32 ms·
Alan Kay is still waiting for his dream to come true
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- scottlegrand2 9y agoThe ad layout on mobile makes this article unreadable on my phone to the point of rage quitting halfway through or so. How appropriate somehow...
- digitalengineer 9y agohttps://www.mozilla.org/nl/firefox/focus/ https://www.mozilla.org/nl/firefox/focus/
- paulsutter 9y agoElon didn't wait, he just made it happen
- jlg23 9y agoI don't know Elon Musk personally, but I'm pretty sure he'd refer to Alan Kay as one of the giants on whose shoulders he and quite a few industries stand on.
- ktRolster 9y agoAlan Kay is the one who said "The best way to predict the future is to invent it." He did so by inventing quite a bit of the technology that is in every PC and smartphone today.
- agumonkey 9y agoJust today I read that VPRI fonc mailing list was shutting down because they shifted focus onto other area (communication design or something like that). A YC incubator thing IIRC.
- skadamat 9y agoYC HARC - harc.ycr.org
- agumonkey 9y agoThanks a lot. ps: project list is cool http://harc.ycr.org/project/ http://harc.ycr.org/project/
- kennethfriedman 9y agoHey, the FONC mailing list isn't shutting down! It's just moving! It's now hosted at MIT instead of VPRI. It's located here: http://mailman.mit.edu/mailman/listinfo/fonclist http://mailman.mit.edu/mailman/listinfo/fonclist
- agumonkey 9y agoha good to know, I only read a few mail on that thread maybe I missed the part where they mentionned relocation.
- GuiA 9y ago> rather than the wheels for the mind that Steve Jobs envisioned. Proper quote, for those confused: "I read a study that measured the efficiency of locomotion for various species on the planet. The condor used the least energy to move a kilometer. Humans came in with a rather unimpressive showing about a third of the way down the list....That didn't look so good, but then someone at Scientific American had the insight to test the efficiency of locomotion for a man on a bicycle and a man on a bicycle blew the condor away. That's what a computer is to me: the computer is the most remarkable tool that we've ever come up with. It's the equivalent of a bicycle for our minds.”
- hyperpallium 9y agooblig. Bikes need road infrastructure, or at the very least, a path cleared of trees/underbrush (though less efficient). Condors don't.
- Pulcinella 9y agoPretty sure Condors need a clear path. You usually don't see them flying below the tree tops low to the ground.
- firasd 9y agoI found it interesting that in an HN discussion about how to auto-update comments Alan Kay said, "How about a little model of time in a GUI?"[1] It ties into when he said of smartphone apps, "It's painful to see people using billions of devices that have forgot that undo is a good idea." [2] It made me think about how things like Redux (or even just Google Drive revision history) where you can 'time travel' through state can be more important for UI than we realize sometimes. 1) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11940472 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11940472 2) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S6JC_W9F8-g&t=40m30s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S6JC_W9F8-g&t=40m30s
- cma 9y agoIt is painful that most desktop apps never even got branching undo/redo.
- sytse 9y agoI find it interesting that Google Docs also doeen't have branching undo. There is no way to revert a commit, you can only go back in time. And there is no blame. I loved the article by the way. The future of writing should be version controlled Juniper notebooks. Next step for GitLab is to build a cloud IDE to bring that closer.
- bostonvaulter2 9y agoGoogle Docs has blame by looking at the history of changes in the file, although I will admit that it is not the most obvious.
- sytse 9y agoThey have a commit history. But if I want to see who last changed a certain line I have to go through the history until I see the change. I would love something like https://gitlab.com/gitlab-org/gitlab-ce/blame/master/CONTRIBUTING.md https://gitlab.com/gitlab-org/gitlab-ce/blame/master/CONTRIB...
- 9y ago
- david927 9y agoIf, like Alan Kay, you think we need a major overhaul in software construction and are in the San Francisco Bay Area, let me know. I'm part of a group that meets on Saturdays once a month and we work on side research projects toward that end. My email is in my profile.
