12 ms·
Tesla unveils its new ‘sleek and low-profile’ solar panel made by Panasonic
- itchyjunk 10y agoSolar power is catching on. Along with it, other things are changing. Selling back to grid only gets you credit towards your power bill which you need to use up in 6-12 months or you lose it (someone who recently got solar told me this is how it works for him). I would like to see ways for customers to sell power among themselves (if possible) in this case. If I generate some extra power and someone needs it to charge their car, i'd rather sell it to him. Instead of the shady power company. But maybe it doesn't work like this.
- givemefive 10y agoWhat about Folding@Home or other high energy computing tasks. If you have your PS4, XBOX, home desktop, SO's laptop, etc running high intensity tasks how much energy would that be?
- Synaesthesia 10y agoThe biggest power consumer is things like Geysers, kettles, stoves and so on. A desktop running at 100% uses like 200W whereas a geyser uses like 2kw.
- acover 10y agoThe biggest power consumer is electric heat/ac. http://www.torontohydro.com/sites/electricsystem/residential/yourbilloverview/Pages/ApplianceChart.aspx http://www.torontohydro.com/sites/electricsystem/residential...
- ClassyJacket 10y agoMy high end gaming PC would push over 500W when mining Bitcoin (actually Lite coin) back in the day. Side note: Swype keyboard will not allow me to write Litecoin as one word with a bracket after it, no matter how much I correct it.
- infogulch 10y agoWhen autocorrect refuses to cooperate I find that spacing things out between normal words then deleting the spacers usually works. Correction usually only occurs after typing punctuation, not for deletion. Litecoin and [] Litecoin []
- ClassyJacket 10y agoYeah, that seems to be the only way to do it. (Litecoin)... Strange, it's changed its policy now.
- patrickk 10y agoI mined Ethereum last summer on a 6 GPU, dual-PSU rig. Each GPU consumed roughly 220W-250W IIRC, so the heat and noise was considerable.
- astrodust 10y agoThat's one panel worth of power, theoretically.
- ClassyJacket 10y agoThe heat from that would be horrendous. A typical space heater consumes about the same as that. Even at just 500W my machine would heat the room considerably over a few hours.
- dm3730 10y ago> Geysers For those wondering, that term means hot water heater.
- Someone 10y ago2kW when the faucet is running, about zero when it isn't. With a duty cycle of 1% (= running hot water for 15 minutes a day), that desktop could beat your geyser, even when running at 10% throughout the day.
- matt4077 10y agoIgnoring the time limit you mention, I fail to see the difference? Electricity isn't tangible. In the case of AC, they're just wiggling the electrons in your appliances back and forth. Any promise that your power goes to your neighbour, via the grid, would be a lie. In financial terms, letting anyone sell electricity to the "shady power company" at the same price they buy it at is only possible as a government-mandated subsidy paid by all customers, intended to promote clean energy. It effectively makes the grid your free, unlimited, zero-loss battery. If you want to sell it to your neighbour at the same price they and you pay to have the grid wiggle your electrons, there's no difference. If you want, for unfathomable reason, to set a different price, you can just walk over and hand them some money whenever you feel like it. But currently, there are no circumstances under which it would make sense to not sell as much as you can to the power company: if you're producing at costs above grid prices (still likely in most locations), your neighbour could always get his power cheaper from the grid. If you're producing below grid prices, selling as much as possible at the subsidised rates is your best choice.
- glandium 10y ago> In financial terms, it's extremely generous to let anyone sell electricity to the "shady power company" at the same price they buy it at. In some countries, it's even a better deal, because the "shady power company" has to buy it for more than they sell electricity for. (I don't know if it's still true, but it was the case in France)
- baddox 10y agoI think the previous commentator's point is that distributing power between neighbors is a theoretical way to avoid the time limit imposed by the power company. Of course, with current infrastructure I assume the power company would still need to support this model by doing some simple math with everyone's meters in a neighborhood or region.
- LoSboccacc 10y agoIf the time limit is 6 months as he say and you have excess panels to cover average winter needs, summer surpluses are lost More importantly it was left unspecified if the discount given was dollar for dollar electricity. If it's less than that suddenly your ideal, infinite battery becomes less than perfect But I agree selling to the neighboor is not gonna work - a feasible alternative would be to have the resources pooled for building a larger panels with a larger battery
- programmarchy 10y agoA Powerwall helps with being able to store charge for yourself. It'd be awesome to share power directly with neighbors, too. You could always install your own cable, right? Doesn't seem like the power company would even need to be involved.
- taneq 10y agoIn Australia at least, there are regulations against installing power cabling that goes between premises (unless you're a power company, of course).
- hodgesrm 10y agoSame in California. The rule is that the cabling can't cross a street. So actually you could provide power to neighbors within in the block but not the next one.
