15 ms·
Digital coins may be on the verge of going mainstream
- booleandilemma 9y agoMy parents know about bitcoin, so as far as I'm concerned digital coins are already mainstream. I'm still waiting for them to ask me what an ICO is.
- sillysaurus3 9y agoWhat is an ICO? (I'm only being half-serious. But it's amusing that there isn't a consistent definition. It's basically "you can buy an asset I created out of thin air that may or may not have any utility.")
- avaer 9y agoI have a theory that once you can define ICOs, they will cease to exist in their current form. If the layman buying ICOs for their speculative value understands the asset they're buying, they might not want to buy it anymore.
- grandDesigns 9y agoI have another theory, that this has already happened.
- hathawsh 9y agoI see what you did there. ;-) https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/2397-there-is-a-theory-which-states-that-if-ever-anyone https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/2397-there-is-a-theory-whic...
- nugget 9y agoDon't be so sure. The penny stock market is alive and well. People love to gamble.
- wslh 9y agoI have another theory, ICOs will evolve with public due diligence, real products instead of whitepapers, etc. In this way, companies and people from developing countries and below could raise money faster and with less friction. I am not saying that scams will be surpressed but interesting projects will find a better destiny.
- jjawssd 9y agoAn ICO is the process of providing liquidity to early coin miners and investors.
- a_d 9y agoProjects are issuing tokens to raise funds (ICO ~= IPO). They are of two types: 1) Protocol coins (coins that have some value within the project / product) and 2) Asset coins (coins that can be thought of as shares in a company). Protocol coins are being positioned as presold revenue and need not necessarily conform with securities laws. Most ICOs are trying to position their coins as kickstarter-type "token gifts" (e.g. T-shirts) Asset coins on the other hand, come under the purview of securities laws and act People are buying these coins because of FOMO. Large majority of these projects having ICOs are scams - not too different from the dot-com bubble. Eventually, some good ideas are going to come out of these projects.
- kowdermeister 9y agoPretty good summary: http://www.investopedia.com/terms/i/initial-coin-offering-ico.asp http://www.investopedia.com/terms/i/initial-coin-offering-ic...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- TaylorGood 9y agoMy dad has Bitcoin and sends me Cryptocurrency articles. My girlfriends father was an investment banker during the 80s and is long on gold. Every time I see him he asks me about Bitcoin. Note: I am not a crypto expert.
- dcw303 9y agoWe're a long way off mainstream. Take the Web as an example: When my university lab computer got trumpet winsock and Netscape installed, it wasn't mainstream. When Hotbot was launched and could actually search with some degree of efficiency it wasn't mainstream. When I learned html and javascript from reading Webmonkey posts it wasn't mainstream. When I switched to this new upstart called Google it wasn't mainstream. When I could use Google Maps to zoom in on the house I used to live in it wasn't mainstream. When I could publish posts on Blogger it wasn't mainstream. When I could post on Twitter and Facebook it was starting to feel like it was mainstream. But when my parents could figure out how to get on Facebook on their mobile phones, I knew that the web had become mainstream, even thought it's debatable how much of the web is really left. In the same way that today's web users don't care about html, http, or urls, digital currency won't be mainstream until they don't have to care about private keys, bitcoin addresses, or even (gasp!) the blockchain. We're a long way off. EDIT: Since I get the sense a lot of cryptocurrency proponents are taking this as a dismissal, let me say that I do think it has a bright future. I just think there's a lot of work ahead until we get there.
- Jasper_ 9y agoEven taking your (IMO incorrect) assumption that the web only became mainstream when Facebook launched at face value... > When Hotbot was launched and could actually search with some degree of efficiency it wasn't mainstream. That was 1996. > When I could post on Twitter and Facebook it was starting to feel like it was mainstream. That was 2004. So roughly a gap of 8 years. Bitcoin started in 2009. It's now 2017. A gap of 8 years. So, uh, how much longer is a "a long way off"?
- zippergz 9y agoAsk your parents to explain cryptocurrency. It's not about wall clock time. It's about milestones.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- 9y ago
- discombobulate 9y agoIncorrect title.
- discombobulate 9y agoThe fucking title is wrong. Not only that, I got downvoted for pointing out it's wrong. & It hasn't been changed.
