46 ms·
Four Earth-sized planets detected orbiting the nearest sun-like star
- h4l0 9y agoHearing distances like 12 light years makes you think if it is ever possible to travel there. However, when you start to think about it, nihilist thoughts start to kick in.
- fsiefken 9y agoWith the EMdrive it'll take around 150 years (give or take a century), so it's within the realm of possibility if we can engineer a ship with shielding that can last that long. The mission becomes an order of a magnitude more difficult if you want to put a viable human population on it... watch Pandorum for one scenario.... perhaps it's best to send a seed ship (as written about in the excellent SF story by Pamela Sargent, Earthseed)
- swasheck 9y agoGive or take a century? So you're saying that the range could be 50-250 years?
- delecti 9y agoOn the scale of interstellar distances, even 250 years one-way is just down the block.
- kibwen 9y ago150 years by what calculations? Are you also factoring in deceleration time?
- ajross 9y agoAn "EmDrive" is a pseudoscience device. Poor calculation rigor is not the biggest error component in that number.
- jandrese 9y agoIt's a good example of the problem though. Any drive that relies on reaction mass will take too long to cross the distance to even nearby stars. The rocket equation kills the plan unless you're willing to make an absolutely ridiculous starship. So you need a reactionless drive, which thus far is entirely science fiction. This is even before you start thinking about micrometeorites in the way (which long transits increase the danger from), and simply maintaining complex machines in perfect working order for decades or centuries in the harsh vacuum of interstellar space with no external power source (no solar panels). And that's before you start thinking about how we don't even know how to colonize an alien world, and unless you're willing to wait centuries to get intelligence on the planets you're flying in blind. IMHO the answer to the Fermi Paradox is the most depressing one. Interstellar travel is too difficult and expensive. By the time it's feasible you are already well past the point of needing it. You can build endless orbital colonies and mine your home system and it's nearly unlimited resources forever. There is no need to embark on a colossally expensive boondoggle to colonize a distant solar system when everything you need is at home.
- abecedarius 9y agoThere's a bunch of ideas that the rocket equation doesn't apply to: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interstellar_travel#Non-rocket_concepts https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interstellar_travel#Non-rocket... Yes, it's hard at our current tech level. But not nearly hard enough to explain the Fermi thing. I mean, take your scenario of solar system development: it'd be natural to exploit the Kuiper Belt and then the Oort, and the Oort blends into interstellar travel, as Freeman Dyson pointed out -- still quick on a geological timescale.
- jandrese 9y agoThe problem with thinking about it on geologic timescales is that humans (and civilizations!) don't exist on geologic timescales. It's going to be a tough sell to tell people "You need to pay an extra tax for your entire life so we can fund construction of an interstellar ship that your great grandchildren might witness the launch of, but won't arrive at its destination for a thousand years after that." It's hard to imagine anything that could motivate the human race to do that short of the Vogon constructor fleet announcing that it will arrive within a couple of centuries, ready or not.
- fsiefken 9y agoit was an estimate based on a vague memory of this article https://www.nasaspaceflight.com/2015/04/evaluating-nasas-futuristic-em-drive/ https://www.nasaspaceflight.com/2015/04/evaluating-nasas-fut...
- svachalek 9y ago12 light years is actually very close as interstellar distances go. Such a mission could probably be launched in our lifetimes if the whole world got together behind it (which they won't but still...)
- dmix 9y agoWhich has fascinating implications when considering extraterrestrial life. But at the same time it's entirely possible that the closest other life is extremely far away which would make any theoretical travel time be too long to meaningfully discover earth. Does anyone recommend any books that have explored these ideas?
- jogjayr 9y agoFrom a practical standpoint though (assuming that every nation decided to work together) how would such a mission work? We'd most likely need a generation ship, given that current estimates of max velocity is in the range of 0.5 to 0.8c. That means spending trillions of dollars and putting thousands of people in a ship in orbit, sending them off and most likely never seeing them again. But before that we'd want to send unmanned probes to: a) test out the propulsion and other systems b) scout the planets themselves, identify a good candidate But the probe itself would take 20-30 years to reach + 12 more to report back. Otherwise you're asking thousands to be explorers and guinea pigs for all this technology, with no guarantees about finding a habitable planet or coming back home. With something like the Mars mission you'd probably get volunteers without any family. People would be far more reluctant if it's a generation ship.
- kuschku 9y ago> Otherwise you're asking thousands to be explorers and guinea pigs for all this technology, with no guarantees about finding a habitable planet or coming back home. That sounds like Mass Effect: Andromeda. Which is basically about that, humanity sending a sleeper ark to another galaxy (due to a perceived threat that might wipe out humanity in our galaxy), with no guarantee that there will be something there (although they did do some telescope measurements of the potential planets there).
