19 ms·
America Needs Small Apartment Buildings
- TheApexTheater 10y agoI've recently begun to think about the availability of housing and how that impacts the middle/lower stratum of the US, and it seems to me that there have been several short-sighted policies put in place that have put us in a much worse position for the future for short term gain (the article explains how subsidies for single-family homes are a reason for the shift away from small apartment buildings). Has this always been happening, or has it appeared to become more pronounced with the recent focus on gentrification? What can be done to improve affordable housing? I'm not all too familiar with this field, so anything helps!
- khuey 10y agoIt's become more pronounced lately because the original solution, which to move further and further away from the city, is no longer scaling.
- Endama 10y agoA lot of it seems to exacerbated by limited access to quality public transport. As jobs become more consolidated in city centers, the middle and lower class are more likely to get priced out of living near their work places. High insurance and other private vehicle costs (tickets, maintenance, traffic) make car ownership impossible for mid/lower class citizens. So you end up with a bunch of people, living in poor housing conditions, with poor access to quality transportation, which means the amount of time they are spending in transit, or the jobs that they can reasonably have access to, is constrained. America should have spent more time trying to shift demand away from private car ownership and more towards effective public transportation. Doing so would make areas outside of major metropolitan areas available for middle/lower class people and allow smaller/mid sized cities benefit from the tax revenue.
- loeg 10y agoRedlining[0] was going on through the 80s. Much of many Americans' net worth is tied up in their houses, and house prices have risen somewhat faster than inflation in American cities. Consider the magnitude to which black Americans as a population were disenfranchised by this practice until quite recently. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Redlining https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Redlining
- mc32 10y agoI sometimes wonder why smalltown America prefers "trailer parks" over small-to-midsized apartments. Instead of spreading out over dozens of acres, you could have a couple of complexes with nice communal gardens/parks/playgrounds and have people live vertically densely enough to encourage shops. Instead they either have single family homes (that's okay) or they have trailer parks --if it's a college town then they have squat apartment buildings with little in the way of design other than cheap and utilitarian with very little noise dampening, for the most part. If you travel thru rural California (HWYs 49, 120, 99, etc) there is so much sprawl consisting of cheap housing --instead of gobbling up farmland with crappy buildings they could build alright apartment buildings resulting in better quality of life for the residents (better concentrated service, more walkable for the poor folks, etc.) on the other hand, fewer taxes for the municipality, given the property tax system.
- Raphael 10y agoNoise dampening should be part of the health code or something.
- shiftpgdn 10y agoNoise dampening isn't cheap though. How do you meet all the required regulations without massively cutting corners AND still have affordable apartments? If you're going to go through all the trouble of putting up a new building you might as well shoot for the golden goose.
- lsc 10y agoeh, a modern apartment built with modern noise-dampening standofs on the drywall (something like "resilient channel" - there are several technologies, but the idea is to make the attachment between the drywall and the stud absorb vibration) is better at preventing noise from one apartment to another than older mobile homes are. it's not expensive, either. https://www.google.com/shopping/product/1727307288755176845?lsf=seller:8740,store:2545785678247058220&prds=oid:3504893161321980062&q=resilent+channel&hl=en&ei=fu7dWNCGLYjS0gKBrZS4Bg&lsft=cm_mmc%3DShopping-_-LIAs-_-D22-_-202090218&lsft=gclid:Cj0KEQjw2fLGBRDopP-vg7PLgvsBEiQAUOnIXFEek0iMsfqZOrQwvUtTS77Y9rOWDtuwMRXg52r4bDcaAh6m8P8HAQ https://www.google.com/shopping/product/1727307288755176845?... of course, I've never installed the stuff (I've heard stories, though) so I don't know what it does to labor costs.
- LinaLauneBaer 10y agoIn mid April I will move to a 200sq ft apartment. Very small. I am a bit anxious if my plans work out. Up until now I had about 3.5x that space for me alone. The apartment ist directly at the central station of the city which allows me to get to work super fast and the central station is not too far away from the inner city... walking distance. Let's see how this goes.
- ianai 10y agoI'd feel like I existed solely for that job.
- crooked-v 10y agoI lived in a space of around 300 square feet for years quite comfortably. The only persistent annoyance was doing laundry. Though, the key part of it was to never let any clutter build up, and I am one of those people who can get by without much "stuff".
