26 ms·
Guaranteed Minimum What?
- AndrewKemendo 10y agoThe early adopters will be the largest companies with the most to gain from improvements in efficiency. This pattern is actually the one I'm worried about the most. New tech is giving outsize advantage to the major players across almost every industry, who can afford to invest in creating internal teams for these big new technologies. I see this in every industry I encounter. The middle class worker lost out over the last few decades. Now the middle tier company is going to get killed cause they can't change fast enough.
- habitue 10y agoThere is a counterbalancing force, which is hard to see going away, which is that larger companies have a harder time seeing which way the wind is blowing and getting ahead of the curve. They make decisions slowly, and tend to be wary about investing in risky things that might pull resources away from their existing profit centers. They have something to defend, so they're anchored to past decisions in a way smaller nimbler companies aren't.
- AndrewKemendo 10y agoMy critical contention is that those counterbalancing forces are going away because Large companies have the following vectors: 1. Invest in small companies broadly enough so they get key insight so they can acquire before they become a threat. See GV, Intel Ventures etc... 2. Overwhelm small companies through brute force if they can't acquire. See: Facebook vs Snap 3. Invest in internal moonshots that startups can't compete with. See: Google X In previous times, big monoliths didn't have the foresight to do this or weren't agile enough to restructure internally. I think the way AFGAM operates and has proven they can pivot at scale, using their market dominance to change that whole equation.
- marcosdumay 10y agoCompanies have been doing those 3 forever. It works most of the time, it fails once in a while. All established companies sooner or later face the choice between destroying a huge revenue stream to get a chance on the new thing, or keep the current revenue and limit its lifetime. Nearly all of them choose the second, and the ones that choose the first do not always make it either.
- mabbo 10y ago> New tech is giving outsize advantage to the major players across almost every industry, who can afford to invest in creating internal teams for these big new technologies. Oohh, this very much. Inside Amazon warehouses, there are tens of thousands of employees called 'Pickers'. They walk around with these handscanners with 300x300 pixel screens that tell them where to go and what item to get next. For two years, my job was to make the UX of that application a little bit faster. Not the order to pick the items (another team) not the decision of which shipments should be processed next (also different team) or which items should be picked by which picker (you guessed it- a different team). Just the UX for the 0.9MP of screen space in front of the user. Labour costs for that job are in the hundreds of millions per year, so any team that made a 1% improvement to overall efficiency would be covering its own costs a many times over. And we did. Amazon can afford to get those small 1% gains multiple times per year, but for smaller companies the gains wouldn't pay for the costs. If they want to beat Amazon, they'll need to find a very big win that Amazon didn't see first. The only company I can think of that did that was Kiva Robotics- wait, it's called Amazon Robotics now.
- AndrewKemendo 10y agoThis is exactly one of the processes I see happening, and thanks for the real world example.
- dexterdog 10y agoThat's actually a .09MP screen. Makes it sound as pathetic as it is.
- mabbo 10y agoOh God you're right. 300x300 pixel screen, IE 5.5, tiny tiny processor, 128MB of ram (64MB on the old ones). The only advantage that thing had was that if you dropped it from a fourth story window, the device would be fine. I was told we had tested this to be sure.
- nfriedly 10y agoI think the only realistic way for a small player to beat Amazon at selling physical goods is to charge more and convince customers that it's worth it.
- maverick_iceman 10y agoBig companies get blindsided by new tech all the time. Think IBM vs Microsoft.
- AndrewKemendo 10y agoMore accurate to say "Big companies have traditionally been blind sided by new tech..." I'm not aware of any major example of this since the introduction of the iPhone.
- adamsea 10y ago...which was really not all that long ago. Give it time ;)
- WalterBright 10y agoThe demise of Kodak?
- izacus 10y agoiPhone was built by one of the richest corporations on Earth do not sure if even counts.
- AndrewKemendo 10y agoThis is exactly my point. It wasn't like some small time player came in and reinvented the market - a big player did it themselves.
- dredmorbius 10y agoLook at what's happening to the desktop/laptop industry. Print and broadcaast media. Telcos, especially wired. Politics. News. Propaganda.
