18 ms·
Forget Equifax. Facebook and Google Have the Data That Should Worry You
- traviscj 9y agoSeems like there's a (difficulty/physical file size)/(profit or effort)*(likelihood of success) score that matters in these things: a terabyte of credit card numbers (alone) would be 62.5 billion card numbers, but a terabyte of facebook chat messages/private pictures is some small fraction of data. It'd be much easier for O(20 mb) to move off the network than O(500 GB). The former can be profitably resold, while the latter requires a careful search to find high value data (e.g. pictures like the fappening, I guess?) and no foolproof profit mechanism. And the sheer size brings other problems like how to store it and how to exfiltrate it and deal with it without being noticed. And of course, if you ARE good at all of the above, why not give in to a chill life in SF instead of a "life of crime" and all the volatility/violence/cloak-and-dagger that goes with it? Not saying a Facebook/Google data breach isn't terrifying -- it certainly is, and the privacy implications are indeed upsetting -- but the profitability path is just not as clear. The "Russian propagandists" angle from the article is interesting, but seems a bit separate from the "FB has a shitload of data on people" problem. It's basically using the ad/social aspects of the service as designed: changing people's perspectives on something you want them to feel differently about. (Albeit aimed at a different target!) Not sure how to solve that problem.
- 21 9y agoWhat's the value of a credit card number? It can quickly be changed and you would be hard pressed to exploit a billion of them at the same time. What's the value of a psychological profile built from FB data? People say Trump won the election because Cambridge Analytica built a psychological profile of most Americans and targeted them with customized propaganda. Probably an exaggeration, but it's early days. This will only get better. Can you make your psychological profile invalid the same way you can change your credit card number?
- ben_w 9y ago> you would be hard pressed to exploit a billion of them at the same time. Really? A billion automated orders for something, followed by the banking system having a metaphorical heart attack and either cancelling lots of/all cards (breaking normal usage until the card printers can catch up), or few/no cards (and risking further, directly exploitable, fraud)? Sounds like a potent way to successful fight a nation-state from a coffee shop.
- solomatov 9y agoYou're thinking in terms of today. Network throughput keeps growing and 500GB in 10 years might become really little. We should think ahead not try to fix it after the disaster.
- eveningcoffee 9y agoNo, both are bad and we should not forget none of them.
- program_whiz 9y agoI think that the US gov has not yet realized the full potential danger of data exposure. The best thing is to plan for these disaster scenarios like you would pandemics, wars, and natural disasters. There should be strong regulations, a set of protocols, a way to mitigate these situations. Understandably, the government is way behind on this issue, still seeing the digital information (especially on social media) as secondary or less important. I think its the type of thing with banks that slowly evolved, where security got higher and higher, FDIC was established, bank vaults improved, alarming improved, money tracing was implemented. We aren't there yet for cyber crimes.
- singularity2001 9y agoI think the people have not yet realized the full potential danger of the US gov abusing our data.
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoThe danger is basically a nonrepudiation problem. Look at all the finger pointing after Trump was elected. It was Hillary's fault. It was Bernie's fault. It was the Dem's fault. Trump was what people wanted. It was the Russians. It was Facebook. It was the MSM. All this is just for an election. Assume someone does use the massive data stores of Google or FB to do something bad. How can you even identify that that happened? How can you identify malicious actors and the incompetent ones?
- program_whiz 9y agoThat's sortof like in the old days when someone robbed the bank, you had no way to even identify them if they were masked. If they travelled far, you couldn't find them, no cross-state warrants. Also, they would rip off the traveling gold wagons and make off with untraceable gold they could melt and split for money. In those days, the idea of tracing or catching these criminals would have seemed nigh impossible. I'm sure with enough brain power, lost billions, corrupt elections, and casualties, we'll come up with something sooner or later to mitigate the issues.
