23 ms·
Out of all major energy sources, nuclear is the safest
- FussyZeus 9y agoThe brain is not designed to understand statistics. Nuclear accidents are theatrical and fun, and therefore get a lot of play on the media when they happen. Look no further than the media circus surrounding Fukushima to confirm. Everybody is scared to death of Sharks, yet sharks killed only 1 person in the US last year. Cows killed 20, 75% of which were deliberate attacks, but almost no one is afraid of a Cow. Meanwhile 17,775 people died in traffic accidents, yet people jump in cars like it's routine. You're literally 17,000% more likely to die in your own car than you are by a shark, but again, brains don't understand that.
- uoaei 9y agoPeople and their egos crave control. With something like driving, you feel at least somewhat in control of your own destiny. Coming face to face with a shark does not afford the same sense, same with an unstoppable chain reaction occurring deep in a nuclear reactor and the ensuing fallout.
- mamon 9y agoPlus, our reptile brains has deeply ingrained fear of wild animals, cars are too new invention to be able to affect our instinct the same way sharks do.
- FussyZeus 9y agoYou're correct, but there's only been a few failures like that in the entire history of Nuclear energy, one of which was a ridiculous test far beyond the scope of logic and reason (Chernobyl), one of which was a completely safe and designed failure that killed no one and did nearly nothing in terms of actual damage (3 Mile Island) and one that was the result of a plant being hit in the exact wrong spot by a natural event that it had not been designed to withstand in the first place, and despite that, still failed in a largely predictable and contained way. And not to mention, the much wider used coal plants and natural gas plants kill way more people in a lot less theatrical ways, largely through disease of the lungs and skin. Again though watching someone die of black lung isn't nearly as interesting as watching someone die of radiation sickness, so we don't hear about it.
- tathougies 9y ago1,700,000% more likely actually :)
- FussyZeus 9y agoI can't math good apparently, heh.
- sdy 9y agoYou may be on to something. Have we checked how far North Korea is able to launch sharks and cars? /s I think nuclear can't be compared to cars and sharks.
- EADGBE 9y agoI really think you're just spitting out numbers. Where are you getting these numbers? Particularly the cow one (deliberate killings only). Generally intrigued. > yet people jump in cars like it's routine. It is routine. Time spent driving is much, much, much higher than time spent swimming near sharks. So... My brain understands that if I refused to go skydiving, then I can not die from a skydiving accident. Which is about as likely as going for a swim instead of a drive to get to work.
- EADGBE 9y agoShark attacks in the US. Having a hard time finding anything recent, even to average out to one death every other year. http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2005/06/0613_050613_sharkfacts.html http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2005/06/0613_050613_... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_fatal,_unprovoked_shark_attacks_in_the_United_States#2010s https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_fatal,_unprovoked_shar... Also, closer to 30k+ traffic fatalities (last reported year is 2015, so far it seems) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_motor_vehicle_deaths_in_U.S._by_year https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_motor_vehicle_deaths_i... Still can't find cow numbers.
- yellowapple 9y agoABC has an article about the killer cows (which cites data from the CDC, though I've yet to find the data): http://abcnews.go.com/Health/shark-versus-cow-deadlier/story?id=24931705 http://abcnews.go.com/Health/shark-versus-cow-deadlier/story... British cows are apparently similarly deadly: http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/cows-officially-the-most-deadly-large-animals-in-britain-a6727266.html http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/cows-official...
- EADGBE 9y agoThanks for pointing this out. Whoa, now I'm very concerned about snails.
- maxerickson 9y agoSchistosomiasis is largely a disease of poverty. When drugs and treated water are available, it is easily controlled.
- pierrebai 9y agoI've encountered thousands of cars today. I've yet to encounter a single shark in decades. I'd expect very high danger in the presence of a shark. I've not yet been injured by all the cars I've seen in my life. People understanding of stats is fine. They understand that the pre-requisite to being attacked by a shark is super-extremely low. That does not make sharks safe. I'll put my hand on the hood of a car any day instead of on a shark. Your reasoning about Fukushima shows the same kind of problem: it's because of all the urgent actions after the accident that there's not been more consequences. Your argument would show that a house on fire is not dangerous because after people were evacuated, no one died of burning. It's the evacualtion of of a fire that saves life, it's not the lack of danger of a blazing inferno.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoOh I love that analogy, I thought I would figure out where it came from. Most people reference the times story [1] which talks about 20 cows a year, however that story references a CDC study [2] which talks about 21 cows over 5 years. Which makes it actually about 4 people a year (average) being killed by cows. Which is still more than death by Sharks at about 1 every other year on average according to [3]. [1] "The image of cows as placid, gentle creatures is a city slicker’s fantasy, judging from an article published on Friday by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, which reports that about 20 people a year are killed by cows in the United States." -- https://tierneylab.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/07/31/dangerous-cows/ https://tierneylab.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/07/31/dangerous-co... [2] "A total of 21 deaths met the case definition for 2003--2008 (Table 1). Four fatalities occurred in 2003, two in 2004, six in 2005, and three each year during 2006--2008." -- https://www.cdc.gov/mmWR/preview/mmwrhtml/mm5829a2.htm https://www.cdc.gov/mmWR/preview/mmwrhtml/mm5829a2.htm [3] https://www.floridamuseum.ufl.edu/fish/isaf/contributing-factors/species-implicated-attacks https://www.floridamuseum.ufl.edu/fish/isaf/contributing-fac...
- Qwertious 9y agoOn the other hand, IIRC nuclear has a reverse bell curve, where it's most dangerous at the very start and end of its' lifetime. And if you take nuclear plants that are not quite at the end of their lifetime, then average the deaths over their last 40 years, and compare that average to solar (the majority of which are 3 years old or less - at the start of their lifetime), then you can make nuclear appear an order of magnitude safer than they actually are. People don't handle statistics well, but statistics are also easily manipulated and therefore potentially completely unreliable (Mark Twain quote here). It's not quite as simple as "people need to listen to the statistics". Also, people go to the beach way less often than they go near roads. If most people only go to the beach 1 day a year and go on roads every day, then it's more like "you're 50x more likely to die by car than by shark". That's a far cry from 17000x. That said, I've always thought that stat could be abused to push car safety - "Imagine you're attacked by a shark - now, cars are like that but TIMES FIFTY! Drive safe, look both ways, etc".
- melling 9y agoStrange, there have been lots of discussions about nuclear on HN and a lot of people here don't like it. e.g. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13234463 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13234463
- pavel_lishin 9y agoAccording to the headline, that's to be expected.
- known 9y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Signal_to_noise_ratio https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Signal_to_noise_ratio is very high
- abritinthebay 9y agoThis has been known for a long time in informed circles. The problems with nuclear are waste and that we use vastly outdated designs and fuel sources. Nuclear is not perfect, but we should not buy into a perfection fallacy when looking to get away from fossil fuels. Solar is a better long term bet but a good progressive nuclear strategy that added a handful of small modern reactors could be massively complementary to it.
- Fej 9y agoWaste is a miniscule problem. Put it in the ground. Or, perhaps, in the side of a mountain... The only reason waste is an issue in the United States is that the Congress decided that nuclear waste repositories have to last for 10,000 years uninterrupted. As far as we know this is just about impossible. 10 millenia ago we were in the caves. Placed at the bottom of a pool, it's perfectly safe. This is a solved problem. The issue is political (especially from uneducated NIMBYs) rather than technical. https://what-if.xkcd.com/29/ https://what-if.xkcd.com/29/
- zuzun 9y agoWhat a flawed comparison. Take the water from the pool and drink it and give it your livestock to drink and water your plants with it and see how that works out over the span of a few decades.
- have_faith 9y agoIs it the safest when projecting for increased usage? While also taking into account modern threat vectors to a nuclear plant? I have no idea, just thinking out loud.
- anorphirith 9y agothe only problem is where to get the uranium, I believe russia gets it from kazakhstan. france from niger. does US buys it from kazakhstan as well ?
- scottLobster 9y ago"In 2011 the United States mined 9% of the uranium consumed by its nuclear power plants.[7] The remainder was imported, principally from Russia and Kazakhstan (38%), Canada, and Australia.[8][9][10] Although uranium production has declined to low levels, the United States has the fourth-largest uranium resource in the world, behind Australia, Canada, and Kazakhstan.[9]" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uranium_mining_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uranium_mining_in_the_United_S...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- pj_mukh 9y agoFriendly neighbours to the north[1]. We don't like tooting our horn enough, but America gets the bulk of its energy raw materials from us.[2] [1]https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=2150 https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=2150 [2]https://www.eia.gov/tools/faqs/faq.php?id=727&t=6 https://www.eia.gov/tools/faqs/faq.php?id=727&t=6
- jussij 9y agoAustralia has plenty of Uranium.
- dubcanada 9y agoAustrilia is #1 by reserves, Kazakhstan is #2 and Canada is #3. US as of 2012 buys about 25% of it from Canada and the rest from a variety of places. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_power_in_the_United_States#/media/File:US_Uranium_Imports_2012.png https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_power_in_the_United_St... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_uranium_reserves https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_uranium_r...
- jcranmer 9y ago
- tinco 9y agoAll the energy sources in this article except for nuclear are horrible for our environment and for our health. The important question is what do we replace them with. And if that is the important question, what good is this article if it shows only one solution, explicitly not comparing it with the other solutions?
- beders 9y agoChernobyl: 56 direct deaths, estimated 4000 killed by cancer caused by it, economic damage: $235b Radiation of the disaster still detectable all over Europe. Fukushima: 6 dead, estimate of 1600 more people killed indirectly, economic damage so far: between $10b and $100b Radiation detectable on California beaches. No solution for the radioactive waste (other than dumping it into the pacific where it can mingle with the Great Pacific Garbage patch) FUCK energy sources that are capable of doing that. FUCK these opinion pieces.