- AndrewKemendo 10y agoI'm talking specifically about AFGAM: Apple owns consumer Facebook owns Social Google owns Search Amazon owns E-commerce Microsoft owns enterprise Nobody is coming even close to taking them out in their categories and they are collectively dominant in pretty much everything else except hard infrastructure - even then they are gaining ground. Snapchat could have had a close chance against FB before FB targeted them hard, so you can forget about that. But even then, google capital is an Investor and on top of that is getting $2BN in revenue from snapchat using google cloud! Name any potential serious startup competitor to any of these. Doesn't exist.
- RangerScience 10y agoThis feels topical: http://marshallbrain.com/manna1.htm http://marshallbrain.com/manna1.htm
- nemo1618 10y agoI've read this twice. The writing isn't spectacular, but it's fun to see a future like this fleshed out.
- cbanek 10y ago> Humans are agressively being eliminated from as many business models as possible. Well that's true, where they don't add value. What's the difference between the case of getting movie tickets and your waiter at a fancy restaurant? One of them is practically a useless annoyance, and the other one is part of the experience. Someone in a movie box isn't going to tell you about the movie, or have a conversation about it with you. They are there to take the most basic info (movie, time) and money, and give you a ticket. It's also always done thru a thick bit of glass that makes communication sometimes difficult if not painful. On the other hand, the fancy waiter will make recommendations. Will tell you about other things, and is generally part of the ambiance and experience of eating out. Honestly, do we really like interacting with the people with minimum wage jobs? Not really. Most people seem to prefer the automated checkout, ordering on their phone, etc. While sometimes the person doing the job can be interesting, or friendly, even if the person is amazing, generally these jobs are pretty repetitive, and could be done easier, faster, and cheaper with automation. Not only for the employer, but the customer. Most of these people also are not thrilled about their jobs and be lazy, or do a bad job (I can't blame them really, you get what you pay for). The only thing keeping employees around was that automation was more expensive (and more unreliable). Now it's the flip - labor is much more expensive and unreliable than automation. Now people in those jobs have to prove where they add value, if it's only to watch over the machines.
- e_d_e_v 10y agoWhen I worked in the movie box, that was not at all true. People would come in and ask about the movie. How long was it, whether it was any good, should they see another one instead? We gave them real answers. Just because you have a minimum wage job doesn't mean you're a bump on a log. If you've lost sight of the value of basic human interaction with anyone not baked into your caste, I pity you, even if you are in the majority. Also, 99% of movies today are crap, so there's not much to talk about.
- cracell 10y agoI would find this super annoying while waiting in line to buy tickets. If that's a service that makes sense to have theaters can always keep it. One staffed line for people that want to chit chat and automated kiosks for people like me who just want to buy a ticket.
- atemerev 10y agoGuaranteed minimum income is: sustainable, sufficient for basic life necessities, can be implemented for the current population levels. Choose two. It is as inevitable as CAP theorem.
- goldbeck 10y ago[citation needed]
- lamby 10y agoIf only economics was this simple!
- atemerev 10y agoSome numbers: Current US population: 324 million people, 250 million adults. Poverty line income: $22,000 for the family of four (it is hard to estimate individual poverty line income, but it's more than $22,000 / 4. Let's say $12,000, which is $1000 / month). Total cost of universal basic income of $1,000/month for the US: $3 trillion per year. Total US income tax revenue: $1.8 trillion for personal income tax, $0.4 trillion for corporate income tax.
- dllthomas 10y agoYou are making the case that it's currently impractical. That is very different from "as inevitable as [the] CAP theorem". For instance, if the cost of "basic life necessities" was somehow $5/yr, but incomes (and tax revenues) similar to today (... presumably people are spending an awful lot on luxury goods?), it could certainly be all three of those things. It may be the case that that is somehow impossible, but that's a case that you need to make in some way other than listing off what the current numbers happen to be.
