27 ms·
Why Germans pay cash for almost everything
- majidazimi 9y agoI think tax is the killing factor. Most of small shops don't want to reveal how much they earn, thus resisting against electronic payments.
- mtmail 9y agoAccording to https://www.cashforless.de/ec_cash_info/Fakten_zur_Kartenzahlung_in_Deutschland.png https://www.cashforless.de/ec_cash_info/Fakten_zur_Kartenzah... methods for payments in stores 2011 was 57% cash, 5.3% credit card, 33% debit card (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electronic_cash https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electronic_cash). > "of course, [the Germans] attitudes toward currency must owe something to Germany’s tumultuous monetary history. During the Weimar-era hyperinflation that peaked in 1923 [...]" > "the German tendency to settle up in cash undeniably reflects the fact that for much of the last century, Germany has been either on the brink of, in the midst of, or struggling to recover from, disaster." As a German I call that theory into question. Our currency has been stable for 60+ years. It would've been nice if other countries with recent disasters (war, hyperinflation, sanctions) and their attitude toward currency was compared against.
- egeozcan 9y agoDebit card is pretty equivalent to cash, though. When my friends and family from my hometown (Istanbul) visit me the first time, they are usually quite shocked that most shops here do not accept credit cards at all. In Turkey (a place I call micro-USA), many credit cards automatically divide the payments for some transactions to 3+ months, whereas here in Germany, there's always some bureaucracy involved, even if you explicitly ask for it. 11 years ago, when I was living in Istanbul, I had bought bread from a supermarket and I paid with my credit-card, vendor of which had a deal with that supermarket-chain and automatically divided the payment of the bread to 10 months. If I remember correctly, they later banned the postponing of the payment of basic goods because it was getting ridiculous.
- BartSaM 9y agoNot really. Debit cards are debit cards, not cash. You are comparing CC to DC as far as I can tell, but they are completely different products. There is a huge difference between having currency in your hand or use a medium to access money held by the private organization that can go bankrupt (and this happens much more often than, for example, governments with their currencies).
- gehwartzen 9y agoWhen paying with cash you are also only exposed to the risk of loosing what you have on hand. A debit card is a bit more akin to handing over the key to the vault with a contractual agreement as to how much can be taken.
- yxhuvud 9y agoIf you think that is a problem with debit cards you should go get a better bank.
- swimfar 9y agoAre there banks that provide credit card-like protections for debit cards? I thought you couldn't reverse debit card transactions. There are usually daily limits, though, which would limit how much you could lose.
- gehwartzen 9y agoI haven't had this problem with my bank just pointing out the inherent differences. With a debit card you are relying on the cyber security and data retention policy of the store, the bank, and the electronic network provider. Now I realize that if your account is used without authorization most banks refund the money. This can take a certain amount of time and could lock up your remaining funds in the meantime.
- yxhuvud 9y ago
- ant6n 9y ago> As a German I call that theory into question. Our currency has been stable for 60+ years. Also as a German, OUR currency has been stable for 26 years. I'd still question the theory.
- danielbln 9y agoYeah, what a silly theory. Not once have I thought "oh, gee, I better not pay with CC because remember what happened back in the 20s/30s". And yes, you could argue for some sort of cultural trait that stems from that time, but I don't know anyone who pays with cash because they inherently distrust the financial organisations.
- jdboyd 9y agoWouldn't it be only 15 years? (Since switching to a new currency)
- ant6n 9y agoRe-unification was in 1991. The Euro transition was stable.
- jdboyd 9y agoWouldn't it be only 15 years? (Since switching to a new currency)
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- _Codemonkeyism 9y agoAs a German a.) I mostly pay cash because it's faster b.) some shops that can afford it only have cash payments to save on CC costs Not because of inflation or because something happend 100y ago.
- sparkling 9y agoAs a German a) I don't want to feed the Visa/Mastercard/Amex/Whatever leach earning a few cents of every transaction.
- wila 9y agoNot German, but I simply don't want to leave my trail of what I am spending and where.
- eatbitseveryday 9y agoAnd what of purchases made on websites?
- theEXTORTCIST 9y agoWas waiting for this comment. I often ask myself, "Do I want any entity to have a copy of the exact dates and amounts of my entire daily consumer activity?". Whether anonymized or not there is a tremendous amount of knowledge that can be gleaned from non-itemized debit card ledgers.
- 9y ago
- sparkling 9y ago> Euro > stable
- laumars 9y agoYour economy is much more stable than mine in the UK yet anecdotally I've observed we use cards to pay for everything. Even silly little things that only cost a couple of £. In fact it is rare that I ever carry cash. The same is true for a fair number of my friends and family as well.
- macspoofing 9y ago>Even silly little things that only cost a couple of £. I use a credit card to pay for a $1.25 coffee. I never have cash, partly because I forget to take some out.
- arjie 9y agoContactless is faster than making change, so it's just far too convenient to use a contactless card.
- dspillett 9y agoSame here, though I think a lot more recently than a few years ago because of the growing ubiquity of contactless options which are very convenient for those small payments. Is that payment option as common in those countries at this point?
- oneeyedpigeon 9y agoI'm pretty sure I used my UK (debit) card, the other day, to pay for something absurdly cheap - maybe 49p? I was about as surprised that they accepted it as I am when a shop requires me to pay a huge minimum - e.g. £10 - and it's not quite as straightforward as "big shops do this, small shops, that".
- laumars 9y agoThe "I only have my debit card on me. What's your minimum spend" conversation used to be annoying. Thankfully that's been less of an issue since contactless as shops now often expect you to pay for small items on card.
- discombobulate 9y agoDid you learn about the inflation @ school? In the UK we weren't taught about the Weimar Republic's hyperinflation (in education up to 16 y/o). My friend who did history @ a more advanced level was, however.