- xg15 9y agoCan anyone explain to me why "deaths/tWh" is even a meaningful measure? Of course nuclear energy has one of the highest Wh outputs, no-one is disputing that. However, what does that have to do with the risk of use? That seems like a measure very skewed to make arguments in favour of nuclear power. I might as well argue that car drivers are safer than pedestrians because the average deaths/horse power is vastly lower. Also, why did they leave away hydro, water and wind power in those "deaths per x" charts?
- simias 9y agoWell because in the end the amount of power is what matters? I'm not sure I understand your point. If you replace nuclear with renewable (or the other way around) you'll have to produce the same amount of power, all other things being equal.
- xg15 9y agoYes, however this assumes that number of deaths of any technology would linearly scale with its energy output. e.g. if I built n times more wind turbines to match the energy output of nuclear energy then, according to this measure, I would also get n times the number of wind-power-related deaths. I see no basis for that assumption, especially as nuclear energy has known risks that e.g. wind power doesn't.
- saagarjha 9y ago> I see no basis for that assumption, especially as nuclear energy has known risks that e.g. wind power doesn't. But why do the risks matter? One would expect that two turbines or nuclear power plants would kill twice as many people, on average…
- DangerousPie 9y agoWhy do you think it's not meaningful? What would be the alternative?
- 9y ago
- payne92 9y agoI believe the politicization of nuclear energy (the resulting lack of investment & innovation) will go down as one of the major blunders in human history. We'd be in a far, far better situation with greenhouse gasses if we (as a human race) had continued to invest in nuclear energy. There would have been mishaps along the way, but at a much smaller scale than we're experiencing now with deaths from air pollution and looming risk of a warming planet. We'd have much, much safer systems with modern reactor designs.
- dimillian 9y agoWell, they tried that in the Fallout universe, everything was running on nuclear power... it didn't ended well ;)
- QAPereo 9y ago>I believe the politicization of nuclear energy (the resulting lack of investment & innovation) will go down as one of the major blunders in human history. It's more or less ensured that we won't be in any shape to record histories sooner rather than later.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- lispm 9y agoNuclear energy was politicized from day minus one. It was developed out of government driven military technology. In day zero nuclear energy was set up by politicians: goals, strategies, financing, deployment, risk handling, etc. Everything was coming from energy politics. Investments were directed and the market®ulations for nuclear were set up. Government largely financed it and insures it. The large scale, the monopolistic businesses and the government centric energy politics made it ideal for corruption. Remember, Fukushima was claimed to be fully save after inspections, just before the accident happened, which destroyed several reactors. The investment into nuclear energy was a political decision. Every further investment into nuclear is a political decision. The 'small modern reactors' are mostly funded by government and the users are mostly military. The military is already mostly the only user of small reactors: nuclear powered ships and submarines. Now we see other players which favor other energy politics (like the current US President who favors fossil fuels like coal, because his voters want jobs in the coal industry). The point is: energy is always politics.
- cjsuk 9y agoApart from the waste. We really don't know what to do about it other than bury it and leave it for a few tens to hundreds of generations in the future to deal with with the hope that they will know what to do. So it's the safest option. But only for now. We might just be dooming our descendants to deal with the mess and they might be in a worse state than we are now.
- c3534l 9y agoWe found it in the ground, we're just putting it back in the ground when we're done with it.
- simias 9y agoNot in the same state and not in the same concentration. I'm not anti-nuclear in the least but let's not spread disinformation (or "fake news" in modern parlance).
- canadianwriter 9y agoThat's why a lot of people see it as the lesser evil and a good stop gap before we move to 100% renewable.
- gaius 9y agoWe really don't know what to do about it Another myth. Of course we do: breeder reactors. Hint: why is nuclear waste dangerous? because there is still loads of energy in it.
- swerner 9y agoAnd then we put the breeder reactors into abandoned mines. Breeders aren't the solution, they have waste products too, and those waste products are also radioactive.
- sliverstorm 9y agoThe good news is breeder waste is a mix of very short half lives and very long half lives. The very short ones decay to safe levels quickly, and the very long ones have a low level of activity.
- beders 9y agoAh, nuclear fans downvoting again. Can't stomach simple facts. Chernobyl: 56 direct deaths, estimated 4000 killed by cancer caused by it, economic damage: $235b Radiation of the disaster still detectable all over Europe. Fukushima: 6 dead, estimate of 1600 more people killed indirectly, economic damage so far: between $10b and $100b Radiation detectable on California beaches. No solution for the radioactive waste (other than dumping it into the pacific where it can mingle with the Great Pacific Garbage patch)
- DrNuke 9y agoYCombinator was investing in nuclear energy recently, so an update may be nice here, both at short and medium term level. Thanks in advance.
- pbreit 9y agoI have not skimmed but didn't see wind, solar or hydro?
- jlebrech 9y agopopular belief is full of people below average intelligence
- jlebrech 9y agowhat about thorium https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c7baTdyHv8g https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c7baTdyHv8g
- inputcoffee 9y agoTwo important points: 1. What about wind and solar? 2. The death/unit energy misses out the fact that we spend a lot more to keep nuclear safe because we are worried about it. If we spent a fraction of the same amount on other energy, we might get similar safety results.
- windlep 9y agoIndeed, it also fails to mention hydroelectric. Nor is there any mention of how much it costs per TW/h, especially when you factor in the insane cost from just a single accident or the fact that the waste has to be safely and securely stored for a very long time.
- vhost- 9y ago> 2. The death/unit energy misses out the fact that we spend a lot more to keep nuclear safe because we are worried about it. If we spent a fraction of the same amount on other energy, we might get similar safety results. this seems extremely hard to quantify.
- m0skit0 9y agoHydroelectric depends too much on orography. Not all countries have waterfalls, and if they have, they could be in inaccessible regions where it is very costly to build, let alone transport.
- anotherbrownguy 9y agoIsn't nuclear hysteria created mostly by American CleanTech industry? Solar is not a reliable source to begin with so you can't use it to power anything critical. It has to be combined with something like nuclear or fossil fuels to have reliable power. But if we go nuclear, we will have 1000s of years worth of power. So, where exactly does Solar fit in?
- yellowapple 9y agoSolar doesn't have to be reliable; it just has to charge a battery (or some other means of energy storage) which is reliable. Also worth mentioning (at the risk of being very pedantic) that solar is technically nuclear power.
- 0xffff2 9y ago>Also worth mentioning (at the risk of being very pedantic) that solar is technically nuclear power. At the risk of being even more pedantic, solar is fusion power, whereas "nuclear" in the common parlance refers specifically to fission.
- merpnderp 9y agoA very expensive battery made from a material we likely don't have enough of to scale for the world.
- yellowapple 9y agoEven that's not necessarily true; your run-of-the-mill lead-acid car battery works fine for this at small scales, and a collection of them can be good enough for household-wide use. Not the most environmentally-friendly option, but such batteries are cheap and abundant. You're right that at large scales (neighborhood-wide, city-wide, nation-wide, etc.) we don't really have the battery infrastructure in place quite yet. I'd guess that said lack of infrastructure could be resolved well before 2025, though.
- michaelsbradley 9y ago
- jesus92gz-spain 9y agoHow can nuclear (fision) energy be safer than wind/solar/hydro? New efficient solar cells should be enough, environment friendly, and safer than other alternatives as long as the manufacturing of these are environment friendly as well. Also, everyone can setup their own solar plant at home, I almost did so, but the price of the materials and the setup are too high for me. I'd like you to consider if nuclear material is useful for something apart from generating energy. It may be useful for other things we don't even know right now, and in the future we may have consumed all the resources.
- tboughen 9y agoI believe it us due to the installation deaths. Typically solar cells are installed on rooftops, which are non-trivially dangerous places to work. Multiply the risk by tens of thousands of installations and we get fatalities due to solar power.
- jesus92gz-spain 9y agoYou serious? And building an hydroelectric/atomic/coal plant is not dangerous? It's not a too dangerous place, when the people who set these up are professionals who are following a security guideline. I see lots of people working on their roof, so, at least for me, this is a nonsense argument to discredit solar energy.
- ZeroGravitas 9y agoThe number should fall as solar becomes something that you add when a roof is constructed, rather than retro-fitted, since that roof work is already being done.
- mikeash 9y agoYou have to look at statistics, not just declare that installers are professionals so it's nonsense. Yes, building power plants is dangerous too. The question is, how do they compare? Wikipedia has some stats: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_accidents#Fatalities https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_accidents#Fatalities Rooftop solar is vastly better than anything fossil fuels, but worse than nuclear, wind, and first-world hydropower.
- simias 9y agoPeople are scared of nuclear energy for the same reason that they're scared of taking an airplane. Even though it's technically and statistically very safe, the perceived risk appears much greater. In particular in both cases when something goes wrong it tends to go extremely wrong and you're completely helpless to stop it. In contrast getting in a car accident or slowly suffocating in coal power plant emissions seem manageable. Personally I'm of the opinion that going all nuclear would be a mistake but on the other hand it's a great way to move away from coal and petrol while we're still figuring out how to scale renewable energies (and maybe fusion, but that's still a moonshot). It provides cheap, reliable and reasonably safe energy with very little CO2 emissions. I'm more worried about global warming than Fukushima and I'd gladly trade even a dozen of Fukushima-type incidents in the next decades (highly unlikely) if it could stop global warming and its dire, hard-to-revert consequences. In particular I genuinely do not understand why most ecologists seem to be staunchly anti-nuclear. I can understand asking for better funding in renewable R&D and planning for a transition but, at least in Europe, ecologists seem to favor dropping nuclear immediately, no matter the cost. For instance they applauded when Germany decided to completely stop producing nuclear energy, even if it meant more pollution in the short term. I find that hard to justify.
- Koromix 9y ago> People are scared of nuclear energy for the same reason that they're scared of taking an airplane. Even though it's technically and statistically very safe, the perceived risk appears much greater. [...] I'm more worried about global warming than Fukushima and I'd gladly trade even a dozen of Fukushima-type incidents in the next decades (highly unlikely) if it could stop global warming and its dire, hard-to-revert consequences. I could not agree more, but unfortunately global warming suffers from the exact opposite effect. The perceived risk appears very low to most people, because it is not very spectacular on human time scales. Even though it is by far the greatest existential risk we face.