- mncharity 9y agoIf anyone in the Boston area is interested in whiteboarding high-skill software development environments in the context of 2018/2019 hardware, I'd be interested. So: continuous speech recognition; hand tracking, controllers, and haptic exoskeletons, but still keyboards; HMDs with 30+ px/deg, and eye tracking, but still screens. Dynabook was a nice vision. As always, society executed poorly, and failed to realize much of the potential of its technologies. No doubt that will happen again with VR/AR. For example, there's a toxic cauldron of patents brewing. Screens and keyboards and mice, have had a good half-century run. And GUIs, and personal local hardware. But perhaps time to shift focus.
- theoh 9y agoWhen you say society always executes poorly, what alternative social reality are you comparing it with?
- mncharity 9y agoI don't understand - are you suggesting the only way to know you could have done something better, is to see someone else doing the same thing for comparison? That's certainly one way. Others include... all the ways you evaluate the execution of a company or project, when you don't have a direct competitor to compare it with, no?
- theoh 9y agoMaybe you would agree with the statement "reality is broken"? I certainly don't think it's meaningful. The unfortunate associations of wanting society to "execute better" (i.e. the merger of industry and the state found under fascism) just underline the fact that applying performance measurements to human life/social phenomena is misguided. We don't all agree on the purpose of life or the nature of happiness, nor should we.
- kerkeslager 9y agoPop-up warning.
- pcl 9y agoIt's clear from the interview that Kay thinks mobile computing isn't where it should be. But I haven't studied the DynaBook. Does anyone know exactly what Kay thinks is needed, in order to realize his dream? I found a few such things in the article: - more-discoverable undo - some sort of AI-based virtual assistant - a stylus and holder, and presumably input methods and applications that are better suited for that stylus - something nebulous about having warning labels and being designed for the higher-order cognitive centers of our brains
- ktRolster 9y agomore-discoverable undo I think he wanted more discoverable everything, the undo was just used as a particularly bad example on the iPhone. He wants the world to be more discoverable, to modify our very culture so that learning is easy (an example he gave was with math, so it's not just a small, 'smart' percentage of the population who actually gets it, but everyone absorbs it from a young age).
- digi_owl 9y agoIn the end i think he, like many intellectuals, overestimate people's interest in learning. Aka you can bring a horse to water, but you can't make it drink.
- runevault 9y agoactually I'd argue he understands the problem pretty well. He talks about needing to offer something SO compelling they cannot help but interface with it, in spite of their desire for things that do not push them.
- p1esk 9y agoI'm not sure if there's a problem at all. Learning how to do anything is much easier today than ever. Just type "how to do X" in google, and you will probably see a nice YouTube video, or a tutorial. If you get stuck, there are online forums with people willing to help for free, 24/7. Has the number of people who want to learn decreased? If so, was it because of iPhones/iPads?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- norswap 9y agoFor all the respect and admiration I have for Alan Kay, I think he's often showing a lot of bad faith. His ideal vision is always described in very abstract terms. If he took the care to write it down precisely, what it should look like, I'm sure there would be hundreds eager to build it for him. Of course, part of it is "design principles". But then do some common use cases. When the abstraction meets reality we get comments like "the iPad should have a pen". Which is really an interesting observation, but doesn't quite rill the crowd like the abstract impressive-sounding stuff does. And you'd hardly call these isolated observation "vision". Clearly, the user interfaces we have today are sub-optimal, and I can make hundreds of factual remarks on what could be improved. But I don't think this works out to a "vision". In fact, a vision is I think sometimes bound to be too abstract. If we just had products where the shit was fixed relentlessly, I reckon we'd get to "good" without needing them.
- ktRolster 9y agoHis ideal vision is always described in very abstract terms. If he took the care to write it down precisely, what it should look like, I'm sure there would be hundreds eager to build it for him. Look at Squeak. http://squeak.org/ http://squeak.org/ The idea that you should be able to dig in and modify things is very powerful. Another way to look at it is in terms of discoverability: you are at one level of understanding (using the phone, clicking on things), and it should lead you to a deeper level of understanding (perhaps moving things around, modifying them). At each level, there are hooks inviting you deeper, drawing you in. Ideally you get down low enough to start programming, to actually understanding how assembly and the CPU works, so there is no longer any area of magic.
