8 ms·
Support Grows for a Seattle to Vancouver Bullet Train
- hackuser 10y agoI wonder how recently intensified U.S. customs enforcement will affect this project? It affects demand for travel to the U.S.: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13742033 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13742033 And the difficulty of crossing the border could deter some passengers: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13741423 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13741423
- bruceb 10y agoCurrently for VAN-SEA train they inspect your passport before at the train station before you board. It also stops at the border but they just walk through the train. Of course they could hold you then but for the most part you would be denied entry on the train without being detained.
- guyzero 10y agoOne hour travel time and three hour delay while the CPB agent grills you on the wikipedia definition of a red-black tree. (https://twitter.com/cyberomin/status/835888786462625792 https://twitter.com/cyberomin/status/835888786462625792)
- angry_octet 10y agoI kept reading the tweets because I was sure it was a joke. That is bizarre! I wonder how big their corpus of questions is? Are they going to save all the answers to do deep learning on? INS CAPTCHA! If only I had the balls to put down Gerbil Rancher for profession.
- StClaire 10y agoThat whole area is completely geologically unstable. Before we build a bullet train we need to reinforce major buildings in Seattle and prepare Vancouver Island for a tsunami
- blazespin 10y agoI think you meant to say Vancouver Island. Vancouver has a massive island protecting it from a tsunami.
- Cyphase 10y agoYou don't have to be faster than the bear, you just have to be faster than someone else.
- StClaire 10y agoNice call
- flukus 10y agoWould the island protect it or help to funnel all the water up the bay?
- chx 10y agoProtect it. I live on the shores of English Bay and the water typically barely ripples, waves are rare and more than that is practically unheard of. Compare this to the Pacific Ocean storms out on the open.
- kobeya 10y agoThat's not what a tsunami is though. A tsunami is not a wave in the sense you allude to, it is the whole water level rising in unison. A breakwater does not protect you from a tsunami.
- Kluny 10y agoVancouver islander here - tbh, Vancouver Island is mostly okay too. If you look at the map, you'll see that a huge peninsula shelters the most populous area (Victoria) from tsunami. Most of the smaller towns are on the inside passage. The only places that are in real danger are Tofino, Ucluelet, Port Renfrew, and several small native settlements. It's a shame because those are some of my favorite places on earth, but 90% of Vancouver Island doesn't live there. (I did the research on this last year after I had a nightmare about tsunamis.)
- revscat 10y agoWon't happen. The political reality is that America is opposed to these things, and I'm not sure which party is more to blame. Sorry, but it's true. These things come up over and over again, only to be killed root and branch by whatever means necessary.
- edblarney 10y agoSo is Canada. We have zero high speed rail. In fact, many traveller rail lines have been closed over the years. Sadly.
- ghaff 10y agoBecause Canada has many (more?) of the same geographical and distance/density issues that make most high-speed rail uninteresting in the US unless you ignore economics.
- flukus 10y agoCanada has the benefit of most of the population almost lined up along the US border, at least the distance issues are only 1 dimensional.
- angry_octet 10y agoThere is a crossover point in distance where it is going to be quicker and cheaper to fly. Except for (Detroit-)Toronto-Ottawa-Montreal the distances are too great.
- mikekchar 10y agoEven on the Detroit-Toronto-Ottawa leg, which should be hugely profitable, Via manages to screw it up. Admittedly my experience is several years old, but I once took the train from Ottawa to London, Ontario. It took over 12 hours which I think was something like 5 hours late. Because all of the passengers to Detroit missed their connection, Via drove them by taxi from London. I asked the porter if this was common. He told me it happened on virtually every run. I used to take the train everywhere that I could when I lived in Ottawa and the Hamilton-Montreal side was quite a bit better, but still ghastly. If Canada ever gets serious about rail, they need to do something about the rail infrastructure and the Via monopoly. Don't think it will ever happen though.