- atemerev 10y agoYes, the luxuries like rent, education and healthcare. And yes, "somehow" is a word that appears very often in every discussion about UBI.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoThat is a pretty well presented argument for mass unemployment. But it suffers from all such arguments in that is extrapolates "today" into "tomorrow" without acknowledging that there are literally billions of variables at work. A simple example of the challenges this sort of reasoning present; assume you're a being that perceives time very slowly, perhaps your lifetime is a mere 100 milliseconds rather than 100 years. But your perception is fairly good and you can observe and measure things several yards away in all direction. And you're living in seawater near the beach. Through out your entire life, and for several generations, the amount of seawater above your head has been growing and growing. You believe that eventually there will be sea water "as far as you can observe" above your head. As an outside observer with a different time scale and perception, we "see" that this being is part of an ocean wave that once the mass of water above the center of gravity moves ahead of it because of water below being slowed by the the beach, the wave will 'crash' and fall into foam. Now if we could explain this to the creature in the wave, or if the creatures there had some sort of stored history, they might know that in the past there have been waves and the waves have crashed and that the seawater never extended so far into the sky. And there might be debates because some waves reached a height that was higher than any other wave in recorded history and so maybe this time, this time the wave would grow forever. Except from our time spanning view we realize that all of those fears and understandings arise from the the short lifetimes of the creatures versus the longer time of a wave cycle, and so few creatures will ever encounter another who has experienced "the crash". These unemployment doomsday articles suffer from a similar myopia. Yes, technology does advance, and yes, it changes how people are employed and what it takes to be employed. Technology shifts however have not resulted in a 'net loss' of employment opportunities when looked at in the full view, ever. So rather than focus on the 'loss of jobs' let us focus on "transition" support. I point out to people all of the time that we have tremendous gaps between supply and demand in what have historically been called "the trades." The reality of that was brought home to me when I started a bathroom remodeling project in Las Vegas. For that project I need a plumber, an electrician, and a mason. Three classic 'trades'. I cannot find three people that I can schedule who are licensed contractors, any sooner than 6 months from now. They are all booked up, and as a result leaving money on the table from unfilled demand. What is more, Las Vegas has very affordable housing. It was hit hard by the mortgage crisis and house prices have still not recovered in large parts of the city. So it isn't like a plumber can't afford to live in the city. I really think we need to stop stressing out that the number of retail cashier jobs are going away and start figuring out why people aren't able to train for the jobs that are available and going unfilled.
- bluedino 10y ago>> I noticed iPads on the tables They're tablets, from Ziosk. iPad is the Kleenex of this generation. I rather like those, nothing like paying (and leaving) when I want instead of trying to track down the waiter for 20 minutes
- dsacco 10y agoYeah, those are the best of both worlds when you're not dining at an upscale place. Don't have to use cash, don't have to wait for them to complete two round trips just to leave. I never understand why waiters don't give me a chance to hand them the card immediately when they drop the check. I don't need to sit with it for 10 minutes, especially after it took 10 minutes to flag you down for it. Years ago I was a waiter, so I don't really sympathize with an argument that they're too busy. The whole system could be revised.
- settsu 10y agoThey drop the check out of courtesy. On occasion—if I've been in a hurry, for example—I've gotten my card out once done eating and had it ready to hand to the server when they bring the check.
- dexterdog 10y agoIf you want to review the check you're going to have to wait for a round trip. If not, just hand the card when the check comes or better yet, give them the card when you ask for the check.
- dsacco 10y agoIn general I don't review the check until it's time to sign it. I've been told that's a bad habit but...well, if anything jumps out at me when I'm signing, I mention it then. And I think you might be surprised how many waiters seem to drop the check and simply leave. I'm not talking about restaurants where you expect excellent service. I'm talking about restaurants where you can't take it as a given that they're going to be attentive to something you say when they put the check down.
- triangleman 10y agoI found this debate to be helpful in my understanding of the UBI: http://www.intelligencesquaredus.org/debates/universal-basic-income-safety-net-future http://www.intelligencesquaredus.org/debates/universal-basic...
- dexterdog 10y agoI listened to this debate on my podcast subscription. The TL;DR is the audience poll shifted massively toward UBI being a bad idea by the end of the debate.
