36 ms·
In Bay Area, six-figure salaries are “low income”
- ShakataGaNai 10y agoFor a family of 4. That's the critical bit left out of the article title. 104k is low income for a family of 4, in some areas. Which makes sense when it's hard to find somewhere to live alone, in SF, even at 100k. Finding a place big enough for a family of 4 plus all the costs related to 4 humans? Not surprising in the least.
- cbhl 10y agoOnce upon a time, a family of four had the same number of working adults as a family of one.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- lisper 10y agoOnce upon a time a family of four would live in a 1200 square foot house and own one car and one television, would rarely travel, rarely go out to eat. That kind of life style can still be sustained even in the Bay area on $100k/yr.
- throwa38282 10y agoOnce upon a time, the woman stayed at home and didn't need a second car. Televisions were prohibitively priced as to make one even a stretch. And, travel was prohibitively priced so that only the ultra-rich could afford planes. When cars hit the scene en masse, it brought rise to car trips. So, I guess you're saying people aren't living within their means? But they weren't necessarily then either... And boy, I sure miss all of the great stuff from the 50s.
- douche 10y ago> Televisions were prohibitively priced as to make one even a stretch. It's just astounding how cheap televisions have become. A 32" flatscreen is like $150, and weighs ten pounds.
- itomato 10y agoWhereas content is $100/month when it used to be $0.
- throwa38282 10y agoBroadcast TV is still free. Movies always cost a fair amount of money. An internet connection with youtube is $30 which is WAY more variety than "back then".
- itomato 10y agoMmm. Yeah, I get loads of value from Univision and Home Shopping Channels like HSN, QVC and the others. Can't forget Qubo and Me.tv. Good times, for sure.
- throwa38282 10y agoCBS, NBC, ABC, FOX, PBS Also, I'm suspecting you're not a Spanish speaker, so I guess it's okay to discount a channel that over 10% of the US has utility for. Cable TV is a relatively recent invention, has quickly declining subscription rates, and has always been billed as premium.
- geebee 10y agoYou know, maybe not. Even in the excelsior, a 1200sf ft house that is liveable (not remodeled highly, just liveable) will run you $900k. It can go up from there easily. It's possible, I suppose... You'd need to be a one income family at 100k, because there's no way you could cover that and child care. But yeah, a stay at home spouse and a working spouse who brought in 100k might be able to make it work south of 280. EDIT: just realized you said Bay Area, not San Francisco. That changes things.
- Veelox 10y agoEven with your edit I would like to chime in that I got a condo in San Jose that is 3 bed, 2 bath for <500k. It isn't fancy but it is home.
- linkregister 10y agoWhen did you buy this condo? Surely not recently.
- Veelox 10y agoI closed in December of 2016, as I nice side affect I got a rate that was a little lower then they are now.
- jostmey 10y agoGreat point. Let's regress backwards. San Francisco's housing crises and living cost is self inflicted by limiting supply.
- derefr 10y agoKeep in mind that 1. California has high taxes, and 2. those taxes go down as your number of dependents goes up. Your employer has the same number in your salary column either way, but your take-home pay tends to rise to match your needs, up to a point. (It doesn't work out for e.g. n=8, but it tends to take care of n<4.)
- vkou 10y agoYes, but any spare income earned by multiple working adults in a family will eventually be siphoned up by either landlords, or banks.
- unit91 10y agoIf your bank is eating your income, you need a new bank.
- nommm-nommm 10y agoUm what!? My family has two incomes. We save the entire second income (before taxes) and then some. Not to mention interest rates are at historic lows. (PS, people's spending tends to match their income no matter how high the income, it's called lifestyle inflation)
- vkou 10y agoIn hot markets, landlords will charge as much rent as their tenants can bear. If enough people have an entire income available to them, rents will rise.
- bonzini 10y agoThat did not last for long though, maybe forty years from after the second world war till the early 80s. The model that did last for centuries had families of 8-12 people, with men working in the fields and women looking after children and grandchildren.
- danharaj 10y agoThat's inaccurate or incomplete. Women shared a significant portion of agricultural labor throughout history and on top of that maintained the household and performed auxiliary labor.
- bonzini 10y agoYes, I was simplifying a lot. The point still stands, in that except for a short period of time it has never been "one person working", because maintaining the household and looking after all the young in the extended family is a job of its own. It was not at all like having two kids, who spend half the day or more at school.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- cowardlydragon 10y agoYou're questioning statisticians for assuming a population-replacement breeding rate?
- mrweasel 10y agoThere's only four zip codes in Denmark that have a higher average income per household, and Denmark is a pretty expensive place to live. It seems obvious to move that some tech companies would move away from San Francisco, offer lower wages, but still manage to give their employees a better deal.
