9 ms·
What the death of the CRT display technology means for classic arcade machines
- crttvcomeback 10y agoDo not give up on CRT arcade monitors. There is still one manufacturer left in this world making new CRT TV's today in India. Do not give up hope. If we get together, we will find a way to rebuild or manufacturer new CRT Arcade Monitors in The United States or Imported to the United States. CRT technology is not dead. Find ways to learn how the CRT works and do simple Cathode Ray Tube experiments using a glassblower and other tools. If people do this, eventually, we can make custom CRT's one by one for video game and arcade collectors. Yes, this way might cost alot, but there will be collectors willing to pay that price. Another way is to make CRT rebuilding equipment to rebuild CRT arcade monitors. Early Television Foundation and museum will be rebuilding a 1950s B&W CRT TV Tube in May. Please don't give up on CRT displays. Have hope that New CRT displays will come.
- zellyn 10y agoI've been working on an existing Apple II emulator, OpenEmulator, which takes an interesting (and as far as I know, unique in the Apple II emulator world) approach: it renders a fairly raw NTSC-like signal, and then uses GPU shaders to convert to colors, while adding fairly realistic CRT effects, like persistence, curvature, dot masks, etc. The result is an emulation that is incredibly close to what I see when I walk downstairs and run my test code on the real Apple IIe in my basement. I guess that's what happens when a DSP person writes an emulator :-) (The original author has disappeared themselves from the internet, unfortunately.)
- zellyn 10y agoOh, one more note: I do not believe it would work with a light gun.
- eropple 10y agoDepending on the latencies and frame drawing speeds, a Zapper-type ("show a light on the screen, poll whether the gun sees it") might work, but probably not. A Super Scope-type (going off hblanks) definitely would not.
- braveo 10y agoIt's pretty common in the world of emulators, it's just that a lot of people don't care and choose not to use the plugins for it (I'm one of those people).
- XaspR8d 10y agoRelatedly, if anyone hasn't read it, Kyle Pittman has a lovely rundown of his attempts at emulating various CRT-effects digitally during development of the indie game Super Win the Game: http://www.gamasutra.com/blogs/KylePittman/20150420/241442/CRT_Simulation_in_Super_Win_the_Game.php http://www.gamasutra.com/blogs/KylePittman/20150420/241442/C... Of course, most people (Pittman included) felt that configuring the visually emulation too accurately was annoying and/or unbelievable. :P
- tlb 10y agoI made an attempt at this around 2001, as part of the XScreensaver collection. See video at https://youtu.be/p3QZqhp67l8?t=30s https://youtu.be/p3QZqhp67l8?t=30s. It generates an NTSC signal, adds noise, and recovers the H and V sync and color in a DSP implementation following the schematic of an old TV. It reproduces the color fringing of text and many other cherished artifacts of Apple ][ computing.
- zellyn 10y agoAwesome! I've actually seen people reference that as the most accurate emulation they'd ever seen. Perhaps we should add noise to the OpenEmulator one too! :-) [Edit] the bending, and shadowing to the right of the characters is amazing :-)
- Zardoz84 10y agoIt remember me a lot when I plugged my Spectrum +3 via composite video to my small TV when I was a child.
- to3m 10y agoThere's an Electron/VIC20/2600/Oric emulator that does this too: https://github.com/TomHarte/CLK https://github.com/TomHarte/CLK - looks authentically horrid and it's got that somewhat elusive 50Hz feel. (Not many 50Hz Electron games, though! Firetrack is one.)
- vermontdevil 10y agoIf anyone can fix and maintain classic arcade machines, it would be these people: Museum of Play - International Center for the History of Electronic Games http://www.museumofplay.org/about/icheg http://www.museumofplay.org/about/icheg If you are in the area, you should stop by. They have every cool toy possible from many many years back. Brought back many memories. Plus you can play many old arcade or pinball games!