- taneq 10y agoWe're not even allowed to run cable between two adjacent properties owned by the same company. (A former employer of mine got around this with a "temporary" 3-phase cable going between the two, but it was regarded as a bit dubious.)
- cardiffspaceman 10y agoIn many places the streets form a grid, it's true. You would possibly have only a dozen homes that could be connected. In other places, the streets are arranged as a tree with cul-de-sacs as the leaves. An island of acreage could emerge in such developments where you could visit dozens of homes without crossing a street.
- ClassyJacket 10y agoYep, they're so strict that the National Broadband Network was worried that simply powering distribution point units for Fibre-to-the-Curb internet would break those rules.
- 10y ago
- manicdee 10y agoA scheme used here in Australia is to sign up your PV+battery to a virtual power plant, then sell electricity on the wholesale market when it is profitable to do so. e.g.: Reposit Power http://www.repositpower.com http://www.repositpower.com
- toomuchtodo 10y agoTesla will be doing the same with their vehicles and Solar City's tech team: distributed virtual generators and demand. ISO operators will be able to issue price signals, and Tesla will be able to supply to or draw power from the grid (in accordance with their customer's wishes of course) in aggregate
- TorKlingberg 10y agoI'm sure you could, but you'd have to lay your own cable to your neighbor. If you want the power company to transmit the power and handle load balancing, you will end up paying for it.
- Shivetya 10y agoSolar power is catching on but it does not work on all roofs in all locations and I am curious if companies pushing home roof top installations are upfront with their numbers. I know our local energy co-op lets you "invest" into a facility they have constructed where they are adding panels as demand increases. The logic here is, not outlay of funds by the home owners, maintenance needs are consolidated to one location, and it can be ideally situated. Until panel installs become near maintenance free and service technicians are common where inspections are fast and cheap its not going to solve our problems. I am hoping TESLA's previous announcement related to solar shingles and such plays out well. It needs to become cheap enough that even if your system is not ideally situated its cheap enough to be economical.
- whiskers08xmt 10y agoThere's an interesting project called Solar Coin[0] attempting to do this. I'm not too sure how it relates to crypto-currency, though. [0] https://solarcoin.org/en/front-page/ https://solarcoin.org/en/front-page/
- norea-armozel 10y agoIt's probably why Tesla wants to sell people the power wall despite its own shortcomings. Why give that power back to the grid operators who are going to screw you over? Just get a battery storage solution that also charges your car and maybe covers some of the power consumption in the home? I think in the long term this is the only viable option or until the grid operators and other concerns outlaw usage of battery tech that stores power in advance of daily usage.
- syncsynchalt 10y agoGrid operators would love it if you leveled out your energy usage in that way. They see the duck neck coming: https://www.caiso.com/Documents/FlexibleResourcesHelpRenewables_FastFacts.pdf https://www.caiso.com/Documents/FlexibleResourcesHelpRenewab...
- sjg007 10y agoIt's funny how power companies quickly moved away from the pay you cash for your power to credits to now fixed rates for life. Solar is a huge disruptor.
- wklauss 10y agoIt was obvious that pay you for power was not scalable. Eventually you'll see people disconnecting from grid altogether to avoid fixed rates.
- moonka 10y agoWhen I was a child this is how I thought solar panels would look in the future. These look much nicer, and I imagine will help win over those who are very concerned about curb appeal.
- astrodust 10y agoI think the reason you thought that was because of Syd Mead: http://www.sydmead.com/v/12/ http://www.sydmead.com/v/12/
- taneq 10y agoThis looks slick, but there's actually a reason that rooftop solar panels are installed with a gap between the panels and the roof. Panel power output drops noticeably on hot days as panel temperature rises. The air gap creates a siphon effect, pulling air past the panels and cooling them.
- viraptor 10y agoThere's still a gap, so I hope they took that into account / measured the drop.
- aerovistae 10y agoI seriously doubt that they've spent 10 years in the industry and would read this comment and go "Wait, what?? Oh shit! We fucked up! Turns out nobody working here had any relevant expertise at all, and we were just guessing how this worked and how to design it! If only we'd talked to anyone who knew had even basic knowledge about solar panels before creating a factory to produce them!" A more valid wording for this comment would be "I wonder how they altered the design to accommodate for the siphon effect the gap generated," instead of implying they have no idea what they're doing.
- MPSimmons 10y agoRelevant: http://www.commitstrip.com/en/2016/06/02/thank-god-for-commenters/ http://www.commitstrip.com/en/2016/06/02/thank-god-for-comme...
- Sarkie 10y agoSo fucking relevant.
- bigtimeidiot 10y agoWhat are you doing on a message board if you think no one here has anything insightful to offer?
- sschueller 10y ago
- OrwellianChild 10y agoWith a relatively attractive panel like this one, what case remains for the solar roof product? Particularly considering the fact that there is a positive social signal associated with visible solar on your house? I'm not sure I understand the trade-offs between the two. Isn't this the superior product?
