26 ms·
Facebook is an attack on the open web
- id122015 9y agoI closed my FB in 2013 and time passes so quick. I created a dummy account to have access to certain pages but I dont use it. But a lot of people have created thousands of dummy accounts to show how many friends they have. They sell on the market fake accounts/followers. And I dont want to be part of such a group. Plus other reasons like the ones in the article like this.
- unabst 9y agoThey've been openly attacking the open web since day one. I think the problem now is that they've been too successful. Zuckerberg was on to something. He saw the web connecting pages, but not people. So he created a web connecting people and now it has grown to what it is. With both MySpace and Google+ practically buried, Facebook has no competition. We desperately need an alternative, and not just one for the sake of not being facebook, but something that works. The open web needs a way to connect people.
- aesthetics1 9y agoWhat does an alternative look like that does not eventually lead to another Facebook? I've seen decentralized platforms, platforms that do not sell your data or target you with ads - how are they sustainable?
- unabst 9y agoThis and this. Precisely the right questions. I haven't checked the landscape in a minute, but I wonder if there are any new projects out there.
- thanatropism 9y agoWhen I was in college (in 2002-2005), everybody had blogs. Girls who wanted to appear intellectual had blogs; cliques had blogs. I remember being heartbroken that I hadn't been invited to a little friend group's group blog. Comments worked, we linked to each other constantly, etc. But frankly this still was at a time when the internet was more nerdish. Writing blogs was work -- intellectual work -- for reward that was only tangible because we saw everyone everyday and could physically high five or thumbs-up. So of course blogs declined because of Facebook. I myself find myself periodically using Facebook as a blogging platform -- to write and read and debate long takes; but also because most people are not nerdish enough to have blogs. I think we're watching horrified at the de-nerding of the internet. --- Relatedly. I'm really really jealous of kids and their snapchats. I wish my generation used some such platform. I remember when we used IM status lines as short-lived messages into the world -- "Hi friends, I feel sad", maybe with some song lyric. For a very brief while (like a week, maybe less), Messenger Stories started picking up steam in my network -- until it was integrated on Facebook. Facebook has too many people. Disappearing stories encapsulate the whole reason someone my age (I'm 34) needs online social networks: you drift away from your great friends from yesteryear, have less and less time and energy and emotional need for new ones -- at least at the investment it takes -- and everyone in your cohort is either doing the same or trying too hard to be artificially social. If, instead, I could access a significant section of my circle of acquaintances/quasi-friends/might-have-been-friends-if-I-had-met-them-earlier-in-life, etc. and just take a picture of a really good fresh-squeezed OJ I had somewhere or a pretty sunset or some Counting Crows lyrics? In such a way that everyone who is kind of paying attention is aware, but everyone else just misses? It would make a significant dent at this need for a semi-social life. Maybe I could even make a couple of really fucking great friends out of the interesting acquaintances I have. I'm rambling, of course. But hey, startup people. Make Snapchat for adults, please!
- 659087 9y agoThe only thing Zuckerberg was on to was someone else's idea that he took for himself.
- throwaway-1209 9y agoWhy do people keep reading (and linking to) this clown? His posts are 100% predictable, ergo, even if you do care about his opinion, you can just assume what it will be. Apple -- good, everybody else -- bad. Google -- very, very bad. There, saved you a click.
- oxguy3 9y agoI don't agree with a lot of things Gruber says/does, but this blog post is completely on point.
- macawfish 9y agoAmen. There are dozens of very good reasons for righteous anger toward Facebook, and only a handful are in this article. But just those are enough. And enough is enough.
- tobyjsullivan 9y agoNot everything on the internet needs to be public (or part of the "open web" as the article calls it). Facebook is a fantastic place for web content that isn't meant to be public. This idea of posting "public content" on Facebook is inherently flawed. I agree with the article on that much. However, what I haven't figured out yet is if this is actually an evil-Facebook issue or just a user issue. Is Facebook actively encouraging this web breaking behaviour or is it a "mis-use" of what the tool originally intended (e.g., a safe place to post content/blog/etc. with privacy restrictions)?
- cmod 9y agoI believe the main issue is that people use facebook as if it were the open web. People aren't posting because they want to keep their content in a silo, but rather because they don't know of / have an alternative publishing vector. Nobody is saying don't have private silos, but I believe Gruber and co are saying don't pretend like a private silo is public, when it isn't.
- ovao 9y agoI'd argue that Facebook defines content that's "public" in a way that some — perhaps many — would not, so it's a potential point of confusion. I don't consider it evil, but it certainly results in a sort of Facebook-first inclusiveness. Gruber hits on this with Facebook's intent that posts not be indexable by search engines.
- tobyjsullivan 9y agoThis makes sense. I think it's an inherent challenge to the domain. In Facebook's defence, there is a difference between "public" and "discoverable". They don't go out of their way to make things discoverable. That's their business and may be evil or not depending on someone's given values. But "public" content on Facebook could potentially be seen by anyone - and that's staying true to the definition.
- jbigelow76 9y agoHowever, what I haven't figured out yet is if this is actually an evil-Facebook issue or just a user issue. I have a side rant that has been bubbling in me for a long time on this issue. My city's alternative weekly paper, The Dallas Observer, switched from Livefyre to Facebook's commenting system about two years ago. Livefyre was bad but the Facebook comment system is worse. With Facebook forcing "real" people accounts, comments plummeted on stories that presented alternate takes on local stories that didn't fall into line with the Dallas Morning News's traditional power structure patriarchs (mostly land developers). The editor's suggestion to people that wanted to comment on a story without using their "real name" was to create a separate Facebook account. Un-fucking real. My conspiracy theory is that The Dallas Observer, and probably all Village Voice Media properties, were promised better exposure in Facebook user's news feeds if they used the Facebook comment engine. Seems like a devil's bargain to me. I put the Facebook comment system squarely in the evil-Facebook pile.
- tantalor 9y ago> I don’t know what your privacy settings are. So if I point to your post, it’s possible a lot of people might not be able to read it Easy: open the page in an incognito window.
- subway 9y agoEasier: Don't bother; it's Facebook.
- adtac 9y agoI'm sure Facebook is still tracking you in some way. Some low hanging fruits: IP address, user agent, screen resolution, network speed based tracking, geo location, presence of various web technologies. With all this and Facebook's backend data, I'm absolutely sure they'll be able to narrow you down to at most 5-10 people.
- 5ilv3r 9y agoI went to a great talk at linuxfest with a mozilla developer talking about ways you could prevent tracking, and some of the means were mind blowing. For example, they can process an audio clip using your audio hardware without playing it to you, and then based on the artifacts introduced, they can figure out if you are using the same sound card as a previous sample they collected. The firefox property that allows this is 'dom.webaudio.enabled', and it is not related to playback.
- adtac 9y agoThat's insane. http://webkay.robinlinus.com/ http://webkay.robinlinus.com/ has some more interesting methods. One of my favourites is querying every IP address in your local network and seeing which ones are up to generate a profile on you.
- hardworkforyour 9y agoExcellent finally somebody is saying this loudly and clear!! Ps. Be careful, suckerberg will delete your accounts soon and google will follow.
- hardworkforyour 9y agoIm proud of this post!!
- wehadfun 9y agoThe popover things pisses me off as well. For a company like facebook to use such an annoying thing to get people to subscribe seems immature.
- arprocter 9y agoIt's incredibly obnoxious - the first time my dad showed me I couldn't believe how much space it took up. He has no interest in joining Facebook but his friend promotes his business via pictures on there
- irrational 9y agoI have a feeling that Facebook will be on the decline. My teenagers and early-20 year-olds and their friends (not just local, but all over the US) think Facebook is for old people. I actually heard a 16 year old recently giving a speech where he mentioned Snapchat Stories, then, as an aside, said, "That's like Facebook or Pintrest for you old people."
