9 ms·
Over here (in Europe) we get the impression that US has such a crazy healthcare system. Why aren't people marching in the streets? Is it not as crazy as it so
by rwmj 9y ago
Over here (in Europe) we get the impression that US has such a crazy healthcare system. Why aren't people marching in the streets? Is it not as crazy as it sounds for most users? If you're taken to ER how are you supposed to know if the doctors are all part of "your network" (whatever that even means)?
- madengr 9y agoToo sick.
- istorical 9y agoBecause those in the middle and upper class have employer-paid health insurance which protects from the worst of bills. You only go bankrupt if you're uninsured and usually only those in the lower-middle or lower class are uninsured. And those in the lower echelon of society economically are those least able to have the time or money to march or lobby for change.
- maxxxxx 9y ago"You only go bankrupt if you're uninsured" With copays and out of network stuff a lot of people will go bankrupt in case of a serious illness.
- chimeracoder 9y ago> With copays and out of network stuff a lot of people will go bankrupt in case of a serious illness. By law, those are capped for people with insurance. The maximum that you will have to pay out-of-pocket can be no more than about $7,000, and many private plans set the cap at a lot less. $7,000 is a non-trivial amount, but it's not a large number of people that both are insured and can't afford their out-of-pocket maximum without bankruptcy.
- madengr 9y agoMax contribution to an HSA is about $6,800/year. I have been putting $600/month into it for three years and have never been able to get more than $6k saved; family of 4 and no dental insurance (employer dropped it). This is the equivalent of a car payment for the rest of my working life.
- maxxxxx 9y agoYou can easily add tens of thousands of out of network costs with some medical issues.
- chimeracoder 9y ago> You can easily add tens of thousands of out of network costs with some medical issues It doesn't matter, because that's still capped.
- maxxxxx 9y agoI know people who have run up medical bills in the hundreds of thousands due to a long term illness despite having insurance. I don't know how this could happen, but it did.
- chimeracoder 9y ago> I know people who have run up medical bills in the hundreds of thousands due to a long term illness despite having insurance. I don't know how this could happen, but it did. The bills themselves aren't capped. The amount they are obligated to pay is. Insurers make up some of the difference, and the rest is forgotten about. (It's not written down in the accounting sense, because the hospital doesn't necessarily actually treat the entire billed amount as receivable.) I explained in a top-level comment how this works and why it works this way.
- maxxxxx 9y agoI hear what you are saying but I know people who have 6 figure medical debt despite being insured. This happens.
- spydum 9y agoIndeed it doesn't take much imagination: chronic illness + prescriptions + high deductibles. Worse if multiple family members are sick (so many problems are inheritable and so on). Also worth mentioning, it's been broken for a while (e.g.: ACA is not even broken in yet).
- myke_cameron 9y agoNot to mention the historical "lifetime limits", which only since the ACA have been lifted. You could have an unimaginable great plan with a huge network and no deductible, but an extended hospital would still bankrupt you.
- muninn_ 9y agoI just logged in to say this (trying to comment less and read more) but this needed said. Even with a vanishing middle class, the middle and upper class that remains still have largely great healthcare and healthcare plans, it's the poor who are largely being screwed. Even then, they don't support universal healthcare (it's mostly us hipsters or whatever) because they are still weary of the government and we're still dealing with post-mccarthyism where any sort of government service for the public benefit is socialism.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ProAm 9y ago> You only go bankrupt if you're uninsured This is absolutely not true [1] [1] http://www.cnbc.com/id/100840148 http://www.cnbc.com/id/100840148
- wccrawford 9y ago>NerdWallet estimates nearly 10 million adults with year-round health-insurance coverage will still accumulate medical bills that they can't pay off this year. That's only saying that you'll have bills you can't pay, not that you'll go bankrupt from it. Most (if not all) insurance plans have a maximum out-of-pocket expense amount that's like $10k. Yes, that's more than some middle-class Americans can afford to pay in a year, but it's not enough to go bankrupt over. They just defer paying it until they can afford to.
