21 ms·
“From the beginning, the employees dedicated to Project Titan looked at a wide range of details. That included motorized doors that opened and closed silently.
by tambourine_man 9y ago
“From the beginning, the employees dedicated to Project Titan looked at a wide range of details. That included motorized doors that opened and closed silently. They also studied ways to redesign a car interior without a steering wheel or gas pedals, and they worked on adding virtual or augmented reality into interior displays.
The team also worked on a new light and ranging detection sensor, also known as lidar. Lidar sensors normally protrude from the top of a car like a spinning cone and are essential in driverless cars. Apple, as always focused on clean designs, wanted to do away with the awkward cone.
Apple even looked into reinventing the wheel. A team within Titan investigated the possibility of using spherical wheels — round like a globe — instead of the traditional, round ones, because spherical wheels could allow the car better lateral movement.”
Very interesting, and one heck of a leak if true.
- make3 9y agoVery large tech companies always have people looking into weird slightly bullshit things. Doesn't necessarily mean that they had any real intention of committing to these ideas.
- intoverflow2 9y agoSomeone correct me if I'm wrong but it was my understanding Apple specifically stopped having teams "looking into weird slightly bullshit things" when Jobs returned. The Apple Knowledge Navigator video comes to mind, it feels very similar to video-vaporware like Microsoft Origami and Microsoft Courier
- stephengillie 9y agoOne example is Xerox's PARC.
- colechristensen 9y agoSeems like they were biting off way more than they could chew. If Apple partnered with an existing car company to apply their design principles on top of an existing car platform (e.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fiat_Mini_platform https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fiat_Mini_platform ) they could see a lot of success if they weren't too ambitious. They wouldn't win if they tried to reinvent the wheel because there would be far too big of a chance of either taking 10 years to build nothing or for building something that ended up being overly strange (e.g. Segway) Build a car that was familiar built out with quality materials and an iOS dash interface and you'd sell like hotcakes.
- onewaystreet 9y ago> Build a car that was familiar built out with quality materials and an iOS dash interface and you'd sell like hotcakes. That's basically what Tesla is doing with their Model 3.
- icpmacdo 9y agoWith the percentage of this project being a drop in the bucket compared to the 260B war chest I have nothing but positive thoughts for Apple attempting ambitious projects. In the next ~10 years they could be a trillion dollar company if they figure out how to get iPhone like growth out of another industry.
- hallmark 9y agoWe have the iPhone because Apple was so ambitious. Imagine if they had just partnered with existing phone manufacturers rather than trying to build a magic touch slate. Wait, we do know what would have happened - the Motorola ROKR, which everyone should be forgiven for forgetting.
- function_seven 9y agoI don’t forgive you for reminding me of that hobbled abomination. Though I guess it serves as an example of unchecked carrier power. Something to point to for today’s net neutrality arguments?
- greggman 9y ago
- timdorr 9y agoSounds a lot like The Homer to me: http://simpsons.wikia.com/wiki/The_Homer http://simpsons.wikia.com/wiki/The_Homer
- icpmacdo 9y agoThe Simpsons episode about self driving trucks was really before it's time too
- wodenokoto 9y agoSo much that it felt unrealistic and silly even for the Simpson! Crazy how a re-watch wouldn't be a look at far fetched science fiction.
- colordrops 9y agoSounds like a lot of bike-shedding.
- dmix 9y agoSounds a lot like a company that wanted to build a new house of the future but found out they prefer redesigning the light fixtures, faucets, etc rather than the house itself. Aka the general UX details rather that would be ideal in a modern house rather than the house itself. Apple probably would never have developed the smartphone first but they did a hell of a good job at getting all the details right with the iPhone once the bigger picture was worked out by other companies - and general technical progress. I'd imagine the same thing for the future AI interface. I'd want my AI front-end to be developed by Apple but my pedestrian detection algorithm developed by Google, and my car designed by BMW. The most important thing for talented people (and by proxy organizations) to figure is what they are best at contributing to the world and focusing on that. Instead of trying to do everything.
- colordrops 9y agoIsn't that just a form of bike-shedding?
- pertymcpert 9y agoHow is that bike shedding?
