7 ms·
Is Productivity Growth Becoming Irrelevant?
- svara 9y agoThe idea of "zero-sum" economic activity sounds sort of plausible. And it feels like there's a lot of truth to it, but when I think about it harder I find it really difficult to nail down what that actually means. Most of the examples given in the article are of things that you could argue provide a sort of "infrastructure" service: Legal services allow businesses to have confidence in their contracts, financial trading serves to allocate resources efficiently, advertising solves the problem of discovering new goods and services. Yes, I know that sounds like a crazy optimistic view of these industries, but how do you know which parts are useful and which aren't? Do we know it's even possible to remove the useless parts and keep the important ones? It seems to me that one interesting definition of "value of this activity" would be: How many other activities depend on it? By that particular definition, any activity that provides some sort of "infrastructure" would be particularly valuable.
- matt4077 9y agoLegal services aren't infrastructure. They're legal services. We know what that means. It doesn't need metaphors to be comprehendible, especially not completely wrong ones.
- ridgeguy 9y ago"We know what that means." I don't. I found the parent's post a bit thought provoking. If you'd expand your thoughts, it might be interesting.
- dharma1 9y agoWhile there is definitely some need for tweaking government/tax incentives on some of these, to direct money flows to better purposes, I think (hope) free markets will drive down the prices of some of these "infrastructure" services like legal and financial services as ML automation starts kicking in
- yuhong 9y agoI think the main problem now is the trade deficit. Many countries invest the FX reserves in things like bonds, driving the yields down and encouraging investment in things like stocks. This is part of why higher profit margins are good for the US economy.
- mattmcknight 9y agoMore directly, methods of GDP calculation add exports and subtract imports, so the trade deficit is part of the GDP value presented. It's really not an effective measure.
- arcanus 9y agoNo, productivity growth _as measured by economists_ is becoming irrelevant.
- blazespin 9y agoHow should we measure it?
- crdoconnor 9y agoIt's not really measurable. Whatever it is, GDP / hours worked isn't it.
- mattmcknight 9y agoNo sure why you are being downvoted, as this is a main point of the article. "But the essential insight is still important: much that delivers human welfare benefits is not reflected in GDP." GDP is not that useful of a measure for the wide variety of things that used to be expensive but are now free. It also includes a lot of things that are not exactly products, depending on which calculation is being used. In a broader sense, these national level calculations ignore the global economy except to add exports and subtract imports. Countries that import a lot thus have worse looking GDP, while still consuming large amounts of others' production. We used to use GNP (until 1991 or so) as the official measure, but it made the increasing amount of the budget spent on government debt obligations look bad so they switched. No doubt we'll find another gross measure to use.
- FryHigh 9y agoAll business is aimed at "human welfare". Even if the people in the business are not fully aware of it.
- woodandsteel 9y agoYou are absolutely correct. So for instance, corporations never attempt to make money doing something they know would be bad for society.
- mhluongo 9y agoSomeone's welfare, sure. Human welfare in the greater sense, not so much. Arguments about the invisible hand fall apart in the face of regulatory capture
- Animats 9y agoFrom the article: The growth of “zero-sum” activities may, however, be even more important. Look around the economy, and it’s striking how much high-talent manpower is devoted to activities that cannot possibly increase human welfare, but entail competition for the available economic pie. Such activities have become ubiquitous: legal services, policing, and prisons; cybercrime and the army of experts defending organizations against it; financial regulators trying to stop mis-selling and the growing ranks of compliance officers employed in response; the huge resources devoted to US election campaigns; real-estate services that facilitate the exchange of already-existing assets; and much financial trading. Much design, branding, and advertising activity is also essentially zero-sum. ... Such zero-sum activities have always been significant. But they grow in importance as we approach satiation in many basic goods and services. In the US, “financial and business services” now account for 18% of employment, up from 13.2% in 1992. What's interesting is that it's the UK's former top financial regulator saying this. It's not a new idea, but it used to be the sort of thing you saw in Mother Jones, and occasionally heard from Warren Buffett. This is a concept that needs to become mainstream and start influencing tax policy. There's a lot that could be done through tax policy to push capital in more productive directions. The elephant in the room is zero-sum financial activity. Buffett used to say that short-term capital gains should be taxed at 100%. Taxing them at top-bracket personal income tax rates might not be a bad idea. It's a start. Hedge funds get a completely unnecessary tax break which has a small but powerful lobby. All the ways that businesses pay for capital should be taxed at the same rate. This includes dividends, interest paid, and stock buybacks. There's a bias towards borrowing rather than dividends, which generates unnecessary banking activity. It's the relative tax rates that matter, not the absolute ones, because they drive business decisions. Maybe advertising should not be a tax-deductible business expense. US consumer advertising just moves demand around. It doesn't add demand because US consumers are spent out, as the CEO of WalMart says. Politically, the key to doing this is to do it all at once, with the overall corporate tax rate adjusted to make it revenue-neutral. There will be losers, and they will have lobbyists lined up halfway down the Mall to get into the Capitol. But there will be winners, too, mostly in industries that actually do something. It's politically possible.
