I prefer knowing the name and track record of my driver You know their name, but their track record? You can see previous ratings, but that's not exactly going to include "1*, driver sexually assaulted me" is it?
- bko 9y agoI personally never had a negative enough of an experience to warrant a bad rating, but I know people in the US that rated their drivers a low score for some reason (poor navigation, speeding, cell phone use), and they subsequently had an Uber rep reach out to them to discuss. It seems that they take the ratings very seriously. And it also shows because many of the drivers I spoke to were concerned about their ratings and even offer such amenities like water and cell chargers to make the ride more pleasant. As for yellow cabs in NY, many times I've witnessed the cab driver speaking on his phone and refusing to open the door before final destination is disclosed. Also, reports about not picking up minorities or people in less wealthy neighborhoods. These bad behaviors have gotten better over the years, but I attribute that to more competition from Uber
- mrow84 9y agoThat is factually a quote from the Mayor of London, Sadiq Khan, as reported in the article. It is not the journalist's job to provide specifics on the behalf of others.
- FeepingCreature 9y agoInvestigative journalism? Sort of is their job. You're not just supposed to blindly reprint things people say. Admittedly everyone does it anyways, but still.
- mrow84 9y ago> You're not just supposed to blindly reprint things people say. They did not reproduce what he said as though the content of his statement was factual - they reproduced it to report what he had said. To illustrate the point further, they had his quote: > Mayor of London Sadiq Khan said: "I fully support TfL's decision - it would be wrong if TfL continued to license Uber if there is any way that this could pose a threat to Londoners' safety and security." and then several paragraphs later they had this from an Uber driver: > But one driver with Uber in London said: "I don't think it is a fair decision. Uber offers a flexible schedule, and a weekly income." The also reported on statements by "Fred Jones, head of cities for Uber across the UK and Ireland", and "Uber's general manager in London Tom Elvidge". Reporting on the statements of a range of parties interested in a particular dispute is perfectly reasonable journalism, and should not be compared to opinion-led journalism where the statements of favourable individuals are rewritten as though they were facts. To clarify, I'm not claiming that the BBC as an institution is devoid of opinion-led journalism, I just don't think that demanding that journalists substantiate the claims of interested parties (as O.P. did) is very reasonable.
- isolli 9y agoIn what city do you live?
- grecy 9y ago> a company that are seeking to become a worldwide cab monopoly Who said anything about them seeking to become a worldwide cab monopoly? They are a cab company, expanding globally. Any other company can do that too, if they want.
- Nursie 9y ago>> Who said anything about them seeking to become a worldwide cab monopoly? They behave as if they are attempting this, IMHO. >> They are a cab company I believe, depending on which way the wind was blowing, they might dispute this. Their argument is that they are not a cab company, merely a service for connecting drivers and potential passengers. This is how they avoid pesky things like employment laws. >> Any other company can do that too, if they want. Few others have the access to VC money that Uber do - I would consider this reliance on an absolute ton of investment, which allows them to operate at the prices they do, to be something of a market distortion.
- microcolonel 9y ago> They behave as if they are attempting this, IMHO. Every rational company should behave as if they're attempting to become a monopoly, this is a completely meaningless point to argue either way.
- Nursie 9y agoThis is like the idea that every rational company must skirt the very edges of the law, regardless of good ethics, to maximise profit. I don't personally believe either to be true, and I do believe there's a very real difference between out-competing the competition and using a ton of VC money to undercut them, or skirting rules and regulations that may add cost.
- conanbatt 9y agoTaxis have an ACTUAL monopoly. Are you seriously siding with "banning potential monopoly" to protect an entrenched centuries old monopoly.
- nikanj 9y agoMost Uber-sized companies squirrel the profits to tax havens in the Caribbean. Getting the profits to the reach of the US tax system would be unexpected.
- kbart 9y agoThat's why many people prefer small, local cab companies that pay license fees and taxes to a local budget.
- lotsofpulp 9y agoIn the US, I don’t think I’ve ridden in a small, local cab company whose cars didn’t smell like cigarettes and was barely legal to drive, and often had drivers trying to scam you. It was always nice expensive black car service, or shitty local taxi company, which was a super last resort. The transparency and accountability that Uber brought has been preferred by everyone I know, and people are voting with their dollars.