- sampo 10y ago> There's only four zip codes in Denmark that have a higher average income per household, and Denmark is a pretty expensive place to live. In Denmark the following costs are cheaper or entirely nonexistent: Paying for health insurance (for every member of the family), saving for retirement, saving for sending kids to college, kids daycare, kids school fees, and also rent or cost of buying a house is cheaper than in the Bay Area.
- mrweasel 10y agoWhile you partly right, you do need to pay for at least daycare, and retirement. It varies, but around 15% of your salary should go towards retirement and even if you employer pays part of you retirement that normally include in the statistic for house hold income. The four zip code, with the higher average income also have an average price per square meter of 7000USD, so that's of cause a little less than in the Bay Area, assume the 8000USD per square meters I saw a while back is correct.
- sampo 10y ago> you do need to pay for at least daycare I guess in the richer areas in US, $1000 per child is not an unusual monthly fee for daycare. Whereas in Finland, the monthly fee tops at 290€ per child, and I would guess Denmark is more or less similar to Finland.
- nommm-nommm 10y agoHow much does that have to do with our increasing desire for more space though? The square footage of living space per person in a new home has increased from 506.6 to 980.7 since 1973. https://www.aei.org/publication/todays-new-homes-are-1000-square-feet-larger-than-in-1973-and-the-living-space-per-person-has-doubled-over-last-40-years/ https://www.aei.org/publication/todays-new-homes-are-1000-sq...
- mdorazio 10y agoI've seen this argument before and it's not a clear-cut relationship to desire at all. Did home buyers absolutely demand more and more space, or did developers realize they could make more by building bigger and bigger homes? Now we are in a situation where many, many young people looking to move to cities would be perfectly happy with smaller living spaces at associated smaller costs, but those properties straight up don't exist, and also aren't being built.
- Dunan 10y ago"many, many young people looking to move to cities would be perfectly happy with smaller living spaces at associated smaller costs, but those properties straight up don't exist, and also aren't being built" This is it right here. Many municipalities won't even allow them to be built. I would love to live in a small town but such towns are designed around car ownership, total separation of residential and commercial districts, and massive housing lots. If you can't drive, you're stuck living in the big city. And that's only getting more difficult if you're middle income.
- fps 10y agoThe space doesn't cost as much as it once did. In almost every market, the land is the expensive part, not the house. Modern building materials are cheap and energy efficient. I moved from a 1400sqft 1930 built house to a 3600sqft 2014 built house, and the new house costs half as much as the old one to heat and cool. For a builder, there's hardly any reason not to build the largest house that fits on the property, because most of the high cost components are the same if you have a small house or a large house.
- chrisseaton 10y agoIt's a low income if you are supporting a family of four and only one person is working. It doesn't mean the salary is in the low income bracket for a single tech worker on six figures.
- cletus 10y agoCue the standard responses about lack of development, rampant NIMBYism, Prop 13 and rent control. There's really nothing to add at this point. All of this is also why I really prefer living in NYC, which actually has the infrastructure for this sort of thing (meaning if you're a lower to middle income earner in the tri-state area you're not totally hosed like you are in the Bay Area).
- obstinate 10y agoRecently moved to NYC from the bay myself and could not be happier with the decision. At almost any price point, NYC is a more ergonomic place to live.
- make3 10y agowhat are your options then? legit curious
- cbhl 10y agoLive on the other side of a subway or commuter train line. New Jersey, Brooklyn, Queens, that sort of thing.
- chadlavi 10y ago> Brooklyn Hahahahahahahaha, good one. Maybe you're in some alternate dimension Brooklyn, but the one I live in is full on crazygonuts expensive.
- glup 10y agoI know Greenpoint / Williamsburg / Dumbo / Brooklyn Heights / etc. are but what about Bushwick or other parts further inland?
- billmalarky 10y agoBushwick is expensive now. It's not even safe (for the price) yet but it sure it expensive.
- bardworx 10y agoI don't know much about SF salaries, but in NYC, 100K is really middle class. With enrage rent at 2k/mo, salaries have to be high in order to keep up with cost of living. Everyone makes a huge deal about the number but shouldn't it be more of a ratio? Like the cost of living to base salary? That should be a better statistic to judge quality of life.
- cm2012 10y agoThe median annual family income (for a whole family including all earners) is 50k. 100k for a family is in the top 20% of NYC.
- emodendroket 10y agoWell to really answer the question we have to define what we mean by "middle-class," which is often deliberately left so nebulous that it covers practically everyone besides the homeless and the stratospherically wealthy.
