11 ms·
Paul Allen's new rocket-launching plane
- ndr 9y agoThe article doesn't mention SpaceX, I wonder what's the difference in energy and cost for launching (and landing) the relative stage 1s. Does anyone have an idea on that?
- wolf550e 9y agoAt separation, Falcon 9 first stage is doing about 2500 meters/second and is at about 70km altitude. The two connected 747s flying in formation don't get that fast (or that high, but horizontal velocity is much more important).
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- mabbo 9y agoThe Falcon 9 first stage releases stage 2 at around 6-10 times the height and 10x the speed. That said, remember that the difficulty of elevating yourself above a given height is much worse the lower you are. Using a plane-drop means skipping the very worst parts of the launch. The air is so much thinner. There's other advantages though. Launch windows get much easier, as the plane can fly in any direction, and stay at a given heading a bit longer.
- Analemma_ 9y agoI'm confused as to what this thing can accomplish. It can probably fly very high, but I assume it can't fly very fast (relative to orbital speed), and I thought the overwhelming majority of the delta-V to get something into orbit was for forward momentum and that just launching from higher up wouldn't help much. Clearly there's something I'm missing here (or they wouldn't have built it), can anyone fill me in?
- modeless 9y agoFor anyone unclear on why launching a rocket from a plane isn't as great of an idea as it sounds like it would be, this is an excellent explanation: https://what-if.xkcd.com/58/ https://what-if.xkcd.com/58/
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- bamboozled 9y agoCheckout the photo gallery, it seems to launch a rocket from between the two hulls while flying very high in the atmosphere (less drag and gravity).
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- grkvlt 9y agoNot really that much less gravity, certainly not enough to notice, let alone have a difference to a rocket launch. Gravity varies as 1/R^2 where R in this case is distance from the earth, so it's the difference between that at ~6380 km and ~6400 km (for a 20 km altitude) which is not much - you have to be well into space, at over 1000 km up, before gravity drops to less than 7 km/s^2 for instance.
- tejtm 9y agoThe less air you are pushing the cheaper it is to achieve that delta-V
- daveslash 9y agoThe article claims that it hold's the record for largest wingspan, which is 385ft. It then goes on to say that this blows away the previous record of 65ft. I don't know what the largest wingspan is, but I thought B-52s had a wingspan of 185ft? Error in the article?
- alpyne 9y ago"by 65 feet"
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- robbiep 9y agoIf you read a bit more carefully you'll see that the previous record holder was the Spruce Goose
- tonyhb 9y ago> previous record by 65 feet
- roywiggins 9y agoIt beats the previous record by a margin of 65 feet, I believe.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- sparky_z 9y agoBlows past the previous record by 65 ft. The Spruce Goose[0] had a wingspan of 320 ft. (It's possible the article has been updated since you saw it to correct that.) [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hughes_H-4_Hercules https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hughes_H-4_Hercules
- daveslash 9y agoThank you all. My mistake. Much embarrass.
- rmason 9y agoPaul Allen isn't alone in this endeavour. The field is actually getting quite crowded: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_launch_to_orbit https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_launch_to_orbit
- mLuby 9y agoIANARS but this plane should give the remaining stage(s) four advantages: 1. +230m/s orbital velocity [1] 2. +9km launch altitude [1] 3. can launch in more weather conditions 4. 1st stage can abort mid-launch without loss of payload. Of these, the most important is the increase in launch altitude, because that means stage 2 launches in air of greatly decreased density, leading to the following efficiencies: A. a vacuum-optimized nozzle can be used, increasing engine performance B. less aerodynamic/drag energy losses C. max Q should be lower, allowing full throttle usage, reducing mass needed for structural elements, and reducing vibration stresses on payload [1] http://dailym.ai/2soH6FD http://dailym.ai/2soH6FD P.S. Thank you KSP for teaching me this stuff! :D Bonus: video of pegasus air launched rocket: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jz_5hnIw2jc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jz_5hnIw2jc
- guscost 9y agoNeat - I kind of intuitively knew about B. from playing KSP, but the other two are interesting.
- Gravityloss 9y agoYou can also fly towards the equator before the launch for more boost. Further from the Earth's axis. For example Cape Kennedy is 28 degrees north. If you fly to the equator, you get another 200 m/s. Depends a bit to which orbit you're launching though. Another good thing is flexibility if you are more constrained by launch windows in a stationary launch location. Hard to explain.