- pimeys 9y agoIsn't Instagram still quite popular with teenagers and can search engines index pictures from Instagram?
- icantdrive55 9y agoYea, I have three nephews. I used to see them on FB, shirts off--Pea cocking, but they all deactivated, and didn't come back. I activate/reactivating daily. I have a watch repair group on the site. FB thinks it's my business, and is constantly begging for ad money, but I'm just giving away information I learned. I honestly don't hate FB anymore. Maybe I'm a old people? I still cringe when I see the person with 400 friends, and is portraying a life of 007, or the female equivalent--I don't know what that would be? Women need a fictional character to emululate? (Off topic, but it interesting how Hollywood affects speech. I'm wondering when they will start using "Buckets of money".)
- criddell 9y agoYour 16 year old will eventually be old too. Facebook will still be there.
- irrational 9y agoBut who will move to it? It's not like the 16 year old will magically start using Facebook just because he is 26 or 36 when all of his friends still aren't using it. Facebook has such a negative connotation among young adults that I can't see them moving to it just because they are getting older. It's not like Facebook is required to get by as an adult. I'm in my mid-40s and I've yet to use Facebook and I haven't suffered any negative repercussions (though I will admit that I was glad that I had a sister who was keeping tabs and reporting to me on my kids Facebook usage back before they abandoned it).
- rndmind 9y agoI deleted my facebook account in highschool and have never looked back. The melodrama and immature antics are hilarious to observe, I'm so glad that I'm not a part of all that.
- ovao 9y agoAnother way to say that is "I'm glad I'm not in high school anymore" ;) I'd say what you're describing isn't symptomatic of Facebook, but of the relationships themselves. For the most part my Facebook feed is comprised of 30-somethings and melodrama basically doesn't exist. Political rants, on the other hand...
- linsomniac 9y agoI took the route with facebook, just like in real life, that I culled out the people who are immature and melodramatic. But if I ever get the hankering for some melodrama, I can count on the inevitable "I deleted facebook" replies to any post about Facebook. :-)
- thr0waway1239 9y ago>> Facebook going out of business seems unlikely Is it? Because it seems to me that they are having plenty of issues with gaining the trust of advertisers too. Considering that advertising is the bread and butter of their business, this would normally be something of a mini-crisis. A quick search for "do advertisers trust facebook" gives me https://techcrunch.com/2016/11/12/facebook-needs-accountability-to-win-back-advertisers-trust/ https://techcrunch.com/2016/11/12/facebook-needs-accountabil... https://venturebeat.com/2017/02/10/facebook-verification-ad-buying/ https://venturebeat.com/2017/02/10/facebook-verification-ad-... http://www.thedrum.com/news/2017/01/31/will-facebook-chip-away-its-walled-garden-restore-advertiser-trust http://www.thedrum.com/news/2017/01/31/will-facebook-chip-aw... http://www.adageindia.in/digital/40-of-marketers-say-they-plan-facebook-audits/articleshow/56667098.cms http://www.adageindia.in/digital/40-of-marketers-say-they-pl... http://marketingland.com/facebooks-measurement-errors-impacted-marketers-trust-200091 http://marketingland.com/facebooks-measurement-errors-impact... Of course, no one actually believes anything Facebook says with regards to privacy, and probably never did. I would seriously doubt if there is anyone who actually looks at their practices who doesn't think they conduct large scale psychological experiments on the human lab rats who continue to use FB. In other words, seems like there are enough ingredients here for an implosion. Something has to give.
- ceejayoz 9y ago> Considering that advertising is the bread and butter of their business, this would normally be something of a mini-crisis. It would, if there were an alternative.
- jtmarmon 9y agofacebook has a certain level of monopoly over people's attention. i don't think a little snafu like this is suddenly going to make advertisers think they should stop advertising on facebook.
- AlexAffe 9y agoThere is a relevant xkcd, that calculates FBs lifetime to end at ~20 years from now.
- adtac 9y agoYou've ever been to one of those pages that embed Facebook's comment engine? Yeah, those are the worst. I did some analysis on a random page with just three Facebook comments. Requests to Facebook's servers accounted for 1.5 MB of the 2.4 MB tranfered by the ENTIRE page. 87 network requests, 35 javascript files injected and it didn't even load all the comments! (I had to click on a "Load more comments" button to load the rest of the comments.) Why the hell do you need 37 javascript files and 1.5 MB to load three comments? (Shameless plug to my own open source, lightweight and tracking-free comment engine alternative to Facebook, Disqus and the rest: https://github.com/adtac/commento https://github.com/adtac/commento)
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- korzun 9y ago> Requests to Facebook's servers accounted for 1.5 MB of the 2.4 MB tranfered by the ENTIRE page. 87 network requests, 35 javascript files injected and it didn't even load all the comments! (I had to click on a "Load more comments" button to load the rest of the comments.) This is an issue for a really small segment of users. Not really a cause for concern in 2017. Especially when most of that stuff is already cached. > Why the hell do you need 37 javascript files and 1.5 MB to load three comments? That's oversimplifying it. You are loading 37 assets to support a social commenting platform.
- adtac 9y ago> This is an issue for a really small segment of users. Not really. I'm from India; while my home network connection is pretty good, when I'm travelling anywhere outside the metros, the mobile network speed is abysmal. However quite a few news outlets employ Facebook's comment system. You can imagine what a nightmare it'll be for users to load all that with a 2G connection. > You are loading 37 assets to support a social commenting platform. 37 Javascript files out of which, I'm willing to bet, most are tracking agents employing every trick in the book to record all activity. Wasn't there a recent article that discovered that FB continuously sent home the position of your cursor when you're scrolling through your newsfeed so that they can place ads better?
- Tossrock 9y agoI deactivated my Facebook account several months ago, and it's been about 90% great, 10% frustrating. It's great for all the obvious reasons (less timesuck, less compulsion to endlessly scroll your life away, no notification interruptions). The frustrations are real, though. Primarily it's around events and photos. There are some communities I participate in that regularly organize events through Facebook, and now I don't really get invited to those anymore. It's also harder to organize events where you casually invite people you don't know as well. It's also occasionally annoying not being able to dig up a certain photo you wanted for reference. Even if you have a copy of the photo somewhere, if you don't have it hosted online then you can't really bring it up to show it to someone. Still, frustrations aside, it's 90% great, and I recommend everyone try it for themselves.
- pcsanwald 9y agothis has been my experience almost exactly. It's not my nature to be part of an online community where I don't actively participate, so the idea of having a facebook account which I "never check" wasn't appealing to me at all. And while my reasoning was less idealistic than Gruber's, I think he makes a bunch of great points and I very much agree with the spirit of his post.
- tw334 9y agoI deleted the main FB app from my phone and use the Events app which works really well as a standalone product. I also use Google photos, which has all of my photos, not just the ones I've uploaded to Facebook. Plus the search is great. Maybe these suggestions could help your problem and clear that 10%.
- manyoso 9y agoDeleted my facebook account in January. For me it is 100% great and do not miss it even a little.
- srge 9y agoDeleted my account 2 years ago along with Twitter's and Instagram's. It's just a better life for me now. Less stress, less anger.
- kirse 9y agoAll this open-web bitching sounds oddly familiar from back when AOL was a tech monstrosity with nearly everything inside its walled-garden. Facebook is basically just a worldwide version of AOL, and plenty of people are tiring of it, just as they tired of AOL's dialup shenanigans and obnoxious floppy disk marketing. And Facebook, too, will eventually crust away when the underlying tech improves (universal 5G? who knows?) and the next Steve Case / Mark Zuckerberg visionary builds the next generally-centralized service for most internet users. But the open web will survive just fine.
