12 ms·
I'd actually say just the opposite - the memo seemed to be written as well and in as conciliatory manner as it could be written and the memo made good (or at le
by joe_the_user 9y ago
I'd actually say just the opposite - the memo seemed to be written as well and in as conciliatory manner as it could be written and the memo made good (or at least plausible) point and bad points. But the bad points were so bad that it was appropriate and necessary to fire Damore.
Essentially, as analogy, there's no way for a person to say "Black people are inferior and shouldn't be hired", as a message broadcast through their entire workplace, and not have that person be creating a hostile work environment for African Americans. If that person says "I don't mean in general, I mean inferior just for this occupation, I don't mean inferior, just 'differently talented, they've got great rhythm'", it doesn't matter, if that person says "here's a study which says this, we should consider this in an open minded fashion" it doesn't matter. The message is unacceptable. That person is done, that person should be done.
- dguaraglia 9y agoThe memo makes a whole case against "the Left" (capitalization from the memo) and how "leftists" are violent. That doesn't sound like "conciliatory manner" to me, especially considering he makes a blanket statement about Google "leaning left."
- rpiguy 9y agoThe blanket statement that Google leans left is empirically true. You also seem to have misread his comments about violence, as he claims the left tends to be more compassionate. Did you read the memo?
- mempko 9y agoAn advertising company cannot lean left by construction.
- mantas 9y agoToday's left has went a far way from socialism and whatnot. It's funny how today's far right cares about "common man" and labour rights more than far left which is busy with identity politics. For example, in Europe more and more labour is voting for right wing parties. While left is becoming more and more rich/educated urbanite.
- dguaraglia 9y agoI don't want to go into a whole politics discussion about it, but while I do agree with you regarding the left/right switch on the working class voters, I don't necessarily agree that it comes from the right being about "working people" but rather about working people feeling threatened by recent cultural/economic changes brought by globalization. It's not a coincidence that both American and British people voted against their own interests because they were concerned about "immigration". In any case, it's not a discussion for HN, but I wouldn't mind having it over a few beers/coffees.
- mantas 9y agoEh, HN has went enough political recently... But personally I enjoy a diverse set of reasonable people to talk politics with. There're little places with not much echo chamber AND not much shouting at each other at the same time... The major question is what does count as being "about working people". Is it claiming you're for equality/diversity/whatever? Or working to make working people life better? Labour feel threatened by globalisation, migrants and so on. Today's left is very clearly for that. Thus labour feels left is no longer working for their interests. The right, which is against migrants, feel much ore for their interests. Of course, there's an economic theory that migrants help the host country's economy and everyone end up being better off. But a "working man" only see his wage stagnate due to increased competition and his rent raise. Or his work place gone completely due to outsourcing. The left just declaring that they're for the working man is not enough. Their recent actions very clearly don't ring a bell for the working man. The feels (as much as I don't like that) is very important in politics. People are tired of politicians talking about several-degrees-removed benefits. Although sometimes (but, as we can see, not always) politicians are totally right and it is actually the right thing to do, public needs at least some direct benefits right away. Although this is frequently called as populism in a derogatory way, I believe it's a crucial part of democracy. And it especially rings true to less educated and less well off people which happened to be core electorate of the left. Which is not a sign of "bigotry" or being "backwards" or whatever. Better off people have more wiggle room, can take more risks (e.g. voting for people who offer few-degrees-removed benefits in the future) and generally care about higher level stuff in Maslow pyramid. The labour don't have this luxury.
- dguaraglia 9y agoNo, I didn't misread the memo: > While Google hasn’t harbored the violent leftists protests that we’re seeing at universities, the frequent shaming in TGIF and in our culture has created the same silence, psychologically unsafe environment. What he does is list "compassion for the weak" as a "left bias". That's not necessarily a statement in support of leftist ideals when combined with this two assertions: > In addition to the Left’s affinity for those it sees as weak, humans are generally biased towards protecting females. > The same compassion for those seen as weak creates political correctness[11], which constrains discourse and is complacent to the extremely sensitive PC-authoritarians that use violence and shaming to advance their cause (Which, BTW, is right before the first thing I quoted.)
