17 ms·
The right solution to this problem is, when traveling, always answer "no" to "may I search your laptop?" It sucks, and it many mean a lot of hassle ranging fro
by stickfigure 9y ago
The right solution to this problem is, when traveling, always answer "no" to "may I search your laptop?"
It sucks, and it many mean a lot of hassle ranging from confiscated equipment to being held at the border to being refused entry, but this is just one of the new risks of travel. Border security only gets away with this because people say yes.
Companies need to make clear to their employees (and the public) that sharing passwords is a terminable policy violation. You should be able to say, honestly and credibly, "I won't unlock my laptop because I don't want to get fired."
- rosser 9y agoDo you honestly think customs agents care whether you'll get fired or not? US immigrations will permanently sever families that have been together for years or even decades with utter disregard for the emotional trauma they're inflicting. Your job matters exactly fuck-all to a CPB agent.
- noja 9y agoThat border agent is a real person, who is "only doing their job". So are you. It works both ways. If enough people say no, then after a hellish but hopefully short adjustment period, the policy will change.
- DanBC 9y ago> the policy will change. The policy might change to include cells at the borders where people are detained until they hand over login details or voluntarily decide not to enter.
- komali2 9y agoShould the slope become that slippery we'll have a much better reason to stand outside a legislator's office with pointy sticks than "I was mildly inconvenienced by the TSA."
- Jare 9y agoIf what is already happening across the country is not a good enough reason already, I doubt anything will be.
- chronic940 9y agoYep. Quite simply, the 0.1% of the US population here on HN does not care about privacy nor protesting nor writing to their local or state government. HN needs to stop living in a bubble. Only 1/3 of the US even bothered voting in the Trump v Clinton presidential election. I'll let you think about that for a moment. Now think about border searches. Has your phone been searched? Neither has mine. I'll go back to my company catered lunch now.
- thesumofall 9y agoWhere did you get the 1/3 from? It's been 55% of eligble voters. Counting non-eligibles wouldn't really make sense in your argument Source: https://www.google.de/amp/s/amp.cnn.com/cnn/2016/11/11/politics/popular-vote-turnout-2016/index.html https://www.google.de/amp/s/amp.cnn.com/cnn/2016/11/11/polit...
- thaumasiotes 9y agoIf you really care about the issue, why abstain just because someone else doesn't want to count your vote?
- syshum 9y agoActually you should count all Adults not just "eligible" for a few reasons 1. No one once reaching the age of majority should have their voting rights taken, for any reason including criminality 2. The figures also do not include people of age who are ineligible to vote or have not registered. The "Have not registered" is a key part because many stated in the last 2 election cycles have been passing a number of laws to disenfranchises segments of the populations making it harder and harder to register 3. The concept of our nation is "Consent of the people", that is all people, not just those voting. the majority of PEOPLE reject the 2 candidates put forth buy the corrupted and unethical political parties then the government can not claim to have the consent of THE PEOPLE... Many many many Americans feel complete disenfranchised by the political systems that gives them 2 Choices that are equally terrible and corrupt. Forcing a defensive vote that is mainly against the person you do not want to win instead of voting for a qualified person you actually want to be in office. As a life long Libertarian, I have no interest in voting for either a Republican or Democrat
- rosser 9y agoThat job they're "just doing" is, as it's drilled into their minds, to act as a barrier against anything that even might be a threat in some form or fashion to their country. They have pretty broad authority toward that end. You (the notional you) aren't even from here. If you say no, you've identified yourself as a potential threat, and can just sit in a room by yourself for as long as it takes to put you on the next flight back to wherever you came from, at your expense. And you probably won't be allowed to return. If you're a citizen and say no, they might confiscate the device, and might make you wait around long enough to miss your connecting flight (and maybe even the next couple, if they're feeling particularly peevish), but that's about all they can do.
- rhizome 9y agoThat job they're "just doing" is, as it's drilled into their minds, to act as a barrier against anything that even might be a threat in some form or fashion to their country. They may get that drilled into their skulls, but I think it's more that they just don't want their boss to yell at them. No police officer arrests a DUI and says "but I'm just doing my job." It's only when the other person (the traveler in this case) has an entirely legitimate reason to resist them that "I'm just doing my job" comes out, with an implied threat that the authority they're appealing to (that they themselves don't have) will come down on everyone involved, and they don't want that. Also, they don't have any personal liability for anything that goes wrong in this process, except perhaps that the company they work for will lose the contract (unlikely here). Again, "boss will yell at me." These people are better thought of as clerks than cops. And yes, they can inconvenience you, but that's not the same thing as compliance.
