8 ms·
Over time, leaders lose mental capacities
- arthulia 9y agoIt would seem some leaders are born this way. I wonder how easily it can be passed to offspring (via nature or nurture).
- kebman 9y agoIt's the Atlantic... It's proven that you get brain damage from reading too much of it.
- Retra 9y agoAnd what of comments like this? Are they the cure?
- crucini 9y agoThe article seems biased: it pathologizes power. However our ability to adapt to social role is probably an important asset. Most likely the changes they measured are good for the group's survival. A leader should not be seeking approval as much as a commoner. Maybe the problem is that we've violated some unstated "design assumptions" of our tribes. As for this CEO who got hauled before Congress - a blank affect sounds like the right approach. It's just a ritual for politicians to show off for the cameras, but expressing contempt (as Shkreli did) is dangerous.
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y agoI'm not sure what relation pathologizing power has with bias? I'm also not sure that losing your empathizing ability when in power is any more adaptive than any physical sort of atrophy is adaptive when bedridden. When you're powerful you don't have to exercise the empathizing muscle and so (many) leaders don't. But they should in the same way that I should go and exercise my physical muscles even though I don't have to.
- ThrustVectoring 9y agoMuscular atrophy is definitely adaptive as an anti-starvation tool. Don't need that particular muscle? Lose the muscle and become more calorie-efficient. And you get some free caloric energy out of consuming the muscle at the same time.
- joe_the_user 9y agoMuscular atrophy certainly is the result of adaption over time. Pissing your pants when you get scared enough is also a product of adaptation. But neither is particularly convenient for a modern human today, which is clearly the actual point of the post above. Reflexive lack of empathy for people in proportion to the degree you have power over them may be a logical product of the evolution of the human organism. But it might not be something a democratic society benefits from in its leaders, to bring thing back to the topic.
- andrewflnr 9y agoA potentially useful instinct that has exceeded its bounds of usefulness is still a pathology. Eating lots of food is useful when you don't know when your next meal is, but in a modern context it leads to obesity. In this case, or seems like the CEOs' performance objectively went down, do I don't see how that's "good for the group's survival" in 2017.
- jimbokun 9y ago"The article seems biased: it pathologizes power." Nope. It just claims power lessens people's capacity for empathy.
- bjornsing 9y ago> Most likely the changes they measured are good for the group's survival. Unless I've missed something it seems much more reasonable to assume that the changes they measure were good for the leader's reproductive success, historically. That's a very different thing though...
- gech 9y agoThey didn't mention seeking approval, they mentioned losing empathy. Those in power losing empathy for others is a big deal.
- __jal 9y ago> Most likely the changes they measured are good for the group's survival Why is that "most likely"?
- Danihan 9y agoMirroring = doing whatever others are doing / fitting in. It makes sense that people in authoritative positions would not do this as often.
- cdubzzz 9y agoI don't think that is what "mirroring" means as used in this article. It's about visualizing oneself doing something someone else is doing (aka empathy, to some degree), not copying what is being done.
- DonHopkins 9y agoAs in the sense of Dr. Timothy Leary's Mind Mirror. http://www.donhopkins.com/mediawiki/index.php/Timothy_Leary%27s_Mind_Mirror http://www.donhopkins.com/mediawiki/index.php/Timothy_Leary%...
- Lagged2Death 9y agoMirroring = doing whatever others are doing / fitting in. It's a natural guess, but no. Check out: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mirror_neuron https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mirror_neuron
- qb45 9y agoStill, it seems related to understanding and following others. I think many so-called "leaders" today aren't even serious leaders but actually they have a somewhat unnatural role of imposing on their subordinates arbitrary decisions received from their superiors, cold-blooded analyses, formal processes, etc. In such situations, understanding of the subordinates is unnecessary and any subconscious tendencies to follow their emotional states actively counterproductive, as it is the "leader" whose job is to dictate reality.