- b0rsuk 9y agoFacebook has wider reach than AOL. Maybe walled garden builders are getting better at their tricks ?
- wuliwong 9y agoIt's a bit of tough comparison. When I used AOL, it was literally my "portal" to the internet. I may have even used a browser embedded in AOL? Facebook is not that for most of it's users. But that being said, if we are just concerned with statistics, obviously Facebook's user numbers are much larger than AOL ever saw but I wonder what percentage of people using the internet use Facebook today vs. AOL "back in the day"?
- b0rsuk 9y agoI read comments on HN that claimed Facebook is many people's only portal to the Internet. Especially in Asia. Recommender reading: How to confuse a Facebook user (2010) https://www.theguardian.com/technology/blog/2010/feb/11/facebook-readwriteweb https://www.theguardian.com/technology/blog/2010/feb/11/face...
- dvt 9y agoThe irony, I think, is that Facebook tends to be too open. There are pictures or posts or status updates I'd like hidden from the world. Facebook isn't necessarily an attack on the open web, it's an attack on content ownership. When it comes to my personal blog, I can create, alter, and delete as I see fit. On Facebook, I'm sure that posts from my early 20s still linger somewhere in the abyss of their data centers. I'm sure that some embarrassing or unflattering picture of me is somewhere out there. And I think that's the crux of this problem: Facebook is the gatekeeper; it decides whether or not it wants to open or close the door on content. Of course, this has an implication as far as its openness is concerned, but the far more dangerous aspect is, as I mentioned, the fact that I should be the gatekeeper for my own content. At least that's the way I see it. I agree with the idea that as a social platform, Facebook is dying. People contribute less and less personal and intimate content in lieu of linking articles or throwaway memes. Nowadays, I mostly use it as a news feed. I think there's a vacuum out there ripe for disruption; a combination between Snapchat and Tumblr. A sort of MySpace for the new decade and a platform where people can be themselves again.
- joshbaptiste 9y agoah a "Why FB is evil" article, here come the slew of HN'ers to proclaim their deletion of FB years ago. I myself have no issues with the social network, I keep up with friends, family and it isn't a time suck for me anymore than HN.
- exergy 9y agoAnd contrarians who revel in their "I'm not snobbish like you all" Regular Joe aura. At least the ones who talk about why they quit stick to their own experiences rather than belittling others who still find value in it.
- 5ilv3r 9y agoThat is naturally what gated community members seem to do to outsiders...
- ambulancechaser 9y ago> At least the ones who talk about why they quit stick to their own experiences > I myself have no issues with the social network, I keep up with friends, family and it isn't a time suck for me anymore than HN.
- exergy 9y agoI'm taking issue with his first sentence, not second.
- dsacco 9y agoPretty soon we're going to need an "Anti-Facebook Evangelism Strike Force" or an "Open Web Evangelism Strike Force." Judging by the way people throw the word "evil" around here, you'd think Facebook was murdering kittens and using human batteries to power Free Basics, as Zuckerberg sat on a throne of acquired-company logos laughing to himself. How dare Facebook provide limited internet to the developing world instead of nothing at all...
- 9y ago
- ArchReaper 9y agoI'm no Facebook fanboy but this article feels like a "why does my square peg not fit into their round hole" type of complaint. Facebook is a social network, not a public blogging platform. Here is my interpretation of the complaints. Please point out what I am missing. >It's impractical... Square peg round hole. >It's supporting their downgrading and killing the web... Facebook posts being inherently (mostly) simple text is 'killing the web'? I don't buy it. >Facebook might go out of business. Just a generic SaaS complaint. Nothing unique to Facebook about this. Am I missing a core argument here?
- exergy 9y agoNope. Like you, I'm no fanboy (more an active hater), but this article seems like a general sense of unease about Facebook wrapped into a stream-of-consciousness argument.
- 5ilv3r 9y agoYes, you are. The argument is that facebook has become something that causes the rest of the web to be worse off. Less open, more bloated, more central.
- ArchReaper 9y agoI don't see any supporting arguments that directly support that thesis. That's a very open-ended, subjective statement.
- wuliwong 9y agoI think the main argument of the article is a little murky. The notion that you shouldn't write an article to be shared around the web on Facebook is simple enough and pretty obvious to a technically savvy audience. But the argument is baked inside of this very emotional claim that because of this Facebook is "killing" the open internet. While that may or may not be true, the fact that I shouldn't write blog posts inside of Facebook doesn't map directly to "Facebook is killing the web!"
- pier25 9y agoYou are not wrong. I think the problem is not really Facebook but its users. Sharing a blog post on Facebook is as wrong as sharing your travel photos on HN.
- cwyers 9y agoThe open web is an attack on the average user. It's unremittingly hostile as a place to go to if you aren't part of the culture that spawned it. Facebook does a very poor job of sheltering people from the worst of the open web, but it's about a billion times more bearable than the open web scaled up to modern adoption rates would be.
- codq 9y agoWell that is certainly a viewpoint I don't hear very often around these parts.
- dredmorbius 9y agoInteresting viewpoint, and not without some truth. But could you see an alternative that doesn't leave a single entity in control?
- camillomiller 9y agoAnd why would "learning a culture" before getting to be a part of it be any bad? Why should we be entitled to a free pass to some place that needs a culture to be grasped? This is exactly facebook problem: lowering the bar is not a good thing per se, especially if you then pretend to run away from the responsibilities that come with it (i.e. being a fucking awesome amplifier for the worst shit ever)
- cwyers 9y ago> And why would "learning a culture" before getting to be a part of it be any bad? Because they don't want to. They don't want to learn it, they don't want to be a part of it. So they stay in a walled garden where they can participate in groups they want to participate in, with their own culture. And they're not the ones complaining about it, the open web advocates are complaining about their voluntary association with each other.
- hyperdunc 9y agoFinding the open web hostile is a sign of a dangerously sheltered mind. The last thing such a person needs is to be restricted to a relatively sanitized space like Facebook. Far healthier in the long term to engage with ideas that aren't tightly curated and learn to filter out trolls.
- namuol 9y ago> I’m sorry no matter how good your idea is fuck you I won’t help you and Facebook kill the open web. This is not how you win hearts and minds.
- rocky1138 9y agoI like his/her attitude, to be honest. It's jarring, which is what most people need to snap them into thinking for themselves.
- omash 9y agoYep and Google to a bigger extent.
- tuna-piano 9y agoI posted this comment a few weeks ago, but this seems super relevant to extend the author's point. I agree that Facebook is a walled garden. But in the developed world, Facebook is just part of the internet that people use. However, in some parts of the developing world, Facebook is the only internet people use. ------ Facebook's dominance is even more pronounced in parts of the developing world. I've met people in Asia (Myanmar and Nepal) who have just accessed the internet for the first time in the past 12-24 months (through their Android smartphones). But they don't know the true internet - they only know the internet through the Facebook app. They use it like we use Google and web browsers. To them, Facebook is the internet. They don't have email accounts. They don't use the browser. They don't search the web. I met someone in a small town who never even used the maps feature. I tried to think of what value the true internet might bring them, but when I suggested that "you can search for news and read other things", the response was that they already did that with the Facebook App. One guy handed me his phone, so I could add myself as a friend on his Facebook. While I started typing my name, I noticed his search history... and to him, Facebook was even a substitute for what people in the USA might use Incognito mode for! I would call Facebook their internet portal, but it's not really a portal to anything - Facebook is just the entire internet to them. Buzzfeed (yes, Buzzfeed) did an excellent writeup of Myanmar, that mirrors what I saw there: https://www.buzzfeed.com/sheerafrenkel/fake-news-spreads-trump-around-the-world?utm_term=.wb6pxGMyM#.qlR21yOxO https://www.buzzfeed.com/sheerafrenkel/fake-news-spreads-tru... “Nobody asks, they don’t care about the email,” he said, explaining that most don’t know that creating an email address is free, and easy. “No one is using that. They have Facebook.”