- oftenwrong 10y agoThis is one of my favourite blogs. The author is able to extract thought-provoking stories and insights from very unlikely places. The heavy use of photos is no doubt an important part of the formula. Most of the photo essays fall outside of HN's typical interests, though. I linked to some of my favourite entries here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13825177 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13825177
- chris_va 10y agoI realize that UBI is a very popular position on HN, so I am hoping someone here has given this more thought and can comment. My problem with UBI is that all tests to date look great, but have only been done on a micro level. The fundamental issue I would like addressed is the macro scale inflation you would expect when redistributing trillions of dollars without commensurate economic value being created directly. Money is a complicated subject, but essentially it represents a transfer of a future scarce resource. For commodities, the cost is essentially the sum of labor to generate it (either to mine the raw resources, build the factory, etc). If no economic resource is being added to the economy, then you are just devaluing money. That is usually very regressive, and in this case could be made worse by people slightly reducing their economic labor because of the extra income stream. I could see this leading to a bad cycle, where any economic gains due to increasing UBI are later undermined. Anyway, it would be nice if it worked, but I've seen no evidence that it will in a large system. Comments appreciated.
- FussyZeus 10y ago> My problem with UBI is that all tests to date look great, but have only been done on a micro level. The fundamental issue I would like addressed is the macro scale inflation you would expect when redistributing trillions of dollars without commensurate economic value being created directly. The thing is though, most people who would benefit from UBI are not currently generating enough economic value to live, or barely so, and many are probably not capable of doing so for any number of reasons. We can do this because: > Money is a complicated subject, but essentially it represents a transfer of a future scarce resource. For commodities, the cost is essentially the sum of labor to generate it (either to mine the raw resources, build the factory, etc). ...the costs of all of these things are plummeting due previously to outsourcing, and now to automation. As manufacturing becomes more and more automated and the costs of these items continues to drop, you start seeing volume sales/renewing subscriptions being the only possible way to make money on some products. > If no economic resource is being added to the economy, then you are just devaluing money. That is usually very regressive, and in this case could be made worse by people slightly reducing their economic labor because of the extra income stream. I could see this leading to a bad cycle, where any economic gains due to increasing UBI are later undermined. This is my one beef with UBI and the one thing that does make me worry about it, but the way I see it is that whatever effect this does have the overall value of the currency cannot possibly approach the effects that the results of borrowing and printing currency to fund things like the outrageous defense budget (of the US) do, the economic benefits of which are muddy at best. For me this is both an issue of economics -and- of people. To me, in a country as rich as mine it's embarrassing that we still have such vast areas of the country that look more like the slums of Brazil than the cities they're usually parked next to. It's also the simple fact that if you continue to displace more and more people, as we've done, who are too old/not smart enough to change careers, eventually something is going to give. Frankly I pitch UBI as how we avoid the second Civil War, where instead of North vs South, we have Urban vs Rural when the much larger (and better armed) population gets tired of the cities and their nonchalant attitude towards their plight. These are legit questions and I hope we get better answers than mine (I'm no economist), but speaking as someone on the higher end of the income brackets who would never see a dime from UBI, I really don't think continuing to pretend that the rich can keep on getting richer and the poor poorer is a good plan. When it comes right down to it, there are more of the poor than the rich, and the cash won't save you when they break down your door with pitchforks.
- TACIXAT 10y agoI always feel we will just scale larger and larger. We automate farming and move onto industry. We automate industry and move onto service. Now we are automating service and we will move onto something else, perhaps tech. We are a long ways off from programs programming themselves. NLP and machine learning are still in their infancy. Program analysis and automated bug patching is still young tech. There is still a lot of work to be done and I am confident we will find ways to provide value to each other.
- xg15 10y ago> My best guess is that we’re not going to resolve these challenges in any intentional comprehensive logical manner. At least not at first. Instead circumstances are going to overwhelm us until enough of the population is miserable enough to demand real change. That’s been the historical model and it tends to be messy. Big fun. The historical precidents he, I believe, refers to were less messy and more bloody.
- sparkling 10y agoFrom Henry Hazlitts 1946 classic "Economics in One Lesson": You cannot make a man worth a given amount by making it illegal for anyone to offer him anything less. You merely deprive him of the right to earn the amount that his abilities and situation would permit him to earn, while you deprive the community even of the moderate services that he is capable of rendering. In brief, for a low wage you substitute unemployment. You do harm all around, with no comparable compensation.
