14 ms·
How Nasty Gal Went from an $85M Company to Bankruptcy
- jagtodeath 10y agoNo pay wall http://news.morningstar.com/all/dow-jones/us-markets/201702243741/how-nasty-gal-went-from-an-85-million-company-to-bankruptcy.aspx http://news.morningstar.com/all/dow-jones/us-markets/2017022...
- em0ney 10y agoCan't read the article without a subscription to WSJ
- smcl 10y agoOh dear - they closed the loophole. It's a shame, but if it's something they need to do to survive then fair play. I do wonder if these should be permitted on HN now though...
- merb 10y agoHow could a site make an article behind a paywall that's available for free somewhere else, especially if it's not their article... getting money from others work seems a little bit odd.
- vogt 10y agoyeah, no clue. after seeing this article behind a paywall I simply googled "nasty gal" and the results returned this article first and a LA Times version of the story second. no paywall on the LAT for me. whether or not the story was the same quality, I have no idea.
- cyberferret 10y agoI believe if you click the 'web' link under the title of the article here on HN, it will take you to a Google search page which will (sometimes) show you other sources for the same article. Also, I've been getting around the paywall from Washington Post and NY Times etc. by right clicking on an article I know comes from their site and selecting 'Open in Incognito Window' in Chrome. The lack of cookie tracking gives me infinite free article previews. (Yes, I do feel a little guilty about this and will pay for a subscription to one or both papers to support them sometime soon). :)
- smcl 10y agoYou're not the only one feeling the guilt. The only journalism I was paying for (well paying currency for at least) was my Private Eye subscription for a couple of years, but I found that I didn't want to read it in paper-form. I'd gladly have paid the same amount (which was something like a couple of pounds a month) or more if the same material was available online too. update: just checked on a whim and it seems that some time over the last couple of years Private Eye have a completely new online portal. Time to put my money where my mouth is :)
- DanBC 10y agoThis no longer works reliably for the WSJ.
- DanBC 10y agoI can't edit my post, but here's a thread full of people saying the WSJ workaround no longer reliably works: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13434938 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13434938
- merb 10y agoWeil somebody Posted a link from the same author and the first three lines were exactly the same. I think that there is not a single word that differ. Shame on WSJ that they try to monetize such a thing.
- amorphid 10y agoIf you're asking how one would do that at a technical level, I imagine they would use HTTP Referer info [1]. Essentially they decided if someone was being referred to WSJ.com by a search engine, then show the whole article, else show the paywall. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/HTTP_referer https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/HTTP_referer
- Dylan16807 10y ago> It's a shame, but if it's something they need to do to survive then fair play. Depends on how much they value that google traffic, since google doesn't like being tricked into fake search results.
- headmelted 10y agoThe most interesting part of this to me is the purchase by Boohoo.com, itself capitalising on legendary dotcom failure boo.com's branding. It sounds very much like the parent is running a business model very similar to the "one last draw" model Warren Buffet was so successful with earlier in his career. It might make a lot of sense for the right type of investor, too. The growth won't likely be there in the long term (minus an unlikely resurgence), but revenue will come early, meaning a fast if limited return. I'd be interested to know what kind of revenue Nasty Gal is doing now, obviously it's not anything like $85m on a price of $20m.
- alaskamiller 10y agoRevenue is vanity. Profit is reality. Selling $85MM in 2014 is nifty, but fashion industry is hard. Average EBITA is maybe 10%: http://www.mckinsey.com/industries/retail/our-insights/the-state-of-fashion http://www.mckinsey.com/industries/retail/our-insights/the-s... to realize how brutal it is. Let's piece this together... She had 280 FTE at 2013 and got into a lease for 500k sqft warehouse: http://www.inc.com/30under30/donna-fenn/nasty-gal-sophia-amoruso-2013.html http://www.inc.com/30under30/donna-fenn/nasty-gal-sophia-amo... At ~$60k/yr avg and we'll pretend a killer deal on the space at ~$30/sqft, half off the avg ask that year in KY http://www.loopnet.com/Louisville_Kentucky_Market-Trends http://www.loopnet.com/Louisville_Kentucky_Market-Trends, her bill was probably $31.8MM. She also got into manufacturing. And with how much she was willing to spend, I would imagine she threw maybe $1MM here and $1MM there for that. Probably another few millions on the two B&M. Boom, that's $40MM gone, just like that. Smart VCs don't invest in ecommerce. The investors bought into Sophia Amoruso's narrative. The second she took the money she had to spend the money so can't blame her for that. That warehouse must have been albatross around the neck. She thought they could repeat the $85MM high score but clearly that didn't happen; they never mentioned revenue numbers ever again. Next year she asked for another $24MM, prob to cover for the lease and half the head count. But again, another bad year. All the while she got distracted writing her vanity book, going on her vanity tour, rationalizing what's good for her must be good for the brand. So 3 years in they lost $64MM just like that chasing after the dragon. Crazy ride. Who's got next?
- 10y ago
- firasd 10y agoOh snap, I didn't expect this headline sentence to end this way. It was so lauded in the media for a while. Good PR. (File under sama's warning about founders falling in love with personal press? http://blog.samaltman.com/the-post-yc-slump http://blog.samaltman.com/the-post-yc-slump)
- jmcgough 10y agoI saw several small fashion startups pop up in the bay area after Nasty Gal got big revenue numbers. They all were obsessively trying to replicate them and chase after their success (even to the point of copying Amoruso's way of writing and NG's edgy image). I have a feeling we'll see a few less copycats now. In unrelated news, Nasty Gal seems to be running a 70% off everything sale right now to dump inventory.