- mattdeboard 9y ago2017 is the year of Linux on the desktop
- gojomo 9y agoSince POTUS tweets using an Android device in the Oval Office, we can at least say 2017 is the year of Linux on the top desk.
- jerrylives 9y agoDoes Trump still use an Android as POTUS? Any info on what make, OS?
- samtoday 9y agoI believe it is a Samsung Galaxy 2. A quick search yielded: http://bgr.com/2017/01/26/donald-trumps-android-phone/ http://bgr.com/2017/01/26/donald-trumps-android-phone/ https://www.cnbc.com/2017/03/29/donald-trump-apple-iphone-android-unsecured.html https://www.cnbc.com/2017/03/29/donald-trump-apple-iphone-an...
- quickthrower2 9y agoThat's a bit cheapskate for a president.
- lightbyte 9y agoBit too risky to upgrade, don't want the POTUS's phone to spontaneously combust.
- DaiPlusPlus 9y ago*Year of Linux running inside pico-processes on top of the NT kernel.
- tootie 9y agoChromeOS put Linux on the desktop and no one noticed.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- skshetry 9y agoAnd, now, we have two bitcoins. Cash and umm, Bitcoin.I wonder what effect it has(will have) on the future of cryptocurrency?
- godzillabrennus 9y agoCoinbase is going to support cash... as they go others will as well...
- gthtjtkt 9y agoCoinbase currently has no plan to support Bitcoin Cash trading. They won't even support withdrawals until 2018.
- godzillabrennus 9y agoCrawl, walk, run. Market demand will change all that.
- AgentME 9y agoBitcoin Cash isn't the only altcoin. It's just a recent popular one that forked from Bitcoin's blockchain history.
- stronglikedan 9y agoRegardless of whether it will ever go mainstream in the near future, and as a newbie to cryptocurrency, is it expected that, whenever it goes mainstream, the value will? 1) Dramatically rise 2) Rise 3) Behave as usual (depending on current trend) 4) Fall 5) Dramatically fall I just curious. I dabble because some eTailors give discounts for Bitcoin, but I can also invest a bit at any time (just not enough to seriously get involved in the day-to-day).
- Nition 9y agoThere is a limited total number of bitcoins and the number of bitcoins is increasing very slowly now so technically the more people buy in the more it should go up. Because there is more money in bitcoins but not more bitcoins.
- stronglikedan 9y agoThanks. So a physical bitcoin is not worth 1 bitcoin, but rather a percentage of the entire bitcoin market value (maybe not the right term), relative to the number of physical bitcoins, correct?
- sgspace 9y agoHuh? There is no such thing as a physical bitcoin. 1 bitcoin will always be worth 1 bitcoin. To calculate the total bitcoin market cap you multiply the number of circulating bitcoins by the current exchange rate for your preferred currency.
- stronglikedan 9y ago> There is no such thing as a physical bitcoin. Of course there are: https://www.google.com/search?q=physical+bitcoin&oq=physical+bitcoin&aqs=chrome..69i57&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8 https://www.google.com/search?q=physical+bitcoin&oq=physical... As to how they relate to crypto, I have no idea, which is why I asked about it.
- chrismealy 9y agoUntil I can pay taxes with it, not interested.
- Gigablah 9y agoI feel like it's already mainstream, in Singapore at least. I was getting a haircut at the neighbourhood barbershop and I overhead the shop owner talking about cryptocurrency with a female customer -- stuff like regulatory issues, Satoshi's identity, altcoins, and so on. They probably had more knowledge of Bitcoin than I did.
- solomatov 9y agoIt sounds like a sign of a bubble to me.
- kowdermeister 9y agoSounds like cyberpunk to me.
- DennisP 9y agoSingapore's government has been very favorable to cryptocurrencies. Startups around the world who want to do ICOs have been basing themselves in Singapore, along with several other friendly countries. It wouldn't be surprising if the five million residents of Singapore have an unusually high level of awareness.
- solomatov 9y agoI heard similar conversations from laymen in USA recently. During 2000s bubble I heard that you can hear about perspectives of different IT companies form unexpected people as well.
- wilg 9y agoQuick question: what do people do with them? Invest?
- mirimir 9y agoPeople pay me for doing stuff. And I pay for stuff, mainly for VPN services and servers.