- frgtpsswrdlame 10y agoYou are economically misinformed. You should read "Economism" by James Kwak.
- zimzam 10y agoEconomics has been evolving from a field dominated by navel-gazing theorists to being more behavioral and research-based. Try letting go of the 70 year old theories and read some modern research.
- marcosdumay 10y agoCompetitive forces are a thing. If your competitors can hire cheap people for working there, you will never be able to justify hiring more expensively. But if they can not hire that cheaply, you will be able to spend more too.
- fsaneq2 10y agoYou will also never be able to justify hiring more expensively if you can instead use a cheap/free machine, which is of course where we're heading, since people refuse to acknowledge the truth in OP's quote.
- antisthenes 10y agoAre you citing it as an example of a theory that's been proven wrong or what? It's hard to tell with many HNs saying incorrect things about economics and then realizing they were serious.
- 10y ago
- SirensOfTitan 10y agoI really don't understand why ideas like the Negative Income Tax aren't being considered before Universal Basic Income. In that scenario, the government just sets an income floor and pays the difference (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Negative_income_tax https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Negative_income_tax). UBI makes little sense whenever someone making 500K a year still gets it unconditionally. The marginal utility of that is nil, but its tax implications are massive (how do you even fund something like that in today's economy).
- kmicklas 10y agoThe argument for UBI over NIT, as I understand it, is that if rich people but UBI too they'll be less likely to attempt to defund it. I don't find this especially convincing, since from a purely rational point of view decreasing UBI increases net income for the rich. But maybe there are complex psychological/political factors at play.
- bryanlarsen 10y agoNegative income tax is just Friedman's name for UBI. They're functionally identical.
- SirensOfTitan 10y agoUBI (at least in all the circles I've seen) refers to basic income wherein the government gives an unconditional sum of money to citizens. Negative income tax is not unconditional.
- Kevin_S 10y agoAs I've seen, all real discussion of UBI is essentially a negative income tax. UBI is just the term that stuck.
- learc83 10y agoEvery serious UBI proposal includes an progressive income tax increase. Everyone gets the UBI, but the more money you make, the more you're paying in additional taxes to support the UBI. At some threshold you're paying as much in additional taxes as your making in UBI payments. Past another threshold and you're paying more in additional taxes than you're taking in.
- redleggedfrog 10y agoI hate to say this, and this is in no way a troll, but I believe the solution for this will eventually be to kill the poor. Not directly, at least I don't think, but through lack of health care, lack of shelter, lack of education, poor diet, use in waging war, incarceration, and probably once they get desperate and try and get theirs, being labelled terrorists. People who have money, and therefore power, in the United States are not going to give it up so someone down the economic scale can have a modicum of comfort and dignity and purpose. They will, carefully and covertly, and maybe even inadvertently, remove them.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Normal_gaussian 10y ago>> inadvertently, remove them I think this is the 'natural' progression and it is well understood by the key members of the major social improvement movements. The intent of these movements is to change this, to improve the human condition.
- marcosdumay 10y agoThat was a big part of the deal that "solved" the Industrial Revolution. The other big part was training the ones that managed to survive.
- mnm2 10y agoThe interesting part is that humans go through different phases (decades/centuries), where different skills are required: Native Indians in Middle America weren't strong enough to work on the plantations, so Africans were brought in. Today there are probably more Africans living in the Carrebian, since they once made the money to attract a female, make it a wife (marry here, very important for women) and then have a family (kids), which some/most Native Americans maybe didn't achive, since no job/money (and thus no true love ;)
- BeetleB 10y ago>I hate to say this, and this is in no way a troll, but I believe the solution for this will eventually be to kill the poor. Only works if they die before reproducing...
- yeslibertarian 10y agoyeah of course, I'm all for a guaranteed minimum income. I guess you are going to do a kickstarter right? I hope you are not proposing to forcefully steal my money through taxes.
- Eerie 10y agoI'd like to see you being forced not to use anything that was payed for by taxes, since you hate them so much. Like water, electricity and roads.
