13 ms·
The European Parliament votes non-bindingly to reintroduce visas for Americans
- DiegoRamirez 10y agothe EP is doing tit-for-tat when there is no tit-for-tat!
- vslira 10y ago"The main reason for the vote is the way that travellers from some EU countries are treated by America. While most citizens of EU countries can travel to the United States without a visa, those from Bulgaria, Croatia, Cyprus, Poland and Romania must still obtain one. Because the EU demands equal treatment of all its citizens in such matters, it says it is legally obliged to fight back." I won't say it's a good idea - the vote is not even binding, btw -, but at least there's a reasoning behind it. EU wants to be treated as a country[1] and no country accepts different visa requirement for their states. [1] Maybe
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- bpodgursky 10y agoYeah... Not going to happen. Americans spend billions on European vacations, and nobody is going to threaten that when push comes to shove (any additional hassle is going to send people to Cancun instead). This is just posturing.
- Cuuugi 10y agoThat is absolutely true, however the majority of European sway is with Germany, and the lost tourism would hit other countries (Greece, Spain, Croatia) much harder.
- cplanas 10y agoThere will be a hit in tourism, but I doubt that it will happen on those three countries. When Americans go to Europe they tend to focus on France/Italy; Spain is more popular for Europeans. Think about tourists in Miami (searching for sun) compared to tourists in New York (searching for "history").
- tonfa 10y agoWhat about France?
- kzrdude 10y agoThere's a ton of tourists in Germany during summer though.
- sleavey 10y agoFor me to go on vacation to the US, as a European citizen (outside of the 6 countries that are the reason for this action), I just need to get an ESTA for $15 or so. I guess the EU visa will cost something similar. It's not going to change anything.
- blibble 10y agothe EU is already introducing a similar system to the ESTA regardless: http://www.schengenvisainfo.com/brussels-prepares-eu-wide-scheme-visa-free-travel-authorisation/ http://www.schengenvisainfo.com/brussels-prepares-eu-wide-sc... (doesn't apply to Ireland or the UK) they're proposing requiring full visas for US citizens if the US doesn't comply, the sort where you have to book an appointment with the consulate for an interview and pay several hundred dollars.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- vmarsy 10y agothere's around 12 million travelers* from the US to Europe every year, so if a ESTA-reciprocity is implemented, it'll bring around $180m of revenue to European immigration offices. * that's only counting leisure travelers, there might be many more business travelers?
- dottedmag 10y agoHow much will it cost to staff these offices and process visa applications?
- vmarsy 10y agoESTA is all electronic, the process would be automatic, I'm sure you can run it for less than $180m a year. It could be as simple as: Enter first name, last name, passport number, passport country, date of flights >>> Cool you have 90 days this year! or >>> You've stayed more than 90 days, please get a real visa. If one gets denied the ESTA, like the US system he'd get refunded $10 of the $14 and if he stills want to travel, he would then have to show up to the embassy for a real, couple of hundreds dollars visa, similar to what today's countries who are not part of the ESTA program have to go through to visit the US.
- StreamBright 10y agoLike Europeans spend billions on American trips with the strictest VISA system, handing over even social media accounts and going through other non-standard border procedures. I don't think VISA requirements are a major force in tourism. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_Tourism_rankings https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_Tourism_rankings
- JohnTHaller 10y agoThere will be in uptick in international travelers skipping the US and going elsewhere in Europe. The downward trend in travel to the US is being called the Trump slump. NYC for instance is now projecting 300,000 fewer international tourists in 2017 than the previous year instead of the 400,000 gain over the previous year predicted a few months ago. Travel searches for flights and lodging in the US are down 20 to 50% worldwide outside the US. Those vacationers have to go somewhere besides here. It may as well be EU countries.
- metachris 10y agoThe reason being that the US still requires visas from 5 EU countries: Bulgaria, Croatia, Cyprus, Poland and Romania. And "The EU says it notified the United States in April 2014 that it was not meeting EU visa rules, and had given the country two years to comply."
- vmarsy 10y agowhat most likely would happen as most of these agreements is full reciprocity. i.e., like Europeans have to pay $14 for the ESTA visa waiver to travel in the US, Americans would have to do the same and register online. That visa waiver would hopefully work for the entire E.U. Or, like Australia, Brunei, Japan, and Canada which were similarly notified and implemented the changes, the US will do the same. http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/europe-visa-free-travel-americans-european-parliament-vote-a7609406.html http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/europe-visa-f...