- vinchuco 9y agoI made happy returns (poor-student-sized and regrettably non-leveraged) on three occasions simply by monitoring when exposure would go up and timing the end of hype (e.g. when the first senate hearing on BTC). stats.grok.se, forums and HN were good informers. Then I quit. I wish I knew the full answer to your question.
- nemo1618 9y ago>For this reason, none of the investors I spoke with engage in short-term trading but instead choose, in the online parlance of cryptocurrency enthusiasts, to “hodl” (“hold on for dear life,” rather than sell off for temporary gains). Someone trolled this author. "hodl" is just a misspelling of "hold," not an acronym.
- trendia 9y agoFirst seen here: "I am hodling." https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=375643.0 https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=375643.0
- noddy1 9y ago"Pop bottles and Hodl"
- discombobulate 9y agoSaw Chris DeRose troll him. He runs a sceptical crypto-based podcast (changing the name to 'Chris DeRose Uncensored' (the pod, that is))
- jeppebemad 9y agoThat amused me too as well. But I wouldn't be surprised if "hodl" eventually turns into an abbreviation. In order for cryptos to "go mainstream", it will have to say goodbye to some of its attached memes.
- Animats 9y agoIt's all zero-sum. It doesn't create wealth.
- mathgenius 9y ago> It's all zero-sum. But this is the same as "conservation of energy". Everything is zero-sum, and yet we still do stuff. > It doesn't create wealth. Well I have two answers for this. One is simple: these are financial products, and people need those. The other answer is a question: what is wealth ? Or, what is value? And these questions are like koans, they are both profound and also without solution. Wild price gyrations on exchanges going back hundreds of years are testament to this.
- marcosdumay 9y agoIf it enables new kinds of transactions, it will create wealth.
- rmason 9y agoQuite the day for bitcoin, it may be going mainstream. A few years back I had to travel to the Valley to find a bitcoin ATM and now there are three in my hometown! Front page of today's Lansing State Journal: http://www.lansingstatejournal.com/story/news/local/2017/08/03/lansing-investing-invest-investment-bitcoin/497148001/ http://www.lansingstatejournal.com/story/news/local/2017/08/... Can't get more mainstream than that!
- AlphaWeaver 9y agoI tend to believe this is being upvoted because people want to believe this, not because it's actually true.
- thirtyseven 9y agoSeriously, TFA was posted in the Style section. It's not exactly the most rigorous part of the Times.
- deelowe 9y agoThere's also probably quite a few influential people who have a vested interest in digital currency increasing in value.
- zhoujianfu 9y agoMyself, for example!
- richardknop 9y agoThis is a big reason. A substantial amount of people with vested interest that would benefit greatly if the price of crypto increases are in tech and post on HN. So you get a lot of crypto and bitcoin related posts upvoted very quickly here. It's just that HN has disproportional amount of people invested in crypto so they act in their interest. Most bitcoin early adopters were hackers after all.
- discombobulate 9y agoIt also has a clickbait title added; which gives it an advantage wrt attention.
- dogruck 9y agoThis is dangerous! When everyday folks go bust on their crypto holdings, there will be pain, suffering and retribution. Or, perhaps you agree that we don't need any of these pesky financial and gambling regulations and safeguards. If this article was about Beanie Babies or penny stocks, would you be clapping?
- josiahtullis 9y agoIt's not about Beanie Babies or penny stocks.
- kaffeemitsahne 9y agoJust keep in mind the age-old adage: never invest more than you are willing to lose. Same goes for beanie babies, penny stocks, and index funds.
- dogruck 9y agoShall we abolish the FDIC and the SEC? Then, should we redirect some of the funds into gambling addiction support groups?
- jknz 9y agoBitcoin seems quite straightforward and easy to understand, compared to our current banking system. A lot of comments mention the difficulty of explaining what is bitcoin and how it works, and that mainstream people cannot get enough understanding to start using it. What about the actual banking system? There are so much mainstream ignorance about our current banking system. What does it even mean that I own $2000 at a bank? Ok I understand that I can withdraw this cash, but other than that it is a very abstract concept, built into the opaque IT system of my bank. If I transfer money from bank A to bank B, what does that mean? Did the banks exchange an envelope of cash? Do mainstream users really understand the details of a bank transaction? I personal have no clue about the inner workings of this banking IT systems. Bitcoin seems very easy to grasp. Understanding quantitative easing? In the bitcoin world this is transparent and easy to grasp. For my national currency I have no clue of how quantitative easing is done, by how much, etc. The more I think of our national banking/currency systems, the more I believe bitcoin is way simpler to explain and understand.