- Gravityloss 9y agoI had a big mistake in the comment above, it's 220 km/h or about 60 m/s. cos(28)=0.88 0.12*(2*pi*7000 km) = 5300 km 5300 km / 24 h = 220 km/h 220 km/h / 3.6 m/s/km/h = 61 m/s
- jameshart 9y agoIs 4. really doable? Would have thought landing while carrying a fully fueled rocket might be pretty high risk.
- jacquesm 9y agoI'd really hate to see that thing land in a crosswind, I don't think I could watch it.
- nbanks 9y agoThey could always use a chase car like they do with the U-2 Dragon Lady because of its ridiculous wing span. This wouldn't help you avoid watching it, though. youtu.be/W2tnCDBkIoI
- jacquesm 9y agoThat pilot is an artist. Such a narrow gear stance on such a huge wingspan and he lands it perfectly. Wonder how many times it went wrong versus how many times it worked.
- jeffdavis 9y agoDumb question: why don't they launch rockets from the tops of mountains?
- mLuby 9y agoNot a dumb question—Saddam Hussein was trying to do this. https://www.wikiwand.com/en/Project_Babylon https://www.wikiwand.com/en/Project_Babylon It's prohibitively expensive and logistically challenging to build on a mountain, and mountains on Earth don't go nearly as high as planes can.
- countryqt30 9y agoBuilding a mountain is expensive and not scalable
- mikeash 9y agoI think it's mainly that the difficulty of building infrastructure up there, and hauling rockets and payloads up every time you launch, isn't worth the benefits. If you could magick a launch pad and rocket to the top of Mount Everest and launch it from there, you'd get a small but decent performance improvement.
- adt2bt 9y agoI imagine it's a mix of mountainous terrain making it hard to transport launch vehicles to the top and most mountains aren't next to the sea (so the payload would have to travel over land, raising the stakes of an unplanned early failure).
- vit05 9y agoBeing close to the equator is more important. And mountains that could be used to construct a base are not so high.
- the8472 9y agoThose are not mutually exclusive, you could build one on some plateau in the andes near the equator. But I guess the economics still don't work out for that.
- ufmace 9y agoThe really interesting question - does the modest increase in initial velocity and altitude with a boost out of the lower atmosphere make it practical to build a Single Stage To Orbit rocket? If they can, then it's an impressive achievement. If not, then it doesn't really seem worth the trouble.
- averagewall 9y agoWhile having fewer stages sounds simpler and easier, that's not necessarily a major cost. Having a big and powerful 1st stage is a major cost so this should allow either a cheaper 1st stage or a heavier payload.
- PhasmaFelis 9y agoTechnically I think the carrier plane counts as a stage, so two-stage-to-orbit is the minimum. Yes, I know what you meant. :) Interesting question.
- Symmetry 9y agoThe altitude boost is certainly not worth the work. The velocity from the plane is small but since fuel requirements go up exponentially with necessary velocity every bit helps. More important than that is that the rocket doesn't have to punch through as dense of an atmosphere when getting up to speed. That means you don't have to reinforce the rocket as much since it's maximum dynamic pressure (maxQ) is lower giving you a better mass ratio and it means that you're not losing as much delta-v to air resistance but that's only another 100 m/s or so for a decently sized rocket like the one being launched here. But more importantly you can design your engines so that they don't have to work at higher atmospheric pressures. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rocket_engine_nozzle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rocket_engine_nozzle A Merlin engine with a bell designed for taking off from sea level has a trust at sea level of 845 kN but a thrust in Vacuum of 914 kN all while burning the same amount of fuel. And a Merlin with a nozzle sized for vacuum use can go up to 934 kN when firing in vacuum, again for the same fuel flow rate.
- curtis 9y agoIt seems like air launch doesn't buy you a whole lot, but it turns out that a small win on delta-v can result in a fairly big win on payload. This might seem counter-intuitive, but you have to remember that in orbital class rockets, payload is only 5% or so of total mass at take-off.
- InclinedPlane 9y agoIt's a small win on delta V, a small win on gravity losses, and a small win on Isp (due to atmospheric pressure). The delta V and Isp wins are exponentially related to stage mass fraction so they actually become very big wins.
- mabbo 9y agoIt's a bit like having a very small first stage that gets you out of the thickest air, with a little speed and altitude. The Falcon 9, by comparison, uses the first stage to get many times higher, but spends a huge amount of it's fuel during that first part of takeoff. For smaller launches, the plane-drop seems a much better idea.
