15 ms·
The Myth of Drug Expiration Dates
- barking 9y agoAt one time we were required to keep an extensive list of emergency drugs at work. Off the record, it was generally accepted that we should never, under any circumstances, use any of those drugs, bar adrenalin, for fear of doing more harm than good. The cost was substantial and one company seemed to have the monopoly on supplying them. They also kept a record of the expiry dates and supplied replacements as stocks went out of date. The most annoying thing was that they seemed to deliberately supply drugs with most of their lifespan expired. They of course denied that this was a policy.
- korethr 9y agoI'm glad people are contacting the FDA to try to get them to extend drug expiration dates, but this article gives me the impression that after the FDA fails to reply, or replies non-committally one way or another, people give up. Have any of the efforts involved tried to move up the chain of command to Congress? The FDA might not seem to be willing to move on the issue, but if one could get one's senator or representative to care, that congressman probably has more means to get the FDA to act than the average person.
- djrogers 9y agoIt seems that a law simply allowing private testing of drugs for efficacy, the same way the federal government is allowed to, would go a long way to saving money here. Hospital systems and HMOs are large enough to save millions for a bit of testing, and once enough data is gathered they can easily and safely adjust their retention policies.
- KekDemaga 9y agoGood idea but I suspect, the FDA won't give up their ability to pick winners and losers anytime soon.
- jws 9y agoHospital systems and HMOs turn their inventory fast enough that inventory control can probably handle their problem. Small hospitals and pharmacies probably suffer more from expirations.
- lobster_johnson 9y agoAren't there many drugs that hospitals need to have at hand, but are rarely used? Things like antivenins, anti-rabies serums, or other agents that are only reached for in extreme cases. It may not be a high proportion compared to what hospitals are using on a daily basis, of course (but they might be proportionally more expensive, too).
- pitaa 9y agoAs far as antivenins, it is my understanding that most hospitals don't keep them on hand for the most part, and instead rely on an "antivenin bank" to fly it in when needed. Interestingly, the main bank in the US is run by the Miami-Dade Fire Rescue [1]. They have a 24 hour hotline and will arrange to have antivenin immediately flown to anywhere in the world. [1] http://www.miamidade.gov/fire/about-special-venom.asp http://www.miamidade.gov/fire/about-special-venom.asp
- lobster_johnson 9y agoThat's very interesting, thanks!
- djrogers 9y ago> Hospital systems and HMOs turn their inventory fast enough that inventory control can probably handle their problem. Doesn’t sound like it from the article...
- harshreality 9y ago> The findings surprised both researchers: A dozen of the 14 compounds were still as potent as they were when they were manufactured, some at almost 100 percent of their labeled concentrations. What kind of reporting is this? Anything less than 100% is not "as potent as when manufactured", and the sentence implies some of those dozen weren't close to 100%. > The idea that drugs expire on specified dates goes back at least a half-century, when the FDA began requiring manufacturers to add this information to the label. The time limits allow the agency to ensure medications work safely and effectively for patients. To determine a new drug’s shelf life, its maker zaps it with intense heat and soaks it with moisture to see how it degrades under stress. It also checks how it breaks down over time. The drug company then proposes an expiration date to the FDA, which reviews the data to ensure it supports the date and approves it. Despite the difference in drugs’ makeup, most “expire” after two or three years. That seems to be the problem. There was a procedure in place to set expiration dates scientifically, and it was ignored for some reason, limiting the legal shelf life of even the most stable compounds to a few years.
- thaumasiotes 9y ago> That seems to be the problem. There was a procedure in place to set expiration dates scientifically, and it was ignored for some reason, limiting the legal shelf life of even the most stable compounds to a few years. To investigate how a drug breaks down over a ten-year timespan, you'd need to do at least one ten-year study of the drug. That seems difficult to justify.