- pvg 9y agoMaybe you disagree with him or perhaps think his position is ill-considered or too woolly or somesuch. But 'bad faith'? You really believe he's being intentionally duplicitous and deceptive?
- bitwize 9y agoOn Hackernews there was once a skeptic of postmodernism who got into a debate with a Derrida fan. The skeptic said "If deconstruction is not BS, how about you explain to us, in plain English, what it's all about." The Derrida fan replied "No. How about you demonstrate that you've read Husserl, Heidegger, Hegel, Nietzsche, Freud, and Levinas. Then we can begin to talk about Derrida." If Alan Kay were like the Derrida fan, then he could have rebuffed anyone who came asking what the Dynabook was about with "How about you demonstrate that you've studied the achievements of McLuhan, Montessori, Papert, Minsky, Engelbart, etc. Then we'll talk." Of course he's not like that so he's going to try to give the reporter a bit of the background he has in those things and let them figure it out for themself. The Dynabook is supposed to be, roughly, an iPad with a keyboard, stylus, and a Lisp Machine-like OS. Of course Apple and third parties have closed the gap with keyboards and styli but it's the OS that's the really important bit because in order for a Dynabook to be a Dynabook it must not be a thing that you can just download and run preapproved apps on. You have to be able to discover -- and change -- the entire system from the bare metal on up. Think "Stallmanism on steroids". It's like a television you can talk back to. Computing is a dynamic medium that demands interaction from its user, so to deny the user the ability to question and change the assumptions of the medium is to lock them in to certain stereotyped modes of interaction and deny the full richness of the medium. This is where Kay's "real guitar vs. Guitar Hero" analogy comes in. You can either have a device that offers its full potential up front, like a real guitar, or you can have a device that can only be used in circumscribed ways, in vague imitation of having the full richness of the original device, like Guitar Hero. The price you pay for having a real guitar, or a real Dynabook, is what we call "ease of use" -- the ability for a complete neophyte to pick it up and immediately display something resembling proficiency with it. (It is much easier for a trained data-entry clerk to operate a 3270 terminal than it is for that same clerk to fill out a modern Web form, but that sort of ease doesn't count.) And Apple has really doubled down on ease of use, at the expense of everything else wonderful about having a powerful computing device you can hold in one hand. To the point where it's become just like regular, can't-talk-back-to-it television.
- ksec 9y agoThis isn't the first time Alan Kay express his view on HTML / CSS and Javascitpt. But what alternative do we have / had?
- johansch 9y agoIt is terrible though. It is worth stating the obvious fact once in a while. This organic design of the web stack with layer upon layer upon layer upon layer can't go on for forever. At some point it will just become too painful and an alternative will emerge.
- firasd 9y agoThe web platform has its virtues though. I can still load a webpage made in 1996 and at least read the text if nothing else; we can't say the same of erstwhile competitors like Flash, Silverlight, Java applets...
- johansch 9y agoOpen standards tend to win/survive...
- digi_owl 9y agoPerhaps. but try loading various present day pages without JS enabled. Many of produce just a white screen unless you turn on JS for 3+ external domains to the one you are trying to read. And once those load, you often find half the screen filled with persistent headers and footers. In effect Flash didn't go way, it was just turn into JS+CSS. And in large part i fear we get this because the people in charge are hell bent on recreating printed media in electronic form.
- firasd 9y agoThe JS just fetches the text over the network and transforms it though. The browser still renders HTML markup in the end. I agree with the rest of what you said but those are just design decisions. My point was that, regardless of the code headaches, the platform itself (HTML, CSS, JS) is an incredibly flexible and resilient system.
- johansch 9y agoI have seen this pattern in other people with interesting but narcissistic personalities: "Steve wasn’t capable of being friends. That wasn’t his personality."
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- cerealbad 9y agowriting diminished thinking and reasoning capacity, computers continued offloading cognitive functions to adaptive machines. dig up, stupid! is a fitting epithet.
- pmoriarty 9y agoI kind of feel sorry for Alan Kay. He's trapped in endlessly rehashing ideas from 60's and 70's.
