36 ms·
Richard Stallman Explains [video]
- Boothroid 9y agoI was amazed to see that Stallman doesn't install his OS himself - hasn't for years. He seemed diminished in my eyes after I learnt this.
- ue_ 9y agoHis programming and social acheivements in my opinion vastly outclass installing an OS by himself, though I wonder why he doesn't do it; I assume he knows how partitioning etc. works. And to be honest, how often do most people need to reinstall their OS? I would be surprised if he has reinstalled more than 3 times in 5 years.
- setr 9y agoProbably because the process is at best dull and at worst, a massive PITA; either way it has little to no relevance to his actual work. If I had the chance, I'd avoid any kind of software installation/maintainence as well...
- ovao 9y agoDoesn't it speak rather poorly for free software if installing it is a "massive PITA"?
- __s 9y agoNon free software is too. Especially when you start dealing with licensing. Where I work we have people assigned to licensing & other people assigned to actual install. Of course the licensing goes through a third party provider... for which we're a third party provider to our clients
- setr 9y agoALL software does this. If it works, I might as well have let someone else do the waiting. If it doesn't, then It requires a few hours mindlessly running around until you find some stupid flag that was set. Which I might as well leave to somebody else to do. That this is the state of software is a pretty damn good thing, that most of it has become busywork. But its still busywork and I don't why I'd ever want to do it more than a couple times (once I know the general process)
- wutwutwutwut 9y agoI wouldn't consider it busywork. You don't have to sit and wait for the progress bar to move. Start the installation and go for lunch.
- oblio 9y agoThat's if the installer is designed well and all the questions are front-loaded. Unfortunately not all installers are... Heck, I think it took Microsoft until Windows Vista to do it for the OS.
- em3rgent0rdr 9y agoRMS ought to try installing one of the easier free OS's listed on https://www.gnu.org/distros/free-distros.html https://www.gnu.org/distros/free-distros.html such as Trisquel (based on Ubuntu), which I think even he will find is easy to install. You don't need to know anything about partitioning if you don't care about it and don't have anything you need on your harddrive or anything else (just accept all the default options).
- krick 9y agoI'm still struggling to understand, what exactly Stallman's social acheivements are. It's not like he is the reason people care about proprietary software and surveillance. No, the real reasons are these things themselves, because — I won't say "all people", but many people understand the dangers and inconveniences of it pretty damn well. I myself perfectly agree with Stallman on many (if not all) of his convictions, but so what? I still use Android phone and many other nasty things, because it's convenient and actually less harmful than making "normal people" around you too dismiss you as some "conspiracy freak". I hate it, but I use it. Not using Facebook alone is pretty troublesome in my social life. And GNU project software (with a few important exceptions, of course) now feels more like a legacy, than a salvation. It has it's own statute of limitations, so to say. So I don't see how complaining without actually making a difference helps someone.
- quadrangle 9y agoRMS created the foundations for the existence of a fully-free OS, both technically and socially. He created the concept of copyleft and the GNU GPL, a fundamental feature of the free software movement. He founded GNU and FSF which remain important enough to be notable. Even the Linux kernel started off with a weird non-free license until Torvalds decided the GPL was a good fit, changing his views on commercial-restrictions after hearing RMS talk. RMS is a philosopher of sorts and is already seen historically as a fundamentally important figure in the philosophy and ethics of technology. Sure, the ideas would be out there some way even if RMS wasn't around. Similarly, biological evolution was inherently an idea that was even being thought about by others at the time of Darwin, but we still acknowledge Darwin's major contributions even though we'd almost certainly at some point know everything we know now even if Darwin had never published anything.
- wmf 9y agoStallman reminds me of a king who has everything done by servants and knows only what his courtiers tell him. Being free of menial tasks like installing software leaves him more time to tackle serious issues. But it also insulates him from the problems that real people face.
- mikegerwitz 9y agoIt's not really something you can observe well from the outside, but in working with Richard on many things, I was surprised early on how much respect he gives to those he trusts, and how appreciative he is of help. So "servants" is far from how he views volunteers. And after working closely with him for a few years within GNU, I don't feel at all like a servant---there is mutual respect, and we're not afraid to state our opinions or disagree with one-another. Much of the time he makes me feel like I work beside him, not below him. It's quite constructive. And this is typical with others as well.
- na85 9y agoThis seems incompatible with what I read recently in an emacs discussion on HN, wherein they were unable to merge a popular package into emacs without Stallman's rubber stamp despite him being essentially uninvolved since 2008.
- mikegerwitz 9y agoAre you referring to Magit? All code that is part of Emacs requires copyright assignment to the FSF; it's that simple. If Jonas Bernoulli can make that happen, then the issue is resolved. Jonas' original response: https://lists.gnu.org/archive/html/emacs-devel/2017-07/msg00516.html https://lists.gnu.org/archive/html/emacs-devel/2017-07/msg00...
