11 ms·
Always Free Usage Limits
- ploggingdev 10y agoSince it's not mentioned in the linked page, it's worth mentioning that the free trial in GCP is now $300 for 12 months [1]. Previously it was $300 for 60 days. IMO this is a major change since GCP is much better positioned to attract developers just getting started who used to gravitate towards the AWS free trial mainly because of the longer trial period of 12 months. The new non expiring free tier in GCP (aka Always Free Usage Limits) also offers a f1-micro instance while AWS does not offer a VM as part of their non expiring free tier. [1] https://cloud.google.com/free/docs/frequently-asked-questions#free-trial https://cloud.google.com/free/docs/frequently-asked-question...
- unwind 10y agoPerhaps worth pointing out that the $300 you're referring to is the amount of credit you're given when doing the free trial. As in, you can spend $300 worth of computing resources over 12 months, for free. I totally failed to understand that (I'm not very cloudy) and had to go to their sign-up page to figure out what was up.
- JorgeGT 10y ago> The new non expiring free tier in GCP (aka Always Free Usage Limits) also offers a f1-micro instance However in order to do this you have to enable billing, unlike with the free tier of App Engine. I'm always wary of these things because I fear I'll screw up and run into a huge bill somehow. I currently have a pre-paid 1€/month VPS with $european_competitor to prevent this.
- ktta 10y ago1€/month?! What kind of performance are you getting? Is it usage for a web server? Would you mind sharing the VPS provider?
- JorgeGT 10y agoI would say the performance is quite good for the price, I use it as a web dashboard/alerting server with InfluxDB+Grafana and it is quite snappy when browsing the graphs and so on. No problem sharing the provider, ArubaCloud, I just didn't want to sound like an advert.
- eriknstr 10y agohttps://www.arubacloud.com/vps/configurator-virtual-private-server.aspx https://www.arubacloud.com/vps/configurator-virtual-private-... Well, well, well, turns out they offer FreeBSD 10. If it upgrades nicely to FreeBSD 11 then I think they've earned themselves a customer and Vultr will have lost one customer due to Vultr no longer giving best bang for the buck. Moving to ArubaCloud would give me 1GB RAM + 20GB SSD instead of the 768MB RAM + 15GB SSD my current Vultr VPS has, and it'd do so at a lower price. Meanwhile it seems also that the VPS configuration I have at Vultr for 5 USD per month is no longer available for new VPSes, instead Vultr now has 512MB RAM + 20GB SSD for 2.50 USD (which is about 2.35 EUR) per month and 1GB RAM + 25GB SSD for 5 USD (about 4.71 EUR) per month. And how much is ArubaCloud charging for 1GB RAM + 20GB SSD? 1 EUR per month, it says! But the ArubaCloud prices are excluding VAT, it says. Does that mean they will bill me, who lives in Norway, slightly more than 1 EUR per month? Either way it'll be cheaper than Vultr.
- JorgeGT 10y ago> But the ArubaCloud prices are excluding VAT, it says. Does that mean they will bill me, who lives in Norway, slightly more than 1 EUR per month? Yes, I pay 1.21€ because general VAT is 21% in Spain. In any case it is almost inexpensive and so far the service is good. Virtualization is through VMware, you can script daily images, etc.
- sterex 10y agoWow. That's pretty good. But how viable is it for them?
- 10y ago
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- popcorncolonel 10y agoHell yes. When I AWS trial expires you know I'm switching to this always free model.
- markdog12 10y agoWhat if you already did the free trial and spent, say, $10? Do you now get $290 for 10 months?
- ben1040 10y agoI'm wondering this myself. I signed up about a year ago. However I only used about three bucks and change over the 90 days because I was looking at using it for a side project and never had time to get far. Can I get the remaining $296.xx for 9 more months?
- yebyen 10y agoIf your trial is not over as of the date of this announcement, you get 12 months from your trial start date (mine started less than a month ago, and it now says 352 days remaining). If it was over and you only spent $3.50, and you don't seem to have the Free Trial flex banner message bar at the top of the page anymore, that's a bummer. I'd recommend to see if there's any way for you to contact support and ask them to restart your free trial, while this announcement is still fresh.
- rdslw 10y agoWelcome to the USA, where marketing lies are everywhere and product owner writing quoted below sentences does not find anything wrong with it. Quoting the page: "Always Free Usage Limits. Included products and usage limits are subject to change." Why they don't write a truth: "Current Free Usage Limits, which are subject to change." ? This used to be fine print (which is still wrong). These days I call it bullshit print.
- dewey 10y agoThat doesn't seem to be US specific...