- funkymike 9y agoI was thinking about this today after hearing a report on the radio this morning on this topic. Hospitals end up throwing away large amounts of drugs each year due to expiration, potentially hundreds of millions of dollars - although there is no real data currently. It seems like it would be a good long term investment for a group of hospitals to partner together and begin a systematic study of the actual lifetimes of drugs. Instead of destroying all expired drugs they could send off samples to a lab for testing. They could even intentionally keep expired drugs in an off-limits area for 1, 2, 3 years past their expiration dates to gather more information. With enough hospitals participating they could gather a significant amount of data without any one hospital shouldering all of the burden. Once there is enough evidence that a particular drug is still potent the FDA could extend the allowed shelf life. This would save the hospitals money over time since they could stop paying to dispose of and replace as many expired drugs. It would also provide a general benefit to the public since people would have solid scientific evidence for the actual effective lifetime for particular drugs. This would include poison control centers, the hospitals themselves, etc. that would be able to better handle cases where someone has already taken an expired drug. Of course an alternate way would be to require the drug companies to accept returns from hospitals of small amounts of expired drugs that they would then be responsible for testing and providing the data to the FDA. Limiting the returns to large institutions would keep the costs down (reducing push-back from the pharma companies).
- dmschulman 9y agoThe myth is that those dates on the side of most drugs are expiraration dates.
- ghostly_s 9y agoWhat?
- azhenley 9y agoBut mine explicitly say "EXP" beside the date.
- DamnYuppie 9y agoI believe the OP's point is that really isn't when it not be effective but when you are supposed to throw it away as per the FDA. It could very well be effective well past that expiration date.
- bcook 9y agoI always assumed that the expiration date was partly legal, in the way that you only have 1 year within which you can legally have the drug in your system. I mean, if I am prescribed oxycontin, can I legally have the drug in my system for the rest of my life?
- schrodinger 9y agoI'm pretty sure it's never illegal to have a drug in your system (besides something secondary like a DUI). It's only possession that's illegal.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- rhblake 9y agoDepends on the country. In Sweden it's illegal to have certain drugs in your system. E.g. if THC is found in your blood you can be convicted for a minor drug offense. We're sadly pretty extreme with regards to drugs though.
- dragonwriter 9y agoIs it illegal to have THC in your system or is having THC in your system admissible as rebuttable evidence of possession/use of illegal drugs? Either would support the outcome you describe, but they are meaningfully different. E.g., with alcohol, the “in the blood is illegal” rule would criminalize auto-brewery syndrome occuring in those legally denied alcohol (e.g., due to age), while the “in the blood is admissible as evidence of use” would not, though those with the syndrome might need to present evidence of it to avoid charges.
- rhblake 9y agoIt's the latter: (intentional) use of (illegal) drugs is illegal, and having THC in your blood is proof enough to convict you (even if you've consumed it in a different country where it's actually legal; there's precedent). Typically you'd just get a fine though, if you admit guilt and don't go to court. See § 1 here for the exact law: http://www.notisum.se/rnp/sls/lag/19680064.htm http://www.notisum.se/rnp/sls/lag/19680064.htm
- noonespecial 9y agoThe cynic in me suspects that if this gains too much traction, drug manufacturers will simply start adding self destruct compounds to all of their formulations "for our safety". In fact, some of them have track records of such "ethical" behavior, it wouldn't even surprise me if they turned them poisonous vs simply inactivating them.
- verroq 9y agoThe only solution is to fix the economic incentives so that drug manufacturers want to make less wasteful medicines. Same with preventing planned obsolescence. The only solution is to encourage more competition.
- zajd 9y agoOr we could just make it illegal. Then again, with today's political climate it wouldn't surprise me if someone was unironically opposed to regulating drug manufacturers.
- gnaritas 9y agoLaws are merely barriers to work around, incentives guide what's going to be attempted. Making something illegal adds some negative incentive, but isn't nearly as good a solution as simply having positive incentive to do the right thing.
