9 ms·
I grew up on the Commodore 64 (1 Core, 1 hyper-thread :-), almost 1 MHz clock freq, almost 64 K usable RAM). The machine was usually pretty responsive, but whe
by weinzierl 9y ago
I grew up on the Commodore 64 (1 Core, 1 hyper-thread :-), almost 1 MHz clock freq, almost 64 K usable RAM).
The machine was usually pretty responsive, but when I typed too quickly in my word processor it sometimes got stuck and ate a few characters. I used to think: "If computers were only fast enough so I could type without interruption...". If you'd asked me back then for a top ten list what I wished computers could do, this would certainly have been on the list.
Now, 30 years later, whenever my cursor gets stuck I like to think:
"If computers were only fast enough so I could type without interruption..."
- fredley 9y agoIt's all just trade offs. However fast or powerful your machine is, software will use as much of that resource as possible, up to the point where it occasionally interferes with input (but not too much or you'll switch to something else).
- anigbrowl 9y agoBut why? What good is an operating system on a multi-core device that allows anything to get that close to the performance envelope? This is a fine example of competition driving change for change's sake rather than real innovation and everything ending up worse as a result. I like new features as much as the next person, but not when they compromise core functionality. Not being able to type is inexcusable.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoI agree. However at this point, I don't see anything an OS can do to help. I see plenty of typing slowdowns every other day now. But I'm not sure just how many of them are the OS's fault. When your typing seems to lag, there are two places that can be slowing it down - the input side (reacting to hardware events) and the output side (drawing and updating the UI). I suppose keyboard buffers are pretty well isolated, and native UI controls tend to work fine too. The problem is, everyone now goes for non-native controls. You type in e.g. Firefox, and it is slow not because of your OS, but because Firefox does all its UI drawing by itself. And God help you if the application you want to use is done in Electron. There's so many layers of non-nativeness on top of that, that the OS has close to zero say in what's being done. There's no way to help that - resource quotas will only make the problem worse, and giving such program free reign will only take everything else down. All in all, it's just - again - problem of people writing shitty software, because of laziness and time-to-market reasons. Blame "Worse is Better".
- noir_lord 9y agoIntellij still freezes while indexing on my work desktop which has 8 cores and 16 threads, at least they finally allowed pause/resume for that so that's a win.
- jug 9y agoAgreed, abstraction seem to be exploding these days and I’m not even sure we are at the end of the road yet! Linux or Windows never had any trouble with essentially realtime keyboard feedback in their Terminal windows. It’s not the OS.
- mark-r 9y agoIt's hard to believe the OS couldn't help when Windows 10 has the problem but Windows 7 doesn't.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoIn this particular case, yes. But this subthread was about a more general principle of letting an app exhaust system's performance. What I'm saying is that, when facing a crappily coded app, the OS can at best choose between letting it suck or letting the performance of everything suck.
- simias 9y agoYou have alternatives though. I've been using basically the same linux environment for about a decade now. I don't have a proper desktop environment like Gnome or KDE, just Xorg and StumpWM as a window manager. Then I have Firefox, Emacs and urxvt running tmux. I use a handful of GTK applications when the need arises like Gimp, Inkscape, Evince and maybe a couple others. Done. It boots up in a few seconds from a SSD, it's always snappy. It worked fine on a core2duo and HDD 10 years ago, it works even better on an i5 and SSD now.
- anigbrowl 9y agoYeah I have a Linux environment on a keychain USB device that I now use often enough to think seriously about abandoning Windows (though I don't hate Win as such, but kept using it because of some applications I relied upon). Linux has (sometimes) had sort of the opposite problem, insufficient innovation in user interface design. I'm looking forward to Gnome 3 now; I felt that when CSS took over the web a lot of UI innovation moved to the server end and stalled at the client (think the really long hiatus in the development of Enlightenment, which was at one time the cutting edge of UI design/customizability while still being fast and responsive). If you want ideas for where Linux capabilities should b going, please go check out Flowstone, which I think is criminally under-appreciated. The current version uses Ruby, but previous incarnations allowed you deploy code in C or assembler(!) within the visual programming environment. It's doin' me a heckin' confuse that this isn't a standard development environment option for everything from shell scripts to large-scale applications. Once you go to flow-based programming text-only IDEs look masochistic and pointless, and text-only is a terrible way to teach programming to people because discovery and syntax are inaccessible and really better done by computers. I like NoFlo for js development but the Linux desktop is crying out to be brought into a flow-based paradigm. Sorry about going a bit off-topic but when I see exhortations to go with extremely simple solutions like StumpWM I have the opposite-but-similar reaction to the OP: why am I running some beast of a computer (at least by historical standards) so I can have a 20 year old user interface? Surely there is some middle ground between cancerous levels of abstraction/feature creep and monk-like asceticism.
- agumonkey 9y agoThere's a talk by Guy Steele 'growing a language', he says that ideally a language should shrink as it gets smarter semantics.
- gkya 9y agoThat's is better rewritten as "however fast or powerful your machine is, software will waste as much of that resource as possible".