- SerLava 9y agoThose things aren't zero sum. When a business gets hacked and shuts down, a bunch of people spend time sitting around trying to get a new job, and then learning that new job. If going outside is scary, police can make it not scary and value will be generated out of thin air. And so on.
- woodandsteel 9y agoThe article is saying that productivity growth has become disconnected from increasing human welfare. I think part of the problem is that when economic science was getting founded, economic growth did translate it welfare increases, at least to a considerable extent, and so economists never worked out good measures of human well being, much less how it relates to productivity growth.
- paul_milovanov 9y ago>> The growth of “zero-sum” activities may, however, be even more important. Look around the economy, and it’s striking how much high-talent manpower is devoted to activities that cannot possibly increase human welfare, but entail competition for the available economic pie. Such activities have become ubiquitous: legal services, policing, and prisons; cybercrime and the army of experts defending organizations against it; financial regulators trying to stop mis-selling and the growing ranks of compliance officers employed in response; the huge resources devoted to US election campaigns; real-estate services that facilitate the exchange of already-existing assets; and much financial trading. >> Much design, branding, and advertising activity is also essentially zero-sum. That's a remarkably short-sighted view of economic activity. A functioning legal system is critical for the operation of an economy. Without one, markets don't work and neither do various sophisticated financial services we enjoy (insurance, loans, mortgages, etc). Financial fraud, regulation & policing are the cost of having a dynamic and sophisticated financial system. It's had a tremendously positive impact on our societies and individual lives, which we're almost completely oblivious of. Ditto every other item in his list. If you think that some popular, ubiquitous sort of human activity creates no genuine value to individuals or the society, you probably haven't thought about it long enough.
- krona 9y agoBang on. New instruments of finance/investment (public companies, bonds and shares) and the legal institutions that arose at that time to protect investors were one of the most important catalysts of the industrial revolution, possibly the most important driver of productivity growth in the history of mankind. You could argue that eventually the finance industry becomes so large that it reaches equilibrium within the markets it operates (Mervyn king has suggested the same about the City of London), thus becoming zero-sum, but this nuance is completely absent.
- matt4077 9y agoThe article doesn't require _all_ financial services, legal services, advertisement etc. to be zero-sum. It only needs some aspect, of some of these activities, to be zero-sum.
- stretchwithme 9y agoIt's irrelevant for creative work for sure. But for anything that can be automated, yes. Of course, there will be new kinds of work that will use all the new tools we are creating. But I don't have a lot of faith that government can understand and measure these changes fast enough to provide any meaningful insight.
- lordnacho 9y agoPut simply, the things economists tried to measure when they created the GDP measurement system are no longer a proxy for what they want to measure, which is welfare. It makes sense that this should happen. Economic growth was still a relatively new thing when economics was in its infancy. Back then it was obvious that you wanted more food. Nowadays more food is bad for you, amazingly. But we still have the baggage of the old apparatus. What you can know is that when you look at a system that is outside of its observed parameters, there's a fair chance that it will behave differently to what you've observed. You may observe something completely new, who knows? Interpolation vs extrapolation. The problem is a lot harder now, for the reasons he writes. Certain activities are clearly zero sum, but are measured as positive. Other things are positive, but are not measured. There's going to need to be a lot of thinking about what we really mean by welfare in the future. There are already everyday situations where you're not better off, but the numbers think you are: - You go into a shop, and there's 50 kinds of toothpaste. You spend time researching on the internet, coming to no conclusion about the dozens of variables. If there was just one kind left, you'd have bought it. - You invent something, so now you need a patent lawyer, in case the other guy hires one first. That's money you can't spend on R&D. And one of you will lose his stake.
- chiefofgxbxl 9y agoThe first bullet point you wrote about the 50 kinds of toothpaste becoming debilitating is a good example of the "Paradox of Choice". A good TED talk is given [0], or a shorter animated one: [1]. Essentially, too many options leads to paralysis and second-guessing yourself. Good videos if you have the time to watch them. [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VO6XEQIsCoM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VO6XEQIsCoM [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F4QzhSlqmqg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F4QzhSlqmqg
- watwut 9y agoI kind of buy random average costing toothpaste and never suffered for it. Neither mentally nor physically. Human's are adaptable and most of us adapted to toothpaste choices just fine. The suffering from having to do irrelevant choices is a bit overstated imom
- xupybd 9y agoVery interesting article. Would this mean that it would be a good idea to develop a better metric than measured GDP. Is there anything existing that could be a better metric?
- untangle 9y agoThe military is another largely "zero-sum" activity. If all militaries were disbanded immediately, no change in economic value would occur. In fact, the economic value of "winning a war" is questionable, let alone losing one. I'd extend this argument to the "war on drugs" as well. And the "war on terror" (as currently fought).
- refurb 9y agoIf all militaries were disbanded immediately, no change in economic value would occur. Not sure I agree. If you define economic value to include future value generation, I would argue that getting rid of a countries military might turn their future value from $XXXB to $0B pretty quickly. South Korea is a good example.