- jfoutz 9y agoWhat new ideas are there though? Social networking I guess. Have you seen the mother of all demos? Engelbart's team invented, like, everything. On the programming side, dependent types maybe. Everything else is from ml or lisp. Neural networks are old old ideas as well. Computers have finally gotten fast enough to make use of the ideas.
- thomastjeffery 9y ago> On the programming side, dependent types maybe. Have you learned about monads yet?
- scroot 9y agoUnlike CS programs in high schools and universities. They're stuck in the 50s rehashing sorting algorithms for their students. Meanwhile an entire community of "programmers" was trained and let loose in the wild to endlessly engage in pedantic debates about type systems, or which ALGOL like language is the best for this-or-that.
- chmaynard 9y agoBehind his curtain, it turned out that Alan Kay was a good man but a terrible wizard.
- kemiller 9y agoNeglecting path dependence is the root of all evil. I mean, he’s not wrong, but maybe the answer is just that this is fucking hard. And some of his specifics are just wrong. The pen? No. It’s super useful in some areas, like drawing, but if you include it by default you get lazy developers making UI that depends on it for navigation. Apple absolutely made the right call. I’m not taking away any of his amazing contributions, but his habit of slamming every incremental bit of mainstream, at-scale tech because it doesn’t fulfill his vision (yet) is not that helpful.
- thoughtsimple 9y agoInteresting that neither Kay nor the interviewer seemed aware of Swift Playgrounds. I would have loved to hear his criticisms of that environment as a teaching tool for kids. It seems to be targeted at 8-12 year olds given the graphics. I would be curious as to how closely Swift Playgrounds follows Papert’s ideas.
- cocktailpeanuts 9y agoI have total respect for Alan Kay but I hope he stops criticizing other people and actually shows his vision through his own execution (and by execution I don't just mean invention of a prototype but actual productization and distribution) If you're building something visionary and are not the one who's making tons of money off of it, you have two solutions: 1. IF you're interested in making money: Try to figure out what you're doing wrong and fix it so you actually CAN capitalize on your original invention 2. IF you're NOT interested in making money: Enjoy the respect these people pay you and please don't badmouth others who worked hard to build important products that changed the world. I feel like Alan Kay is on the second boat, so my heart breaks whenever he badmouths other people who worked hard to build cool things. It doesn't matter what came first. What matters is what actually managed to pull off the ultimate success.
- discreteevent 9y agoAnyone who has put as much work into it as Kay has and delivered as many innovations is absolutely entitled to criticize. He is especially entitled to criticize products that built on his ideas but because of some fundamental flaws actually hobble the ideas and hobble society. This is important to point out and if he isn't qualified to do so then who is?
- cocktailpeanuts 9y agoThere's a difference between badmouthing and constructive criticism. Try reading through the entire article. I did. And there's tons of badmouthing and condescension.
- shalabhc 9y agoThe article is filtered through another reporter and I didn't find specific instance of badmouthing (but my reading is also filtered through my own notion of where I think Alan Kay is coming from.) If you're interested in what Kay really means, maybe listen to some of his numerous other talks?
- 9y ago
- noam87 9y agoReminds of what the people of Red lang are trying to achieve: http://www.red-lang.org/p/about.html?m=1 http://www.red-lang.org/p/about.html?m=1 Maybe I'll finally give it a try! Every once in a while I daydream about a sort of "distributed app platform" built on top of Scheme and IPFS. -- Perhaps Red would actually be perfect for this...
- detaro 9y ago> Every once in a while I daydream about a sort of "distributed app platform" Have a peek at dat and beaker browser, they've done interesting stuff in that regard recently.
- anotherbrownguy 9y agoI hope someone could tell Alan Kay about the Galaxy Note. It has a really nice pen and a place to put it.
