12 ms·
“Dig once” bill could bring fiber Internet to much of the US
- rayiner 10y agoThis is a great bill. It creates a slight public subsidy for broadband, but the total amount of subsidy is minimized by tying it to digging that's already going to be done. This should be extended to power line and water pipe construction. No reason you can't put in some dark fiber while you've got someone up there hanging new power line (which I imagine is way more expensive). Most importantly, it minimizes market distortion. Inatead of making it more expensive to deploy broadband (which is the ironic side effect of many broadband deployment policies), it makes it cheaper for competitors to enter the market.
- DiabloD3 10y agoMore importantly: we already did this. Remember when they overhauled the highway system in a lot of areas back in the late 80s and through the 90s? While they were digging, they dropped a lot of fiber. Almost all of the major routes we use today for teleco/internet routing were laid or substantially upgraded then. Almost all the dark fiber laid was laid then. The hilarious part? Most of the fiber laid could do at least 40gbit, thus the cost of upgrading a lot of the existing backbone could be as easy as just swapping the line cards on either side. IMO, we may not actually need more fiber (outside of last mile usage, which this bill is directed at), but just better use of existing fiber. If you're wasting fiber on anything less than 10 gigabit, please stop. It costs you next to nothing to upgrade compared to what it cost a decade ago: upgrading to equipment that can handle 10GBase-LR/ER/ZR or OC-192/STM-64 or better is worth every dime. Literally, if the US government passed a law stating, say, any fiber over 5 miles long must have a line rate of at least 10 gigabit, and heavily subsidize upgrading equipment that is simply too old to handle it, a lot of Internet speed WTFery would go away in rural and suburban areas. You'd be surprised how many LTE/4G cell phone towers, DOCSIS 3.x headends, or modern ADSL2+/VDSL2/possibly G.Fast DSLAMs do not have 10gbit or greater backbones. It's just absurd in 2017 that we're using stuff that is 90s era at best.
- rayiner 10y agoI think the idea is to get fiber into the last mile. Vast parts of the country are still under construction. New subdivisions are being built, and people are moving there from established northeastern/midwestern states. Requiring conduit to be put underground as you build the roads for a new subdivision, for example, would dramatically reduce the costs to deploy fiber in these places.
- mi100hael 10y agoThis would only apply to projects receiving federal funding, which I don't imagine includes most subdivisions. Most likely just interstates, state highways, and maybe county highways. That wouldn't necessarily get fiber through your front door, but it should get it far enough out to provide a viable high speed option for rural households that are currently stuck with dial up or satellite.
- AnthonyMouse 10y agoThere is no reason we couldn't or shouldn't also do the same thing at the state level.
- ec109685 10y agoThey can make taking federal highway funds contingent on adopting a dig once policy for locally funded projects. This is how the speed limit and drinking age was standardized across the country.
- jessaustin 10y agoIt will be an interesting change, for the federal government to use this power for good rather than evil.
- milesrout 10y agoI still find it astounding Americans can't drink until 21.
- 10y ago
- rhino369 10y agoAnd you can even create a deployment tax that pays for the tiny cost at a later date when the conduit is actually used.
- JoshTriplett 10y agoI agree entirely. If you're building a road or doing construction, why not put in conduits that allow installation or upgrades for years to come, rather than having to dig repeatedly? And if you have to re-dig an area because it doesn't have conduits, don't just bury a wire, install conduits. This is directly the job of local government: to build infrastructure. And this wouldn't force the use of any particular service; rather, it would make it possible for many services to exist.
- npratini 10y agoI'm definitely on the same page - that said, a big determining factor of success is the efficiency of the local gov in question. For example, dig once already exists in San Francisco (http://sfgov.org/dt/dig-once http://sfgov.org/dt/dig-once). I've had a conversation with someone who project manages fiber installation across the city, and he mentioned it takes many months for any dig to actually happen, because every potential stakeholder has to sign off before going forward. Again, am on the same page that dig once makes a lot of sense, but there are some practical roadblocks that could make it less desirable.
- zkms 10y agoThe "dig once" policy is a public subsidy for broadband in the same sense that a national roads network is a subsidy for FedEx or Amazon.com -- it indeed reduces the costs that operators need to pay to get into the market but there's a panoply of benefits to the public beyond those of a literal, "paying government money to broadband operators" subsidy.