- killercup 9y agoYes, I learned about the Weimarer Republik and it's economic issues in school in Germany. (I guess it was in 8th or 9th grade and that history class was mandatory.)
- discombobulate 9y agoLooks like the Bitcoin laws are v favourable in DE. You can pay taxes in BTC(!) & BTC is a unit of account[0]. That makes sense if the memory of WR hyperinflation is written to the citizens' mind. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Legality_of_bitcoin_by_country_or_territory#Central_Europe https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Legality_of_bitcoin_by_country...
- germanier 9y agoYou can't pay your taxes with Bitcoin (the Wikipedia author probably means something else?). You can't even pay most tax in cash even if you wanted to. Bank transfer in EUR is the only way.
- icebraining 9y agoThe Wikipedia author cited a quite unclear CNBC story that said that bitcoin "can be used for tax and trading purposes". From what I can tell from other sources, what it really means is that one must pay VAT when purchasing stuff with it.
- icebraining 9y agoReally? It's standard in Portugal, as part of the context of WWII. My textbook even had a picture of people with a pile of bills.
- conanbatt 9y agoArgentina has rampant cash usage at all stages of inflation, mostly for tax evasion purposes (VAT is 21%)
- zeta_ 9y agoWe had hyperinflation in Brazil (end of 80s and begin of 90s) and you can use credit/debit card almost everywhere (I even saw a video of a Brazilian that lived in Japan for 10 years commenting how weird this is for him)
- felipelemos 9y agoBrazilian here. We had a three-to-four-digit annual inflation rates that last 14 years, from 1980 to 1994 (and it topped 5000% on the last year). Almost everyone uses debit or credit card nowadays. Even transport cards machines, taxis, small vendors, food trucks accepts credit cards. Usually I only carry cash for some emergency to the point I don't even remember how much I left on my wallet.
- lanevorockz 9y agoTo be fair, in Brazil we usually prefer cards because of the risk of being robbed.
- mrisoli 9y agoTrue, Uber's decision of allowing cash payments in Brazil(because a lot of people can't get a credit card approved) was met with a very negative drivers' response due to increased robbery risks.
- mrisoli 9y agoFellow Brazilian here and I don't carry a lot of cash with me because that was how I was raised, mostly my parents taught me to be scared of being robbed with a lot of money. Even though I am not living in Brazil ATM I still act like this. Plus fraud is becoming rarer with chip credit cards(and apps which allow you to lock your card much faster in the case of theft), while counterfeit bills are also harder to reproduce these days you can still find some.
- triztian 9y agoI can add that in Mexico the culture is to also not carry that much cash - due to risk of robbery and losing the wallet or it getting washed in laundromats.
- richardknop 9y agoAlso remember that whole Eastern Europe (including East Germany) had no electronic payments before fall of Soviet Union. So credit cards took off in US in 80s but half of Europe just got out from under communism in early 90s and they were not very trustworthy of western banks so would prefer cash. Also the banking and payment infrastructure was non existent so needed to be built from scratch. This probably slowed down uptake of credit/debit cards considerably. Cash is still king in Eastern Europe today.
- germanier 9y agoNot sure how far east you want to go but in both Poland and the Czech Republic card payments are far more prevalent than in western Germany.
- richardknop 9y agoWith young people yes. But older generation still uses cash heavily.
- exelius 9y agoMy theory with Germany specifically is that the Germans I have known have all been extremely protective of their privacy. I'd be interested in seeing stats on social media adoption in Germany, because my hypothesis is that they lag the rest of the world. If privacy is such a concern (and particularly privacy from one's own government), then the use of cash makes sense. My guess is that this distrust of government did grow from the abuses of domestic surveillance by the Nazi regime and East Germany. I'd be curious to see how this breaks down between the old east/west lines as well. And I'm sure individuals don't use cash for these reasons; but because the system in Germany functions that way out of historical legacy. As a consumer, it's simply easier to buy things with cash.
- george_kaplan 9y ago>I'd be interested in seeing stats on social media adoption in Germany, because my hypothesis is that they lag the rest of the world. Not only do they lag in general, but I also remember a study which showed that in Germany higher education levels are associated with significantly less social media use, while it's quite the opposite in the rest of the world.
- true_religion 9y agoThat's true. The fastest growing social network within German universities was an anonymous one. This is opposed to the USA, where Facebook was the fastest growing network based on the ideal of knowing exactly what classes Y person on your campus went to.
- jshevek 9y agoDoes that social network still exist, and can you share its name please?
- ahartmetz 9y agoJodel https://jodel-app.com/ https://jodel-app.com/ I had it installed for a few days once. I decided to uninstall it because it took too much attention (there are MANY users in Berlin) and I kind of felt too old. The typical user is a student in the first few semesters.
- lkrubner 9y agoOur currency has been stable for 60+ years. Older osti don't see it that way. When I say "older" I mean "everyone over the age of 40" so not really that old. They've seen their currency change.
- dvfjsdhgfv 9y agoThis seems counter-intuitive to me. The author argues it's due to hyperinflation from the pre-WW2 era, concluding that "People in countries that suffered banking crises quite sensibly often prefer to save in cash." If there really is some national memory of that crisis, wouldn't they actually prefer to actually avoid saving in cash? During the hyperinflation period your cash could lose half of its value overnight. This just doesn't make sense.
- blowski 9y agoPerhaps it means that when your money is in a bank account, the bank can refuse to give it back to you until it loses all its value. In cash, you can spend it straight away.
- Spooky23 9y agoNo. The institutions become untrustworthy. In a hyperinflation environment your priority is converting cash into assets as quickly as possible.