- adjkant 10y agoHeads up, the difference between 200ft and 300ft is huge. I'm all for small living in the middle of cities, but I think 200 would be too small for me. Wish you the best of luck of course, but I think going for 300ft would be good for next time :)
- masklinn 10y agoFor the imperially challenged that's 20 and 28 square meters respectively. And yeah 20-ish is really small.
- Broken_Hippo 10y agoThank you! I moved to Norway a few years ago. Getting a grasp on housing sizes has been a challenge so far.
- Sharlin 10y ago
- patrickg_zill 10y agoSimply allowing store fronts at the ground level with 1 to 5 apartments above would help.
- ianai 10y ago.
- barrkel 10y agoIt's how most of the rest of the world works.
- Noughmad 10y agoIs this not common in America?
- jnordwick 10y agoIt used to be and there's been a push to get back to it. I think City Journal, major conservative/libertarian group, has been writing about it. It basically went away with modern zoning laws.
- TulliusCicero 10y agoIt's fairly uncommon, yeah. Often it'll be allowed in a smallish 'downtown' area and nowhere else, so most of the city isn't very walkable in terms of doing errands.
- onion2k 10y agoHere in the UK in most cities the amount of empty commercial property is astonishing. You can get space on really good terms eg first 6 months free, next 18 months heavily discounted, and a 5 year lease. A decade ago that would have been nothing free or discounted and a 10 year lease. The reason being that high street shopping is dying. Shopping centres have occupancy rates as low as 80% and are gradually being converted in to complexes of restaurants and bars instead. Store fronts are an anachronism. Building new commercial property in places where you can't put a service business like a bar is pointless. And very few people want to live above a bar.
- ianai 10y agoI feel like the US needs a new way to structure corporate America. Office space needs to be about as sparse as residential. i.e. Instead of having massive business centers have large numbers of small offices interlinked via tech. I'm aware this is pie in the sky. You can't have it both ways, though.
- flukus 10y agoThat just increases reliance on cars and cuts the employee pool for the business. There is an area on the outskirts of my city that they decided make into a large office park. It's great for the people that live around there, but they are always desperate for employees because most don't want to travel that far for work, and the area isn't exactly where people live if they have a choice.
- danielbln 10y agoIdeally you interweave business and residential, like in European cities.
- elastic_church 10y ago> not motivated by money > want the choice to not live in that neighborhood in particular (/ ಠ_ಠ)/
- closeparen 10y agoIt could actually decrease reliance on cars. If employers are widely dispersed, then housing within walking distance of any given employer is not in egregiously high demand, and could be affordable to its employees. There are always going to be more desks than beds in central business districts.
- phamilton 10y agoThat assumes employment is as sticky as housing, which is actually the the opposite of the current trend. The advantage of living close to a large urban center is that I can change jobs without a significant impact to my housing and lifestyle.
- matt_wulfeck 10y agoThere's a lot we can do even in cities. I own a house now and it's pretty ridiculous how restricted the city makes your home. For example, I must set the house back 25 feet from the front curb, and 15 feet from the back. Basically you can't legally extend just about any house and make room for a growing family. You must always move.
- icantdrive55 10y agoIt's overly restrictive zoning, and towns that seem to have nothing better to do than enact new municipal codes. "Oh--apply for a Variance? But that's $1500.00 just for a nay. My little town has made a fortune off of denying variances. I was 25, and about to buy a broken down cabin in a coastal Marin town. The cabin was literally sitting, half way, on a dead redwood stump. I thought I just need to rebuild the foundation. I wont be increasing size, but just putting in a proper foundation. Yea! My first home! Went to the zoning department. The lady told me that house needs 75 feet of front yard, and 25 feet side set backs. I couldn't build because my cabin would be negative in size. The minute I started to rebuild the cabin, the county could red tag the cabin--leaving me with a piece land that's useless. (Now I know why the seller seemed nervous.) She said, there's always a variance. I was about to ask for the paper work. She looked me up, and down. She said, "They haven't approved a variance since I've been here. In retrospect, I should have just bought the cabin, and lived I it until it slid down the hill. I believe that old Redwood stump would have held, but I was young. These towns have enacted too many laws. I literally had a cop show up for having a sun shade on a relatives car. "It needs to be 25 feet back." Then a Fireman said the potted Bamboo plant needs to go--there a fire danger. He said the fine could be up to $350 if I don't remove the plant. Oh, and parking tickets. If the purpose of no overnight parking on streets is for the egress of emergency vecciles; why can my wealthy neighbors by quarltly overnight parking permits? I wish there was some way to turn back a lot of these fee producing muni codes, but they seem bullet proof. It looks like it easier to remove a federal regulation, than a local one?
