7 ms·
I'll vouch for the effectiveness of losing 30+kg (65+lb). Which only reduces the back pain problem for overweight people to a known-intractable weight loss pr
by bigiain 9y ago
I'll vouch for the effectiveness of losing 30+kg (65+lb).
Which only reduces the back pain problem for overweight people to a known-intractable weight loss problem... :-/
- femto 9y agoAgree that weight/load is an issue. In my experience, a measurable side effect of a daily routine is some weight loss, which if nothing else provides motivation for continuing.
- taneq 9y agoWeight loss isn't "known intractable". Physically it's very simple, if an overweight person is physically prevented from eating too much, they'll lose weight, just like physically it's very simple to quit addictive drugs. And the drug analogy is a good one, because just like quitting drugs, you can't quit overeating (barring the aforementioned option of someone physically preventing you from doing so - which is literally what gastric sleeve surgery and the like are doing) until you actually choose to. When you wake up in the morning, look at yourself in the mirror, and instead of "oh I'm so fat" or "it's not fair" or "I wish I could lose weight", you think "I choose to lose weight by controlling what I eat", then you lose weight. And it stays off for as long as your choice holds.
- beebmam 9y agoIt is not physically simple to quit addictive drugs. It depends on the drug. Even alcohol is not simple to quit, depending on the person: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Delirium_tremens https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Delirium_tremens
- taneq 9y agoA few people seem to be reading my comment as "dietary restriction is easy and so is quitting addictive drugs." I meant the comparison with addictive drugs to illustrate how difficult it is to resist the urge to overeat. And I believe the two cases are essentially the same - you can't save an addict who doesn't want to be saved, and you can't convince a fat person to diet if they don't want to lose weight more than they want to eat food.
- Cthulhu_ 9y agoTIL what the beer brand is based on, thanks for that :p. (it's a strong beer with a pink elephant logo, very good stuff)
- logicallee 9y agoyou do not even need that. just set appetite = 80 in the human source code so you start eating 80÷ of your daily caloric use. the pounds will melt off. when you have a goal weight set appetite = 100÷ and you will simply stay at that weight. it is very simple physically. as for where to set it, I have nothing to say about it just as you have nothing to say about how to make a choice. /s The fact is, a choice fat people can make is "I will get gastric sleeve surgery" and this "commit" is statistically enough. the "commit" that parent suggests is the same as my suggestion at the top. I give no practical advice at the top of this comment and neither does parent comment. if there were a variable that would set someone's appetite and saciety then it would work. if there were a variable for commitment then parent's advice would work. parent ignores the hard work of finding and setting that variable, and parent ignores statistics that most fat people have spent a few dozen hours looking for how to set that variable and have failed to do so. your advice is as bad as when people defend some totally useless setup on the grounds that it's turing complete. yes, you can make a social media app with a custom backend written in C++. No that does not work statistically and most people who set out to do so fail. but physically it's very simple. reasonable people don't ignore the statistics.
- moogly 9y agohttps://www.nytimes.com/2016/05/08/opinion/sunday/why-you-cant-lose-weight-on-a-diet.html https://www.nytimes.com/2016/05/08/opinion/sunday/why-you-ca... Apparently, boffins are starting to realise it's not that simple.
- tome 9y agoA neuroscientist claims neuroscience is the key component that makes weight loss difficult. Colour me sceptical.
- zurn 9y agoConstant application of great amounts of willpower against your most basic biological instincts is possible for some individuals, but generally you are really arguing against the dictionary definition [1]. [1] [trak-tuh-buh l] .. easily managed or controlled; docile; yielding:
- mirimir 9y agoThere's been strong selection, I suspect, for overeating when food is available. Also for focusing utilization on essential stuff when it's limited.
- panglott 9y agoIt's not mere availability of food. Obesity rates vary quite widely across OECD countries; the US is at 35%, France/Italy/Spain are at about 5-10%, Korea is below 4%. Overeating is a stress response for a lot of people, and overeating often occurs among people in high-stress situations. The US is a country that tolerates a very high level of poverty, inequality, and insecurity, and this results in high obesity rates in some sectors. Obesity isn't the same problem for people who shop at Whole Foods and spend hours at the gym on weekends; it's a more severe problem among people who have to work a horrible job 60-80 hours a week to avoid really desperate poverty, live in decrepit housing, spend hours on neglected bus lines, and are physically insecure.
