8 ms·
Does anybody know why development at reddit is so slow? I know they have an engineering team, but if you track the changes over the last couple years, it's not
by komali2 9y ago
Does anybody know why development at reddit is so slow? I know they have an engineering team, but if you track the changes over the last couple years, it's not much given how much time has passed. And that's not for lack of feature requests that Reddit staff have admitted would improve the site.
- sjg007 9y agoGot to keep the site up.
- jliptzin 9y agoMaybe they don't want to fix what's not broken. If their usage continues going up at acceptable rates year after year, then maybe they have all the features they need right now. I have witnessed more than a few properties decline after site owners complicated the UI with stupid features barely anyone was asking for just for the sake of working on new stuff.
- pmoriarty 9y agoYou can't even edit the title of a Reddit post. That's been known for years and nothing's been done about it.
- redthrowaway 9y agoThat's almost certainly by design. Just as with tweets, it would be massively abused.
- kalleboo 9y agoYeah I'm pretty sure mods can...
- adventured 9y agoMight make sense to make it optional per subreddit. Some communities are far less filled with trolls than others. Locked after N hours or minutes is also a potential solution elaboration that could give subreddits flexibility (on/off, if on then lock after N time options). Default it to locked. One more layer would be to enable only for established accounts and or based on the account behavior historically, and so on.
- sillysaurus3 9y agoPlease no. We've seen how much mods can be trusted when given toys. Any true Scotsman redditor will express their hatred for how often posts on /r/all are summarily locked by a mod. Often the justification is "lol no" or "I'm not spending my saturday policing the modqueue." Which is valid, but sucks for the 300k people that have to deal with it.
- johnfn 9y agoAges ago an admin said "yeah it would make sense for post titles to be edited within the first x minutes of making one", an incredibly low-hanging fruit that has been requested since forever. It still hasn't been added.
- rickhanlonii 9y agoI can think of a few problems with this just off the top of my head: The first x minutes of a post are _heavily_ influential in the success of the post, editing after allows you to hijack successful titles for gain (spam) For large subs, posts only hit the top of /new for x minutes (for small x), editing after is basically useless if it's not successful in that time Mods patrol the /new queue as posts come in, allowing editing will complicate moderation which is already a difficult job
- johnfn 9y agoI mean whatever your concerns are, the admins/developers of Reddit are okay with this change.
- orf 9y agowhere ok, or at least one was in a comment posted 'ages ago'. That's very different.
- squeaky-clean 9y agoAt least allow mods to change titles. Even that isn't possible.
- shalmanese 9y agoThe reddit button for submitting a post still says "save". I brought it up to a reddit designer last year and apparently there's some mountain of technical debt that would make changing the label a week long task so its languished at the bottom of the priority queue for many years now.
- CM30 9y agoI'm sorry, but this reason for not having title editing (and post editing on other sites like Twitter and GameFAQs) always bothered me to hell and back. Yes it could be misused, but go on any forum where you can edit titles or post content and look at how often such a feature actually does get abused. It pretty much never happens. Most people (like 99.99% of them) either use the functionality how it was intended or don't bother editing at all. I don't see the point of limiting a feature because about 0.1% of the userbase might theoretically abuse it in a certain situation. It's basically the social media/forum equivalent of the trolley problem and automated cars. Something that's going to happen very rarely at the most but draws a lot of discussion about 'what ifs'.
- fictioncircle 9y agoTo be fair, doing so would require a bunch of cache invalidations and they've always barely had enough money to limp on to the next investor. It would also likely be abused. Its quite possible many features simply would raise their costs by .X% and therefore were impossible for that reason.
- dredmorbius 9y agoI'd prefer a different approach: a true draft / submission cycle for more substantive works. This starts approaching a blogging or CMS system, but then, Reddit is already damned close to that, though with a larger community than most same. Under this model: * An item would be submitted. * If approvals / edit / drafting is set, it goes to a submission or edit queue. * A set of mods/editors would provide feedback and/or make edits (which of these apply depending on the sub). * The item is then submitted. This would allow for adjusting titles, self-text, formatting, etc. I'm not claiming this is something all subs would want, but some would (and I've a few specific ones in mind). For now, the fix is to delete the submission entirely and submit it anew. I've certainly done that within my own sub(s).
- Medaber 9y agoYou can't enable this. Too much abuse. 1. Make a post "Who likes Ice Cream!?" 2. Wait for responses and upvotes. 3. Change post to "Who likes pedophilia?"
- beager 9y agoAlso for context, Reddit found a lot of steam when Digg suffered a mass exodus based on seismic product shifts. I wouldn't be surprised if Reddit was consciously and unconsciously averse to that kind of mutation.