- zmk_ 9y agoI fully agree, if anything this would be about bank runs. Also it is a cherry picked example, I can cherry pick one too. Poland had a hyperinflation episode in 1920s and another high inflation event in the 1990s; yet card adoption (and adoption of innovations in consumer banking) is among the highest in Europe. The differentiating factor is whether a solution is supported by the merchant. If it is, you will see adoption. Merchants in Germany do not support CCs and limit debit cards, so people do not use them. They do not do that partly because they can get away with it and partly because the fees they are being charged are high (both per transaction and per POS). Naturally there is room for the government to step in here. E.g., said Poland lowered the maximum allowable fee Visa/Mastercard can charge a few years back; along with that went away minimum spending limits on transactions in shops. This will change though as Germany starts moving to a cashless economy as, e.g., Sweden is doing.
- YSFEJ4SWJUVU6 9y agoIt might be worth mentioning, but the payment preference goes both ways. Germans' preference for cash payments sometimes means or meant that payment options common elsewhere might not be available. This caught me out at a McDonald's in Berlin that accepted neither Visa nor MasterCard earlier this decade. Even bigger brands adapt to local culture, it seems.
- blowski 9y agoMcDonalds didn't accept card payments anywhere until around 2002.
- moogly 9y agoIs that really true? Whilst I probably haven't been to McDonald's in the same amount of years I'm not sure how that could have worked even 15 years ago in Sweden, which is one of the countries with the least cash usage in the world.
- jruz 9y agoAgreed, most places in Berlin won't take cards or only take EC cards. That has made me use cash, and not fear of any kind.
- SyneRyder 9y agoThis is somewhat frustrating as a tourist to Germany (withdrawing cash usually involves a 3% exchange fee, and bank fees if you use the wrong ATM), but wouldn't be so bad if there was a way to get a reloadable EC card (or bank account with EC card). But as far as I can tell, reloadable EC cards don't exist, and I don't think there's a way to get a German bank account without a permanent residence in Germany.
- cknight 9y agoI've been able to witness the change over the last 5 years in Germany. While gradual, it has been quite noticeable to see more plastic options become available, and my ATM visits have become less frequent. It's still a far cry from home (Australia) where I hadn't needed cash on hand in quite a long time, but it in terms of convenience it's not a big deal. it certainly beats France where cheques are still in extremely frequent use vs. wire transfers.
- Spooky23 9y agoThey're smart. I went all cash a few months ago for everything except hotels and rental cars. It's very liberating. Credit cards give you 3-5% incentives to spend because you spend more. Since going all cash, we spend in average 15% less.
- swah 9y agoHere in Brazil most places prefer debit or credit card and always have a hard time finding change. Money is mostly for buying stuff on the street (bottled water, papers).
- SyneRyder 9y agoI have the opposite problem - using cash means it takes more time for me to enter transactions into my finance software (Quicken). With electronic cards (whether credit, debit or presumably EC), I can download a list of my transactions at the end of the day in one go & be up to date. With cash, I'd often fall days behind.
- gehwartzen 9y agoNot surprisingly Germany has one of the highest household savings rates in Europe. In fact almost all the top countries are German speaking or have German as an official language.[1] [1] http://stats.oecd.org/Index.aspx?QueryId=51648 http://stats.oecd.org/Index.aspx?QueryId=51648
- yxhuvud 9y agoThose incentives go away if you use a debit card though.
- lima 9y agoAs a German, I disagree. I've had many discussions about the upcoming NFC payment options and the main argument was privacy.
- lower 9y agoI (German) have never used NFC payments and was curious how that would work with my bank. Turns out they want me to install an app on my phone for this, which is definitely not going to happen.
- aianus 9y agoWe just tap our credit cards against the terminal in Canada. No PIN, no signature, way faster than cash.
- Froyoh 9y agoWith Apple/Android Pay it's even faster, no need to dig around in your wallet.
- miguelrochefort 9y ago> Turns out they want me to install an app on my phone for this, which is definitely not going to happen. Why not?
- hottycat3 9y agoBecause we don't want to be tracked by the bank what stuff we buy?
- CrystalGamma 9y agoIn my case, it would be that I trust my phone much less than a single-purpose card.
- chrisper 9y agoThere are two different ways of NFC payment. One is through NFC of your phone and another one is NFC directly in the card.
- cocoa19 9y agoIn America, I would prefer to use a debit card or cash, but many credit card issuers offer 1%-3% cash back, meaning, they give back 1%-3% of the purchases you make. That amount adds up over time.
- simonh 9y agoThe more you spend, the more you save!
- revelation 9y agoBecause you are paying much more in transaction fees. In the EU, transaction fees are capped at <<1% so there are no silly cash-back programs.
- dcosson 9y agoBut you pay those transaction fees whether or not you use a credit card. I believe there are even laws against charging more for paying with a credit card (beyond just having credit card minimum like you see at delis and mom and pop shops). Yet another example of wealth transfer in the US from the poor (who often don't have credit cards, or don't have the high rewards ones because they cost $150+ dollars a year) to the upper middle class.
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoIn the US it's common to see cash prices at gas stations.
- icebraining 9y agoI believe there are even laws against charging more for paying with a credit card Yes, in nine states and DC. It was also part of the contract, but the courts struck that down after a big lawsuit.
- gruez 9y ago>I believe there are even laws against charging more for paying with a credit card not really "laws", more like merchant agreements. also, there's nothing preventing shops from offering a cash discount, which is effectively the same thing.