- jsonne 9y agoI'm no biologist or scientist of any sort, but it seems this is a problem with all apex predators to some degree. You get to the top of the food chain by adapting to and being highly reactive to short term and catastrophic risk. Once you get there you have to do a 180 and suddenly be highly attuned to subtle and long term issues to stay there. It's simply a different skill set and frame of mind.
- eloff 9y agoMy understanding, which is admittedly drawn from HN "napkin math" , is that at current prices for solar and wind, nuclear is a non-starter. That trend is only intensifying. It seems to me that nuclear could have been a good option, but because we've neglected it for so long, squashed innovation with regulations (not necessarily complaining that it didn't need the regulations!) it is uncompetitive economically and will likely stay that way for the near future. Amazingly enough even coal is uncompetitive in many parts of the world now too. The future is starting to turn green under the invisible hand of market economics.
- itsthecourier 9y agoin my opinion, the problem with nuclear is the consequences of fuck-ups. if you fuck up with solar, wind, coal or oil, shit can get wrong. like oil spill in Mexico coast wrong, but manageable. Chernobyl and Fukushima's fuck-up is still to this day not completely resolved. Let's focus in solar/wind for our peace's sake
- bradleyjg 9y agoEven leaving aside the question of how much insurance should be required and how to underwrite that, as well as what kind of reserve should be mandated for cleanup and long term waste storage, the economics of nuclear are very rough. The lion's share of the costs are upfront and the break even period is measured in decades. What is the energy landscape going to look like in 30 years? That's a question that you need to be able to answer with high confidence if you want to correctly price bonds that will be used to construct a nuclear power plant to be paid off from the revenue of the plant. If the potential bond buyers can't answer that question with high confidence then they don't know what interest rate is appropriate for the bonds and they probably won't want to buy them.
- martinald 9y agoSolar and wind has a lot of 'negative externalities' though that are generally borne by the grid or other operators. I think the economics really work against it at high% penetration (30-40%+). The problem is that solar and wind requires backup generation, usually CCGT natural gas. This is ok until you scale higher and higher. You end up having CCGT only producing 20-40% of the time (to fill in for wind and solar blips). This massively increases the capex of CCGT plants, as you're only producing rarely. This would get more and more extreme with more solar+wind penetration. Another massive problem is solar+wind overproduction, which is really hard to solve and is starting to really hit the German, UK and California grids. On very sunny AND windy days you get massive energy overproduction. You then have to either: a) Turn off solar+wind remotely (often very expensive to retrofit to existing installations as the Germans found out) b) Pay other (natgas, coal, nuclear, etc) operators to shut down, which can be very expensive c) Hope that negative electricity prices make more demand. This is unlikely to happen as industrial users can't switch on extra production quick enough to respond to this. This is made worse by feed in tariffs being paid at any energy price, incentivizing solar+wind to continue generating even if electricity price is negative (say it is -€0.05kWh spot, but your FIT is €0.20/kWh, you are still going to produce as you will net 0.15euro per kWh. The two 'solutions' which are often mentioned are battery storage and HVDC long distance transmission. Battery storage is still horrendously expensive on a kWh basis. It may come down, but this is an enormous problem. I am personally not sure there is enough lithium left that is easily extracted to make this viable at the scale (billions of kWh) required. HVDC connections I also am suspicious of - if it's sunny and windy in Germany, it is likely to also be the same 1000km away more or less.
- 1337biz 9y agoLogical arguments do not apply in that scenario. Other energy forms might kill people a slow, invisible death. But when a nuclear reactor melts down the pictures of death and drama will go around the world.
- itsthecourier 9y agoIn my opinion, the problem with nuclear is the consequences of fuck-ups. if you fuck up with solar, wind, coal or oil, shit can get wrong. like oil spill in Mexico coast wrong, but manageable. Chernobyl and Fukushima's fuck-up is still to this day not completely resolved. Let's focus in solar/wind for our peace's sake
- hristov 9y agoYou have to be very careful about these studies, because most official government studies flat out lie about the effects of nuclear disasters. The most egregious example is Chernobyl, where the official Soviet position was that only a single person died from the disaster. But studies from other nations say the death toll may be close to one million. Well believe it or not a lot of these studies that show how safe nuclear is actually take the official Soviet data about chernobyl as truth. (I am not sure whether this is the case for this particular study because their source is behind a paywall). But similar (if not as outrageous) lies have also been said about accidents in the west. The official story about three mile island for example is that it caused no deaths, yet studies find drastic increases of all kinds of cancers in the affected area. See, for example, https://www.counterpunch.org/2015/03/27/cancer-and-infant-mortality-at-three-mile-island/ https://www.counterpunch.org/2015/03/27/cancer-and-infant-mo... I usually believe that we should be guided by science and data in our public decisions, but the data surrounding nuclear is so distorted by governments that it is just not to be trusted. And now that we have truly safe alternatives like solar and wind, we can finally put that nightmare behind us.
- mpweiher 9y ago> You have to be very careful about these studies Yes you do. The WHO has been following the Chernobyl consequences, and come out with a new report about every decade. Each report dramatically lowers the estimate of deaths and other health consequences. As a matter of fact, the largest health effects now are psychosocial effects. That is, fear of and (over-)reaction to the radiation effects is causing more actual harm than the radiation itself. So potentially one of the easiest ways to mitigate the harmful effects of nuclear accidents (best of course: let's not have any!) is to (over-)react less. Of course not reacting at all would also be wrong, but it looks like the balance today is out of whack.
- padseeker 9y agoThis is the year 2017 - This article deliberately skips over any consideration to Wind, Solar, etc. What kind of BULLSHIT excuse for journalism and scientific study is this? Who in the nuclear industry paid for this? I only read the first 3 paragraphs but I can already tell you this article is not worth your time. The article compares the statistics of energy sources, but all of the charts focus on fossil fuels. This article starts off giving lip service by offhand mentioning renewable sources in one sentence. "While the negative health impacts of modern renewable energy technologies are so far thought to be small, they have been less fully explored." Maybe in the short term nuclear does kill fewer people, in the short term compared to recent history. If nuclear plants are maintained safely - thats a pretty big if - and no other disasters befall a plant, maybe there current status is true. One of the many things I have learned while working in technology is Risk Assessments. If an upgrade or change has a low chance of failure but a high potential for damage then you need to be very careful and cautious. Nuclear Power strikes me as having a small chance of risk of failure but the potential damage of that failure is catastrophic. There are only 3 nuclear power mishaps I know of - 3 Mile Island, Chernobyl and Fukushima. I guess 3 Mile wasn't too bad, but the other 2 had epic consequences. That's not even considering the waste issue. Or a dirty bomb.
- nextos 9y agoTaleb would say all this statistics are bullshit, cause they ignore the long tails. I doubt a gas or coal power station can destroy a nation. A nuclear plant has the potential to do so.
- padseeker 9y agoThat is an excellent comment. The downvotes are already coming in, your comment was grayed out (downvoted) by the time I saw it. No substantive responses yet, just anonymous click revenge. :(
- philippnagel 9y agoIt would be interesting to hear his actual opinion on this topic.
- 9y ago
- _Codemonkeyism 9y agoMost relevant sentence from article "Here we limit our comparison to the dominant energy sources—brown coal, coal, oil, gas, biomass and nuclear energy;"
- the_gastropod 9y agoIt appears that these figures take into account _just_ energy production. They don't seem include the mining, enriching, construction of reactors, disposal of waste, decommissioning reactors, etc. When mining low-grade ore (which isn't uncommon, and is becoming more command as high-grade ore becomes more scarce), nuclear plants are as inefficient as coal-fired plants [1]. Nuclear advocates tend to ignore the full system, and focus on where nuclear shines: power production. The setup to get to that point is extremely costly. [1] https://www.stormsmith.nl/i05.html https://www.stormsmith.nl/i05.html
- mikeash 9y agoWhat are the sources of CO2 for mining and all the rest? If it's electricity production then you're basically blaming nuclear for emissions from fossil fuel generation, since those would be much lower in an all-nuclear world. If it's transport then it's more justified, but when looking at how it could be in the future, transport can be electrified to close that loop.
- datenwolf 9y agoIt's mostly due to the chemistry required to liberate the Uranium from the ore. What you have in the ore is mostly Uranium oxides. You have to strip away those pesky oxygen atoms in order to further process the Uranium. And in that process quite the amount of CO2 is produced. Now keep in mind that this must be done to all the Uranium, before it undergoes enrichtment. So for every atom of U235 you get about 200 (give or take) atoms of U238 and you have to account for all of them on the chemical side of things. It's not that much better with Throrium either.
- CydeWeys 9y agoThanks for the info. It's seeming that solar and wind are better from a full-lifecycle perspective, and if we can just solve that pesky energy storage issue then it's done. Nuclear is oddly politicized, both pro- and anti-, whereas I think the truth is somewhere in the middle. It's not the worst power source but it's also not the best. It's not worth continuing to invest in for the future because better sources are already coming online that don't have the associated fallout risk, hazardous materials disposal issue, and intensive mining/refining processes.
- pinaceae 9y agoFunny humans care about their children. Nothing is scarier than birth-defects. Radiation causes very visible birth defects. Hence people are very, very scared of radiation. And rightly so. A windpark will not cause disfigured babies. Hence wind is better. And: Nuclear is the most expensive energy source, by FAR. safety, waste, clean-up - super, super expensive. dismantle a wind park and it is gone, poof. dismantle a reactor and now you have a new problem. Also very hard to weaponize wind or solar. Blow up a wind park and well, the wind park is gone. Steal a rotor and now you have a rotor. etc etc etc. What is sooo hard to understand about this?
- PeterStuer 9y agoThere is one huge problem with nuclear energy. Humanity has time and time again proven they can not handle that kind of responsibility.
- cratermoon 9y agoTwo words: Hanford Site
- libeclipse 9y agoIf course it is, but the bullshit propaganda, scare-tactics, and political policies like that of the Green party in the UK have led the world to shun one of our best chances.
