13 ms·
Snap falls to IPO price
- stevenj 9y agoI think Snap's stock price will continue to fall (to under $10) and then at some point it'll be acquired, possibly by an asian company or investment group.
- JumpCrisscross 9y agoLock-up expires 29 August [1]. On the other hand, they have $3.2bn of cash and short-term investments (as of 31 March) while burning about $600MM of cash from their operations (FYE 31 December 2016) a year. That's 5 years to get it right. EDIT: insider lock-up at T+150 comes in at the end of July. [1] http://www.nasdaq.com/markets/ipos/company/snap-inc-899497-82723 http://www.nasdaq.com/markets/ipos/company/snap-inc-899497-8...
- chollida1 9y ago> Lock-up expires 29 August [1]. Its actually the end of July for the first and most important IPO lockup expiry. > The first key lock-up date for Snap will occur roughly 150 days following the IPO. At that point, pre-IPO investors, such as company insiders, will be allowed to sell their shares. The second major lock-up date applies to 25% of the shares that were offered in the IPO itself. Of the 200 million total IPO shares, 50 million of the shares will be restricted for one year.
- jonbarker 9y agoFounding team cashed out pre-IPO for hundreds of millions each.
- chollida1 9y agoNot sure this is really news worthy. They've been heavily shorted for a while now and their puts are expensive. But really 1 Billion new shares could flood the market in just a few more weeks. To put it in perspective I believe Twitter, the other poster child for giving away options, had about half that amount. Even the IPO underwriters are starting to crack. Credit Suisse used the stock drop to keep an "outperform" rating on the stock while lowering its target from $30 to $25. IMHO Snap will do just fine for hte next year. They are big enough that companies will carve out a piece of their marketing budgets for Snap. It won't be until a year later when they have enough data on how well their Snap advertising is working that they'll decide if its worth it or not.
- mmanfrin 9y agoPardon my language but: no fucking shit. $20bil was unbelievably overpriced. This is the one major tech stock that I simply do not get. ~$125 a user is insane.
- acchow 9y agoFacebook is >$200 per user.
- charlesdm 9y agoFacebook was having decent growth at the time. Snap is undergoing massive competition from both Instagram, WhatsApp AND Facebook. Personally don't believe in the stock. Perhaps at $5 to 7 a share I would buy in, but I'm not really seeing it.
- toomuchtodo 9y agoFor Facebook, it's not unreasonable. For SNAP, it is.
- __jal 9y agoFacebook is a panopticon with a massive dataset on each user, and has a pretty substantial moat by way of users 'punishing' each other for leaving, among other competitive advantages. Snapchat is a trendy app that could easily become uncool, and when it does, I don't see how users feel much of a penalty for leaving in the same way FB users do.
- fergie 9y ago> Facebook ... has a pretty substantial moat by way of users 'punishing' each other for leaving What do you mean by this?
- boobsbr 9y agoI think it's because you might lose contact with people if you don't have a FB profile. If you're not on FB and don't interact with your 'friends' frequently, people kinda forget you exist and stop talking to you, and friendships wither. Even geographically close friendships. Kinda like being ostracised.
- skywhopper 9y agoAs skeptical as I am that Snap will ever be a moneymaker, this data point is not meaningful in any way. Facebook traded below (often _well_ below) its IPO price for the first 15 months on the market.
- bdcravens 9y agoI don't think the two are equivalent however.
- exelius 9y agoAgree with you here -- Facebook had a well-formed mobile strategy, the only question was whether it would work. Once it started to work, the stock took off like a rocket. Snap is a much bigger question mark. So far their plan looks to be "Do what Facebook did, only for AR/VR". Except Facebook and Snap will be splitting the market; where Facebook had no competition and absolute dominance before they IPOed. Facebook is obviously playing to win on Snap's home turf. Even if Snap is successful, Facebook will make it very expensive for them.