- colordrops 9y agohttps://en.m.wiktionary.org/wiki/bikeshedding https://en.m.wiktionary.org/wiki/bikeshedding "Parkinson observed that a committee whose job is to approve plans for a nuclear power plant may spend the majority of its time on relatively unimportant but easy-to-grasp issues, such as what materials to use for the staff bikeshed, while neglecting the design of the power plant itself, which is far more important but also far more difficult to criticize constructively" For Apple's task of building a automated car, industrial design is an "unimportant but easy-to-grasp" issue since Apple's expertise is design. They should have focused on the harder core problem of a car that can drive itself. In fact this seems almost like an archetypical example of bikeshedding.
- EddieRingle 9y agoI remember reading about Goodyear releasing a "spherical wheel" concept in early 2016: http://www.popularmechanics.com/cars/a19747/goodyear-eagle-360-spherical-tires/ http://www.popularmechanics.com/cars/a19747/goodyear-eagle-3...
- tempestn 9y agoISTM you could get all the same benefits much more easily using four-wheel independent steering, on regular, cylindrical wheels. The design could also be much more compact by sacrificing fully horizontal motion. (IE if the rear wheels only turned up to +-30 degrees, say.) It could still park very tightly using a zig-zag motion, and in any other situation tighter turning wouldn't be useful. Porsche (and possibly other companies) are already moving in this direction, with newer models featuring computer-controlled rear wheel steering. At low speeds the rear wheels steer in the opposite direction to the front, and at high speeds in the same direction.
- MrFoof 9y agoActive rear-wheel steering actually has a far larger history than its recent resurgence from Porsche, actually coming from Japanese manufacturers with mostly hydraulic (not electric) implementations. * Nissan stared offering it with several 1986 Skyline trims, and would also offer it on Z32 300ZXs. * Honda starting offering it on the 1987 Prelude, and also on the Accord starting in 1991. * The 1988 Mazda 626 sedan (predecessor to the Mazda 6) had it. * Toyota offered it in Japan on the Camry/Vista for the 1988 model year. * ... and many, many more. From MPVs to pickup trucks. The modern resurgence started again with Nissan, with several Infiniti models (the M and Q) offering electric versions from around 2006, and it appeared in the R35 GT-R. Though BMW was technically first with the E65 7-series. Porsche got into the game with the 991 911 GT3 (and optional on all 991.2 911s) because it alone hacked 1.5% off of lap times. The benefit of the newer setups is how wonderfully simple it is in terms of parts, complexity, and reliability (and no more hydraulic leaks!) Having driven both the R35 and 991.2s, the difference is pronounced. RWS is one of the reasons why the GT-R could manage itself (it is approaching 4000 pounds) as well as it could around the track, and why the latest 911s I've driven on track were so eager to dive-bomb apexes compared to any other 911 I've ever driven.
- nradov 9y agoSpherical wheels are such a stupid, dangerous idea. The contact patch on regular tires is already tiny. Make them spherical and the contact patch becomes even smaller, which will cause them to lose traction and spin out in any rapid maneuver (like to avoid a collision).
- ars 9y agoOnly if you massively increase the PSI so that the tire stays spherical. If you keep the PSI at normal levels the contact patch will be exactly the same size as it is now, and the tire will deform on the bottom. So just design it to be extra flexible.
- xgbi 9y agoDropping the pressure in the tire will lead to (way) higher risk of tearing of the tire fabric. You should never drive with a deflated tire, it multiplies the risk of tire failure like crazy. So no, deflated spherical wheels is not a good idea :/
- lagadu 9y agoHe's not saying it should be completely deflated, it just shouldn't be at max pressure; you can control the amount of deformation with pressure.
- nradov 9y agoNo that's not how it works. Look at a regular car tire. It's basically flat perpendicular to the direction of travel so the entire width of the tire is in contact with the ground. With a spherical tire the sides bend up away from the ground and only a single point is in contact. In order to get a larger contact patch you would have to run much lower tire pressure leading to worse handling, higher fuel consumption, and accelerated tire wear.