- a_imho 9y agoI wonder how much nuclear suffers from PR. Clearly statistics are not really effective at changing opinions. But what would happen if popular Elon Musk/Steve Jobs type of public figure get into the lobby game with a nuclear company? Could that swing perception either way?
- dfox 9y agoIt suffers a lot from bad PR since the start. In public view, nuclear anything is usually related to atomic bomb and mushroom clouds and such stuff, although most reactor designs are inherently incapable of sustaining uncontrolled supercritical fission (excluding for example Chernobyl's RBMK).
- unabst 9y agoThe public's nuclear acceptance is not about day to day death toll. It's about broken promises and Armageddon. Looking at the chart, I'd take gas over nuclear in a heartbeat thinking of what nuclear has done to Japan. Nuclear can both power and destroy a country. Gas and other options do not. Neither does solar or wind which are not even in that chart. Say we have a new technology that is safer than nuclear, but had a one in a million chance to destroy Earth. It would be safest on paper, for however long paper and researchers still existed. "But Fukushima was a horrible place for a nuclear power plant and it was run by incompetent people," you say. But that's exactly the point. If we make a list of all the plants in the world and the safety measures they undermined and their staffing situation, how many would be stellar? How many would even admit anything?
- mikeash 9y agoNatural gas kills 4,000 people per PWh generated. Fukushima killed zero immediately, and might kill 100-200 eventually through increased cancer incidences. Fukushima made a few hundred square kilometers briefly unsafe, and some tens of square kilometers temporarily uninhabitable. (Or really, inhabitable but slightly unhealthy.) Fossil fuels are wrecking the entire planet. It's interesting that Fukushima seems to be all people remember about the Tohoku earthquake. 16,000 people died (for comparison the worst natural disaster in the US, the 1900 Galveston hurricane, killed 6,000-12,000), hundreds of thousands were displaced, and many towns were destroyed, but nobody remembers that. A dam failure triggered by the earthquake killed 12 people but nobody uses this to argue against dams.
- beders 9y agobriefly unsafe What crack are you smoking? How about you move to Chernobyl and check in with the local population. Oh, that's right. No one can live there anymore....
- mikeash 9y agoA good chunk of the area evacuated for Fukushima was later cleared and the residents allowed to return. See here: http://fukushimaontheglobe.com/wp-content/uploads/Evacuation-zone-03102017.pdf http://fukushimaontheglobe.com/wp-content/uploads/Evacuation... I guess understanding the situation means I'm smoking crack?
- ebbv 9y agoOh great another pro-nuclear article that focuses on deaths and ignores the long term costs of spent nuclear fuel and the damage that inevitably happens in disasters like Fukushima. Before Fukushima the story was the same as this "Nuclear is the safest! Nuclear is the best! Problems of the past are gone!" Then Fukushima happens and the nuclear industry continues its same message. Give me a break. Solar and wind are obviously better for the environment, and the way of the future. Fortunately most of the world already knows this.
- merpnderp 9y agoHow many people have died from the Fukushima accident? How many people died mining coal for your local power plant? And solar and wind need nearly as much power generating capacity in natgas plants (or in Germany, dirty coal plants), driving up costs and even more deaths through fossil fuel mining.
- jdeibele 9y agoWhen they use .00 on all the figures it calls into question everything else about the article.
- skndr 9y agoWith a potential reduction in the Department of Energy's budget, this might not hold. There may not be enough funding to properly dispose of the waste. Not to mention that some of the effects of past storage aren't well-catalogued [0]: Three years ago the D.O.E. sent the local tribes a letter to say they shouldn’t eat the fish they caught in the river more than once a week. [...] Hanford turns out to be a good example of an American impulse: to avoid knowledge that conflicts with whatever your narrow, short-term interests might be. What we know about Hanford we know mainly from whistle-blowers who worked inside the nuclear facility—and who have been ostracized by their community for threatening the industry in a one-industry town. (“Resistance to understanding a threat grows with proximity,” writes Brown.) One hundred and forty-nine of the tanks in the Hanford farms are made of a single shell of a steel ill-designed to contain highly acidic nuclear waste. Sixty-seven of them have failed in some way and allowed waste or vapors to seep out. Each tank contains its own particular stew of chemicals, so no two tanks can be managed in the same way. At the top of many tanks accumulates a hydrogen gas, which, if not vented, might cause the tank to explode. “There are Fukushima-level events that could happen at any moment,” says Carpenter. “You’d be releasing millions of curies of strontium 90 and cesium. And once it’s out there it doesn’t go away—not for hundreds and hundreds of years.” The people who created the plutonium for the first bombs, in the 1940s and early 1950s, were understandably in too much of a rush to worry about what might happen afterward. They simply dumped 120 million gallons of high-level waste, and another 444 billion gallons of contaminated liquid, into the ground. They piled uranium (half-life: 4.5 billion years) into unlined pits near the Columbia River. They dug 42 miles of trenches to dispose of solid radioactive waste—and left no good records of what’s in the trenches. In early May of this year a tunnel at Hanford, built in the 1950s to bury low-level waste, collapsed. In response, the workers dumped truckloads of dirt into the hole. That dirt is now classified as low-level radioactive waste and needs to be disposed of. “The reason the Hanford cleanup sucks—in a word—is shortcuts,” said Carpenter. “Too many goddamn shortcuts.” [0] http://www.vanityfair.com/news/2017/07/department-of-energy-risks-michael-lewis http://www.vanityfair.com/news/2017/07/department-of-energy-...
- SubiculumCode 9y agoWhile the threats from coal and gas are regularly distributed through time (near constant rate of pollutants) the threat from nuclear energy are sporadic (ie meltdown, terror) and are thus harder to model and assess. Also agree with others that wind and solar are being discounted unfairly despite their growth factors.
- kaikai 9y agoNo one seems to think disposing of nuclear waste is a problem until someone tries to dispose of it in their backyard.
- kzrdude 9y agoAt the same time, it wasn't predicted that solar power would be this viable, was it?
- ZeroGravitas 9y agoI've seen claims that the price decline has been predicted since the 1970s, since almost all products get better when built at scale and that Germany and China have both put government action into place based on these long term trends. Combined with carbon tax type modelling of coal's emmissions which would massivel raise it's cost if accounted for, I'm not sure it's that unexpected.
- shams93 9y agoWind works so well in places like Santa Monica the utilities were able to make it illegal to use wind power for your home. Fortunately they were not able to do the same to solar. We have home owners in california generating more energy than they use with their home solar panels, like my parents they generate more than they use even at the height of the summer.
- burnbabyburn 9y agodon't worry about waste, you could bring that here in italy, for little money.
- padseeker 9y agoPlease retitle the article to as follows; "It goes completely against what most believe, but EXCEPT FOR SOLAR AND WIND AND OTHER RENEWABLE RESOURCES BECAUSE WE COULD NOT BE BOTHERED out of all major energy sources, nuclear is the safest" This is the real title of this article. And if it was, then it would not be #1 top of the list on Hacker News.
- internalfx 9y agoCan anyone comment on if the LFTR is legit? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uK367T7h6ZY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uK367T7h6ZY
- wbl 9y agoIt isn't. Molten salt is highly corrosive.
- marcoperaza 9y agoWe don't have to choose between energy abundance and good stewardship of the environment. Why do green activists and a majority of Western governments want us to? Attempts to force Western countries to cut emissions, without a corresponding transition to nuclear power, are unacceptable and represent a wealth transfer from rich countries to poor countries.
- lootsauce 9y agoThis report seems to discount the tail risks involved with potential future nuclear accidents. Lets ignore the very complicated question of risk tradeoffs vs other sources for the moment. Nuclear power has extreme tail risk that is hard to quantify based on the few examples of it happening. For the thee major events we can reference how do we know we didn't simply get lucky? With fukushima for example, "Japan's prime minister at the time of the 2011 earthquake and tsunami has revealed that the country came within a “paper-thin margin” of a nuclear disaster requiring the evacuation of 50 million people." [1] Clearly the lack of deaths directly attributable to nuclear accidents does not accurately capture the risks. So what exactly is the risk of a catastrophic event that has thankfully never happened but could? Its not clear but rather than rolling dice with those risks we can actually make better systems without those unquantifiable risks in the first place. That takes us to the tradeoff calculus. Just in the realm of nuclear power there are far better approaches we should be investing in as opposed to traditional plants such as LFTR [2] which does not have proliferation, waste or meltdown risk. Picking on coal is a little unfair at this time because coal is being supplanted by much cleaner natural gas purely on market forces and solar and wind are growing dramatically. Of course there are issues with these as well, scaling issues and their own kind of impacts but they do not harbor the same kind of unquantifiable massive tail risk of traditional nuclear. [1] http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/asia/japan/12184114/Fukushima-Tokyo-was-on-the-brink-of-nuclear-catastrophe-admits-former-prime-minister.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/asia/japan/1218411... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liquid_fluoride_thorium_reactor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liquid_fluoride_thorium_reacto...
- joaomacp 9y agoI don't have much knowledge of the issue, but couldn't it be that big investments in nuclear energy would propagate and facilitate the process of isotope separation for enriching Uranium, which would mean more countries having the technology to build nuclear weapons, and thus increase the risk of nuclear war, and ultimately human extinction? This stuff sounds scary to me, not the energy part
- Tomte 9y agoBefore Chernobyl blew up, nuclear energy proponents promised us, nuclear energy was safe. When Chernobyl blew up, it was obviously a stupid Soviet design, with stupid operating personnel. But now we've got new reactors, they are safe! Nothing could ever happen! Then Fukushima blew up. That was obviously okay, because it was a Tsunami in conjunction with a few other improbable acts, and we obviously can't expect the nuclear industry to plan for that! So we're now in the next round. Again, we're totally safe. We've got passive reactors. Really disruptive (g) tech! I'm sorry, I said it before and I said it again: proponents of nuclear energy have either been lying to us every single time over the last decades, or they can't really manage nuclear energy. I don't care which one it is, and I don't care whether they believe nuclear energy is safe now. They have been playing with catastrophes of a magnitude we can't really comprehend, and the best they manage to do is "it could have been even worse" and "we promise this was the last time". As far as I'm concerned, I'm all for making sure it was the last time.
