14 ms·
The relationship between mindset and getting old
- ilaksh 9y agohttp://www.sens.org http://www.sens.org -- after reading the article, still by far the most scientific and fully developed approach that I have seen.
- myth_drannon 9y agoI wonder if nostalgia is a human mind's hack to slow down aging.
- klfasdf77 9y agoI see it as "doing what you know" keeps one comfortable, less anxious, and more active in its discussion. If all you know are references to pop culture from a bygone era, however, you're going to be really limited. This comes up a lot in discourse among older and younger generations: kids should just get a job (because in my day they were all over and paid well), or not realizing college tuition has skyrocketed. People are locked into the era they were most active in participating in. Some people like to sit and ogle others creations; their novels, films, code, etc. All those neckbeards and "critics" who are simply consuming others creations, and being annoyed by things they don't like, without dipping real toe in themselves. IMO, forcing people to trade, and filling their lives with shallow knowledge like the new Ian Fleming book, is the problem. I'd rather our cultures move to protecting one's freedom to create, both experience in their mind and in the physical world. We tend to favor protecting trade, which generally means people are forced to create then trade it away. Why should forced trade be something we care to protect? Seems ripe for exploitation. If you're busy trading to survive, you're not creating. You get stuck in 1959 when you were most actively trading and watching the world. But you end up with nothing of your own. You've been trading for others.
- ianai 9y agoConstant change does harm. That's my takeaway.
- nostrademons 9y agoCurious how you got that out of the article? I didn't see anything in it that seemed to suggest as such.
- ianai 9y agoThey seem to have been stuck in a year. I only briefly skimmed it though.
- robertlagrant 9y agoSome of the article was okay (although you can cherry-pick a lot to achieve a conclusion) but Langer's study in particular seemed very dubious. They "looked younger"? Stop - that's just way too objective for me!
- mistermann 9y agoConsidering the subject of the article, that's kind of an interesting most noteworthy (to you) takeaway.
- Retric 9y agoSeems an odd takeaway after "memory, vision, hearing, and even physical strength had improved"
- coldtea 9y ago>They "looked younger"? Stop - that's just way too objective for me! What part of this kind of process: they showed before and after pictures of them to third parties who didn't know them --nor did they know the order the pictures were taken-- and the majority identified the latter as younger looking seems "too objective"?
- reasonattlm 9y agoPhysical activity is the likely mediating mechanism between acting younger and gaining modest benefits by some measures. Since the development of lightweight accelerometers, studies of physical activity have demonstrated strong correlations between even modest activity of the housework/gardening variety and health in old age. There is a mountain of further research demonstrating the benefits of increased moderate exercise and lesser forms of activity in older people. But ultimately the end is the same. You can't reliably exercise your way to 90, even. The majority of people who are exceptionally fit die before reaching that milepost in the environment of the last 90 years of medical technology. The future of health and longevity in later life will be increasingly determined by medical technology, and nothing else. Aging is damage, and that damage can be repaired given suitable biotechnologies to do so. DNA methylation patterns correlating strongly with age are a very promising tool when it comes to assessing treatments for the processes of aging. Companies offer various implementations now - see Osiris Green for a cheaper example, to pick one. In the SENS view of aging as accumulated molecular damage, epigenetic changes are a reaction to that damage; a secondary or later process in aging. We'll find out over the next few years how the rejuvenation therapy of senescent cell clearance does against this measure, now that things are moving along there. But you shouldn't think it impossible to construct useful metrics of biological age more simply. There are a number of excellent papers from the past few years in which researchers assemble weighted algorithms using bloodwork, grip strength, and other simple tests as a basis into something that nears the level of discrimination of the epigenetic clock. When it comes to a biomarker of aging, there are lots of promising candidates. Researchers will spend a lot of time arguing before they come to any sort of pseudo-standard for that task. Industry (today meaning the companies developing senolytic therapies for the clinic) will overtake them and, I'd wager, adopt one of the epigenetic clocks because it basically works well enough to get along with, and can be cheap in some forms.
- chiph 9y agoNot to be "that guy", but I will credit strength training in helping my father make it to age 92. What we found was that it increased his balance and stability. Of course muscles use the skeleton as levers, and there's studies that show that training will slow the reduction in bone density as you age. So dad's training likely prevented his breaking bones when he did take a tumble. This fellow is involved with training those over 50. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5DDGOXkpZxI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5DDGOXkpZxI
- jldugger 9y ago> getting old 'aging' is the word you are searching for
- Fifer82 9y agowhat is the difference?
- lisper 9y agoOne syllable.