- chimeracoder 9y ago> Most (if not all) insurance plans have a maximum out-of-pocket expense amount that's like $10k It's more like $6800 for 2016 and $7100 for 2017. That's the federally-mandated cap; many private plans set their cap even lower.
- maxerickson 9y ago2x those for a family.
- ProAm 9y ago> That's only saying that you'll have bills you can't pay, not that you'll go bankrupt from it. This is one of the things Obama-care addressed, because before that most bankruptcy's in America where caused by medical bills. I'll see if I can find the article. [1] But with Obama-care going away/being changed this might be a thing again. [1] "A study done at Harvard University indicates that this is the biggest cause of bankruptcy, representing 62% of all personal bankruptcies. One of the interesting caveats of this study shows that 78% of filers had some form of health insurance, thus bucking the myth that medical bills affect only the uninsured. Rare or serious diseases or injuries can easily result in hundreds of thousands of dollars in medical bills - bills that can quickly wipe out savings and retirement accounts, college education funds and home equity. Once these have been exhausted, bankruptcy may be the only shelter left, regardless of whether the patient or his or her family was able to apply health coverage to a portion of the bill or not. (Find out what you can do to avoid a financial meltdown when there's a medical emergency. " http://www.investopedia.com/slide-show/top-5-reasons-why-people-go-bankrupt/ http://www.investopedia.com/slide-show/top-5-reasons-why-peo...
- empath75 9y agoI just spent over a year and countless phone calls arguing with the hospital over bills for the birth of my son. We had two employer paid insurance companies and HRA, and they still managed to send us to collections until we threatened to take them to court. They eventually sent us a refund of $600.
- damontal 9y agoSimilar experience w/ twins in the NICU. when you have 2 employer paid insurance plans, the two insurers fight over who pays and the hospital doesn't get paid, which leads to them coming after you.
- godot 9y agoI went to ER a couple of months ago for a relatively minor issue and stayed for a few hours total. This was in-network hospital, doctors and so on. Purely by co-pays this ended up being a ~$800 bill after all the insurance kicked in. If I didn't have a comfy software engineer salary, and instead lived paycheck to paycheck, this would've been devastating, even with insurance.
- SilasX 9y agoWhich is ridiculous. We're at the point where the insurance is just covering the cost of the overhead that necessitates having insurance in the first place. There's no way the real charge should be $800, let alone co-pay.
- bdamm 9y agoThis is exactly right.
- chimeracoder 9y ago> Which is ridiculous. We're at the point where the insurance is just covering the cost of the overhead that necessitates having insurance in the first place. There's no way the real charge should be $800, let alone co-pay. You're right. Of course the private insurance premiums have a negative expected value. Aside from insurance always having a negative expected cash value by definition, private insurance premiums are literally used to subsidize care of Medicare, Medicaid, and uninsured patients.
- madengr 9y agoThat $800 is cheap. I have a high deductible plan, and a recent visit will easily wipe out $4,500 of the $6,000 I had saved in my HSA. For a family of 4, I have been trying to save $8,500 (my OOP family maximum) for 3 years, but the HSA max contribution caps me at $6,750. Can't get there.
- alonmower 9y agoVery similar story, in the US as well. Went in, had a couple of tests that ruled out anything serious and was on my way in ~1.5 hours including all of the various wait times. Saw one doctor for maybe 1 minute and had a couple of nurses spend about 10 minutes with me total during the various tests. Insurance was billed ~10k, with coinsurance I had to pay $1,400. This is after the hospital billing in multiple rounds and forgetting to bill insurance on one of them and also forgetting to send the bill to me (which if I hadn't been proactive about following up with would have led to it getting sent over to collections). I'm assuming I have better health insurance than a decent percentage of the population and I can afford the bill but how the hell can most people? What a terrible, terrible choice for someone to have to make between getting care when they're at their most desperate and avoiding financial ruin
- dungle6 9y agoThose in the lower echelon of society are unfortunately too stupid not to support powerful groups that have the opposite of their best interests in mind. Ie not many rural poor or lower class support single payer -- the support mostly comes from middle and upper middle class.