- jawns 10y agoOne thing that might cushion the displacement of workers by automation is if the workers themselves had an ownership interest in the automation technology. Yes, they would lose their jobs, but having an ownership interest would allow them to generate income. Maybe instead of UBI, we should consider a scheme where we grant an ownership interest in productive property. One naive way to implement that is to just grant shares in an index fund that tracks the robotics/automation sector, such as the ROBO Global Index (http://www.roboglobal.com http://www.roboglobal.com). Obviously, that's not the best way to do it, because if I've just been laid off and have to pay my mortgage, I'm going to turn all my shares into cash. But there might be some more sophisticated way to grant ownership of productive property that would both generate income and also give influence to the very workers who are most affected by the technology's success.
- muninn_ 10y agoSo this is a naive, honest question, but why not just index funds?
- mark_edward 10y agomost people don't have enough wealth for investment income to matter much, and they probably will never have it. the average american has a negative net worth.
- orangecat 10y agoDisturbingly low, but not negative: https://www.fool.com/investing/general/2015/05/17/americans-average-net-worth-by-age-how-do-you-comp.aspx https://www.fool.com/investing/general/2015/05/17/americans-...
- aeorgnoieang 10y ago> Maybe instead of UBI, we should consider a scheme where we grant an ownership interest in productive property. A sovereign wealth fund that automatically distributes 'shares' to its citizens, prohibits them from selling their shares, and distributes a dividend regularly? Seems pretty functionally equivalent to a UBI.
- maverick_iceman 10y agoAh, the tired old argument of machines will take our jobs away. This has been wrong before and will be wrong again. 70% of US workforce was engaged in agriculture in one point, now it's 1.5%. There was no bloody revolution. Also some argue this time is different because we're now automating jobs which require thinking. They conveniently forget that many jobs were automated before. E.g. in WWII an army of women used to calculate artillery ranges, now it's all handled by computers. New jobs will be found just like before.
- massysett 10y agoI have no idea why this is getting upvoted. A blog post that simply observes a bunch of self-serve kiosk machines, has a bait title, and is used on HN for an uninformative rehash of a UBI discussion that has taken place here over and over. I was hoping at least for a piece that made an argument or said something informative, not for some photos of a movie theater lobby and a restaurant.
- aeorgnoieang 10y agoThe 'argument', and the admittedly more informative content, is distributed over many posts on that blog (which I like and follow). This was a relatively sparse post compared to others from the same blog and is, in my opinion, mostly a 'look, more examples' kind of thing for the blog's regular audience. In this case, literally 'look, more examples of low-status work being squeezed out of the world'.
- rhino369 10y agoIt would be funny to read this bloggers response to Lotus 123 in 1984.
- notahacker 10y agoAnd, as I've pointed out in various other threads, kiosks used in the food industry is more or less the worst possible example of automation making people redundant. I mean, the first example is basically a digital version of leaving a menu with tickboxes and asking people to have change ready so it can be picked up by the food deliverers as they pass your table, which has been a possible way of cutting staff - in the few restaurants that don't think waiters encourage more purchases per customer - since mass literacy. Robotic barista? We've had coffee vending machines since the 1940s (the first vending machine was proposed in 215 b.c). And whilst the arm adds novelty value, it's still less likely to be cute or good at upselling muffins as minimum wage earners. I wish UBI discussions on here generally revolved around actual predictions and the awkward mathematics of who's paying for it when, but I understand that it's easier to sell dubious ideas with pictures of robots than falsifiable claims
- lux 10y ago> My best guess is that we’re not going to resolve these challenges in any intentional comprehensive logical manner. At least not at first. Instead circumstances are going to overwhelm us until enough of the population is miserable enough to demand real change. That’s been the historical model and it tends to be messy. This is why I think we need to accelerate the pace of automation as much as possible. That's the only way of creating enough governmental pressure fast enough to reduce the suffering time of the first waves hit by automation. Counter-intuitive, but the faster we get there the less suffering in the transition and the faster society wakes up to the fact that we have to take care of our own. The right to subsistence has been conveniently tied to the ability to work because that's easy to understand, but it's always been an artificial link.
