12 ms·
German universities take on Dutch publishing giant Elsevier
- hetspookjee 9y agoHow did Elsevier acquire the wierd position it is in? What added value does Elsevier provide?
- nomercy400 9y agoAdded value: Reputation. You get your paper published in an Elsevier journal, your reputation amongst you peers rises. Usually this means more funding and better career prospects. Think similar to Fitch and Moody's in the financial sector (right?).
- tankenmate 9y ago1) Largely through mergers and acquisitions 2) Network effect (although with newer technology (social media, cheap hosting, cheaper devops, etc) this value is dropping precipitously)
- JMCQ87 9y agoThey bought up a bunch of academic journals. Added value is arguably negligible now, but some of the publications have the highest profile in their fields for years.
- twanvl 9y agoBefore the internet, publishers actually printed journals on actual paper. This cost a lot of money, and it makes sense that universities payed for subscriptions to physical journals. Today, the cost of these subscriptions hasn't changed much. But the added value is much less since everyone reads papers online.
- Vinnl 9y agoIf you're really interested, The Guardian recently did a very good longread on it: https://www.theguardian.com/education/2017/jul/10/the-lucrative-business-of-science-publishing https://www.theguardian.com/education/2017/jul/10/the-lucrat...
- Dolores12 9y agothey will find out soon that they are fine on their own without Elsevier...
- kutkloon7 9y agoGood for them. I never understood why people are paying Elsevier anyway. It seems like everything they do can be done for free.
- IshKebab 9y agoThis is great, but I don't know why the governments and universities don't just fund their own totally free open access journals. Journals can't be expensive to run. You basically just need a few admin people to poke reviewers, and a trivial website to host papers.
- lorenzhs 9y agoMany hiring decisions in academia still rely strongly on the reputation of journals where applicants published. This may be less accentuated in computer science, where most research is presented at conferences and preprints are often available on the arXiv, but it's a very important factor in many other disciplines. It's also the primary reason why researchers don't boycott these journals: most of them are simply not in a position where they can afford to without seriously damaging their career prospects. See also https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Price_of_anarchy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Price_of_anarchy - a system can get stuck in a terrible state where everyone's best move is to keep going. A much better equilibrium could be constructed (Price of Stability), but how do we get there?
- heavenlyblue 9y agoYou don't have to boycott anything - if a university starts a new journal and their respective academics start publishing with it they would have a public plausible deniability on why they're also publishing in this journal. That's a no-loss situation.
- matt4077 9y agoThe problem isn't that you're somehow branded a 'rebel' if you refuse to publish with Elsevier journals. It's that, when you're applying somewhere, they'll rank you by SUM(paper_i * impact_factor(journal_i)). That score will suffer, and nobody will care about your reasons. You're also underestimating the independence of researches at a university. They're not employees in the usual sense. In fact, the best method to stop them from publishing at some journal Y would be for the administration to tell them to publish in Y.
- lorenzhs 9y agoPrevious discussion of these negotiations and Project DEAL 8 months ago at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13187315 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13187315 Also, the article's link to Project DEAL is wrong (it goes to the German Research Foundation), it should be https://www.projekt-deal.de/about-deal/ https://www.projekt-deal.de/about-deal/
- karllager 9y agoBest of luck. Elsevier and other giants are putting significant resources in mimicking free and open structures in their portfolio to hide the infamy of their business model (selling a few bytes of publicly funded research over and over again). To the average decision maker these "new models" will sound perfectly fine. The EU want to make all research public by 2020? Elsevier and other have very deep pockets, so my guess would be 2025 at the earliest.
- karllager 9y ago> so my guess would be 2025 at the earliest. And since we are in guessing mode, here is another one: In a few years we will have multiple sci-hubs and pirate edu sites so by the time the public arrives at completely free research, it won't even be a victory any more - just a symbol of the wretchedness of their fight - which, by then, will make everybody wonder, why it took so long.
- Freak_NL 9y agoWhile SciHub etc. will help to liberate research for individuals, it won't stop university libraries from spending a lot of money on legacy journal subscriptions just yet.
- mirimir 9y agoMaybe, but: > Gowers hopes that German negotiators and Elsevier will both ‘refuse to budge’ and that contract talks break with no agreement. Under such a scenario he believes it will become clear that Germany’s researchers have not suffered any serious inconvenience. ‘This, I believe, is what would truly embolden other countries and lead to a collapse of the current system.’