- zajd 9y agoWhat makes you think laws aren't incentives? "Merely barriers to work around" kind of misses why laws exist in the first place. Making something illegal is what society should do if we collectively agree that behavior is to the detriment of society without any positive gain. What do we gain by allowing drug manufacturers to put false expiration dates on their products?
- gnaritas 9y ago
- unics 9y agoIn Denver there is a program that supplies hospitals internationally with expired drugs and equipment that would otherwise be without. It's been going on for decades and saved many lives.
- euyyn 9y agoI'd think there's a business opportunity in recycling the still-active chemicals in those pills.
- dp-tyvek 9y agoA lot of cost of drugs comes from R&D, quality control etc. The chemical synthesis itself generally isn't that expensive. And expired pills would be a quite unpredictable precursor, which isn't very desirable in the pharma industry (or anywhere else for that matter). In other words, I doubt you could make much of a profit (if any) from purifying non-decomposed chemicals from pills.
- cwkoss 9y agoI wonder if you could get around drug patent laws with the first-sale doctrine.
- Overtonwindow 9y agoAnother facet to this is "Medication Adherence" which is defined generally as taking medication properly, but which the drug industry defines as taking all of your medication, and getting a refill for more. Speaking only as a lobbyist who has (regrettably) worked for a Pharmacy Benefit Manager in the past, there is tremendous amount of money and thought being put into how to get patients to take all of their medication. The belief is that this will lead to patients refiling that prescriptions, oh and probably help them overall, but refills are the number one priority for the drug industry.
- L_Rahman 9y agoAlong with some other people in the healthcare industry (process person at a large provider, product person at a large EHR), I'm trying to make a map of the "systems truth" of healthcare in America. We'd love to talk to you (in confidence!) about how the PBM part of the world works. Please reach out to me if you'd be interested - contact information is in my HN bio.
- coding123 9y agoAlmost all of the drugs I have in my cabinet are expired, and all have been 100% potent as the day I got it when I needed to take it years later. I have known this for a long time. There is also a reason the expiration date on your prescriptions is exactly one year after you get it from the pharmacy, when those bottles are actually sitting in a different bottle for months and months at the pharmacy. The entire reason for a 1 year expiration date is money.
- tzs 9y agoFor prescription drugs in the hands of consumers, as opposed to hospitals and pharmacies, I would be concerned about consumers misusing drugs. For example, suppose someone goes to their doctor with certain symptoms and are diagnosed with a specific condition. They are prescribed a drug to treat it. They use up half the prescription, and the condition goes away. A couple years later they develop similar symptoms. Instead of going to the doctor and getting diagnosed they just assume that it is the same thing the had before, and so start taking the drug again. If they are right, great. They have saved the time and cost of a doctor visit. But what if they are not right? What if this time they have something different that just shares some major symptoms with the prior illness, but that needs a different treatment? Worse, it could even turn out that the side effects of the drug make what they have this time worse.
- jinglebells 9y ago> and cost of a doctor visit. And we've nailed the problem. I don't pay to see the doctor so I have no reason to stockpile the drugs.
- AstralStorm 9y agoOh but you do. Even in socialized care there are taxes and opportunity cost of time to visit. It sometimes gets hilariously bad as a patient is supposed to get out of bed very ill to go get a sick leave paper...
- hyperrail 9y ago> But neither Cantrell nor Dr. Cathleen Clancy, associate medical director of National Capital Poison Center, a nonprofit organization affiliated with the George Washington University Medical Center, had heard of anyone being harmed by any expired drugs. Cantrell says there has been no recorded instance of such harm in medical literature. I am more than a little surprised by this. Fanconi syndrome, a kidney disease that can cause bone damage [1], has been repeatedly found in the medical literature to be caused by taking expired pills of the antibiotic tetracycline. [2] That these people completely failed to remember these cases is distressing at best. (I heard an interview with the author of this story on NPR Morning Edition today, and also scanned this story webpage. The only mention of tetracycline was by a web commenter on the story.) [1] https://medlineplus.gov/ency/article/000333.htm https://medlineplus.gov/ency/article/000333.htm [2] https://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&q=tetracycline+fanconi+syndrome https://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&q=tetracycline+fanc...