- perseusprime11 10y agoCan we do full reciprocity in terms of taxes and tariffs on imports?
- rbanffy 10y agoThe US would need reasonable public healthcare first.
- FabHK 10y ago$14 is visa waiver. Visa is much more expensive, $160, plus a visit to the consulate for an interview.
- zaatar 10y agoIt's not simply the financial implications; the visa-process for B1/B2 entails handing over a ton of paperwork (e.g. student records, health records, employment records, etc.) which go into your file, and further, all your 10 fingerprints. The VWP doesn't entail all of that extra stuff. One could argue that the $160-$14 saving is but the simple part, the bigger issue is the loss of privacy that comes with the application of a visa.
- bandrami 10y agoThey do this every few sessions and the commission never acts on it.
- JumpCrisscross 10y agoSource?
- vanattab 10y agoFrom 2013 http://www.europarl.europa.eu/news/en/news-room/20130910IPR19556/ep-backs-rules-allowing-suspension-of-visa-free-travel-only-as-a-last-resort http://www.europarl.europa.eu/news/en/news-room/20130910IPR1...
- _delirium 10y agoThat seems more like the initiation of the current process. They adopted rules in 2013 requiring reciprocity and specifying a series of steps to take if there isn't any, with revocation of visa-free travel to the EU an option as a "last resort". The vote today is claiming that those other steps have been tried and failed regarding the U.S. (unlike with some other countries, like Canada, where progress was made), and therefore advocates taking up that last resort, which was authorized in 2013 but has never yet been invoked. I do agree that there is a good chance the EU Commission will attempt to avoid doing so, though.
- vanattab 10y agoThis is what piss me off about this article. They don't mention that this has been done before and the commission never acted on it. Why? Because it does not fit with the story that there is a huge gulf opening up between the us and Europe as a result of the election of Donald Trump. Disclaimer to protect my future employability in tech: I don't support the DT I just am not a big fan of the media of late either.
- dang 10y agoThanks. Between that and the non-binding nature of the vote (now added to the title above), this is just high-end trolling. I wish we could mature enough as a community not to act like decapitated chickens in response to these. Another classic article pattern is when someone 'introduces a bill' (most proposed bills, of course, go nowhere).
- harigov 10y agoWhat is going on in this world? I was reading news today that the parties on the right side of political spectrum are gaining ground all over Europe. US already has Republicans in power. Every country is becoming more nationalistic. What is driving this change? AFAICT there are no major issues that should have caused this.
- techsupporter 10y ago> AFAICT there are no major issues that should have caused this. Populism and a perception that a more globally-connected world is concentrating the benefits of growth into the assets and control of a handful of individuals instead of "a rising tide lifting all boats." Also, the message that some politicians have been using ("trade agreements are evil!" "immigration is bad!" "the EU is making us abuse you!") has taken hold and people are pushing back against the perceived wrongs. (I intentionally made no judgment call on the accuracy of these perceptions.)
- mistermann 10y agoI find most people have no problem acknowledging that the gap between the rich and poor is increasing, unless the topic is populist politics, then minds seem to change on the topic.
- dragonwriter 10y agoOh, plenty of people that oppose the brand of right-wing politics usually denoted in talk about "populist" politics (which is largely authoritarian nationalism) have no problem acknowledg ING that the charge of current economic policies unfairly and unnecessarily increasing the rich/poor gap are true. It's possible to believe that and think that the program of the "populists" coming to power on the back of it does nothing to alleviate that problem, as well as causing a bunch of other problems.
- quickben 10y agoCapital tends to amalgamate. Thus, I find your perceptions to be on the right track.
- youeeeeeediot 10y agoThe EU is not a sovereign country, its political and economic union. The US is under no obligation to accept all 28-member countries as equal.
- freeone3000 10y agoRight, but the EU is saying if the US doesn't, the EU will require visas from US travelers.
- ucha 10y agoWhat's the logic there? The EU is under no obligation to allow Americans to travel without a visa.
- beejiu 10y agoNobody is saying the US is under any obligation.