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y agoThe people who need to march the most are the ones who can't, the ill. And when they do it's not exactly pretty: http://time.com/4829103/mitch-mcconnell-protest-senate-health-care-bill/ http://time.com/4829103/mitch-mcconnell-protest-senate-healt...
- maxxxxx 9y agoThere is a lot of propaganda how bad systems in other countries are. Plus, this is the only system most people ever have seen so they think this is just the way things are and have to be.
- abalone 9y agoAdditionally, the U.S. working class (who are most affected) is disorganized and politically weak. Other democracies often have "labor" parties; that doesn't exist in the U.S. Labor unions have been under attack for decades. There is a saying that the U.S. has one political party, the Business Party, with two factions. Elements of the working class are so desperate and underserved by establishment Democrats that some are turning to Trump-ian false promises and easy answers. Remember Trump (falsely) promised to fix their health care and offer cheap, quality plans.
- wnevets 9y agosocialism is bad, most americans stop thinking at the point until it affects them directly.
- getemback 9y agoMost Americans repeat "socialism is bad" while driving down their toll-free interstate highways.
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoAhh, the good old false equivalency.
- occultist_throw 9y agoUnfortunately, We've tried. It does little good. This last Saturday, there was a peaceful protest of around 200 people held in DC in front of Congress. One of my friends attended this protest. Around 150 of them were arrested, and then given bullshit charges, like crowding, obstructing, incommoding, or resisting arrest (of what charge were they being arrested for, angering Trump...).* When you try to "peacably protest", and "redress the government for a redress of grievances" and are arrested, detained for 6 hours, and then given a $25 citation of 'crowding' - what else do you do? Molotov Cocktails? AR-15's? The answer, unfortunately, is nothing. You keep your job, eat decent food, and live a life under whomever the current 'king' is. And hope to the gods that nothing knocks you down to a lower socioeconomic ladder rung. * https://www.washingtonpost.com/local/public-safety/police-arrest-155-health-care-protesters-at-us-capitol/2017/07/19/c6a04286-6cd4-11e7-96ab-5f38140b38cc_story.html?utm_term=.b1044853f685 https://www.washingtonpost.com/local/public-safety/police-ar...
- purple-again 9y agoWe have rules in place that allow the population to peacefully protest without interfering with the business of others. These people didn't follow the rules and were punished accordingly just like every other law on the books. If you are unable to enact the change you want from within the system it's because not enough people agree with the change you are proposing. Welcome to the complexities of Society. If you don't want to participate you don't have to. Abandon the laws of man and return to the laws of nature. Just remember the law of nature demands conflict be resolved in the favor of the more powerful will. I doubt very much you would fair well.
- jaymzcampbell 9y agoFellow European (UK) here. From what I understand one argument often given, is that there's a mistrust of the government for anything like this and people prefer to "shop" for it themselves. By making their own choice (even if all that actually means is picking from 1 or 2 options given to them by their employer) - they feel empowered and in control of it. There is a general feeling of "if you want it, pay for it". This StackExchange answer sums up it up succinctly: https://politics.stackexchange.com/a/16372 https://politics.stackexchange.com/a/16372. I find it immensely saddening; the same goes with the general population's attitude to education (in many countries) or providing housing. For what it's worth I know a lot of people with private healthcare in the UK with the attitude that the NHS is complete trash (something I very much disagree with) - I fear this sort of mindset is spreading. "Pull the ladder up jack" as they say.
- chimeracoder 9y ago> From what I understand one argument often given, is that there's a mistrust of the government for anything like this and people prefer to "shop" for it themselves As a data point: the patient satisfaction scores for Original Medicare (government-run) are drastically lower than every single major provider of Medicare Advantage (privately-run). As much as people dislike insurance companies, people in the US are even less happy with the government-run programs, compared to their private counterparts.
- justin66 9y agoOn the other hand, patient satisfaction correlates with increased rates of hospitalization, higher expenses, and increased mortality. You'd want to dig a little deeper than patient satisfaction before drawing any conclusions regarding medicare vs. medicare advantage, I would think.