- eigenvalue 10y agoYou also have to define "NYC"; this includes outer boroughs like the Bronx where incomes and rents are MUCH lower. If you restrict yourself to Manhattan or a couple outlying areas in Brooklyn/Queens that are considered desirable, the numbers change quite dramatically.
- bardworx 10y agoI used NYC as the 5 boroughs. I also used working class neighborhood rent as comparison instead of manahattan, which would be a bit more
- bardworx 10y agoI live in Brooklyn, by Verrazano bridge which is an hour away from Manahattan by train. I don't know how a family can servive on 50k in a working class neighborhood like mine. I believe there is a great disparity in NYC between Section 8 housing and regular, rent stabilized, apartments. Section 8 brings down family income median as the housing is very affordable but cannot be classified as desirable by most standards.
- archeantus 10y agoWow, this resonates with me. In 2013 my wife and I were living in the Bay Area and had just welcomed our third child into the family. I was making 105k/yr at Apple (which seemed like a ton at the time!) but I felt like I was saving very little of that. I was approached on LinkedIn to take a job with matching pay but that was fully remote. I could live anywhere I wanted in the entire country. I jumped at the chance and felt like I became rich overnight! I miss working at Apple, and would definitely jump at the chance to work remotely for them, but I don't think I could ever afford to move back to California.
- gshulegaard 10y agoJust curious, as an engineer finding myself thinking along similar lines, where did you end up moving?
- archeantus 10y agoWe moved to Utah where the tech scene is actually quite strong, and the cost of living is significantly less. We bought an 8k sq ft house for the price of many 1,500 sq ft town homes we had been putting offers in on in California. It can be such a rat race down there, it is refreshing to remember that it doesn't have to be that way. Life exists outside of The Valley, and it happens to be a pretty darn good one (and affordable!) :)
- leesalminen 10y agoHere in Boulder CO, the cutoff for "affordable" housing subsidies is ~80k for a family of four. 104k in the Bay Area seems about right.
- davidw 10y agoBoulder managed to copy a lot of the good stuff about Silicon Valley - but also seems to have copied the brutal, rampant NIMBYism https://www.nytimes.com/2016/07/04/business/how-anti-growth-sentiment-reflected-in-zoning-laws-thwarts-equality.html?_r=0 https://www.nytimes.com/2016/07/04/business/how-anti-growth-... Great place, and I understand not wanting sprawl, but... build up and in?
- ProAm 10y agoBoulder didn't copy that, Boulder has been that way since the late 70's, tech just happened to move here and the culture was already in place.
- davidw 10y agoFair enough. It just struck me how they've managed to get a lot of the good stuff right when so many places are trying - and not doing a great job - to copy Silicon Valley, but also have that exact same NIMBY problem. William Fischel draws some links with environmentalism in Zoning Rules! ( http://amzn.to/2oIKbyM http://amzn.to/2oIKbyM ) which make sense. Not that he's against it, but just that it sometimes gets a bit perverted to further the ends of NIMBYs rather than actually protecting much of anything. Making people drive 15 miles back and forth to Longmont isn't terribly great for the planet in some ways. In any event, both SF and Boulder are both places that do have a strong sense of environmentalism (in a lot of good ways too, I think), so that could well be the connection. Edit: Exhibit A: SF's Sierra Club fighting to save... a parking garage. http://thebaycitybeacon.com/32740/282282/a/the-sierra-club-fights-to-savea-parking-garage http://thebaycitybeacon.com/32740/282282/a/the-sierra-club-f...
- sigstoat 10y agoit's probably worse, in a sense. you can't build up in boulder because there are height restrictions on buildings.
- rogy 10y agoInterestingly similar discussion going around in the UK at the moment after a UK MP came out saying that '£70,000' salary makes you 'rich'. 70k as a single income won't get you a flat in London in any reasonable time and you'll most certainly be renting forever on that kind if money in London. Even if its triple the average UK wage. Location means everything.
- praneshp 10y agoActually at a previous job (at the front page of HN today for CEO severance) I started developing sympathy for politicians who say things like that. I saw how out of touch upper management was with what was actually going on, and in something like government it's at a much higher order of magnitude. Doesn't excuse them, but I can understand how they say such things.