- genericpseudo 10y agoNo-one claimed it was! It's hardball negotiation. In this, the US meets the EU's demands or it doesn't get what it wants.
- nonglobal 10y agoEither the US meets Brussels demands, or the EU cuts off its nose in spite and throws gasoline on the anti-EU fire for member states that depend heavily on tourism from the US. Brilliant strategy, that.
- dang 10y agoWe've banned this account. You can't use HN for political and ideological battle. That's an abuse of this site which destroys what we care about here. Please stop creating accounts to break HN's guidelines with. https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- cm2187 10y agoThat being said ESTA is a visa with a fake nose.
- raverbashing 10y agoAs its own name say, it's an authorisation relating to a Visa Waiver Program
- runesoerensen 10y agoIt's not even a visa, and neither is VWP (a program designed to allow individuals from certain countries to enter the U.S. without obtaining a visa) which ESTA determines your eligibility for.
- blibble 10y agothe picture in the article is of the UK Border, but the UK is not part of the EU common visa policy. as a result, this reintroduction of visas for US citizens will not apply to US citizens visiting the UK (even if the change occurs pre-Brexit)
- lend000 10y agoThe sooner the EU dissolves, the better.
- castis 10y agoYeah? What makes you say that?
- lend000 10y agoThe EU is composed of seven major institutions, only one of which has direct representation by voters (the EU parliament), and the number of representatives of each country is (roughly) proportional to their size, so any given voter of a small EU country has effectively zero representation. The EU is very far from a democratic, representative system, and yet it hold tremendous power over its 'constituents.' Not to mention the irresponsible ECB policies and fiscal safety net draining the few remaining EU countries with any wealth... I'd like to see more state sovereignty and individual sovereignty return to Europe. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apportionment_in_the_European_Parliament https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apportionment_in_the_European_... The freedom of trade and movement that the EU brought is great, but I suspect that for the most part, that can be negotiated without a 'super-government' making the rules.
- Findeton 10y agoThe problem is that the EU is organized in such a way that it is at an intermediate stage between it being just a bunch of different nations and it being something similar to the USA. We need more EU and less nationalism to become something similar to the USA, we need a bigger EU government and smaller nations governments. The EU government is about 1% of the GDP and the nations governments are 50%, we need to reverse those numbers. Of course I agree that the EU is not very democratic right, we also need to change that.
- blibble 10y ago> The EU government is about 1% of the GDP this is not actually true, the way the EU has been setup is very clever: it does not attribute a large proportion of costs directly incurred by its policies to itself. when powers are transferred to the EU, the national institutions used to implement those powers (that previously served the national government) remain, but now implement the EU's legislative program, but the costs incurred doing so are still paid by the national treasuries. prime examples are civil aviation, food safety and agriculture policy. these departments are essentially operated by and for the EU, yet the expenses of those departments are not correctly attributed to the EU. if these expenses were correctly attributed for that 1% would likely be 3-4x higher, and people would be a lot more upset.
- anonymoose111 10y agoThis is a non story, a few paragraphs down: "Implementing the parliament’s recommendation would require the agreement of all EU members, which would probably take years." Many European countries rely heavily on US tourism, and anything to threaten that could damage their economies.
- jinglebells 10y agoInteresting. Which countries?
- Exofunctor 10y ago> What is driving this change? AFAICT there are no major issues that should have caused this. I honestly can't imagine how you could avoid exposure to any of the incredible amount of discontent in Europe right now. European leaders have been importing millions(!) of people from incredibly violent, theocratic, illiterate, and regressive regions, to the detriment of peaceful, secular, educated, and liberal Europeans who are not socially or memetically equipped to handle such an influx of radically different and heavily indoctrinated people. European news media emphatically denies that anything bad is happening; "No, rape rates have only gone up a little bit! No, we're not putting a wall around the Eiffel Tower, it's an aesthetic perimeter! No, Sweden isn't banning christmas lights in public for Muslims; it's because we all of a sudden realize that street lights can't structurally support christmas lights!" Most people in Europe are not dumb enough to fall for this. For decades, the sentiment in the European political system has been "us last". Here's a great quote from the President of the EU Parliament until earlier this year, Martin Schulz: (and yes, it's a real quote): "For me, the new Germany exists only in order to ensure the existence of the State of Israel and the Jewish people." The conclusion that any impartial observer would make is that European politicians don't seem to give much of a shit about Europeans, and instead see them as more of a resource to be used up for the sake of various political causes (mass immigration is a big one, and as Mr. Schulz demonstrated, Zionism is another). It should come as exactly zero surprise that, at some point, Europeans are going to get fed up with being treated like shit by their own political system. I'm not even European, but this sentiment is very obvious to me from my European expat friends. A large number of them are in support of leaving the EU in favor of increased national sovereignty (because then at least their own interests might come into play), and those that want to stay in the EU mostly feel that way because they falsely conflate free movement and free trade with the existence of the EU. The result of this discontent with (forced) social globalism is that countries are becoming more isolationist. This led to Brexit, will possibly lead to France leaving the EU as well (although the EU parliament is currently trying to attack Le Pen), and who knows what next. To be clear, I'm not happy about any of this, but I honestly don't know how people didn't see it coming.