- lgas 9y agoI don't know, I think they mean the same thing, but "getting old" has the connotation that it's towards the end of your life. That is, a baby is constantly aging into a slightly older baby, but it's not getting old yet. A thirty year old ages into a thirty one year old, but unless you're a teenager you wouldn't generally say they're getting old yet. But someone who's retiring and moving to florida? They're getting old. Of course you might also say "you're getting old!" to say a fourteen year old cousin that you haven't seen in a few years. It depends on context. But I don't think they literally contain the same information except for syllables. So I think jlduggers pedantry is misguided in this case.
- iammyIP 9y agogetting old is binary, aging is continuous.
- Bakary 9y agoAlthough the technically mean the same thing, the feelings they evoke are quite different
- robteix 9y agoI wonder how much the effects vary between different professions. I'm in my 40s. Incredibly old for HN standards. And yet, I feel no nostalgia for the "good ol' times." I mean, don't get me wrong I'm sure there's a lot of things that set me apart from newer generations -- I don't get Snapchat at all ;) -- but I don't see me being happier by being put in a house set up to look and feel like the 90s/80s. Is it maybe because we as programmers tend to be less prone to be stuck to the past? Just wondering
- samastur 9y agoNo, it's you. I'm 43 and while I don't see myself as particularly nostalgic either, I have plenty of colleagues who are. I have no idea how we compare to general population.
- medill1919 9y agoI'm 55. I'm nostalgic, but also forward seeking. There were certainly things about the 70's and 90's that were better than now. Not sure I'd want to go back though. I'd rather change the future...
- ido 9y agoThe best thing about 15 years ago was that my body was 15 years younger. Missing their youth probably has more to do with missing any particular specific cultural artifact of the time.
- cableshaft 9y agoFor me it's: I miss my youth and health, and I'd love to be able to go back just so I could have the time and energy to work on the things I'd like to work on now. I am still making things, it's just more difficult now. But video games are a hell of a lot better now than they were back then. Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild? The Witness? Life is Strange? Persona 5? So, so good. And there's nothing stopping me from playing the old games when I feel like it (except having the time). Also I wouldn't mind having another replay of my high school and college years with the confidence that I have now. A lot of my experiences with women would have gone a lot more positively then if my attitude and approach then were the same as it is now (Well, in the past five years. I'm in a solid relationship now). I wouldn't want to replay the sitting around a classroom or schoolwork part of it though.
- michalu 9y agoI suspect the reason they felt better and more vital is that the change of mindset and environment altered their biochemistry. How we feel and what we think of ourselves affects our levels of Testosterone, Cortisol, Serotonin, etc. Even a 5 minute conversation can give you a T boost of 30%+ ... or believing that you're perceived as high status alters your Serotonin. Those hormones in turn make you more vital. So who knows what was the reason... maybe more social interaction with strangers? Or simply putting their mind into a different, better place? http://www.ulm.edu/~palmer/TheBiochemistryofStatusandtheFunctionofMoodStates.htm http://www.ulm.edu/~palmer/TheBiochemistryofStatusandtheFunc... http://www.cep.ucsb.edu/topics/courtship/roney%20et%20al_2009_proceedings%20b.pdf http://www.cep.ucsb.edu/topics/courtship/roney%20et%20al_200...
- astrobe_ 9y ago> Even a 5 minute conversation can give you a T boost of 30% How is it different from taking drugs, really?
- michalu 9y agoNot sure I understand what you mean. What kind of drugs?
- astrobe_ 9y agoWhat is the difference between taking artificial mood altering-drugs versus engaging in behaviours that result in the production of "natural" mood-altering drugs?
- Bakary 9y agoFrom this literal definition the entirety of our lives could be defined as simply "taking drugs". We chase the high by doing various things. The difference between taking drugs and doing these things is that the reward mechanism is the product of many years of evolution, whereas drugs can sometimes produce harmful side effects due to not being fully fine tuned to our own bodies' expectations. The distinction would go away entirely if drugs were more sophisticated. But in that case it would pretty much be the end of life as we've hitherto experienced it.
- afpx 9y agoI look forward to living to 100. But, 80 would be even better if only I could regain a 12-year-old's sense of the passage of time.
- Hydraulix989 9y agoAccording to my AncestryDNA test results, I don't have the centennial gene, so I doubt I'll make it past 90.
- Bakary 9y agoYou can emulate a poor man's version of this by continuously trying new and challenging things.
- DrNuke 9y agoWhatever your past, it is irrelevant now and future the only way forward, so smile and enjoy your ride together with the people you love (mid 40s here and still pushing, ehehe).
- Bakary 9y agoIn a way neither the past nor the future exist. There is only the present.
- gerbilly 9y agoWhile I certainly agree that western people live too much in their heads, ruminating on the past or worrying about the future, the past and the future certainly do 'exist', in that the effects of actions in the past become the cause of effects in the present or future.