- michaelt 10y agoSaying that a £70,000 salary makes you rich sounds like sensible politics to me. In the UK the median pre-tax income is £22,400 with £72,000 putting you in the 95th percentile [1]; £70,000 is in the middle of the pay scale for a salaried GP/family doctor [2]; and MPs receive a base salary of £74,000 [3] (plus a bunch of extra income through a variety of opaque means) I think you would look pretty out of touch, from the perspective of someone earning £22,400 if you claimed earning £70,000 didn't make you rich. [1] https://www.gov.uk/government/statistics/percentile-points-from-1-to-99-for-total-income-before-and-after-tax https://www.gov.uk/government/statistics/percentile-points-f... [2] https://www.bma.org.uk/advice/employment/pay/general-practitioners-pay https://www.bma.org.uk/advice/employment/pay/general-practit... [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Salaries_of_Members_of_the_United_Kingdom_Parliament https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Salaries_of_Members_of_the_Uni...
- vilmosi 10y agoWhile I agree with your point, that 22400 number talks about household income not median income of an individual.
- anon374939 10y agoAfter two years in San Francisco, I had to move back to my small(er) home town city because I ultimately realized there's little to no future for me in a city like San Francisco, despite making 250k/yr. I'd have to make at minimum $1M per year for a similar lifestyle (and even then, the stress of living in the bay area will reduce years from your lifespan... what's each year of your life worth to you?).
- stevenwoo 10y agoCurious as to what was causing the stress specific to the Bay Area for you?
- anon374939 10y agoMost activities seemed at least 2x more difficult, and that differential probably becomes 3x with kids. Service all around isn't very good in the Bay, there is a higher chance of simple things to not go as planned. Over the years I've realized that stress is something that creeps up on you slowly but surely, and most often you don't even realize it. Over the years it adds up, and ultimately can reduce your lifespan. It truly is the silent killer.
- sbrks 10y agoCan you elaborate a little more on the activities here being 2x more difficult? I'm curious because this is a metric I use when comparing quality of life between NYC and SF (I made the move about a year ago). Activities like laundry, grocery shopping, and commuting I find easier in SF than in NYC, even though some of the salient variables haven't changed much (e.g. in both cities I don't have in-unit laundry so I go to the closest laundromat). Not to say things aren't harder here than in most places. Just having in-unit laundry seems like something most non high-COL, urban-dwelling Americans take as a given.
- anon374939 10y agoNYC seems to be on par with SF. Both living situations are extreme for someone with a more suburban upbringing. Lack of mobility if you don't have a car, lack of available parking if you do, long lines in general, lots of traffic. Very poor care at many establishments due to overworked and over stressed staff. Miniscule and generally not so great living conditions. For example I lived in a nearly 100 year old house in Oakland with others, which 1 yr later found out had mold problems (a serious health hazard). Also lived in two very modern apartments in the heart of SF both of which had a converted living room bedroom with three roommates. One roommate slept on a couch for a year, paying over $1000/mo. Crime due to homeless situation (witnessed crime frequently during my time, petty crime especially. Side note, didn't a Bart train get robbed just yesterday?). Medical care is another big one (multiple experiences, one for me personally) Even little things like cooking are very difficult when your entire kitchen is 1/5 the size of what you'd find in a similarly priced suburban home. Little things like this add to stress as I wrote a bit about already. And sadly the south bay isn't that much better as a "suburb". The home prices in Palo Alto for example are quite outrageous. There are a lot of far nicer suburbs in other parts of the country without the wild price tag. I was young when I moved, and don't regret the time I spent in the Bay at all. I learned a lot, it was positive for my career and most of all I just had to get it out of my system. The glitz and glamour of it all wore with time, as I suspect it does for many, and ultimately I felt it wasn't where I would want to build my future.
- geggam 10y agoSingle income, Alameda county ( Fremont ), family of 4 No car payment, No credit card debt, 130k will let you live and eat with a bit of room to go do things once a month. If you have a car payment and or credit cards kiss that once a month thing goodbye 150k will let you have a car and do things Source : I left that area recently
- TaylorAlexander 10y agoSame for me. At $130k I was paying off debts at $2k/month but otherwise living paycheck to paycheck. At $160k I now finally have a little extra, replaced my old broken car and have a little cash to save. Rent is $1450 for a studio with no kitchen. I am 32 and single but want a home. I grew up in this area and I feel like I'll have to work forever and start saving aggressively to be able to buy a home and have anything for retirement. Over the next few years I will travel and see what other areas of the country are like.
- jqueryin 10y agoAnswer: you live like a king at 100+ in lots of major cities.
- ryanSrich 10y agoHonest question. I just looked at Redfin and the average house costs around $1.2mm. How would anyone making $130k with 4 dependents buy a house? You seem to fit that criteria so I'll ask you. How on earth did you afford that? Because based on my simple math there just isn't enough money for it to be possible.