- hodder 9y agoYes they have immense amounts of personal data and that is worrying. It is worrying they share this data with government agencies, marketing agencies etc. BUT, unlike Equifax they haven't been completely compromised by hackers. Equifax is unique it's level of incompetence. I'm surprised the equity is holding up as well as it is. The company is grossly negligent.
- nxsynonym 9y agoNot only that but Facebook and Google collect personal data voluntarily, to some extent. Equifax leaked THE personal identifier used in the U.S which affects a persons livelihood. I'm not worried out Facebook getting hacked and someone getting 10 years worth of photos, shopping data, or browsing history. Even credit cards have better protection than what Equifax has for SSNs. And again, the consumers who shoulder the burden of this catastrophic data breech had absolutely no say in who brokered the SSNs.
- 21 9y ago30 mil US accounts on FB were scraped using Mechanical Turk in an ingenious way. No hacking was required. I don't think that for many it matters if their data was obtained through hacking or through legal means. https://theintercept.com/2017/03/30/facebook-failed-to-protect-30-million-users-from-having-their-data-harvested-by-trump-campaign-affiliate/ https://theintercept.com/2017/03/30/facebook-failed-to-prote...
- ggggtez 9y agoYou don't have your social security number and loans on your Facebook profile (or maybe you do). However whatever you put on Facebook was your choice. Nobody "posts" to Equifax.
- 21 9y agoI agree with you, but things are changing. Facebook can create a shadow profile on you, friends can tag you into pictures without your consent, when you delete data it will still remain in Google caches and you will need to individually request removal for each URL, because it won't automatically remove them if the original page from FB is gone.
- arkem 9y agoI'm not particularly worried, Google and Facebook have two of the best security teams in the world and spend an amazing amount of money to protect customer data. The amount of convenience I get from Facebook and Google outweigh the risk I'm exposed to in my opinion. If Governments want to create data protection regulations I'll save my opinion until I see whatever regulation is proposed but I think it'll be difficult to create data protection regulation that is effective at protecting people without imposing a large expensive burden on companies.
- mcast 9y agoYou're a little foolish to believe that some sensitive data within Google/Facebook/XYZ does not get shared outside with FVEY countries and intelligence agencies.
- arkem 9y agoAs someone who has worked for a five eyes intelligence agency and at Google I can tell you that Google does not share sensitive data with the Government unless compelled to do so by law.
- psyc 9y agoDo you have the "pay grade" to be able to make this assertion credibly? One cannot, in general, see the forest for the trees. This adage is not merely a put-down.
- lisper 9y agoI worked for Google a long time ago and it's almost certainly true that this still official company policy. The real question is whether all Google employees always act in accordance with that policy. That is a much dicier proposition. It's also an open question how much data Google is compelled to share by law in the age of NSLs.
- arkem 9y agoIf you're asking whether I was the director of my agency or the CEO of Google then the answer is no. I have also not worked for the Government in about 6 years or Google in 4 years so maybe everything changed the moment I left. However, I was an Assistant Director (which is a senior tech / middle management kind of level) at first an intelligence agency, and then at a similar grade in a law enforcement organization and then later a security engineer at Google. The idea that an intelligence agency (or law enforcement agency) would ask Google for help isn't far fetched, in fact when I was in law enforcement we'd ask private companies for help all the time. Some of the time they'd help, the rest of the time they tell us to come back with a warrant. Google was famously in the second category, to the point where we'd not even bother asking. Even if we had a warrant we'd hesitate because we'd expect Google to challenge the warrant in court and it'd be a huge expensive hassle. When I worked at Google it was the same, the idea of sharing private information with anyone was anathema. Engineers even being able to see private information without an audit trail and alarms going off was next to impossible. The idea of a secret extra-legal conduit of information from Google to the US Government seems so far fetched to me that I have trouble even considering it. If there is a conduit for information it's there because the US Government has some legal instrument to compel Google to create it and that Google grudgingly has accepted the instrument as valid. But what do I know, like I said, I wasn't the CEO of Google or DIRNSA. Maybe I just was never in the right rooms or policy meetings? Maybe everything I saw was staged for my benefit.