- adventured 10y agoIt's not, the parent could have made the same point without focusing it on the US at all. It's a rather mediocre and cheap excuse to bash the US. You can use the US for nearly any topic of punching, due to its size culturally and economically, its superpower status, omnipresence, etc. and people will overwhelmingly look the other way and or join in (any excuse to get that outrage hit).
- jpttsn 10y agoAn interesting twist in the evolving hivemind. Westerners generations ago assumed the rest of the world were savage. Today's westerners assume that they are the savages, and that the rest of the world is enlightened, free from self-interest, kumbaya all the way. Lest we learn about the wider world, I guess.
- wingerlang 10y ago> Today's westerners assume that they are the savages, and that the rest of the world is enlightened, free from self-interest, kumbaya all the way. That's a very broad statement which I think is not even remotely true.
- jpttsn 10y agoI agree. It relied on context. Mea culpa.
- homero 10y agoThat's cool, I can get .2 cores free. No one else offers this. Do we get an ip? That can be expensive for Google.
- whyagaindavid 10y agoSerious question. What can I do with 0.2 cores? I wonder if I can run a bootstrap static website. Any suggestions. Thanks
- regecks 10y ago.2 cores is plenty. A static website (properly served) wont't even register on CPU until you are doing traffic >100mbit. A CRUD app in language that doesn't smash the CPU (i.e. closer to Go net/http than WordPress) would probably perform adequately as well.
- petters 10y agoI just spun up a f1-micro instance. It got a public IPv4 and I was able to reserve a static IP. I did not see that IPv4s would cost extra.
- homero 10y agoSame I even made it static, their ephermal changes instantly. I love my little .2 core vm!! I don't know how they're going to give out 100k ips tho
- homero 10y agoNo cloud sql?
- manigandham 10y agoCloud SQL runs on Google Compute Engine nodes so it would be too high for the limits (considering they only offer an f1-micro in this tier).
- sapphire_tomb 10y agoFor some probably very good reasons I can't figure out - you can't sign up for the free trial as an individual from the UK - only as a business. So I guess I won't be trying this.
- Symbiote 10y agoGoogle doesn't charge VAT, they expect the customer to account for it. Only businesses are allowed to pay VAT in this way. I signed up pretending to be a business, but I assume the VAT on the $3/mth I spend isn't worth anyone's time to account for. £0.20/year? See https://www.reddit.com/r/UKPersonalFinance/comments/4g50uu/tax_google_cloud_vat_reporting/ https://www.reddit.com/r/UKPersonalFinance/comments/4g50uu/t...
- sapphire_tomb 10y agoThanks for the link - that's a useful read. So I signed up as indicated - but perhaps this free tier thing doesn't really work for accounts outside the USA either - as when trying to fire up an f1.micro instance it still says it's going to charge me (albeit out of the $300 free credit), so maybe I misunderstood something about the article.
- 7ewis 10y agoDoes everything work as expected? Might sign up as business too.
- thesoonerdev 10y agoBy far, the most common complaints I have heard when researching about GCP online are the following: 1) You cannot use SQL in the same way other platforms allow you 2) Only a subset of language features are supported for Java and Python and it is a little hard to know when you will run into that issue 3) As a combination of 1 and 2, it is not easy to migrate out of GCP and this makes it a kind of vendor lock in. While many people seem to agree that the platform itself works very well, if you are developing on GCP, free credits or not, doesn't this mean you are knowingly getting into a platform that will be hard to leave? Can someone who has worked with GCP address if these concerns are still ongoing? Also, are there some positives which are not easy to see from the outside which might have helped you choose them/stick with them?
- homero 10y agoThat's for cloud platform, cloud compute gives you a real vm.
- marksomnian 10y ago> That's for cloud platform You mean App Engine?
- thesoonerdev 10y agoSo these limitations are only in Google App Engine? Is there a reason people choose to use the App Engine then?
- paragraft 10y agoThose limitations apply to the old model of App Engine they call the Standard Environment, which abstracted much more over the underlying resources (you didn't have to think about what VMs you were using). At some point they realised that maintaining their own parallel forks of the runtimes was a loser's game and now gently push you toward the "Flexible Environment", which maps more transparently onto GCE (their equivalent to EC2) instances (which is better for them since you're billed much more directly according to your resource use), and has much more up to date runtimes, and you can supply your own docker image if none of them fit. The only people I know of who actively use the Standard Env anymore for new projects are trying to have a hobby project run for free in the free tier.
- WaxProlix 10y agoHas GCP found a way to integrate with Google Domains yet? I had to transfer a domain that I'd bought on GD to Route53 because I couldn't figure out how to get redirects with domain masking. Super frustrating, whereas the AWS equivalent was just Route53 -> S3 bucket for my little static site. $.53/month, not bad.