- Broken_Hippo 10y agoYou can often build upwards.
- jakozaur 10y agoSingle family households are all time high: https://www.statista.com/statistics/242022/number-of-single-person-households-in-the-us/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/242022/number-of-single-... Probably if more decent small apartment buildings was available there would be even more of them. Especially in hot tech hubs such asn San Francisco it's ridiculous how many well-paid employees (FB,GOOG) still lie with roommates, because renting alone will eat too much of their paycheck.
- dredmorbius 10y agoA thought that's occurred to me regards housing is a dynamic which seems to affect asset classes generally, and real estate has very much become an investment asset class: Owners of assets prefer to have those assets appreciate over time. This applies whether you're holding cash, gold, stock, bonds, loans ... or real estate. Or capital goods, educational degrees, guild memberships, computer language skills, etc. The basic principle is simple: if the value of whatever it is you're holding goes up, you have more financial wealth. One consequence is that whoever it is that holds some asset will tend to talk it up or otherwise see that what you own, or have, or control, appreciates in value. Among the key ways to do this is to control the supply of a thing -- this is what cartels (De Beers, OPEC, Standard Oil), guilds and professional societies (medical and lawyers credentialing organisation), taxi medallion holders, and homeowners do. If the good is simply an investment asset, and has no productive or consumptive value of itself, say, stocks or bonds, this isn't much of a concern. You may still have problems of asset inflation bubbles, but nobody will be deprived of life nececessities because stock prices are doubling every 10 years. For housing, both the price and the supply impacts have tremendous effects. Households are forced either to spend an inordinate amount of income on housing, to live far from work, or to crowd (often illegally) into small spaces shared with others. Among the differences is that the investment asset is what I'd consider a Maslovian good: one that is essential to livelihood. Food, water, shelter, clothing, security. There are some goods which have borderline properties -- they're both necessary and carry a strong Vebelen status-signalling component, such as college education (depending on the institution). But generally, this case of treating things people need in order to live as investment vehicles ... seems problematic. How to not do that becomes an interesting question. A Georgian land tax seems as if it might actually be one of the better options.
- cmarschner 10y agoIt seems to me city planning can be quite easily supported through simulations. Like a Sim City on steroids. You want to optimize "quality of life" -"as manifested by a bunch of factors - walkability, low pollution, short commute times etc. Partially these targets can be formulated in some differentiable manner. Partly one might need to do some more black box optimization. Then overhaul zoning rules...
- masklinn 10y agoThe biggest problem in the US is the wide-spread application of "Euclidian" zoning which strictly segregates use (often down to single versus multi-family dwellings), which leads to dead suburbias with houses everywhere but not a grocer or convenience store in place, which makes for absolutely dreary and dreadful environment. You don't even need to run sims to get something better, you can just look at "organic" countries and cities and how they implemented their zoning. Here's a comparison of Japanese and American/Euclidian zoning for instance: http://urbankchoze.blogspot.be/2014/04/japanese-zoning.html http://urbankchoze.blogspot.be/2014/04/japanese-zoning.html (the first link leads to an article on Euclidian zoning)
- cmarschner 10y agoWhen I was a kid and played Sim City for the first time it was also the first time I was confronted with zoning. The whole concept of having a square grid and strictly separate residential/commercial/industrial zones seemed foreign to me. I understood slowly that there was plenty of cultural bias in the game. For me the most natural form of a city was that of a circle surrounding some central area. That would be the european bias I guess... We do have zoning as well of course, but in fact new laws are coming in place that aim for more of a mixture of spaces within a city. I think this is a great development.