- rmason 10y agoThey don't really say how large the market might be. Or if there are patents that would block a startup. I'd be willing to bet that you could find or train people in Detroit right now to build these CRT's. All you'd need are a couple of people to train them for a few months. They said the same thing about vinyl records, soon the industry would die. Detroit has become a hub for pressing records and as old machines become scarce they're now supporting a company making new machines. http://www.rollingstone.com/music/features/inside-jack-whites-new-vinyl-pressing-paradise-w468376 http://www.rollingstone.com/music/features/inside-jack-white...
- plorkyeran 10y agoI would guess that up until now the biggest thing preventing anyone from investing in small-scale CRT manufacturing is the simple fact that there was an inventory glut that covered the world demand for CRTs for nearly a decade after the last one was made. Now that we're apparently getting close to the point where there's actually demand for new CRTs is when we can find out if it's something that you can build a business around.
- jjeaff 10y agoBut is there really a small cohort of CRT nostalgics out there? I mean I get the records, the sound is unique and music is absolutely ubiquitous. Arcade gaming is a much smaller market and I find it hard to imagine that there are enough CRT purists out there to warrant a business. Especially considering a nice new OLED could be fashioned to look like a CRT.
- PhasmaFelis 10y agoAh, but it would be less "vibrant" and "nostalgic", according to the article.
- amagumori 10y agovinyl : digital audio as crt : lcd
- kibwen 10y ago> We’re looking at a situation where playing Donkey Kong in the way that its creator intended is reserved only for the most dedicated collector. It will be prohibitively expensive to recreate that experience. While this is a bit sad on some level, the art itself will survive the transition. After all, nobody these days experiences Romeo and Juliet in the way that its creator intended, yet it endures. What I'm more worried about are those games that are going to be completely lost once the hardware expires; we can preserve the game data itself all we like, but without proper emulators you're SOL (and unless CPU speeds start doubling again, we're never going to be able to even semi-accurately emulate anything past the Xbox 360/PS3 generation). To say nothing of online games that will vanish into the mist once the servers get taken offline...
- daurnimator 10y ago> unless CPU speeds start doubling again, we're never going to be able to even semi-accurately emulate anything past the Xbox 360/PS3 generation Luckily all the new consoles use x86_64 processors for their main processors, so no low level emulation will be required.
- WaxProlix 10y agoIs that true? The prospect of emulating a console on similar-gen PC hardware is super appetizing, but this is the first I've heard of the possibility.
- izacus 10y agoWhile the CPU is indeed x86-64, the architecture of the SoC and the device is rather different so emulation still won't be all that easy. This 33c3 talk gives a lot of fascinating information on how PS4 differs from your run-of-the-mill PC and what kind of issues they hit when trying to run Linux on it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QMiubC6LdTA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QMiubC6LdTA
- Sanddancer 10y agoYep. Both the PS4 and XBox One are using semi-custom AMD chips with 8-core CPUs and 1152 shader GPUs. So managably beefy.
- PhasmaFelis 10y ago> “It’s just not gonna feel as nostalgic,” Ware tells GamesBeat when we asked him about the problems with the modern display technology. “The pixels will be sharper on an LCD, but they may not be 100 percent accurate. Colors won’t be quite as vibrant.” The absolute loss of dead online games bothers me. I can't get too fussed about arcade games that are still 100% playable but with less nostalgic pixels.
- khedoros1 10y agoI've never cared for most online games, although it bugs me on an intellectual level that they'll stop working. CRTs are connected to my childhood and early adulthood, and I get warm nostalgic feelings seeing one still in use. If I had space at home, I'd have a 30" CRT sitting next to my main LCD TV, to connect my older game consoles to. They work on the LCD. Then again, so does emulation on a PC. Not quite the same.
- donatj 10y agoI have all my pre-HD systems (NES - Dreamcast) hooked to a round 32" CRT in my spare room the way I remember growing up.