- wingerlang 9y agoIt means they are holding $2000 of your money. And if you send it to another bank then it means they send it to them and now the other bank is holding your $2000. Nothing hard about that. Bitcoin might be easy if you're a techie and interested in it. I am not interested in it and I barely even know where to start. What does it mean to mine stuff? Blockchain? What.. There is no way my parents would remotely get started with Bitcoins at this point. And I believe that once it becomes easy enough for mainstream, it will be as abstract as anything.
- honestlyreally 9y agoIf everyone wants to take their $2000 out at once, can they? In most countries that's highly unlikely, so is it really $2000? Or something entirely different?
- wingerlang 9y agoI think it is common knowledge that banks use money to invest, lend to others for profit and so on. So no, not everyone could take it out at once as it would crash the bank. I guess you could say that they hold your $2000 most times, but at times they use it for something else and are in debt to you. I don't think on the user-level it is complicated at all. You can literally go to a bank, have them create your account and give them physical money. Then take it out.
- vinchuco 9y agoWhat exactly is 'going mainstream' as it relates to digital coins? Seems like everyone draws the line differently.
- knodi 9y agolol, no. Go ahead download the ledger.
- dangero 9y agoit bears mentioning here that the vast majority of cryptocurrency investors seem to be male, and their Twitter discourse tends to be less than refined, with insults often lodged at devotees of rival currencies. The vast majority of cryptocurrency investors probably don't even have a twitter account. This seems like a big logical jump to make.
- neilwilson 9y agoTulip bulbs are prettier.
- sleazybae 9y ago"I am clever because tulips and Holland lol. you certainly won't find ME getting taken by all those bitcoin hucksters, yuk yuk yuk"
- rubatuga 9y agoI believe that crypto currencies will not affect most people’s lives (<10%), and therefore it will never go “mainstream”. The applications for BTC are quite limited, and are mostly edge cases such as evading detection, and easy international transfers. The value of a BTC is currently based on the price of mining one BTC, plus mass speculation. If you consider the immense inefficiency and resources required to mine a BTC, you realize that in most cases using your state’s currency is a better option. The trust and safety provided by BTC is subject to the law of diminishing returns, meaning that most will be content with the money system currently being used today.
- malikNF 9y agoLets start with the whole, "crypto-concurrency mining is wasting money" argument. This link https://www.federalreserve.gov/faqs/currency_12771.htm https://www.federalreserve.gov/faqs/currency_12771.htm shows how much it costs to print a currency note just in the US. This shows how many notes are in circulation in the us https://www.federalreserve.gov/paymentsystems/coin_currcircvolume.htm https://www.federalreserve.gov/paymentsystems/coin_currcircv... Then there's the cost in securing the money, transferring it, and keeping track of it add the cost of fake notes, lost and damaged notes and you should see where I am going with this argument. Then lets talk about "application of btc for edge cases" moving money internationally is not an edge case, it is something that makes the world go round and disruption in that area is no trivial thing. Its not an edge case. As for crypto being used by people to avoid detection, well, you can do the same things with fiat currencies. Why do you think there are organisation like the FBI hiring highly skilled people to track and trace what people do with their money. In a crypto world there is a better chance for law enforcement to catch criminals. The best thing about the blockchain is it helps us solve the problem of trust, ofcourse I agree there are problems with this model right now, for example how mining pools can technically launch a 51% attack on the major block-chains and the wole tx/s problem. But what you need to realize is these problems are being acknowledged by the community and are being solved little by little, the technology is progressing there's billions of dollars worth of money tied up in this project. One more point, the block chain is not just about currencies, there's so many more areas where they can be useful. Take a look at the Ethereum project. Therefore I am someone who really believe that block-chains are here to stay and they are going to effect every single one of us.