- Herodotus38 9y agoI was going to post a similar reply. However, outside of tetracycline, there have never been reported adverse effects from expired drugs. Furthermore, there were only three cases of expired tetracycline related Fanconi Syndrome and that preparation responsible is no longer made. Of course, if it's old... Otherwise I agree I'm surprised by the reporting ignoring this because this is a classic board question in internal medicine. Source: http://www.mdedge.com/internalmedicinenews/article/113748/should-i-throw-out-my-expired-medications http://www.mdedge.com/internalmedicinenews/article/113748/sh... Edit: Apologies that the above link has a paywall. When I accessed it via google it worked once, then shot up a paywall. If it doesn't work at all I'll remove it.
- Reason077 9y ago"Berkowitz picks up a box of sodium bicarbonate, which is crucial for heart surgery and to treat certain overdoses. It’s being rationed because there’s so little available." Huh? US hospitals have a shortage of Baking Soda?
- detaro 9y agoYes. One of 2 (or 3?) manufacturers in the US making it as a medical product had manufacturing issues, so there isn't enough of it that's cleared for medical use available. EDIT: https://www.usatoday.com/story/money/2017/05/31/how-baking-soda-shortage-became-health-care-crisis/102320494/ https://www.usatoday.com/story/money/2017/05/31/how-baking-s...
- doctoring 9y agoOh yes... it's a pain in the ass. Recently in the news, too [1]. There weren't many days where the hospitals I've worked at weren't short on something. (And these are like, big name academic medical centers in big U.S. cities.) I've run into a shortage of normal saline before. Yes... salt water. Sometimes hospitals will even stockpile basic supplies to keep from running into shortages... which only makes the whole situation worse. It causes a lot of patient harm, even if it's usually not catastrophic because we usually have redundant meds. Recently my hospital was out of a common, generic, cheap antibiotic. For many infections in many patients, this meant we had to switch to the second-line drug -- which was more expensive, had more side effects, and was less effective against the bug. This type of thing happens to chemo drugs, to drugs you give after a heart attack, to drugs you need for planned surgeries or procedures. I don't know how to solve this. Less regulation? More regulation? Subsidies for manufacturers of essential medications / supplies? I mean, normal saline is already ridiculously expensive enough [2]. For more reading: http://news.medill.northwestern.edu/chicago/hospital-drug-shortages-what-is-really-causing-them/ http://news.medill.northwestern.edu/chicago/hospital-drug-sh... [1]: https://www.nytimes.com/2017/05/21/health/sodium-bicarbonate-solution-critical-shortage-hospitals.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/05/21/health/sodium-bicarbonate... [2]: http://www.nytimes.com/2013/08/27/health/exploring-salines-secret-costs.html http://www.nytimes.com/2013/08/27/health/exploring-salines-s...
- jessriedel 9y agoThis article has some shoddy logic. For the vast majority of drugs, the actual marginal manufacturing price per pill is essentially zero. That means that when the expired pills are thrown away and new pills are manufactured, there is no true economic loss. Rather, all that potentially happens is a transfer between the consumer and the manufacturer. If pill prices were set by some external force, this could at least be an important society-wide transfer. But in fact, in equilibrium pill prices will be affected by the expected rate at which pills expire without being consumed. Even when manufactures have a monopoly, the manufacturer-surplus maximizing price is determined by the demand curve of the consumer which takes into account the expiry rate of pills. (If 10% of pills expire before I consume them, they are worth 10% less to me in expectation.) Yes, I'm sure there are market model where expiry dates create net economic drag, or a net value transfer between manufacturer and consumer, but it's not even clear which direction the transfer goes. Such an analysis depends on the details of the world and how they are reflected in your model, which are completely absent in this article. Most importantly, the intuition that "letting $100 pills expire for no good reason must cause $100 of damage" is completely false when the marginal cost of manufacturing is low. (There are exceptions where the marginal manufacturing process is expensive, but the article doesn't focus on these.)