- arvidkahl 9y agoMost brick & mortar stores in Germany will not offer debit card payments under 10 Euros, since the fees they have to pay are extremely high. Most clerks will frown upon small card payments for that reason, and sometimes outright decline the payment, even if that means no purchase happening. Credit cards are rarely accepted in any store but larger ones in malls. Most Germans, and that was pretty spot-on in the article, don't even have a credit card. You can imagine how detrimental that is to building a German SaaS business. Stripe and the like have started going into the ELV market, which is pretty much a direct debit payment - and you need to pass quite a few restrictions to even be allowed to offer ELV as a vendor. All in all, it is both a consumer, banking and a merchant issue, and it severely limits the German E-Commerce landscape in terms of payment solutions. Paypal has taken over German online payments, since it can be linked with a bank account. Credit cards? Not so much.
- kerkeslager 9y agoI can see why this is problematic for the e-commerce industry, but you seem to be saying this is problematic for the economy as a whole. If that's what you're saying, could you provide some justification for this claim?
- arvidkahl 9y agoIf you want to see e-commerce as a relevant branch of the economy, it's stifling growth. Funny enough, banks are now charging withdrawing fees for cash. So if you only ever buy things with cash, you will loose money on just acquiring it. Net loss for the non-banking economy.
- kerkeslager 9y ago> If you want to see e-commerce as a relevant branch of the economy I don't, and I don't see much evidence that anyone outside the e-commerce industry should want to see that. > Funny enough, banks are now charging withdrawing fees for cash. So if you only ever buy things with cash, you will loose money on just acquiring it. Net loss for the non-banking economy. It's fairly simple to avoid ATM fees. Every bank and credit union I've ever banked at had a network of ATMs, and there's usually no fee for cash back at grocery stores. In contrast, credit cards always charge a fee to the receiving business. Additionally, many workers receive some or all of their pay in cash, cutting banks out of the equation entirely. I don't think you can reasonably claim that credit cards take less from the non- banking economy than cash.
- overcast 9y agoConsidering everyone is carrying around wads to pay in cash. Are thieves/muggings a big problem in Germany?
- distances 9y agoNormal person doesn't carry around wads of cash during their normal day. From the article: > On average, wallets in Germany hold nearly twice as much cash—about $123 worth Not worth a mugging in a Western country that doesn't leave its citizens starving.
- overcast 9y ago$123 is still a lot of money. Pickpockets aren't roaming gangs of starving thieves.
- Retric 9y ago$123 * 365 ~= 45k/year. So, you would need to mug / pickpocket 1 or more people per day per person involved. At a guess that's not very stable and your very likely to get caught. aka, you might get 100 peoples wallets at moderate risk, but going for 10's of thousands is a lot more risky. Also, stolen CC can be turned into cash.
- overcast 9y ago$45k a year, untaxed, for what, a few minutes of work per day? Sign me up. There are professional pickpockets all over the world, that make a healthy living off of it. Also, average monthly salary in Germany is $2666. Sounds WAY more profitable to be a pickpocket.
- Retric 9y agoUntil you get caught. The problem is not so much being an experienced pickpocket, the problem is getting to that point and then living off of it for 40 years without spending a lot of time in prison.
- ijafri 9y agoI have experimented with it too, and you may as well, leave your credit cards at home, and only use 'Cash' ... you will think twice before paying for $100 consumer item ... whereas using Credit Card, you barely had noticed the price tag .... so bottom line is, Yes, paying through Cash can 'significantly' cut your expenses on 'extravagant spendings'.
- distances 9y agoMust be personal variance, as I'm not any more likely to spend with a card. I would guess it's the other way around for me -- cash is "spend money" to be used more freely, while using the card draws from the savings so the transaction carries some hesitation.
- wott 9y agoThat's even more true with small spendings: with cash, you easily see the amount stocked in your wallet decrease item after item, shop after shop, drink after drink; you also need to "refill" at the cash dispenser when it gets empty so that reminds you that you have already spent the XX or XXX € you had taken 2 days ago; you also may not be bothered to refill and opt for a lower priced item, or a lesser quantity of items, or do without the item. If you start paying small amounts with a card, it is too easy and also you don't keep track of your spending rate, you don't "feel" it, so you end up spending more. (After all, that's the point of it, shopkeepers wouldn't bother losing time and money to offer card payment if they got no benefit from it.)
- ijafri 9y agoYes that was the actual point, with CC you don't get the feel or pain of losing money ... When paying through cash you physically feel losing an amount of money. Humans.
- Cenk 9y agoIn my experience Germans use cash due to privacy concerns — they don’t want anyone knowing what they buy.
- Hersentooped 9y ago> One explanation is that, as researchers have found, memories of hyperinflation have quite a bit of staying power. People in countries that suffered banking crises quite sensibly often prefer to save in cash [...] For the same historical reasons—they loathe debt. This explanation seems absurd (or at least counter-intuitive). If your fear is hyperinflation the two things to do would be to avoid hoarding cash that can be worthless tomorrow and to buy as much tangible stuff as possible with a debt you will have to pay back with this devaluated currency.
- stupidcar 9y agoI spent a few weeks working in Munich and was surprised when I first went into a supermarket to buy lunch. The payment process was like stepping back in time 20 years in the UK. No self-checkout kiosks, just a single cashier, and a line of people all paying in cash. It worked, but it was a much slower process than was I was used to. I guess the stereotype of German super-efficiency made me assume they would be quick to adopt such technologies. But I think perhaps that is countered by a degree of conservatism about switching away from systems that are understood, and proven to work.
- DanielleMolloy 9y agoI am a German living in the Netherlands right now and find that quite annoying every time I come back to Germany, too. Before NFC I would have agreed that card payments are just much, much slower than cash. Most shops in Germany won't let you pay by card if the total amount is less than 5€, so you would always carry cash around anyway. NFC and self-checkout are quite widely spread in NL; in fact a small supermarket at a university here only has self-checkout systems with NFC. Often heard (from Germans with some international experience and its point of view) that innovations need around two years to arrive in the heads of Germany. Skepticism towards new ideas tends to impress people more than open-minded consideration of new developments. This may change at the moment as much of the younger generation gains lots of international experience and is exposed to frequent technological developments and innovative start-up culture.