- homero 10y agoThere's cloud dns
- Perceptes 10y agoTempting to run an Algo VPN on the free tier of GCE, but these days I'm trying to use Google products less rather than more.
- ubercow 10y agoI want to move some project I have running on AWS to Google Cloud Functions, but they currently only have a hack for triggering them on a schedule. From what I understand based on the docs, you have to run an AppEngine instance just for the cron functionality.
- planetjones 10y agoWhat's the deal with getting SSL on your custom domain name now? I moved away from app engine for small projects previously as I think they wanted $60 a month for this. I did look on the website but I couldn't find the information. I have to say on a mobile device the GCP pages are very poor IMO. Too big a font, too much spacing, intrusive sticky header and too many scrolling effects where content magically appears or disappears. And even worse - when I click the pricing calculator it doesn't fit on the iOS safari screen so it is unusable. It does feel that some CSS and JS wizard got given far too much free reign.
- micklinghoff 10y agoI set up SSL for my custom domain on App Engine with Let's Encrypt yesterday - once you know how to do it, it takes only 5 minutes, I followed this tutorial: https://realguess.net/2016/09/26/installing-let-s-encrypt-ssl-certificate-on-google-app-engine-using-certbot/ https://realguess.net/2016/09/26/installing-let-s-encrypt-ss...
- dudus 10y agoI don't remember the $60. I remember that at some point custom domains with SSL where tied to GSuite in some form. But it hasn't been the case in a long time. You can get your certificates anywhere you want and just upload them through the UI. I get mine from LetsEncrypt using a process somewhat automated similar to [1]. It is still a pain in the ass semi-manual job I have to do every few months but I get SSL for free. I hope they launch some better integration with LetsEncrypt in the future. [1]: http://blog.seafuj.com/lets-encrypt-on-google-app-engine http://blog.seafuj.com/lets-encrypt-on-google-app-engine
- chestnutpku 10y agotest
- djhworld 10y agoHas anyone from the UK/Europe been able to successfully sign up to GCP? I can't seem to select "Individual" when I sign up, it permanently selects "Business" and asks for a VAT number. I don't want to lie and get in trouble with the tax authorities or whatever. I only plan to use it for tinkering at home! AWS doesn't do this, why Google?
- hobozilla 10y agoIf it makes you feel better all this free stuff generally only applies to the US anyway. Go Google!
- dotdi 10y agoI signed up about a week ago from Germany and it worked fine. I didn't have to provide any VAT number, but they wanted my CC number, stating that they won't charge anything without my prior confirmation. Today I got an email saying that my free trial was extended to 12 months.
- djhworld 10y agoI'm presuming you already have plans in place to pay the VAT on any charges you accrue though, it doesn't look like Google do this. This is what worries me the most, plus Google stipulate that your usage of the cloud platform must be for economic benefit, not for personal use. AWS don't seem to have this restriction and they will collect and pay VAT on your behalf. Why doesn't Google? Is it some sort of tax dodge?
- tcwc 10y agoUsually a seller doesn't add VAT to B2B invoices into the EU, VAT is accounted for by the purchaser under the 'reverse charge' system. B2C is different, they would need to charge the local VAT rate in each member state. I suspect they simply haven't gotten around to supporting it yet.
- SeanDav 10y agoPerhaps go with AWS and not Google then - let the market speak.
- atkbro 10y agoMentioned in the thread that was on the front page yesterday: In European Union the only available account type is Business https://support.google.com/cloud/answer/6090602 https://support.google.com/cloud/answer/6090602 which means many users won't be able to take advantage of the offer ($300 trial or free tier usage). I guess I'll just have to keep using AWS/Azure/$competitorX :(
- modeless 10y agoWow, you can run an instance 24/7 for free, and there's no end to the free period? That seems pretty great! Like having a free always-on Raspberry Pi in the cloud.
- kyledrake 10y agoIs this the 3rd or 4th post about some random Google Cloud thing today? I'm losing track. No news here, just the usual business model of the "cloud": cheap in, expensive out. They rope you in with a fee tier then charge you 9-18x more for egress than you pay for it running your own hardware with IP transit (or going with a VPS provider like Vultr that charges you the correct prices for it). Have fun scaling your company economically, hope you don't need to send any data to your customers.
- qeternity 10y agoAh the classic anti-cloud post that pretends to understand everyone's use cases and economics. You realize that everyone knows how expensive this stuff is. You realize that people plan and model growth around these figures. You realize that despite all of this, many people still go with cloud solutions because they get other benefits. I mean ffs, I would be laughed out of the room if I went to my investors and said we were putting everything on Vultr. And fwiw, we're not cloud based for the exact reasons you mention (some spot usage). It makes sense for our business model, we have predictable computing growth needs, so we go bare metal. But I understand why that doesn't make sense for other people.