- mirimir 9y agoThose are good points. Heavy marketing of highly processed food that's loaded with fat and sugars is also an issue. Maybe also because that crap is relatively inexpensive.
- vonmoltke 9y agoWhere are your numbers from? According to Wikipedia's summary of a 2014 WHO report the US is at 33.7%, France is at 24%, and the major Anglo nations in between. There is not nearly the disparity between the US and the rest of the world you claim. Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_Body_Mass_Index_(BMI)#WHO_Data_on_Prevalence_of_Obesity_.28BMI_.E2.89.A5_30kg.2Fm2.29_.282014.29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_Body_Mass...
- onion2k 9y agoYou're right that weight loss is largely a mental rather than a physical issue, but very, very wrong to suggest it's as simple as making a choice. Mental health issues can prevent someone from making good, rational decisions, and the notion that they're somehow failing to make an "easy" choice shows a contemptuous lack of understanding and compassion.
- tome 9y ago> very, very wrong to suggest it's as simple as making a choice taneq didn't suggest that.
- PhasmaFelis 9y ago> Physically it's very simple So is cutting your arm off with a hacksaw. "Simple" does not mean "easy."
- tome 9y agoAnd that is exactly taneq's point.
- PhasmaFelis 9y agoThen he made it very poorly, as the other responses here attest.
- pif 9y ago> Weight loss isn't "known intractable". Indeed, weight loss is "simple", as you said. The problem arises when you have managed to get to your target and you realize that, short of amphetamines or similarly dangerous drugs, there is no known way to keep your weight stable with an acceptable life quality. Obese people are not stupid when they choose to keep eating; they've just learnt by experience that, unless you solve the hunger problem, loosing weight will not yield a better life. By the way, surgery actually looks like an option.
- mukundmr 9y agoI switched to one full meal a day and fruits / salads / soup for the other times. This takes care of hunger issues and helps with losing weight. Change of habit is required and it is not easy. Bariatric surgery can help, but it has it's own annoying side effects and long term (>7 years) reports aren't available widely.
- pif 9y ago> Change of habit is required Sure, obesity is clearly (also) a problem of bad habits. The question that still needs an answer is: when will the new habit become natural for me? Hunger is not like exercising: while a couple years of training can make a marathon feel natural for the body of a former sedentary person, no amount of training (AFAIK) can either ease the feeling of satiety with the correct amount of calories or set your stomach/brain system to "hunger is normal" state. Edit to add: I'd lovee to be proven wrong :-)
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoSatiety is apparently a complex mix including mental aspects but also chewing. Have you tried chewing more? Either "over chewing" (just keep each mouthful of food in your mouth longer and chew it to a complete pulp) or lower calorie foods that you physically have to work on more to actually eat (carrots, celery, ...)? Water before eating may help you slow down too, which means your body can realise you're sated at an earlier point through the meal. Just suggestions, YMMV, IANADietician and haven't fully researched these ideas scientifically (though they are based on research I've heard about in passing).
- Dylan16807 9y ago>Weight loss isn't "known intractable". Physically it's very simple, if an overweight person is physically prevented from eating too much, they'll lose weight, just like physically it's very simple to quit addictive drugs. Locking people up away from food is even more intractable!
- dkersten 9y ago"physically it's very simple to quit addictive drugs" Quitting some drugs cold turkey can be dangerous, so "simple" isn't quite correct.
- lmm 9y ago"Holds" implies something a lot more passive than it is. Losing weight is a full-time job, harder than anything else I've done. I've succeeded over the last couple of years but only because I'm in the privileged position of literally everything else in my life going well enough that I can focus all my willpower on it.
- BearGoesChirp 9y agoThis feels only the level of suggesting a person can choose to not be depressed by thinking positive thoughts. Mental issues are 'just choices', yet we aren't sure that free will even exists or if choices can be made. Research on the brain shows it isn't nearly as simple as just choosing to be better. Brain does a great job of tricking us into thinking we have control.
- pmarreck 9y ago> Physically it's very simple Claiming weight loss is "simple" is like claiming that climbing Mount Everest is simple because you simply put one foot in front of the other and repeat until you reach the top