- wizardforhire 9y agoSurely he takes care of his own parrots.
- 9y ago
- drakenot 9y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=umQL37AC_YM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=umQL37AC_YM A video where he talks about never installing his own OS.
- taneq 9y ago"A beginner shouldn't be installing operating systems"? If a moderately-intelligent, moderately-literate beginner can't install your operating system, then your operating system (or at least, its user interface) is crap. Edit: Just to be clear, I'm responding to the quote, not calling Linux crap. I run a combination of Linux and Windows machines and VMs and they're both very straightforward to install, a complete beginner can just click next / next / next and still get it working.
- generic_user 9y agoThere are hundreds of Linux distributions with install media for usb/dvd install. Installing a distro like Fedora is as easy as setting up windows and has about the same UI quality. Distros like Slackware or Gentoo give you more complicated setups but they are designed for experienced users. There are so many places online to get help with a Linux install now. If you stick with the main distros as most do for there first taste of Linux its really simple.
- boomboomsubban 9y agoNo one installs Windows, and frankly it isn't a ton easier than installing free operating systems. It's only easier because you rarely run into driver issues, the computer was probably built to run Windows, and you're rarely trying to install it as a second operating system.
- yellowapple 9y ago"rarely run into driver issues" My decade's worth of experiences having to transfer over wired (wired!) NIC drivers onto computers that are completely supported by the average Linux distro because Windows doesn't ship with them strongly suggests otherwise. Windows has thankfully gotten better about this lately (e.g. in the Windows 10 era), but the continued lack of drivers in the default install is really annoying when said drivers are for devices that virtually every free operating system supports out of the box.
- rand98765 9y agoThis is just a practical thing afaik. fsf sysadmins are more knowledgeable about it and they do it for the rest of fsf computers already, so why not let them do it? What does diminished mean? I mean, like as a person he's not impressive? When I remember I'm reading a comment that's hiding behind a pseudonym, they are also diminished in my eyes.
- jrimbault 9y agoI think I agree with you, buuuut "rand98765" is your current username.
- copperx 9y agoDiminished for not installing an OS? The man who could write an optimizing C compiler from scratch in a few days just so he could make it free?
- Boothroid 9y agoFair point - perhaps it was his comment that everyday users could just go along to a user group to get Linux installed, and needn't worry about doing it themselves. This seemed painfully out of touch to me, as if he were talking about finding someone to solder your Altair together or something.
- ezoe 9y agoProbably for the tough requirements for the free enough computer he can get today. He is currently using Lenovo thinkpad X60, flashing free bios, then install Trisquel(Ubuntu minus non-free binary blobs). Probably harder to install than most of us do(get non-free binary blob infected compute and install linux kernel with a lot of non-free binary blobs)
- yellowapple 9y agoMakes sense to me. I'd assume that an org the size of the FSF would have pretty standard imaging procedures. If Stallman doesn't need or want to deviate from, say, the FSF-wide Trisquel image, then why should he?
- nvr219 9y agoThis is still my favorite Stallman video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I25UeVXrEHQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I25UeVXrEHQ
- generic_user 9y agoIts the two girls one cup for geeks. Stallman is as they say, a very special guy. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S76pHIYx3ik https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S76pHIYx3ik
- bamboozled 9y agoWhat does this have to do with what he is talking about in the linked video? Does it make him a bad guy or ruin his credibility or something?
- generic_user 9y agoOccasionally people in the FLOSS community have been known to crack jokes and 'have fun'. Even tho most of the jokes are not very funny and the fun that is had is rather autistic by most peoples standards I see no reason why we should stop. Many of us have been listening to Stallman for close to 20 years and have been part of free software movement for that long. Having a good chuckle at Comrade Stallman expense is rite of passage in a way.
- bamboozled 9y agoI'm aware of that, but this is just bullying the guy, how would you like it if that was a video of you?
- generic_user 9y agoRichard S has a great appreciation of self deprecating humor. Which is why he does silly things. Being able to criticize each other and crack jokes about each other is essential to open source and it helps to build community. We can criticize and crack jokes at each others expense because we learn to trust each other. That's how you build real community. When people are two afraid to criticize each other or crack jokes about each other then you really can not have a healthy community where people have a true respect and admiration for one another. And you certainly can not build a community that has to have critique about code quality, architecture and so forth to sustain itself.
- firefoxd 9y agoOk, 2 seconds in and I'm shocked. All my life I pronounced gnu as new, like Nutella.
- lsh 9y agoDo you pronounce Nutella "Nu-tella" or "Nut-ella" ? FWIW, I pronounce 'GNU' as 'nu'.