- dkarl 9y agoIf people could understand what computing was about, the iPhone would not be a bad thing. But because people don’t understand what computing is about, they think they have it in the iPhone, and that illusion is as bad as the illusion that Guitar Hero is the same as a real guitar. That’s the simple long and the short of it. Some kids learn guitar. Some kids fantasize about learning guitar. Apple makes machines that enable the computing equivalent of both of these things. You're never going to turn all listeners into musicians, all readers into writers, all theater-goers into actors. You can't even get everyone to dance at a wedding with an open bar. Technology can play a role in getting a few more people over the line, but Alan Kay's head is way too far in the clouds for him to even see the problem that way. Honestly, I think what he's done is dissociated himself from his own snobbery. He talks about technology failing humanity, but he's really saying he doesn't like people. He doesn't like how most people think and live. Why else would he constantly be disappointed in technology failing to turn all of humanity into always-on cultural creatives? It's like he looks at books and says, well, the dream for books is for everyone to read challenging literature, but at the beach or on the subway you see mostly "Eat Pray Love" and Stephen King, so clearly books have failed. People are doing the same dumb shit with books and technology that they did without it. They choose passive consumption. When I complain about it, I'll blame it on technology so I don't sound like a misanthrope. He constantly talks about creating, learning, and education, but he doesn't bring any attention to any current work supporting these activities. He doesn't say, look, here's this great work being done for kids, and it's limited because the iPad needs this feature. He doesn't say, look, here's this great computing system I use to support my own work, and it be a lot better with this specific kind of OS or hardware support. Instead of talking about how the Apple hardware is holding back current work, he's talking about how it fails to implement his own ideas from thirty years ago. You'd think he could find SOME new idea to promote and celebrate, if only to point out what he thinks progress looks like, but apparently Apple has snuffed out every worthwhile avenue of improvement by a few unfortunate unfortunate hardware choices. Hell, where's even the usesthis interview with Alan Kay?
- dilemma 9y agoHis "vision" is too self-centered and he expects people to live after his ideals but in fact people have better things to do than create art, or whatever. >They choose passive consumption The same person is likely an active producer in one area, and a passive consumer in others. I know I am.
- jstewartmobile 9y agoIt's like there's blood running in the streets, and he wants to fund a mission to Mars. Last VPRI paper I read was some whiz-bang way of laying out proportional text. Cool, but when the whole damned industry is a battlefield for locking-in devs and wringing as much money as possible from the digital peasantry, making a slightly better text rendering algorithm seems like mental masturbation. If he took that money they were giving him for VPRI to re-live his glory days, and gave it to devs who are giving away high-quality creative software instead, that would go a lot further towards his goal. https://www.blender.org https://www.blender.org https://ephtracy.github.io https://ephtracy.github.io http://16-bits.org/pt.php http://16-bits.org/pt.php http://www.audacityteam.org http://www.audacityteam.org https://www.gimp.org https://www.gimp.org http://picoe.ca/products/pablodraw/ http://picoe.ca/products/pablodraw/
- mkhalil 9y agoI don't buy it that everyone would be a digital creative if they just had the right tools. To make quality content, whether it be apps/music/movies/etc..it requires much more than tools. I respect Alan Kay, but I don't understand the need to bash on modern day technology. Have we really come along way in terms of general computing? Maybe not [Example: 0]. But in terms of the digital world, I can take a video of my parents and send it to my cousin who lives 10,000 miles away and he can respond in a matter of seconds. I can literally meet people in remote areas of the world. I can interact with people who barely have food but somehow can get cell phone access and now they are learning and communicating with everyone else. I can't imagine a better way to level the playing field (socioeconomically) globally then how we have it. Do we have a lot more work to do? Sure. But Rome wasn't built in a day. The future of the internet & technology, the direction it's headed, is going to come from small contributions from millions across the world. What people will need will turn into what we have and use. And there won't be some magical device that just pops out of nowhere that will change everything. [0]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yJDv-zdhzMY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yJDv-zdhzMY
- scroot 9y ago> "I don't buy it that everyone would be a digital creative if they just had the right tools." That is not Kay's argument. Not everyone who scribbles notes or draws something on a piece of paper is a "creative" or artist. Not all who write at all are professional writers. But we do not have the computing equivalent of paper for everyone. Sure, someone can write in a word processor or draw in a drawing program, but that's not all that a computer is for -- that's just imitating paper. The outstanding question is: can we make something that is as extensible as pen and paper and literacy for aiding human thought for the next level, the computing level? All we have now are stiff applications. Saying that such things make people literate in computing is like writing by filling out forms. > "Do we have a lot more work to do? Sure. But Rome wasn't built in a day." Kay is your ally here, a constant gadfly putting the lie to all the hype and BS. He's a constant reminder that we shouldn't feel so satisfied with our mud huts. He's reminding us to build Rome at all.