- nailer 9y agoReferring to incidents of left wing violence does not imply all leftists are violent.
- dguaraglia 9y agoWhat's your point? The same could be said of "conservative parties are a platform to neo-Nazis and white supremacists" it doesn't imply all conservatives are neo-Nazis and white supremacists, but... "the implication."
- weberc2 9y agoThose are different statements. The memo didn't say "liberal parties are a platform to authoritarians and antifascists". If it had, I would agree with your characterization. The strawman arguments in this drama are staggering. I guess Damore couldn't have been all wrong if his critics depend on mischaracterizations and other fallacies.
- nailer 9y agoMy point is that you wrote: > the memo makes a whole case... how "leftists" are violent. Which isn't true.
- InclinedPlane 9y agoOh really? Left and right imply different sides from a center. Do you have evidence that google "leans left" versus merely embracing majority positions? A sizeable majority of Americans believe in things like LGBT rights and the value of diversity. Those aren't "leftist" positions, they're widely popular American values.
- rpiguy 9y agoDamore's memo was in favor of diversity. Left and Right alike favor diversity, it how you get there where they disagree. Diversity does not mean supporting the thought police, encouraging mob mentalities, and adopting zero tolerance attitudes. A sizable majority of Americans do support gay marriage by almost 2:1, but they are very closely divided on other LGBT issues, particularly around what should and shouldn't be funded by the tax payer, etc. And while Americans value diversity they also value freedom. Scientifically the role of biology in gender behavior is not a settled issue, despite the many wishing to declare it so. I do not agree with the conclusions to which Damore jumped, nor do I feel strongly that biology was particularly relevant to the point he was trying to make. But it amazes me how even broaching the discussion triggers people.
- mixmastamyk 9y agoRight. Anytime I read or hear someone stress the left or right (lib/con, etc) in an argument, it is often a warning sign that the person watches too much corporate television and that a low-quality argument is on its way.
- Danihan 9y agoHe said PC_authoritarians are violent. Not leftists.
- dguaraglia 9y agoStraight from the memo: > While Google hasn’t harbored the violent leftists protests that we’re seeing at universities, the frequent shaming in TGIF and in our culture has created the same silence, psychologically unsafe environment. Emphasis mine.
- Danihan 9y agoYou seem to have modified the memo slightly to enforce your point. >While Google hasn’t harbored the violent leftist protests that we’re seeing at universities He's saying the leftist protests at Berkeley were violent. Which... is simply a factual statement.
- dguaraglia 9y agoI did clarify the emphasis was mine. Also, I'm not sure I'd qualify it as "simply a factual statement" when there were a bunch of alt-righters participating in the violence. Ever heard of alt-right hero "Based Stickman"? People pay for his tickets to go incite violence across the US. Such a symbol of peace! Seems more like a lie by omission to me.
- ShannonAlther 9y agoYou didn't just add emphasis, you changed the original text from "leftist" to "leftists" and failed to indicate this, which is dishonest.
- dguaraglia 9y agoHuh, I was going to complain about it being a direct cut and paste from the document, but it does look like I managed to stick an 's' in there after I copied the text. Sorry, didn't notice. The actual quote is: > While Google hasn’t harbored the violent leftist protests Still doesn't change the meaning, my point being that the "violent leftist protests" he talks about don't happen in a vacuum. On the other side of the 'violence' there's always been lovely people like the alt-righter "hero" Based Stickman inciting violence. To me, his choice of side to blame for the violence is pretty telling of what he thinks about "the Left". Whether correctly or incorrectly identifying them as the culprits of the violence, he's making a statement about the "movement" and not the particular instance of violence.