- hn_throwaway_99 9y agoKudos to reddit for not following the trend of "lets redesign the site just because we can" ethos. Not only did the product shift kill Digg, I also think it led to the earlier downfall of Slashdot. I may be dating myself, but I remember how each revision of Slashdot made it less usable for me. The "cleaner, minimalist, lots of whitespace" designs that were in vogue actually made it much harder to navigate comment threads quickly and see good content easily while avoiding the chaff. Even today I prefer to use the desktop version of Reddit on my phone, because I can just go through content threads a lot faster than compared to their mobile site.
- gtm1260 9y agoI agree! It feels like a good portion of the time when I see a new feature on a website it seems like it only exists because all the people needed to create it are employed at the company and we can't have them just sitting around all day.
- FiveDegrees 9y agoI'm looking at you, Slack.
- paulddraper 9y agoYou mean Facebook?
- hn_throwaway_99 9y agoYes! Slack is dangerously close to the point of "every new feature makes it worse", while basic features that should work (scrolling to earlier in a channel that reloads history feels like a roulette wheel) stay broken.
- colordrops 9y agoBut there are several issues they don't bother fixing either. They could at least address those.
- JosephLark 9y ago> Maybe they don't want to fix what's not broken Unfortunately, this doesn't appear to be the case. They haven't been hiding that they're gearing up for a major redesign. From what I've seen so far, I'm not at all excited for it. They launched user profiles recently, and it's an uninspired blocky design with way too much unnecessary whitespace for a desktop site. Also, even on desktop there is noticeable Javascript induced lag and content pop in. Although the rest of the profile page tries to look like a standard reddit page, it's actually entirely done with react and the subreddit/notification bar at the top has the same lag and content pop in. They're also hiring mainly for React frontend/Node.js backend, so I'm worried the entire redesign is going to be low density and slow.
- Roritharr 9y agoI'm in a weird position there. I've recently decided on react for most of our frontend in the future because of all the technical advantages this offers and the productivity benefits I see, but I still harbor reservations against react because in practice I've rarely seen react pages that feel snappy and fast, rather than choppy and slow.
- SkyMarshal 9y agoInteresting observation, b/c one of the original value propositions of React's virtual dom model was faster rendering than most other frontend frameworks at the time. I wonder if it's gotten so complicated it lost that? If so, there are a number of other intentionally lightweight virtual dom frontend frameworks. Mithril, Riot, Preact, virtual-dom all come to mind, and there are a probably a few more.
- bauerd 9y agoReact's virtual dom/diffing is certainly not "slow". It's not the tool that's the problem, but how it's used. There's also more to perceived slowness than how fast your library reconciles the DOM, e.g. I too often encounter pages that will "preload" all their assets behind stupid loading screens, ill-timed CSS animations, modals on top of modals, React Components that badly wrap jQuery plugins, leaked callbacks, … tl;dr Don't blame tools but their usage
- shawnz 9y agoRecently Reddit introduced a new kind of user profile where you can make text posts to your own profile. It got a huge amount of negative feedback (although I'm coming around to it, personally), and many obvious features, such as being able to mix a user's posts and comments together like on the old profile page, were missing. They claimed they were all-hands-on-deck adding these highly requested features, and even now, over a month later, the only thing that's changed is a slightly bigger hyperlink to the comments page. That to me sounds like fixing what's not broken while ignoring what is.
- FridgeSeal 9y agoIt (rightfully) copped a lot of flack because it is a terrible idea: Reddit users don't want another user-driven/user focused Facebook clone, they want a community and topic driven platform. I'm hoping that, like some of Reddit's other weird ideas, it kind of just gets abandoned and left to die.
- traskjd 9y agoCould be wrong, but I'd assume some of it is related to scale of features. For example, when they started hosting images - they started at pretty extreme scale, so that would likely slow down feature delivery. Having said that, not all features would be _that_ intensive on systems.
- GSimon 9y agoToo busy working on April Fools day material: https://redditblog.com/2017/04/13/how-we-built-rplace/ https://redditblog.com/2017/04/13/how-we-built-rplace/
- jordache 9y agoI don't get the need for all these tech companies to prove their "wit" by trying to out do each other on 4/1. Then the tech blogs all rush to cover the various 4/1 "jokes"
- arcticfox 9y agoReddit's version was more like an excuse to do something fun. It would just be weird to release that on a normal day. But on 4/1, it was a blast.
- dredmorbius 9y agoCreative people like creative outlets. Creative outlets that you can share with others are also rewarding.