- nathancahill 9y agoI had exactly that thought when listening to the NPR interview this morning. Unfortunately, the value was taken for granted (even extrapolated x4000 to estimate total value loss across all hospitals in the US).
- learn_more 9y agoThe cost model is like a time limited software license. If there is some new trick to extend the license, the drug companies would likely just charge more up front.
- jessriedel 9y agoExactly. The price is set by the willingness to pay (the demand curve), which accounts for the fraction of purchased pills that will actually be consumed.
- samstave 9y agoI wonder if there are any that become more potent/dangerous after a period of time.
- mherdeg 9y agoI have a lot of respect for this kind of reporting from ProPublica. It's a really good public service to report news that isn't actually new. In this case, part of the news is that the FDA's 1986 Shelf-Life Extension Program ( https://www.fda.gov/EmergencyPreparedness/Counterterrorism/MedicalCountermeasures/MCMLegalRegulatoryandPolicyFramework/ucm411446.htm https://www.fda.gov/EmergencyPreparedness/Counterterrorism/M... ) has been working fine for decades. This is important for people to know and it's worth re-publishing from time to time as a reminder. They had another great article like this last month, https://www.propublica.org/article/hundreds-of-judges-new-york-preside-without-law-degrees https://www.propublica.org/article/hundreds-of-judges-new-yo... , which basically reported "local courts in New York state had terrible problems according to an in-depth 2006 New York Times report and are still terrible in 2017". Great stuff. Likewise a lot of the reporting on "civil forfeiture continues to happen and continues to be unfair, here are more examples" provides a valuable civic service. I know it can be tough in a news organization to re-report something that everyone already knows is true. It can certainly be tempting to pass over truly important stuff in favor of seeking out brand-new news -- a fair amount of science reporting is driven by "what's in the journals this week" -- but this kind of long-term focus on "what's still true that needs your attention" is equally valuable and great work.
- slr555 9y agoThis issue is a conundrum. Most drugs don't fall off a cliff of efficacy when they reach their expiration date. There are drugs such as tetracyclines that should never be used past their expiration dates because they degrade into toxic compounds. Certain classes of drugs such as anti-arrhythmics or drugs like warfarin are dosing critical to the point where I would not want them if they were out of date. I worked in pharmaceuticals in a medically underserved community for a couple of years. At that time when drug samples expired, sales representatives had to return them to their companies for destruction. One doctor in the area made sure that all the drug reps knew he would accept short dated (but not outdated, which would have been against policy for reps) samples for a free clinic he ran. Everyone I knew participated when they had short dated samples. While reps could not distribute outdated samples, doctors had much more latitude in how they dealt with them. It was one of those rare and wonderful situations that was good for patients, created good will for reps and was all completely within regulations. I should say this was some years ago and regulations may have changed since then.
- agumonkey 9y agoI wonder if a single rule 'no consumption past date' is a safeguard to insure simple behavior from population. If people started to think some drugs can and some cant they might indulge into trying random stuff.
- dekhn 9y agoyes, that's a big part of it. It's a simple rule that's easy to follow, which can often be better in terms of health overall.
- agumonkey 9y agoYeah unless we put something better in place, maybe a dedicated QR code website to quickly verify if that box is 1, 2, 10, toxic
- dgfgfdagasdfgfa 9y ago
- JshWright 9y agoThe "extended use dates" that Pfizer published mean that we now have 'older' drugs with expiration dates that are past the expiration dates of newer batches. They didn't just say "add 1 year to all expiration dates" they said "for these specific lot #'s, the new expiration date is: XYZ". They only published extended dates for some lots, since they expect more recent lots to still be in date by the time the shortage is addressed. I may have spent the better part of a day a couple weekends ago relabeling a bunch of vials with a sharpie...