- thethirdone 9y agoHow is South Korea a good example? They have a sizeable military (huge for their population), and have a high gdp.
- MagnumOpus 9y agoYes, exactly. And if the did away with that military, the whole country would become a giant gulag within a few years.
- ryandrake 9y agoOnly works if all militaries and military activity were disbanded simultaneously. War is one of those weird economic activities specifically designed to be negative-sum. No matter the outcome of a war, society on average ends up worse off.
- Consultant32452 9y agoI wonder if without war, or at least the fear of it, we'd have created the interstate highway system, or satellites, nuclear power, jet-liners, etc. No doubt we'd have probably invented something. It's not entirely clear we would've invented the same things. The threat of eminent death tends to allow governments to "rationalize" insane spending on R&D on projects that they'd otherwise not have the stomach to wait on.
- KamBha 9y agoNot sure if the author of this link is responsible for this page, but it does not work in Firefox :(
- BenoitEssiambre 9y agoI'm not convinced all the activities enumerated as "zero sum" are really zero sum. Justice is worth something, crimes would happen even if there weren't any polices so policing is also worth something. However, looking past this weaker aspect of the argument, there is a lot that is worth talking about here. There can indeed be competing processes that are so optimized and near maximally productive that doing one process depletes the small amount of resources that would make the second process possible. The limit that technological progress pushes us towards is not that of people all going to manual one-to-one, face-to-face labor but of getting near the physical constraints of energy, space and matter. Pushing towards these limits means that everything starts competing for natural resources and energy. We are starting to see very high competition for space in technologically advanced urban areas. Energy and raw materials have always been subject to competition. This is where the true "zero sum" game lies (until we colonize other planets I suppose). To illustrate, imagine we lived in a world where labor was unimportant because machines did most things better than humans could. These machines would still required time and natural resources (space, energy and matter) to produce goods and services. For most people, "working" in this world would consist of going online, buying or trading an amount of energy, buying raw materials or spent matter that is ready to be recycled and pressing a "Start" button. Machines would produce some new goods or services. Some people may also work on designing new better machines that produce finer goods. This would be mostly creative work as the technical part would mostly be automated. The machines could be specialized for maximum efficiency and quality. People wouldn't have to go out to work. Machine owners could watch webcam feeds of their machines working in an industrial park somewhere. The finished goods, spent matter (trash) and the machines themselves, would be picked up and delivered by self driving delivery robots. To get some variety, people would trade the production of different machines and they would trade excess spent matter. They would also trade the machine designs and the land or space to host the machines. The machines would sometimes have to be replaced when worn out or obsolete. Total energy production might be constrained globally to a more or less fixed rate based on what could reasonably be captured from the sun. Total production would be limited by this. People might own and trade shares of energy production capacity. There could be a level of inequality in this society. This depends on how much governments would allow ownership of things to be concentrated, especially ownership of energy production. The key thing to combat inequality would be to not allow too concentrated ownership of energy, matter and land and also make sure everyone owns or have access to the robots that turn the raw materials into goods and services. It is true that as we get closer to maximum efficiency, it becomes more and more difficult to raise productivity. We should start to think about how a society can run under these types of limitations.
- jpao79 9y agoMaybe this is a better way of measuring progress instead of GDP and productivity? TED: Which country does the most good for the world? Simon Arnholt https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1X7fZoDs9KU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1X7fZoDs9KU And maybe instead of re-distribution of wealth (which is zero-sum) it should be a redistribution basic food, housing, entertainment and access to education (which is non-zero sum and can be optimized for).
- PeterisP 9y agoOne aspect is the quantity vs quality issue. If the farming industry finds a way to make e.g. twice as much food (or electronics industry twice as many smartphones) with the same land/people/resources, then we see it as a productivity growth - either you double the consumption (more GDP) or you do it with half the people/resources, and whatever else these people/resources produce will increase GDP. However, if the farming industry finds a way to make the same food twice as tasty (or the smartphones twice better) with the same amount of labor and resources, then that won't necessarily increase the prices (everyone's product gets the new feature, supply is the same, and demand is mostly the same if other industries advance as well) - so there's no observable growth; the economy produces the same number of widgets, trade happens for the same total amount of dollars, even though people's needs/wants are satisfied better.
- Zarath 9y agoI've been thinking about this a lot lately. How is it that so many people work so hard and are still struggling to pay rent? This is definitely one of the factors I have come to. While I certainly wouldn't make the same arguments as the article, I feel like so many people devote so much time to work that doesn't really improve people's quality of life. The amount of time and energy spent on advertising, clickbait garbage, video games, sports (specifically broadcasting, discussing, writing, etc.), drugs, gambling, cosmetics, television, and other pointless time wasting technologies is truly staggering. Sure, people enjoy many of the things I've listed, but we have certainly reached the point of diminishing returns on investment in these things. The sheer amount of infrastructure these things have created to essentially take money away from people while providing nearly no social benefit is mind boggling. People can enjoy baseball or football without billion dollar industries being built around them and the same is true with video games or television/theater/movies (just think what could be done with the average budget of a blockbuster film).