- wutbrodo 9y ago"...if you let it". Some of us have decided that the value of marginal eye candy et al isn't worth interrupting our UI flow. I suspect that many people would have decided the same if most modern OSes weren't built around removing so much control from the user.
- Aloha 9y agoSimilar in sentiment to "I have always wished for my computer to be as easy to use as my telephone; my wish has come true because I can no longer figure out how to use my telephone."
- Yuioup 9y agoYour Commodore 64 had one hyper-thread? Wow, that's forward thinking.
- torrent-of-ions 9y agoPlus ça change, plus c'est la même chose...
- jmartinpetersen 9y ago"The more it changes, the more it’s the same thing." [0] [0]: https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/plus_%C3%A7a_change,_plus_c%27est_la_m%C3%AAme_chose https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/plus_%C3%A7a_change,_plus_c%2...
- twobyfour 9y agoThe common idiomatic translation is "the more things change, the more they stay the same."
- virtualwhys 9y agoFor English the equivalent meaning would be, "the more things change, the more they remain the same". I don't think I've ever heard the literal translation in English.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- anigbrowl 9y agoI have almost the same background (Vic-20, if you thought programming was hard try having only 3.5k of RAM) and feel the same irritation...but I don't wonder why computers aren't faster, I wonder why operating systems and application is so utterly shit. I have a Moto X phone (not too old) and watching it slow down is almost comical. Sometimes I'll decide to close a few apps and hitting the selector button brings up screenshots of all the open apps. Then I have to wait a few seconds for the X to appear on the app frames so I can close them. If I had the inclination and temperment to be one of those YouTube personalities who makes a schtick out of complaining about things I would have no shortage of material for a 'designed by idiots' channel.
- staofbur 9y agoI think most of the shit is concentrated on a couple of notable platforms: Windows and Android. Outside of that space I've noticed less productivity hampering nightmare tools and OS features. Really I get perhaps one or two bits of stupid from Linux a year on the server-side, usually when integrating it with Windows ironically, and on the macOS/iOS front I haven't had a notable issue since I switched about a year ago.
- jonathanstrange 9y agoI'm using Linux for my daily work for more than ten years now and develop for MacOS since around 2000, and I honestly cannot confirm this. If you have a fast and well-tuned machine, the sluggishness of modern applications might not be so notable, but it surely is there, and then there are also many usability issues of desktop software on Linux. Not to speak of browser-based applications, which mostly have unusable user interfaces anyway. For MacOS, usability is still high, but the multithreading and API layering on Cocoa is and always has felt sluggish to me. I no longer use Mail.app but remember it as a particularly bad example. I agree with the OP, for actual use computers can do more powerful things than they used to be able to, no doubt about that, but programs and operating systems continue to feel slow and clumsy. Android in particular, but in the end all operating systems. Bloated GUI frameworks, use of unoptimized images in GUIs, and non-optimal multicore programming are to blame, I guess.
- RJIb8RBYxzAMX9u 9y agoExcept without interrupts, your computer would miss all the keystrokes. :-)
- hypervis0r 9y agoThat's so deep, it hit me in the IDT
- agumonkey 9y agoway more naive but my first own desktop was a P75, a few years down a friend of a friend got his hand on a batch of P233MMX and I started to fantasize that these could be so fast, the menus may appear before you even finished clicking. I didn't know how non linear computers were at the time. Few things also, I'm often surprised how fixed is the responsiveness of systems, hardware grew 3-4 orders of magnitude but the cruft and chaos plus the change of resolutions keep latency around the same value. It's sometimes even worse. Psychologically when I boot a 64MB windows machine and can enjoy word / IE / winamp I feel very weird (video could be offloaded to a chromecast for that matter).
- twobyfour 9y agoThe worst is when this happens when you're not doing anything that should be computationally intensive, just entering text in a web app that abuses JavaScript.
- Houshalter 9y agoEven just entering text into the search bar uses loads of resources. Every character entered does a full search of your history and bookmarks, sends a request to Google to do autocomplete, prefetches the web page you are typing, applies spellcheck, etc.
- twobyfour 9y agoSure, but I for one have yet to experience input lag typing into a URL bar when my computer wasn't otherwise under extremely heavy load.
- digi_owl 9y agoWhy i refuse to indulge the latest eyecandy and bling from the desktop world if possible. If i didn't need a GPU to do window switching back then, why do i need it now?
- swiley 9y agoFVWM and VTWM switch windows and workspaces instantaneously on my crappy netbook with just the EFI framebuffer. I always laugh a little inside watching people try to do the same on windows 10 and OSX with all the hardware acceleration and waiting multiple for seconds.
- marcosdumay 9y agoTo save battery power.
- digi_owl 9y agoThen stop drawing all the eyecandy in the first place.
- mmargerum 9y agoI remember writing C code on my Commodore 64 in my early teens using Power C from spinnaker software. If memory serves I had to put 3 different 5 1/4 disks in to compile / link. There were compiler 1, compiler 2, and a linker diskette.
- ghostly_s 9y agoWeird that no-one here is mentioning how Windows is the only platform that still has this problem. UI threads on a graphical desktop should always be the most privileged processes.