- wimagguc 10y agoHave you guys seen Musee Mecanique in Fisherman's Wharf, San Francisco [1]? It's a collection of older-than-old slot machines and games, I want to say I've seen some 100 year old ones, but the point is: there's Heavyweight Champ' style boxing, there are all sorts of sport games, and even a mechanical road runner [2]. The gameplay is obviously changed with technology, but for some games the core idea survived some heavy decades of transitions. The originals would probably be less engaging for today's kids, so it's only fair to ship them a 3D/VR/mobile version, and keep our nostalgia from trying to sell mechanical road runner to all arcades. CRTs will phase out in favour of everything else, and that should be ok. [1] http://museemecaniquesf.com http://museemecaniquesf.com [2] https://www.facebook.com/museemecaniquesf/videos/vb.51627194717/10151480936271635/?type=2&theate https://www.facebook.com/museemecaniquesf/videos/vb.51627194...
- camperman 10y agoYes! I spent at happy morning there last time I was in the city. That old submarine is right outside the front door. There was some very cool old arcade games in there but some of the mechanical ones were incredible, like the baseball game.
- artmageddon 10y agoMy wife had never really been in a real arcade till she and I visited that very same one, and we were both blown away!
- drzaiusapelord 10y agoThis is my thinking as well. Hamfisted attempts to make LCD's look like CRT's by artificially curving the screen and messing with colors is just nostalgia. It doesn't add anything to game and 1980s designers were most likely pissed they had to deal with these limitations like color distortion, curvatures, ghosting, burn-in, etc. Pac-man isn't better on a shittier screen. Pac-man succeeds because it had novel game mechanics for 1982. Outside of lightguns not working this seems like a non-issue to me. I'm sure the emulation community can find a work-around for this for the few people actually using lightguns under emulation. >Have you guys seen Musee Mecanique I live in Chicago and have access to all sorts of barcades as well as one of the largest, if not largest, arcades in a nearby suburb, so I'm pretty well versed in the arcade experience today as well as from my childhood. I went to Musee a few years ago and was expecting an experience like that, but instead the game floor was mostly these near turn of the century mechanical games. I was fairly disappointed, from a gameplay or mechanical perspective they were kinda terrible and largely uninteresting. They had historic value but that's about it and probably better off in a proper museum and lovingly maintained than beaten up for quarters. I think in 20-30 years this is exactly how CRT's will be seen. Kids will marvel at how terrible their low resolutions, framerate, color accuracy, and ghosting are.
- 0xcde4c3db 10y ago> Additionally, Ware explained that the refresh rate on an LCD may not play well with an old game’s code that is expecting a much more responsive CRT monitor. It could cause unsightly screen tearing that looks like one half of the screen is occasionally redrawing before the other. Does this really happen with LCD arcade monitors? It happens with PC-based emulators because they usually can't make the OS/drivers/GPU/monitor switch to a refresh rate that matches the emulated hardware (which, despite the quoted "more responsive CRT" bit, is just as likely to be below 60 Hz as above it, and usually not by a large amount either way) but I don't see how CRT vs. LCD is a major factor if we're talking about monitors that are actually made for arcade machines.
- donatj 10y agoMany games knew exactly where the beam was and played tricks on your eye. These don't translate well to LCD.
- matthewwiese 10y agoBogost & Montfort's Racing the Beam (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Racing_the_Beam https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Racing_the_Beam) is about that very practice, though concerning the Atari 2600 in particular.
- mgkimsal 10y agoLoved that book! Loved all the behind-the-scenes stories and the deep-dive in to some of the tech issues (it was past my ability to comprehend it all, yet "not enough detail" for a friend of mine).
- 0xcde4c3db 10y agoAre there many that actually depend on syncing up to the physical refresh and not just fiddling with registers at the right point in signal/pixel space? The only thing I can think of is some old-school light gun games, which involve a physical sensor pointed at the screen and thus depend on sufficiently high brightness and sufficiently low input lag (and so almost always fail on LCDs).
- userbinator 10y agoI was under the impression that there are still a few small companies in China making CRTs --- a search of Alibaba shows a few sellers still advertising CRT TVs, but I'm not sure if those are NOS.
