21 ms·
This reads as extremely bizarre. I mean, reading the fifth amendment makes it pretty clear - no one should be compelled to witness against oneself. However, it
by smsm42 10y ago
This reads as extremely bizarre. I mean, reading the fifth amendment makes it pretty clear - no one should be compelled to witness against oneself. However, it looks like the current executive and judicial are thinking "well, those Founders were just idiots for putting such an amendment in, clearly it'd be much easier to prosecute people if we could compel them to witness against themselves, so why don't we just ignore it and put people in jail indefinitely until they agree to witness against themselves?". Terrifying that it is so easy for them to completely ignore all constitutional protections.
- bobbington 10y agoThe supreme court is unelected, and are the supreme authority in this nation, above president and congress. the solution is simple - make the supreme court stand up to elections. America has had atrocious decisions from the supreme court. In Dred Scott, they said black people have no rights because they are black. In Roe v Wade, the abortion laws of 47 states were struck down by 5 oligarchs. No matter what you believe about black people or abortion, it isn't right that 5 unelected people should determine the fate of a nation, able to overrule every state and federal law with no consequences.
- hackuser 10y agoI don't see U.S. (or any) elected officials, including Congress and the White House, making better decisions. All have made atrocious decisions. The argument in the parent is well-worn, but it fails serious consideration if it ignores the facts that the U.S. courts interpret laws made by the elected officials, that the judges are appointed by elected officials, that their unelected status is established by elected officials and a national referendum (i.e., the votes that established the Constitution), and the reasons for their unelected status.
- bobbington 10y agoPower corrupts. Unelected officials in office for life are at particular risk. i still think the people should be supreme. Right now, there is no legal way for the people to fight an outrageous decision. They can't elect somebody new in 4 years. Thomas Jefferson was adamantly opposed to said judiciary, because it made the constitution a "thing of wax" The whole reason behind federalism was that states would have different ideas of what is good and should implement that. that way you could get away from states with bad laws. Today the Supreme Court and other judges completely ignores the constitution. If they say the sky is green, nobody can correct them save Death itself.
- downrightmike 10y agoChecks and balances
- RangerScience 10y agoYes! Diversity. All systems have failure modes (current fav: utility monsters). By combining multiple systems, you limit the severity of a failure of any one system. All participating systems must be in a failure mode for the overall systems to be in a failure mode. If the Supreme Court were elected, it would suffer from basically the same failure modes as other elected offices, and would be able to provide a systemic durability against those failure modes.
- Steko 10y agoIf 47 states still wanted abortion to be illegal, they could certainly have made a constitutional amendment through their elected representatives in Congress and state legislatures. The fact is the restrictions were quickly eroding at the time of Roe and 20 states had already passed laws making specific exceptions including 3 where it was legal.
- bobbington 10y agoYeah but in Dredd Scott the Supreme Court did a massive backpedal on blacks rights, overturning state law that favored them. The question is the same. Back then they argued Over whether a black person is a person. Today they argue over whether a foetus is a person. My question is why should 5 unelected people decide the answer for a nation? I say let states decide for themselves. The reason is people feel very strongly about their opinions, and I think forcing your opinion of what is right on many people is a bad place to be.
- lazyasciiart 10y agoYes, letting the American people elect Donald Trump to the Supreme Court would obviously improve their decisions.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- michaelmrose 10y agoThe supreme courts and indeed the judicial branches role is spelled out in the constitution they aren't given unlimited discretion to rule by fiat they are given the power within the boundaries written into law by the legislative and enacted by the executive to interpret the law. Don't like their interpretation? The other branches have the power to change the underlying law. Your statement is the sour grapes of those whose wishes are too unpopular to become the law of the land.
- int_19h 10y agoI agree that the sheer power and reach of SCOTUS today, and increased partisanship in practice (even though everyone pretends it's a non-partisan body), does necessitate some reform. But electing judges makes no sense - you might as well then just give the fullness of power to Congress, a la UK's parliamentary sovereignty. What I think we should do is revisit what exactly SCOTUS does, and why. Right now they basically have the final say in any question of constitutionality, and the outcomes are either "it's constitutional" or "it's unconstitutional". I think that's wrong - the third possible outcome should be "Constitution is ambiguous on this". Currently this gets folded into one of the other options, depending on the majority of the court, but I think it's a poor model - if Constitution really is ambiguous, I don't want a simple majority of a few unelected people, many of whom are quite partisan, to make that decision. Instead, I think this option (ambiguity) should be explicit. The way it would work is something like this - if the court decision is unanimous (or maybe with at most one dissenter) one way or the other, then it's assumed that the Constitution is really unambiguous on the subject, and that's the ruling - same as now. But if you get a bigger split, then the ruling is automatically "ambiguous". At that point all the disagreeing parties on the court should have to sit down and write a short opinion on what changes to the Constitution they would require to make the other side's opinion unambiguously correct (if there are more than two sides - which can be the case if different judges rule the same way for different and unrelated reasons - then such opinions should be written for all parties other than the one in question). Then, those opinions are automatically submitted as proposed constitutional amendments to the states for ratification, per usual procedure, except that each state can only ratify one at a time, and there's a reasonable time limit. If one of the amendments wins, then (since all judges have already stated under oath that this is what is required to remove any ambiguity) the ruling is in favor of the corresponding opinion. If none of the amendments get the requisite majority of state ratifications, then court decides based on simple majority, just like today - but the resulting decision is not considered binding precedent, and only applies to that one case. If the same ambiguity arises in future cases, the process has to be repeated. Ideally, this should be combined with a lower bar for constitutional amendments - 3/4 of states is really quite ridiculous, given the sheer number of them, and population differences. Something like 2/3 would be more sensible. Although ideally it should incorporate direct popular vote in a referendum as well, in a series of cascading vetoes to check each other - e.g. 2/3 of popular vote is enough to amend, but a simple majority of states can veto that, but 3/4 of popular vote can override the veto.