- ZeroGravitas 9y agoWomen are more "left" than men generally. They're also less violent than men, so a) you'd think that would make the right more violent, and b) it puts his stated goal of more right-wing thought at Google in direct opposition to hiring more women.
- Udik 9y agoAgain, like many others you are confusing "less people from this group are qualified" with "people from this group are less qualified". The first doesn't say anything about single individuals, and doesn't suggest any discriminatory practice against the group. The second does.
- jandrese 9y agoIn practice both statements have the same outcome. Hiring managers aren't omniscient.
- Delmania 9y agoYes, there's no way to say either of those statements to a member of a given group and not offend that person.
- Udik 9y agoI can understand this. But things can be offensive and still be true. It's a possibility. I'm not particularly fond of pointing out, or even researching, possible differences between groups of people; however, the insistence on the opposite, when it's not perceived as backed up by substantial proofs, ends up provoking a response from those who value truth at least as much as harmony.
- rhcom2 9y agoThe article rebuts this point by name.
- dguaraglia 9y agoOne of the women in the article addresses that very aptly: > Assuming that it’s true that women on average are more likely to have trait X, why should any woman have to overcome the additional barrier of proving that she’s not like other women, or that if she IS like other women, that the trait has no bearing on her job performance? Creating a stereotype generates distrust in the individuals that are part of the group described by the stereotype. You yourself had to delve on the wording of the phrase to explain why you think it's different. Do you think the average person would put as much thought on the wording?
- jandrese 9y agoIt's entirely possible for an argument to be correct, but too narrowly focused. If you're saying "group X is inferior and and I can prove it mathematically", that's still wrong because those people don't have a choice about being a member of that group and still exist in society. Discriminating against them drags society down. It's a prisoners dilemma. If everybody hires fairly then the relative drag is spread across the entire economy and everyone comes out better in the end. If they try to cheat then they'll have a local advantage but in the end it only encourages everyone else to cheat and you end up in the worst case scenario with the massive drag on society as a whole. So the only rational solution for these corporations is to pretend to be as inclusive as possible while secretly trying to cheat as much as possible, which is exactly what we see. When some dumbass publishes a paper to the entire world saying "Hey, we should openly cheat.", of course he's going to get fired.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- generic_user 9y agoOr you can just move most of your operations to Asia or Eastern Europe where they don't have these western liberal ideological impediments to business. And Ironically provide a higher percentage of highly qualified Women in STEM professions.
- mathw 9y agoWell what do you know, I think you just proved that the ratio of qualified women in STEM professions in the Western world is due to cultural discrimination or disincentivisation instead of inherent capability!
- MollyR 9y agoAs a korean woman, I can tell you its the opposite. We don't have the luxury of pursuing passion jobs. I would have preferred to be an artist or a philosopher, bu t my family was poor and had bills to pay.
- zo1 9y agoI'm always amazed at how touchy discussions on that topic are, even more so than the Male/Female ones. I personally wouldn't bring up any studies/factual-statistics regarding it in polite conversation with a member of the relevant race being present. There is a whole wikipedia article devoted to it with a range of information on the topic: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Race_and_intelligence https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Race_and_intelligence
- joe_the_user 9y ago"I personally wouldn't bring up any studies/factual-statistics regarding it in polite conversation with a member of the relevant race being present. [links to studies]" Which is to say you either A: don't consider hn polite conversation or B: don't imagine the "relevant race" is present.
- mastazi 9y agoHN is definitely not what I would call polite conversation. Casually talking about the weather, asking how the wife and boys are is. It is my understanding that this community makes a point about sharing "anything that a good hacker would find interesting".
- flukus 9y agoMore likely C: They won't get fired for a post on HN.
- mundo 9y agoThat's a really inflammatory and totally inappropriate analogy. Downvoters, please cite which part of Damore's essay you think is comparable to overt racism. He explicitly said that he thinks women are capable, and should be hired.