- jordache 9y agoexcept none of these april fools efforts are funny.. developers are not comedians. most of their crap is cringe worthy
- DINKDINK 9y agoYour post answers itself. It's to get free press and to engage your users. If a company can get a 10X rate of return on an April Fool creation, why wouldn't it?
- TheSoftwareGuy 9y agoI imagine a lot of their expenses are used on keeping certain things off the website and to keep it becoming like 4chan
- kaspm 9y agoI know for a long time the engineering team was not very big, certainly not the "usual" size of a team with that much traffic (Instagram not withstanding). My guess is the team was simply keeping up with the normal expansion of complexity that comes with scale. That said, I believe they are heavily recruiting at all levels so if you want to work for Reddit, apply now.
- FullMtlAlcoholc 9y agoWith the immense and demographically diverse userbase, I imagine keeping the site running smoothly and user analytics is their chief focus. Their strategy probably is to introduce changes slowly so as not to alienate or confuse people (I'm looking at you Facebook). Also, they expose their data via an API that developers have used to make all sorts of features, giving them the luxury of being able to basically test features without actually implementing them.
- ben_jones 9y agoIsn't the modern approach to that problem simply limiting new features to a subset of users then analyzing the result and deciding whether or not to release it to the full user base? As a heavy user of Reddit there is an argument to be made that it is (mostly) feature complete to the average user, and they have certainly made significant strides in scalability (though not without a decade of hiccups). I'd really like to hear from a reddit volunteer moderator, a group who essentially keeps the site running for free and who have voiced their concerns over lack of tooling for... again a decade. Finally we're only a year or two out from major PR issues at the company. I would not be surprised if it alienated engineering talent (that and presumably a smaller budget for compensation due to the revenue, profitability, time since last raise, etc.).
- BEEdwards 9y agoRES kind of disproves the feature completeness theory though, most of the features in RES should just be default features. https://redditenhancementsuite.com/ https://redditenhancementsuite.com/
- FullMtlAlcoholc 9y ago> Isn't the modern approach to that problem simply limiting new features to a subset of users then analyzing the result and deciding whether or not to release it to the full user base? For most companies it is. But sites like reddit get people to do it for free. Basic A/B testing takes a not insignificant amount of resources, usually consisting of at least a marketing/analytics person, a developer, a designer, qa resources and a project manager.
- beager 9y agoWith zero inside knowledge, it appears to me that they have a very brittle legacy feature set due to scale concerns, tolerated integrations/extensions, and being held hostage by the community. There is new product feature development happening but it appears disjointed from the legacy, which could indicate leadership conflicts on priority, an inability to marry the old and new, or an inability to devote time to anything but upkeep of the legacy. Previous large-scale changes have been presented to their community and generally have been panned by the community, and often unreasonably so.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Cacti 9y agowell, they are developing quite a bit, but they test out the features among subsets of their user base long before the features are available to everyone. And in most cases they probably turn out to not be as good as they seemed they would be, and are tabled. They are pretty careful about changing things... I mean, if it ain't broke. Personally I prefer it far, far more than the constant changes some startups seem to feel is necessary to justify their existence.
- Alex3917 9y ago> Does anybody know why development at reddit is so slow? I read through the front page of each of the top 5,000 subreddits (by subscribers) over the last few weeks, and a lot of the subreddits are adding hundreds or thousands of new subscribers per week. They seem to have gone into hypergrowth recently without anyone really noticing. The other interesting thing of note is that of the 125,000ish posts I read through, there are only a few dozen submissions from independent blogs on the front page of all of these subreddits put together at any given time.
- jacquesm 9y agoAssuming those are real accounts and not bots.
- ReverseCold 9y agoMany people also create multiple accounts for various purposes like joke accounts/throwaway accounts/etc.
- austenallred 9y agoI believe Sam Altman about this time last year mentioned that Reddit grows by more users than Hacker News has total every day.
- alt2501 9y agoCan you clarify what you mean by submissions from independent blogs? You seem to be saying that the new users are bots or something from media/marketing ? Or am i reading too much iwmto this...
- Alex3917 9y agoI.e. submissions not from YouTube, Imgur, nytimes, etc. submissions from actual people with a point of view, where you can subscribe if you want to learn more. Think Fred Wilson, Seth Godin, Venkatesh Rao, Gwern, etc. writing on their own domain, or at least on their own subdomain where they pay for hosting.