- jnordwick 10y agoThose aren't really quality of life metrics though. They are things you think might lead to quality of life, but the isn't the same thing. Walkability might not be the important thing, but ease of commute might be and separate cars might win out on that (convince a majority of LA natives to give up theirs cars in exchange for the subway and see how far you get). Your most likely scenario is going to be a simulation that optimizes the preferences of the person seeing it up. This is a problem and we haven't even come to the part about knowing how goals and actions interact with each other. This would literally win you a Nobel prize and change the world.
- dbg31415 10y ago> America Needs Small Apartment Buildings. Nobody Builds Them Nobody builds them, because people don't want to live in them. I lived in a "small" apartment building with like 8 units in New Orleans, and also in Seattle. They tend to be older, quaint, and rife with issues... heaters that don't distribute heat evenly, no amenities like a "full-size" apartment complex would offer (gym, pool, covered parking, in-unit washer / dryer hookups, proper cooking ventilation, someone to sign for package delivery, etc.), and not nearly enough sound insulation. Granted these things could probably be slightly improved with new buildings... but for a housing developer... why go through all the hassle of getting a lot zoned for multi-family if it's "cheaper for renters" (meaning probably less profit margin). Having lived in small apartments and big apartments, and having my own house now... man, I love having a yard and space and not worrying about a line when I go to do laundry. But if I had to go back to apartment life, I'd want one of the big, resort-style complexes that felt like a college campus.
- bbarn 10y agoI'm the opposite. Have lived in high rises, small buildings, medium buildings, rented houses... the 6-9 size is the sweet spot for city living. Intimate enough where things like bringing in packages, giving a neighbor a spare key, etc still happen, but not so much that everyone is up in your business all the time.
- dbg31415 10y agoIt's about economies of scale. If you're in a 6-9 unit building... you can't employ a full-time handyman for maintenance... you're stuck using whatever contractor comes in lowest bid. That won't lead to quality in the long run. But if you have a few hundred units, you can have a maintenance staff that cares about the property (or at least their jobs)... and that keeps everything nice. My mom own a few 4-12 unit apartments in CA. She bought them in the 90s, and charges what seems like a fortune in rent -- but after taxes, and maintenance, and all the various costs involved... she pretty much just breaks even. Her plan is to sell the buildings when she retires... and that'll be a nice windfall when that day comes. Until then... as much as I hate to say it about my own mother, she's basically a slum lord. She does only the bare minimum to fix anything when it breaks, and drags her feet for tenants who complain too much in hopes they just move out. She has to manage the properties herself... deal with tenants who are late on rent, deal with all the hassles because if she hires someone it puts her into the red. We've had long discussions about it... the profit isn't there to justify spending more. She'll do the basics... whatever is legally required of her... past that she has no incentive to spend money on the properties. Anyway I know there can be nice small multifamily structures, but in many places I think the landlords hit the scale issue. They don't make enough off the properties to hire better property management, or keep things as nice as the apartments that have hundreds of units. Maybe a brand new 6-9 unit building would be OK, but one that's 30-50 years old... it's going to have a lot of issues or sky-high rent -- or both.
- Svexark 10y agoI thought it was obvious. We're still living in a housing bubble and the people who would otherwise live in buildings such as these are in homes they're struggling to pay for. There's no market for them until the inevitable correction.
- elihu 10y agoI kind of wish apartment buildings in the country, just outside of town were a thing. I don't love living in an apartment, but to live in one surrounded by a couple acres of lawn/trees/whatever and maybe some actual fields seems like it would be a lot nicer. (My current apartment happens to overlook a field in the middle of a city. It's great when they plant clover in the spring and the whole thing is bright red for a couple of weeks.)
- jitix 10y agoIsn't that what suburbs are? I live in a suburb and while the apartment buildings are pretty big (but 3 story) they overlook lush greenery.
- gedy 10y agoWouldn't separated, mini houses be better in that case?
- noja 10y agoHow would separate houses be better? More to maintain.
- lostlogin 10y agoI'd take more maintanence for simple lines of ownership any day. A line in the ground with everything on one side being mine. As far as I can tell, appartment body corps can be a political nightmare and contractors charge a lot for work. Is this because New Zealand hasn't got a long history of apartments or is it difficult everywhere?
- noja 10y agoEven when you're sixty years old?