- m_mueller 9y agoAs a Swiss German I think the currency stability argument is moot. Swiss Frank is one of the most stable currencies available and we still have a similar attitude to cash as Germans. IMO it's mainly due to the following reasons: 1) CC is slow, at least in Switzerland. Like in Germany, efficiency is baked into the culture - people hate to wait on someone paying his chocolate bar with credit card. It's also not rare for people to show you that discontempt. This trains people into behaving. 2) Switzerland, as most of Germany, is a mostly urbanized place with good public transport and facilities close to where people live. Meaning, there's way less weekly mall-shopping going on than in less dense countries like the US or France. So, the average total price is lower since shopping trips are more frequent, often about every second or third day after work. 3) Security concerns. For a long time CC were as insecure as the US ones, with a simple swipe of the magnetic stripe being sufficient, and CC fraud was relatively frequent. So, many people have an instinct of only using CC when necessary, and if at all possible not in public places. Debit card on the other hand have always been relatively secure (6-digit pin code, 3 tries), so they are used more often, maybe more so than in the German example since Swiss banks have pushed them since around 20 years ago.
- Semaphor 9y ago> CC is slow, at least in Switzerland. Like in Germany, efficiency is baked into the culture - people hate to wait on someone paying his chocolate bar with credit card. I pay with my card faster than the vast majority of people with cash. I also worked as a cashier during school, my favorite people were the older ones who'd just hand me their wallet so I could take the best mix of coins for the payment. Most people are horribly slow when trying to pay optimally. Anyway, at least here in Germany the whole NFC thing seems to be taking off and card payments are even faster now.
- intsunny 9y ago> 1) CC is slow While the CC may or may not be slow. In the 5+ months I've now been living in Germany, I've noticed that people are very keen to pay with exact change if they can dig it up. This is an even slower process, but also seems to be the norm.
- joezydeco 9y ago"German aversion to mortgage debt is part of the reason why the country has some of the lowest homeownership rates in the developed world." That's not just because of an aversion to debt. German Banks require a much larger down payment for their mortgages. Usually 30% or more. Banks will also look at the physical age of the borrower. They will not hand out 20-30 year loans to someone in their 60s.
- ChemicalWarfare 9y agoIn the US you are protected by the Equal Credit Opportunity Act so the bank can't turn you away based on your age. That said though - you do need to show sufficient income to qualify.
- killercup 9y agoIt's funny that Lidl, the store in the picture at the top of the article, is one of the stores I always pay with debit card in Germany. They have great NFC support and don't give a damn if I pay my 79¢ bread with card.
- dullgiulio 9y agoI live in northern Europe and once at a shop I had a shop-money credit applied automatically and was left to pay 1 cent. I didn't have absolutely any cash and paid it with debit card. I didn't hear any complaint :)
- patrickk 9y agoChains like Lidl are competing in the ultra-competitive German discount supermarket sector (Germans loooove discount chains, there are so many in Germany, and the price of groceries is therefore cheap on average), so it makes sense they'd be quick to deploy it.
- jupp0r 9y agoAs a German, I think ot's always intersting to get an outsiders perspective. The article strikes me as absurd, though. There is a deep caution against technology here, especially if it's foreign technology. There were numerous attempts by German banks to reinvent the wheel with incompatible payment systems (Geldkarte, ...) none of which could be used for online payment. All of them failed. I would also counter the efficiency argument: having recently visited Norway for vacation, I'm still impressed with the efficiency of grocery shopping where everyone pays with their credit cards. Imho it's a mixture of privacy concerns and generally negative attitudes towards technology.
- k__ 9y agoBut I have the feeling credit cards are getting more mainstream lately. When I moved to Stuttgart 10 years ago I only could pay with EC card at supermarkets, now I can pay with credit card. With the RFIDs they even got much faster, I often don't have to enter a PIN or give a signature, just wave my credit card over the terminal and be done with it. Also I can withdraw money from all ATMs of all banks without any fees.
- rb2k_ 9y agoI moved from Stuttgart to the US 5 years ago. I am always delighted to come back and see that I need less and less cash. It blew my mind when even Aldi and Lidl jumped on the credit card train. Looking forward to the day when I can visit Germany without having to go to the ATM.
- Thlom 9y agoNorwegians mostly use debit card thanks to the BankAxept system which all banks are part of. Most BankAxept cards are both bankAxept for everyday use and VISA if necessary (online shopping etc). When you pay with BankAxept it's counted against your account immediately. Another reason debit is mostly used is that not all shops accept credit card (which might also be because everyone has a BankAxept card so having MaterCard capabilities or whatever costs more than it's worth. I think BankAxept is pretty similar to the Danish Dankort.
- 9y ago
- jurgenwerk 9y agoI thought it was the other way around - that the reason German people pay cash is simply because shops and bars refuse to support credit cards. Whenever I visit Berlin I'm so frustrated because I have to plan my spending ahead and make sure I have enough cash in my pocket before I go buy anything.
- ant6n 9y agoJust keep a couple hundred in your pocket, like everybody else and their grandma.
- martinald 9y agoWhat if your wallet gets stolen or you misplace it?
- chr4004 9y agoAbsolutely, I too think it's a matter of supply. So often shops refuse to take cards to avoid the fees. I suspect a systematic or law issue making card transactions more expensive.