- axaxs 9y agoThey do this BS in every 'poor' nation. In many, they even offer 'free facebook' as a carrier perk. The sooner facebook dies, the better.
- downrightmike 9y agoThat is super depressing.
- yla92 9y agoFolk from Myanmar (but working in Singapore) here. People in my country, they regard Facebook as "The Internet". They walked into the mobile phone shop, they asked for "open Facebook for 3$" which comes with a FB account, followed the celebrity pages etc. They do everything you can imagine on FB. Now there are "digital agencies" who take care of the celebrity/company FB pages, post click-bait articles, run campaigns and throw money for advertising. I don't think these things are going to change anytime soon and I don't have an answer. So, either promote yourself, things you are doing, on FB or your online presence is mere. Just sad.
- amelius 9y agoReminder to self that I should put in my LICENSE files: Copyright (c) <year> <copyright holders> Permission is hereby granted, free of charge, to any person ... (the usual stuff, followed by ...) It is the express wish of the author that this software shall not be used in derived products or services to collect or spread information about users against their will for any purpose other than the main functionality of the product or service. Users will need to explicitly "opt-in" to such use of information if desired. The functionality of the derived product or service should be sufficiently broken down to avoid an all-or-nothing proposition to the user. Suggestions for extensions and/or better phrasing welcome. The rationale is that, while this will not have meaning or uphold in a court of law, the least we can do as developers is to send a message of our disapproval for the way big companies are treating the web and its users.
- Ajedi32 9y agoProbably not a good idea. If you include vaguely-worded restrictions like that in your license you're 1) using a non-standard license, and 2) breaking Freedom 0 of GNU's Free Software Definition. Personally I feel that it'd be better to put that sort of statement in the README; especially if you're not concerned with whether its legally-enforceable or not.
- amelius 9y ago> Personally I feel that it'd be better to put that sort of statement in the README; especially if you're not concerned with whether its legally-enforceable or not. You're probably right. And the README would be better, because the message would be visible on the main page in Github :) Another option could be to have the text "The following is not part of the license, but expresses the wishes of the author regarding use of this software ..." in the LICENSE file. I'm hoping we could have a standard phrasing for this kind of thing (just like we have standard licenses). Perhaps the EFF could develop one.
- throwanem 9y agoPerhaps then EFF can develop a way of giving companies that might use these libraries a reason to care that this language is present. "The following is not part of the license" is just a long-winded way of saying "Feel free to ignore what follows this clause even harder than you feel free to ignore what precedes it." I mean, full marks for cooperative nature, but being real here, the licenses in your Github repositories mean exactly as much as you're willing to pay a lawyer to enforce them, assuming you even find out they're being violated in the first place. It would be nice if the world were otherwise, but pretending that is so doesn't seem to me likely to help much of anything. Perhaps I am wrong in so thinking.
- awinter-py 9y agoI'm in a small minority of people who want to pay money to get on FB and can't. I've been trying for months to advertise on there but there's no such thing as a business-only FB acct, you need an organic personal account. And some combination of my activity (not friending anyone, not using FB for anything, using an incognito tab, my IP address? I don't know) looks like trouble to the powers that be so my account keeps getting shut off. I hate them just as much as these other guys but for 2x the reasons.
- darksaints 9y agoBy altering the title, you've taken something deliberately strong and watered it down. This isn't a situation where a different title better conveys the authors intent or content...this is explicitly an opinionated essay expressing exactly what the title summarizes. It is unnecessary censorship. Sure it is a word that commonly is considered vulgar, but it is also a word that has significant visceral meaning. HN shouldn't censor words just because they're strong enough to be offensive.
- lolsal 9y agoI disagree that it is a form of censorship. I think the title of the post linked is more click-baity than the HN title. I am more interested in this article as it's presented on HN than I would have been if I had stumbled on an article named 'Fuck Facebook'.
- donatj 9y agoI find the change of title in complete opposition to the message and meaning of the post.
- zelphir_kalt 9y agoUnfortunately no surprise here. We need more websites telling people this, until finally people realize it.
- MachinShinn- 9y agoI'm baffled by some of the comments here... Is it so difficult for you guys to just have a facebook account that you don't check in on? You can still sign into random sites that require it that way, arrange meetups, etc but without 'scrolling your life away' I expect people like me who spend most of their day on the computer to have at least as much digital self discipline as I have, but perhaps that's a poor assumption to make...
- nnfy 9y agoMy problem with an idle Facebook account is at least twofold: my activity is still being tracked against my will, and out of principle I refuse to support an organization which so blatantly disregards personal space.
- exergy 9y agoMine is even more simplistic. I lack self control. With an account, even a deactivated one, I've been guilty of logging back in at 2 AM on a Wednesday morning just to stalk an old acquaintance from high school.
- criddell 9y agoSign out of Facebook and delete the cookie. You should be fine after that.
- nnfy 9y agoThere is no question that Facebook is tracking you by other means, including IP. Even non-social media companies do so. Why, you may ask? Because mining data about the pages you visit after Facebook allows for targeted advertisement, at the very least.
- Jach 9y agoI'm sure Facebook will still track you (this applies even if you don't have a Facebook account). You'd need to block their domain and any ad domains that may be related. (Edit: Also mentioned here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14463127 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14463127)
- thsowers 9y agoToo relevant...Trump tweets out a link to the livestream for his announcement on the Paris accord, and Facebook bugs me with a banner, and then informs me after clicking on the stream: "Please log in to continue"
- nnfy 9y agoDespite having deleted my little used Facebook months ago, Facebook still finds ways to remind me of its authoritarian intrusiveness; I have a fake account which I use for commenting, and I was asked to upload a copy of a photo ID. I was given a list of options, which included a driver's license and a passport. This level of privacy invasion is simply unnaceptable to me, and I wish people online were more guarded with what amounts to their identity...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- knieveltech 9y agoFacebook is an attack on society itself. Ignorance of other people's stupidity, bigotry, and pettiness is a necessary lubricant for society to function.
- camillomiller 9y agoTotally agree. Especially if the expression of such ignorance comes with a sense of pride and entitlement. It's easy to get entitled and proud, because nobody in real life would give you 200 nods to your racist musings while in line at Walmart. But 200 people press a stupid like button, and suddenly you feel like your idiotic and uneducated opinion has a great meaning. This is straightforward dangerous for representative democracies, which are founded on the subtle concept of an elite of better people that have a mandate to lead society. The fact that this mandate has been misused so many times is no excuse to suddenly drop all the good that comes from having someone who knows more in a position of power.
- makecheck 9y agoThe interesting thing to me is how online numbers are nowhere near statistically significant and yet they "matter" to people. There are billions of people, thousands just in your neighborhood (probably) and yet most people interact with a few dozen network links and the few dozen comment posts they are likely to read. That skew is gigantic, and it should terrify people that they are not relying on more professionally-edited sources.
- camillomiller 9y agoWhat makes the difference, I guess, is the fact that you can actually measure "agreement" in a direct way, with numbers of "agreement units" such as likes. Very easy to misread and blew it out of proportion. Facebook KNOWS that and definitively leverages that. The mission of the company is inherently broken and Mark Zuckerberg, if he's really being honest when he talks about it, well then he's in full blown denial.
- jroseattle 9y agoGruber's post is overly dramatic. He was an Apple fanboy for the longest time, and didn't see that eco-system as an attack on interoperability? The only difference I see here is he doesn't like FB.