- wuliwong 9y agoI haven't been following SnapChat too closely, I know they made some glasses not too long ago. It is surprising to me that they are trading on the ID that they will be more successful in AR/VR. I can't imagine have invested nearly as much into AR/VR as Facebook/Oculus. Amount invested doesn't mean success for sure but I expect Facebook to be at the forefront of AR/VR at least in the near future.
- bdcravens 9y agoMy understanding is that the glasses were little more than a gimicky way to get more use of their platform. Felt kinda CueCat-ish to me.
- giobox 9y agoAR is unfortunately such a broad label, covering an enormous variety of implementations from dedicated headsets to phone cameras. I'd argue Snapchat delivered one of the first mainstream AR 'hits' - many of my friends can't get enough of their AR photo filters. To be fair, many of them are extremely impressive tech demos, fluidly augmenting the user's face in real time video. Whether that's a meaningful strategic advantage is another question!
- beager 9y agoWhat does $SNAP need to do to deliver on the hype? Is there anything that can make $SNAP a good investment for anyone other than the parties involved in trading the IPO? I tend to be bearish on $SNAP in general, but I'm interested in the discussion. How do they right the ship and boost back up to that $25-30 range? What's their play?
- physcab 9y ago- Positive user growth numbers, not flat or negative - Positive revenue growth numbers, not flat or negative - New features launched and positively accepted in the market
- skinnymuch 9y agoSo they need to do almost everything right and have luck on their side with things like positive acceptance. A betting man prob doesn't like all those bullet points needed.
- nikkwong 9y ago+1 this. I've asked multiple people and ideas are mostly mixed on what Snap's strategy should be going forward. Being a social app will definitely be a difficult play. IMO they could try to leverage their AR expertise to do, well, something. But social definitely seems like it will be tough. Good luck to the team though. It must be a stressful time there.
- jayess 9y agoThe fact that no one is responding with ideas tells you what you need to know.
- dingo_bat 9y ago> AR expertise to do, well, something Is it really a big expertise now? I think it was a big deal when they started those face filters but now even small players have that stuff. For example, hike: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.bsb.hike https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.bsb.hike
- cft 9y agoFinancially it does not matter for the founders that much anymore. Significant wealth has already been transferred and cashed out: http://www.nasdaq.com/quotes/insiders/spiegel-evan-1016829 http://www.nasdaq.com/quotes/insiders/spiegel-evan-1016829
- adventured 9y agoThere are only a handful of people on the planet that could reasonably claim that $1.4 billion doesn't matter that much to them (and none of them are likely to actually hold that belief). It's an absurd premise to claim that 80%-90% of someone's wealth does not matter much to them. Not to mention implying all sorts of horrible things about their character in the process (to claim what you are, is identical to claiming that Spiegel is ok with losing that money as opposed to keeping it and doing something good with it, that he would feel indifferent to the contrast of said scenario).
- tanderson92 9y agoI believe the point is more about the marginal utility of wealth and what additional products and services $1.4 billion can buy relative to the $250+MM net worth they have now.
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago$250 million means I need to fundraise to build my spaceship. With $1.4 billion, I can get started on a Dyson sphere. Depends on your goals.
- gpolak 9y agoIf you think you can completely encompass a star for quarter the price of an aircraft carrier, damn what's your secret? :)
- tanderson92 9y ago
- habosa 9y ago$17.00 was the IPO price but only for investors with access. Your average investor with an eTrade account saw a price of $24.00+ when the market opened that morning, and it hit almost $27.00 that day. So those folks have seen a 30%+ drop since IPO. Given that Snap paid out billions in IPO bonuses to executives and other employees, it's turned out to be a pretty big wealth transfer from retail investors to Snap employees.
- acchow 9y agoDid you try to subscribe to the IPO? It was not hard at all. I'm an "average" investory with a standard Charles Schwab trading account and subscribed to it with a few clicks of my mouse. I imagine anyone else could with their brokerage. It was oversubscribed tho, so I got half the quantity I wanted and sold shortly after opening.
- WheelsAtLarge 9y agoNot everyone was able to buy at the IPO price. My friend was invited but could not buy any shares. BTW, being invited does not mean you'll be able to buy. It just means you'll be able to request shares.