- wbl 9y agoHow many people died in all of those? Now compare to the particulate pollution coal releases, which would force evacuation of neighborhoods if we treated them as nuclear plants. The US Navy has operated hundreds of reactors for decades 24/7.
- pps43 9y agoThe point is not how many people have died, but how bad the impact can be. Even if nobody dies, the need to evacuate a large city like New York or Tokyo because a nuclear power plant nearby underwent rapid unplanned deconstruction might easily wipe off all economic gains from the nuclear energy, and then some.
- scaryclam 9y agoAs opposed to...the entire planet being affected, like it is with fossil fuels?
- 9y ago
- bmcusick 9y agoCtrl+F "Solar", "Wind". No matches found. That's weird, huh? I'm all for a rational assessment of risk, but shouldn't they be on the list? Actually, I've seen such comparisons, and solar and wind do pretty well. They don't kill anyone from air pollution and global warming, but manufacturing and maintenance isn't risk-free. When you install things on roofs, sometimes people fall off. Most solar installation these days however are utility scale deployments in empty fields. It's pretty low risk, plus the same pollution and AGW benefits that nuclear benefits from. As an aside, I wonder if anyone has done the math on storing high-level nuclear waste on the Moon, now that a fully reusable SpaceX Falcon Heavy is almost here. That might be cheaper than the financial and political costs of places like Yucca Mountain.
- CydeWeys 9y agoI'd be surprised if the biggest source of injury from solar wasn't from installers falling off roofs. You can't count all of those injuries against solar itself, though, as roofing injuries will happen regardless, and putting up solar panels greatly extends the life of a roof, so the amortized total injury to installers doesn't go up as much.
- bmcusick 9y agoPlus with Tesla's solar roof, you might say that the additional risk of solar is zero, since it's (probably, I'm guessing) no more dangerous to install than any other roof.
- ricw 9y agoThe quoted statistics are interesting, but irrelevant when it comes to the actual use of nuclear. Furthermore, why are solar and wind energy missing from these stats? They account for 90% of new power in Europe in 2016 [1], and I'd assume similar for the major world economies. I'd like to know who funded this study. It screams of nuclear industry backing... For anyone still being in disbelief of nuclear being made obsolete: Why has not a single (!) private insurer been willing to fully insure a nuclear facility without government backing?! The reason is simple: the risk is too high, even for insurance companies worth billions. TLDR: nuclear has, as yet, not worked using private financing. [1] https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2017/feb/09/new-energy-europe-renewable-sources-2016 https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2017/feb/09/new-ener...
- CydeWeys 9y agoThe linked article just screams "last decade's energy mindset". Its conclusion may have been true then but it's certainly not true now in the age of cheap and widespread solar/wind.
- pmoriarty 9y agoThere needs to be more awareness of this. If nuclear power was so amazingly safe, private insurance companies should have no problems insuring it. But they won't.
- pps43 9y agoComparison is incomplete without taking into consideration BDBA (beyond design basis accidents). Probability of an accident worse than Chernobyl is low, but not zero. Multiply it by economic loss from large densely populated area becoming uninhabitable, and it can easily flip the conclusion.
- chicob 9y agoFission power's bad rep is bad for fusion power, the latter being way more safe in any respect. Anyway, although it is a serious issue, to this day no cities had to be evacuated permanently because of air pollution. Regretfully, nuclear energy has an aura of doom, and investment in nuclear power plants wrongfully reek of hubris. Even if it isn't a renewable source, fission power is one of our best allies in tackling CO2 emissions. At least it may buy us some time before fusion power and the dissemination of renewables.
- thinkcontext 9y agoI find this line of reasoning a little misleading. Looking at nuclear's safety record isn't entirely the correct measure, its that the potential consequences are so extreme. Consider Fukushima. In some ways Japan got lucky, it was entirely possible that an additional reactor on the site could have melted down and the holding pond could have breached. Because of this they were having to consider evacuating areas on the outskirts of Tokyo. Obviously, if that had happened we wouldn't even be having this conversation. I don't claim that we have considered the risks appropriately, have a sensible nuclear policy, or are considering nuclear correctly wrt climate change. But to claim nuclear is the safest because direct deaths to date are lower is not the full story.
- m0skit0 9y agoGot lucky? I think the opposite: Chernobyl was unlucky. I mean, you're basically calling all these nuclear incidents "lucky". That doesn't statistically hold. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lists_of_nuclear_disasters_and_radioactive_incidents https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lists_of_nuclear_disasters_and...
- thinkcontext 9y agoImagine you were behind the scenes of the Fukushima crisis. You have to begin planning for the evacuation of the outskirts of Tokyo because you have been told that the situation on the plant site is uncontrolled, there have been multiple meltdowns and explosions and there's the possibility for things to get worse. At that point the game has changed around the calculation of risk. A few days later the situation is declared under control. How do you feel? I can think of no appropriate feeling aside from "lucky". The point is that the error bars around nuclear power operation are so large that perceptions of risk are not the same as for conventional power. Its interesting to think about the role of luck for Chernobyl. A grossly unsafe design combined with a bunch of incompetents performing live tests with multiple safety systems disabled, not much luck there. Was there luck in consequences of what followed? Possibly.
- nisa 9y agoChernobyl was not unlucky. This was organisational failure and technical failure - few to none knew about xenon pit and that positive void coefficient was a compromise at the time to fulfill the demands. Fukushima? I'd say ignoring the known geological situation and dangers (no excuse for that IMHO) and the design of the backup cooling system that fails on a flood is also not unlucky. It's compromises to save cost and ignore dangers both times. We also have rotting reactors here in Europe: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tihange_Nuclear_Power_Station https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tihange_Nuclear_Power_Station
- egl2016 9y agotl;dr: if we assume deleterious effects from CO2-driven global warming and discount effects from long-term storage of high-level nuclear waste, nuclear is safer.
- lasermike026 9y agoThe question is how can we do nuclear right? From outward appearances it looks like have been doing it wrong, Three Mile Island, Chernobyl, and Fukushima for example. French nuclear systems appear to get it more right.
- komali2 9y agoNow that is an introduction! >The production of energy can be attributed to both mortality (deaths) and morbidity (severe illness) cases as a consequence of each stage of the energy production process: A lot of people here may know what mortality and morbidity mean straight off, but I want to share this article as much as possible, and it does a great job reaching out to laymen. I also like how it starts right off with "more energy is good, here's a link demonstrating why, let's move on."
- moomin 9y agoI'm something of a fan of nuclear power, but there's no way it's safer than a solar panel array. Ah, they didn't include renewables. Colour me surprised.
- ronald_raygun 9y agoRenewables solve a different problem though. There aren't great ways of storing energy on a large scale. So you end up needed two components to a grid - a baseline that you can scale up whenever (coal, natural gas, nuclear), and a renewable component. Saying that nuclear is the safest in regards to a baseline energy load is a valid argument to make.
- moomin 9y agoThat's a valid argument. The one in the article misses out that rather important nuance.
- zanny 9y agoMechanically we have the perfect solution to storing power - reverse hydro. Pump up into a reservoir while the grid is full of renewables that you drain through turbines when the renewables drop off. All the logistics are solved problems, it is mostly a matter of just paying to transition to it: * The grid itself would need a dramatic rework. It needs renovation for renewables in the first place, but introducing a hydro base load solution increases pressures on existing infrastructure. * You need enough solar / wind volume to justify a sizable centralized investment in such a power solution. But broad wind/solar causes problems involving peak grid load well before you even start building these things, along with the aforementioned grid updates, make a real chicken and egg problem. Hydro storage facilities are also vulnerable to extreme climate, take a long time to build (especially in countries where bureaucracy makes building anything take 10x longer than it should) and aren't expandable. But they would work, easily, to solve the power storage problem. Hail potential energy!
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoI find it amusing that HN is so divided on this issue yet quite unanimous distaste for how the middle east treats people and how the far east treats the environment. Nuclear power will look a lot prettier when it's competing on price with socially and environmentally ethical solar cells and fossil fuels.
- meri_dian 9y agoChina is charging ahead with nuclear in order to replace their outdated coal dependent energy infrastructure. >https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-01-31/china-s-nuclear-power-fleet-seen-overtaking-u-s-within-decade https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-01-31/china-s-n... As they develop and improve their reactor technology their plan is to export safer, more efficient fission reactors to the rest of the world.
- swills 9y agoClean, safe, too cheap to meter! /s
- quantdev 9y agoTrying to understand risk by looking at historic data alone is wrong when you're talking about catastrophic ruin and uncertain tiny probabilities. Add the word weapon in the headline quote to see what I mean, "Contrary to popular belief, nuclear weapons are the safest modern weapon" Arguments that nuclear power are safe need to prove that while assuming the worst-case scenario, since the probability of such a scenario is a-priori unknown despite what much of this comment section seems to be claiming. Solar is knowingly much safer because it is much easier to reason about.
- vbuwivbiu 9y agoI'm against centralized power generation of any kind. Make a household fusion generator that's safe and maybe I'll consider it, but until then I'm for solar because it can be deployed in a decentralized network (with batteries), and it's clean. That leaves the problem of the mining and manufacture, which is still centralized. This problem can be solved with GM organisms. We engineer fungi and bacteria to grow on roofs and generate electricity. They'd use CO2 in the growing process too. We can grow batteries in a similar way. Bacteria, yeast and viruses can do anything. They're the ultimate nanotech, we just need to learn how to program them.
- zukzuk 9y agoCame here to say more or less this. A centralized power grid was perhaps unavoidable, but now that decentralization is a possibility, the sooner the better. Nuclear is a good option when compared to big gas or oil plants, but what we really need is an energy paradigm shift, and there is little room for fission power in a decentralized grid.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- tabtab 9y agoIt's going to be politicized no matter what. Stop spanking humans for having human nature and lecturing them about being more rational. Politicians have to consider perception or they get voted out. It's just a technology that freaks people out on an emotional level and you can't stop that.