- kbart 9y agoIt might be due to the fact that in most parts of Europe there's a cheap and good public transport available, so cabs must compete with it too. In USA, there's not much to choose from, so cabs have local monopolies, hence higher price and lower quality service.
- cholantesh 9y agoCanada is in the same position. Cab drivers regularly take longer routes than necessary to drive up the meter and often pretend their card machines aren't working to force cash payment.
- kofejnik 9y agomost taxi services in Europe are quite bad and hugely overpriced due to artificial monopoly, to the point that I try to stay away from the countries without Uber
- cm2187 9y agoWhat profits? Aren't they problematically loss making?
- dbbk 9y agoThey're loss making by choice so it's not problematic for them at least.
- bko 9y ago> I don't want to give any business to a company that are seeking to become a worldwide cab monopoly You don't have to use their service
- Nursie 9y agoI don't, and I'm happy to see it disappear if it can't or won't behave fairly to passengers and drivers, and compete honestly.
- KyeRussell 9y agoFor now, sure, but you may have missed the word "monopoly". Fact is, Uber is running an unsustainable business in a lot of markets to gain market share. It's anticompetitive business practice. Free market fanboys will argue that the issue will fix itself after Uber raises prices - thus allowing more healthy competition, but this takes time. Not everyone can drive or rely on public transportation. In modern society, transport is a utility, and to act like people can simply "not use" a taxi service is ridiculous.
- Nursie 9y ago> Free market fanboys will argue that the issue will fix itself after Uber raises prices - thus allowing more healthy competition Yup, by which time the current players may well have been driven out by the undercutting. Not really a sign of 'healthy' competition.
- kofejnik 9y agoI would welcome the current taxis going bust
- crdoconnor 9y ago>Free market fanboys will argue that the issue will fix itself after Uber raises prices The "issue" will likely fix itself by uber going under and losing all of its investors their money in a spectacular and richly deserved hubristic implosion. What uber is attempting has been managed before (e.g. the 'bus wars') but it's unlikely they will achieve a sustainable monopoly.
- snakeanus 9y ago> app-driven Does that mean that you can only order for a cab via an app? Or are apps an alternative?
- kbart 9y agoI'm not an original OP, but in my city there's a centralized call center and several apps -- you may choose to use whichever you prefer as most cab companies support all or at least many of them.
- Nursie 9y ago>> Does that mean that you can only order for a cab via an app? Or are apps an alternative? Well, apps are my primary way of ordering cabs now, because I can set the pick-up and drop-off precisely by map, and track the vehicle before it arrives etc. But they still have their phone lines too.
- FreeRadical 9y agoMore UK cabs need to start allowing cars payments. Instead they use their local monopolies to force cash use and under declare taxable income.
- Aethelwulf 9y agohttps://tfl.gov.uk/info-for/taxis-and-private-hire/accepting-card-payments https://tfl.gov.uk/info-for/taxis-and-private-hire/accepting...
- microcolonel 9y agoIf the anecdote and the law are both accurate, then that certainly goes to show exactly how effective all those stringent regulations are. It seems like this one would be simple to check.
- foldr 9y agoYou can just refuse to pay any other way except by card. There is not much a black cab driver can do in response to that, since they are now not even allowed to be on the road accepting customers if they don't have a working card machine.
- microcolonel 9y agoCan you? I would think common law would take precedence over taxi regulations.
- PaulRobinson 9y agoAll London black cabs must take card payments. If their machine isn't working, they're not allowed to be on the road.
- vixen99 9y agoAnd that applies to tips?
- bsmithers 9y ago>We have a perfectly healthy cab ecosystem in my city, app-driven and with fare competition and city regulation Sure, but that doesn't exist in the majority of cities. The user experience is why I use Uber.
- moomin 9y agoUber's rhetoric doesn't seem appreciably different in London from elsewhere. And yeah, I'm a Londoner, don't really feel the need for Uber to exist in my area.
- AsyncAwait 9y agoIn my city, especially as a disabled person, I've had vastly better experience with Uber than with regular cabs. Just being able to indicate precisely where to stop on a map is an incredible improvement for me over having to provide instructions to a cab driver who can't find the spot. Not having to deal with cash, drivers more willing to help etc. gives me a much better experience with an Uber.
- foldr 9y agoLondon cabs can be hailed using apps and accept card payments, so Uber has no real advantage in those respects in London.