- prostoalex 9y agoYep, same here. Fidelity account with pretty low balance but profiled for "aggressive growth", opted into their IPOs, and I got an invitation to participate. Blue Apron, too, among others.
- davidw 9y ago> It was oversubscribed tho, so I got half the quantity I wanted and sold shortly after opening. This seems like a pretty good reason to auction the shares in order to maximize the amount of money the company takes in. That they very rarely do has always seemed kind of dirty to me.
- acchow 9y agoGoogle tried to be cheeky and go the auction way. It was wrought with problems. As far as I can tell, all tech IPOs following that went back the traditional way.
- zitterbewegung 9y agoFollowing snapchats fluctuations about its stock price is somewhat interesting . To be honest though I'm getting fatigued on this. I remember when Facebook IPOed and we were getting similar posts. The fact that Snap was able to IPO and get money to become more competitive will have to wait for a few quarters though.
- naturalgradient 9y agoI think the situation is not comparable at all precisely because Facebook did not have a larger network strangulating their growth. I wonder if there is any precedent for a social network (or any large application for that matter) having their growth stalled to single-digits and then it picking up again. To me, it looks like there is a very real possibility that facebook already killed them in the sense that they will never go beyond 250 million or so users, which does not support their valuation. So share-wise, they might end up a second Twitter, just with a much faster turnaround this time because user growth has already come to a grinding halt.
- korzun 9y agoI think it is safe to say that the IPO was a total scam. The company was never profitable, and numbers never made any sense. I have a bridge in Brooklyn up for grabs (cheap) if you still think the valuation was based on ridiculous data points such as active users, etc. People already lined their pockets up and you will be reading another P.R piece on how great of a businessman Evan is within the next couple of months. Spend all of the funding on aggressive marketing to get the numbers up pre-IPO, file for an IPO and cash out. Rinse & repeat.
- jayess 9y ago> I think it is safe to say that the IPO was a total scam. Precisely.
- gruez 9y agoIs it really a scam if there was no deception and every buyer knew what they were getting into?
- cocktailpeanuts 9y agois pyramid scheme a scam?
- NDT 9y agoYes, people that buy into them are just dumb.
- mmmpop 9y agoInvest in the things you love and use most! What could go wrong?!
- andirk 9y agobut dikpiks can only get you so far, no matter how wonderful we all collectively think they are. I think this was L.A.'s attempt at a Silicon Valley.
- gigatexal 9y agomaybe twitter should buy them
- dfrey 9y agosnapchat baffles me. It's just another instant messaging platform except that they came up with the idea of messages that delete themselves after a time period. The problem is that this killer feature is easily subverted by taking a picture of your screen. So basically, they have provided an instant messaging platform with one extra useless feature.
- beager 9y agoMore to the point, this "killer feature" is easily cloned by a competitor and shows that the product creates no competitive barriers. Coupled with the fact that the cloner has a much better idea of their users and can target ads much more successfully, this creates a long road for $SNAP.
- thaumasiotes 9y ago> More to the point, this "killer feature" is easily cloned by a competitor This doesn't really agree with > The problem is that this killer feature is easily subverted Let's let one company implement the feature before we decide it will be easy for competitors to implement it too.
- gomox 9y agoWhatsApp, Instagram and FB all have it now. TBH I only see widespread use of it on Instagram, but everyone around me seems to have stopped giving a crap about Snapchat since.
- thaumasiotes 9y agoYou missed my point. Do WhatsApp, Instagram, or Facebook Messenger have working ephemeral messages? Or do they have marketing that claims they have ephemeral messages? The feature is fundamentally impossible in exactly the same way as DRM, because it is DRM. You're sending someone a bunch of data and saying "now, you promise not to look at this, right? Except once."
- smpetrey 9y agoFor your consideration, not a single share purchased is a voting share. SNAP’s shares should be closer to $13.