- simonh 9y agoSince the Orbital ATK Pegasus already exists and already has a customised plane it launches from, can we assume launching Pegasus is just phase 1 for this plane? If that's all it's going to do there would be no point. So presumably this has capabilities the current Pegasus launch plane doesn't have, and eventually we'll see it launching something like a Pegasus XL Plus? Do we have any indication how big a rocket this thing can carry? Also, I wonder how this compares in capability to the XS-1 currently under development, which will be a vertically launched first stage rocket that can fly back for a runway landing. Edit: just found the link below from last year on Space.com. http://www.space.com/32680-stratolaunch-rocket-vulcan-aerospace-mystery.html http://www.space.com/32680-stratolaunch-rocket-vulcan-aerosp...
- HXFIVE 9y agoOriginally it was going to use a Falcon 5 Air, and later a Pegasus II. Both projects were cancelled.
- SkyMarshal 9y agoThis is awesome but a little bit scary. Interesting that they didn't physically connect the tail wings at all, I wonder what stresses and torques the main wing will endure under maneuvering or turbulence. I assume all the control surfaces are computer controlled to synchronize and minimize that, but from the perspective of an ignorant observer, looks a little fragile.
- kashkhan 9y agoit's a proven design. scaled composites, which built this also built the GlobalFlyer with similar configuration. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Virgin_Atlantic_GlobalFlyer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Virgin_Atlantic_GlobalFlyer
- monk_e_boy 9y agoSo the bit of wing that joins the two fuselages is made of carbon fibre? Are there any details on how it was constructed? Imagine that thing, fully loaded taking off into turbulent air. Scary.
- kashkhan 9y agothe plane structure is all carbon/CFRP. you can see in the earlier pictures in the hangar before. http://www.stratolaunch.com/gallery.html http://www.stratolaunch.com/gallery.html the black is cfrp under the white paint. Scaled Composites has some secret CFRP processes of construction which non Americans are not allowed to know about under ITAR regulations, so i cannot tell you haha.
- rbanffy 9y ago> Scaled Composites has some secret CFRP processes of construction which non Americans are not allowed to know about under ITAR regulations Everybody knows that. We just don't want you to know we know ;-)
- SkyMarshal 9y ago
- bogomipz 9y agoDoes anyone have any insight into how the dual flight decks are utilized?
- jeffbarr 9y agoThere's only one flight deck and it in the right-hand fuselage. I was at a recent friends and family day at Scaled Composites and was able to see and touch this amazing plane.
- PhasmaFelis 9y agoBoth fuselages seem to have identical windows. Is that just so they can use the same tooling for both, or is there something else in the left fuselage? Passenger/observer seating, maybe?
- CydeWeys 9y agoThe fuselages are used 747s that were repurposed. They have identical windows because of the design of a typical 747, not anything purpose-specific to this mission.
- bogomipz 9y agoI see, so it's just uniformity of production. How fortunate that you are to be able to tour this! Cheers.
- CydeWeys 9y agoIt's literally just two cannibalized used 747s attached together, with a minimum number of necessary modifications made (which doesn't include changing the cockpits or forward sections of fuselage).
- Tomminn 9y agoThis is a very good idea. In rocketry, air is your enemy. At the speeds rockets move it causes enormous heat/mechanical stress on the rocket, drag energy losses, and it messes with the flow of matter out the back of the engine that provides your thrust. With a jet engine, air is your friend, because it is the matter you spit out the back of the engine. And at the much smaller speeds of an airplane, mechanical and thermal stresses are much smaller.
- innergame 9y agoI feel overcome by the Dianne Kruger effect, to an extent I don't remember feeling any time recently. I'm becoming more and more interested in news about rocketry (due to SpaceX of course) but I'm still a full on space-pleb. I see something like this and my intuition screams "Woah! Of course! Why don't other rocket companies do this? What's wrong with them?!" But the rational part of my brain kicks in and slaps me down for being so arrogant. It feels humbling to be reminded how stupid one can be.
- dontreact 9y agoDo you mean Dunning-Kruger effect?
- sidegrid 9y agoDianne Kruger......?????
- innergame 9y agoHaha! *Dunning–Kruger :P
- MBCook 9y agoThe Dunning-Kruger effect: The idea that people of low skill or knowledge about something don't know how much they don't know and thus think they're much better at it then they actually are. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dunning–Kruger_effect https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dunning–Kruger_effect
- oculusthrift 9y agowas dianne his wife?
- sidegrid 9y agoThank you for getting it.
- 9y ago
- tomkat0789 9y agoHas anybody tried launching a rocket from an airship/dirigible?