- AsyncAwait 9y agoMy concern is more about the precedent that this sets for other cities to follow suit.
- djsumdog 9y agoI hailed a cab during the big tube strike a few years back. 60 GBP got me, not to the airport, but the DLR (automated trains; no drivers). We had to stop by an ATM since he didn't take cards. Uber had surge pricing at the time due to the strike, so I'm not really sure which one would have been worse.
- shamas 9y ago"healthy cab ecosystem"? Have you lived in outer London? If you're out as far as one of the houses outside Brixton, the cab system isn't even in existence, let alone healthy.
- Nursie 9y agoThat comment was about the city I live in now, Southampton, where we have multiple cab firms with reasonable prices and reasonable apps. That said I used to live in Streatham in the mid 00s, and sure, the transport situation wasn't great. There was choice back then, but between terrible or worse.
- spiralx 9y agoIn what part of London aren't there multiple cab firms operating locally? Certainly not "as far out" as Zone 2, where I've caught a cab from dozens of times, and that's not even thinking about firms like Addison Lee that operate across London.
- vidarh 9y agoI live in Croydon, zone 5, much further out than Brixton, and have no problem relying on black cabs several times a week, on top of at least half a dozen minicab companies.
- necessity 9y agoBecause having more options, knowing the identity and location of your driver, having a feedback mechanism to report mis-behavior and paying a lower price is bad for consumers. If you don't want it don't use it, stop imposing you will upon others.
- chi18 9y ago> I don't want to give any business to a company that are seeking to become a worldwide cab monopoly Do you buy from Amazon? Essentially the same thing, and I for one use it regularly. Like you, I worried for a while about a monopoly, but I think capitalism will pan out. Amazon and any other online retailer that can successfully provide massive selection, good product review system, and reliable and fast home delivery will drive a change in the landscape of retail locally. This will eventually lead to smaller local physical stores through agreements with those retailers where the most popular items are stocked. (The exception for the short-term will be supermarkets. And you've already seen the attempts at transformation; many generic retailers are half-grocery store now. That's what they will become in full, if they survive. But, home delivery will take that over also, eventually.) Uber had poor decisions made, but along with Lyft in the US, Mytaxi in the UK, etc.- these are the "early Amazons" of the transportation business. The old method that Taxi services use is no longer relevant now that anyone can find directions easily. London is somewhat unique in that some of its cab drivers are known worldwide as those that have incredible memories, and that's great, but they are the typewriters of the future- used by some, but not by most. All of the dispatch and directions have been automated.
- erwan 9y agoThis decision has officially nothing to do with tax evasion/optimization. It is on grounds of consumer protection that Uber's licence is not being renewed. Anyone who has taken a black cab should immediately understand the hypocrisy motivating this decision. The user experience is absolutely horrendous and there's no good tracking system to make black cab drivers accountable. In short, as everyone knows, it is just another artificial monopoly enshrined into law by regulators. A good thing is that same regulators are losing lots of credibility. For decades they could pretend they were acting on basis of consumer protection. Now it is clear they aren't. People love Uber (not necessarily applies in the US anymore) because the experience is amazing at decent prices. Even in a city with a high density public transportation system like Paris, you are always happy to have that option in case it is past 1:00am or you're in a hurry.
- Nursie 9y agoI didn't mention taxes, but it seems to be explicitly about non-cooperation in criminal matters, workers rights and all sorts of other areas. Black cabs are far from a monopoly, and Uber are far from the only alternative.
- kodablah 9y ago> ...it seems to be explicitly about... The BBC article is a bit light on details. Do you have a link where I can read the detailed license revocation reasons so I can make my own judgement?
- Nursie 9y agoCheck out the rest of the thread, onion2k gave a few
- kodablah 9y agoI saw those links, and can Google others as well when searching for Uber wrongdoing. I want their details, not a commenters. I saw the Tfl's statement which only had four abstract bullet points. What did they ask about Greyball and what was answered? Which unreported crimes and were there cover-up attempts by the company? In general, one might expect a level of detailed transparency in these rulings lest it's seen as a foregone conclusion retroactively finding reasons. Is there a commission report I can read or a committee hearing I can watch?
- mijoharas 9y ago> Which I suppose is why Uber, though present, hasn't really taken off here. This is very far from my understanding, most people I know use Uber quite regularly.