- mdpopescu 9y agoYou underestimate the power of propaganda. It's what made people like radioactive materials half a century ago [1] and what makes them fear nuclear power now. [1] https://www.google.com/search?q=radium+water+filter+ads+from+1960s&tbm=isch&tbo=u&source=univ&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwiN8tLHm7TVAhVJvBQKHYS5B7cQsAQIJQ&biw=3440&bih=1310 https://www.google.com/search?q=radium+water+filter+ads+from...
- lordlimecat 9y agoNot shown in the graph: Hydroelectric, which conjures up images of beautiful dams, rather than the hundreds of thousands of people who die at once when it fails.
- dredmorbius 9y agoSince I specifically highlighted the failure of Banqiao, and could give you Vajont and ... an Indian dam disaster of about 5,000 souls: what hydropower represents is a systemic risk, but not a long-tailed one. The worst disasters, in 1975 (which is to say, exceptionally deindustrialised) China, and in India, the deaths were amplified greatly by inadequate preparation, planning, communications, and response. Hubris has played a tremendous role in numerous dam failures (the above, Teton Dam, Johnstown). Which ... is pretty much amplified if you look to nuclear power. Plus that long tail. And there's the fact that there simply aren't many good natural hydro sites left, which means that the upside potential for creating additional risks is small. A decidely mixed blessing, if you call it that, but so it is.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- chris_va 9y agoThere are a couple of things everyone should know when it comes to energy production: 1) Energy investment is primarily driven by cost, not perceived/actual safety. Safety regulations do affect cost, but not enough to significantly change investment (at least in the US, with the current conditions). 2) Base load power and intermittent (e.g. solar/wind) power are not the same thing, and are not comparable. The concept that "solar and wind will save us all" by themselves is fundamentally incorrect, and actually they make things worse in many ways. Nuclear fear mongering has resulted in high levels of regulations around nuclear power, but even without that natural gas has an edge in $/kWh. There just hasn't been demand to build nuclear. On top of that, nuclear needs to run 24/7 to amortize high capital costs. With solar/wind, there is high variability in grid supply, so nuclear is significantly less cost effective, and is getting phased out in favor of low-capex plants (i.e. natural gas). Barring some energy storage miracle, we'll eventually end up with ~35% renewables, 15% hydro, 50% natural gas in the US, with HVDC interconnect. No nuclear, no coal. (source: I work in a Climate and Energy R&D group)
- Chathamization 9y ago> The concept that "solar and wind will save us all" by themselves is fundamentally incorrect, and actually they make things worse in many ways. Sure, this comes up a lot in these discussions. We don't need to rely 100% on any one type of plant, and we don't even have to eliminate coal plants completely. In the end, we're going to have to use a variety of options to fight climate change, and some of the major ones (like increased efficiency) aren't even going to deal with energy production.
- chris_va 9y agoI agree that we'll likely have a mix, but the point I was trying to make was: Before, we had low variability in demand, so things like nuclear, hydro, and geothermal ("clean" methods of producing base load power) had a chance to compete. Now, we have high variability in demand, so all of those solutions are out (though hydro is a special case), unless externalities like future-cost of CO2 is priced into production cost via taxes or cap&trade. Wind/Solar + Storage is too expensive, so the market will shift to wind/solar + natural gas. We'll end up burning possibly more fossil fuel, or roughly the same.
- epistasis 9y agoBefore we even get to the safety, and the disposal of the nuclear waste, we have huge difficulties with the basic economics and construction of nuclear in the US. The two plants under construction, Summer and Vogtle, have been plagued by construction difficulties and cost overruns. The Summer plant was just finally cancelled today. It seems that the Vogtle plant is going to follow the same route. The management competence and institutional knowledge needed to build these large, insanely expensive projects seems to have disappeared. The time for nuclear in the US is done. Other options are cheaper, faster, and more responsive. And that's ignoring the political aspect of it all. http://www.utilitydive.com/news/breaking-santee-cooper-scana-abandon-summer-nuclear-plant-construction/448262/ http://www.utilitydive.com/news/breaking-santee-cooper-scana...
- clock_tower 9y ago> The management competence and institutional knowledge needed to build these large, insanely expensive projects seems to have disappeared. And whose fault is that? Not the fault of nuclear-power supporters and advocates! Nuclear didn't die, it was killed.
- epistasis 9y agoHold on, there's more than enough blame to go around. Westinghouse Electric Company's bankruptcy and lies to Toshiba [1] weren't caused by nuclear's opponents. That's all on the heads of Westinghouse's management. And if management was competent, perhaps Summer would have been closer to being on budget. It's not as though the AP1000 is impossible to build, other countries are doing it just fine. It's just impossible for US contractors to pull through, apparently. That's not the fault of nuclear's detractors. [1]https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/economy/westinghouse-files-for-bankruptcy-in-a-blow-to-nuclear-power-industry/2017/03/29/4a64b6f2-1338-11e7-833c-503e1f6394c9_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/economy/westinghouse...
- clock_tower 9y agoI'm not surprised that Westinghouse behaved idiotically; they've always struck me as the Ford of washing machines, and I can only imagine what they're like at utility scale... It sounds like the best course of action is to bring in foreign firms to construct reactors in the US; but that'll probably have to wait for the 2020 election... if it happens at all, that is.
- titzer 9y agoThe ironic thing is, and I'll probably be downvoted for even positing this, but Chernobyl was the best thing that ever happened to that local environment, at least when you look how local wildlife has bounced back since it's been cordoned off as an exclusion zone. http://news.nationalgeographic.com/2016/04/060418-chernobyl-wildlife-thirty-year-anniversary-science/ http://news.nationalgeographic.com/2016/04/060418-chernobyl-...
- _ph_ 9y agoI get your point, but I think it should be clarified. What is good for "the environment" and what is good for mankind are very different things. Wild boar in Bavaria have less reasons to be eaten by humans, now that they are radioactive. For us humans it is of course less beneficial to live in a regions where we should not eat game and mushrooms.
- graphitezepp 9y agoBeen talking about this for years. Yes nuclear has some scary dangerous factors. But in the real world example of things going horribly wrong the long term damage just isn't as bad as what people talk about. Unless of course all that wildlife is getting crazy amounts of cancer that I don't know about and I am wrong.
- Taylor_OD 9y agoMost people who I've talked to about their fears over nuclear energy say they wouldn't want to be in the blast zone in case of a meltdown or near a potential terrorist target. Then I pull up the map of existing nuclear plants and more often than not they already live close to one. I've found its a fear thing for most people.
- danieledavi 9y agoWe should try to use as much as possible renewable resources and save precious, expensive, rare elements to be used only for scientific research purposes and space missions (propulsion and power plants). We have many alternatives on earth but we don't have energetic alternatives on other planets and outer space. We are just wasting the opportunity to go far.
- ThinkBeat 9y agoThe discussion I have seen so far on this thread go something like this: 1. Nuclear is really safe. The best. 2. Someone brings up an incident that actually happened. 3. Apologists excuse the incidents that happened because a. It wasnt designed right b. It was due to corruption c. It was bad planning. etc. We live in the real world here. You dont prove nuclear is safe by excusing every accident and actually using the disaster to prove how safe it is.
- Turing_Machine 9y ago"2. Someone brings up an incident that actually happened" Generally an "incident that actually happened" in which no one was actually, you know, killed.
- VT_Drew 9y agoCan we just stop with this nonsense? If you have a byproduct that has be buried in special containers in the desert, and that land can't be used, and there are people actually trying to come up with symbols that indicate danger that could span all language and culture in case a meteor hits the earth and civilization slowly rebuilds then finds the site, then it isn't "safe" be any stretch of the imagination.
- deepnotderp 9y agoThis assessment ignores the cm ecological cost of mining and waste disposal, both highly nontrivial concerns.
- beat 9y agoOf course, this is only comparing to fossil sources, not solar, wind, or other renewables (except biomass). I don't think this is going to matter in the end, though. The best, most optimistic arguments the nuclear proponents can make would still take 20-30 years to build out enough to make a standard-deviation difference in greenhouse gasses. Meanwhile, solar/wind are already hitting production costs that rival or beat nuclear, with lower setup costs and other barriers to entry. A wide variety of storage are being actively developed (with real investor support) to cache cheap surplus production from solar/wind, making a mostly-solar grid viable. What will our solar/wind/storage grid look like in 30 years? Nuclear as a stepping-stone to solar won't matter. It's faster and easier to just to straight to solar.
- pil4rin 9y agoNot to mention not having some nuclear waste to store for the rest of the foreseeable future.
- mitchty 9y agoWhat is the rest of the forseeable future exactly? If we use breeder reactors we can get the half life down to 500 years which is easily dealt with via stuff like glass entombment. The current nuclear waste solution is ignoring a lot of advances from the 90's.
- specialist 9y agoI support traveling wave reactors, explicitly to reduce our stockpiles. If we get some other benefits, like some electricity, bonus.
- beat 9y agoBreeder reactors are ridiculously dangerous. There's a good reason nobody uses them except for weapons-grade material generation. They're also a major weapon proliferation problem, since it's easy to use them to generate weapons-grade material. Are you planning to build one in Libya anytime soon?
- dijit 9y agoAs a person who actually likes nuclear energy: The issue I have with Nuclear is that we have not managed to fix the waste issue, and nobody seems to want to talk about it. I'm not a huge fan of "salting the earth" for 10,000 years. And when you say "it's safe", you're inherently ignoring that you basically have this toxic waste that is too costly to shoot into space and too dangerous to keep anywhere on earth for 10,000 years where it wont eventually harm the ecosystem.
- tehabe 9y agoOne thing is simply missing from the piece. You can't really distinguish between the civil use of nuclear power and the military use. Maybe there is some reactor design which can fix this but the reactors which are currently being build are not those designs. Also they are build for 60+ years. A lot can happen in 60 years. Discussing an energy source just by pointing about future developments is not the answer. The EPR reactors in Finland and France are several times over budget and took much longer than planed to build. In the time you could have build wind turbines and solar cells all over the country with an equivalent or higher amount of power output. And according to the current statistics every added kilowatt would have been cheaper than the last one. Also you might now say, but solar and wind are not always available. But at the same time you think that all problems with nuclear can be overcome but not the storage of electricity?