- Danihan 9y agoThe article isn't talking about mirror neurons though. It's referencing the section of the brain that is used for social mirroring, I believe.
- jetsetter439 9y agoJust another intellectual circle-jerk from The Atlantic designed to make you hate people in positions of authority by discrediting their mental health through physical 'signs' of damage
- senthil_rajasek 9y agoThis article ends in a gloomy note, I fear it might even start normalizing "asshole-ery". I am reminded of a quote by Buffett or someone similar about more money turning assholes into even bigger assholes meaning there is nothing wrong in staying humble even after you become rich and powerful.
- andai 9y agoI can't access the research, but I was wondering if they tested on mostly men or if there was a decent size female group as well, and if they found any difference between men and women in this regard.
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoIf men were more susceptible in a statistically significant way they would have called it out at least as a "further research needed" because it opens the door for future resource allocation. If women were more susceptible in a statistically significant way they wouldn't have framed the discussion so negatively in terms of CEOs and world leaders but instead framed it as a health issue because doing anything else in most academic settings is being needlessly reckless and unprofessional. Since there's no mention whatsoever I'm betting there was no meaningful difference or the test group wasn't big enough to investigate the possibility of said difference.
- r-u-k-m 9y agohttp://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/jofi.12432/full http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/jofi.12432/full They don't talk about it in any sentences, but they found that female CEOs correlate with having slightly higher stock volatility (1.612). Not sure if this is a valid interpretation, as I'm reading from a table. N = 8533 CEOs, btw.
- binthere 9y agoArticle starts with jokes and it's hard for me to keep following as if it was a serious research.
- erikpukinskis 9y agoI think there is something to this, and there are also aspects of whiteness and masculinity which cause similar forms of brain damage. Before anyone jumps down my throat, I would also posit that "white" is not an ethnicity, it's the fiction of a lack of one's ethnicity. And that men are many things besides masculine. In these senses both masculinity and whiteness are defined in terms of power, not in terms of intrinsic human qualities. A white man is not such because of his Y chromosome and skin color, but because of his adherence to fictitious power dynamics tied to those things. To the extent that white men are not intrinsically masculine, and have ethnic identities, we are not White Men and we exist outside of those power dynamics, and can recover from the brain damage participation in them causes. Crossing my fingers commenters have it in their hearts to contradict me, and not just vote me out of the conversation, because this is still a pretty ethereal idea in my head. And it's difficult to find places where it feels safe to bring it up. It's something I would enjoy seeing HN's thoughts on.
- rarec 9y agoI find issue with the very first posit that you mention. White isn't an ethnicity, yet somehow Black or Hispanic, or whatever is? You presume then that attempting to be a white masculine man leads to brain damage, but what about black masculine man? Do they somehow not suffer the brain damage? Why is it considered damage in the first place? They did get in power, maybe what you see as damage is instead optimization.
- erikpukinskis 9y agoI don't think black or Hispanic are really enthicities either. They're racial categories. I think black men suffer some of the same brain damage as white men. Women with masculine personality traits probably suffer it in some conditions too. If it's real, it's a fuzzy cluster around men, not a strict aspect of manhood only.
- Kenji 9y ago>there are also aspects of whiteness and masculinity which cause similar forms of brain damage. You are an absolute lunatic. Being racist and sexist (while thinking one is the opposite) really seems to be the newest fad. >"white" is not an ethnicity, it's the fiction of a lack of one's ethnicity That doesn't even make sense. You define white in a way nobody else does.
- GhostVII 9y agoBecoming worse at empathy is not the same as brain damage, people loose certain skills all the time if they are not exercised.
- nostrebored 9y agoThere is also evidence suggesting that empathy is a poor trait in leaders/judges, are we are most probably to empathizing with people we find relatable.
- wavefunction 9y agoSo you're saying CEOs have trouble relating to the average person? ;)
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- lasermike026 9y agoAndy Kaufman used to work as bus boy when he was famous and when people asked him, "Are you Any Kaufman?" he would deny it. I wonder if doing things like this is a good treatment.