- denzil_correa 9y ago> Elsevier and other giants are putting significant resources in mimicking free and open structures in their portfolio to hide the infamy of their business model (selling a few bytes of publicly funded research over and over again) This is the key aspect here which everyone needs to address. Just moving from a subscription model to "open access" where you still pay 2000$ per article won't solve or alleviate the problem.
- bcraven 9y agoThis is an excellent article from The Guardian that chronicles the history and current business practises of academic journal publishing if anyone fancies a read: https://www.theguardian.com/science/2017/jun/27/profitable-business-scientific-publishing-bad-for-science https://www.theguardian.com/science/2017/jun/27/profitable-b... (It's also on the Guardian Long Read podcast if you subscribe to that)
- wolfi1 9y agoperhaps also of interest: http://www.the-scientist.com/?articles.view/articleNo/27383/title/Elsevier-published-6-fake-journals/ http://www.the-scientist.com/?articles.view/articleNo/27383/...
- im3w1l 9y agoI used to think that Elsevier et al were just rentiers, and that bringing them down would be a pure win. But I'm not so sure anymore. When money left journalism we saw a big big quality drop. We now have lots of problems with fake news. It makes me think: what if the same thing will happen in science? I guess the affiliation of the researchers will still be there, but it still leaves me a bit uneasy.
- askmike 9y agoResearchers are not paid for the research, just the publishers. I can only see quality going up without them moderating and filtering with their misaligned incentives.
- llukas 9y agoElsevier doesn't pay for review nor to the authors.
- im3w1l 9y agoBut they pick trustworthy reviewers though?
- ansible 9y agoYes, but if Elsiver disappeared tomorrow, those reviewers could just go to other journals.
- lorenzhs 9y agoNo, the editor and their associate editors do that, and they don't get paid by Elsevier either. https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/43574/how-much-is-an-editor-paid https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/43574/how-much-...
- stoshe 9y agoAuthors can typically "suggest" reviewers for their papers. There have been a few scandals in the past where papers were published after being reviewed by family members, or even the original author using a maiden name. Elsevier, and many of the related companies under the Reed Elsevier family, make their money by facilitating the process, or making data searchable. Once upon a time this was huge as doing either of those things was a significantly costly and time intensive exercise. Today, they continue on pure momentum. If a few major research universities were to band together and form a cooperative non-profit journal, things would start to unravel for Elsevier.
- Boothroid 9y agoInteresting, I'd love to know what level this has escalated to behind the scenes - governmental? EU? If Merkel did a deal could the universities be forced to back down?
- lorenzhs 9y agoThat is so far outside of their competence that I'm not sure how you constructed this absurd scenario. Why would Merkel be able to sign a contract on universities' behalf? The EU is pushing for more open access publishing, but the way it can do that is via regulation or adding it as a requirement to EU-funded research.
- Boothroid 9y agoI was merely asking a question. Elsevier no doubt contributes large amounts of money to the Dutch tax authorities. Governments pick up the phone about this type of thing all the time. There is ample evidence of deal making at the EU level - I'm thinking of the watering down of emissions legislation to benefit German car makers. I don't think it's far fetched at all to imagine a quid pro quo taking place behind the scenes. My question was partly around what kind of leverage Merkel might have down at the university level, as I have no knowledge about this.
- Vinnl 9y agoThe funny thing is that the EU has largely been pushing for more Open Access due to the Netherlands' EU presidency last year - the Netherlands was already taking the lead at that point. Then again, the way the Open Access transition appears to be taking place right now seems like it could end up creating really nice profit margins for companies like Elsevier again, so maybe that was their plan all along.
- JMCQ87 9y agoThe federal state is not supposed to meddle in education in Germany, policy is decided on Bundesländer-level. They frequently do anyways, but I don't think it's important enough to them to get involved in this case.
- smartbit 9y agoDiscussed in January https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13187315 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13187315
- nomercy400 9y agoIf the German consortium is so big and influential worldwide, why bother with other journals like Elsevier? They might as well start their own open-access journal. Or isn't the Consortium that big/influential?
- kuschku 9y agoBecause they only decided to band together in 2014, and didn't want to spend their time and money on creating something new (which might even be illegal, the government can't compete with private companies)
- apexalpha 9y agoSure it can. Many, many government companies compete in the open market in my Country. I'm sure it's the same in Germany.
- kuschku 9y agoIt's not in Germany. And the government companies that did have been sued all the time, and lost every time. My city currently has the issue that we need new low-income and student housing, the private companies refuse to built it (not profitable enough), but say they'd immediately sue if the city would build on its own. The resulting housing crisis has driven up rent for 2 decades now, but we can't do anything. It looks like they're slowly coming to an agreement now, with the city making a deal that they can build such housing, in small amounts that are unlikely to influence the market prices, if it's built in places where no private developer wants to build.