- 9y ago
- semaphoreP 9y agoThis title is a bit imprecise. They detected four planets with lower bound on their masses to be down to 1.7 Earth masses. Because these planets don't transit, there are no direct measurements from their radius. They can use mass-radius relations to infer the radius of these planets, but the key finding is their masses (actually lower bounds on their masses).
- eggpy 9y agoCan you say they _don't_ transit? They say the planets were detected by analyzing star wobbles, which doesn't necessarily mean that the planets don't transit, just that it's not how they were detected.
- snug 9y agoWell it doesn't transit from our point of view, so yes, I think he can say that as the observer. "In astronomy, a transit or astronomical transit is the phenomenon of at least one celestial body appearing to move across the face of another celestial body, hiding a small part of it, as seen by an observer at some particular vantage point."[0] [0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transit_(astronomy) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transit_(astronomy)
- eggpy 9y agoI understand that. I guess I don't know how small we can reliably view transits. We can certainly see large planet transits. Perhaps planets of this size are too small to view at this distance/ with this star type with our current technology. Just because we haven't observed a transit doesn't mean the transit isn't happening. But again, I don't really know this specific circumstance.
- semaphoreP 9y agoI guess you're right. I know there aren't any observed transits, but I also don't know what the current constraints from monitoring the star's brightness for transit is (the star is actually so bright that it becomes hard to monitor for planet transits). However, we have a good prior on the inclination of these planets, because we know the inclination of the dust disk around the star (https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/tau-ceti-s-dust-belt-is-huge/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/tau-ceti-s-dust-b...), and it is likely the planets are at a similar inclination. Because the disk isn't edge on, the planets also likely aren't, and won't transit.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deanCommie 9y agoKey line to mitigate disappointment: "The outer two planets around tau Ceti are likely to be candidate habitable worlds, although a massive debris disc around the star probably reduces their habitability due to intensive bombardment by asteroids and comets."
- arnarbi 9y agoWe'll just wear helmets!
- pixl97 9y agoToday's forecast is a 50% chance of iron magma precipitation with a light sulfur fog.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- kemiller 9y agoI would think the lack of gas giants in the system would increase that risk as well.
- fireismyflag 9y agoThen we will fight in the shade
- misja111 9y agoThat debris disc is obviously a Dyson Sphere.
- chrismealy 9y agoThe fastest spacecraft ever built would take 4000 years to travel one light year.
- kowdermeister 9y agoIn 4000 years we can build way way more faster ships and catch up to those poor guys launched a centuries earlier just because they thought they are fast enough :) On the serious side, we only need antimatter and the drive problem is kind of solved (yes, I might be the one in the good enough ship :)).
- jcadam 9y agoGood, the folks on the faster ship can arrive ahead of us 'poor guys' on the first ship and get stuck with all of the hard work of establishing the colony and performing any necessary terraforming before we arrive.
- kowdermeister 9y agoIt would still suck to arrive at a supposed to be human free planet just to realize they have a 2000 years of history :) On the other hand, they would probably have beer.
- pc86 9y agoIf they don't, I'm going back home.
- delecti 9y agoI don't see us doubling-up on the initial missions unless it becomes really trivial to catch up. Even if technology gets a 4000 year trip down to 500, even or 100, we'd probably just let the poor 4000 year schmucks go on their way. If it got down under a year maybe, but predicting what might happen if we invent FTL is a job for people who are deliberately making things up.
- peckrob 9y ago
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y agoIs there any benefit to the planets being earth-sized? I would think the important part is that they're in the habitable zone.
- graphitezepp 9y agoAny hypothetical colonization effort would require substantially less adaptation if we don't have to worry about humans growing up in much different gravity.
- pilsetnieks 9y agoGravity. A rocky planet, roughly Earth-sized, will have about the same gravity as we have on Earth. Both larger and smaller planets will have a deleterious effect on human health, at least until we (our descendants) adapt (if it's even possible.)
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y agoAh silly me, how could I forget about that? <floats slowly away>
- kibwen 9y agoIf a planet is too small, it has a hard time retaining an atmosphere (see Mars) and a hard time sustaining the inner dynamo necessary for a magnetosphere (see Venus). For the latter, the fact that Earth is barely larger than Venus suggests that Earth might be very close to the lower bound of habitable terrestrial planet size. Bigger is better than smaller, but too big and you obviously stop being terrestrial, the atmosphere becomes too thick to breathe, the surface temperature gets too hot from pressure, and it might become impractical to escape the surface with standard rocketry due to increased gravity. I think I've read that double Earth's mass is somewhere around the suspected upper bound for reasonable human habitability.