- jonshariat 9y agoI"m not saying this is the main factor for not choosing nuclear but this should be considered: the one difference with Nuclear is that when a system fails, you can't use that area of land for a few thousand years.
- agumonkey 9y agoA French engineer, Jean-Marc Jancovici, has been claiming this for a decade, with many talks and documents. I'm only 80% fan of his reflection because he doesn't account much for human change and new technological reconfiguration.
- CodeWriter23 9y agoBullshit. Any energy source where we do not have the technology to clean up the worst case scenario is not the "safest".
- kumarski 9y agoI've been writing about, thinking about, and exploring lithospheric energy extraction for the better part of 20 years. I studied operations research during college in the hopes of working on India's nuclear supply chain. The west choked us out of Uranium and Plutonium, similar to how the British choked us out of Rice during the Bengal Famine of 1943. http://engineersf.com/people-against-nuclear-energy/ http://engineersf.com/people-against-nuclear-energy/ http://engineersf.com/nasa-needs-plutonium%e2%80%8a-%e2%80%8a238-for-interstellar-flight-the-only-viable-production-source-is-nuclear-weapons-production-waste/ http://engineersf.com/nasa-needs-plutonium%e2%80%8a-%e2%80%8... http://engineersf.com/2500-10000-indians-die-every-day-from-lack-of-uranium-access/ http://engineersf.com/2500-10000-indians-die-every-day-from-... http://engineersf.com/why-is-india-so-behind-the-question-i-get-from-westerners/ http://engineersf.com/why-is-india-so-behind-the-question-i-... http://engineersf.com/4000-kilometers-through-my-own-country-an-engineers-viewpoint/ http://engineersf.com/4000-kilometers-through-my-own-country... More than anything, the brown/black people of the world need the west to give in to our demands for the approval of our uranium desires to help us get to progress driven escape velocity Nitrogen + Steel economies.
- dredmorbius 9y agoNB: That content might be interesting ... but it's not publicly readable. You might consider writing for (or publishing to) a venue which makes its works generally available.
- qweqweqweqw 9y agoI've come to the conclusion that nuclear energy is a good thing when done correctly, sadly we seem to be plagued by 60 year old power plants with severe safety problems still running because the power companies don't care about safety, they just want to run them as long as possible until they fail.
- egypturnash 9y ago[misleading headline] > Here we limit our comparison to the dominant energy sources—brown coal, coal, oil, gas, biomass and nuclear energy; in 2014 these sources accounted for about 96% of global energy production. While the negative health impacts of modern renewable energy technologies are so far thought to be small, they have been less fully explored.
- mmirate 9y agoRenewables aren't as reliable or powerful as fossil fuels or nuclear reactors; one simply cannot power a grid with only renewables. And the one exception, hydroelectric dams, are geography-dependent and can cause massive floods during any rapid unplanned deconstructions.
- oregontechninja 9y agoCheck out NuScale if you want to see what a modern nuclear company is trying to achieve.
- MR4D 9y agoThis is laughable. It's almost like saying that nuclear weapons are safer than sticks and stones because nuclear weapons have killed less people. Never mind that nuclear weapons have the possibility of making our species extinct. Likewise for nuclear power accidents.
- BinaryIdiot 9y ago> Never mind that nuclear weapons have the possibility of making our species extinct. Likewise for nuclear power accidents. Please elaborate. How can nuclear power plants make our species extinct?
- MR4D 9y agoA better phrasing would have been, "In a similar fashion", but I've answered it below as well. A bad nuclear spill into the ocean of significant extent would kill our food supply pretty quickly. And if not "kill" it, it would definitely make it inedible. (Roughly 1 billion people depend on fish for their primary protein.) A bad nuclear spill into the atmosphere (think a large Chernobyl) would have a devastating effect on human health as well. Basically, the point I was trying to get across is that nuclear power has extreme tail risks that things like solar won't. Sure, people will fall off their roof, but that is a distributed set of events, not a concentrated one like a nuclear accident.
- BinaryIdiot 9y ago> A bad nuclear spill into the ocean of significant extent would kill our food supply pretty quickly. And if not "kill" it, it would definitely make it inedible. (Roughly 1 billion people depend on fish for their primary protein.) I don't think this is anywhere near remotely possible. Radiation has terrible penetration into water as it is so water is a fantastic radiation shield but even so if you wanted to poison the water with enough radiation to kill off even a tiny amount of the food supply you'd...well I don't know the calculations or even how to do them, honestly, but I'm pretty sure you'd need orders of magnitude more uranium than we've ever mined (and it would have to be enriched, too). > A bad nuclear spill into the atmosphere (think a large Chernobyl) would have a devastating effect on human health as well. Hmm, I think to cover enough of the atmosphere you'd need a really, really huge nuclear explosion. I'm not sure how else you'd do it and even then most estimate of the world's stockpile of nuclear weapons wouldn't be able to kill off all humans (though it's a considerable chunk if I remember correctly). > Basically, the point I was trying to get across is that nuclear power has extreme tail risks that things like solar won't. Yeah, it's riskier than Solar. Everything is, honestly. Even wind. But we also have a high chance of dying in a car crash and that doesn't stop people and the risk of a nuclear failure, especially in a modern plant, is almost zero. It's far less risky than coal mining especially if you extract the uranium from sea water (though I don't know how easily it is to enrich without mining but then again I'm not a nuclear expert at all).
- maho 9y agoWhile I mostly agree with the article's risk assessments, it unfortunately leaves out one major risk factor: Nuclear proliferation. If more and more countries have access to nuclear power plants, then they also have the possibility to divert significant quantities (SQ) [1] of fissile materials towards nuclear weapons. I cannot find the source right now, but a talk given by non-proliferation experts outlined how accounting for fissile material in a reactor is about 99% accurate. But even 1% of nuclear fuel, on a nuclear-powered-world scale, is equivalent to hundreds of SQs per year, assuming current genration and next-generation reactor technologies. A nuclear conflict, even if regional (only a few dozen discharges) can potentially have dire, world-wide consequences. The article should have at least touched on those. [1]: http://nsspi.tamu.edu/nssep/reference/technical-safeguards-terminology/safeguards-approaches,-concepts,-and-measures/significant-quantity/NSEP-Reference-Term-iPhone-RD.aspx http://nsspi.tamu.edu/nssep/reference/technical-safeguards-t...
- mncolinlee 9y agoNot true. In the short run, solar is the safest. A massive spill of solar energy is just called a nice day. In the long run, it's the most dangerous. The sun may eventually consume the Earth and much later, go nova.
- acuozzo 9y ago> In the short run, solar is the safest. The externalities of the production and disposal of solar panels cannot be ignored in this kind of assessment.
- neurotech1 9y agoNuclear energy is only as safe as the people operating it. Admiral Rickover demanded a high personal standard for reactor personnel, and there was ZERO reactor accidents[0] because of those standards. IMO Natural Gas/BioGas powered turbine generators are better option to augment wind and solar power generation. The GE LM6000 [1] gas turbine (based on a 747 GE CF6 engine) can produce 40MW+ of electricity. They could even recycle a surplus CF6 engine to reduce manufacturing resources required. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hyman_G._Rickover#Safety_record https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hyman_G._Rickover#Safety_recor... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Electric_LM6000 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Electric_LM6000
- frabbit 9y agoAs the article makes clear, this another technology that might be useful in the future, but is currently unusable thanks to the problem of the waste generated from it. There are no safe options for storing nuclear waste right now. It really is time that we start looking at cutting back mindless generation and consumption of energy and that mostly means a big shift in lifestyle for North American and European consumers. Either that or else you can all explain to your children and grandchildren (whom you love very much and would do anything for etc.) that you decided that living an hour's drive or more from work and commuting in every day while eating fresh dragonfruit and shrimp flown from the other side of the world was just fine. Reduce. Re-use. Recycle. Time to start actually working on the first of those.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Animats 9y agoIt doesn't kill many people, because even when there's a disaster, there's time to evacuate. But you lose an entire city once in a while. Major reactor disasters so far: - SL-1. Steam explosion due to control rod lifted too far during maintenance. Small experimental reactor, built in the middle of nowhere (Idaho Reactor Test Station) for good reason. Inherently unsafe design. - Three Mile Island. Meltdown due to cooling water failure due to instrument confusion. Contained by good containment vessel. No casualties. That's what should have happened at Fukushima. - AVR pebble bed reactor. Pebble jam, radiation leak into ground. Contained, but too much of a mess to decommission. - Chernobyl. Meltdown and fire due to operational error during testing. Totally inadequate containment. Entire region evacuated and contaminated for decades. - Fukushima. Loss of coolant and meltdown. Containment vessel too small, reactor cores melted through in three reactors. Containment problem well known in advance; Peach Bottom PA has same design. A big, strong, containment vessel can keep a meltdown from becoming a major disaster and has done so at least twice. Size matters; a large containment vessel faces lower pressures when all the water boils to become steam. But a good worst-case containment vessel can cost as much as the rest of the plant. Some of the recently-touted small reactor designs try to omit a containment vessel on the grounds that their design couldn't possibly melt down. That's probably not a good approach.
- AdamJacobMuller 9y ago> Some of the recently-touted small reactor designs try to omit a containment vessel on the grounds that their design couldn't possibly melt down. That's probably not a good approach. Agreed, but, fail-safe and walkaway-safe designs coupled with moderate containment vessels seem like a good medium. It is all about mitigating risk. I don't think we should ever accept that a design has actual 0 risk for meltdown, but, if you design with a goal of having 0 risk of uncontained failures and then design containment for a moderate level of failure, that seems like you have a robust overall solution.
- rtx 9y agoEven if there is a meltdown it will have localized environmental impact. Which will self correct in few centuries. Greenhouse gases are affecting the whole planet, same with minerals for batteries.
- xyproto 9y agoIf only there was no connection to nuclear weapons, which are... unsafe.