- geggam 10y agoYou are right. You dont buy a house there. I left
- grumblestumble 10y agoMy wife and I work full time, combined income is just below $400k. With a mortgage on a 3 bedroom in Oakland, daycare and after-school care costs, student loans, et al, we have never been more broke in our lives. I was living large when I was making $75k and not living in the Bay Area... now, it's beans and rice most nights, and hoping the early 2000's honda doesn't break down on the way to school.
- BadassFractal 10y agoLet's set aside cost of living in the Bay for a second. Here's a completely taboo subject. At what point do we hold people accountable for their reproductive choices? You want to have 2, 4, 6 children in the most expensive slice of land in the US? Great, but please bear in mind that choice comes with real financial consequences to your lifestyle and you should not expect the state to bail you out of it.
- enknamel 10y agoOf course people should be responsible for their choices. However that doesn't mean we can't be more accommodating to people making 100k or less. You think Starbucks will stick around if they have to pay their employees 100k or make them commute a couple hours? The bay needs more housing to meet the needs of all the companies that need employees here.
- throwthisawayt 10y agoThe Bay Area is the most expensive place in the US for no real reason except for regulation. It's kinda like everyone cheering for Uber and Lyft because medallion rules in SF prevented ever having enough cabs. There's no real reason and that's the problem. Also maybe they had those kids in the 1990s when things were a bit more affordable ? The Bay Area wasn't always the most expensive place in the US
- duderific 10y ago> The Bay Area is the most expensive place in the US for no real reason except for regulation. Isn't it more about supply and demand? There are many people here making big salaries at the tech companies, so there is not a shortage of people who can pony up $1-1.5M for a 1200 sq. ft. house. If the demand wasn't there, the prices would come down to meet it.
- BadassFractal 10y agoExactly. Singles and DINKs moving in, chasing the gold rush, willing to pay whatever it takes to be part of the action. The market adjusts itself accordingly. Nothing new here.
- enknamel 10y agoI feel this pain everyday. Getting a house in the bay (because 3-4br apts are super rare) in a decent school district is right around a million dollars. That's a $5k/mo mortgage (not to mention every new development has some insane HOA fee). No way to afford that on a 100k salary. Even at a 200k salary that's pretty uncomfortable.
- hourislate 10y agoWhy would a young professional person want to live anywhere where earning 100k + is not enough when they could live in quite a few other states and earn a 100k + enjoying a cost of living that is 1/3 of what it is in SF or NYC? My wife and I both make well into the 6 figures working at boring corporations enjoying a lifestyle where we would have to earn the equivalent of 7 figures in the Bay Area or NYC. There are a lot of great boring corporations that pay extremely well. They don't provide couches or hammocks and you have to drink regular coffee and sure you have to sit in a cube (no open spaces) but it sure beats having to scrape by on 100k + a year.
- thomasahle 10y agoYoung people are likely to trade away living standards for living where they see the largest future potential, professional or otherwise. I think that's quite natural.
- eigenvalue 10y agoWell, one reason is that it is possible to make a lot more than $100k in places like NYC and SF with a bit of luck/talent/hard work. Plenty of people in NYC make $1mm+ per year. But that is simply not going to happen in most parts of the country if you're not an entrepreneur. So you have to consider that "option value". Plus, NYC attracts some of the best and brightest, has great cultural offerings, is diverse in many respects, doesn't require driving, etc. It's a no brainer for me to live there.
- istorical 10y agoProbably because young people don't know about those positions or how to find them.
- matmo 10y agoYep, that's my situation. Been in the valley for a few years now since graduating. The work experience is good for now, but you quickly realize that affording a house here is mostly impossible unless you're on top of the bell curve or you have high combined incomes. I want a garage, a driveway, a dog, the ability to really customize my living space, etc, but I don't think its going to happen here. I'd like to magically move somewhere else but its a somewhat intimidating process.
- phoenixProgram 10y agoI was asked to work on a team at Google. I was being paid six figures. I would have been the only white person on the team. Google tried to turn me into an immigrant equivalent. I turned down the offer. I was given a very low level (3 at first, then promoted to 4 for no reason) whereas my peers were given higher levels (5 and 7). Google forced me, a white person who grew up in Oregon and California, to work with immigrants because Google hates Americans who aren't immigrants. I suffered a major psychological attack because I wasn't an immigrant and I was told that if I wanted a job, I would have to act like an immigrant. American immigrants are evil worthless scum. They hate Americans who aren't immigrants and they work together to stab non-immigrants in the back, especially white non-immigrant Americans. Google wants immigrant equivalents. They want slaves they can exploit. It is an evil company. It is run by evil people who should be hunted down and tortured. Let me repeat that: Google is run by evil people who should be hunted down and tortured. This is how capitalists learn lessons: through torture. They will not learn the lesson unless you torture them. Torture is the right tool in the toolbox to get the result you desire when it comes to the people who run Google. Dignity demands torturing these god damn psychopaths to death.