- wyager 9y agoI assume you're referring to illegal immigration, in which case there is at least a legal (if possibly not moral) basis for screwing people over. The story with stealing citizens' personal information is entirely different; there is almost certainly no legitimate legal basis to fuck over US citizens for excercizing the basic rights explicitly protected by the 4th and 5th amendments, just because they happen to be at a border area.
- kasey_junk 9y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Border_search_exception https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Border_search_exception The Supreme Court has actually weighed in on this and granted it a legitimate legal basis.
- 0xTJ 9y agoBut what about non-Americans? As a Canadian, I can have a very valid reason to go to the States, and even refusing a search once could cause me issues any time I try to go to the US.
- Sir_Substance 9y agoYup. The correct solution is to stop traveling to the US. Stop sending your employees to the US as well. If the rest of the world starts insisting that US companies always come to them because of how US border agents act, that shit will bubble up to the lobbyists real fast.
- jjawssd 9y agoIt's just that easy.
- sqeaky 9y agoIf hurts people with money, something will change.
- Fiahil 9y agoCome and see us in Europe, it's nice here !
- brianwawok 9y agoNo thanks!
- dognotdog 9y agoNo, it's not. That's similar to saying just stay away from bullies, or leave if you don't like your job/school/whatever. It is easy if you view the issue in isolation, but for a lot of people it is more complicated, such as how will you see your loved ones / do your job / travel freely? In this case, the ones most dependent on being able to travel have little choice if they can't take on almost unlimited (potentially, but still) risk to their livelyhood.
- kasey_junk 9y agoAnd to the UK: https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2017/may/14/campaign-group-to-challenge-uk-over-surrender-of-passwords-at-border-control https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2017/may/14/campaign-gr...
- Youareweakhn 9y agoYou sound like a weak cunt with no spine
- ForrestN 9y agoIt completely depends if you are white or not. If you are white, and speak politely, the agent will care deeply about your concerns, including potential firing as an example. If you are not white, and especially if you appear black, Latino or Arab, then your comment will definitely hold true.
- skyrw 9y agoYou are absolutely the worst kind of person.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- JadeNB 9y ago> You are absolutely the worst kind of person. What? I'm not sure I believe the grandparent's post, and it would be nice if it were sourced or clarified as opinion rather than stated as fact (as briandear (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14406689 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14406689) and Banthum (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14407293 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14407293) urged), but your reaction seems grossly hostile and unconstructive.
- dang 9y agoWe've banned this account. No one is allowed to post like this here. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html All: upvoting such blatant violations of the site guidelines also causes accounts to lose voting privileges on HN.
- briandear 9y ago[citation needed]
- TallGuyShort 9y agoRecently delayed by the TSA to the point of missing my turn to board. Was subjected to additional searching. Upon finding nothing, I discovered the extra searching was what they do when you fail the hand swab test. I had not had the test administered. So they administered the test. I passed. They then searched my things again and I was questioned regarding the quantity of business cards I was carrying. Oh also I'm white.
- briandear 9y agoDoes customs anywhere else the world care more? Explain your refusal to allow a search to a Chinese, Korean or UK customs official.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- RodericDay 9y agoIf you, as an innocent person, don't refuse to have your belongings inspected, you participate in making belonging-inspection-refusal into a great heuristic for determining guilt. This is a form of "citizen duty".
- nihonde 9y agoI've witnessed US border agents mocking someone for hours in the waiting area before summarily sending him back to where he came in from.
- vijayr 9y agoCompanies need to make clear to their employees (and the public) that sharing passwords is a terminable policy violation So which is a better option? Losing a job (or) refused entry/detention/harassment after 24+ hours on the plane/getting treated like a criminal....? (not that criminals need to be treated badly) The right solution to this problem is saner laws and educating the public about privacy and related topics
- stickfigure 9y agoThe right solution to this problem is saner laws Considering the history of the civil rights movement in the US, we're not going to get saner laws without a little civil disobedience. It sucks to bear the brunt of this harassment, but saying "yes" only enables the system to harass everyone more efficiently.
- caseysoftware 9y agoI opted out for years and made fun of TSA agents during the pat down. It turns out you're not allowed to requests pat downs from specific agents. Who knew? ;) But now I don't even opt out. Instead I tell them that I can't raise my arms above my head. They direct me around the scanner (sometimes the metal detector too), swab my hands, and call it done. I often skip 10-15 people in the process. If they ask why, I tell them I have a medical condition and they're not allowed to ask further so I don't explain. Hopefully the bad guys never figure it out!
- fernandotakai 9y ago> always answer "no" to "may I search your laptop?" in my case, that would mean deportation due to not being american. i either get deported and lose all the traveling plans or i get searched.
- ptaipale 9y agoI think in this case the correct technical term is "denied entry". You haven't passed immigration to the country. Deportation is the expulsion of someone who's actually in the country, past the border, and resident or visiting.