- umanwizard 10y agoDemocracy isn't an end in itself. The Supreme Court has consistently made better decisions than the democratically elected branches of government.
- paulddraper 10y agoIt's not as black and white as you make it. If there is a warrant to search my property, I am obligated to assist if required. E.g. open the gun safe. (Hey, speaking of guns...You know what other antedquated amendment from the Founding Fathers would be really convenient to ignore...) Now, AFAIK, no one has tested whether that still hold true of a combination safe, where the access substaintivly requires information from the accused. And a combination safe is very similar to an encrypted drive.
- naasking 10y ago> If there is a warrant to search my property, I am obligated to assist if required. I'm not sure that's true, the police are authorized to break whatever they need to if you don't assist. As for combo safes, this seems like a good overview: http://blogs.denverpost.com/crime/2012/01/05/why-criminals-should-always-use-combination-safes/3343/ http://blogs.denverpost.com/crime/2012/01/05/why-criminals-s...
- paulddraper 10y agoYes, they can proceed without your assistance. Also, they can charge you with obstruction with justice.
- Chris2048 10y agoWhat's the penalty that goes with such a charge?
- paulddraper 10y agoIDK, but you can't keep breaking the law, and have penalties stop. So it won't be one-and-done.
- Chris2048 10y agoYeah, but in this case you have to weigh it against the penalty for being proven guilty. Maybe indefinite detention, and a chance at public attention is better than life in prison as a convicted child molester.
- eridius 10y agoThe argument made in the article is that it's a "foregone conclusion" that there's child porn on the drives, so decrypting them isn't self-incriminating because they already know what's on the drive. That said, personally I don't buy it. What if there's evidence of other illegal acts on the drive too, ones the police don't know about? Then decrypting the drive would definitely be incriminating because it would tell police about the other illegal stuff, stuff which fails the "foregone conclusion" test.
- shard972 10y ago> The argument made in the article is that it's a "foregone conclusion" that there's child porn on the drives, so decrypting them isn't self-incriminating because they already know what's on the drive. The immediate thought that comes to my head when they say this is: Then whats the problem? You can prove it, so why do you need more proof? Unless your possibly maybe your case isn't rock solid or you want to find more crimes.
- rayiner 10y agoIt's not bizarre at all. "To be a witness against himself" is not metaphorical or ye olde English. It literally means what it says--the government can't force someone to testify against himself (i.e. to provide a confession). If the Founders had meant to say that the government can't compel someone to cooperate in an investigation at all, they would have said that.
- fjdlwlv 10y agoThe Constitution is extremely abbreviated because it was written by hand. Your arbitrary definition of "witness" isn't more or less correct then someome else's; these terms are negotiated over the centuries with a great deal of context. The Fifth Amendment has been consistently interpreted to mean far more than "confession"
- pvg 10y agoThe Constitution is extremely abbreviated because it was written by hand. ?!
- throwaway91111 10y agoAhh yes, they spell out their interpretation clearly in the companion manual to the constitution.
- rtpg 10y agoI think it's about the meaning of words when the text was written. "To bear arms" doesn't mean to have human arms, after all
- rayiner 10y agoThe companion manual is called a dictionary. The word "witness" means someone who provides testimony based on personal knowledge. If the framers had meant to say "provide evidence" instead of "be a witness" they would have said that. They were lawyers and those words were commonly used legal terms that meant the same things they do today.
- deleted 10y ago
- jaredklewis 10y agoYour interpretation of the 5th amendment is quite different than it has been historically interpreted by the courts. For example, in a trial, the prosecutor might subpoena some documents and you cannot refuse to turn over those documents, unless doing so would trigger a 5th amendment assertion. Turning over the documents implicitly testifies to at least two important pieces of information: that the documents exist and that you know about the documents. So if you're asked for the documents and the prosecution has no evidence that the documents exist or that you know about them, the 5th will cover you. However if during a police interrogation you admit that the documents exist, when they are subpoenaed, you can't withhold evidence. I imagine that the 5th will work much the same with passwords. If it is known that you have the ability to unlock the device, refusing to do so will be withholding evidence. However if revealing the password implicitly reveals the hitherto unknown information that you know the password, 5th will work.
- Sir_Substance 10y agoSo here's my concern: guy's now been in jail without charge for 18 months. The prosecutors say his guilt is a foregone conclusion, but apparently it's not foregone enough that they're willing to go ahead and prosecute without the contents of his hard drive. They're gonna hold off until they get what they need. We're starting to get to the edge of the point where this guy might legitimately forget his password. I think we can assume the FBI has been running a common passwords/dictionary attack with common password symbol substitutions for the last 18 months, and apparently they haven't found the answer, so this password is probably a pretty good one that's not based on a word or even a sentence. If he stays in jail without trial for another two years and then says "I can't remember my password any more", what should we do?
- dublinclontarf 10y ago> what should we do? Release him and pay millions in compensation for violating his writ of Habeas corpus.
- umanwizard 10y ago
- Esau 10y ago"no one should be compelled to witness against oneself" More specifically, no one should be compelled to assist the government in one's own prosecution.
- rayiner 10y agoThe text of the fifth amendment says no one should be compelled "to be a witness against himself." It prohibits one specific way in which someone might be compelled to assist in one's own prosecution.