- kyledrake 10y ago> I would be laughed out of the room if I went to my investors and said we were putting everything on Vultr. For reasons better analyzed by anthropologists than technologists, but all I would really like is for HN to not be constantly bombarded with not-news GC marketing spam all day.
- webmaven 10y agoFeel free to upvote the stuff that you do find interesting, and encourage others to do the same.
- qeternity 10y agoFor reasons better analyzed by historians and statisticians. The historical statistics are that Vultr is far more likely to be a risk to the business than Google is. It's as simple as that.
- option_greek 10y agoTheir console is really slow. Go to any section (eg compute) and spinner will be your best friend for a long time. What the heck are they doing in there anyway. In comparison, AWS console loads much faster (anecdotal of course).
- joshgel 10y agoThis is great. Lets you run a full time server for free. Display a hobby website or a development site or whatever. Thats amazing! No one else offers this "always", right?
- nrki 10y agoNote that the Always Free offers includes only a small amount of egress traffic per month per service. e.g.: 1GB for GCE/GCS.
- aeosynth 10y agoHeroku does.
- darkstar999 10y ago> SLEEPS AFTER 30 MINS OF INACTIVITY Yeah, I don't think that really counts.
- aeosynth 10y agoYou can trivially bypass that with an infinite loop: while true; do sleep 1; done
- mark_l_watson 10y agoIBM Bluemix has a very generous free tier, enough to run a few web apps for free.
- yupyupp 10y agoFrom my quick glance it looks like Bluemix is only a 30 day trial though. :/
- mark_l_watson 10y agoBluemix has a permanent free tier.
- joeyspn 10y agoSo, the flexible GAE environment has finally a free starter quota?
- roryisok 10y agoHave these limits increased or decreased? What were they before?
- X-Istence 10y agoIt was a lot more limited before.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- alberth 10y agoOff topic: does google.com run on GCP? I ask because since 2010, Amazon.com has been running on AWS. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dxk8b9rSKOo&t=7m32s http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dxk8b9rSKOo&t=7m32s (Around 7m30s into video)
- packetslave 10y agoCloud runs on the exact same underlying compute, storage, and network infrastructure as search, gmail, and other Google services. The big google services are not built on top of cloud themselves (e.g. not inside GCE VMs) partially because they existed before cloud did. Some cloud services are also public versions of existing internal Google services (cloud spanner, cloud bigtable, etc) Source: work at google, but on search, not cloud.
- alberth 10y agoAre there plans for Google Services (search/gmail/etc) to move GCP anytime soon? I'm hesitate to use GCP, given that technically Google itself isn't using GCP (totally understanding that a lift and shift of this size takes times, but it would speak volumes if you can tout that Google itself is on GCP)
- Omnipresent 10y agoIn addition to making GCP cheaper and easier to try out than AWS, they need developer advocates and available resources using which developers can switch their apps from AWS to GCP. After being a leader in this space for a long time, the main advantage AWS has is the perception of "how easy it is to use"
- ionwake 10y agoJust remember guys when my startup hit the front page and I clicked on the pay to upgrade from free to paid the system automatically took the whole site offline for 24 hours. Make sure they changed / fixed this before trusting GAE If anyone could confirm this is still the case please say Edit - is GAE usage == GCP ? If not I will remove this comment immediately sorry
- hashkb 10y agoDear Google: add managed Postgres and I'm leaving AWS for you.
- bskap 10y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13831277 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13831277
- sscarduzio 10y agothere is, but not in free tier.https://cloud.google.com/solutions/set-up-postgres https://cloud.google.com/solutions/set-up-postgres
- hashkb 10y agoYeah I saw the other post. Time to put my money where my mouth is!!
- koolba 10y agoWait so does this last forever v.s. only the first year like AWS does? If so, does that mean I can have a personal server running in the cloud, for free, forever? There's a hell of a lot you can do with a tiny server these days.
- shthed 10y agoI thought it was strange that the free network egress excluded Australia. I can understand why they might charge more for China, but Australia? Then I found this article (written 3 years ago): https://blog.cloudflare.com/the-relative-cost-of-bandwidth-around-the-world/ https://blog.cloudflare.com/the-relative-cost-of-bandwidth-a... Bandwidth to Australia cost 20x that of EU or US because of Telstra :( Good news though, Google are planning a Compute Engine zone in Sydney this year :)
- Veratyr 10y agoI'm curious whether this'll change when the NBN is more prominent. Does anyone know what their peering policy is/will be? I had a look around but couldn't find anything.