- codeka 9y agoPotato/potahto, really. Good luck getting a visa next time if you've ever been "denied entry". Really, for non-Americans the best advice is just don't go in the first place. Second best advice is just comply with border security personnel. Any tricks like leaving the battery empty, bringing a burner, not bringing a laptop and getting a loaner when you get there etc, they do nothing but raise suspicions.
- fwn 9y ago> they do nothing but raise suspicions Oh god, no. Technical measures - of course - do work. So does erasing data from phones, laptops, hard drives, etc. Do not let the security theater scare you into obedience.
- patmcc 9y agoAgain, this is not valid advice for non-citizens. If you're a citizen, sure, feel free to go through with an empty or password-protected device. Maybe you'll be detained for a while, inconvenienced, given a stern talking to, etc. If you're not a citizen? You can be denied for literally anything the agent feels like. They feel you're suspicious because you claim (falsely or not) you don't have a facebook account? You're not coming in. Visa denied.
- Analemma_ 9y ago> Companies need to make clear to their employees (and the public) that sharing passwords is a terminable policy violation. You should be able to say, honestly and credibly, "I won't unlock my laptop because I don't want to get fired." The USG has shown that it is perfectly happy to kneecap entire domestic industries (aerospace, semiconductor) for the sake of "national security" via ITAR. You really think they give a shit about one person's job?
- elorant 9y agoThe solution to this problem is to not visit US.
- sandov 9y agoThen Europe is going to do the same, and the solution will be to not visit Europe, and so. Eventually we won't be able to leave our country without giving up our privacy. The real solution is that people from the country protest when such an abusive policy is introduced.
- rurban 9y agoOnly the UK is doing the same, in France civil rights still do exist. No worries. Even if they are at war right now, and abolished civil rights for a few years.
- tyfon 9y agoThis is the solution my company chose for a milestone trip we will undertake in half a year. The plan was to go to NYC, now the plan is either Paris or Tokyo instead for the 70+ employees.
- misingnoglic 9y agoIll tell the TSA no if you buy me a new laptop/phone when it happens.
- BrainInAJar 9y agogood luck with that.
- brianwawok 9y agoHe can tell them whatever he wants. Doesn't mean they will care.
- misingnoglic 9y agoIll tell the TSA no if you buy me a new laptop/phone when it happens.
- spydum 9y agoI can tell you most of the corporate policy says comply with all law enforcement requests when asked while traveling and report it to corporate security/legal.
- underwater 9y agoMany US workers are not citizens. Your solution would mean losing both their job and home if they were stopped on their way back into the US. A better solution is to not allow people to travel with anything that would be catastrophic if lost. My former employer would give employees loaner devices for travel to certain countries.
- smileysteve 9y agoI think part of the point is that employers also can't lose all employees, so they are encouraged to fight back with their economic blight, in part by lobbying.
- Havoc 9y ago>always answer "no" to "may I search your laptop?" Good luck with that when faced with a border nazi & zero rights. I just leave my personal laptop behind when travelling to countries with dubious personal freedom policies...like the US.
- matthewaveryusa 9y agoI think this is bad advice. Protect your sensitive data with plausible deniability, that's what the pros do. The travel feature is just that, as well as truecrypt decoy partitions. Showing you have nothing to hide is a lot more pragmatic and versatile than the cryptonerd fantasy alternative https://xkcd.com/538/ https://xkcd.com/538/ .
- beefsack 9y agoJust saying "no" will work in very few countries.
- BrainInAJar 9y agoIt's always Americans who can, at worst, get their laptops and phones seized that have this stupid ill-informed opinion. If you enter the United States as a non-citizen and don't submit you will be denied entry for 5 years or life, still have your devices seized, and any visas or permanent residency can be cancelled. Possibly be jailed.
- groby_b 9y agoHey, look, a citizen (or non-USian) commenting on immigration matters. Without any clue what this means for non-citizens who live in the US. If you're e.g. an H1B visa holder your friendly ICE officer might decide "no" is reason enough to eject you out of the country. Just one of the new risks of travel. (Well, not new that they can send you back, but a new reason for the little tinpot dictators who revel in their power)
- ssambros 9y ago> Companies need to make clear to their employees (and the public) that sharing passwords is a terminable policy violation. Companies cannot tell their employees to not comply with lawful request of a federal officer, and some companies specifically underline that in a company policy.
- imartin2k 9y agoHave you done this in practice? Have you been asked and answered "no"? If not, it is probably way to easy to make such a statement.
- alpb 9y agoMost large companies I worked for ask me to unlock my corporate laptop shall CPB agents ask me to do so (and tell the corporate security afterwards for obvious reasons). I don't think an American company will fire you for complying with the law enforcement.