- chimeracoder 9y ago> On the other hand, patient satisfaction correlates with increased rates of hospitalization, higher expenses, and increased mortality. You'd want to dig a little deeper than patient satisfaction before drawing any conclusions regarding medicare vs. medicare advantage, I would think. I didn't in my previous comment, because we were talking about the overall public perception, which may or may not be connected to the tangible metrics that we actually want a healthcare system to focus on. As it turns out, though, Medicare Advantage also consistently outperforms Original Medicare on medical outcomes, and it comes in under-budget for identical coverage. Medicaid options vary much more (and they're different in every state, because Medicaid is administered at the state level), but the equivalent private plans for Medicaid coverage also typically perform much better than the public ones. Hacker News readers aren't generally in the demographic for Medicare[0], but for anyone who is: there's really no reason to use Original Medicare. Every jurisdiction should have Medicare Advantage plans that cost you the same amount as Original Medicare does, and your experience (and overall care) will be vastly improved. [0] people over the age of 65, or people of any age who are on dialysis for more than two years, etc.
- astockwell 9y agoIt is exactly as crazy as it sounds, unfortunately. But due to many years (decades!) of pre-meditated political maneuvering, one of our political parties has managed to inextricably relate any kind of desire for "single-payer" or "socialized" medical system with effectively being a communist USSR apologist. No exaggeration.
- sehugg 9y agoExcept for Medicare.
- dragonwriter 9y agoMedicare is not a single payer system (which is why I get confused when sibgle-payer advocates say they want “Medicsre for All”); it's more like “Obamacare with an public option for some services”; the prescription drug program (Part D) is private plans with public subsidy, and Medicare Advantage (Part C) is private plans for public subsidy as well. Parts A and B are public plans for core inpatient and outpatient services, but theres been a big push to Advantage plans (including as a vehicle to handle Medicare/Medicaid “dual eligibles”.)
- JustSomeNobody 9y agoBecause, literally, one side of the street would be the Republicans and the other side of the street would be the Democrats. Nothing would get done as neither side feels the need to concede anything.
- JackFr 9y agoFor an explanation of how the bizarre US system came to be I would recommend the following episode of EconTalk: http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2017/06/christy_ford_ch.html http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2017/06/christy_ford_ch.htm... The guest is an economic historian who details the historical forces which led us to where we are right now. She also describes a few different, more effective and rational models (not just single payer) which could potentially have existed, but which sadly are, for all practical purposes, impossible to get to now.
- mikeash 9y agoDecades of propaganda has convinced half our electorate that the US's system is the best in the world, and that countries with socialized medicine are hellholes where you have to wait months to get a broken bone looked at.
- mistermann 9y agoSimilarly, decades of propaganda in Canada has convinced far beyond half our electorate that the Canadian system is the best in the world even though you actually do have to wait several months for treatment if your issue is not "urgent", the definition of urgent being unknown.
- sloppycee 9y agoI take it you have never experienced a true urgent health crisis? Once you have you'll quickly realise that the 'long wait times' narrative is complete propaganda FUD. Anecdote time: My sister is anaphylactic, when she goes to the ER she is admitted, hooked up, and given epi almost immediately. When my aunt couldn't move her arm one day, she got an MRI, diagnosed brain cancer, and had brain surgery in the same week. I'm glad to have a system that when you are waiting it's because there are people with more urgent needs, rather than because there are people who paid more.
- mistermann 9y agoSigh. Do you think I was suggesting that emergency rooms in Canada should adopt a FIFO approach? > Once you have you'll quickly realise that the 'long wait times' narrative is complete propaganda FUD. This is a decent example of the typical Canadian attitude I was referring to, blind refusal to even acknowledge any issues, such as the well documented long waiting times for non-emergency procedures, as well as the outright refusal to treat ailments deemed "not important enough" by your doctor.
- Declanomous 9y agoMy understanding, as an American, is that people in single-payer countries tend to see doctors much sooner than Americans do. Say I'm sitting around and I finally decide to get pain in my wrist looked at that I've had since I broke it ten years ago. I could see a specialist in less than a week. However, I probably would have had it looked at 7 or 8 years ago if I was in a single-payer system. Maybe I would have had to wait 6 months to see a doctor, but that still puts me about 7.5 years ahead of where I am now. I know a lot of people who have bones that never healed right because an emergency room visit is going to cost you a fortune whether or not you are insured, so they don't go to the ER because it doesn't hurt 'that bad'. I imagine that is somewhat less prevalent in places with socialized healthcare.
