10 ms·
YouTube-mp3 agrees to shut down
- h2youtube 9y agotry https://h2converter.com https://h2converter.com, best tool convert youtube video to mp3 ;)
- Multicomp 9y agoLong since moved to Peggo. Works just as good but even has a video saving option
- tekmate 9y agoso, theoretically, if i used the asm.js port of ffmpeg.js to do the conversion clientside that would be ok?
- sigio 9y agoWhy bother transcoding... youtube will gladly serve you various audio and video formats seperately. Just download the opus stream and save to a file. Let te user transcode to mp3 if they need it.
- gruez 9y agoafaik they only serve AAC and opus audio, which should be fine on modern players, but people with embedded players and/or old ipods might need a mp3. >Let te user transcode to mp3 if they need it. convenience factor
- striking 9y agoYou need to put the video and audio streams together, though. Which requires a transcode pass.
- mixedCase 9y agoI think that's called muxing, since you aren't really changing codecs, just bundling streams together.
- satysin 9y agoNot a transcode just a mux of the different audio and video files into a container such as MP4 or MKV. Pop ffmpeg in the same directory as youtube-dl and it will do the work for you. A simple 'youtube-dl [video url] -f bestvideo+bestaudio' will get you a nice single file with the best audio and video :)
- intoverflow2 9y agoSo glad I exist in a timeline where youtube-dl exists. Having culture locked up in these corporate sites that can wipe it out or remove it in less than a second makes me so anxious.
- api 9y agoI am a confirmed packrat. When I hear a really interesting podcast, obscure piece of music, etc. I mirror it to local storage... especially if it's political. Storage is cheap. Doesn't even have to be 'verboten' political. It would be easy for an AI bot trained to curtail e.g. 'hate speech' to delete loads of things that are just unorthodox.
- Dirlewanger 9y agoAgreed, but it also makes me a little sad that we could potentially only have some shitty compressed transcode of a transcode copy of some rare album, since YouTube is plagued with those kinds of uploads. Really makes the loss of what.cd hurt even more.
- isatty 9y agored isn't doing too badly though
- ams6110 9y agoI'm a YouTube Red subscriber, and I also use youtube-dl to allow for offline listening on various devices. Since I'm paying Youtube, and not redistributing my downloads, I don't feel this is any different from DVR-ing a TV show or the old (and legal) practice of copying a vinyl LP to cassette tape so I could listen to it in my car.
- baldfat 9y agoExcept the content makers aren't getting revenue since YouTube Red pays for engagement. I LOVE YouTube Red I only use youtube-dl for special use cases.
- Synaesthesia 9y agoNever heard of it! However there’s keepvid.com, clip-converter and of course youtube-dl.
- slazaro 9y agoI use jdownloader, which can also download from many other sites.
- xrisk 9y agoyoutube-dl can also download from a wide variety of sites, contrary to what its name would have you believe.
- spookyuser 9y agoYeah it's more like *-dl. It's hard to find sites it doesn't work with.
- slazaro 9y agoI didn't know that, I'll check it out, thanks! :)
- akerro 9y agoList of supported sites: https://rg3.github.io/youtube-dl/supportedsites.html https://rg3.github.io/youtube-dl/supportedsites.html
- bo1024 9y agoI think this is an important ideological gray zone for copyright. The RIAA wants to have their cake and eat it too -- use Youtube to publicly and 'freely' distribute music to your computer (along with ads), but also completely control what your computer is allowed to do with the music. I don't see what kind of case they'd have against youtube-dl, which runs on your own computer, but I guess they can argue a site like this is "copyright infringement" even if it does the same thing as youtube-dl, just because it's a middleman website in between the user and youtube rather than code on the user's own machine. The reasoning is not too far from suing a CDN for copyright infringement because it doesn't have explicit license to copy and distribute the music.
- onli 9y agoIn many countries it is not a gray zone. It is explicitly legal.
- Mindwipe 9y agoIt is difficult to see how it would be explicitly legal in any country that is a signatory to the Berne Convention and the three step test. Which is almost every functioning country in the world.
- onli 9y agoHave a look at Germany then.
- alansammarone 9y agoCould you please expand on the matter?
- onli 9y agoSure. Dating back from the days of radio and cassettes, it is (to my knowledge) absolutely legal to make copies of streams for private use. Since artists are payed for copies via the GEMA, a organization distributing the german hidden taxes for it, people have the right to make such copies. Copies for private use are as such not a gray area, but explicitly legal. I fail to see how a site that helps making those copies could be illegal in any way. There was a court fight in Germany over the backups the site was doing, but it is telling that it was only about that, not the core functionality, and that this current attack on peoples right was launched from an US court.
- fh973 9y agoThere is also http://convert2mp3.net/ http://convert2mp3.net/ (from Germany). If I understand correctly, the reasoning is that a download is private copy, which is allowed in Germany, and can't be forbidden by the Youtube ToS. Unfortunately there is no information about the case available in English, here is some German: http://convert2mp3.net/index.php?p=legal http://convert2mp3.net/index.php?p=legal
- meirelles 9y agoGoogle also is trying to wipe out any reference they can to youtube downloaders. The publisher's Adsense account may get suspended/terminated if they link to (or mention!) any well-known youtube downloaders.