- Cozumel 9y agoI think this is more an indictment that people don't actually know how to use FB. YOU control what you want to see and who you interact with, spending to much time there? Take charge of your own life and click off. Seeing something you don't want to see? Hide it. It's not rocket science. Personally I get a great deal of value from it. It's a tool like any other, but you have to know how to use it.
- skc 9y agoYou nailed it, actually. I don't actually find it too ironic that HN is missing the point that Facebook is a cultural phenomenon. The way people communicate has changed, culturally, and Facebook facilitates that. I have an account that I only use to get notifications from long lost family members and friends etc.
- cheaprentalyeti 9y agoI stopped using Facebook when they made it too hard to control what-you-want-to-see-and-interact-with, myself.
- Huhty 9y agoRecent post from my blog that goes into this a bit further: Modern Social Media Platforms Are Kicking Your Blog’s Ass. Here Is How You Can Fight Back. http://blogenhancement.com/blog/2017/03/28/modern-social-media-platforms-are-kicking-your-blogs-ass-here-is-how-you-can-fight-back/ http://blogenhancement.com/blog/2017/03/28/modern-social-med...
- doughj3 9y ago> But Facebook pulling a Vader and altering the deal, blocking public access in the future to a post that today is publicly visible? Or, maybe worse, altering visibility for something that is private today such that it is public tomorrow.
- woodandsteel 9y agoIt's really very simple. Facebook was able to become a huge success because it could compete freely on the open web. Now that Facebook has become so powerful, it is trying to destroy the open web so no one can compete with it. Speaking of which, what wonder what its position is on net neutrality.
- camillomiller 9y agoFacebook has become successful because for the first time in history it materialized the ungraspable matter that is the concept of relationship. It's like a magic device that shows the invisible treads that link the individuals in their own monadic lives. It's like a fucking superior level of intercommunication. And it's scary, and too powerful, and way over the point of no return. Plus, I don't think it's making the world a better place in any meaningful way.
- 659087 9y agoFacebook and Google both have differing "public and private stances" on issues like mass surveillance and net neutrality.
- jessaustin 9y agoPoor Dave Winer. 131 HN comments and no one even pointed to his post that shook Gruber out of his slumber in the first place. http://scripting.com/2017/05/31.html#a110526 http://scripting.com/2017/05/31.html#a110526
- eridius 9y agoThat link is literally in the first sentence of Gruber's post.
- oconnor663 9y ago> Facebook forbids search engines from indexing Facebook posts. Content that isn’t indexable by search engines is not part of the open web. When you make an argument like this, you need to acknowledge that tons people want the opposite thing you want. That doesn't make you wrong, but leaving it out makes it so much harder to have a good discussion.
- krupan 9y agoFacebook has done wonders to get people creating and consuming content on the internet. However, Facebook has grown to the point where it has no competition and is no longer innovating in ways that benefit us. Facebook should split into Facebook the aggregator and Facebook the content hoster. You could talk about a third piece that is Facebook the content provider, which is for providing things like gifs, templates, memes, emoji, games, and other stuff like that. Because Facebook hasn't completely broken from open web standards those types of content providers already exist today. Aggregators would be where you go to set up your friend list and see your feed. It could look and feel like Facebook does now. It would have an open standard protocol that content hosters would use if they wanted to be aggregated. This could still be an add driven business, but subscription, self hosted, and DIY solutions could exist too. Content hosters could either charge a monthly hosting fee, or they could serve up their own adds. Self hosted and DIY solutions could also exist. The big benefit to this would of course be the competition. Since it's an open standard anyone could be a content host, and anyone could be an aggregator. To make extra sure there is competition, and this could come in a phase two after the initial splitting up of Facebook, there should be open standards for exporting and importing friends, follows, likes, etc. to and from aggregators, and open standards for importing and exporting content from the hosters. Speaking of follows and likes, there could also be aggregator aggregators (AAs). People could opt in to publicly and anonymously share their likes and follows and the AAs would consume those and report on trends that cross aggregator boundaries. Anonymity could be much more protected this way while still giving us that interesting information about what is trending. One tricky part of this is how do I as a content author only allow my friends to see certain posts of mine? It would have to be with encryption. My content provider could keep public keys of my friends and only my friends (well, their aggregators) would be able to decrypt my posts using my friends' private keys. I can see some challenges and holes in this, but it doesn't seem any worse overall than how Facebook protects privacy now. Open implementations and peer review could get us to better-than-Facebook privacy quickly. Facebook would ideally recognize their stagnation and initiate this split themselves. We as their user base can and should help them understand the importance of this. Hopefully it doesn't have to come down to government enforcement of anti-trust laws, but that could be a useful tool to apply here as well.
- ilamont 9y agoI have used FB since 2004. It became less and less of a place I wanted to spend time in when they started filling the feed with junk. First it was Farmville updates and other social games, then viral videos, then ads, then links to news articles and clickbait that I had no interest in clicking on. I must have blocked hundreds of apps, sites, and clickbait generators shared by friends in the last few years alone. However, I won't disconnect FB as long as it's the primary way for me to check on/communicate with/share photos with relatives and friends from years ago. But it's hardly an addictive time-suck for me, and also for some of my friends judging by how seldom they post updates.
- Sir_Cmpwn 9y agoI usually post this on HN's Facebook threads, happy to do it again: https://www.facebook.com/help/224562897555674 https://www.facebook.com/help/224562897555674
- bradgessler 9y agoWhat honestly replaces Facebook today with a product and business model that's not dependent on advertisements? The best thing I can think of is Apple Photos and Messages.
- jarjoura 9y agoI think it's hilarious that the comments in here suggest Facebook gets in the way of quality of life because of the way it captures your attention. Yet, then they spend a large amount of time on this site practicing another form of toxicity. I get that some people, here especially it seems, have very strongly held beliefs about privacy and personal space that Facebook will never accommodate for. Nor should they be expected to. Clearly those people will never be the target audience and that's 100% okay.
- Wissmania 9y agoI agree with the authors points about blogging on facebook and having a decent logged out experience, but I want to push back against him lumping in anti-adblock pop overs. Every publisher of high quality content is dependent on advertising to stay in business. When you are using adblock, your eyeballs are freeloading off of all the users who are using the website as intended. I certainly understand the urge to use adblock, but it's amazing to me that people would feel entitled enough to actually expect publishers not to try to prevent this.
- makecheck 9y agoAnd he is a publisher of content too, with ads, and you didn't notice what he does differently? All text, simple links, and usually a nice blurb describing the company/product. I have read 2000% more of those than I have ever cared about any pushy, animated, noisy ad on any other site. His system works, without being obnoxious.
- rdslw 9y agoIn 6..18 months, I'll short facebook stocks.
- pelasaco 9y agomimimimimi
- ProAm 9y agoThere is a bit of irony here with how Gruber defends Apple but finds Facebook a threat.
- tkubacki 9y agoWhenever I see Gruber talking about openess and standards I smell hipocrysy - same way we can say iOS ecosystem is an attack on open computing (walled garden).
- eridius 9y agoiOS apps being a walled garden doesn't really have anything to do with the open web. Apple has long embraced the open web, so there's nothing hypocritical about this.
- enos_feedler 9y agoApple embraces the open web, but I think what people get upset about is their lack of effort in moving it forward. For example, adopting "PWA" browser APIs in mobile Safari.