- spinlock 9y agoBecause people don't get sick every day. Most people don't run into these bad situations and, in general, americans lack empathy for others who do wind up in bad situations. We have a media that tells us -- and religion before -- that you get what you deserve. So, if you're rich, you deserve it. If you're sick, you deserve it. The idea that life is unfair and random is not accepted by america.
- getemback 9y agoEssentially, poor white Americans oppose any kind of social service that might benefit black Americans. Virtually every problem that America faces is complicated by this one simple fact, which is an echo of the fact that half the country literally went to war over their preference to enslave black people. Despite this glaring and obvious reality, most commentators are afraid to mention it.
- doubt_me 9y agopoor white americans oppose any kind of social service that might benefit anybody but themselves including other white people. Black americans oppose any kind of social service that might benefit anybody but themselves including other black americans. People are people and ignorance doesn't have a color. It has always been like this. Blaming one or the other doesn't actually fix anything and it is also why nobody brings it up any longer not because they are afraid to mention it.
- Houshalter 9y agoBecause it didn't used to be like this. Healthcare in the US was 5 times cheaper in 1970. The cost has been ballooning up since then and no one can explain why or how to stop it. We don't necessarily need socialized medicine. If we just went back to the way things were done in 1970 everything would be solved. The money the government currently spends on healthcare subsidies could buy free healthcare for everyone at 1970 prices. Life expectancy was a bit shorter in 1970, but not by that much. And most of the increase is due to other factors than healthcare (e.g. the smoking rate has dropped a lot, cars are much safer, air pollution is reduced, etc.) And there have been studies done that show increased spending on health care doesn't really correlate with increased life expectancy.
- ugh123 9y agoYour impression is reality. And its more f'cked up then you think.
- breischl 9y agoIt's at least as crazy as you think. I don't think that anybody really believes that the mess we've made of billing/paying-for services via insurance + government + hospital/doctor is a good idea. At least nobody who has dealt with it for more than 5 minutes, which is most people over 25. The problem is that nobody can agree on how to fix it. One side wants to socialize the whole thing, the other side wants to do... something else, I guess. Regardless, neither side has enough power to just do what they want, so we're stuck with this bizarre Frankenstein's monster instead. Meanwhile it's almost impossible to escape from the mess. You can't just have no insurance and pay for yourself, because they've made the prices for most things ludicrously high and then basically rebated them to the insurance companies. Actually, it reminds me just a bit of that paraphrase of the Laws of Thermodynamics: you can't win, you can't break even, and you can't get out of the game.
- abritinthebay 9y agoUK but live in the US now - simply because to them this is always how it has been. The UK cried and moaned when the NHS was introduced but now (aside from Conservative efforts to "starve the beast" on it) most wouldn't go back for the world (though it could be improved, obviously). The US has a mentality that it's the best in the world for everything. Even when it's objectively not true (like in healthcare) this colors the debate.
- ionised 9y ago> The US has a mentality that it's the best in the world for everything. Fundamentalism, basically. Or maybe fanaticism is a better word.
- abritinthebay 9y agoSimple nationalism really. Quite importantly different from patriotism.
- Danihan 9y agoWhat would marching in the streets accomplish, exactly?