- chiefalchemist 9y agoKinda like a placebo effect, yes. It would be interesting to take a group of slightly younger test subjects and see what happens to them when they live with older people in the present. Moi? The body and mind are both subject to: Use it or lose it. We also, as humans, tend to assimulate into the norm around us, be it smoking, obesity, and now I guess perhaps youth. Finally, I have to wonder about the effects of essentially being on holiday. In addition, perhaps the group discussions energized them? That is instead of waiting to die, they had more reason to live? In any case, interesting.
- sdenton4 9y agoIt's an effect probably at least as real as ESP: https://slate.com/health-and-science/2017/06/daryl-bem-proved-esp-is-real-showed-science-is-broken.html https://slate.com/health-and-science/2017/06/daryl-bem-prove... Which is to say, I'm dubious as hell of this result: For something this click-baity, at this point in the history of psychology research, I'mma need some serious replication before I give itan ounce of belief.
- TheOtherHobbes 9y agoIn my 50s. Not exactly pickled in nostalgia. I think the computing party is just getting started. Non-trivial domestic AI will be here within a couple of years, personal robotics 5-10 years after that. The current ad mania sucks, but it's going to have to evolve or die. I don't miss much of the past. Pocket phone computers, tablets, GPS, video calling, massive data storage, and the potential of renewables and distributed energy grids are all awesome. Like. Even social has its moments. The real problems are cultural and political. There's been some movement there, but not nearly enough. The system has nearly enough energy to go through a phase change soon, and that's when things will get really interesting.
- hyperpallium 9y agoAI; "nearly enough energy to go through a phase change soon" I like the intriguing idea, that once we figure out AI, we could do some very powerful things even on today's low-end phones (10's of GFLOPS). OTOH The recent "deep learning" breakthroughs have, have come from throwing resources at NNs. And it might be that we create AI long before we understand it and are able to do it efficiently.
- theprop 9y agoAge may mean certain things about DNA methylation, but it doesn't mean you can't continue inventing, challenging yourself taking chances e.g. 94 year-old co-inventor of lithium batteries co-invents a solid state (solid-glass electrolytes) battery. http://www.canadianmanufacturing.com/technology/94-year-old-lithium-ion-battery-inventor-unveils-new-solid-state-breakthrough-186868/ http://www.canadianmanufacturing.com/technology/94-year-old-...
- dheera 9y agoIt would be interesting to see how much of this is truly biological and how much of it is due to societal and situational conditioning. There were lots of things I could do in my 20s (e.g. refuse to use gasoline-powered city transportation, refuse to patronize places that used disposable cutlery, refuse to use non-free software, etc.) that I can't do when I'm in my 30s because people around me would think I'm a stubborn idiot, jeopardizing my career at a point where I have not yet established myself. It's very easy to tell a colleague, advisor, anyone at school that you're going to bike to the destination or take electric-powered transit [because you don't believe in a fossil fuel future]. It's very difficult to say the same thing to an investor, co-founder, employee, customer, or whoever is offering you a ride in their car, without feeling like an ass. I'm basically forced to be "normal" during work times and fit into the mould of society. I can only be myself on evenings and weekends. I can only imagine how much more "being normal" I need to do if I had kids, pets, tenants, or whatever. I don't have any of those at the moment. The other night I was pondering over potential improvements to our music and mathematical notation systems while staring at the Milky Way. (I didn't come to anything conclusive, but I love thinking outside the boxes that society defines for us.) 10 years ago, I could truly be myself 24 hours a day. I was basically learning all kinds of things about the world by doing that. Now, I only get about 5 hours a day to be myself. The rest of the time, I need to conform. The lack of "me" time itself may be contribute to some degree of mental rot/aging, apart from the biological component.
- flyGuyOnTheSly 9y ago>It's very difficult to say the same thing to an investor, co-founder, employee, customer, or whoever is offering you a ride in their car, without feeling like an ass. I would argue that being honest and explaining your true feelings and position on a certain subject to a person that you wish to hold a close relationship with is the best route imho. They will respect you more for being honest, even if they disagree with you. It's really not that weird to explain to somebody that you'd rather not trash the planet if you can avoid it when you think about it. >I need to conform. I sent a Ron Paul "It's Happening" GIF to my (rather staunch) clients the other day and they absolutely loved it. Which made me chuckle.
- coldtea 9y agoA man is as old as the woman he feels (G. Marx)
- Schiphol 9y agoThe experiment that kicks off the piece looks pretty replication-crisis worthy.
- anentropic 9y agoHas anyone reproduced the results from this study of 49 people back in 1979?
- kusmi 9y agoIt's official, my boss really is feeding off my youth.