- rayiner 10y agoInfrastructure, whether broadband or highways, has positive externalities that are hard for infrastructure builders to capture, so the free market under-invests in infrastructure. However, government investment in infrastructure also is distortionary and needs to be considered in every instance. For example, it's great that we can get products delivered overnight from Amazon. However, as you point out, that is effectively a public subsidy of Amazon's business model, and that has negative effects too. Subsidizing public road infrastructure makes shipping products across the country artificially cheaper compared to making and selling them locally. That essentially strips away an advantage local retailers and manufacturers would otherwise have against big, national companies like Amazon.
- zkms 10y ago> That essentially strips away an advantage local retailers and manufacturers would otherwise have against big, national companies like Amazon. Indeed -- my hope for "dig once" policies would be that they have an opposite effect on competition; namely, that national-scale incumbents (who can currently afford to throw a million dollars here or there to put in fibre of their own in a new region/market) can get effective competition from local ISPs (who don't have a comparable ability to throw cash around).
- jon-wood 10y agoIn the UK we've had laws requiring common access to telecoms infrastructure since at least the early 2000s, and its had exactly that effect. In almost any home you have a choice of a dozen or so providers, ranging from super cheap basic providers who'll give you a few megabits and a stingy data allowance right up to business specialists who can provide multiple redundant lines on different backbones with 4G backup, generally without any sort of installation being required because. We've also got a big cable provider who run their own lines and give pretty competitive pricing because of all the other options.
- saycheese 10y ago>> "It creates a slight public subsidy for broadband" Maybe it's me, but $3 billion is not a small amount of money: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13941757 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13941757
- jmcdiesel 10y ago$3B is pretty small on the large scale. Especially when you consider the cost of adding them later (while it may not be paid for up front by the government, costs of doing construction, like closures, do add to gov't costs)
- late2part 10y agoAccording to some sensationalist stories I've read, it's only ~10X what we're spending to protect/transport President Trump on his weekend vacations.
- indolering 10y agoWhat does this contribute to the conversation?
- late2part 10y agoSomeone said it's not a lot of money. Someone else said it was. I provided a relative reference. Not the most monumental - but my intention was to add perspective.
- Godel_unicode 10y agoContext. Reasoning about government budget-size numbers is difficult for most people.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- oh_sigh 10y agoIn normal human terms, yes, but 3B is only .08% of the federal budget. Also, there is some economic gain from this activity...paying construction workers to install it, and whatever the end users decide to do with it. Is that gain > 3B? I don't know.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- jdjebc82747 10y agoJust a fun fact, wholesale power lines are about $1mm/mile.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- dbg31415 10y agoI think this bill is a great idea. All of my hassles with AT&T and Google wouldn't have come up if this law existed when my neighborhood in Austin was being built. Time Warner installed cable when the homes were being built. Then about 10 years ago AT&T went through and installed their "fiber" (their words, not mine), and tore up everyone's lawn in the process. This last year Google came in... and just made an enormous mess[1]... but the good news is they did lay pipe that other services can run cables through. [1] I've commended on this recently in other posts -- Google isn't supervising the contractors they hire in Austin and the work is getting done shoddy... and Google hasn't been doing much of anything to remedy the situation. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13878909 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13878909 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13885886 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13885886 http://imgur.com/a/Al39Z http://imgur.com/a/Al39Z
- stronglikedan 10y ago> and tore up everyone's lawn in the process They just did this to mine and a few neighbors, even though they weren't supposed to. They had a Ditch Witch (DW) Directional Drill [0] that would tunnel under all the lawns, and only make a little hole every few houses. However, they didn't count on the coral rock, and the DW broke, so they had to bring in a bigger one which was going to take a week or two. Well, they weren't getting paid if they weren't working, so instead of waiting for the bigger DW, they started digging trenches through the lawns. They did this to about 5% of them, with mine being the last one before the new DW got there. They did resod, but it's all dying because they just threw the dirt back in without putting the soil back on top, and everyone's tree rings and other landscaping are ruined. All the neighbors are pissed. I had to explain to a lot of them what fiber even was. They still don't understand why I'm too excited to be pissed. [0] https://www.ditchwitch.com/directional-drills#content-304 https://www.ditchwitch.com/directional-drills#content-304
- zafka 10y agoWhere do you live? Miami area?
- 10y ago
- saycheese 10y agoPossible my numbers are wrong, but based on the "1% of the project cost" appears this will cost 3.5 billion dollars in total; $305 billion total cost [1] * 1% of total = three billion fifty million for "dig once" [1] "Congress passed the five-year, $305 billion “Fixing America’s Surface Transportation (FAST) Act” on Dec. 3, 2015, and President Obama signed the bill the next day."