- dep_b 10y agoThe arcade CRT's are different from TV CRT's, the voltages are a lot higher (I heard 10.000 volt somewhere) and therefore quite dangerous to handle even. This is also the reason the colors were much brighter in the arcade then on your home system connected to your TV.
- c3833174 10y agoThe voltage is related to display size, a 17" monitor might run on 27kv while a 32" might run on 34kv, but at higher voltages more X-rays are emitted so most TVs have safety mechanisms to limit voltage. As for the safety I'd expect anybody servicing arcades to know what they're doing.
- kozak 10y agoAs a person who is more sensitive than average to sub-85Hz flicker of CRT and plasma screens, I'm happy to see these technologies dying.
- barrkel 10y agoI'm quite sensitive to sub-75Hz monitors - I could not stand 60Hz - but another side-effect of higher refresh rate is smoother desktop updates when scrolling or moving windows. I recently upgraded my second monitor on my home PC to a 144Hz gaming version. The smoothness and responsiveness of UI on that monitor side by side with the standard 60Hz is really remarkable, I'd forgotten how big a difference it makes. The PC physically feels much more pleasant to use. OTOH, my partner doesn't notice the difference at all.
- WWLink 10y agoI'm more sensitive to the really high pitched eeeeeeee that comes from CRTs and their flyback transformers.
- kozak 10y agoThat sensitivity goes away "automatically" with age.
- bentpins 10y agoAs someone who missed most of the classic arcade games on CRTs, I was blown away trying out Asteroids on a machine with a CRT Vector Monitor. Because the electron beam can focus longer in one spot, it could pull off ridiculously bright bullets. I don't think you could get the same effect on any modern display.
- ivix 10y agoIt's interesting how we have traded off some aspects of display quality in favour of overall unit size and practicality.
- ekianjo 10y agosame story for digital photos vs film. Film is still superior in several areas but not as convenient.
- rimantas 10y agoWhich areas is film superior to the modern sensors?
- datenwolf 10y ago- higher resolution (with fine grain sized stock) - higher dynamic range - gracefull saturation behavior and IMHO the absolute killer feature: - a "fresh" sensor for each and every frame captured (no worries about scratches in the optical lowpass coating, no hassle with dust on the sensor). Also absolutely no dependency on charged batteries if one uses a purely mechanical camera.
- mizaru 10y agoThe Sony A6300 offers 13.7 stops of dynamic range (according to DxOMark, so not entirely uncontroversial). The slightly more expensive Nikon D810 goes up to 14.8 stops. It's hard to find definitive numbers for film, though.
- Tepix 10y agoSo playing a classic arcade game will look different than it did back then. But if you think about it - if the screens we have today would have been available back then, what do you think would the game designers have preferred? Also, screens will continue to get better. Gaming on [an arcade machine with] a HDR OLED screen could be amazing.
- andai 10y agoYou're right, eventually modern display technology will catch up to the point where it indistinguishably simulate CRT screens :)
- autokad 10y agothe game designers would have obviously preferred CRT. they were designed for a specific usecase that todays screens don't handle well, and probably never will unless a completely new tech comes along. Also, if you have played games a lot on CRT, you will find HDR OLED not amazing at all. HDR OLED makes mistakes between were things are in memory vs the screen. so you think 'that thing didnt get me' and then it does even though it was pixel(s) away.
- Tepix 10y agoMistakes? You mean it introduces delays? Or something else?
- phkahler 10y ago>> But if you think about it - if the screens we have today would have been available back then, what do you think would the game designers have preferred? The best example of design-to-the-CRT by far is the original Star Wars. For starters it's a vector game - electron beam is deflected in lines to directly draw the objects. Vector monitors start with a very distinct look. Then they went further. For the enemy bullets (snowflakes or whatever you call them) they overdrive the electron gun which causes the tube voltage to drop, which in turn defocuses the beam and creates a wide-soft vector for those objects. And finally when you lose a shield (get hit) they draw a very much oversized square so far off screen that the electrons scatter off the back of the tube and flood the entire screen with a haze or fog as you take the hit. Oh, and the death star explosion also has a bit of a unique look as it involves more vectors than the hardware can quite keep up with. That game was designed for the medium and is the pinnacle of genera. There is no substitute.