- langtieshan 9y agoOK
- Animats 9y agoScaled Composites built it. It should work. Although Rutan has retired, the company goes on. It's interesting that they didn't connect the tails, like the old Lockheed P-38, but there's probably some good reason for that. Launching a Pegasus XL has to be just a demo. That's normally launched by dropping it from an old Lockheed L-1011; it doesn't need this monster. They need something bigger to launch. There was a contract with Pegasus for a "Pegasus II", but that didn't work out. The "Dream Chaser" mini-shuttle is a possibility, if that ever gets built. The 747 engines are probably used. There are lots of retired 747s around, many at the Mojave boneyard. Great aircraft, but a fuel hog by current standards.
- schiffern 9y ago>The 747 engines are probably used. There are lots of retired 747s around, many at the Mojave boneyard. Great aircraft, but a fuel hog by current standards. Correct. They just flew in two used 747s and cannibalized them for parts. http://www.seattletimes.com/business/boeing-aerospace/paul-allens-giant-plane-takes-shape-in-the-desert-but-its-market-is-unclear/ http://www.seattletimes.com/business/boeing-aerospace/paul-a... >The crew’s flight deck is literally that of a 747. >Allen bought two used jumbo jets formerly flown by United Airlines and cannibalized them for parts that account for about half the empty weight of the Roc. >So although the shell of the cockpit and all the rest of the plane’s body is new — hand-built by Scaled Composites from carbon fiber composites — various key pieces and systems, including avionics, hydraulics and fuel subsystems, are salvaged 747 parts. BAE Systems was subcontracted to disassemble the 747 and install its systems on the Roc. >The cockpit seats look old and used because they are. The seats as well as the controls the crew will manipulate and the windows they’ll look out of all came from the 747s. >So did the plane’s six Pratt & Whitney engines, which are already refurbished, cleaned, wrapped and set aside in a corner, ready to hang on the airframe when it’s finished.
- CydeWeys 9y agoThat's absolutely how I would've done it. Way cheaper to make a monster hybrid of two used 747s than to try to make a one-off custom airplane from scratch. Sure, it won't be as efficient at its job as if it were purpose-built, but you'd never get all of that R&D money back.
- nether 9y agoReally interesting thing is the flat walls on the fuselages. They were done that way for ease of construction, and are not pressurized containers therefore don't suffer from stress singularities at the corners.
- vadym909 9y agoAny more billionaires feeling left out of the space race?
- mabbo 9y agoShould we worry that every billionaire seems highly intent on building ways to get the heck off the planet? ... Do they know something we don't?
- vuln 9y agoSpace penthouses.
- ORioN63 9y agoNo. We already know that the planet will undergo drastic changes in the next 100 years.
- vadym909 9y agoExcept Musk and Branson who've been doing this before it was the cool new thing- it feels the newcomers are just doing it for legacy. Having hospitals and colleges named after you isn't special enough anymore. Space is the new frontier for ego battles.
- synicalx 9y agoI can just imagine him up there in the plane, listening to Huey Lewis and the News.
- PhantomGremlin 9y agoI'm confused by this. I don't know if Paul Allen is a Huey Lewis fan. What I do know is that he's a big Jimi Hendrix fan. Allen basically built a museum to (mostly) Hendrix. It's since been re-purposed somewhat, and Wikipedia doesn't have much of the history. But originally the museum was mostly Hendrix. Here are links to a few early articles that make it clearer: http://www.independent.co.uk/travel/americas/in-search-of-jimi-hendrix-in-seattle-9131310.html http://www.independent.co.uk/travel/americas/in-search-of-ji... http://www.voodoohendrix.com/jimi-hendrix-museum/ http://www.voodoohendrix.com/jimi-hendrix-museum/
- yakshaving_jgt 9y agoIt's a reference to American Psycho. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vzN3qO-qc8U https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vzN3qO-qc8U https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cISYzA36-ZY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cISYzA36-ZY
- sargun 9y agoThis might be a dumb question, but it looks like there are two cockpits on this plane. I imagine the plane is drive by wire, so it doesn't matter where you are on the plane. Why do they have two? Extending my question further, why does this plane have a cockpit at all? Isn't this something you could remotely pilot, especially to mitigate the potential risk of being at 30k feet with thousands of kilos of RP-1 or similar?
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoI'm guessing they made it out of two of an existing plane design and that is just what you got. Or for balance, you wouldn't want them to differ much.
- CydeWeys 9y agoThey just bought two used 747s and stuck them together. Way more work to remove the cockpits than just leave them intact on their individual airframes. Hell, for all we know, this could be remotely piloted.