- 120bits 10y agoI moved out of California 5 years ago and I think I won't consider back moving back at all. I enjoy my 1K/month 2 bedroom-2 bath apartment. 15 mins commute to work and a decent pay to manage my monthly expenses. I dont get paid in 6 figures, but close and I still leave a pretty decent life. I have a friend who works for vmware and gets paid in 6 figures, and still complains about how hard is to manage and do budgeting. Most of the friends are in bay area in tech industry, tells me that tech scene here is amazing and I miss out on the cool dev meetups. I agree, but I think I got used to my life style now. Good work-life balance is hard to achieve.
- dmode 10y agoSix figures is a bit misleading. I make close to 300k, which is also six figures and have a family. Don't really feel poor. I have a 4000 sqft home and take plenty of vacations
- kevinburke 10y agoA lot of the unaffordability is due to the high price of housing in the area. Here are some concrete steps you can take to help lower the price of housing: - The Brisbane City Council is deciding whether to build 4400 units of housing on 600 acres south of San Francisco, about the same number of units SF built in total last year. The Brisbane Planning Commission recommended building an office park instead. Contact them and ask them to build the housing version of the project. - The Mountain View City Council is deciding whether to build 2000 units or 8000 units of housing next to Google. They are leaning toward the low end - 2000 units would be tough to support a grocery store or frequent transit. Contact them (or show up to their board meeting - tonight!) and ask them to build the high-housing version of the plan. - The San Francisco Board of Supervisors is considering a plan to require 28% of all new developments to be below market rate. When you consider the unit costs to build in SF, that would make it _extremely_ difficult to justify new housing starts here. Please contact your Supervisor and ask them to oppose the Peskin/Kim Prop C plan. - Call your CA State Assemblymember and ask them to oppose AB 915 (makes it harder to build affordable units) - Call your CA State Assemblymember and ask them to support AB 71 (higher property taxes on second homes, money goes to affordable housing) - Call your CA State Senator and ask them to support SB 167, which would put teeth in the state's Housing Accountability Act. (for more on this see carlaef.org) - Call your CA State Senator and ask them to support SB 35 (would remove the ability of local government to block projects that meet certain criteria - near transit, have a high % of affordable units, use union construction labor) - Email your VC's and C-level executives and tell them how hard it is to find housing in the area. Tell them about your awful commutes and the difficulty of finding good school districts for your kids. Ask them to get more involved politically in pro-housing causes. Ron Conway is a good example here. NIMBY's are really well organized and things don't change unless we do something about them. All of these changes listed above will go a long way to support the development of housing in the Bay Area, which should help lower prices, and help keep families here and teachers in our neighborhoods. https://kev.inburke.com/kevin/sf-housing-politics/ https://kev.inburke.com/kevin/sf-housing-politics/
- 1024core 10y agoIf I had the money, I'd just put a ballot measure on the ballot to raise the height ceiling for new buildings built within 2 blocks of a MUNI line to 100ft, no approval required. Also: legalize the unpermitted "in law" units.
- pascalxus 10y agoSection 8 is destroying our housing market. All these subsidies just encourage people to stay in CA/Bay area and push up the cost of housing for everyone else to unsustainable levels. Of course the solution is to have a massive increase in the supply of housing. That will never happen. The next best option is to have mass exodus of people leaving the bay area.
- kevinburke 10y ago> Section 8 is destroying our housing market. That's flagrantly false, and a dog whistle. If anything, the existence of Section 8 should encourage more housing supply, since there's more money for rent. NIMBY's have an unusually large say in the approval process here, and we've been underbuilding for decades. NIMBY's are very well organized and they have huge incentives to invest tons of money in their homes due to Prop 13, and to block new housing development so existing property values keep going up. CEQA gives NIMBY's and environmental groups wide latitude to file lawsuits to block projects they don't like, and they succeed in about half the lawsuits they file. Cities prioritize office building over residential due to Prop 13.
- pascalxus 10y agoEverything you said is true, except one thing. You assume that the supply can increase if there's more money for rent. But, that's not entirely true. As you said, NIMBYs are blocking developments at every turn. The supply is not being allowed to increase. And by hamstringing developers with affordability requirements, that's going to decrease supply even further.
- joshmarinacci 10y agoHopefully this will encourage more Bay Area companies to allow full remote working. I moved to Oregon a decade ago and I love it, but remote work options are limited.