- aerovistae 10y agoWait, did you actually research this before making a comment? What were you thinking ?!
- bigtimeidiot 10y agoWhen does the HackerNews brigade come and start accusing random people of being paid Tesla's shills, like they did in the John Deere threads?
- DanBC 10y agoYou can flag comments that accuse others of being shills. Click the timestamp of the comment to get the flag link. I think you need 30 karma for the flag link to appear.
- bigtimeidiot 10y ago>I think you need 30 karma for the flag link to appear. Interesting. I guess my poor attitude makes that 30 karma threshold a tough row!
- rory096 10y agoYou have 104 karma. Note that you'll have you click on the comment's timestamp to see the full set of options.
- sctb 10y agoPlease don't be personally thorny with other users—the guidelines ask us to be civil. We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14085771 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14085771 and marked it off-topic.
- aerovistae 10y agoWell I was implying that this was a good comment, well researched, and that that's uncommon. It was sarcasm.
- makomk 10y agoThis seems like the final nail in the coffin for SolarCity's in-house solar manufacturing technology from Silveo, which as I recall was meant to be part of the justification for Tesla buying them. The tiles were already announced to be using Panasonic solar cells, and with their non-tile solar product switching to Panasonic-made panels too...
- ecopoesis 10y agoThey look a lot like Sunpower's all black panels. I wonder how efficient they are? In Sunpower's case, the all-black ones are lower wattage and less efficient then their traditional looking ones, but also cheaper.
- ckastner 10y agoThe full title reads "Tesla unveils its new ‘sleek and low-profile’ exclusive solar panel made by Panasonic". From the sources it references, it also appears that Panasonic is manufacturing Tesla's batteries. Does anyone know how much of this is Tesla's technology, and how much Panasonic's? If it's mostly the latter, what would stop Panasonic from providing the same technology to other parties?
- nickpinkston 10y agoAccording to what I've heard from public sources, the machines and tech are Panasonic, but the factory lay-out and product design is Tesla. I think you can think of Tesla as "Standard Lithium" - like Standard Oil in the past, they built a giant refinery (The GigaFactory) to give economies of scale and built many channels of distribution to sell it all + compliments: cars, battery packs, solar, etc.
- bigtimeidiot 10y ago>If it's mostly the latter, what would stop Panasonic from providing the same technology to other parties? There's a big benefit for Panasonic supplying a company with hot products, like Tesla. But outside of whatever contractual obligations they have, there's nothing stopping them. I implore you to look around at these industries from other sources. If you only read HackerNews, you'd think Tesla is the only company that can make a decent EV (even though motortrend said the Bolt performed nearly as well, had longer range and was $30k cheaper than the Model 60), that no one is close with self-driving and that Tesla are the only one providing this type of solar panel or battery storage solution. These are all hyper competitive, low margin spaces. Tesla is doing some very cool things, but the unjustified hype is going to blow up in people's faces. Expectations are too high.
- yttrium 10y agoI don't understand your recent comment strings - your comments in the John Deere thread yesterday were equally confrontational without anything to really back it up. Confidence in Tesla is high because people like the brand. Panasonic similarly works hand in hand with Tesla because they're confident the value of the Tesla brand. People will read that motortrend comparison and still buy a Tesla - because the bolt is ugly and looks like your lyft drivers car, and because they want a Tesla. The idea that Tesla has unjustified hype is not a novel position to take and I don't know why it would serve as a good position to snipe at Tesla when it hasn't worked at all in the past. (see recent short sellers woes)
- rb808 10y agoThe pictures look great, but black or slate roofs are not so common in the USA so I'm not so excited. If you want the nice look a black roof parts that aren't covered with panels will probably make the attic way too hot. With less airflow the panels must be less efficient too. I preferred the Tesla Solar Roof Shingles they announced last year https://www.tesla.com/solarroof https://www.tesla.com/solarroof. I any case its an exciting time and great to see people working to make them better looking.
- codecamper 10y agoAmazing how much press Tesla gets for solar panels. How about JK Solar, Canadian solar, JA Solar.. these companies ship GWs of solar panels. Today. Meanwhile their stock is worth tiny multiples.
- _-__--- 10y agoNot sure about the products/companies you're listing, but cult of personality must have a lot to do with the extra press. People will click on links to stories about Tesla/Elon/SolarCity without the journalists having to do as much.
- Animats 10y agoThat's a nice design. The bevel around the edge makes it look better, as does making the interconnects and edges black. Uni-Solar had a similar all-black look with their solar shingles.[1] They were once #1 in flexible solar panels. But they went bankrupt in 2012. [1] http://www.uni-solar.com/#&panel1-1 http://www.uni-solar.com/#&panel1-1
- _Codemonkeyism 10y agoPanasonic batteries, Panasonic panels. Panasonic does a very bad PR job.