- champagnepapi 9y agoThe only reason as to why I pronounce "GNU" with a 'g' sound is because of Richard Stallman. Otherwise, I use the silent 'g'.
- firefoxd 9y agoNu-tella, though i don't have an american accent.
- imron 9y agoHe appears to pronounce it newtella.
- snvzz 9y agoThere's a p2p network called gnutella. It's not associated with GNU. It gets confusing.
- gschier 9y agoDon't forget g-nome too!
- dllthomas 9y agoThe name of the animal has a silent g. In software that would be a bit too confusing, though. "Do you use <nu> make?" "N-E-W or G-N-U?"
- lsh 9y agoHats off to the interviewer, I thought he did a good job of curbing Stallman and keeping him on topic. He does have this fantastic meandering style that would undermine his agenda if his audience has a short attention span. Like so many of us these days. I first read about RMS in 1999 in an Australian PC Authority magazine, it also featured an interview with Linux Torvalds. The distinction between the two personalities was felt keenly at the time as well. RMS really hasn't changed in those 18 years.
- trestletech 9y agoI feel like we're not far off from a digital version of the Amish. "Technology was perfected by the FSF in 2003; everything developed since is evil."
- peterwwillis 9y agoJust operating systems, and it was 30 years earlier by AT&T. Our user interfaces have gotten progressively worse, though, along with almost all user apps.
- amelius 9y agoEverything developed by big companies that deals with our data on their premises is evil. We should simply not allow that, and let big companies just develop the hardware.
- possiblydave 9y agoI mean, given the recent and continuing rash of hardware backdoors, wouldn't that just make your premises their premises?
- teekert 9y ago""We" should not allow that"... Yeah that sounds like freedom to me. You are free to deal with these companies or not. Whether you agree with these companies and their ways is irrelevant. This is same as not agreeing with another persons' religion, you are free do choose a way to lead your life, don't try to force your way upon others. Others happily share their data with Google and reap the benefits of a very helpful Google Home assistant. Direct your efforts towards educating these people about the potential downsides, yes, but don't try to use law or other forms of powers to change their ways. That is not freedom.
- icebraining 9y agoWorrying about free software advocates using the law against others is hilarious. It's like worrying about Walmart cashiers demanding to make more money than software developers.
- trentgreene 9y agoGreat video! However, I would like to point out that the name "Richard Stallman" is incorrect. Who you're referring to here should actually be called "GNU/Richard Stallman"
- 11thEarlOfMar 9y agoI suppose it's a philosophy. Are there enough who share Stallman's view to advance computing technology at a pace that can match what we see with commercial sector? For sure, I am amazed at the power and scope of open source software and it's a highly influential movement. But at some point in the food chain, software developers need to put food on the table and send their kids to school. How does that happen if all software is free?
- Ace17 9y ago> But at some point in the food chain, software developers need to put food on the table and send their kids to school. How does that happen if all software is free? Please note "free" has nothing to do with price, but with end-user freedom (to use/study/modify/share). (example answer to your question: custom/internal software).
- lloydde 9y agoIt actually does have to do with price. All free software is one user away from the possibility (likelihood) it is free as in beer. The parent comment is correct that free software has put magnitudes less food on kids bellies.
- tho9Ohx1eo 9y ago> The parent comment is correct that free software has put magnitudes less food on kids bellies. At the same time it empowered those who could not afford to pay or could not pay (legal/geo-restrictions, DRM etc).
- lloydde 9y agoAbsolutely! Additionally, if we are able to create more cases where this inherently collaborative delivery leads to better software then it would unlock real economic growth. Unfortunately, these are ultimately hard people problems.
- icebraining 9y ago
- teekert 9y agoEver since I listened to this episode of the Linux Action Show [0] I can't take RMS serious anymore. He bases everything he believes on one assumption he doesn't dare to argue himself: "Proprietary software is evil." That is it. When you attack his values and stances, he falls back to that sentence. When you argue: But aren't you restricting freedom when you would keep a creator from sharing his software under his own terms? He comes back to "Proprietary software is evil" in the end. He is incapable of defending beyond that point. I think Bryan makes some very good points in the podcast below [0] that RMS fails to answer properly to. I love open source, I love the philosophy, I want to use as much FOSS as possible and I see how it ultimately will protect our society, I get that. But I see no evil whatsoever in someone making a software tool and selling only the binaries to someone who is happy to use said binaries under the terms the seller and buyer agree upon. That to me is freedom, nobody is forced in that scenario. [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=radmjL5OIaA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=radmjL5OIaA
- tequila_shot 9y agowell RMS has nothing to do with Open Source. Open Source is different from FSF. But I generally agree with your comments. I have seen in a number of videos that RMS tends to always fall back on the "Proprietary software is evil".