- Jyaif 9y agoThe surface contact of perfect cylinder (a regular car tire), and a perfect sphere (the iTire) is the same: 0 cm^2. From that fact, you are saying that "obviously" the deformation of a cylinder (with some diameter/width ratio) filled with gaz at a certain pressure against a flat surface will lead to a higher surface than a sphere with the same pressure? It's not obvious at all. Give me math+physics proof or GTFO.
- Animats 9y agoA team within Titan investigated the possibility of using spherical wheels — round like a globe — instead of the traditional, round ones, because spherical wheels could allow the car better lateral movement.” Somebody liked the Audi RSQ from Minority Report.[1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Audi_RSQ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Audi_RSQ
- aiiane 9y agoAs the page you linked indicates, the Audi RSQ was from I, Robot. The car in Minority Report was a Lexus 2054 (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lexus_2054 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lexus_2054). :)
- eloisant 9y agoApple is good at taking something that works but in a clunky way, and make it clean and perfect for consumers. Not to be first to market. There were smartphones before the iPhone, and there were mp3 players before the iPod. If Apple is to reproduce the successes they had they will release a driverless car a few years after the competitors but it will finally be the one that "just works", without the clunky design and the necessary tweaking and weird options.
- mhb 9y agoAnd, if it's electric, you'll have to replace the power cord every year or two because strain reliefs are aesthetically offensive.
- LoSboccacc 9y ago> because spherical wheels could allow the car better lateral movement uhm, looks more like management entered the project without any real goal or metric for success, throwing ideas at walls just for the sake of budgeting.
- jacquesm 9y agoThis so reminds me of the discussion about fire from the Hitch Hikers Guide to the Galaxy. The challenge of a self driving car is to get it to drive by itself, not to try to make it look good and to solve a whole pile of engineering problems that have had everybody in engineering looking at them since as long as we have the profession. Making gadgets and making a self driving car require a different mind-set. The first is an exercise in consumer packaging, the second is a serious endeavor in engineering something tremendously difficult from the ground up. What the vehicle looks like is not important at this stage, what is important is whether it can be done at all with sufficient reliability to let it out of the lab and into the mass market. When someone seriously suggests to 'reinvent the wheel' it is time to re-focus.
- majjam 9y agoHere's a link to the relevant HHGTTG quote: https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/The_Hitchhiker%27s_Guide_to_the_Galaxy#Chapter_32 https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/The_Hitchhiker%27s_Guide_to_th...
- wut42 9y ago>When someone seriously suggests to 'reinvent the wheel' it is time to re-focus. Goodyear released spherical wheels. It's not that stupid at all to reinvent the wheel, sometimes: https://www.sciencealert.com/watch-goodyear-unveils-the-future-of-tyres-with-spherical-maglev-wheels https://www.sciencealert.com/watch-goodyear-unveils-the-futu...
- jacquesm 9y agoYou're missing my point. It may not be stupid to reinvent the wheel at all. But that's not a project that you should mix with inventing a self driving car unless you conclude that spherical wheels are the only way a self driving car will ever become a reality. Similar to how every software application project could theoretically result in a new database, a new operating system and if you really want to go all out a new CPU it is much more efficient to concentrate on your application if you actually want to see it go to market. > Goodyear released spherical wheels. No, they didn't, that's just some fancy CG stuff, not an actual product. Also, it just so happens that Good Year is in the wheels-and-tires business so for them such research makes good sense, and of course it is a theory of a concept, not an actual proof of concept much less something that they are ready to roll out. It's more like serious science fiction even than actual science, it's how things maybe could work, not how they actually work.
- amelius 9y agoPlease don't glorify companies before they actually deliver.
- jordache 9y ago>Project Titan looked at a wide range of details. That included motorized doors that opened and closed silently. Another example of apple putting too much emphasize on fluff... who cares about the door mechanism when the company doesn't know how to build the car it bolts to.
- dkonofalski 9y agoI remember when people went crazy trying to nitpick the probability of spherical "wheels" when "I, Robot" came out and Audi had designed a car with exactly the type of system being mentioned. The general consensus, and even Audi agreed, was that spherical wheels would really only work "in the future" when roads weren't as gritty and mechanical as they are now. They would really only work when roads were smooth and made of some yet-to-be-invented material that wouldn't crack or break in pieces under regular use.