- Kenji 10y agoWe already have guaranteed minimum income. Look at the people employed by the state. Doing mundane tasks, day by day, that could be automated cheaply and effortlessly. Literally sorting and storing documents, something the computer is proficient at. It is invented and completely senseless and stupid work. Depending on the country, we are talking about 20-50% of the population being state employees right now, in the first world. And the trend is that it's increasing, fast. There's your UBI, and as a bonus point, it keeps people off the streets and they think they are doing something.
- vivekd 10y agoPeople have it tough. To compound to this the cost of things like food, housing and energy are sky rocketing, at least the have been in Toronto where I live. I don't know if UBI is the answer, or even if the problems are tied to mechanization. But certainly I think we hit the nail on the head when we realize that things are glib and something needs to be done. If not UBI, than something big to ensure that everyone can share in the wealth our society produces and that people are not scrounging, fighting and drowning in debt just to barely get by.
- coldtea 10y ago>Humans are agressively being eliminated from as many business models as possible. Well, that only works as long as many businesses don't do it. See, business models tend to require people with jobs and money to spend. You can rip profits by catering to those still working if you automate your restaurant or supermarket first. But it gets increasingly harder to make money for any businesses when those whose jobs got automated away get increasingly many.
- etskinner 10y ago"There will always be a need for someone to wipe down the tables, mop the floors, and take out the trash so a few minimum wage level positions will linger on." Hah, yeah right. Boy is the author gonna be surprised when those jobs get automated too.
- zanny 10y agoSeriously, we already have robots that mop and vacuum. Scrubbing tables and taking out trash are just more expensive - it isn't a technically infeasible thing to do right now, especially if you sacrifice some of the magic by just putting UV strips on the tables to indicate where the robot should scrub, or some such. That eliminates the day labor, you would probably still want a weekly cleaning crew to come around and get in all the nooks and crannies, but it is also reasonable to design buildings around being robot-maintenance friendly, and the more and better of a job the robots can do the less often you need the cleaning crews coming through until you never need them anymore. The problem right now is that buying a robot that can wipe tables is a large upfront expense few places want to eat up. Prices will come down, though, as they always do. The cost to manufacture machinery is fairly fixed by volume in the endgame anyway, you just have to overcome the R&D costs.
- cr0sh 10y ago> The problem right now is that buying a robot that can wipe tables I'm not sure how it would help with the "cleaning" part of things, but what if the tables were robots themselves? Could that help with cleaning? It could help with a lot of things - for instance, imagine a conference center that could re-arrange itself between groups or conferences, then put itself "away" as needed. Or imagine a garbage can at some venue that loiters around people with disposable items (and perhaps reminds them about its presence when it senses they need to throw something away - I experience this once at a "human level" at a 5-star hotel, where instead of visible garbage cans, there were people who stood around to take your "garbage"). One could potentially think up many such instances - where everyday items become robots for tasks (which might also help to keep such things clean, as well).
- pasbesoin 10y agoRight now, in the U.S., I'd settle for guaranteed basic/effective health care. If you aren't going to outright kill people, and if you expect them to "bootstrap" and move on to the next job, you should put some effort into making sure they are healthy enough to do so. Not to mention basic morality. Nor that problems treated early are smaller and cost less. And that society pays that cost, whether through cost spreading by private healthcare (hospital critical care -- the last line of defense); Medicaid and government programs; or prison. Unless you really are going to just bury them, and spring for a pauper's grave. Sounds rhetorical? Look at Jeff Sessions' latest mandate to prosecutors: 'Lock them up! For as long as possible!' Look at the widening gaps in longevity. Follow the money (to the top).
