19 ms·
It took me about 8 paragraphs in to figure out what Greyball is, so to save you the time: Uber used various data sources to identify which people are likely gov
by SilasX 10y ago
It took me about 8 paragraphs in to figure out what Greyball is, so to save you the time: Uber used various data sources to identify which people are likely government officials who are trying to collect incriminating data on them, and then blocks them from the service so they can't be caught in sting operations.
But there's a lot in the article that doesn't make sense:
>Other techniques included looking at the user’s credit card information and whether that card was tied directly to an institution like a police credit union.
I couldn't find a good source, but it doesn't seem like that's something a CC merchant would have access to. Do they really get to see that?[2]
Also, how were they able to do it so accurately without disrupting their service? Most city employees and police aren't going to be involved in sting operations against car services, so their customer support will have to deal with a torrent of very confused government employees [1] who keep getting mysterious rejections when they try to use they app, and which support can't give a truthful answer on.
Plus, this seemed to require significant on-the-ground intel and human intervention:
>If those clues were not enough to confirm a user’s identity, Uber employees would search social media profiles and other available information online. Once a user was identified as law enforcement, Uber Greyballed him or her, tagging the user with a small piece of code that read Greyball followed by a string of numbers.
So, I'm surprised it worked at all.
[1] identified by the fact of that person having more-than-usual activity inside something recognized as a government building
[2] EDIT: Okay, I get it -- you can look up banks from the CC number. Can we not have further comments just to point this out?
- fisherjeff 10y ago> I couldn't find a good source, but it doesn't seem like that's something a CC merchant would have access to. Do they really get to see that? The first six digits identify the issuing institution. Here's a free service for looking up a bank based on that information: https://binbase.com https://binbase.com
- chris_wot 10y agoThey also record the last 4 digits. I guess they could use some sort of algorithm to determine the probability it is an official, especially if they combine it with other data.
- SilasX 10y agoInteresting! But don't the CC agreements require them to only use CC numbers for the absolute minimum purposes necessary to process the transaction? (They can't store the numbers themselves except the last four digits IIRC.) So (based on the site) they could presumably use that number as part of fraud prevention but not to "identify possible narcs" -- I imagine the CC companies will be livid at this usage.
- liuhenry 10y agoCC processing agreements don't normally have any such restriction - the only information that absolutely can't be stored is the CVV/CVC number. If you handle CC information, you are subject to security standards auditing (called PCI compliance - like encryption at rest, etc.), but the BIN number and last 4 digits are not considered privileged information. I'm also not aware of any restrictions on how you want to use the BIN information - for example, merchants often use the BIN number to block prepaid card usage.
- tzs 10y agoAnother good use for BIN information is justifying tax decisions. A little while back the VAT rules in the EU changed for online merchants. Before, you collected VAT based on your location. After, you collected VAT based on the buyer's location. Each country implemented a thing called VAT MOSS, and you can register with a country's tax authority to use their VAT MOSS system. You only have to do this in one country. Once a quarter you submit a VAT MOSS form that lists your sales in each EU country and how much VAT you collected. You pay that to the tax authority of the country whose VAT MOSS system you use, and they distribute the appropriate amount to each country. They don't want it to be trivial for online buyers in high VAT counties to claim they are in some low VAT country, so merchants are not allowed to simply collect the VAT for whatever country the customer picks on the "country" drop down during check out. The merchant is required to have two pieces of non-contradictory evidence to justify their choice of which country's VAT to collect. One can be the country selected by the customer. What we normally use where I work is the customer's selected country and the country that MaxMind's ip to country database says they are ordering from. If those two agree that's two pieces of non-contradictory evidence and we're done. That's good enough most of the time but sometimes it fails. In that case I'll lookup the bank that issued their credit card from the BIN. Almost every time that bank turns out to be a bank from the country that the customer claimed to be from, giving two pieces of non-contradictory evidence for that country. Maybe once or twice the bank from the BIN did not match the claimed country but did match the IP country, so I went with that instead. There have only been a handful of times when that was not good enough, and I had to dive into their past orders, support tickets, and logs of their software contacting our update servers to play detective and try to get enough evidence to justify picking a country.
- chris_wot 10y agoI'd like to see them subpoenaed to explain what they were doing. They were deliberately violating the law, and trying to avoid detection just makes things much, much worse. This has got to be illegal.
- JumpCrisscross 10y ago> This has got to be illegal It doesn't seem that different from Cloudflare et al throwing up CAPTCHAs and blocks when I browse through Tor. Uber was trying to prevent abuse. Until someone identifies themselves as a city official or Uber is put on notice that it is under investigation, I think they are well within their rights to do this.
- matt4077 10y agoI don't get the analogy... Cloudflare is trying to protect websites from hacking attempts and similar, most of which is illegal. Their treatment of Tor also wasn't a deliberate decision but the result of empirical data they collected. A government official (or anyone, actually) trying to check for compliance with the law isn't doing anything illegal. Uber may be within their rights because companies usually have wide latitude to refuse doing business with someone, although that will ultimately depend on what kind of violations they were trying to hide, how invasive their stalking of customers was etc. Morally, though, this is just more of the shady shit that's been coming out day after day. How any investor would be willing to trust them with their money is beyond me. Considering how intransparent their financials are, I wouldn't be surprised if this ends in an Enron-style meltdown.