- daurnimator 10y ago
- wapz 10y agoI've lived in all sorts of tiny apartments in Japan and think they are very useful but only for very specific groups of people (students and single people). The great thing about them is you can rent extremely cheap (I paid $450/month in a guest house where it was only the room and shared bathroom/kitchen/laundry etc). For a tiny 2 bedroom apartment I rented for $600/month but far away from the station. These are great for students and single people because you can meet others, it's very safe (generally), and very affordable. I don't know the new apartments going up in SF but if they made them extremely small units I'm sure they could fit a lot of people and be very reasonably priced (relatively).
- sundvor 10y agoCome to Melbourne, Australia. Tiny apartments is all you'll ever find, and we're building them in great supply. I'm sure it'll work out splendid.
- geff82 10y agoLooking at this discussion, I have to say that everyone seems to want what he can't get easily. Looking at the extensive single house areas in the suburbs of the big US cities, I have a voice in my head saying "I want exactly that". Living like this costs only a fraction of housing in a similar size like here in the Frankfurt area of Germany where most ground now is small and freaking expensive. Even better earning people here essentially can now only affort living in apartments.
- mtberatwork 10y agoLand is expensive in the US as well depending on where you live. However, building construction techniques are different in the US, which brings down costs tremendously. In the US, newer residential homes are mostly wooden, "stick built" (even apartments!) buildings which go up in the matter of a few months. Bricks are even used as siding facades instead of structural support. In Germany, buildings are constructed with a limestone/sand/brick masonry mixture, take much longer to construct and of course are higher in costs. But homes in the US aren't as resilient and are often torn down and rebuilt, whereas in Germany, homes are built for the long-term and passed down between generations.
- geff82 10y agoYes, sure, construction is in general a bit more solid over here. But with pre-constructed houses, you can also get wood-based buildings starting around 150k (price to build). So here you get the quality, but the financial burden to buy one of these highly engineered houses makes it more difficult to own one when you are young. Sure in the US, there are areas where housing is extremely expensive. But when I look at metropolitan Dallas for example, where the economy is quite good, I can get deals for great looking homes for about 250k including large enough ground. A similar home in a similar economic area here, just comparing ground and building size (not quality) would cost me 500-800k in Germany. So maybe many US homes are not for life, but you can start one in them.
- andy_ppp 10y agoRemember when we were promised better things every year? In 1950 we were told by now we'd hardly have to work, have lots of leisure time etc., but at least we all got a 3 bed house near a nuclear power plant. Now we get fewer crumbs off the top table than ever. We could just build more, better buildings; enough to make the price go down. There is no incentive for property developers to do this of course.
- bluGill 10y agoLook at how people in the 1950s lived: do you really want that. They had ONE black and white 13 inch TV - 19 inch color TVs existed but only the rich could afford them. They lived in smaller houses than we live in today, and the furnishing where more utilitarian. They had one car (odds are the women wasn't allowed to drive though this part of culture was changing), it didn't have AC, you might or might not be able to afford the optional heater and radio (it broke down often despite doing tuneups all the time). They had one phone - it was a party line so they could share some of the costs with their neighbors... Today we have a much higher standard of living. We have decided that the toys, space, and luxury is worth more than the time we have to work to pay for it. Is this the right choice? That is an interesting discussion: I can take either side of it. I know of a few people who have chosen to work less. They live a sparser life - generally working at WalMart or some such because the better paying jobs won't even give you the option of working less hours - this is a choice they made and they are happy with their life. It is well known that there is a spike in deaths just after people retire: most people don't actually know what to do with more leisure time, and their work hours also double as part of their social hours. As such for many people working for luxuries is the correct choice.
- andy_ppp 10y agoTechnology has provided benefits but the rich take an ever increasing slice of those improvements and that's deliberate to keep the proles working. Housing was arguably better built in the 50s (and earlier) than it is today and it was certainly bigger. Maybe we need to figure out a way to use technology to help the problem of high quality affordable homes.