- pgwhalen 9y agoI'm curious, why $13? Why not worthless? (I don't believe they should be worthless, but I'm curious how you decided on the precise middle ground)
- andirk 9y agoWith no knowledge other than using the app and from general bar talk, I saw this as a huge flop. I wish I shorted it. It may have potential, but I don't see what that potential is when their features are so incredibly easy to mimic. And no, SnapChat, I don't care what Puff Daddy did with Beyonce or whatever it is their news feed tells me.
- jdavid 9y agoBased on revenue and flat growth, the company is worth about $4 a share. If it get's to that price I'll think about buying in, if and only if i think the company is going to turn it around. I've made good money waiting for the time to be right before buying in. This stock is worthless above $8 a share.
- speg 9y agoWhy not making money in the meantime going short?
- blahblah3322 9y agoHave most employees sold their RSUs yet?
- bsaul 9y agoi wonder if the community realizes how bad those kind of overhyped companies makes us look to the general audience, with founders cashing out shortly after the stock gets public and everybody realizes valuation were simply absurd. i don't think we'll have to wait for a long time before we see traditional investment funds and banks not willing to take part in that game anymore.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- havella 9y agoAs an excercise for the reader, would be interesting to test the performance of a buy and hold strategy of stocks a.) Going below IPO price, b.) Going below 50% IPO price. A second filter that can be applied is the time span between first day of trading of such event.
- swetabhsuman8 9y agoREGISTRATION STARTED FOR HACKERS BASIC EXAM https://hackernucleus.com/registration-for-hbe/ https://hackernucleus.com/registration-for-hbe/ HACKERS ARE USING THIS NEW ATTACK METHOD TO TARGET POWER COMPANIES https://hackernucleus.com/hackers-are-using-this-new-attack-method-to-target-power-companies/ https://hackernucleus.com/hackers-are-using-this-new-attack-... BEST HACKING TOOLS OR SOFTWARE WITH EXPLANATION https://hackernucleus.com/best-hacking-tools-or-software-with-explanation/ https://hackernucleus.com/best-hacking-tools-or-software-wit...
- Rjevski 9y agoI can't understand what are they doing to not make any profits. They are selling ads. Server resources to exchange the pictures are a minor cost, so where is all that ad money going to? If they stopped wasting money on development time making their UX even worse, or stupid stuff like Spectacles, or this: https://www.recode.net/2017/6/17/15824222/snapchat-ferris-wheel-cannes-ad https://www.recode.net/2017/6/17/15824222/snapchat-ferris-wh... - maybe they would actually be making profits right now.
- olegkikin 9y agoThey have 1-5K employees. Even if you take a median salary of $40K, that's $40-200M/year. That's just the salaries with no taxes/overhead and no consideration that IT salaries are generally much higher.
- pcurve 9y agoSnapchat has 2000 employees roughly. But why? And why does twitter need 4000 employees? What do they all do? edit: n/m. Their job postings are quite telling. https://www.snap.com/en-US/jobs/ https://www.snap.com/en-US/jobs/ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oEli06ID6t8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oEli06ID6t8
- salesguy222 9y agoActually they are contractually obligated to spend billions of dollars with Google's hosted server (... "cloud" ...) business arm. https://www.recode.net/2017/3/1/14661126/snap-snapchat-ipo-spending-2-billion-google-cloud https://www.recode.net/2017/3/1/14661126/snap-snapchat-ipo-s...
- mrweasel 9y ago>They are selling ads. They do? Where does those ads show up? I've never seen ads on Snapchat, I get the feeling that most people aren't.
- Rjevski 9y agoThey had a "Discover" section at the top of the stories which are essentially sponsored stories companies (like Buzzfeed) pay for. Now they've changed them and it looks like sponsored snaps appear in between your friend's snaps when you view their stories.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- nicolrx 9y agoAll my friends are turning off their Snapchat account to keep using Instagram that does the same + better photo features.
- opendomain 9y agoIs is much below the IPO price now currently 15/62 but trending lower This is before the lockup period ends when ususal new stocks drop