- jondubois 9y agoMoney has been getting increasingly less tangible over the past few thousand years. Initially, the value of money was in the materials that made it up; e.g gold, silver coins. Then people started paying with paper backed by gold; so although the paper itself had no value, it could be used to redeem gold. ... People got used to paper. Then people started paying with paper fiat currencies not backed by anything. Then people started paying with electronic numbers on computer screens in their bank accounts backed by the fiat paper money. ... People got used to digital numbers in their bank accounts. Now we have cryptocurrencies which are backed by the electronic numbers in our bank accounts. It does seem like a logical progression.
- neilwilson 9y agoMoney has never been tangible. It always has been a token for a debt owed by somebody. There is no difference between a paper bill, a coin and a cheque other than the account it references.
- jondubois 9y agoThere is a huge difference between a coin and a paper bill. Unlike the paper bill, the gold coin is both a currency and a commodity - It has many useful properties. It can be melted down and turned into jewellery, used in electronics, tooth fillings, glass-making, paint, etc... Fiat money can be exchanged for other things but fiat money in itself cannot be converted into anything useful. Destroying fiat currency to sell the underlying material is illegal in most countries. When gold coins were currency, people would shave slivers of gold from their coins to pay for small things. This emphasises that the value of the currency was entirely in its material. The value of a gold coin as a currency was equal to its value as a commodity.
- neilwilson 9y agoYou've obviously never made a paper plane out of a bank note. Or had one with a printing error where it becomes a collectible artwork. The value of any coin is far greater than its metal value in any normal system. Gold included.
- tudorw 9y agoThe value of fiat currency is that the issuing entity assures it's worth, ensures it's security, it's validity and facilitates flow. The benefits of cryptocurrency may look appealing, however, as a store of wealth it's a long way from 'mainstream' and I believe entropy will prevail, in the fiat system entropy is handled, the supply of money is flexible, in a system with entropy, everyone's wealth will tend towards zero over the long term.
- kogepathic 9y agoAnother way to phrase this is: "Are digital coins on the verge of going mainstream?" to which I reply: Betteridge's law of headlines
- discombobulate 9y agoThat's not the headline. The editorialised headline hasn't been changed.
- romanovcode 9y agoAnd 2017 will be the year of Linux desktop.
- ditn 9y ago>“If my landscaper ever asks me about crypto, that’s the day I get out,” he said. My hairdresser spent an hour extolling the virtues of cryptocurrencies to me a few weeks ago, and yesterday an electrician who was in the office was explaining to us his weekend project which was basically a multisig wallet written in PHP. Perhaps crypto has already reached peak bubble.
- asherkosaraju 9y agoNot yet in India. It's almost banned here because of lack of compliance.
- codingmyway 9y agoIf nothing else, cryptocurrency might do one thing that is needed, if only roughly and imperfectly, and is to distribute wealth from the the old to the young. It's the one counterbalance to the debt based asset bubbles of the last 40 years that have transferred wealth to pensioners at the expense of the young
- otp124 9y agoCare to explain? If anything, it's wealth transfer from the coin/token buyers to sellers.
- codingmyway 9y agoYes, it's from more technically savvy to less technical so to some degree from young to old. Not exactly of course but it's the one countervailing flow to the housing and other asset bubbles and debt transfer which have massively transferred wealth in the opposite direction.
- gloverkcn 9y agoThis reminds me of the wired article "the long boom" which described how the economy was on a permanent upswing. The telco / .com crash happened a couple years later. The article asserts that currency will always go up because people will want it as an investment strategy. Sounds like the idea that real estate value will always go up
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Allower 9y agoWow, nytimes behind the times. per usual. what a trash bag of a news outlet
- EA 9y agoThe first digital coin land rush was when people and companies were registering thousands of somewhat random domain names per day hoping to hit on one that someone would eventually want.
- Qub3d 9y agoDigital coins will go mainstream the same year the Linux Desktop does. (A.K.A. $currentyear+1)
- CurrencyDigest 9y agoGrandpa had a pension and we have Crypto. Thats a TERRIBLE retirement strategy!
- ZeusNuts 9y agoMerkle tree code that helps run Bitcoin was written by a grandpa aged person, cryptographic nonces were created by grandpas also and Satoshi and Hal Finney were of the grandpa group too. This generation can thank the last three generations no less, for the opportunity of cryptocurrency.
- Lazy_Killer 9y agoI dont' see why crypto going mainstream is a reason to get out. Look at what happened to facebook. Everyone's mom, grandpa and, great grandma is on it and it's still growing.