- objectivistbrit 10y agoThe following table (Employment by major industry sector) should be more widely known in this debate. The most relevant column is the second one (Thousands of Jobs, 2014). Just seeing this table makes clear how broad the modern economy is. https://www.bls.gov/emp/ep_table_201.htm https://www.bls.gov/emp/ep_table_201.htm Here's a more detailed version: https://www.bls.gov/emp/ep_table_207.htm https://www.bls.gov/emp/ep_table_207.htm
- brndnmtthws 10y agoFreakonomics had an interesting 2 part podcast series about this very topic. If you haven't heard of it, and these things interest you, I suggest you check it out: Part 1: http://freakonomics.com/podcast/earth-2-0-economics-edition-part-1/ http://freakonomics.com/podcast/earth-2-0-economics-edition-... Part 2: http://freakonomics.com/podcast/earth-2-0-income-inequality/ http://freakonomics.com/podcast/earth-2-0-income-inequality/
- jimmywinestock 10y agoWe can draw an interesting historical parallel from the Roman Empire in the 2nd and 1st centuries BCE. Expansion had greatly enriched the Senatorial class (and the Equites). Meanwhile, middle class Romans (I use the term technically to refer those in the middle property classes able to serve in the military) had been the soldiers who fought in the campaigns the senators had used to get rich. The soldiers' farms fell into disrepair while they were away campaigning and were bought by the wealthy senators when the soldiers realised they could not work them anymore. The Senators then used the slaves they had brought back from overseas to work those farms thereby eliminating the need for hired labour from the dispossessed. The now landless soldiers lived off the grain dole until popularist leaders came along and offered to pay them directly to fight for them. This was a key factor in the breakdown of Roman democracy and the rise of the emperors (princeps).
- grblovrflowerrr 10y agoIn the barista example, the robot clearly will be able to make a more consistent cup. Maybe the solution then is to make the barista experience more elaborate and enjoyable, sort of like performance art? Flair bartending is a good example of that, aesthetic differences aside. Humans, when properly trained in the creative arts, are still the best entertainers of other humans. I wonder how this will impact the world of fine dining and establishments that have a great reputation with their community. Just yesterday I was watching a Japanese show about a restaurant owner in Louisiana who would spend all night in his store going between the customers and the kitchen, coming up with new menu items on the fly with his friends(customers), introducing people to each other, going to the neighboring bars to visit and try out their new drinks/food, and just really combining the best aspects of a chef, host, and wait staff. I doubt his store will be severely impacted by automation since you're not just buying food or a drink, you're there to be a part of something you really love and supporting a man and his business in keeping something beautiful alive. Maybe this whole automation issue will give the big box retailers and chain restaurants a kick in the butt to up add a deeper human element to their experiences? Or maybe the space will be filled in by people who can make spaces for people to just have a good time and connect with their community, instead of being walked along like dogs through a programmed conveyor belt experience.
- micahbright 10y ago> We tend to think of that as social engineering and Godless communism. Come on, you're making an argument for universal basic income, but you obviously aren't educated enough to make an argument for or against it if you think only religious bigots and those lacking your level of sophistication are the majority of the opposition. Learn some opposing views, Buddy
- PeterStuer 10y agoThere isn't enough 'high value' work to be done. We don't 'need' so many people to feed or house or even entertain the planet. We have a distribution problem of affluence, not a production problem. Even much of our current value 'work' only exist because we are externalizing the disastrous impact it has on the planet and its inhabitants. Maybe VR will offer a way out. Keeping the masses 'occupied' with virtual labor that has less of an ecological impact. Grinding lvl 863 mining in an MMO, not for fun, but for life.
- grondilu 10y ago> Instead circumstances are going to overwhelm us until enough of the population is miserable enough to demand real change. I'm not sure. During the great depression the USA did not embrace communism. Why should it be different with automation?
- erikb 10y agoActually I would argue to social systems and people arguing like this blog post we already have some slowing that process and its effect. We are actually already doing "better" than nature in this regard, because of culture (if you consider sacrificing survivability in exchange for social benefits better). In general this is just normal evolution, something more efficient replaces something less effecient. And it's not completely stopabble. Let's say you can create laws that force McDonalds to keep staff and not use robots. Then at some point McDonalds will get bankrupt and another company will take its place. Maybe you can make the laws that forces all companies in your country to employ people despite not needing them any more. Then at some point your country will be too poor and gets replaced by another country, either through invasion, or revolution, or both.
- known 10y ago1. Unlike Capitalism, Globalization is Zero-sum 2. Basic income gives impetus to Social mobility