- kposehn 10y agoNotes: 1. The most realistic speed is actually 186mph (300kmh) max making for a ~90min trip between Seattle and Portland - which is still great. 2. There's a completely alternate alignment for a good chunk of the Seattle-Portland distance (former Milwaukee road branch lines and the old chela is western). There is also a rebuilt alignment of the old Tacoma western that will just went in service that will cut 30min off then trip from Tacoma to Olympia anyway. 3. Interestingly, it shouldn't be thought of as a mid-distance intercity train. It's a commuter train at higher speed. In Japan a huge number of people commute on the Shinkansen. Imagine if you could commute in 20min from Everett to Seattle or Olympia to Tacoma.
- jrpt 10y agoSure it'd be nice, but at what cost? The estimate of $125 million to $1 billion per mile is incredibly expensive.
- bildung 10y agoIs cost per mile a reasonable metric? Shouldn't that be cost per passenger per year or something similar?
- Arnt 10y agoBoth are, for different purposes. Cost by distance is reasonable for talking about construction (the supply side). See https://pedestrianobservations.wordpress.com/2011/05/16/us-rail-construction-costs/ https://pedestrianobservations.wordpress.com/2011/05/16/us-r... for an overview. Even $125m/mile places the project a little high on that list, among mostly-tunnel and all-tunnel projects, and $1b/mile is in the WTF zone. Cost by passenger or passenger-trip is reasonable for talking about utility (the demand side).
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- melling 10y ago
- jdminhbg 10y agoSeattle is in the midst of a $1.9 billion 4.3-mile light rail extension that will take over a decade to complete: http://www.seattlepi.com/local/transportation/article/Sound-Transit-completes-tunneling-for-Northgate-9200711.php http://www.seattlepi.com/local/transportation/article/Sound-... As awesome as this sounds, it sounds almost delusional in the current planning/cost/funding climate to price this at $20-30 bn and 15 years.
- twoslide 10y agoI am sure you're right, but it is disappointing that this is the case. Rapid Chinese expansion of HSR suggests that it is technically possible to do it much more quickly.
- NotSammyHagar 10y agoWe would be screwed by the border crossing from canada to the us. You'd have to completely do it in canada. There's discussion of this below, but since i now live in idiocracy, I have little hope.
- akamaka 10y agoWhy do you think $30 billion is delusional? Just because it's a huge number? The US spends well over $1 trillion dollars on transportation every year, to put it in context.
- jdminhbg 10y agoI think it's delusional because a neighborhood spur light rail line in Seattle costs about 1/10 of that (and takes about the same amount of forecasted time).
- trome 10y agoUhh, we just approved $54 Billion for Sound Transit 3, which adds 62 miles of rail spanning from Everett to Tacoma, so no, light rail isn't dirt cheap. It is very effective at moving people cheaply though, and is a big economic boon to this city. Going from Capital Hill to UW in under 5 minutes on the train, versus a 10 to 20 minute drive is amazing!
- Canada 10y agoThis would be so great, but the biggest impediment to transport between Seattle and Vancouver is the border. Both sides treat incoming passengers in an appalling manner.
- madhusharma 10y agoSo is japan. They have zero high-speed rails.
- stevenjgarner 10y agoI wonder what portion of cross-border travelers make transport decisions based on immigration concerns? I sincerely doubt Jay Inslee's feasibility study will look realistically at the role immigration plays in cross-border travel decisions. I was denied entry into Canada in the past few months, while holding an airline ticket from Chicago to Victoria. My Electronic Travel Authorization (eTA) was not approved by Canadian authorities. This left me with no other option other than to change my air travel to fly to Seattle, rent a car, drive across the border to Vancouver (during a blizzard) and catch the ferry to Victoria (all at great extra cost, but otherwise without incident). I was told by several airline staff on different airlines and by border officials themselves that this was all too common. The Canadian eTA web process is broken (I am still unable to upload simple PDF files to my application), and I can only assume such a Bullet Train would require eTA approval.