- xtracerx 9y agoWhy does it feel like there is a barrage of propaganda being published against tech companies right now?
- jacksmith21006 9y agoThink it is pretty clear there is. Now for what purpose and whom? Is it to create more distrust in the US? Is it to try to get us to destroy ourselves from within?
- notacoward 9y agoSome of it might be related to partisan politics, in which these organization play an increasingly important role. Some of it might be competitors or would-be competitors. A pretty fair bit, especially here, is likely to be sour grapes and tall poppy syndrome. Some people feel they deserve those billions, and are extremely bitter toward those who actually succeeded.
- CaptSpify 9y agoProbably because they've been using known and unsafe practices for a long time, and we're giving them a bunch of our data. Seems like "propaganda" is the wrong term, and "legitimate concern and skepticism" would be the correct term.
- ams6110 9y agoI think what we're seeing are the same sorts of things that led to building codes, fire codes, licensing of architects and civil engineers. After so many building collapses, bridge collapses, or disastrous fires, people finally demanded that "build whatever you want, however you want" is not OK if you are making something for use by the general public. I think ultimately we're going to see legislation requiring licenses/certifications for software designers and software companies and software service providers. Like a civil engineer is licensed and personally liable for designs he approves. It's coming. People will only tolerate the current shitshow that is our industry for so long.
- yosito 9y agoIt should be coming, but we can't make any assumptions. This kind of standard won't happen on it's own. People need to fight for this standard to make it happen. The worrying thing is that Facebook and Google have an unprecedented amount of power to resist external restrictions on what they can build and how they can use it. Simply attempting to pass legislation may not be enough.
- blfr 9y agoIt might happen but I don't think it'll work. Codes work because they deal with known, predictable, and repeated problems. You can keep improving the fire code with each disastrous fire and fire will not actively try to outsmart you next time. Security OTOH is anti-inductive because you're dealing with intelligent attackers adjusting their methods. In this environment, security code and certifications will just become another pile of papers for bureaucrats to verify after your data was leaked anyway. But maybe it will at least force manufacturers to make their products' software updateable.
- romwell 9y agoI disagree. The attackers can't get the data if you don't store that data to begin with. Voila! I think there should be legislation that simply restricts who can store which data, as well as legislation that forces open-sourcing of critical infrastructure software.
- samfisher83 9y agoAs far as I know google/Facebook doesn't have my SS number, dl license number etc. I would be more worried if they hacked my bank account etc.
- solomatov 9y agoAre you sure that you don't have your SS or DL number somewhere on google or Facebook? You accountant might have sent you your tax return in pdf via email. You might have took a picture of a document where your SSN appears.
- wodahs02 9y agoYes and no. FB and Goog dont have your most important data. Equifax has EVERYTHING that is core to your being
- ghughes 9y agoIt's the other way around.
- solomatov 9y agoPeople don't understand why it's dangerous because such hacks are what Taleb calls black swans. They are really rare, but their results might be catastrophic in unforeseen way. Those who thinks that Google and Facebook have harmless data compared to Equifax, imagine what criminals might do with all your information located there to target you. Add here AI technologies, like NLP and speech synthesis, and it gets really scary. Think about massive but at the same time highly targeted social engineering attack abusing all this information. We should not allow this to happen and it's better to prevent it now, not after the moment such attack happens. Markets won't solve this problem due to rarity of such events. Only legislation can help here.
- solomatov 9y agoMarc Goodman wrote a book on this: http://www.futurecrimesbook.com/bios/marc-goodman http://www.futurecrimesbook.com/bios/marc-goodman He has a TED talk about the same topic: https://www.ted.com/talks/marc_goodman_a_vision_of_crimes_in_the_future https://www.ted.com/talks/marc_goodman_a_vision_of_crimes_in...