- camillomiller 9y agoI agree that Gruber is leaning a lot towards Cupertino, but when it comes to open Web standards he's always been praising Google's approaches and had critics for Apple's Safari and WebKit approach. Let's not start pointing fingers about being hypocritical, tho, otherwise I would really hear for example how exactly is Google stance on openness not hypocritical. (I know you didn't name Google directly, but it's the easiest example)
- 5ourpu55 9y agoSome ( pro-facebook?) people in this thread appear to have very little empathy for people, like me, who were not able to pull themselves away from the designed-to-be-addictive social media platform, without deleting it completely. Yes. Having an account sitting around, with all of my friends attached to it, was too much of a temptation for me. Purging the entire thing from my life was the only thing that worked. I like to make things easy on myself: I don't keep booze around because I drink it like a fish. I don't keep weed around because I smoke it like Snoop Dogg. I don't keep junk-food around because I eat it. I live right next to my gym to make it easy to get to. I don't keep facebook around because I browse it.
- blazespin 9y agoI love facebook! I never post any selfies or personal news, but I love reading others and I like discussing politics on FB. I'm not a like whore either. I'm pretty happy to just post and get zero likes. I wonder if anyone reads my posts? O well.
- b0rsuk 9y agoThere's a string of submissions critical of Facebook on HN recently. I agree and approve. But one thing interests me: doesn't Facebook have something like that, but in reverse ? I mean updates along the lines "We need more Facebook", "Open internet is for nerds", "Why more websites need to migrate to Facebook"... ? Unless you have a Facebook account, you don't know what's going on on the other side of the barricade. One puzzling fact - stars on github: jquery/jquery - 45k, angular/angular - 25k, facebook/react - 68k, twbs/bootstrap - 111k, On my local job market (I live in a 500k city), react is the least popular JS framework. I keep seeing jquery and especially angular over and over. Meanwhile react, the facebookiest of JS frameworks, shows up least frequently. Yet React is the most popular JS framework and by a large margin! I suspect it's because job offers with 'react' are mostly circulated via facebook. I also see very little job offers with the 'facebook' keyword - mostly for non-technical people, like marketing, salesmen, assistants, various misc jobs. Hypothesis: we, outside Facebook, live in our own filter bubble. We don't get the whole picture.
- blazespin 9y agoI really like facebook. It's nice to stay in touch with your friends, especially when abroad.
- compiler-guy 9y agoFacebook is really nice for many usecases. But it could be way more open without ruining those usecases. It is just so hostile to non-facebook users. The primary example being the one cited in the article: The only reason to block 1/3 of a page to nonlogged in users is to convince you to either sign up or log in. There is no user-based reason to do so. That is open-web hostile. There is no need to make the all the content non-searchable, except to convince you to log in and search locally. That is open-web hostile. I used to think Google was bad for its intrusive "No really, you should log-in" campaigns, but facebook makes Google look so reasonable on this score.
- wuliwong 9y agoI think the reason it seems so strange is because they do let some things be "public." There was a time when you could see zero content without being logged in to an account. I would prefer if Facebook were a 100% walled garden. It would make the usage more simple. But then Zuckerberg wouldn't have as much money, I suppose. Google is murky too but they were coming from the 100% open side of things. I just wish everyone would go back to their corners!
- haywirez 9y agoLove the post(s), the reasons mentioned are precisely why I took the time to make my own site. There are so many unexplored opportunities with custom components that will never work on platforms, but too few are doing it. Alan Kay's talks completely changed my way of thinking - you need to take control of your tools.
- doktrin 9y agoFacebook is probably the last place I go looking for quality blog-type content. Also, the title and tone of this piece both seem intensely hyperbolic to me.
- inostia 9y agoI really, really hate the "log in to Facebook" popover. I haven't had a Facebook account for over a year and I'm incredibly happy about it. The only downside is now I don't hear about local events.
- krishg 9y agoFacebook would be good if they didn't keep shoving more and more services into it. I don't want to order food from Facebook and don't want to sell anything. Ad blocker takes care of ad spam.
- enos_feedler 9y agoIs it that you don't want to sell anything at all? or just on Facebook? When facebook launched this feature I had a bunch of old iPhones lying around and I sold them through facebook really fast. I actually liked it a lot. Identity was not an issue (never felt like I would get ripped off). It was easy to take a photo, set a price and publish within 10 seconds. I started to sell things I didn't even think about selling because it was so easy.
- alkonaut 9y agoPeople should just use Facebook for what it's good at, for example event planning. In a social context Facebook is often the only social platform "everyone" is on - that's a killer feature. No matter how good a competing specialized app is - if you e.g invite people by email it's not even close to the power of Facebook. People (and corporations) should STOP using all the other features and the web will be a much better place. Don't put articles on Facebook like a blog. It's not a blog. Don't make Facebook your only site for your restaurant. A static html page with your address and opening hours is better. And whatever you do, don't ever click a facebook ad or "like" a company on Facebook.
- aanm1988 9y agoso is google. Conglomeration in general isn't great for the open web. That's where we are though.
- lolsal 9y ago> Content that isn’t indexable by search engines is not part of the open web. I'm not really sure what this means, but my knee-jerk reaction is that the 'open web' exists without search engines.
- ominous 9y agoIn Ultima Online you could write books. While those were fun to find, would you say they were part of the open web? What if those books were in Ilshenar, guarded by two stone gargoyles? Hey, let's just meet and talk there. I sure love to go to Ilshenar. I'm sure my friends from all walks of life/culture/class would also love to go to Ilshenar see what I am talking about.
- pc2g4d 9y agoFacebook solved some real problems and thus pointed out weakness with the open web as it is. The way to combat this is not to wring our hands but to improve the web so it solves the same problems. Things like spam/moderation. Is it possible to have a distributed, open solution to this problem?
- bad_user 9y agoI tried deleting Facebook once, but I've got family there and ... the big problem is that I haven't gotten my time spent online back. I'm on Twitter, I'm on Hacker News, I'm on Reddit, I'm on Gitter, I send/receive dirty jokes on WhatsApp, etc. Plenty of opportunity to waste time, no need for FB to be in the picture at all. I've been composing this stupid message for the past 5 minutes. But I'm using Facebook less and less. For me the "open web" is a necessity, not a moral high ground or anything like that. I don't like opening Facebook blog posts because Facebook sucks for blog posts. TFA mentions the Internet Archive or Google not indexing articles. Hell yeah, those are really good concerns. Also, forget the open web ... how about the fact that if you give them permissions to access your photos, on iOS at least, they are uploading your photos to their services for making photo collages, without you explicitly allowing this. I know this because I opened the app a week ago and I was proposed a collage with animated transitions and music in the background, titled "Your Sunday evening in Bucharest", that couldn't have been processed on my phone - especially since iOS restricts background activity, plus it would be pretty bad for battery life. And I freaked out, so now Facebook is gone from my phone. Article mentions an all out assault on the open web. Sure, but it's also an all out assault on people's privacy. I was 7 when Ceaușescu was shot and communism fell in 1989 and before that paranoia was at an all times high. People were afraid for example that their phones were tapped and that their neighbours were listening. Which was in fact true, but oh boy, that's nothing compared with what happens today.
- lyra_comms 9y agoLyra is a breath of fresh air for language and communication on the web. www.hellolyra.com
- calebgilbert 9y agoBesides Facebook banning search engine indexing of itself the search functionality of Facebook itself is terrible. I belong to several groups and I've seen numerous examples of content, which I know is in the group, not showing up in search results while using very straight forward and matching searches.
- colordrops 9y agoPeople in this thread talking about getting off of Facebook like former smack addicts...