- martinald 9y agoAgree, such a pain. Especially in restaurants if you take a large group out and want to pick the bill up. It has got better but I have been totally caught out with this on one of my first visits to Berlin with a fairly pricey group dinner and I physically cannot take more than €250 out of the ATM a day without taking cash out on CC which involves horrendous cash advance fees. I also don't buy this cc fee argument. It's regulated (and low) in the EU, perhaps 1-2%. This must be lower than the cost of storing cash, counting cash, paying it in to the bank, transporting it, getting fraudulent notes, people giving wrong change, etc etc. The other annoying thing is DB machines not taking visa/mastercard and no notes over €10 (though this may have changed recently), which is all you get out of an ATM when you land at the airport. Such a hassle. I hope Berlin can fix this and the BER airport situation one day.
- kuschku 9y ago
- tehabe 9y agoOn the other side, invoices are paid with wire transfers or even direct deposit entries. I haven't seen many checks since the Eurocheck lost its guaranteed value of DEM 400. Personally I think cash is convenient. I also use debit card and credit card but somehow cash is the most convenient was of payment in a store.
- rocking_duck 9y agoAs a german, this techno-phobic attitude was really getting to me for the longest time. It's just so incredible convenient not having to scramble for coins when taking the tram and many other examples. Living in London, I rarely take my wallet with me anymore. Apple Pay and my Mondo card is all I need. Come to think of it, some time in the not so distant future, Germany will probably have the last laugh once the entire electronic payment system collapsed under the Next Big Cyberattack (tm)... insert coin here.
- hardwaresofton 9y agoHow is Japan not on that list of countries that pay for things primarily in cash?
- lmm 9y agoI suspect the main reason is that in a safe country like Germany people feel more comfortable carrying around large amounts of cash. Japan is extraordinarily cash-oriented, but it works because people don't get mugged; even if you leave your wallet on a train you can expect to get it back with all the cash still inside.
- metafunctor 9y agoLots of countries that are very safe use mostly cards instead of cash. Like the all of the Nordics.
- gweinberg 9y agoThe "memory of hyperinflation" theory is an obvious crock, because the prediction is 100% backwards-ass wrong. If you thought hyperinflation in the near future was at all likely, you'd want to buy everything on credit.
- deneb84 9y agoaccordording to this, it seems germans are really near to the europe average. http://en.finance.sia-partners.com/cash-here-stay-question-how-you-manage-it http://en.finance.sia-partners.com/cash-here-stay-question-h...
- jhoechtl 9y agoThe why is easily explained and has nothing to do with the 'tumultuous history': it's all about the privacy. I shudder what data is available in the US (and other countries) on customers buying habbits. Sure, with eShoping on an ever rise, this privacy increasingly vanishes.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- mindcirkus 9y agoI think you'd have to dig deeper in the debt argument, and what it has to do with cash. > "But the real point isn’t that Germans love cash. It’s that—for the same historical reasons—they loathe debt. (Armchair anthropologists have also long noted that German word for debt—Schulden—comes from the word for guilt, Schuld.)" Sweden has the same culture and words for debt. "skuld", and the saying "Den som är satt i skuld är icke fri" ("He/She who is in debt is not free"). Yet Swedes likes using Credit Cards a lot. But as the author might say we have a lot higher household debt than Germany. But Switzerland also has high household debt. And as another commenter notes Switzerland has the same cash behavior as Germany. I'd like to see some data on that though. https://data.oecd.org/hha/household-debt.htm https://data.oecd.org/hha/household-debt.htm I do feel like an armchair anthropologist though.
- Tharkun 9y agoThere's a lot of love for contactless payments in this thread. I would have thought the security-conscious HN audience would dislike them? Has something improved wrt security?
- akx 9y agoFWIW, for my NFC debit card the maximum for a single transaction is 25 EUR, and the card will require a PIN occasionally anyway (I assume the more often NFC is used).
- homakov 9y agoAs a user of N26, sure I always choose cash. They always require typing stupid 6 digit pin (even for paypass). I can't switch it off.
- majewsky 9y agoA few months ago, there was some construction going on just outside the busiest mall in the city center of Dresden. When they dug into the ground, they accidentally dug a bit too far and cut the internet cable for that mall (and a few more blocks around it). That was on a Friday evening, so the replacement cable could not be delivered until Monday. The entire mall was without internet access and, consequently, all credit card terminals, EC terminals and ATMs stopped working. If I had not been able to pay cash (as I always do because of Datensparsamkeit [1]), I would not have been able to go to the cinema that weekend. [1] Does the word "Datensparsamkeit" have a good translation in English? It's sort of an idiosyncrasy of the German language and the German people. It refers to the practice of protecting one's data by not generating it in the first place. Cash is datensparsam because it is anonymous, hence the metadata of my purchase cannot be associated with my identity.
- PythonicAlpha 9y agoI (as others) think, that the stability reason is bogus. The things that where mentioned, happened 100 years ago. To long for most Germans to remember. Maybe we are just more traditional thinking, than others. Some good alternative reasons where given here. In my experience, the cash workflow is faster in most situations than our CC workflow (maybe in other countries it is the opposite). I want to give another reason, that is one of mine: With money in my pocket, I have my expenses under better control. When the money is out before the month ends, I immediately see it. With CC, it is not so. And as we Germans are so economical, many of us like to have control over our expenses. I also think, that there is a good evidence, that it actually works.
- tomatsu 9y agoPaying with cash is faster. Inserting your card, entering your pin, waiting a bit, getting some receipt printed, and finally signing it does take significantly longer than getting the right amount of change from a cashier who is used to doing this. Paying with a debit card always makes you look a bit like a twat. It's similar to paying with a handful of coins.