- CydeWeys 9y agoI wonder why he only attempted to address biological sex, and not also other factors like race.
- unityByFreedom 9y agoHe may actually have referenced race. He brings up IQ here, "the Left tends to deny science concerning biological differences between people (e.g., IQ and sex differences)" IQ has no relevance to a discussion on gender gaps, so, why mention it? The quote's context is politics. In that context, IQ has recently been used in discussions over racial differences [2]. It begs the question, is Damore being honest about his views on race? If we replace "IQ" with "race", would that change the meaning he meant to convey? [1] https://www.quora.com/What-do-scientists-think-about-the-biological-claims-made-in-the-document-about-diversity-written-by-a-Google-employee-in-August-2017/answer/Suzanne-Sadedin https://www.quora.com/What-do-scientists-think-about-the-bio... [2] https://www.vox.com/the-big-idea/2017/6/15/15797120/race-black-white-iq-response-critics https://www.vox.com/the-big-idea/2017/6/15/15797120/race-bla...
- jules 9y agoYou are projecting your own biases onto that statement.
- studentrob 9y agoLooks like the reasoning came from the Quora article. Do you have another explanation?
- bluGill 9y agoAre you saying that even if it is true the message is unacceptable and you cannot say it? I think you just made the point that we cannot talk about some things.
- pishpash 9y agoWhich is another way of saying, once again, that he was extremely naive to believe the freedom of speech exists in the workplace.
- rpiguy 9y agoDamore never said that women were worse engineers or that biology makes them worse engineers. There was no implied inferiority. It is largely the PC crowd who read implied-inferiority into any study of biological differences between male and female. If you look carefully at some of the comments from female Googlers after the memo was leaked, they talk about fears of being perceived as less capable based on their biology. See the memo itself isn't only dangerous, it is what it could lead to. But that isn't at all what the memo said.
- evolve2017 9y agoI think this has been talked about multiple times over - Damore did not have a line that states that women and/or minorities are bad engineers. He does, however, clearly state that Google's hiring standards had 'lowered the bar' for women and minorities. I think it's awfully charitable not to infer that he considers the women/minorities at Google (on average) to be inferior engineers. Still, it's true that he never said that...
- jquery 9y agoBy that logic, any criticism of hiring methods means you view the current crop of employees as inferior. Is saying "we need more diversity" code for "white men are inferior"? You might be on to something.
- cfelix 9y agoNot exactly, preferring a diverse group over a homogeneous one doesn't mean that the individuals of the homogeneous group are inferior. If the goal is to have a diverse group then a group composed only of women isn't ideal either. Diversity is not about raising or lowering the bar.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- literallycancer 9y ago
- nodamage 9y ago"Once we acknowledge that not all differences are socially constructed or due to discrimination, we open our eyes to a more accurate view of the human condition which is necessary if we actually want to solve problems." This is conciliatory to you? Implying that the opposing side is blind to the truth and such blindness is preventing them from actually solving problems? Because to me this comes across as hostile and condescending.
- tracker1 9y agoSo, you're saying that all differences are either "socially constructed or due to discrimination?"
- nodamage 9y agoNo. Note that my post makes no argument as to whether the claim "all differences are socially constructed or due to discrimination" is accurate or not. I could have left that part out, but didn't want to only quote half a sentence. My only point was that the sentence, as written, was hostile and condescending and does not represent a conciliatory approach to conversation.
- tracker1 9y agoyou were opposing "not all ..." as a construct that was hostile and condescending. I don't think that cherry picking one line out of a 10 page document with significant number of disclaimers, and which was originally presented in a way and desire to evolve and gather opinions represents the overall intent and tone of the document.