- hackermailman 10y agoOne of my remote coworkers moved to rural Georgia and bought 6 acres of land with an 8 bedroom house on it for the same price a parking space would cost in my city.
- 1_2__3 10y agoI've been in the bay area for a few decades. I've gone from my salary paying for my family to have a nice rental house in Cupertino to renting rooms from friends so we have a place to live. And I make double what I did back then. It's fucking awful.
- coltalk 10y agoI hear this sort of thing a lot and I have trouble reconciling it with my experiences. I live in SF and my total expenses (rent, food, entertainment, etc.) were ~$15,000 in 2016. I don't feel like I live a life of great deprivation. I get that the article is talking about a family of four, but even if we assume there are no economies of scale, my costs would work out to $60,000 for a family of four. I also get that I have some privileges: healthy enough to bike rather than drive/take transit, minimal medical expenses, no student loans. But I am surely not the only person in this position. What's happening here? What are the other major expenses that people have? (I understand this comment probably comes off as obnoxious, but I'm genuinely trying to understand. This incongruity makes it harder for me to understand/sympathize with others on this issue and I'd like to regain that ability.)
- kevinburke 10y agoAmong other things, childcare is wildly expensive. Throw in life insurance, and you want your kids to live in a good school district, right?
- coltalk 10y agoHm, early childhood care is more expensive than I thought. I think the schools for my address do happen to be good.
- mac01021 10y agoIf you make $100k, you probably net at least $70k after income taxes. The GP could double his rent and still have over $40k per year to spend on childcare. So something is still not adding up.
- closeparen 10y agoYou're indicating that you rent for less than $1250/mo. A studio is out of the question at that rate; even a room in a shared apartment would be unlikely. People I know paying that little money for housing are an entire BART line away from the city (Richmond, Pittsburg, etc), have several roommates or a working spouse, and need cars. What do you pay for housing, what kind of housing is it, and is a lease like yours available to newcomers who don't have your grandfathered status or connections?
- grandalf 10y agoWhy doesn't someone just buy up most of Detroit and create a massive campus with affordable Victorian homes everywhere.
- kevinburke 10y agoNo one wants to live in Detroit. Uber couldn't even convince its workforce to commute to Oakland; they backed out of a deal to move their office there a month ago.
- grandalf 10y agoOakland is great except for the poverty and side-effects of poverty. An influx of capital and ownership drives away poverty and makes it a non-issue.
- kevinburke 10y agoI don't really get what you are trying to say here.
- massysett 10y agoThis is pretty much what the Quicken Loans guy, Dan Gilbert, is doing.
- davidw 10y agoBTW, for those interested in trying to fix things in the Bay Area: * http://www.sfyimby.org/ http://www.sfyimby.org/ * https://techforhousing.org/ https://techforhousing.org/
- mr_tristan 10y agoAnd this is why tech jobs are going to continue to lead the charge to being mostly remote workers. Major tech hubs are crazy expensive, and the jobs are pretty amenable to remote work. At some point, there's going to be another inflection point where a lot of people making comfortable upper middle-class incomes move out to, well, anywhere. Basically, someone's going to do the math, and recognize that remote workers are just as productive, and are a little cheaper then having a bunch of 20-somethings in the office physically. And the incentive for anyone who wants to have kids to work remote is just going to be really, really high. We may also see more software engineers sticking around as engineers instead of becoming managers as well. Because the incentive to grow your income via management may be relieved.
- RDeckard 10y agoGood foresight.
- majani 10y agoI think it's investors holding up the movement at this point. I usually see most tech guys are mentally prepared for this shift, but finance guys are strongly opposed.
- mr_tristan 10y agoWell, there are a lot of complicating factors in the US when a remote worker moves out of state. Health care seems to be a big one. Few HR departments are frequently equipped to provide another kind of health-care package, and health care expensive, heavily subsidized by many tech companies, negotiated because of bulk sales, etc. Depending on the business, the company might actually be subject to massive sales taxes as well if they employ someone out of state. Some states, like CA, have enacted rather byzantine sales tax laws, such that if you were, say, a company in Idaho, and someone wanted to move to CA, you'd all of a sudden have a "presence" in the state and be subject to more taxes. These are just off the top of my head. So basically, unless the CEO wants it prioritized, I suspect the "finance guys" are actually just identifying real costs. So I wouldn't expect remote work to just jump wholesale nationwide without some real infrastructure in place. In any case, the silicon valley area sure seems to have some pretty stark incentives for prioritizing remote work. I'd expect the issues with remote work to be ironed out faster then say, a massive wage raise or controlled real estate costs.
