7 ms·
This looks slick, but there's actually a reason that rooftop solar panels are installed with a gap between the panels and the roof. Panel power output drops not
by taneq 10y ago
This looks slick, but there's actually a reason that rooftop solar panels are installed with a gap between the panels and the roof. Panel power output drops noticeably on hot days as panel temperature rises. The air gap creates a siphon effect, pulling air past the panels and cooling them.
- viraptor 10y agoThere's still a gap, so I hope they took that into account / measured the drop.
- aerovistae 10y agoI seriously doubt that they've spent 10 years in the industry and would read this comment and go "Wait, what?? Oh shit! We fucked up! Turns out nobody working here had any relevant expertise at all, and we were just guessing how this worked and how to design it! If only we'd talked to anyone who knew had even basic knowledge about solar panels before creating a factory to produce them!" A more valid wording for this comment would be "I wonder how they altered the design to accommodate for the siphon effect the gap generated," instead of implying they have no idea what they're doing.
- MPSimmons 10y agoRelevant: http://www.commitstrip.com/en/2016/06/02/thank-god-for-commenters/ http://www.commitstrip.com/en/2016/06/02/thank-god-for-comme...
- Sarkie 10y agoSo fucking relevant.
- bigtimeidiot 10y agoWhat are you doing on a message board if you think no one here has anything insightful to offer?
- sschueller 10y agoBut stuff like this happens all the time. Especially when designers have more say than engineers. Just look at the previous iPhone antenna issues or the samsung batteries.
- aerovistae 10y ago> "Stuff like this happens all the time" It just blows my mind that someone can create a successful space program from scratch and still people think "but he'll probably get tripped up by this tiny thing that even I noticed! Just waiting for company to go belly up."
- makomk 10y agoYou may also recall that Tesla had immense problems making car door handles that actually work reliably (and the same with the doors themselves), largely because they prioritized fancy aesthetics over sound engineering. If they've taken the same approach with their solar panels, this would be completely unsuprising.
- zackbloom 10y agoThey prioritized fancy aesthetics over simplicity, not over sound engineering. Unless you believe sound engineering is just never doing hard things. The doors were new, they were complicated, they took time. I don't think they revealed any fundamental engineering weaknesses of the company, just a reminder that anything new is hard.
- clock_tower 10y agoWere the seatbelt bolts new and complicated?
- manicdee 10y agoIs having the diff not rupture the fuel tank and set the car on fire new and complicated? Is having the engine block not spontaneously catch fire new and complicated? I love this game!
- PinguTS 10y agoTesla presented the best in class Powerwall for an unbelievable cheap price. Everybody said at that time: impossible. Elon said: "We have this number of orders." Actually, you never heard of any significant deliveries. Instead: "We have this new Powerwall 2". Already, the first version of Powerwall 2 is already dropped before deliveries happened. There is only marketing of single prototype large scale installations. The same with the solar shingle. Everybody tells: too expansive because of the expansive installation requirements because of the connectors. A (few) single panels are easier to install. But still Elon claimed the solar shingle will be cheaper than regular before energy payback.
- aerovistae 10y agoThis Tesla press release at the time of the Powerwall 2 says quite clearly that 300 MWh of the first version had been deployed, or 46,000 units of the first Powerwall. https://www.tesla.com/blog/gaining-momentum-tesla-powerpack https://www.tesla.com/blog/gaining-momentum-tesla-powerpack Are you accusing the company of lying? Do you have any source to your accusations here? Kind of seems like you're making some claims to fit your pre-existing agenda without researching it at all.
- PinguTS 10y agoFact checking: — May 2015 Tesla announced: 38,000 Pre-orders for the Powerwall and 2,500 pre-orders for the Powerpack, which would equate to 25,000 Powerwall http://www.theverge.com/2015/5/6/8561931/tesla-38000-powerwall-preorders-announced http://www.theverge.com/2015/5/6/8561931/tesla-38000-powerwa... — According to your PR Tesla installed until October 2016 300 MW. (38,000 + 25,000) by 7kW = 441MW (I know a rough calculation) That means, the pre-orders where received in 1 week. All the pre-orders fulfilled means, they never sold anything in addition to those first movers _AND_ they did not sold/installed any Powerpack. But as they installed also some large scale Powerpacks, that means they did not even fulfilled their pre-orders (or a significant amount got cancelled) _and_ they did not sold any Powerwall besides the pre-orders. Just a nice reminder, do your own research and double check numbers. Don't believe in PR only. EDIT: corrected the numbers
- 10y ago
- taneq 10y ago> A more valid wording for this comment would be "I wonder how they altered the design to accommodate for the siphon effect the gap generated," instead of implying they have no idea what they're doing. If you want a rewording that's closer to my original meaning, it'd be more like "I bet these were made with a cold climate, like that in the northern USA, in mind. They'd lose 10-20% efficiency in summer where I live." Edit: Although that may not be a terrible thing, if they're overprovisioned compared with the inverter's maximum output so as to keep the inverter at full power for a larger proportion of the time. Depending on climate, you could probably balance out losses due to summer heat with losses due to reduced winter daylight, at least to a degree, giving more reliable year-round power.
- tw04 10y agoAt the end of the day - does it matter? People expect X output at $X price. If this meets that desire, they're fine. A lot of people would probably be just fine losing some power on hot days to not have something ugly on the roof of their house. For some things aesthetics DO matter - the roof of a house is one of them for most people. Cars tend to be another one as Elon is well aware of.
- astrodust 10y agoNorthern USA. Cold climate. Yeah, like Chicago in July. Super cold.
- mikekchar 10y agoI've seen panels very much like these in Japan. They've been around for a couple of years. It may very well be the ones from Panasonic, but a quick glance at the Panasonic Japanese web page is inconclusive. But in any case, the concept is already tested in the field. And in case you are wondering, it get's very hot where I live in the summer (40C is not unheard of). It would be interesting to see what they are doing to ensure airflow.
- skamoen 10y agoElectrek.co states they're indeed from Panasonic https://electrek.co/2017/04/09/tesla-solar-panel-panasonic/ https://electrek.co/2017/04/09/tesla-solar-panel-panasonic/
- usrusr 10y agoSo basically, Musk-oil infused off the shelf products? This could be the "rounded corners" of energy, cue the Samsung jokes. There have been different levels of awareness for the visual quality of photovoltaic installations before, this one does not strike me as a particularly large jump. Maybe the baseline standard in the US is particularly low so this is relevant? Or do these aesthetics skirt a common HOA threshold? But in the end it does not matter much. Even if it's all just hype, if the hype leads to installations that would not have happened otherwise it must be a net positive.
- wklauss 10y agoOne of the commenters on Electrek points to this: "Panasonic's existing panels have low temperature coefficient, so their performance doesn't drop off as much with heat. If they also add in Tesla's Silevo technology which has even lower temperature coefficient, most of the hit for thermals would be negated as compared to standard panels." I'm sure this is throughly tested, in any case. Panels like these have been in use for a while in Japan.
- burfog 10y agoPower output drops even more when a hurricane catches that gap and rips the panel off the roof, probably taking a chunk of the roof or at least leaving bolt holes. Power output never happens if the panels are never installed, perhaps due to any ugly gap. Really the panels need to be the roofing material. This doesn't mean they need to look like traditional roofing. They just need to span the entire roof, edge to edge without gaps.