- mauvehaus 10y agoI think part of the problem is that they they're neither fish nor fowl. They don't fit into what people conventionally think of as a "neighborhood" with single family homes (or at least buildings that were originally built as single family homes and later subdivided into one or two units), and they also don't necessarily fit into an area full of large apartment buildings for economic reasons (if it's economical to build a 20 story apartment building with 120 units, why would you put a 20 unit building on the same plot). We're watching the first part play out. At the end of our street, there's a garage that was built for a heating oil distribution company. Real estate prices are nuts (Boston area), and the heating oil company has either moved or gone under. The building owner is trying to redevelop it into a 4 story apartment (or condos, TBD) with 7 units. I went the the community meeting with my wife because she has domain expertise with the environmental side of such a redevelopment project. People are having a fit about the building. It's too tall, it'll change the character of the neighborhood. What if the neighbors throw RAGING PARTIES on the terraces? What if they leave their lights on and they shine in the windows of the immediate neighbors? Can you put plants on the edge of the terraces to mitigate that? What if the new neighbors don't trim the plants?! The color the developers are proposing is too ... I don't know, but people don't like it. The neighbors have been holding the developers feet to the fire over what amounts to 1) bikeshedding, and 2) what if we get bad neighbors? How much is it costing the developer to hold people's hands over these things? The only possible reason for doing this I can imagine is that there simply isn't a lot of unencumbered land waiting to be built upon, so infilling smaller buildings is the only way to go about developing unless you have the resources to develop something truly huge on a large ex-industrial parcel. Don't get me wrong, I'm sympathetic to the fact that bad neighbors exist, and we like the neighborhood in part because it is quiet. Still, real estate prices are insane, and building more housing is the only way it's going to get better. In the interests of full disclosure, we rent. Largely because we don't see staying here for more than another couple years (largely because we don't see a realistic way to become home-owners, so we're doing our part to perpetuate the property price problem). We're largely insulated from any property value concerns that people may have about the new building. Still we like the neighborhood, and we do our part to be neighborly to the many owner-occupants we live near. We're as invested in the neighborhood as anybody who doesn't own is likely to be, but we do think the development is wholly reasonable and a great reuse of what is a hulking, windowless brick building.
- lr4444lr 10y agoThe author may be assuming a conclusion: does America need small apartments because they are cheaper, or are they not built because people don't want them, and low demand keeps down the price? His economy of scale argument cuts both ways. Putting a few more units in a city does not appreciably increase the strain on infrastructure and density, but it does much more so in the suburbs where he seems to want them. "Failures" in urban planning are not necessarily shortsighted blunders that arose out of nothing waiting to be found by journalists.
- jhbadger 10y agoOne issue is that smaller apartment buildings just aren't going to have the amenities that make living in an apartment attractive. I live in a large apartment building which has a reception that receives packages while I'm at work, a well furnished gym, and a swimming pool. A tiny building with only a dozen apartments wouldn't have the economies of scale required for that.
- kortex 10y agoThere are a lot of these crappy 6-20 unit apartment complexes around me. They have all the downsides and none of the upsides of renting. They are usually the price of larger apartments but with none of the amenities. I'd far prefer a larger complex with a pool, gym, and reliable maintenance.
- TillE 10y agoLuxury apartments will always exist, no need to worry about that. But plenty of people don't really need those things, and certainly don't want to pay for them. 99.9% of apartment buildings in Germany do not remotely resemble anything in Manhattan, and it works extremely well.
- Arizhel 10y ago>But plenty of people don't really need those things, and certainly don't want to pay for them. Those things don't cost very much when they're shared by a couple hundred units. That's why non-luxury hotels can afford to have such amenities for rather cheap nightly prices. A gym, in particular, is dirt cheap: ~5 exercise machines at even $1k apiece (a high estimate) is still only $5k, which is roughly a month's pay for many people. Spread that one-time cost over 200 units and that's $25 per unit. You can probably expect those machines to last at least 5 years, so that's $5 per year per unit. Whoopee. Definitely not "luxury", unless you're used to 3rd-world living conditions.
- awjr 10y agoI'm beginning to look at the housing market in the UK, a bit like the diamond market. Where the market is effectively controlled by 1-2 companies that ensure the release of a controlled quantity into the market at any one time. Developers have a huge land bank upon which they could develop high density cheap accommodation using modern commercial property techniques however this would destroy their market. It's better to release 200k of 'stock' per year in the market to maintain high house prices. It helps that the government has pretty much stripped the ability of councils to build houses, and more importantly, the sale of council houses (right to buy). Bring in the fact none of these houses have a 'no second home' clause means they are bought up as buy to let facilitated by a change in banking regulation in 1996 that allowed buy to let mortgages. So yeah, we have a housing stock problem. Start thinking about it like the diamond business and the similarities are quite scary.