- wongarsu 10y agoYour math checks out. Seems like a fairly cheap measure.
- eldavido 10y agoIsn't all the trouble we have due to last-mile shenanigans? Until we can address that problem, this seems a bit moot. Perhaps what we need is something like this, but at the state/local level.
- tomschlick 10y agoI believe the idea is that if you can reduce the costs to the major lines, it frees up more money to work on the last mile.
- ubernostrum 10y agoThat hasn't worked in the past. Why are we still trying it?
- jmcdiesel 10y agoThats why sidewalks are included... having conduit with all new sidewalks would definitely ease the last mile
- pc2g4d 10y agoDoes the federal government build many sidewalks?
- scott_karana 10y agoThey don't need to. Per the article: > [The bill] requires states to evaluate the need for broadband conduit any time they complete a highway construction project that gets federal funding
- jessaustin 10y agoIt always amazes and dismays me, how much construction goes on in which developers are not required to build sidewalks.
- stevehawk 10y ago
- hackuser 10y agoIt might work out fine, but we need to hear from the people who would carry the actual the burden under this proposal, such as those in the construction industry that will have to lay the conduit under 'Dig once', and those who currently make money from laying cable who will have their business taken away. We also need to hear from experts in that field about how much it will cost and how it is best done. As written it sounds like those IT projects devised by people who have no knowledge of the field, who imagine that their idea must be easy, who make and sign off on a plan, and only then get me involved. These are almost universally poorly conceived, unnecessarily expensive, and produce bad results. In fact, in those respects it reminds me of another great public networking idea, public, city-wide WLAN networks (and in that case too, many IT professionals drank the Kool-Aid without thinking through the details). Also, when we talk about how easy it is - it is always easy when someone else has to figure out how to implement it, do the work, and pay the bill.
- korethr 10y agoI don't think those who presently are contracted for the cable laying work will have their work taken away from them. If anything, I think this is likely to guarantee work for some time. Say a road construction company wins the bid and gets a contract to work on a section of federally-funded road. I think it is likely they would already have some of the work, equipment or supplies sub-contracted out to specialists. Does it make more sense for them to own the entire supply chain for making concrete, from mining and refining the minerals, to mixing, delivery and pouring? Or does it make more sense for them to sub-contact out to a number of suppliers who they can call and say "I need $foo cubic feet of concrete, with $bar properties, delivered to $baz location at $quux date/time,"? I think the latter is more likely as it gives them more flexibility. Owning and operating the equipment and infrastructure to manufacture concrete has overhead costs like anything else. Similarly, if laying fiber becomes a requirement of taking the contract to build the roads, I think those fiber-laying companies will find themselves subcontracted those projects.
- hackuser 10y agoThat sounds reasonable, but my point is that we all (or most of us, myself included) are ignorant and speculating, and so are the reporter, the article, and possibly everyone quoted in it. You wouldn't believe a story about the costs, feasibility, impact, etc. of an IT project if the reporter only talked to people in the construction industry and not to any IT professionals.
- nvahalik 10y agoBut who owns the infrastructure? Would the government own it? Would the municipalities? Is this just one way for the NSA to be able to tap into the major backbone now by mandating this type of stuff? Don't get me wrong, I'm all for it, but what are the downsides to this? Where is that explored?
- gist 10y ago> But who owns the infrastructure? Would the government own it? The conduit would presumably be owned and managed by the government. The fiber in it by the people who pulled it presumably the provider. But here is the thing. Conduit size is not infinite. If not large enough it could get filled. I can even see a case where a particular company may put in extra fiber just to prevent someone else from doing so (and then either not using or renting that fiber). The government is not particularly good at preventing this type of gaming and manipulation.
- zkms 10y ago> Is this just one way for the NSA to be able to tap into the major backbone now by mandating this type of stuff? I'm pretty sure NSA manages to get access to backbones just fine without the benefit of policies that try to expand the role of fibre in the last mile. NSA has ample access to backbone fibre, both at exchange points and undersea (they have submarines). This is an utter red herring.
- milesrout 10y agoCentral, national government should fund, own and control all infrastructure.