- epx 10y agoDo audiophiles watch movies in "tube" (CRT) screens? :)
- laumars 10y agoWhat this article doesn't touch on but I have found an issue with classic consoles on non-CRT screens is: 1. Light guns Even on consoles as late as the Sega Saturn, the light guns were design around the timings of CRT refresh rates and thus many (albeit not all) LCD screen are not compatible. I would imagine this could be a real issue for collectors / restorers of cabinets as shooting games (eg Virtua Cop) were quite popular in arcades. 2. Early 3D systems as used on Sega Scope for the Sega Master System; and the Nintendo 3D System for the Famicom (Japanese NES) These devices are less common and as far as I'm aware only available on home consoles. For those of you who don't know what I'm talking about, it's active shutter glasses (ie disabled one eye at a time) and was timed around the interlacing on CRTs. At 50/60Hz (depending on your region) the effect can be a little unpleasant. But it's also pretty amazing to play when you consider the devices are approximately 30 years old.
- ChicagoBoy11 10y agoWRT to the light guns, I never quite really understood why you couldn't somehow simulate this with LCDs. Isn't the refresh rate on LCDs higher? So couldn't you work around that somehow? Obviously the answer is prob. not since no one (that I know of) has done it, but I was genuinely curious of what precisely the technical limitation is.
- pjc50 10y agoThe latency on LCDs is much much higher, often as much as several frames. This could be removed but only at the cost of disabling all manufacturer's image post-processing including upscaling. I have a "100Hz" CRT television that won't support light guns because the manufacturers decided they'd put this kind of image-"improving" technology in. There are actually two techniques for light gun operation, one of which is "racing the beam" (unreliable in the presence of high retention phosphor) and the other of which is to draw a single frame of white squares for targets. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NES_Zapper#Technical_details https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NES_Zapper#Technical_details
- chongli 10y agoLCDs cannot simulate this because their latency is too high. By the time the pattern is on the screen the lightgun has already recorded a miss.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- kristopolous 10y agoAll this is saying to me is hoard discarded CRT monitors in a storage locker for 3 years then sell them off for good money on ebay. Am I mistaken?
- cmrdporcupine 10y agoHave fun with the shipping costs on those...
- noxToken 10y agoPass the cost of shipping to the buyer. I resold games in high school. I wasn't savvy enough to write scripts to search for specific games and their prices. I manually combed sites (mostly eBay) to find people/stores that were selling games a few days/weeks before the actual release date. I'd order a few a copies, add a small markup, charge flat-rate shipping (would cover most distances), and be on my way. My point is that there's a market for these. The product I was selling wasn't scarce. My guess why people bought these games was that they were teens who couldn't get their parents to drive them an hour to the nearest store that carried games.
- kristopolous 10y agoI don't think it's reasonable either. The eBay market is strange: 1GB 50 pin scsi drives go for hundreds of dollars, 486 machines can go for $150 and ISA sound cards can be auctioned for hundreds of dollars (http://www.ebay.com/itm/Roland-SCC-1-ISA-Sound-Card-/162342001502?hash=item25cc565b5e:g:pPAAAOSwImRYaVqZ http://www.ebay.com/itm/Roland-SCC-1-ISA-Sound-Card-/1623420...). Don't get me wrong, this is a total waste of time - but the market is probably there for someone who wants it.
- gthtjtkt 10y agoYou can already see the rapid appreciation starting in the console CRT market. All the most desirable monitors have doubled or tripled in price over the past year. A 20" monitor easily sells for several hundred dollars, and the larger ones run into the thousands. More and more people are starting to realize that emulation is no substitute for the real thing, and the supply of functional, high quality CRTs will only continue to decrease.