- pipio21 9y agoMost of the time the drug handles time well but the excipient degrades. This makes it very hard to control how those drugs will work. It opens so many variables. It is like not using the seat belt could save your life if you are thrown away of the car at some specific circumstances, like happened to a person I know. But they are there because it works better most of the time as engineers could design safety with less variables. My father had an emergency immune problem(that we have already identified as it is recursive) and the only required drugs in house were expired for some years. He took those before we bought the new ones and the old ones were like 1/3 potency of the new ones. Given that most of the price of drugs come from intellectual property and patents and each pill cost dollar cents to make, I don't see the urgency of taking expired drugs. If Hospitals trow away expired drugs then it is a good reason to take into account in the global negotiation process, and I bet they already do in countries that buy drugs in bulk.
- gumby 9y ago(former pharmaceutical developer here). This article makes it sound like there's a big conspiracy, which there isn't. A very few drugs (like erythromycin) become toxic so should be discarded. Some drugs become less efficacious over time, but nobody really knows the shape of the curve as they are simply tested to see if they have the same efficacy on day E as they did on day 0. Well of course all drugs will become worthless as t approaches ∞ but you can guess that since tablets have a very low moisture content, if they are kept in a cool dark place it's likely they'll last a very long time. I also happily keep expired drugs in a controlled environment and use them; all drugs in my car's and backpack's first aid kits get replaced annually because they are exposed to harsh environments. (Stockpiling drugs doesn't prove anything BTW: if you are stockpiling them against an emergency the presumption is that some efficacy is better than none). Nobody is going to do accelerated life testing beyond what they have of course. I think extending the required lifetime is a good idea, though I question the size of the economic return claimed in the article. The expiration dates on food are slightly more scandalous: the FDA doesn't require the same level of testing as they do on the medical side so they are mainly set stupidly short. Last week purchased some vacuum-packed lamb that had a manufacturer label with an expiration date a month away, but was prominently labeled to expire this week. And of course US egg producers take steps that reduce the storage time of eggs, which can be months old when you get them -- and then "expire" a week after getting home.
- derefr 9y ago> Last week purchased some vacuum-packed lamb that had a manufacturer label with an expiration date a month away, but was prominently labeled to expire this week. Are you sure this was an expiration dates, and not a "sell by" or "best before" date? A sell-by date is the date at which the grocery store will voluntarily throw out the product—not because it has gone bad, but rather because its unprepared appearance/texture will have changed enough that people will either avoid the product on the shelf, or will complain and return the product, even though those differences disappear once the product is prepared. I'm talking here about things like "bruised" bananas, "slimy" baby carrots, raw chicken that's turned a slightly deeper shade of pink, and anything that "smells off" when taken out of the package. The grocery store can't make a profit keeping these products on the shelf past a certain point—even though they're perfectly fine and safe to eat—so it does some Business Intelligence stuff to optimize the profit-curve given (shelf-space opportunity-cost + complaint PR-cost + return-cost), and out comes a number they print on the label for when they should remove the thing to replace it with a newer one if they want to make the most money. You might think that this makes for a lot of waste. But grocery stores are aware of this waste, and how it translates directly to lost profit opportunities, so they're usually on the hunt for ways to solve this. This is why so many groceries have in-store delis that make ready-to-eat meals: it's a way to turn products people aren't willing to buy, into products they are, by doing the preparation step themselves. Often, also, grocery conglomerates have "up-market" and "down-market" marques they operate under. Down-market customer bases have higher tolerance for these "red-herring signs of spoilage" (probably because they've at some point tried these foods out of necessity and found out they were fine after all), so the conglomerate can take advantage of this when building a centralized logistics pipeline for its stores: when it acquires produce/dairy/meat/etc., the stuff that already has some of these signs (or will likely acquire them sooner) is sent to the down-market-branded stores, while the up-market-branded stores get the products that appear fresher and will continue to appear fresh for longer. This is a necessity—if they didn't do this, they wouldn't be able to keep the up-market stores in stock given said stores' customers' intolerance for signs of spoilage—but it conveniently allows the up-market store brand a cachet of having "the freshest" produce, allowing them to justify charging more for food from the same farms. And, finally, some grocery chains have deals with e.g. homeless shelters, to provide them these voluntarily-expired products as ingredients for free-meals programs. Grocery stores get people to feel good with "can drives" for food banks, donating non-perishables, but perishables are in much greater demand, and it's often the stores themselves that are doing the most good there. (Why don't they talk this up for PR? Because the fact that this is "expired" food would have to come up, and the public will never bother to read and understand what I just wrote above.)