- hitekker 9y agoThree factors. 1. Reddit's internecine subreddit wars required constant admin intervention and mediation. Reddit only has so many hands on deck, so more of than not, they pulled engineers in to help moderate.[1] 2. Reddit is unprofitable, so they have trouble affording top talent. [2] 3. Finally, Reddit's vision for the future has been hazy for the last decade. If the navigators can't chart a course, all the rowing in the world won't move the ship in the right direction. I suspect the overdone April Fools experiments are a result of engineering not being given technically compelling, or perhaps meaningful features to labor over. Sources: [1] https://www.reddit.com/r/TheoryOfReddit/comments/58zaho/the_accuracy_of_voat_regarding_reddit_srs_admins/d95a7q2/?context=3 https://www.reddit.com/r/TheoryOfReddit/comments/58zaho/the_... [2]http://www.thedrum.com/news/2017/04/02/reddit-sets-eyes-profitability-with-revamped-self-serve-ad-platform http://www.thedrum.com/news/2017/04/02/reddit-sets-eyes-prof...
- coltonv 9y ago1. This doesn't require developer talent, or any real expense at all, social media marketing interns will do the job at barely any cost. 2. They've had plenty of money from investments though, their dev team is reasonably sized. 3. This one seems pretty accurate.
- hitekker 9y ago1. I agree that it shouldn't, but they did so. Updated post with link. In another post, he emphasized the "war" part much more, but I think he deleted it. It was fairly angry. 2. I'm having trouble finding their burn rate; the linked article at least hints that they'll use this money to attract talent.
- dredmorbius 9y agoAbuse, like everything else, changes at scale. There's only so much moderation a single person can handle in a day. The NY Times moderation team posted some stats a ways back, it worked out to about 800 items/person/day. Which, in an 8-hour day works out to an item every 35 seconds. Sustained. Throughout the entire day. Techs can leverage patterns, even if it means a lot of ad hoc code. Building training systems is even better. Considering what Reddit's been through in the past couple of years by way of direct information attacks (even not counting any systems-level attacks), involving coloured tablets and giant orange peaches, I don't find the story that dev time has been accounted for particularly unreasonable.
- javiramos 9y agoI mean look at Craigslist. Almost no development.
- zjaffee 9y agoReddit is very different from other social/consumer tech companies in that they are a very small company. Last I heard, they are somewhere around 200 employees. Compare that to how many employees twitter has and you'll notice that actually reddit is evolving their product at a pretty fast pace for the size of the company. Additionally, from the various threads on reddit that I've seen people post about the company. They've done a lot of work on the background to reduce spam, which isn't something that is super obvious to someone not specifically looking to spam the site.
- ekianjo 9y agoValve has less than 400 employees too.
- alt2501 9y agoThis thread is full of comments that at first seem appropriate, but quickly reveal to be utter fluff/rubbish. Count this comment in that category too.
- ekianjo 9y agoI was replying to the above comment. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Valve_Corporation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Valve_Corporation for the source of the number of employees. Your comment is more useless than mine since it does not provide any information and just a bland opinion out of nowhere.
- notatoad 9y agoEvery time they introduce any changes, the userbase revolts. The outrage that happened when they announced they were going to let people put a bio and photo on their profile pages made it sound like the world was ending.
- jokoon 9y agoThe only thing I wish I could do, is search through my upvotes and filter things by subreddit etc.
- SquareWheel 9y agoThere is a dedicated upvote page as a tab on your profile. Not easily combined with subreddit filters without using addons, though. (Just a note, your profile's upvotes appear to be public. This is a toggle available in options)
- jokoon 9y ago> Not easily combined with subreddit filters without using addons, though. Could you be more specific?
- SquareWheel 9y agoI just mean the filters can't be applied together. eg. show me upvoted threads from X subreddit. I thought perhaps that's what you were interested in, so I made a note of it.
- mhomde 9y agoFrom hanging around in r/redditdev I got an impression there was an exodus of much of the experienced backend team about a year ago when there was so much drama (Kemitche and at least two more people I think). Maybe it has taken some time to get a new one up to speed. Also, A lot of resources seems to be focused lately on developing clients for android and ios. I get the impression that Reddit has a lot of technical debt that makes developing new features difficult, and would take some major effort to refactor themselves out of
- threepipeproblm 9y agoThe CEO Steve Huffman recently admitted to editing his political opponent's posts. Maybe they can't get anything done because they're redditing all day.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- baby 9y agoI don't know about the website, but I was really impressed at how fast they released a new iOS app (right after buying Alien Blue) which looks pretty awesome as well.
- komali2 9y agoVaguely off-topic: the day that app was released, I stumbled into 111 Minna (a bar in downtown SF) and saw a bunch of signs for Reddit. Assuming it was a reddit meetup, I talked up this one dude about the new app, how ugly it was, how I was never going to stop using Baconreader if this was the shit the reddit team was gonna put out, etc. Later a girl said "man, Steve thought it was hilarious how you just shit all over our new app. You know this is our launch party, right?" Found out it was Steve Huffman.