- cr0sh 10y agoI see plenty of comments here about how LCDs will have to be the replacement, but there's a big issue about LCDs as replacements for CRTs (bar specialty ones being made): The fact that most of the 80s arcade monitors were 4:3 ratio. Sure - you can get 4:3 ratio LCD monitors today - but they are becoming harder to find. Furthermore, good luck finding them in a larger size than about 17 inches (19 inches, maybe). They never made them larger, from what I remember. The larger LCD screens were all widescreen (16:9?) - and still are. Even most of the smaller LCDs are wide format. And you can't just stick a wide format LCD into an arcade cabinet and add "borders" - because there likely isn't room. So at best, you'll get an LCD stuck in, with a matte board around it, and the display smaller than the original. It'll look like crap, to be honest - and that's before the look of the display on LCD vs CRT...
- VLM 10y agoMore likely you'll have a 16:9 projector with black borders projecting unto flat black side walls, resulting in a full size back projected image. The CRT people like grainy low res distortion so projecting onto the back of a purposefully bent and distorted piece of plastic should appear extremely similar to a CRT. Of course this turns the problem of a CRT with finite filament life into a problem of a projector with a finite bulb life but presumably it would be easy to swap out the entire projector. With considerable plywood hacking you MIGHT pull off attractive forward projection onto a screen for some games (not many of course) Or if you allow really ugly plywood hacking you can just place a projector screen in place of the CRT, ceiling mount the projector, and call it good.
- badlucklottery 10y ago>The fact that most of the 80s arcade monitors were 4:3 ratio. A friend of mine rebuilt an arcade cabinet recently and his solution was to just rotate the display 90 degrees and offset it a bit to get it to fit. It might not be a valid solution for mini-cabinets since they were pretty tightly packed but according to him it was a pretty easy fit in this one. The bigger problems were LCD processing latency and scaling. Most TVs that would fit were cheaper models (I guess it's getting harder to find sub 50" mid-range TVs) so they have a decent bit of processing latency even in "gaming" mode. But I don't think there's really a solution to the scaling problem without much higher resolution LCD panels because non-integer scaling is always going to have some shimmer when scrolling.
- simonlc 10y agoI own a Japanese arcade machine, and while they are still somewhat common in Japan, and the US, it was not easy to find in Canada. The nostalgic feeling and experience of playing not only on a CRT, but actual machine from the 1990's can't be replicated on an LCD. Static on the screen, the hum of the monitor, the flickering of the colors, the look of the glare on the surrounding arcades, the sound of coins dropping down the chute, are the little things I bought my arcade cabinet for. I dread the day that my monitor fails. As it'll mean the death of this experience for me without traveling to another country.
- Keyframe 10y agoI own a few of pro broadcast monitors for consoles. I would really like some contingency when they go belly up.
- tombert 10y agoI'm not asking to troll or be annoying, but couldn't we conceivably have LCDs in the future that have really high refresh rates? I'm not saying this year or anything, but is there a technical limitation to the max refresh rate to LCD?
- sehugg 10y agoYou can see what one custom arcade builder does with their LCDs here, correcting aspect ratio and adding shaders: http://www.paradoxarcades.com/monitor/ http://www.paradoxarcades.com/monitor/ They have light guns too (it uses a Wii-like infrared tracker): http://www.paradoxarcades.com/lightguns/ http://www.paradoxarcades.com/lightguns/ Nice emulations, but nothing is going to match the latency of a board hooked up directly to electron guns.
- grapeshot 10y agoIt's only the best quality arcade CRTs that are going to become unavailable. The US still has warehouses full of worthless CRT televisions that are too expensive to recycle because of the lead content in the glass. http://www.nytimes.com/2013/03/19/us/disposal-of-older-monitors-leaves-a-hazardous-trail.html http://www.nytimes.com/2013/03/19/us/disposal-of-older-monit...