- BurningFrog 9y agoI don't think it changes the possibility for life at all. It does make colonizing it seem less possible, but that's hardly a practical concern anytime soon.
- baron816 9y agoOk, let's assume we find a warm, watery planet like Earth's within ~20 light years, and we figure out a way to travel >= 50% the speed of light, making it somewhat reasonable to get there. If the planet's gravity is greater than 10% different from Earth's, or its Day/Night cycle is much different from Earth's, wouldn't it still be a nightmare to live on. Anatomically modern humans have lived on Earth for 200,000 years, and the creatures we descended from have lived on Earth for 541 million years. Stuff as dumb as the moon cycles affect us. How are we going to live somewhere that isn't exactly Earth?
- radicaldreamer 9y agoWe could try with a much more doable planet like Mars. We could find out if long term survival is impossible, very difficult, possible but difficult, or doable with the right technologies. It's shocking how little appetite there is for redirecting 50% of the budget which is currently allocated to the military to space exploration. I understand that the military is partly a large welfare program which doesn't compete with private enterprise due to different technologies and classified material, but I wish there was a movement to invest more of that time, money, and energy on basic research, climate change, energy technologies and space exploration. It's a hard sell though because I suspect that these technologies would compete heavily with established businesses.
- _joel 9y agoOn the other hand, government funded resource for DARPA created the place we're speaking on now. You could say that created and entire multidimensional marketplace for business. I'm not sure it would have existed if it were purely down to commercials (take Gopher as an example)
- njharman 9y agoThe military application of rockets is only reason we got the tech to reach space and military application of satellites is why we figured out how to stay there and the militaristic penis measuring between nations is only reason we reached moon. Also, - large part of budget is salaries and pensions. - looks like %budget for military is lowest it's been in 20 years, (in 2015) 16% https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_budget_of_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_budget_of_the_United_...
- arkainW123 9y agoHearing distances like 12 light years makes you think if it is ever possible to travel there. However, when you start to think about it, nihilist thoughts start to kick in.
- jamisteven 9y agoI feel like something similar to this is announced every year, and nothing ever comes of it.
- manachar 9y agoWhat do you expect to come of it? Finding more planets is helping understand the universe and give a rough idea of how common Earth-sized planets are.
- Method-X 9y agoBut what would come of it? We're not going to build a spaceship and go there on the off chance it's interesting. We're a LONG way away from exploring deep space.
- dredmorbius 9y agoThe ratte of discovery is accellerating rapidly. This chart only show through 2014: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/c/c5/Exoplanet_Discovery_Methods_Bar.png/1200px-Exoplanet_Discovery_Methods_Bar.png https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/c/c5/Ex...
- kilroy123 9y agoI really really want project Starshot to become a reality. I think this is our best bet for scoping out these near by star systems. At least within our lifetime. If we could hit 50% speed of light we could do a fly-by mission in ~25 years. Then another 12 years waiting for the data. Honestly, ~37-40 years isn't bad for an interstellar mission. Remember the Voyager program has been going on for that long! So we already have experience with long space missions. https://breakthroughinitiatives.org/Initiative/3 https://breakthroughinitiatives.org/Initiative/3 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Breakthrough_Initiatives#Breakthrough_Starshot https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Breakthrough_Initiatives#Break...
- ExactoKnight 9y agoThe other project that needs to become a reality FAST is the construction of a telescope large enough to measure the spectra of exoplanets. Because once you find a habitable planet with oxygen in its atmosphere, you now have an irrefutable and pressing case to move fast with Breakthrough Starshot. Sadly it's going to likely a require 100metre telescope mirror or larger, and current science funding only has a 30metre telescope mirror in the works. The 100 metre telescope was cancelled. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overwhelmingly_Large_Telescope https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overwhelmingly_Large_Telescope The answer is at our fingertips, yet the science community can't get the money to build something that would be a fraction of what F-35 fighter jets cost. What the !@#$ are we doing as a human race...
- moonbug22 9y agoYou know about the SKA, right?