- rectangletangle 9y agoDegraded tetracycline has been documented to be dangerous in those who are suffering from renal failure. There's also the possibility that a person may be suffering from a new undiagnosed condition, which hadn't yet onset when they were initially prescribed the drug. In this case you could think of it less as an expiration for the drug, and more of a suggestion to seek additional medical guidance on continuing after a certain date. There's also the remote possibility that a new drug is developed which could potentially become dangerous when expired. The general population would have to unlearn little morsels of knowledge such as this, in the meantime people could be harmed. Edge cases like this are enough in my opinion to warrant not spreading blanket advice like this, even if it's nearly always true. Erring on the side of caution is the best approach with medical affairs, even if it costs a bit extra monetarily. Giving patients potentially dangerous advice so they can save money is ethically questionable at best.
- valuearb 9y ago3 cases in 50 years? That's all you've got?
- rectangletangle 9y agoI would be more concerned about the second point. A patient developing additional complications isn't unheard of.
- hemanthtt 9y agoCan't there a company which buys up all the "expired" drungs and get the appropriate approval from FDA and resell it for a cheaper price?
- valuearb 9y agoAllowing drug makers to set expiry dates is a huge conflict of interest, they have massive incentives to expire their drugs as soon as possible. I'm surprised the FDA doesn't do the testing and set the dates itself. The best solution is to require drug makers to replace expired drugs with new, for free. Given that manufacturing costs are typically a tiny fraction of sales price, this is not an expensive warranty. This will also give them incentive to make expiry dates as reasonable as possible.
- pitaa 9y agoI was once sedated for a procedure, and heard the Doctor ask for a certain type of needle. The Nurse replied that they were out; she had just thrown them all away since they were expired. The Dr asked "how expired", and she said "2 weeks". He replied that that was fine, he wanted them anyway. And then I heard the lid on the trash can opening... I found it quite humorous; I couldn't care less that their supplies were a bit 'expired,' nor that the sealed packages had sat in the trash can for a bit!
- maxerickson 9y agoWhat's going on with our healthcare system that pharmaceutical grade baking soda is being rationed? W T F.
- refurb 9y agoIt's the generic drug business. Competition is purely though price. That squeezes margins significantly, even for more capital intensive product like injectables. If you're a manufacturer who has a sudden quality control issue, it often makes more sense to just shut down production than try and fix it and lose a ton of money.
- maxerickson 9y agoIt seems that when it comes to business consolidation, what is good for the goose is not good for the gander (apparently there are 2 suppliers left in the US).
- wolfgang42 9y agoMore discussion here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14798615 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14798615 It seems the problem is that the suppliers' supplier had a problem supplying a component (not the bicarbonate itself, but the vial it comes in, I think) and this caused production to come to a halt while the issue was being sorted out. Presumably this particular component has been certified in some way and replacing it with an alternative requires recertification, though the news articles merely say that the companies could not divulge additional details.
- maxerickson 9y agoThat's the proximate explanation. I wonder more about whether such a fragile supply chain is inevitable in a mostly capitalistic society or whether we could do more to ensure stability.
- 23443463453 9y agoBeyond just drug expiration dates, I really wish we could get legislation that requires printing the actual expiration date of foods. Not to focus on any one particular group, but I have received suspicious looks when I suggested that dry goods or even canned goods are edible well beyond the nonsense "best by" dates.