- PeanutNore 9y agoI completely misunderstood the headline going in, expecting something to do with the "current times voltage" sort of power and wondering what sort of gruesome experiment electrocuting brains was going on.
- jxramos 9y agohaha, that's what I thought too, some sort of EMF type research or something.
- jweir 9y agoAre the brain studies in this article subject to buggy and flawed fMRI research? http://www.sciencealert.com/a-bug-in-fmri-software-could-invalidate-decades-of-brain-research-scientists-discover http://www.sciencealert.com/a-bug-in-fmri-software-could-inv... edit: further reading https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/scicurious-brain/ignobel-prize-in-neuroscience-the-dead-salmon-study/ https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/scicurious-brain/ignobe...
- r-u-k-m 9y agoNo, they are not. None of these studies used FMRI; they were either statistical or behavioral, with no neurological investigation. Did you read the article? From the article you linked: "Some people like to use the salmon study as proof that fMRI is woo, but this isn't the case, it's actually a study to show the importance of correcting your stats."
- vilhelm_s 9y agoPresumably not, the mirror-neuron study does not use fMRI. It works by a measuring muscle response to transcranial magnetic stimulation. > A reliable index of resonance is the amplitude of motor-evoked potentials (MEPs) recorded from a specific muscle via electromyography (EMG), while a person observes another person acting. An MEP is elicited by applying a single, fixed intensity TMS pulse over an area of the motor cortex that corresponds to a muscle underlying the observed action. For a given intensity of stimulation, changes in MEP amplitude reflect changes in the excitability of motor cortical representations (see Figure 1; for a review, see Fadiga et al., 2005).
- goofingaround 9y agoThe research does not support this article (surprise). - The researchers primed subjects on "power" by having the subject write an essay about a high, neutral, or low power situation. It's not clear that the intervention maps to what the article calls power. - The researchers did not find statistically significant differences between the low power group and the neutral group. They also did not find significant differences between the neutral group and the high power group. If the neutral group varied this much, are we tracking meaningful differences? - Is reduced mirroring "damage"? Is reduced mirroring necessarily undesirable? We have no idea. https://www.oveo.org/fichiers/power-changes-how-the-brain-responds-to-others.pdf https://www.oveo.org/fichiers/power-changes-how-the-brain-re...
- joe_the_user 9y agoFor good or ill, this article isn't based on single paper but a range of papers from a group of authors. It's still legitimate to critique the approach but I don't think you can simply pick apart a single paper to do that.
- joaofs 9y agoI wonder if this is a common feature of leaders rather than a degenerative disease. Very competitive environments make way for sociopaths to get up to the top more frequently than normal people.
- fideloper 9y agoShower thought: So does love.
- r-u-k-m 9y agoThis is a remarkably low-quality article, and the citations are horrendously scattered throughout. This is much better, and clearer article (cited inside the original) from 2009: https://insight.kellogg.northwestern.edu/article/losing_touch https://insight.kellogg.northwestern.edu/article/losing_touc...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Houshalter 9y ago"Brain damage" is a rather extreme way of putting this. It's a slight decrease in empathy. Which sounds bad, but makes perfect sense. Empathetic people make terrible leaders. They get taken advantage of. They seek approval from others instead of making what they think is the best decision. They have trouble saying "no." They are indecisive when a decision is controversial and might upset some people. I know this because I think I am an overly empathetic person, and I know I make a terrible leader. Even watching shows like the West Wing stresses me out a bit and I don't envy people who have to make hard decisions.
- ErikVandeWater 9y agoMight the best leader be the empathetic leader who recognizes and understands others' perspectives with enough self-control to not give in to others emotions?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- brlewis 9y agoI don't think reducing empathy would improve leadership. Ideally you'd expand your empathy to people you aren't directly interacting with. For example, the difficult decision of firing a problem employee is made more difficult by empathy for that employee, but made easier by empathy for affected coworkers and customers.