- JumpCrisscross 10y ago> it would cost between $125 million to $1 billion per mile to build the Seattle to Vancouver line One of the problems with the American rail debate is you have people who like rail and people who like low taxes. The two don't overlap. Thus, the former sees any opportunity to lay rail as an opportunity to hose taxpayers. "China’s high speed rail with a maximum speed of 350 km/h has a typical infrastructure unit cost of about $17-21m per km, with a high ratio of viaducts and tunnels, as compared with $ 25-39 [million U.S. dollars] per km in Europe and as high as $ 56 [million U.S. dollars] per km currently estimated in California" [1]. The Seattle/Washington per-mile costs above translate to $78 to $625 million dollars per kilometre. [1] http://www.worldbank.org/en/news/press-release/2014/07/10/cost-of-high-speed-rail-in-china-one-third-lower-than-in-other-countries http://www.worldbank.org/en/news/press-release/2014/07/10/co... 2014
- rsync 10y ago"One of the problems with the American rail debate is you have people who like rail and people who like low taxes." US citizen here, in the highest of all possible US+California tax brackets, who is very enthusiastic about rail and non-bus public transportation. It's not that I don't want to pay taxes for rail - I do - it's that we already ramped the tax collection all the way up to 11 without doing any rail. Once you're at >50% effective tax rate[1], where do you go from there ? I can't possibly favor any tax increase - it doesn't matter what for - since we are already past (what I would consider) "peak" taxes. [1] 53% - although in my case, closer to 48% due to minor things like 401k and HSA, etc. Yes, I am one of the suckers who is in the highest bracket but pursues no exotic tax avoidance.
- jhall1468 10y agoHow is your effective tax rate 50%? Even if you are in the highest tax bracket, only the income in that bracket is taxed at the highest rate. Even people earning $475000 in California still only have an effective tax rate of ~40%, which is what you'd need to be making to be in the top US+California tax bracket. And if that's the case you are still taking home nearly $300,000 per year. I'm all for effective use of taxes, but your effective tax rate calculation seems way off.
- kposehn 10y agoThere's been a lot of comments about Chinese HSR here costs, figure I can cover a few things: 1. Their labor cost per mile is a tiny fraction and their work safety standards are far different. 2. Iirc (not 100% sure) the cost per mile is lower as well because they are not taking into account property acquisition costs. 3. The actual equipment they use comes from companies either not selling at a profit or at a steep discount. I still don't have an accurate enough picture here, but it doesn't seem apples to apples at least.
- saosebastiao 10y agoYou would expect that the US would have costs that align more with Germany, UK, France, or Switzerland, wouldn't you? And yet, those countries' costs look far more like China's than they do the US. The US is the outlier here, not China.
- kposehn 10y agoHmm, good point.
- Tiktaalik 10y agoI've taken the Amtrak from Vancouver to Seattle and Portland and various stops in between. Excepting the low speeds and infrequent departure times it's such a great service. A HSR train that would fix these problems would be a dream and there would surely be a big tourism boost along the corridor. One of the benefits of rail would be that you have the ability to have downtown to downtown service and you potentially take a lot of cars off the road. Seattle is dramatically improving its transportation system and it's pretty reasonable to think that in the near future it could be totally viable to travel between Vancouver, Seattle and Portland without a car, leveraging public transit and bike share (oh wait Seattle killed theirs...) to get around. Another big advantage of the train is that it's pretty simple and easy to take a bike along. Pretty useful if you want to go on a bike touring trip in Washington or Oregon or just dash into Portland for a weekend but have your bike along so that you can move about the city easily. Vancouver is currently undergoing the a planning process for the Flats industrial neighbourhood, which includes the old central rail station. I was the nerd that went to the transportation meeting and stuck the "keep the door open to HSR" post it note on the ideas board. I was happy to see that there was a mention of the potential for HSR in the area in the draft plan, though I doubt city planners really believe that strongly that it's a potential reality.
- dexterdog 10y ago> it would cost between $125 million to $1 billion per mile to build the Seattle to Vancouver line $2 billion per mile is a lot of money.
- GingerBoats 10y agoHonestly, I would prefer that Seattle get their own transportation system in order for commuters. Support and focus on a "bullet train" to Vancouver is a rather moot point, especially at the price point.