- madez 9y agoWhere I live the government does compete with private companies. It works good for the people.
- somberi 9y agoA related read: The shackles of scientific journals- https://www.economist.com/news/leaders/21719480-and-how-cast-them-shackles-scientific-journals https://www.economist.com/news/leaders/21719480-and-how-cast... The problem with scientific publishing https://www.economist.com/blogs/economist-explains/2017/03/economist-explains-23 https://www.economist.com/blogs/economist-explains/2017/03/e...
- dschuetz 9y agoElsevier in its core is a bunch of managers/investors trying to get rich from exploiting scientific achievements for profit. They do not have in mind what's best for science, they've made that perfectly clear.
- notyourday 9y agoThat's because absolutely no one cares about it except for whining about Elsevier. We have a perfect way of distributing papers - it is called "Publish it on your blog". If your blog is the most awesome blog or even just more awesome than the lousy blogs, the concerned scientists would go there. Why isn't it happening? Because the content of the papers published on the blogs suck and no one cares.
- dschuetz 9y agoSo it's not that perfect after all? I've read some history about this publishing dependency problem with Elsevier. The scientists are part of the problem too. They are not completely innocent nerds who got bullied into this system. Most of them embraced it for convenience and fame, because, see, they haven't got time and money to do that on their own, because they are so busy 'sciencing' (honestly, most of it isn't 'research' anymore). I admire the German scientists who finally realized that mistake and now are trying to reverse it, if it is even possible.
- notyourday 9y agoBecause the issue is not hosting/prodiding publishing venue. The issue is that submitted original papers that are produced are garbage and neither EICs nor their reviewers give two cents about quality. Had not been the case this would not have happened: http://news.mit.edu/2015/how-three-mit-students-fooled-scientific-journals-0414 http://news.mit.edu/2015/how-three-mit-students-fooled-scien... Most of these companies have XML First type programs. What those who are so passionate about this topic should do is do is pay XML First fees for a sample of random 100 papers in 10 random publications and write a scraper to pull the papers in different production stages - from manuscripts to the end result. The beginning state would horrify you.
- merraksh 9y agoSeems like the trend is gaining momentum, though slowly. It's recent news that editors of a Springer journal (Springer is another large publisher) left and started their own journal [0]. [0] https://www.insidehighered.com/news/2017/07/31/math-journal-editors-resign-start-rival-open-access-journal https://www.insidehighered.com/news/2017/07/31/math-journal-...
- socrates1998 9y agoWhy do they even need that company? How hard could it be to just make everything open source and free? For real, this is like the easiest problem to solve. Just stop giving that corrupt company any money and do it themselves.
- OliverJones 9y agoAaron Swartz's influence on open publishing is still unfolding more than four years after his untimely death. The forces arrayed against open publishing are formidable: governments and big business. It's good to see a nation's universities working together on this.
- plaidfuji 9y agoGovernments are actually in a bit of a gray area. On the one hand, a politician can score cheap points with the public by saying "we should all be able to read what our tax dollars pay for!", and on the other hand, the government would ultimately be footing the bill for open access in the short term because their grant money would funnel to publishers by way of pay-to-publish open access fees. So there's significant incentive for the government to figure out an open access solution that involves as little publishing fees as possible. They just don't want to be the ones who pay for it and administrate it.
- dilemma 9y agoThis is like a university taking on the evil computer manufacturers or something. Sure, you can do it yourself, but you have to put in the work and the money to do so. Distributors and publishers exist for a reason.
- agussell 9y agoIf scientists continue tolerating the monopolies of big editorials, this situation is not going to change. It is time to embrace open access journals. Meanwhile, I use SciHub.
- eecc 9y agoMy minuscule contribution to the debate is lying on github [1]. The idea is to distribute papers over a P2P network. Uploads and metadata are digitally signed with PGP and you get to filter out all rubbish that is not originated from your WOT. You get "peer reviewed" when enough people of type "recognized reviewer" in your WOT publish a signed metadata "reviewed" stamp. It still needs a whole lot of work, I only ever managed to make it work over to machines on a LAN, it is OOM prone, GUI is fugly, and I could (should) probably re-start from scratch. But if you like the idea and feel like helping, do ping me... we can save the world! ;) [1]: https://github.com/ecausarano/heron https://github.com/ecausarano/heron
- AmIFirstToThink 9y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aaron_Swartz https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aaron_Swartz Go Germany!