- zepto 9y agoThe downsides you speak of are not caused by being empathetic. They are caused by not having developed skills in setting boundaries. Being worried about upsetting people isn't a feature of empathy. It's a feature of a lack of perspective.
- squozzer 9y agoI wonder if one could simulate the effects of power by having subjects play Civilization?
- louithethrid 9y agoA thread full of whining and angry Middel-Managers, CEOs and StartUp founders. Well at least the ability for self-pity and denial is not reduced. If you read on after this, not rambling that im a evil traitor and enemy of afuture empire - have some nostalgia. I sort of miss the old english arts of self-distance, beeing able to take a step back, to laugh even at grave personal calamitys and insults, and by laughter master them. "If only all CEOs would have studied the sociological-sciences, and all sociological scientists would have shunned the archieving of power. Im sure the wulfes would have been able to taste the diffrence in brain structure. The aroma, of specialisation absent, with a slight tinge of utopian dream come true. And they would have formed a society, holding human cattle - and philosophize in studys, that only naive cattle could hold the assumption true, that what my mirror cells define as standard, must be a standard everywhere. Howling to the moon, that eating man, gives you the madness of one-size-all-fits."
- fallingfrog 9y agoThis is a standard part of feminist theory- basically the idea is that people with no power spend a lot of time wondering what powerful people think, so they tend to have a good understanding of what powerful people think. But people in a privileged position don't really have any need to think about what less powerful people think- so they don't do it. And that's where you get the trope of women being mysterious creatures, whereas women seem to understand men perfectly. The same logic applies to bosses and workers.
- tyscorp 9y agoCalling it "logic" is a stretch.
- d33 9y agoThat's a really cool theory, but you're also stirring up the hornets' nest by bringing it up anywhere in tech environment, which got really feministic recently. BTW, one thing doesn't seem to stick: they don't label themselves as less powerful - in fact, their misandric agenda keeps trying to repeat the opposite. I personally believe that the "mysterious creature" concept stems from women being more emotional and thus more difficult to analyse - we seem to have more scientific grounds for logic, whereas we still hadn't even agreed what an emotion is.
- nonconvergent 9y ago| "Women being more emotional" You just cited the same argument to justify why the argument isn't true.
- anon808 9y ago'I personally believe that the "mysterious creature" concept stems from women being more emotional' Why do you think women (as a gender) are more emotional?
- erikpukinskis 9y agoYeah, I think that's a trope that needs unpacking to be credible. If anything, I would say women tend to be more inclined to sharing and talking about their emotions. Men tend to try to hide them, or fight them. Which often pushes us down a progression of more extreme emotions, rather than gently easing ourselves back to center. Fighting/denying our emotions also causes us to try to rationalize perceptions driven by our emotions, by ascribing them to the world around us. Because that's a false attribution, it makes it harder for our teams to get an accurate picture of the world outside our emotions.
- mmaunder 9y agoWhen you're leading a team or doing public speaking and just starting out, one of the challenges is that you second guess yourself terribly after you have chatted to the group. I think empathy is part of the cause - you see yourself (and what a complete idiot your are) from the perspective of each individual in the group. It can be debilitating if you don't figure out how to stop yourself from doing that. Part of that is turning off a certain amount of empathy. As others have pointed out, the article may be flawed. But I think the job of leader calls for reduced empathy or some way to control it and the second guessing yourself that comes with it - and that is probably what the author observed.
- jstewartmobile 9y agoI can vouch for it. When you're over people, they're never going to give you their version of the unvarnished truth. You always get the PR-filtered version. Stay in this scenario long enough, and it's very easy to start actually believing the toadies.
- perseusprime11 9y agoLeaders don't but managers do lose their mental capacities.
- cjsthompson 9y agoMore proof that elected oligarchy can't work