- ruleabidinguser 9y agoSeems like an abuse of power
- thrillgore 9y agoAt one point Google said they would never do it, which was the first sign that they were totally going to do it. Google is a for-profit monopoly. Stop thinking they're the fucking good guys.
- SAI_Peregrinus 9y agoThe only people who ever feel the need to say "trust me" are the ones who are trying to lie to you.
- staticelf 9y agoThis sounds like an awesome opportunity for me to create such a site.
- fimdomeio 9y agoThis is getting very weird. Using youtube-dl: Probably ilegal, but no one cares because you need basic technical skills and it's very dificult to chase people who use it. Using an add blocker during streaming: Very likely ok until people also start getting arrested for going to pee during tv comercials. Using youtube or spotify in a public place: This one makes peoples brains hurt, let's not even consider it. In the middle of all this how much are the artists getting for the streamings? how popular must one be for getting more than a cup of coffee worth of royalties each month? If authors are not making that much money do the copyright laws make any objective sense? Since after all they were created first and foremost to protect them. If they are not protected than music be free/libre because of the cultural value it has for humanity.
- baldfat 9y agoyoutube-dl = fightclub Rule #1 ---- No one talks about youtube-dl!!!!!!
- baldfat 9y agoOkay make youtube-dl more visible I am sure that will be a big benefit for the project.
- grapeshot 9y agoOne of the over-the-air TV channels in Los Angeles seems to be run off a YouTube playlist, which I know because it was stuck displaying the video unavailable message for most of last Saturday.
- enzanki_ars 9y agoOver-the-air TV channels fascinate me as their operation is very different across the US. Do you remember which one it was? Genuinely curious as I have been working on some programs to showcase the unique over-the-air broadcasts across the US.
- fapjacks 9y ago
- konart 9y agoUse youtube-dl manually or via telegram bot https://telegram.me/utubebot https://telegram.me/utubebot, for example
- jessriedel 9y agoFolks in this thread may be interested in "4k Video Downloader", an elegant and simple GUI for fast downloading of YouTube audio and video with multiple resolutions and options. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/4K_Video_Downloader https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/4K_Video_Downloader I use this with VLC to watch lectures with fine-grained control over the playback speed (i.e., 1.7x, not just 1.5x and 2x).
- chrshawkes 9y agoMore tools to steal money out of the pockets of those who provide content.
- bo1024 9y ago...in the same sense that bathroom breaks or channel-changing for TV ads are tools to "steal" money from the networks? Sorry, but nobody promised to watch the commercials. I don't think it's fair to imply some sort of moral contract that if I serve you videos with ads, you're obligated to pay attention to the ads as well as the content. You are free to do what you want, including pay someone else to cut the ads out for you or install a tool that does it for free. I have to accept these possibilities when I choose how to distribute my 'content' and so do the advertisers. (I realize that we're currently in an "equilibrium" where a lot of 'content' on the web is ad-supported so it's difficult for creators to distribute in any other way. That's unfortunate both for creators and users.)
- agumonkey 9y agoReminds me of the nice chrome extension that allowed playing youtube music in the background. Streamus IIRC; and youtube was very nasty toward the guy. Anyway farewell ytmp3
- FiveSquared 9y agohttps://en.savefromnet.com https://en.savefromnet.com
- FiveSquared 9y agohttps://en.savefromnet.com https://en.savefromnet.com. Thank me later.
- captn3m0 9y agoRelated to youtube-dl, I recently found out streamlink[0], which is a nice cli tool that does streamripping from various websites (it even supports twitch streams) to help you play these streams on the player of your choice (instead of the browser). Of course this also circumvents ads as a side-effect. [0]: https://github.com/streamlink/streamlink https://github.com/streamlink/streamlink
- seabird 9y agoThe music industry is a scummy vampire industry that is desperately grasping at any life it can suck out of people that actually do something productive. We will undoubtedly see the RIAA fade to effectively nothing in the next few decades, which is a fitting end for an organization that only exists in its current incarnation because of a long history of shafting people. In the age of the internet, there is very, very little that a record label will do for you that will leave you better off. Producing and distributing music is approaching triviality. Arranging concerts and touring isn't easy, but no full-time job (which is effectively what music is for you at that stage) is, and there are plenty of independent acts that have done and still are doing it. More often than not, all industry involvement will net you is you losing out on revenue from record sales with few upsides. I'll be glad to see the RIAA and record label asswipes go belly up in a blaze of tears, weeping, and gnashing of teeth, all while wondering why their business plan that consisted entirely of leeching on actual productivity failed.
- chrshawkes 9y agoI used to think I didn't like the RIAA but they are on the side of good. There is a reason just about every content creator whether a musician or not is on their side.
- zeep 9y agoI usually put this in my .bash_aliases file: alias youtubemp3='youtube-dl --extract-audio --audio-format mp3'
- creatonez 9y agoIf you don't have to, don't re-encode it. All youtube videos nowadays have audio encoded in OPUS format, which compresses way better than MP3
- RealityNow 9y agoCopyright law is so outdated. When are we going to end these parasitic liberty-infringing laws?
- chrshawkes 9y agoThis doesn't just affect musical artist but all YouTuber's whom rely upon the platform to earn money for their work via advertising. Much of their content can instead be stream ripped and distributed without any earnings capabilities. I'm sorry, that's wrong in every way.
- Bromskloss 9y agoPff, that would reencode the audio anyway. Unacceptable!