- arrowgunz 9y agoOh boy, so many users disliking Facebook in this thread. > — a full one-third of my window is covered by a pop-over trying to get me to sign in or sign up for Facebook. I get that John is clearly annoyed by a certain aspects of Facebook, but, I feel like it's unfair to say "Fuck Facebook" based on that. Facebook posts are primarily meant to be shared on the social network and not on the web. You can, of course, share it on the web, if the author of the post wishes to. But, Facebook has an amazing Notes features, which basically acts like a personalized blog. Long posts are meant to be shared via Notes and not the regular status update posts. Check out this awesome note created by Kent Beck: https://www.facebook.com/notes/kent-beck/mastering-programming/1184427814923414 https://www.facebook.com/notes/kent-beck/mastering-programmi... They don't put a pop-over that takes up 1/3 of your page. Also, I see a lot of people complaining about timesuck and how getting off of Facebook has improved their lives. How is any of it Facebook's fault? If anything, it means that it's a win for Facebook since they're providing good content that interests you, the user. Also, stating that Facebook is trying to kill the open web is a bit ridiculous to say. Facebook's main sell is their content. They're not a search engine. They don't have to let non-Facebook users access their protected content. Yes, they do have a search engine that searches across the Facebook platform, but, you'd have to be a Facebook user in order to be able to search for it. Facebook got a lot of heat a few years ago for the lack of proper privacy features. Now, people complain about not having access to somebody else's content? There is no way everybody in this world can be satisfied. Also, expecting Facebook to allow Internet Archive to index Facebook's content is unfair. Why should Facebook allow Internet Archive to index their protected content? The content is for the users to share with whoever they wish to share with, which may not necessarily be everybody in the world.
- garrettjoecox 9y ago> But, Facebook has an amazing Notes features, which basically acts like a personalized blog. Promoting this literally proves his argument. No one even needs a web browser anymore! Just download facebook! /s
- idibidiartists 9y agoI switched to Observer Only mode on Facebook after Trump got elected because I did not want to be stopped and e-frisked at airports. It turned out that that was the best way to use Facebook: stay on top of happenings with your friends and relatives but let them reach out to you on other communication channels if they miss you or wish to communicate some news. All the sudden, I'm having more meaningful, coherent dialog over email and text as opposed to stupid Facebook comments and likes.
- peterwwillis 9y agoYou've got to be kidding me. Google has taken over search, web browsing, advertising, and has the largest mobile platform. They hold your email, maps, search history, personal docs, office suite, and calendar. They authenticate you to services all over the web. All of your actually important data (you really can live without pictures, unless you are a photographer or model) resides with them. They have created several new protocols that the web uses regularly, and influences new standards. They influence how most web content is created. They have leverage over most of the companies doing business on the web. They handle domains, cloud computing, business services, and a range of other products I don't remember. And they control how you use the web with their browsers and OSes. There is no other company that single-handedly controls so many aspects of the web. Facebook is just a social platform; Google is everything else.
- beagle3 9y agoYou are not wrong. And yet, many people spend upward of 3 hours/day with the screen showing Facebook. They actively have google in front of their eyes for much less.
- niftich 9y agoLook, there's no dispute that Facebook is an assault on the 'open web' because it's a walled garden where the data only flows in. In fact, on the HN thread for Gruber's previous post about Google's AMP, I defended [1] some aspects of AMP because at least it tries to be distributed vs. Facebook, and in that post I echo much of what Gruber would later say. But sadly, today's so-called 'open web' is just as much of an assault on the open web: trackers, cookies, and cross-correlated advertisements follow the user everywhere; every new link is literally a crapshoot which may execute arbitrary code placed there by the webmaster or their delegates. It's the devil you know vs. the devil that's brand-new every time: do I want my browsing habits aggregated to help them better target ads and content for me inside some walled garden, or do I want my browsing habits across the 'open web' to be aggregated by a dozen third parties to help them better target ads for me on the outside, while I blissfully extoll the virtues of decentralization and pretend I'm better off? Until recently, the only way to avoid this was to spin off a clean incognito session in a browser running only one window, then close it after every pageview. Who does that? Short of a very particular few, no one. The web is a wonderful, versatile medium of referencible documents and multimedia that we've turned into an application delivery platform; and the one thing that content silos like Facebook, Instagram, Snapchat, and Apple News get right is that not everyone cares to visit unvetted content solely judged by its URL. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14384607 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14384607
- aethertron 9y ago>Look, there's no dispute that Facebook is an assault on the 'open web' because it's a walled garden where the data only flows in. I dispute that. I don't feel like my 'open' WordPress blogs are being attacked by Facebook. Does Facebook's lack of full-blown openness constitute an attack on anything? I don't think it does. It seems open web advocates resent that FB successfully competes against their offering. I have a fondness for the open web. I'd rather see us learn from FB, and compete, rather than whine about losing market share.
- smichel17 9y ago> Until recently, the only way to avoid this was to spin off a clean incognito session in a browser running only one window, then close it after every pageview. What other solution are you implying by "until recently"? > Who does that? Short of a very particular few, no one. I'm probably one of the particular few, but I've found it very painless to 1) Install and use firefox's containers experiment 2) Install the "private tab" addon 3) In about:config, remap <Ctrl-t> to open a new private tab Now new tabs are private by default (although they share cookies within a browser session), and if I want to keep cookies or history I open a new container tab... with nearly zero change in my workflow. Apologies for lack of links; I'm on mobile.
- torgoguys 9y agoI LOVE Facebook, even though I never use it. Before FB, my email was clogged with trivial crap that family members and aquaintances forwarded to everyone in their address book, including me. Now that never happens. Based on everyone else's complaints, it sounds like that stuff has moved to FB leaving my inbox a much more useful place. THANK YOU ZUCK!
- hardworkforyour 9y agoSuckerberg is threatening whole internet with 87 sex options and totally insane opnions of people's privacy! Whole company should be investigated of privacy crimes
- l33tbro 9y agoThe "open web" is really an Eden-like myth, as there has and always will be stakeholders with various agendas chicaning the free exchange of information. Sorry, yes, but we really are opportunistic fucks. Not to Gordon Gecko levels, but an element of it will always be there and we need to collectively acknowledge and integrate it if we are to evolve. Either way, Facebook's obfuscation of data is justifiably a cause for the concern due to the mass adoption of its platform. Yet, it's easy to focus on the machinations and fuckery that Facebook engage in to hold our gaze and numb our minds. What's more difficult is to question the agency of its hundreds of millions of users, who each have a slab of skull-encased smartmeat that gifts them with relative free will in their lives. Rather predictably, it comes down to a question of agency and personal responsibility: if you don't like the site, get off it. But were only it so simple. Facebook is so deeply entrenched in the infrastructure of our personal lives, that it's very difficult for a lot of 'normies'(sic) to just pack up and fuck off. While the HN community may be au fait with the finer points of privacy, mass surveillance, and the founding principles of our nascent virtual civilisation - Dave from softball in Akron or Juliette who has a duck farm in the south of France do not. While they'd be concerned about those things if they were explained and they grokked the implications, their fucks lie elsewhere and, hence, Big Social Media remains a fringe idea. TLDR: We get the social media we deserve.
- SkyMarshal 9y agoIt's almost like Facebook is a new AoL in web's clothing, trying to trick less sophisticated users that it's "the internet" when it's really just a single corporations's closed system.
- oever 9y agoWhy do we need Facebook?
- cornchips 9y agoFacebook is evil. They knew people would be posting videos killing themselves and let others watch. If you know anything about psychology; trauma and copycats. [1] Facebook retains your data, and you can't do anything about it. I don't know how any engineers can work there knowing in their mind the delete button is a ruse -- or "incomplete functionality". From what i've observed there is active censorship especially in regards to negative statements of facebook (of which i'm sure they are aware of copycats). This company has brought out the worst of society and they are deserving of justice -- or at least balance. [1] https://www.theguardian.com/news/2017/may/21/facebook-users-livestream-self-harm-leaked-documents https://www.theguardian.com/news/2017/may/21/facebook-users-... "Experts have told us what’s best for these people’s safety is to let them livestream as long as they are engaging with viewers."