- homarp 9y ago>I don't buy it that everyone would be a digital creative if they just had the right tools. To make _quality_ content,... who cares about quality ? who is the judge of what "quality" is ? As long as someone can create the content _and distribute it_, they are a digital creative.
- kegan 9y agoThe title is ironic, given Alan Kay is the one who said "The best way to predict the future is to invent it."
- ozaark 9y agoWithout the vision that came from parc none of us would be viewing this today. The vision they wanted was vast and it still has more to offer today. Disappointed many comments have disassociated this from where we are now. Thank you Alan. Excellent read.
- c3d 9y agoI recognize the Alan Kay I met at HP. Very sure of his own genius and quick to snarkily dismiss the genius of others. Case in point: The iPad and iPhone makes kids creative like no other tool has before. Kids know how to use it to text, exchange ideas or pictures of kittens, draw or sketch, learn how to program (Swift Playground anyone), take and edit photos. It is everything but a glorified TV where kids are passive. This is the only environment where kids are truly first-class citizens. How on earth Kay could spend so much energy (a whole article) trying to convince us otherwise based mostly on super-weak arguments like "nobody is using the Shake gesture to undo" is truly beyond my understanding. Don't get me wrong. The Dynabook was a somewhat interesting idea. But it's about as much an inspiration for the real thing we use daily as the Star Trek tricorder. What Kay, to this day, did not get, unlike Jobs, is the power of networking, both physical and human. What made the iPhone greater than the Dynabook ever would have been is the App Store, and the combined creativity of millions of developers. What made the iPhone greater is apps like Messages, Facetime, Facebook, Twitter, Whatsapp, and countless others. What made the iPhone greater is Instagram, Flickr, sport apps, medical apps, HP-48 emulators, 3D "kill them all and think later" games. By contrast, what would have made the Dynabook great in Kay's mind was "designed by Kay for Kay's personal interests". Or, as Fake Bill Gates would have said: "One programmer should be enough for everybody".
- icebraining 9y agoWhat Kay, to this day, did not get, unlike Jobs, is the power of networking, both physical and human. What made the iPhone greater than the Dynabook ever would have been is the App Store, Interesting phrasing, considering that the iPhone did not come with the App Store. In fact, Apple's was the third software distribution platform to be released for iOS, after Installer.app and Cydia. Meanwhile, Alan Kay was working in Croquet[1] - a project that allows the creation of multi-user collaborative software with live-editing and automatic distribution and replication - since at least 2001. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Croquet_Project https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Croquet_Project
- coldtea 9y ago>Interesting phrasing, considering that the iPhone did not come with the App Store. In fact, Apple's was the third software distribution platform to be released for iOS, after Installer.app and Cydia. Which is irrelevant. First, because it eventually came, and second, because whether they intend to put one out or not, obviously they couldn't create a first class API for third party use, fix public interfaces as much as possible, write documentation, create a store, et al, all while creating the first edition of a new product (which they didn't even knew if it would be a success or not).
- alankay 9y agoLet me try to help this community regarding this article by providing some context. First, you need to realize that in the more than 50 years of my career I have always waited to be asked: Every paper, talk, and interview has been invited, never solicited. But there is a body of results from these that do put forward my opinions. This article was a surprise, because the interview was a few years ago for a book the interviewer was writing. It's worth noting that nowhere in the actual interview did I advocate going back and doing a Dynabook. My comments are mostly about media and why it's important to understand and design well any medium that will be spread and used en-mass. If you looked closely, then you would have noticed the big difference between the interview and the front matter. For example, I'm not still waiting for my dream to come true. You need to be sophisticated enough to see that this is a headline written to attract. It has nothing to do with what I said. And, if you looked closely, you might note a non seq right in the beginning, from "you want to see old media?" to no followup. This is because that section was taken from the chapter of the book but then edited by others. The first version of the article said I was fired from Apple, but it was Steve who was fired, and some editor misunderstood. In the interview itself there are transcription mistakes that were not found and corrected. And of course they didn't send me article ahead of time (I could have fixed all this). I think I would only have made a few parts of the interview a little more understandable. It's raw, but -- once you understand the criticisms -- I think most will find them quite valid. In the interview -- to say it again -- I'm not calling for the field to implement my vision -- but I am calling for the field to have a larger vision of civilization and how mass media and our tools contribute or detract from it. Thoreau had a good line. He said "We become the tools of our tools" -- meaning, be very careful when you design tools and put them out for use. (Our consumer based technology field is not being at all careful.)