- lovemenot 9y agoDue to complexity it doesn't seem realistic to try to save money by using legacy drugs. On the other hand, the economics of pharma industry are such that manufacturing cost is usually a very small proportion of price. Therefore a better solution would be to introduce a mandatory new-for-old trade-in policy. So they wouldn't lose money on the deal, pharma companies would be rewarded at mfg cost. I.e. sans profit, marketing or research cost.
- PixelB 9y agoGreat idea, never going to happen. Why would they sign up for that when they can just as easily charge full price for those replacement drugs (as they do now)? The only people out there who can change this are making huge profits from the system currently in place, so why would they?
- lovemenot 9y agoThere might be some up-side in terms of reputation gain, but it would have to be imposed by a regulator.
- devy 9y agoRead similar article on HN before. U.S. Army was able to save millions after FDA okays them to use expired drugs.[1] [1]: https://www.thepharmaletter.com/article/fda-tests-let-military-use-expired-drugs https://www.thepharmaletter.com/article/fda-tests-let-milita...
- srtjstjsj 9y agoyes. For the scientists in OP to say they were surprised, they completely failed sat lit review.
- cwkoss 9y agoSeems like an easy fix would be to require the manufacturers of patented drugs to replace, free of charge, any unused expired drugs. Incentivizes the manufacturers to accurately measure expiration times and the marginal cost to them of replacement is much less than to the consumer.
- Steeeve 9y agoA silicon valley startup by the name of SIRUM (http://www.sirum.org/ http://www.sirum.org/) has done some pretty incredible work in this space. They re-distribute medicine nearing it's expiration from hospitals/pharmacies/etc. with surplus to areas that need it and can use it before it expires. I'm sure they do more - I only have a slim memory from hearing one of their founder's speak. They do have a pretty incredible impact and deserve mention in this conversation - they've been attacking this problem from a "what can we do now" perspective for the last 5 or 6 years while others have been spending time debating what to do or if anything really needs to be done. They are good people.
- kiahjw 9y agoSIRUM Co-founder here! Super pumped and happy to chat with anyone! We help orgs donate surplus meds that are often short-dated. We're tackling the $5B of unused, UNEXPIRED meds that go to waste every year in the U.S.
- dfinlen 9y agoDrug Expiration Date Excuses FDA requires testing. testing expensive... really ... how hard would it be to grab 50 tablets per drug for each environment (high UV, extreme humidity etc..) let them sit and once a year grab a pill and run chem analysis. Sounds like it could pretty much be automated, except for maybe the maintenance of the environments. Maybe 500k to 1m per year with the work out sourced with various statistical validations. (Yes I realize this is hard part, damn humans) Take all the generic tablets and voila.. Drugs are cheap to produce Really though, medicine doesn't cost much. It costs because society deemed it so. As it's been explained above/below, but, paying for research, marketing and regulations is probably 90% of the cost. The hard question is A more interesting question is how much can we afford to help others when they are sick? If the difference between health is as trivial as getting the right medicine I know I'd feel guilty if I didn't do something. This is especially true for chronic disease, as the cost benefit is tilted.
- dfinlen 9y agoDrug Expiration Date excuses. FDA requires testing. testing expensive... really ... how hard would it be to grab 50 tablets per drug for each environment (high UV, extreme humidity etc..) let them sit and once a year grab a pill and run chem analysis. Sounds like it could pretty much be automated, except for maybe the maintenance of the environments. Maybe 500k to 1m per year with the work out sourced and gov't providing oversight. Take all the generic tablets and voila.. Drugs are cheap to produce. Really though, medicine doesn't cost much. It costs because society deemed it so. As it's been explained above/below, but, paying for research, marketing and regulations is probably 90% of the cost. The hard question is. A more interesting question is how much can we afford to help others when they are sick? If the difference between health is as trivial as getting the right medicine I know I'd feel guilty if I didn't do something. This is especially true for chronic disease, as the cost benefit is tilted.