- InclinedPlane 9y agoThis is pretty cool but to be honest I don't expect it to be very advantageous. The big advantage of airlaunch is the Isp improvement from launching at altitude. Since the rocket equation is exponential with respect to the ratio of delta V and Isp improving Isp even a little has big effects, and reducing delta V even a little does too. But the big advantage of ordinary vertical launch rockets is that it's fairly straightforward to just make them bigger. The Saturn V was able to launch Skylab with a 6.6 meter diameter. And rockets could easily be scaled up to launch even larger diameter payloads. That's pretty difficult with something like Stratolaunch. Even with basically the largest aircraft ever made it still has a pretty small payload mass and fairing size. One other cool thing about stratolaunch is that it has the ability to launch out of a lot more locations since it doesn't depend on a launch pad and tower. However, I suspect that's not going to be of huge importance. I'd like to see what they can do with this technology but I suspect it'll be underwhelming.
- gambiting 9y ago385-foot wingspan 1.3 million pounds 65 feet 2,000 nautical mile I'm sorry, I know it has been mentioned a billion times already, but can someone make a browser plugin that converts everything on a website to normal SI units? As a non-american I have no idea how big this aircaft is or how much it can lift - sure I can look up conversions(I have) but it would be awesome if there was an automatic website conversion option.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoI second the request. I had an unit conversion extension once, but it would slow the whole browser down to a crawl when it activated on a large and complex page, like Facebook or GMail. So I'm looking for something smarter / more efficient.
- aj7 9y agoJust type the quantity and units into google.
- gambiting 9y agoAs I said in my comment - I have. I just said it would be awesome if there was some automatic conversion option.
- zild3d 9y agoAgree, but just to throw it out there - nautical miles are actually an SI derived unit. It was originally defined as a minute (1/60 of a degree) of latitude, which doesn't convert exactly to km since it is not a constant measure. Although now it has been defined as the mean value. I'd be surprised if a unit-converter plugin didn't exist already, but it should definitely preserve the original measures since the units do have contextual significance. e.g. nautical miles in navigation edit: here's one https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/autoconvert-auto-currency/pbghjbbdfkjffaalmcfgelakmeckapnd https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/autoconvert-auto-c...
- sigrlami9 9y agoThe general idea like USSR's An-225 Buran tandem within MAKS program https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MAKS_(spacecraft) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MAKS_(spacecraft) and it's 25 years old.
- OperationHealth 9y agoThis is being blown out of proportion. Vulcan's Stratolauncher is not the future of launch; if this thing ever manages to leave the ground (with a payload), I doubt it will host more than five-to-seven launches throughout its lifetime, and that's a generous estimate. This vehicle is going to be incredibly expensive, compared to both other air launch options and dedicated smallsat options. Although this can change, the current plan is for Stratolaunch to use OATK's Pegasus-XL payload, which provides an indicator for cost. Pegasus-XL launches are incredibly expensive ($337.3K per kg). Now, this is due to a variety of reasons (the L-1011's incredibly high maintenance costs, OATK's expensive labor structure, low launch cadence). Vulcan will bear similar costs--the inefficient OATK overhead tied to Pegasus-XL, Stratolauncher is a one-of-a-kind aircraft and increasing maintenance costs (despite using 747 engines). Due to significant development delays, the company has yet to develop or execute a customer strategy. Depending on how much more PA pumps into it, the company will not be price competitive in the market. For comparison, other small launchers charge ~$25K/kg-$41K/kg (e.g., Rocket Lab, Virgin, Arianespace), and most of these will be able to launch US payloads. Virgin's comparable airlauncher delivers slightly less mass (15 kg less), but is priced at ~$40K/kg. Virgin is already a leg up as it has engaged commercial, civil govt., and mil-govt. customers. Lastly, it's worth noting that this vehicle still has significant work to be done--look at the wings in the picture.
- victork2 9y agoHi there, you seem to know a lot, any chance we could talk about this topic, would love to hear more of your thoughts on the topic? I don't see an address to contact you. Thanks!
- jlebrech 9y agoWhy not the other way round? Have a plane take off with a small load and have rockets connect with it at it's highest altitude and push it into orbit. expended stages could reconnect with another plane of the same model on the way down.
- kadavero 9y agoI wonder if they considered a half-loop launch, toss bombing style. That way they could dump the wing, perhaps at a price of higher strength requirements.
- wakeupworld 9y agoNice to read how people are so out of touch when they reach to certain threshold.. lol where mark suckerberg rackets ?