- thephyber 9y ago> Is it not as crazy as it sounds for most users? It's primarily lots of Byzantine rules in small print buried in long policies that few people read and even fewer memorize. If you are lucky and are conscious when you need to use a policy to visit a health care provider, you can bring your policy with you to ensure you follow it, but it's not always that easy. The health insurance company claims they told you how to follow the policy, but they don't make it any easier than they legally have to. If you skip a rule (like calling your health insurance company before you visit an emergency room), that might violate your policy. If you visit an "out of network" hospital when you should have visited an "in network" hospital, you may be liable for the difference in cost (which is huge due to health insurance distortions in the medical market). If you try to go to a medical specialist without first going to your primary provider (as defined by your health insurance company), they likely won't cover it. There are usually dozens or hundreds of pages of these rules in booklets that you get when you join an insurance policy. If you don't know about / forget about a rule, you are responsible for the costs associated with the violation. It's easy to unwittingly ask a health insurance question about your policy to the office manager at a doctor's office (who isn't qualified to speak about specific health insurance policies) and getting bad information that you then assume is good. > Why aren't people marching in the streets? I think most people see this as a "free market" problem (since 60%+ are covered by their employer-sponsored health insurance), not a political one. ~20% of Americans are covered by Medicare (the retirement-aged national health coverage) or have military veteran benefits, which are generally considered pretty good (unless you listen to political arguments). How would "marching in the street" fix a problem that people have with the "free market"? The remaining 20% are among the most politically apathetic. We are lucky to get 50% participation of the voting-eligible electorate, even in presidential elections (which have higher turnout than other elections). I think lots of Americans pride themselves on being stubborn and pretending like painful things aren't painful, then trying to ignore them. Lastly, I think most Americans simply don't think that marching works. Rural America doesn't march. Urban America only seems to march for generic social justice causes, not for specific policy improvements.
- ciconia 9y ago> Why aren't people marching in the streets? Americans seem to have always preferred so-called "freedom" to social solidarity. It's every man for himself over there in the land of the free.
- Merad 9y agoBasically, events like TFA where someone gets shafted even with insurance are fairly rare. The system is bad, but many (most?) people aren't exposed to just how bad it really is. The elderly, who require the most healthcare, have Medicare helping them. Working adults often get insurance subsidized by their employer, and young adults/kids under age 26 can stay on their parents insurance plans. With insurance, especially "good" insurance, you don't see all the insanity unless you dig into the itemized details of your medical bills... even then most people will shake their heads, pay their (relatively small) portion of the bill, and move on.
- ams6110 9y agoYes, it is not as crazy as it sounds for most users. Media outlets like to publish horror stories because it attracts eyeballs. Yes they can happen and there are bad actors in the system. But most ER patients either don't pay a dime because they don't have a dime, or their insurance picks up the tab subject to deductible. "In Network" rules specifically don't apply in true emergencies under most plans. Of course if you go to the ER for a runny nose, there may be some pushback.
- chasing 9y agoPropaganda. Pure and simple. People have been lied to about how healthcare should and could work for so long that they hold political beliefs that are completely at odds with their best interests. We have the resources to fix many of these problems. But we won't. The powers that be would prefer lower taxes.
- chrismealy 9y agoA lot of white Americans would rather be fucked over than risk helping non-whites.
- Fej 9y agoSome are beginning to march in the streets, actually. Especially those who stand to lose their lives or a relative's should a Republican repeal bill pass. (Ironically, many of these people votes for those Republicans in the first place.) For the rest who aren't, there's a simple reason: services operated by the government tend to suck (or are at least perceived to be so). It is an American tradition to stand in long lines at the Department of Motor Vehicles to renew your driver's license, or to get your vehicle inspected. The TSA exists to inconvenience travelers. Public schools are perceived to be failing (they are in some places; I was lucky enough to get a very good education in public schools) even if they are not necessarily. The Postal Service is not profitable (even if it doesn't need to be...) and there are always lines at post offices. And so on. (typing on mobile, could give more examples but I'm sure others have their own) Whether these problems are real or not is irrelevant. Americans distrust the government, especially the federal one. You could call it indoctrination, to a degree. Those who benefit from the system are allowed to persuade the populace, even from birth, and are supported by both major parties. (Drug and other healthcare advertising is legal.) It is also part of our history. The tradition of the US is a distrust of big government. Before the US Constitution was written, we had a federal government under the Articles of Confederation. It was meant to be permanent. The federal government was extremely weak, gave too much power to the states, and ultimately did not work. So the Founders had to go back and try a second time and gave the federal government more power. And that's where we are today...but that feeling of distrust has persisted through the centuries. So to sum it up: many like the idea of private healthcare not because they have a choice, but because they believe that the government(s) will screw it up worse.