- cgb223 9y ago> It is not accessible to search engines The thought of potential employers searching though Facebook posts I made when I was a teenager terrifies me. If they ever made this possible I'd stop using their service immediately
- rndmind 9y agoDon't be so naive to think that YOU are the only one who can potentially read and sift through all your facebook information. The is empirical evidence that any one who pays for it, can has access to it, not even to mention nation-states, can has access.
- hossbeast 9y agoI prefer the original title, "fuck Facebook"
- kuon 9y agoI'm a programmer and my facebook account has been created only for testing apps. I don't even really know facebook is for.
- guest 9y ago[WARNING if you do not like rants stay away] First off, the open net is dead, people not giving a fuck killed it when they simply said yet to the shitty deals the unscrupulous companies offered. Those tech savvy should have lead the way away from these sites to alternatives - that didn't happen. If that wasn't enough the knowledge of EchelonV killed it. People will never again act truly honestly on the net, which hopefully will offset any short sighted plans google and NSA has to premeptively steer public opinion. The last real breath was drawn as people kept on using google and that breath was drawn precisely when google "modified" their algorithm to kill off private sites who came in high on rankings. Since then any site that has arisen to challange google seems to have magically have been killed or taken over (suddenly swapping to using google coding for unexplained reasons). Oh to mention a few; scroogle, qwant, lycos, zapmeta, qwant, wn, millionshort, gigablast, xirkle... You can still search through the old altavista pile if u want but yeah. Most other motors gives u a shitstorm of companies that you do not care for before you can read private sites off enligthened people who strive to improve x thing. The next terryfying thing is as what happens when large sites get taken over and the large libraries of knowledge falls into informal hands or simply disappears (IMDB boards to mention a recent setback, and i meant the positive discussions not the large clusterfks of idiots and astroturfers et al). And of before i forget - as someone who saw through FB before it took off (previous avid user of ICQ, AIM, newb at IRC etc) i fucking told you (if any of those i actually told would stumble across this). Localised meshnets could have been the future (with "netbrowsers" as the tool to reach em), though with the thought of all that information being in the hands of normal people governments are "finally" reacting and starting to spread fibre as far as i know through some of europe (scandinavia) which could effectively kill that effort. So start taking political action for a free future of information \/.
- webuser321 9y agoIdea for startup: Compete with Facebook on one item: meetings for groups and organizations. Allow users to join groups without having to join Facebook.
- ossmaster 9y agoWhat happens when zuckerburg runs for president?
- hobarrera 9y agoThat popup that takes up a third of the page is ridiculous (I actually think it's a bit more on my screen). Whenever I get a link to facebook for something I sigh, because that sort of stupid, hostil UX won't get them anywhere. If people wanted an account, they'd have one. It's not like visiting the link is going to be my first time ever hearing of facebook, and that's probably true for 99% of the people visiting one.
- piyush_soni 9y agoBut then, I seem to spend equal amount of time scrolling here on HN as I do on facebook. How many things can I deactivate now? :|
- partycoder 9y agoI think the future of social networks will be turning them into a protocol, the same way we use e-mail. Everyone is connected through e-mail but nobody technically owns it.
- erikpukinskis 9y agoThe popover doesn't seem as big an issue as the fact that you can't browse the archive of public posts unless you are logged in. John Carmack posts public reviews of VR games frequently on Facebook. Here's one: https://www.facebook.com/permalink.php?story_fbid=1717273305173846&id=100006735798590 https://www.facebook.com/permalink.php?story_fbid=1717273305... But if you want to browse previous reviews, there is no mention of them on his public Facebook page. Look at these two screenshots: https://imgur.com/a/wal8p https://imgur.com/a/wal8p If you log in, Facebook is all of the sudden like "look at all this public content!" Totally skeezy.
- cakeface 9y agoFacebook is not an attack. It's just a website people. If you don't like it, don't type that URL in your browser software.
- bambax 9y agoThe (real) title of this post is exactly how I feel about Facebook. Facebook is AOL, if AOL had won. But the question is: what can we do about it? Resist certainly helps (never had a Facebook account and hopefully never will -- although I did get on Whatsapp two months ago). I will also prevent my kids to have Facebook while under my roof. But what else?
- jeena 9y agoMeh, old news at least for me who always has been sceptikal, I point out a lot of those reasons out in my IndieWeb talk: https://jeena.net/media/2016/IndieWeb-Jeena.pdf https://jeena.net/media/2016/IndieWeb-Jeena.pdf
- nihonde 9y agoMy experience with Facebook was that it made me a lot less fond of people that I used to call friends. I'm a bit of a nomad, so I have clusters of friends and family that exist in places I've long since left behind. At first, I was curious about what they were up to, but the reality of their curated online selves was more disappointing than enlightening. I was getting a lot of annoying politics and boring photos of kid play dates, pets, dinners, sporting events, etc. Obviously, the quality of your feed depends on the quality of the people you connect with, but I found myself more disconnected from people who previously occupied a nostalgic fondness in my mind. On the other hand, the people who I cared the most about were routinely the quietest people on Facebook because--let's face it--smart, productive people don't waste time on things like that. I'm relatively old (40's), so my experience is also skewed by that. I left by editing my hosts file to block all FB-related servers and never looked back.
- chuckdries 9y agoI understand why they don't want posts archived by archive.org. It's a privacy thing for users to be able to delete their own content from the web.
- piracyde25 9y agoHide Yo Feed script to turn Facebook feed into a blank page. You wouldn't have to worry about timesucking anymore. https://greasyfork.org/en/scripts/29032-hide-yo-feed https://greasyfork.org/en/scripts/29032-hide-yo-feed
- amauta 9y agoAh~ the beauty of killing a social site. Myspace went downhill little by little (; Blockchain will also help kill FB :D
- aethertron 9y agoI'd be interested to know how you think that will help kill FB.
- mmjaa 9y agoFacebook is the AOL of the 21st Century. There will always be these closed gardens, walled-off. (Could've been CompuServe.) The point is, the open web is the open web. This also needs to be common. Eventually, kiddos grow up and escape the pretty gardens - at least lets have something out here that they can clutch on to, in awe, at all the non-curated, non-owned, non-manipulated/-manipulative content ..
- minmaxmux 9y agoGeorge Soros owns part of facebook. That can only be a good thing, right ? Whats wrong??
- minmaxmux 9y agoFacebook so yesterday so 2000
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- anigbrowl 9y agoFacebook succeeds because the open web is a UX nightmare for anyone without a tech background. FB is the usccessor to AOL is the successor to [prodify, genie, whichever] is the successor to text-based bulletin board software. People primarily use social media to connect with and make new friends. They do not want to deal with a million and 1 different user interfaces in the name of openness. That's why Usenet worked so well until people like Canter & siegel killed it with commercial spam. The open web is great for the same reason that magazines and TV are great, but it's also shit for the same reason that magazines and TV are shit - too much shallow design competing for people's attention, with everyone trying to differentiate themselves from everyone else via style and gimmicks. That's the same thing that made myspace unusual, an impossible excess of visual cruft that far outweighed its substantive communication value. The open web is fine, but the web is not the right platform for social networking. For social you want a fast, clean, boring interface...like the one on HN. If you think FB is the problem (and it's very very problematic but plenty of other people are already making that case), stop rabbiting about web standards and get to work on NNTP 2.0. NNTP was fucking awesome. Gopher was fucking awesome. the semantic web is/was awesome. The web is not for social.
- mmargerum 9y agoSeems like a problem that will fix itself. No one under 18 uses Facebook .
- abetancort 9y agoFuck Facebook! Stop wasting cycles and bytes discussing over something obvious, while making "dumb" excuses why you need to go back and get fucked back.