- chrisseaton 10y agoWhat do people such as yourself have against buy-to-let? It doesn't change the supply level (unless for some reason you need to buy and can't rent). I always thought buy-to-let seemed rather nice and progressive - a good way for ordinary people with a little spare money to invest and build up money for their retirement while their asset still benefits society by being maintained and housing someone. That seems like a great example of sensible British middle-class aspiration.
- djmobley 10y agoIn the typical UK buy-to-let model, the renter pays more than the landlord's mortgage in rent. The only thing separating a buy-to-let landlord and their tenants is mortgage availability (i.e. Existing wealth and income multiples)
- mafribe 10y agothe renter pays more than And why is this a problem? The landlord takes on administrative hassle, and -- more importantly -- risk, for example - Can't rent out the property. - Property needs to undergo repair. - Tenants don't pay rent, destroy the property. - Liquidity risk: property is not as easy to sell as many other goods, in case of emergency. All of the above happen with a certain probability and that needs to be priced in. The last one is rarely a problem but the others are major considerations. And I have not even mentioned transaction costs for buying/selling a property, not to mention taxation. For these reasons, property typically doesn't have a good ROI, vis-a-vis e.g. investing in shares. A lot of property investors are naive, and would be better off investing in a passive index fund. So in many cases tenants get a good deal. In my experience buy-to-let is lucrative primarily when - Landlord has multiple properties, Economies of scale kicks in. - Landlord has relevant skills (plumber, electrician, or ... tax expert, lawyer) so he can get some jobs that need to be done substantially below market price. - Is physically close to the property, so can visit/check easily. - Has unusually low cost of capital (lower than bank-based mortgages). Ideally more than one of those. only thing separating The landlord has already proven financial stability, while the tenant typically hasn't. Many tenants tend to be young, e.g. students who are by-and-large not yet ready to take on the major responsibility of buying and maintaining a house. My heuristic for when you are ready to buy a property: > 10 years in a stable job, enough savings to put up 1/3 of the price up-front. After-tax income high enough so the mortgage can easily be paid. Good timing for a mortgage when you pay it off a bit before you stop earning (i.e. before retirement). Given a 25 year payment schedule and retirement at 65, age 35-40 would be a great time to get a mortage. Plenty of countries do quite well with mostly-rent based system. German Chancellor Merkel rents, for example.
- a2tech 10y agoAs a homeowner in a similar neighborhood as the one described in the article, I wish passionately LESS people would turn their houses into apartment buildings. I hate to use the 'there goes the neighborhood' argument, but renters are ruining my neighborhood. They're loud and disrespectful of others property. The fierce competition in the renting market means steadily declining property maintenance (basically you can charge a small rent uptick for a very nicely maintained property and spend a bunch on maintenance, or spend the bare minimum on maintenance and only lose 5-10% of rental income-which is way more profitable than maintaining the property nicely). I'm currently warily watching some renovations going on at the property next to me-the minute it looks like they're splitting it up into apartments I'm going to have to put my property on the market. I can't live 20ft away from a carousel of characters.
- jimlawruk 10y agoFor those of you in the US interested in this topic, I suggest listening to podcast called The Kunstlercast. It really opened my eyes and altered my views on housing, land use, transportation, etc.
- greggman 10y agoMy first (and I suppose selfish thought) is "where will I ever get to use VR if I keep living in small apartments". My current apartment is about 50sq meters. Unless I removed my sofa and TV or slept in the living room and got rid of my bed there's no place to have room scale VR here. Similarly I've gotten to play Rockband at people's houses but there's no way I could play Rockband in an apartment. Certainly not above the 1st floor with the drums nor on any floor with the singing. Of course those are 1st world problems I suppose.
- leoedin 10y agoDid you read the article? It's not about building small (as in low floor area) apartments, but small apartment buildings. Apartment buildings which are 3-4 stories high, and provide the "missing middle" between high density apartments you find in the middle of cities and the single family homes that make up urban sprawl.
- Allower 10y ago>Small buildings are a good way to add density without compromising the character of quiet, single-family districts. madness
- pasbesoin 10y agoAmerica needs apartments and condos that have decent sound-proofing.