- phkahler 10y agoThere is a down side to this. It would use government money to create a new finite resource and there will be battles over it just like spectrum. From TFA: "Dig once requirements are often opposed by deep pocketed incumbent telephone and cable companies, who build their own infrastructure and would prefer that smaller competitors not have access to cheap and freely available conduit," I suspect the big incumbents would simply lease the space and throw their own fiber in there to monopolize this new federally funded conduit. Then some of the maintenance burden falls on the government. Such wonderful corporate welfare well see down the road!
- matt_wulfeck 10y agoI think the government here is taking a good approach by putting down at least empty pipes, which can be filled by anyone who wants to run fiber through them. This is a reasonable compromise in my opinion. Personally I'd rather they put the fiber in themselves and lease it out, while also giving others the ability to pull their own lines through the pipes.
- throwaway729 10y ago...which can be filled by AT&T, Verizon, and Comcast who use their lobbying firms, teams of lawyers, and war chests to destroy anyone else who wants to run fiber through them. FTFY.
- phkahler 10y ago>> which can be filled by anyone who wants to run fiber through them. No, there is only so much space in the pipe. It has a limited capacity so the next logical step is to charge for access. >> Personally I'd rather they put the fiber in themselves and lease it out... At that point why not just have the government be an ISP an route any and all packets that come their way? See, they're proposing to take care of the hard part - digging and laying the pipe - on behalf of companies. The biggest companies will have the least trouble filling those pipes with light pipes.
- 1_2__3 10y ago
- guelo 10y agoSeems nice but fedarally funded highway projects are not going to affect the last-mile problem at all.
- rdl 10y agoI'm surprised more large planned developments haven't planned for very high speed Internet. CondoInternet up in Seattle, WebPass in SF, and others do well for multi family large buildings, but if I were building out a housing subsidivision, fiber to each house brought back to a central point seems like a no brainer. I'm specifically moving to a place in WA which has its own fiber network in the neighborhood; hopefully will get involved with the advisory board. I'd love to experiment with 10G on a wave to my cabinet at the Westin. :)
- HillaryBriss 10y agothis makes so much sense they'll never do it
- maerF0x0 10y agoHonest question. Is there something better/faster than fibre that they should be laying instead? Seems like fiber is just enough to catch up, but we'd rather get ahead.
- smnscu 10y agoI would also like to know. Google gave me this: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/technology/2016/02/11/scientists-create-internet-cables-50000-times-faster-than-superf/ http://www.telegraph.co.uk/technology/2016/02/11/scientists-...
- tbihl 10y agoThe article you posted is light on details. But as I read it, the research was a multi-channel approach on normal fiber. So in that case, it would be a question of upgrading the equipment connected on either end (though you'd also probably need short hops between equipment to keep SNR high in such a scheme.)
- cookiecaper 10y agoIMO we need to concentrate on wireless delivery methods. We've learned by now that this process of digging up the ground is not remotely conducive to an accessible marketplace, not to mention mind-bogglingly slow, expensive, and disruptive.
- jdshaf 10y agoActually, a single fiber strand can support over 1 Terebit per second in real world applications and even more in a lab setting. Fiber-to-the-Home ISPs today can easily provide 1 and 10 Gigabit per second connections using low cost optics on either end of the fiber cables (and some do!). When you see fiber Internet offerings like Verizon FiOS that has speeds of 50-500 Megabits per second, you are seeing the result of a business decision (price discrimination), not a technological or economic hurdle.
- planteen 10y agoJust as another data point, CenturyLink in Denver offers gigabit to your home with fiber. Considering most people don't have 10g NICs at home, I think it is a pretty good offering.
- Animats 10y agoThis has already been done on many long-haul routes. Fiber to the home is tougher. You can lay a tube past all the houses, but connecting to it means putting in an access box, a tube to the house, and somewhere nearby, a concentrator.
- jandrese 10y agoMy grandmother's house got fiber this way in sleepy rural Minnesota. They were digging up and replacing all of the streets in town and laying fiber (including the runs to the home) as they went. It seemed really smart to me. I have to admit I was pretty surprised to go down into her basement for a jar of homemade pickles and seeing an ONT bolted to the wall. She doesn't even have a computer or cable TV, it was only providing POTS. It's going to be quite the perk for whomever moves in after she dies though.
- beezle 10y agoIt is a shame that this is just being discussed for use by fiber. If they are going to dig up the roads, you need to put in multiple types of conduit for use by telecom, electric, water, etc.
- JumpCrisscross 10y agoWho are the swing votes?