- SoCool 10y agoI have been in bay area for the last 4 years. I moved to bay area for better opportunity. As an Indian, I find bay area more conducive. I moved from deep south (Alabama). Our combined family income is around 350K and with that we were able to afford a very good home in east bay in good school district. I think, the perspective needs to change. If you come to bay area, you are coming here for opportunity in the tech world and it's not going to be easy here. There are many talented people here and to make it here, you have to compete and compete hard.
- haskellandchill 10y agoCongrats on winning.
- alkonaut 10y agoWhere do all the SV teachers, garbage truck drivers, police etc live? How long is the commute for a single person working at a grocery store checkout in SV?
- Element_ 10y agoI believe the average wage for jobs like nurses and firefighters is over 100k in California... some firefighters can pull in 400k with overtime [1]. [1] http://sanfrancisco.cbslocal.com/2017/03/02/firefighters-earning-up-to-400k-in-san-ramon-draw-criticism/ http://sanfrancisco.cbslocal.com/2017/03/02/firefighters-ear...
- wakkaflokka 10y agoI make just over six figures in the southeast, and I definitely have a blessed and comfortable lifestyle (no kids, no debt). I can imagine the equation changes drastically once kids/family are involved. I've visited San Francisco, Los Angeles, and Seattle, and LOVE the cities. But according to CNN's cost of living calculator, I'd have to make a base salary of almost $190k to have a similar lifestyle in San Fran and Seattle. That seems borderline absurd!
- billmalarky 10y agoEven at $190k it wouldn't be completely comparable. Higher taxes eat up a lot of the additional income, and even then things like car ownership and house ownership that are taken for granted in most of the US carry huge costs in places like SF/NYC. To have a comparably sized home you would probably need 5-10 million in NYC for the home alone, as an example.
- taternuts 10y agoI pay $2,500 a month in rent. I also get paid more by my employer to cover exactly that. I have plenty of money to live the way I want to live and still save money. If everyone is claiming just 2k in rent, how are they not making a living on 120k+ a year?
- kevinburke 10y agoThe simplest explanation is that the expenses for a family of four aren't 4x the expenses of a single man.
- pvelagal 10y agoCan you estimate how much it would cost for a 4 member family, with school going kids ? It might help you prepare if you plan to have one.
- xaa 10y agoI must say that as someone who does NOT live in a crazy high-rent state or town, I am not well pleased by the idea of my federal tax dollars going to people who choose to live there but can't make ends meet, and this even though I'm generally pro-spending on social welfare. You may say, "but the poor can't afford to move!". Well, if that's the case, the government should subsidize their move instead. It would be way cheaper and would incidentally drive real estate prices closer to the national median. I'm not trying to cast any blame on people in this situation, as they are likely there through no fault of their own, but this can hardly be the most efficient way to solve the problem. I feel like economics is screaming a message to people in the Bay Area: "There are too many people here! There's tons of land in the U.S.!", but no one is listening, just casting blame on the techies, gentrification, land policy, or whatever.
- DiNovi 10y agoYou're discussing the government force relocating poor people. Think about that...
- xaa 10y agoNo, I'm not. I'm suggesting that they be given the choice of moving somewhere else, of their choice, with subsidies for the move, or trying to go it alone in place. And this only for those people who fall in that gap between (approximately) the national low-income line and the local "low-income" line. People who fall below the national low-income line should be given subsidies, regardless of where they live. I believe in helping people, but not subsidizing irrational behavior that exacerbates an existing problem. Just think about how this looks to someone like me: the low-income threshold in CA is over twice my household income. And I am not classified as low-income. So to some degree my tax dollars will be transferred to subsidize some terrible decision-making. If this looks bad to me, a liberal, think how it looks to moderates and conservatives! Let's take this to the logical extreme: suppose I decide to live literally in Hollywood hills, where one of my relatives lives. I make nowhere near enough to survive there. Should I be subsidized anyway? Does it make a difference if I was born in Hollywood and this situation arose subsequently? I think not, when it comes to the question of what should be done about it now, although reasonable minds may differ.
- arthur_trudeau 10y agoNote that this is "low income" for the purposes of eligibility for HUD programs. Through the Obama administration, those programs have had the goal of dispersing black and hispanic families into white (and usually high income) areas, particularly suburbs, rather than providing "affordable housing" per se in poorer / cheaper areas.
- uiri 10y agoFor those who are interested in looking at the raw data: https://www.huduser.gov/portal/datasets/il/il2017/select_Geography.odn https://www.huduser.gov/portal/datasets/il/il2017/select_Geo... The figures that the article cites are for a family of four. The thresholds for individuals are noticeably lower.
- scotty79 10y agoRent always roughly costs as much as median person has left after feeding himself.