- JoshMnem 9y agoArguments for nuclear power tend to ignore a few things: - They talk about ideal power plants, but not actual power plants. Are they assuming that when the world switches to nuclear, that every country will build these ideal types of plants and maintain them well? - Pro-nuclear arguments don't talk about inevitable wars. When nuclear power plants are scattered across the world in countries that will eventually become unstable, the potential outcomes look different. We are living through an amazing time for peace in many countries, but it isn't a given that things will remain peaceful like this. - Radiation has a cultural effect as well, and those plants and storage facilities make likely targets, since radiation disasters tend to cause people to panic. - After there is no more power from given plants or fuel, there is less incentive to take care of the waste and cleanup. I'm not entirely against nuclear power, but I think that it's more complicated of an issue than most nuclear proponents claim. Energy efficiency and use reduction are two other areas to consider. If it's possible to change behavior and opinions around nuclear energy then it should be possible to change behavior and opinions about efficiency.
- nnfy 9y agoPeople are using Fukushima to rationalize their fear of nuclear, just like we did after Three Mile Island and and Chernobyl. As someone else confirmed by posting [1], the magnitude 9.0 earthquake and 15 meter tsunami have not happened for at least 100 years. We can tear the plant down in hindsight, but it was designed to withstand probable events, just like any safety standards. It may not be pleasant to speak of human life in this manner, but there is always a cost/risk balance in any human endeavor, and this failure does not necessarily indicate recklessness. 1.http://www.world-nuclear.org/information-library/safety-and-security/safety-of-plants/fukushima-accident.aspx http://www.world-nuclear.org/information-library/safety-and-...
- prewett 9y agoThis article severely underestimates the number of deaths by nuclear power by not considering the deaths caused by leakage of radioactive materials over the course of the next 10,000 years. In fact, there really isn't any way to know that number for another 500 years at least.
- meri_dian 9y agoFlying used to much more dangerous than it is now. But we improved the technology and now it's safe enough that most don't think twice before getting on a plane. Discussions of nuclear power somehow ignore the fact that, like any other technology, current reactor designs are not the final iteration. They can be improved upon. Look the Chinese Pebble Bed reactor: https://www.technologyreview.com/s/600757/china-could-have-a-meltdown-proof-nuclear-reactor-next-year/ https://www.technologyreview.com/s/600757/china-could-have-a... If everyone aside from the Chinese ignore nuclear power, then the Chinese may be the ones making a fortune selling their advanced reactor designs to everyone else.
- sunbuntu 9y agoIt is the safest and the slowest and most expensive.
- jwildeboer 9y agoI stopped reading after "Here we limit our comparison to the dominant energy sources—brown coal, coal, oil, gas, biomass and nuclear energy"
- xelas 9y agoLet's cut a crap, shell we? We can't solve climate change problem which might be acute for last 20 years, yet we believe somehow that we are able to solve storage issue of nuclear waste for next 100 000. Egyptian pyramids are ONLY 5000 years old! And we are not 100% sure what is written in there. How do you warn next generation after 10 000 years, that some particular site is dangerous/radiaoctive? How do we keep something safe for 100 000 years? Is our Earth look same after 20 000 years, 50 000 years, 70 000 years? Will there be new volcano or shift of tectonic plates? Ice age? How do you keep such waste safe? Even as of today, there is no final storage solution for spent nuclear fuel. There is one know being built in Finland, and it is just for waste produces in Finland. BTW, there is very nice movie about it: Into Eternity. You should look it!
- xelas 9y agoLet's cut a crap, shell we? We can't solve climate change problem which might be acute for last 20 years, yet we believe somehow that we are able to solve storage issue of nuclear waste for next 100 000. Egyptian pyramids are ONLY 5000 years old! And we are not 100% sure what is written in there. How do you warn next generation after 10 000 years, that some particular site is dangerous/radiaoctive? How do we keep something safe for 100 000 years? Is our Earth look same after 20 000 years, 50 000 years, 70 000 years? Will there be new volcano or shift of tectonic plates? Ice age? How do you keep such waste safe? And what is the true cost of nuclear energy if you account 100 000 years storage of it? Even as of today, there is no final storage solution for spent nuclear fuel. There is one know being built in Finland, and it is just for waste produces in Finland. BTW, there is very nice movie about it: Into Eternity. You should look it!
- dredmorbius 9y agoThe maps below correspond roughly to Zhumadian City, Henan Province, China. The region spans about 100 km east-west. It is presently home to over 7 million people.[0] https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/-Ndd82xj3j1o-3KcyvBkLTB1mRBOfIhczIQOVHOZIdwOOkgaE40IJF4mBdKP11PecZaN59Yxag=w260-h178-p-rw https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/-Ndd82xj3j1o-3KcyvBkLTB1mR... In 1975, it was the site, or perhaps more accurately, region, of the worst power plant disaster in all history: the Banqiao dam failure. News of this only fully emerged after over two decades.[1] You can spot the reservoir itself at the far left of the images, at mid-height. In the disaster, a confluence of events lead to the deaths of approximately 171,000 people, with 11 million displaced. There's considerable uncertainty in those numbers. The causes were multiple: siting, improper engineering, unheeded warnings, a (literal) perfect storm (tropical typhoon striking a cold front and lingering over the region for a full day, dropping over 1 meter of rain), improper emergency plans, failed communications, situational confusion, nightfall, and a hopelessly inadequate response and recovery. Of the deaths, "only" -- a term used advisedly -- 25,000 or so were due to direct flooding. The remaining 150,000 or so succumbed to starvation or disease in the weeks following the events. And yet: the book as been closed. The cities in the floodplain are rebuilt. The dam itself has been rebuilt. Over 7 million people live in Zhumadian City, 95 millions in Henan Province total. There is no disaster exclusion zone. There is no disaster exclusion zone which will persist for the next three centuries. There is no molten reactor core. There is no coreium. There is no radioactive waste which will persist for 10,000 to 1 million years. The book is closed. Proponents of nuclear power assume that we can assess risks with tails not of the decade or so of Banqiao, but of 100, 1,000, 1 million years. Utterly outside the scope of any human institutions, or of the human species itself. Our models of risks and of costs fail us. (They've failed us as well in the case of fossil fuels, and, quite possibly, for hydro power -- I'm not giving this example as endorsements of either, but to give the story of risk and closure, or its lack. Those are other stories, for other posts.) The problems with nuclear power are massive, long-tailed, systemic and potentially existential. The same cannot be said of a wind farm or solar array. There is no significant 10,000 year threat from wind power, or solar power. We're not risking 30 - 60 km exclusion zones, on an unplanned basis, of which we've created at least four in the half-decade of significant nuclear energy applications: Hanford, Washington, Three Mile Island, Pennsyvania, Chernobyl, Ukraine, and Fukushima, Japan. And this is with a global plant of some 450 operating nuclear power plants as of 2017[2] (This compares with over 7,600 power plants in the United States alone.[3]) None of these sites has been fully remediated. In the specific case of Hanford, the current management plan is budgeted at $2 billion, and there is no final management plan in place. This eighty years after the facility first opened. If the total experience has been, say, 500 reactors, over 50 years, or 25,000 reactor-years of experience, and we've experienced at least four major disasters, then our failure rate is 0.016%. The global share of nuclear power generation in 2012 was about 10%.[4] Which means that without allowing for increased electrical consumption within existing or extending to developing nations, the plant count would have to increase tenfold. Holding the reactor-year failure rate constant would mean 80 core meltdowns per century. Reducing that to the present rate of four meltdowns/century would require reducing the failure rate to 0.0008%. That's five nines, if anyone's counting. Five nines on a process involving weather, politics, business, social upheaval, terrorism, sabotage, individual psychology, group psychology, climate, communications, response, preparedness.... And ... the involvement of the Japanese Mafia, the Yakuzi, in the management of TEPCO, who operated the Fukushima nuclear power plant.[5] All of which played a tremendous role in how badly the Banqiao disaster itself played out -- everything which happened at Banqiao by dynamics could just as well have happened in a nuclear plant. But it wasn't a nuke, it was a dam. And after a few hours, the waters receded, and after a few weeks, the land dried, and after a few months, recovery could start, and after a couple of decades ... even in what was still a poor country ... the recovery was complete. Banqiao was a disaster, no doubt. But what it wasn't was a nuclear disaster. ________________________________ Notes: 0. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zhumadian https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zhumadian 1. http://www.sjsu.edu/faculty/watkins/aug1975.htm http://www.sjsu.edu/faculty/watkins/aug1975.htm 2. https://www.nei.org/Knowledge-Center/Nuclear-Statistics/World-Statistics https://www.nei.org/Knowledge-Center/Nuclear-Statistics/Worl... 3. https://www.eia.gov/tools/faqs/faq.php?id=65&t=3 https://www.eia.gov/tools/faqs/faq.php?id=65&t=3 5. http://www.iea.org/publications/freepublications/publication/KeyWorld2014.pdf http://www.iea.org/publications/freepublications/publication... 4. https://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2011/12/yakuza-and-nuclear-mafia-nationalization-looms-tepco/333697/ https://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2011/12/ya...
- secult 9y agoPopular belief in any difficult topic is not a good indicator of anything.
- jonbarker 9y agoA great documentary about this is "Pandora's Promise". In it quite a few previous sustainable energy (wind, solar) advocates lay out the problem: sustainable has too far to catch up and in order to get the developing world to high quality of life they need high energy consumption per capita fast. Only solution to this is a safe version of nuclear.
- s0me0ne 9y agoSure its safe when you dump all your waste in another state. If your state that created the nuclear waste had to keep it, it would be a different story.
- jamaicahest 9y ago>Sure its safe when you dump all your waste in another state. If your state that created the nuclear waste had to keep it, it would be a different story. The article says safest, not safe. And if we compare nuclear waste to carbon dioxide emissions, which actually pollutes more worldwide?
- amai 9y agoHas the author ever been to Chernobyl or Fukushima lately?
- amai 9y agoNuclear energy is the safest energy source - on the sun.