- austenallred 9y agoWow, this article is a pretty egregious misinterpretation of those points. I didn't come away with anything even vaguely resembling what you just said, even if we disregard the factual errors. Candidly, your comments here make a lot more sense than some "We haven't yet built the DynaBook the way we should" piece.
- 9y ago
- jeffdavis 9y agoMany of Alan Kay's concepts will take not only time, but also some kind of catalyst to gain acceptance. What might that catalyst be?
- jeffdavis 9y agoSimplicity is closely related to education, and education is closely related to freedom. How are we supposed to take education seriously when we create devices of such complexity that they are essentially magic, and hand them to students? Before computers, complexity always had tight upper bounds. A watch could only get so complex before it wouldn't fit in its housing; and a car could only get so complex before it could not be efficiently manufactured/repaired. With computers, there is no upper bound to the complexity. We are now overrun with complexity, but it's hard to see how to fix that. A business that puts blind faith in a complex system to do something slightly faster/better will probably win against a business that tries to truly understand what it's doing. An employee who just keeps adding to the complexity will probably win against an employee stepping back to simplify things. A consumer who makes convenient choices about complex things without asking many questions will probably find life easier.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoSimlpicity is related to education in a sense that education is about teaching you a sequence of simple steps that lead toward the complex. Also, I think the perception of computers being magic doesn't come as much from their complexity as from the people who try to force the complex into looking like it's simple. They're hiding complexity so hard the end result doesn't make any logical sense, so it's magic. AK had a lovely quote in the article: "Well, a saying I made up at PARC was, “Simple things should be simple, complex things should be possible.” They’ve got simple things being simple and they have complex things being impossible, so that’s wrong."
- jeffdavis 9y agoEducation offers tools to help manage complexity -- abstract mathematics and lab sciences help us understand the complex world around us. But that has mostly been used to manage complexity that already existed (e.g. physics, biology), or that is somehow inherent to our world (e.g. complexity resulting from social interactions among humans). Now, we are creating our own, new kinds of complexity that didn't exist before. Software isn't there to help us manage complexity, it is adding to the complexity of our world, and dramatically so. That moves education backwards.
- zmix 9y agoAlan Kay comes from a time, when IT business was all about the creation of tools. The companies forming out of the 60's/70's experiments, of which he was a main protagonist, would drive the innovation according to more abstract needs of information management. That era ended in the 2000's. The companies, who drive techical advancement and innovation now, are a shopping mall, some telocs, family camps with added spying bonus, and often any form of information gatherers, that do business by the worst part of our economy, selling image rather than delivering identity. I am talking about the advertisement business. Alone, compare the Windows 10 address book to former installations. Back in the old days, the addressbook was scriptable. You could query it from other apps. Some third party apps had powerful filtering. And now? It is totally dumbed down to the most basic, primitive needs. And while we use cloud based addressbooks these days, it is much more difficult to keep them neat and ordered. I could go on for hours. Like XHTML vs HTML5 and so on.
- thomastjeffery 9y ago> let’s do what Sony did with the Walkman, let’s use this technology to make things more convenient in a way that a consumer can recognize, even if the user interface limits them. That's a fantastic characterization of what I hate about Apple, and to contrast, what I love about free software. The sad thing (in my opinion) is that people love the limitations Apple gives them. There it's no undefined behavior when the behavior is so arbitrarily limited. People don't want to create. They just want content. I find it rather depressing.
- thomastjeffery 9y agoAlso from the article: > Simple things should be simple, complex things should be possible.” They’ve got simple things being simple and they have complex things being impossible, so that’s wrong.