- ascorbic 10y ago> I'm not even European Now there's a surprise.
- geff82 10y agoThe global citizen in me laughs at this decision. The revengeful soul in me hails it (being married to an Iranian women that should currently better not sei a foot there and myself needing a visa because I visit Iran regularily). The European citizen that I am takes a deep breath of calm as he knows that this was "only" a decision in the parliament, so probably not much will happen in real life.
- lispm 10y ago> Most people in Europe are not dumb enough to fall for this. Most people in Europe are not dumb enough to fall for your nonsense. > and yes, it's a real quote It isn't. > I'm not even European I am.
- Exofunctor 10y ago> Most people in Europe are not dumb enough to fall for your nonsense. Feel free to actually try to refute anything I said. > It isn't. It is according to Avraham Burg, and I'm not sure there is anyone more qualified to make such a claim.
- lispm 10y ago> Feel free to actually try to refute anything I said. Refute right-wing propaganda? > It is according to Avraham Burg, and I'm not sure there is anyone more qualified to make such a claim. Point me to a recording where Schulz said anything like that. On the contrary, Schulz has a decade long track record working for Germany and the European Union.
- Exofunctor 10y agoI'm not right-wing by any stretch of the imagination (pretty hard left, actually), so the fact that instead of actually thinking about my arguments you just slap a label on them and dismiss them out of hand should disturb you. Perhaps what's confusing to you is that I'm capable of considering the thought process of people I disagree with. > Point me to a recording where Schulz said anything like that. You understand that not everything politicians say is recorded? That said, Burg has literally no reason to lie about this. http://www.haaretz.com/opinion/.premium-1.574332 http://www.haaretz.com/opinion/.premium-1.574332 > On the contrary, Schulz has a decade long track record working for Germany and the European Union All you've done is prove my point; even people who work for the EU for a long time appear to have plenty of conflicting non-EU interests.
- lispm 10y ago
- edko 10y agoIn the past 8 years, the relations between the EU and the US had improved a lot (despite there being some high profile espionage scandals). I truly hope both sides can work together, and solve minor issues like these. It would really suck to go back to the times of "Freedom Fries", especially with the threat of inner rupture, and Russian pressure in the Baltics.
- masklinn 10y ago> I truly hope both sides can work together, and solve minor issues like these. The issue has been ongoing for almost 3 years (the US were notified in April 2014, alongside 4 other countries which have either resolved the issue or announced a resolution timeline), and the latest report of the commission on the subject (in December 2016) noted: > Despite the stepping up of political and technical contacts, there have not been comparable indications of progress towards the lifting of visas with the U.S. So outlook not so good, the US doesn't seem much interested.
- edpichler 10y agoWhen I was a kid I learnt about globalization, and the world getting smaller. What a strange times are we witnessing? Technology and Internet approaching us, while politics tries to separate.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- fxj 10y agoSoon ETIAS will come (european counterpart of ESTA) which demands all foreigners to register electronically and pay 5 euros.(http://www.politico.eu/article/e5-to-get-into-europe-schengen-zone-travel-non-eu-citizens/ http://www.politico.eu/article/e5-to-get-into-europe-schenge...)
- pskocik 10y agoI'm for a complete and total shutdown of all Americans entering the European Union until we figure out what the hell is going on over there.