- s73ver_ 9y agoDo they? Cause Equifax has my financial info. Facebook and Google know that I like cat videos.
- notacoward 9y agoExactly. Also, people opt in to Google and Facebook, at least to some degree. I never consented to Equifax having my data, and I got nothing in return for it. It's the difference between a free transaction - even one you regret later - and theft.
- CaptSpify 9y ago> people opt in to Google and Facebook What about shadow profiles? Nobody is opting into those.
- SilasX 9y agoGoogle knows everything you searched for. Hope you never looked up an AIDS test.
- bogomipz 9y agoAs a natural-born American you still have the choice to not sign up for a Google account or a Facebook account. You do not however have the option of refusing to apply for a social security number when your child is born. This piece looks likes little more than propaganda from the credit reporting agencies. Shame on you Bloomberg.
- Gracana 9y ago> you still have the choice to not sign up for a Google account or a Facebook account Unless you're careful to guard against it, you're loading up Facebook and Google's trackers on just about every site you visit. Registering for an account is not a prerequisite for them to build a profile on you.
- orthecreedence 9y agoCan someone open a bank account in my name or take out a loan based on data google/facebook have on my browsing history? I kind of doubt it. I saw this post and immediately thought "propaganda" as well.
- _tulpa 9y agoMaybe, just maybe, there's a bit more at stake than just your credit rating.
- orthecreedence 9y agoMaybe I can be concerned about both at the same time. Just because Facebook and Google have damaging information about me doesn't mean Equifax doesn't. Also, I am not a homeowner, so a hit to my credit could be devastating financially. As others have said, google/facebook are opt-in. I have knowingly given them the information they have on me. Equifax is not opt-in. I have never used any of their services.
- 659087 9y ago
- Jimmie_Rustle 9y agoI don't know about the author, but FB and Google do not have my SSN. I don't even think FB has my exact address. How is this the same or worse than the Equifax breach? The point about "private messages, photographs, and most of our secrets" being vulnerable is laughable, unless you are some prime-time celebrity that may be targeted individually. Please tell me how attackers are going to sift through terabytes of completely innocuous or boring communications to find that you were cheating on your S/O or whatever. How would a criminal even monetize such information? They are after personally identifiable information in a reasonable format that is ready to be used for fraud, ie in a table, not sprinkled throughout millions of individual messages.
- TheRealPomax 9y agoHow about "Don't you dare forget Equifax, and Google and Facebook are even worse"? Bloomberg's gotten really annoying with their clickbaity titles this year.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jayess 9y agoI'm becoming more and more convinced that Facebook is simply an evil company, and Google isn't far behind.
- bukgoogle 9y agoIts more than terryfying me.. absolutely hate both
- mooman219 9y agoI don't understand why people villinize Facebook and Google so much. If anything, they've done a fantastic job at data security. They explicitly hire security engineers and even offer bug bounties for potential issues, treating security as a priority. I mention this all the time: What scares me is companies in the wild that consider security as a burden rather than something core to their business. We see companies even actively punishing people for finding issues in their software and going through responsible disclosure. This sort of response should be outlawed. Equifax's breach is just a drop in the bucket compared to all the other breaches less well known companies experienced in the past. Like hey, some obscure pay system at Home Depot got hacked and someone stole my credit card, but fuck Google for tracking me online. We have this "too small to care" mentality about these business committing horrifying security transgressions until it's too late.
- AzzieElbab 9y agoOh man! Why google and not your government, bank or health care provider?
- didibus 9y agoThe vast majority of people have nothing very precious to lose to text message leaks, or even photo leaks, but they do have a lot to lose credit wise and financially from identity theft. Seriously, I'm open for arguments, but the data Google has on me is definitly not as risky. Maybe I'd lose some pride, but not money and financial power. And lets be real, the problem is that government and financial institutions don't use secret passwords, but only ids to authenticate you. That's where the change need to happen.