- pdfernhout 9y agoFor me, the flip side of all of Alan's (and other's) inspiring work on Smalltalk is that, having started programming with Smalltalk in the late 1980s (especially with VisualWorks and OTI's Envy), my entire professional career since then has seemed like a long succession of dealing with less pleasant systems around people who just don't get it. That has been frustrating and painful (even if the money is good) -- in some ways, it might be better not to know what is possible because then you don't miss it. It's sad that ParcPlace Systems made such a mess of commercializing ObjectWorks/VisualWorks Smalltalk (including not licensing it to Sun affordably for settop boxes, where Sun then reacted by creating Oak/Green/Java) and then they sold Smalltalk for a song to Cincom instead of open sourcing it and becoming a services company. I remember talking with one ParcPlace salesperson who kept going on about how Digitalk was their competitor, with my trying to point out that Visual Basic was really their competitor (and ParcPlace buying Digitalk was another part of the disaster for Smalltalk commercially). It was also sad to see IBM abandon two reliable fast Smalltalks it owned in favor of a buggy slow early Java for marketing reasons. And even working within IBM at IBM Research around 1999, I could not use Smalltalk because IBM's OTI subsidiary (which IBM had bought) wanted around US$250K a year internally just to let the embedded speech research group I was in try their embedded Smalltalk for the product we were making. They claimed they'd have to devote an entire support person to it -- and I tried to explain I was going out on a limb there as it was to suggest using Smalltalk instead of C and VxWorks (which my supervisor had already licensed). So instead I got IBM Research to approve Python for internal use (which took weeks of dealing with IBM's lawyers) and Python, not Smalltalk, ended up on Lou Gerstner's desk when he asked for one of our "Personal Speech Assistant" devices for his office. I really learned to dislike proprietary software from that experience of seeing something I loved like Smalltalk being killed by a business model focusing on runtime fees and such. I remember how when an IBM Research group licensed their Jikes Java compiler as FOSS, their biggest surprise was not how many external users they had -- but how many internal IBM users they suddenly had who no longer had to jump through complex hoops to gain access to it. Even now, Java, JavaScript, and Python are not quite where Smalltalk was back then in many ways. Of course, it's decades later, so there are other good things like faster networks and CPUs and mobility and DVCS and above all a widespread culture of FOSS -- and when I squint, I can kind of see all the browsers out there running JavaScript as a sort of big multi-core Smalltalk system (just badly and partially implemented). For a while I had hopes for Squeak, but it got bogged down early on by not having a clear free and open source license. Sames as I did recently to Automattic when it used React with a PATENTS clause, when I pointed out the concern, some lawyer chimed in with how everything was fine -- and only years later did the growing damage to the community become obvious to all. http://wiki.squeak.org/squeak/501 http://wiki.squeak.org/squeak/501 https://github.com/Automattic/wp-calypso/issues/650 https://github.com/Automattic/wp-calypso/issues/650 I really learned to dislike unclear licensing on a community project from that early Squeak experience. Squeak continues to improve and has fixed the licensing issue, but it lost a lot of momentum. Also the general Squeak community remains more focused making a better Smalltalk -- not making something better than Smalltalk. That is something Alan Kay has pointed out -- saying he wanted people to move beyond Smalltalk with Squeak as a stepping stone. Yet most people seem to not pay attention to that. But if even Dan Ingalls could be willing to build new ideas like the Lively Kernel on JavaScript, I decided I could too, and I shifted my career in that JavaScript direction inspired by his example. As luck would have it, my day job is now programming in the overly-complex monstrosity that is Angular, when I know the more elegant Mithril.js is so much better from previous experience using it for personal FOSS projects... I guess every technology has its hipster phase where decision making is more about fads than any sort of technical merit or ergonomics? I can hope that sorts itself eventually. But once bad standards get entrenched either in a group or the world at large, it can be hard to move forward due to sunk costs, retraining costs, retesting costs, and so on. But, thick-headed as I am, I keep trying anyway. :-) And as in another comment I made, there are important social/political reasons to keep trying to create better systems to support democracy: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15311950 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15311950