- paulsutter 9y agoUse of credit cards in the US really took off in 1980 when interest rates were deregulated[1], credit cards were then heavily promoted. I remember at that time, to use a credit card in a grocery store had a social stigma. But now, many people here rarely use cash. What are the credit card interest rates in Germany? (In the US credit card interest rates can be 20-30%). Maybe there's less incentive to promote use of cards in Germany, or maybe transaction fees are regulated to make small transactions impractical? [1] https://www.fdic.gov/bank/analytical/bank/bt_9805.html https://www.fdic.gov/bank/analytical/bank/bt_9805.html
- dingo_bat 9y agoI don't even know what is the rate on my credit card. I use it all the time. I just pay back the full amount every month. I think that's the best way to use it. You don't need to carry cash. You don't need to pay interest.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- cosinetau 9y agoWhat was the social stigma of using a credit card at a grocery store? I think I kinda remember some remnants of that when I got my first card and started using it to pay for everyday/trivial purchases. In fact, I remember the real reason for the wait in the line was were most folks taking time to write cheques. It was a lot like waiting for someone to count bus fare on the coinop.
- paulsutter 9y agoThere was a time when furniture stores, appliance stores, etc, provided credit directly. You could buy items from the store and make payments over time. Credit cards were seen as a generalized way to make these purchases, if you go far enough back in time.
- 9y ago
- thesumofall 9y agoThe article is missing one key piece: how are card payments developing over time? My personal experience is that things have changed rapidly over the last years with most larger stores now accepting credit cards and contactless payments are increasingly becoming normal (just months ago cashiers might have looked dumbfounded at you when waving your card over the reader). It is also critical to note that Germany has some of the lowest prices for groceries. Shops have hence been very slow in offering credit card payments.
- cleansy 9y agoGerman living in UK here. I think the flaky-currency argument is non-sense. I see this argument mostly in anglo-american articles when the authors try to figure out why germans are still mostly cash-transactional. I paid in cash back home mostly because it's faster. Cashiers are used to calculate the change and quick getting it out. CC/Debit card payments take a bit longer, since you almost only have chipped payments, get the device to work, enter pin, wait for receipt that you have to sign sometimes, etc. I was never pick pocketed on the street, so this wasn't an issue either. I only started paying by card with the introduction of NFC/ "contactless" payments, since this one is faster. Also, the UK coins are quite heavy having €10 worth of coins is half the volume at least compared to the old pounds.
- barking 9y agoOn the rare occasions I pay for high cost items in cash, it hurts. I can definitely see the value in paying with cash if you area trying to stick to a budget
- nickbauman 9y agoBorn in Germany to a Hessian mother, lived there twice for a total of 11 years. Left just before the wall came down (wish I had stayed at least for that). In my experience, Germans have a strong debt aversion. Even the young did. My mom's friends would buy new cars by reaching into their purses and pulling out stacks of bills and counting them out in total. It never seemed anything other than weird to me. "The slowest things to change are habits of thinking."
- makarb 9y ago>"The slowest things to change are habits of thinking." As if amassing debt was something positive...
- somecallitblues 9y agoYou buy less useless crap when using cash and it's just nice to have cash. It feels real.
- snakeanus 9y agoI am glad, there are some serious privacy issues concerning credit and debit cards. Not to mention that bringing a third party into this causes all kinds of issues, such as their ability to block your card at any time or taking a percentage of the money. I hope that cryptocurrencies replace cards someday.
- pascalxus 9y agoThe question isn't why germans pay cash. the question is, why would you do it any other way?? I'll tell you why. In other countries we allow credit card companies to tax the masses. By creating regulations that prevent merchants from charging a different price for cash vs credit, you effectively force everyone to pay 2.5% extra for every purchase. That 2.5% goes straight to the credit card companies, even if you pay cash! So, you have no choice but to use a credit card, so you can recover 1.5% on the 2.5% tax your paying.
- IanCal 9y agoCapped at 0.2% now aren't they?
- mtmail 9y agoYes, thanks to the European Union starting 2016. "The new regulation will cap interchange fees at 0.2% of the transaction value for Visa and MasterCard consumer debit cards and at 0.3% for Visa and MasterCard consumer credit cards effective as of December 2015." https://www.adyen.com/blog/eu-interchange-fees-cap https://www.adyen.com/blog/eu-interchange-fees-cap That put a lot of credit card schemes (get fly miles or points or cashback for each purchase) in trouble and they had to change their offers. My credit card company wrote back then I can now only earn status miles with their silver card now, at 99 Euro/year cost.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- golergka 9y ago> By creating regulations that prevent merchants from charging a different price for cash vs credit, you effectively force everyone to pay 2.5% extra for every purchase. Force? Merchants are free to sell things for cash only. But they won't - because consumers want to pay in credit cards, and a shop that only accepts cash will lose customers.
- omni 9y ago> That 2.5% goes straight to the credit card companies, even if you pay cash! You're going to have to explain how this makes any sense at all
- cosinetau 9y agoThere was another article on HN this week that was attempting to predict when the stock market was going to crash. https://isthestockmarketgoingtocrash.com/ https://isthestockmarketgoingtocrash.com/ There's also been a number of suggestions of the kind of economy that we're existing in. The most alarming to me is that we're in a debt economy. Germany struggled to pay it's abhorrent war debt and reparations after WWI, and I'm curious if rather than the government facing that problem if the population in the US, or China will instead? What is the big picture these pieces of information are trying to tell us? Should we be taking a more cautious approach when it comes to using debt? (This commentor has no debt, and wants to keep it that way)
- calvinbhai 9y agoWhat if Germany also has a round of Demonetization, similar to what India did in November 2016? Would the Germans continue to use cash to pay for anything after that? I'm a fan of the Indian demonetization experiment, and I believe it has yielded positive results, at least in terms of being able to use your credit/debit cards almost anywhere. If such a drastic measure is taken, then there'll be some aversion to cash, which will, in turn, move more people to non-cash modes of payment.