- JumpCrisscross 10y ago> Cloudflare is trying to protect websites from hacking attempts and similar, most of which is illegal I don't think we can say "most" Tor traffic "is illegal" [1]. At the very least, we agree that some of it is legal. That means Cloudflare, a private company, is treating users differently based on its interests and its interpretation of the law. > A government official (or anyone, actually) trying to check for compliance with the law isn't doing anything illegal They probably aren't. Neither is Uber. They're just treating their users differently based on their interests and interpretation of the law. Law enforcement has tough-as-nails methods at its disposal. It could subpoena, audit, intercept, sue, et cetera. The downside is those methods come with oversight and transparency requirements. [1] https://www.torproject.org/about/torusers.html.en https://www.torproject.org/about/torusers.html.en
- tmcpro 10y agoAll credit cards have a BIN number (first 6 digits) that typically are associated with one bank. Checkout this list[1] [1] https://www.bindb.com/bin-list.html https://www.bindb.com/bin-list.html
- zippergz 10y agoThe first part of a credit card number is called the BIN, which stands for Bank Identification Number. With that, you can tell which bank issued the card (aka the issuer).
- us0r 10y agoMaybe not a popular opinion but I find this entire thing pure genius. >I couldn't find a good source, but it doesn't seem like that's something a CC merchant would have access to. Do they really get to see that? The first 6 digits of a credit card can identify the issuing bank (BIN number - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Payment_card_number https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Payment_card_number). If you ask your merchant they can readily provide you and up to date list. This plus public payroll records (such as http://transparentcalifornia.com/ http://transparentcalifornia.com/) probably took them quite far.
- creaghpatr 10y agoWouldn't be surprised if this concept spurs its own line of copycat startups i.e. "Uber Greyball for X"
- rootsudo 10y agoCorrect, First siz digits are the BIN. This is how you identify a CC and how carders can guess your limits. e.g. some cards are only allowed to customers with certain credit card profiles.
- JumpCrisscross 10y ago> [credit card BIN numbers] plus public payroll records Do California public records really make available where specific public employees bank?
- gankedfrank 10y agoMy aunt's boyfriend works for California govt and his home address is on display. You'd be surprised at how incompetent and irresponsible govt can be.
- chickenfries 10y agoI think they meant that they could use public payroll records to get the names of city officials.
- freehunter 10y ago
- messick 10y ago>>Other techniques included looking at the user’s credit card information and whether that card was tied directly to an institution like a police credit union. >I couldn't find a good source, but it doesn't seem like that's something a CC merchant would have access to. Do they really get to see that? First 6 digits of any CC# is the Issuer/Bank Identification Number (BIN/IIN), and anyone can get access to that information. Here is an online search tool: https://www.bincodes.com https://www.bincodes.com
- googletazer 10y agoWhoever came up with this scheme at Uber earned their bread.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- knowaveragejoe 10y agoTo add to the confusion, it's not uncommon in cities to have a government office within a building shared with other private tenants.
- tyingq 10y ago"blocks them from the service" doesn't quite capture it right. It doesn't tell them they are blocked. It displays fake cars circling that never show up.
- zhengyi13 10y agoI'm reminded of the Reddit shadow ban, myself.
- SilasX 10y agoGood point. They would be on firmer ground if they just said "you're banned from our service because [vague reason]", even if the real (unstated) reason was "we don't want cops on this". But presenting deliberately fake information to hinder law enforcement sounds like it's going to be illegal somehow.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- bri3d 10y agoYou can see the "greyball" tag fields in Exhibit A in this lawsuit filing. It looks like they did some rudimentary device and payment method correlation as well as whitelisting at the database level: https://www.scribd.com/document/334009796/Spangenberg-Uber-lawsuit https://www.scribd.com/document/334009796/Spangenberg-Uber-l...
- rising-sky 10y agoWell they actually weren't able to do this so accurately without disrupting service it seems. At least I think in my case, and it's part of the reason why I don't use Uber today: I had an Uber account for a couple months prior to this incident but never used it. One night, it was about 3a.m. and I had a bit to drink. A friend gave me a promo code to use, so I could get a discount on my ride home. I put in the code a couple times, but it kept getting rejected. I think I tried this about 3 times, and finally got a message saying my account was blocked or disabled. I gave up and called a cab. I tried to get my account re-instated the next morning, by sending an email from the address I used to create the account in the first place, but got a response from an Uber rep. asking for a copy of my ID! I didn't feel comfortable sending over my ID, especially since it was not required to create the account in the first place and informed the rep as such. The response was: "I completely understand why you are concerned about providing this information. To reactivate your account I do need to verify your identity. If you can cover all but your name, the last four digits and expiration date on your new card, as well as any sensitive information on your ID, that should minimize any security issues". I'm not sure why it was such a big deal to have that information, but I'm guessing that they wanted to ascertain if I was a hostile or not, but I had a car and wasn't dependent on Uber for survival so... no thanks.
- eli 10y agoThat could also be a CC fraud detection algorithm
- repomies6991 10y agoHighly probable. Uber has probably lots of problems with credit card fraud, as do many marketplace services.
- JulianMorrison 10y agoAdditional to what you don't need further comments about: you can ask for billing address at payment time and then validate it with a fraud checking company like ReD to prevent them just making it up, so that a card registered to an organization will have to out itself. Or if it's registered to a "front" that's designed to look residential, flag that address as dirty after having been caught in a sting and then propagate the dirty flag to other cards that also point there.
- Spooky23 10y agoPerhaps this is the reason they want to collect your location when you're not using the app. Need to be sure that city employees are going to city hall, after all.
- bonestamp2 10y agoThat could be true, it could also be to help predict demand/needs for the service.
- Spooky23 10y agoIt could. But when a company profiles people and refuses service based on inconvenient occupations or employers, how can you be sure?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- pweissbrod 10y agoDrivers can and should prefer passengers with a higher probability of being "good" customers. Greyball seems to be a clever tool which attempts to predict the good-ness of potential passengers. The unethical piece comes in to play with the heuristics injected in to greyball. (kinda makes you wonder if "grey" moniker refers to the ambiguity which comes with the territory of rating people)