- dguaraglia 9y agoThere's plenty of antagonizing language in Damore's memo. Not to have to retype: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15022769 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15022769 > Google’s left bias has created a politically correct monoculture that maintains its hold by shaming dissenters into silence > but without evidence this is just veiled left ideology[7] that can irreparably harm Google [[ citation talks about Communist/Marxist ideals, directly equating Google with a Communist/Marxist organization ]] > Google’s left leaning makes us blind to this bias and uncritical of its results, which we’re using to justify highly politicized programs. > Discriminating just to increase the representation of women in tech is as misguided and biased [[ says this without citing any evidence at all of this happening ]] The "tone" of the document is pretty aggressive, even if Damore throws a lot of fluff and "but I don't mean..." in the mix. In general it sets it up as "Left is bad and violent, Google is left, FIX IT."
- oconnor663 9y ago> in as conciliatory manner as it could be written Strongly disagree. I think emphasis is a really big deal here. Here's a key line from the memo: > Of course, men and women experience bias, tech, and the workplace differently and we should be cognizant of this, but it’s far from the whole story. This runs right into the Jon Snow line, "everything before the word 'but' is horse____." It comes across that the author doesn't think workplace bias is as important as [other stuff], or maybe that he doesn't think it's important at all, which is understandably hurtful to tons of people. Maybe that's an uncharitable reading, but can you really write about something like this and ask your readers to be unusually charitable to you?
- joshuamorton 9y agoRelevant to your John Snow callout: https://www.economist.com/news/international/21726276-last-week-paper-said-alphabets-boss-should-write-detailed-ringing-rebuttal https://www.economist.com/news/international/21726276-last-w...
- oconnor663 9y agoNow that you mention it, I definitely got the comparison from that article. Should've credited it!
- humanrebar 9y agoExcept that article itself is an egregious "I'm glad you say you like diversity but...".
- md224 9y agoI may not be correct here, but it seems to me that Jon Snow's remark isn't universally true. (Paradoxes FTW!)
- ljcrabs 9y agoI think that you are projecting emphasis into that sentence. The disclaimer before the 'but' reads quite clearly to me.
- flukus 9y ago> The message is unacceptable. That person is done, that person should be done. This sounds like willfull ignorance, no matter how true something is you aren't allowed to say it because it might hurt some feelings. I'd prefer to acknowledge reality.
- ZeroGravitas 9y agoUnfortunately for him, he did basically say that about African-Americans. How else am I supposed to take it when a self-identity right wing person claims the left don't believe some science related to IQ in the context of a diversity memo. What "science" could he possibly be referring to other than the Bell Curve BS?
- sobani 9y agoDidn't he also refer the bell curve studies that claim that despite the same average intelligence, there are less 80 IQ women than men and there less 120 IQ women than men? So why wouldn't it be reasonable to assume when he was talking about IQ differences, he was talking about that? Why do you jump to the conclusion he must be talking about ethnicity? Afaik ethnicity wasn't referred to at all in his memo.
- ZeroGravitas 9y agoHe repeatedly refers to race in the context of diversity in his memo, at least 9 times the word "race" is used for example. Notably, he doesn't seem to feel the need to back any of that up with science, apart from (maybe!) the casual reference to IQ. Sometimes you'd think there were two completely different memos under discussion given the lack of basic agreement on facts as relate to the memo itself, never mind it's arguments and sources. Though, I guess you're right, he may have left it ambigous about exactly which IQ differences he believes in that "the left" don't. People seem to think it's wrong to complain about his communication style, but as this example illustrates, peppering a memo with alt-right buzzwords and then being ambiguous about which particular controversial IQ studies you support can just as honestly be interpreted as dog-whistling rather than incredibly high levels of naivety. I think most people suggesting his communication skills are lacking are actually just giving him the benefit of the doubt.
- Aeolun 9y ago> If that person says "here's a study which says this, we should consider this in an open minded fashion" it doesn't matter. The message is unacceptable. Ah, the famous, "I don't agree with it so it must be wrong" argument. I can see how the smart and well-reasoning people on HackerNews would use that. Yes...