- dijit 9y agoTo be fair, he's clarified why he feels this way many times. Repeating the same arguments has got to be frustrating and people might pick up on it. (assuming that RMS has very little to say but says it often). FWIW his reasons of proprietary software being evil are[0]: * Proprietary software obstructs the use of its programs * Proprietary software obstructs social cohesion, fragments communities. * Proprietary software obstructs the customisation and adaption of programs. * Proprietary software has network effects: if you have skype, I am more likely to have skype. * Proprietary software prevents choice; swapping out proprietary software with something else can be tricky, if it's not resting on standards then sometimes it's simply impossible. [0]: https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/shouldbefree.en.html https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/shouldbefree.en.html
- chauhankiran 9y agoPeople do not like RMS's "extremeness" for "free" software. But, I personally thing that - if this level of "extremeness" was/is not given by RMS then "free" movement might died within couple of years with loosely couple definition and then more loosely definition of free software by organizations (supported by "evil" companies).
- bretepete 9y agoATTN: We Provide Medical Marijuana to persons in good need of it.we strive to keep both faith and hope alive and most of good health of mind and body.please for more info,reach us on dr.rickerbs0@india.com
- bretepete 9y agoATTN: We Provide Medical Marijuana to persons in good need of it.we strive to keep both faith and hope alive and most of good health of mind and body.please for more info,reach us on dr.rickerbs0@india.com
- nannal 9y agoKind of funny you're all in here posting youtube links, I didn't know they were GNU friendly and I can only imagine how RMS feels given his zealotry.
- cyphar 9y agoYou can use youtube-dl[1] to download videos from YouTube (and transcode them to free formats) without runnning their proprietary JavaScript. There's even a free software Android project[2] that lets you stream videos without running their proprietary JavaScript -- and in my opinion it's much better than the proprietary YouTube app. RMS's concern with YouTube is that they use proprietary JavaScript and they use patented media formats. However, RMS has always made it clear that if you have the ability "at hand" to rip DVDs then purchasing a DVD is not unethical. Both of the pieces of software I mentioned allow you to avoid running proprietary software. His other concern is that RMS wants people to publish things he appears in in a way that is much easier to access with only free software. The Internet Archive and CCC provide video hosting that is completely free software, with non-patented formats like VP9, and is easy to use. The idea is to make those forms of publishing more widely known about. [1]: https://github.com/rg3/youtube-dl https://github.com/rg3/youtube-dl [2]: https://github.com/TeamNewPipe/NewPipe https://github.com/TeamNewPipe/NewPipe
- mikojan 9y agoYou can also just pass the url as an argument to mplayer or one of it's derivatives (all of which use youtube-dl under the hood, I believe). Not even concerned with freedom here. It's just a better user experience when the video is longer, IMO.
- shp0ngle 9y agoYouTube is proprietary and not a free software.
- snakeanus 9y agoIf you have mpv with youtube-dl installed then you can watch the video without using anything non-free.
- missbit 9y agoHe is obviously brilliant. The interviewer wants to steer him into being a crazy nut corner. Pepsi vs. Coke. I realize historically there was only low level software that existed. These days we've got much higher level services which really could benefit from free software. He hits on these ideas. Maybe he'd be open to working on these sorts of things. Services have gotten to the level where they are taking a piece of people's livelihoods. Uber & Airbnb takes 20-30%. why? Amazon is a system of warehousing & distribution... could something like that be run in a distributed / cooperative way which provides as much opportunity to 3rd party retailers as it does Amazon? A level playing field. These are the sorts of things that the free software movement could move towards now.
- fwdpropaganda 9y ago> The interviewer wants to steer him into being a crazy nut corner. Pepsi vs. Coke. Absolutely wrong. The interviewer even said at one point "The things you're describing I believe should be of a concern to many more people than they are." You're totally off.
- missbit 9y agoGeez. I just realized a problem here. If he doesn't want to use any commercial software. This includes IntelliJ or other IDEs? Good luck writing software! Then again, the time he saves from not dealing with iOS provisioning might give him a couple extra years to write other software. Man that interviewer is dumb. Says he is surprised he didn't vote Trump? Eh?
- number6 9y agoUse emacs?
- etiam 9y agoAnyone have an idea what's the project raising funds mentioned at 5:32? The "new computer that will be manufactured specifically for free software".
- unityByFreedom 9y agoStallman argues that free software enables users to control programs, whereas paid software is controlled by corporations. I see two problems with that. (1) Isn't knowledge also power? In this context, developers have the knowledge. Users who aren't programmers don't control free software any more than they do paid software. Further, training more users to become developers requires money. (2) Corporations don't exist unless they serve users in some way. There's an interdependency that I think Stallman ignores. That said, free software is important, and a useful way to challenge the paid model.