- Samuray 9y agoFirst, while it's true that the German "Schulden" is related to "Schuld", it's also true that one of the definitions of "debt" is "sin". I don't know if many anthropologists really have wasted much time thinking about this one, but it seems pretty irrelevant to me. Second, the German banking system is actually very modern. While the Americans and British are still sending cheques through the post, Germans are regularly paying by direct debit and standing order, as a matter of course. Third, I think a point that may be missing is that Germans might be suspicious of credit card payments as they leave records which can be inspected by government agencies. It's bad enough that they might be able to find out how much rent you pay and how much electricity you use, but they really don't need to know exactly which bar you got drunk in last night. I don't know if anyone's done any serious study into this one, but it is very noticeable that Germans are particularly concerned about their privacy.
- Symbiote 9y agoYou shouldn't put the USA and Britain together in your comparison. Direct debit is extremely popular in Britain, and cheques have declined over 10% for several years in a row. Graphs (PDF): http://www.paymentsuk.org.uk/sites/default/files/publication-free/UK%20Payment%20Markets%20Summary%202016%20-%20Free%20Download.pdf http://www.paymentsuk.org.uk/sites/default/files/publication...
- majewsky 9y ago> the Americans and British are still sending cheques through the post I'm from Germany, and I have to ask this... WHY? Related anecdote: When I was still living with my parents, I had to cash in cheques from time to time for them. The cheques came from the lottery which they were playing, but they had no realistic possiblity at all to cash them in (the next branch of their bank was over an hour away by car), but I had an account at the local bank in the small town where I lived.
- CrystalGamma 9y agoOh I would definitely say that debt is looked down upon in Germany. I would say I have generally owed at most a single (monetary) debt at a given time in my life (or two if you count my employer paying me mid-month as a credit of half a month), because debtlessness is freedom (cue Anastacia's Paid My Dues ).
- ZooAgent 9y agoPaying in bars or clubs with my credit card would be devastating for my account and liver. If I calculate in my head how much money I can spare for a weekend and then withdraw the cash, it is much easier to stay on the budget.
- Annoying 9y agoI think it's important to distinguish that many (almost all) places that accept EC (a debit card, really) do not accept credit cards. Hell, even Saturn, that makes Best Buy look small, doesn't accept credit cards unless it's over 1.500€ or something.
- SuperInEveryWay 9y agoThe reason is pretty simple. The German craftsmanship is underpaid and pretty much everyone moonlights a little. In addition the German financial authority is worse than the NSA. No transactions no questions.
- fh973 9y agoNot having to routinely verify my credit card or bank account statement with what would be easily over a hundred transactions per month saves me a lot of time and energy. With cash I know when I was robbed.
- david-cako 9y agoCredit card stigma is interesting to me. For the individual that would otherwise be paying with a debit card, why would you not want to earn rewards on that? Treat it like real money, pay every month, literally zero downside. That said, I imagine rewards in the US are much more attractive than elsewhere, since credit card companies have so much profitability to distribute.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- alaxsxaq 9y agoMaybe it is my German roots, but I share the preference for cash and dislike of personal debt. More than 90% of my Brick & Morter purchases are in cash up to about $500. I stop at an ATM every couple of weeks and withdrawal $300-$500 dollars and I'm set. Cash is anonymous, quick, a one-time thing (no bills to pay later), and the standard method of payment in the small (rural) stores I frequent. Credit cards are reserved for buying gas, large purchases, online transactions, and travel.
- TrueCommander 9y agoBefore coming to Germany, I'd always pay for a coffee or pop or other $1 purchase with a debit card. I know it may seem like it makes more sense to pay for something with a Euro coin, but after the Pf and it becomes a Euro and extra change... and to me, it's just more of a hassle to pay with coins instead of plastic. I did try to get used to not using debit before coming here I just hate fishing around in my case for change and either having to know how much my stuff will cost before getting to the front of the till or dealing with the knowledge that I'm holding up the line.
- supergirl 9y agohow to make a clickbait article. find some random statistic and fill an article with speculation about it.
- SamurayJack 9y agoI'm the complete opposite. I never have cash on me and I get irrational angry when some place does not accept EC.
- NamTaf 9y agoI see Australia mentioned in second place. That doesn't marry with my experience, which is seeing card dominate cash due to the early and very widespread uptake of contactless payment without pin or anything under $100. This makes it faster than anything else for coffee, taxis, etc. To see cash sitting at 65% simply doesn't align with my everyday experience. Maybe it's the legions of baby boomers in the suburbs? I don't know. I would've suggested Australia would've been 1/3 or 1/4 cash payment.
- walterstucco 9y agoThey don't pay almost everything in cash in Germany. They pay some more than the half in cash. It's in Italy where we almost pay everything in cash: in Italy 83% of payments are still in cash. The reasons are obvious.
- Too 9y agoPretty weak thesis I would say. Visa debit exists and is equally convenient as credit card without the debt drawback. You can get one that is indistinguishable from visa cc to the merchant and hence works everywhere normal Visa does (unlike the one branded "visa debit" that existed many years ago).
- wmu 9y agoA few years ago I was working on some bank software. We had access to bank's anonymized data, and I was really surprised when figured out what information is stored with card payments. For instance, I learnt that a guy had bought a pack of cigarettes in a small town at 12:31, Monday. Then I realized how much information a bank may posses. And how dangerous it is, because we have no control on how and who process that info. That day I decided to pay with cash whenever I can, despite inconvenience. I prefer cards or bank transfers when buying expansive stuff, like a car, furniture, a camera, etc.
- mgoetzke 9y agoand most annoyingly apple recently removed paypal as a payment option here in germany. which means i cannot buy any apps anymore unless i go and get an itunes gift card.