- EthanHeilman 9y agoAt first I thought you were making a joke about the human race prioritizing Ska[0] over new telescopes, but then I realized I wasn't on reddit and saw the "the". What is SKA? Super K? Aperture? [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ska https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ska
- ExactoKnight 9y agoI am flabbergasted that as a society we aren't rushing to build a 100 metre wide telescope mirror large enough for us to directly image the spectra of the potentially habitable exoplanets around us. A telescope this large could tell us whether any of these potentially habitable planets contain oxygen, and thus, biological processes. Yet thanks to funding cuts in science the biggest telescope we have in the pipeline right now is one with a 30 metre mirror. This telescope won't be big enough, and as a result, our failure to push now for bigger sizes is almost certainly going to push back for decades humanity's ability to answer one of the most important questions we face: Why are we here, and are we alone.
- saganus 9y agoIsn't building a 100m telescope incredibly hard? does that kind of technology exist already? (I genuinely don't know). Also, what would the effect of the atmosphere be in such a large telescope? would a bigger mirror increase or decrease the effects of Earth's atmosphere for these kind of observations?
- Balgair 9y agoNoise is noise. If you put gain on the signal in general, you'll put gain on the noise too. That's why James Webb is in space and the 30 Meter Telescope (TMT) is in Hawaii, less atmosphere and clear air means less noise inputted. Still, the TMT is pretty darn good. So yes, you are correct, bigger telescope means more noise (in gestalt) while in atmosphere. THe reason bigger is better is because you can resolve smaller angles. The Fourier treatment of optics is useful here. The radius of your lenses/reflectors sets the limit of the higher spatial frequency. Low spatial frequencies pass through small lenses/refectors and high spatial frequencies pass through larger ones. Therefore the bigger the telescope, the more higher order spatial frequencies you can collect. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fourier_optics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fourier_optics Why not a 100 Meter Telescope? Cost and engineering. With these retro reflectors getting so big, you have to worry a lot about thermal expansion and differential levels of it across the whole surface. Also, the structure to hold it has to be monitored really closely in real time to make sure the calculations are accurate. It's not easy. Also, with modern adaptive optics, you'll have apply all the little piezo-motors across the entire surface which goes as the square of the radius, so costs go up geometrically (plus about 15% more for each doubling in surface area due to cabling, power issues, larger facilities with thicker steel beams, more janitors, etc.). If the TMT costs X, then the 100-MT should cost about 11X, and with the 15% doubling factor, its ~15X for only a 3X increase in radius.
- nextlevelwizard 9y agoIsn't nearest sun-like star... the Sun?
- amptorn 9y agoYeah, hence the classic joke "Did you hear they discovered a habitable planet harboring intelligent life orbiting the closest star to Earth?"
- SolarNet 9y agoI mean the implication we exclude the object we are searching for when we say like. If I was looking for a table row "like" the value of row 34, row 34 wouldn't be a match.
- SilverPaladin 9y agoI wonder if the Mormons will be starting their ship construction now?
- jessaustin 9y agoThey should be careful to hire someone they can trust, and they should probably hold onto the ignition keys...
- RandomedaA 9y agoI feel like something similar to this is announced every year, and nothing ever comes of it.
- ExactoKnight 9y agoNo, something has come from it. We now have a growing massive list of habitable planets. What's lacking now is the extra tooling to study them more extensively.
- wfunction 9y ago"This required techniques sensitive enough to detect variations in the movement of the star as small as 30 centimeters per second." This kind of precision sounds insane. It sounds like far more of an achievement than having found Earth-sized planets. Is there any layman explanation of how they do such a thing?
- mbfg 9y agoWould there be any value in putting a telescope on the moon? You wouldn't have the atmosphere problem, and i'd expect servicing it would be mildly easier than have it out at L2 or something.? I suppose the fact that the moon was tidally locked would be something of a problem for full sky observation. Is that the main issue?
- sova 9y agoLet's go! Who's with me? How much stronger do my bones need to be to live on the 1.7x gravity NeoEarths?
- dnprock 9y agoWe need to send bacteria to those planets. That'd make life multi-planet. Maybe, that's how life arrived on Earth.
- deepGem 9y agoUnlike more common smaller stars, such as the red dwarf stars Proxima Centauri and Trappist-1, they are not so faint that planets would be tidally locked, showing the same side to the star at all times. In such planets, the most habitable zone is around an equator like region where the light and dark regions kind of merge to produce a reddish sunset like hue all through the day. I think one of the planets that Kepler discovered is like that. Life would evolve to absorb these light wavelengths. So for instance plants would all look black. Nova has a great episode on these exoplanets. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5HZsFMqqGJo&t=793s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5HZsFMqqGJo&t=793s
- bawana 9y agowhy are we becoming borg?
- dillweed 9y agoGgggggggrrrrreeeaaaatttt
- u801e 9y agoI wonder if an observer 12 light-years away with similar technology to us would be able to tell the difference between Venus and Earth in terms of whether they are potentially habitable.