- nutanc 10y agoThe nastygal google ads are pointing to http://localhost/error.html http://localhost/error.html Is this common? They are out of ad money and Google will not charge if pointed to localhost?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- PaulHoule 10y agoThe clothes were awful. It sounded like a good story from a distance, but if you looked at the catalog it was a definite maybe and if you saw the clothes in person you realized they used cheap materials and were photographed from the good angle.
- atomical 10y agoWere the colors off as well? I have bought clothes from online retailers and the colors looked different in person.
- solatic 10y agoRetailers don't have much of an incentive to accurately portray color in online catalogs. It's one thing to shill out lots of money for high-color-accuracy monitors, automatic color/light calibrators, and high-color-accuracy printers - for print materials, since the color printed is what the customer will actually see (excepting people with color blindness...). But for online catalogs, the retailer doesn't control the color accuracy of the customer's computer or phone screen, so most of the time, the customer won't see the accurate colors anyway. So why bother?
- PaulHoule 10y agoModern plastic clothes often don't have much variation in color. Go to the Salvation Army sometime, where they often sort clothes by color, and you will particularly notice that almost everything red is made with the exact same dye.
- Nomentatus 10y agoIt's also true that colors in between the three frequencies that our eye's cones can easily detect cannot be accurately reproduced by a computer monitor. Yet these colors are great attention-getters for just that reason - you never see them on TV (which abstracts and exaggerates the limits of human cones); so fashion tends to gravitate toward those "in between" colors. Modern flower breeds also bend toward these colors, for the same reason, and artists for the last century have adored them as well - making it awfully hard to buy an accurate reproduction of many or most paintings.
- rpastuszak 10y agoFor some reason I misread the title and thought this was a link to an article about Theranos.
- spaceflunky 10y agoI was very close to insiders at the company, can't tell you who I know, but you'll have to trust me. Nasty Gal was a lot worse of an environment that this article leads on. There's a lesson to learn here, so that's why I'm posting. Basically, Nasty Gal made a string of horrible investments, one after another, which makes one wonder if they were trying to fail. Lots went wrong, but I'll cover the stuff that hasn't been reported.... First they tried to raise their average price point from $60 to like $400. They started off selling cheap crap from asia (think F21), but then when Sheree Waterson from Lululemon came onboard, she convinced Sophia they could follow the Lululemon model and charge insane prices for clothes. (Keep in mind Waterson was a failed exec from Lululemon that joined NG after being fired from Lululemon so she had her own issues) That idea failed and NG alienated customers, while also having a lot of inventory they could sell on hand. Huge loss of capital on that idea. Second, Sophia Amoruso became increasingly obsessed with building a "cult of personality" around herself and using that to sell clothes. Amoruso would regularly commandeer NG's customer mailing list to send out mailers about herself and what she was up to. These emails would result in the highest unsubscribe rates. NG, like a lot of online retailers, lived and died by their weekly emails. Then she decided she had to write a book, so she spent around $500,000 of company money on a ghost writer and marketing for the book. She had a publisher, but the publisher only picked her up because Amoruso was paying all the costs to publish out of the NG's pocket. Amoruso, again use the company mailing list to promote the book, which resulted in a lot of unsubs. Amoruso basically bet that women would buy her clothes if they identified with her story, so she doubled down on building her cult of personality and plastered her face and story all over Nasty Gal. There was some degree of success for Amoruso in the form of fame, but this did NOT result in an increase of sales to the company. Essentially, Amoruso traded company revenue, for personal fame. Thirdly, there were frequent and arbitrary layoffs at NG which killed moral. If Amoruso didn't like a how a project was going, she would fire the whole team. This lead to lawsuits and Nasty Gal has had deal with at least 5-10 different plaintiffs claiming wrongful termination. Many of these settled out of court for a good sum of money. Some of the fired women were pregnant and they accused Amoruso of firing them for actually being pregnant. They had enough of a claim that Amoruso had to settle with them out of court. Fourthly, going back to Amoruso's vanity... She became obsessed with building a lavash office in downtown Los Angeles. She spent about $10-20M on a beautiful, but very expensive office. This came back to bite them later. Lastly, Nasty Gal was continuing to generate money, about $70M a year according the bankruptcy docs, but they were still losing money on that. They still had a big email list that they built up years prior, so that kept them selling. They had to take out what basically amounted to a 'shark loan' from Hercules Capital to stay afloat. About $10MM in 2014. After they failed to right the ship, Hercules basically forced them into bankruptcy and that's why they are where they are now.
- raiyu 10y agoIt looks like overall a classic mistake of trying to go too fast too soon. The issue with taking on VC capital is that you need to be in control of how you spend that money, and if you don't need it, then don't take it. There are also challenges with any business in crossing the chasm. Selling to more customers, or a different set of customers is akin to searching for product market fit a second time and is tricky like the first. The underlying business fundamentals are also critical. A great example of a company taking on VC money but growing slowly and methodically is Github. They raised their Series A well after they had established significant revenue and were already profitable for many years. Though they did get into an extravagent office that was largely unnecessary but they used the extra funds to double down on their own infrastructure and to expand github into the Enterprise. This shift to the enterprise was about finding product market fit with a different set of customers and also about updating the company culture. But luckily they had revenue, profit, and great advisors to hep them navigate the turbulent waters which allowed them to grow but not crumble under their own weight. It looks like Nasty Gal just did too many things at once. Moving to manufacturing, warehousing, retail brick and mortar stores, staffing up the company with senior hires that probably weren't a culture and product fit. One of these errors is costly enough but taken together we now see the results. Had they instead grown more organically, focused on what was working and double down they could have taken on significantly less money, continued to grow, and still be in business today. But of course all analysis is easy from the sidelines and the inside story is rarely told. None the less for a business to be bootstrapped and survive so many years it had to be profitable, then you take on VC money and it falls apart the overall theme is clear. That's not an indictment on VC money either, because Google, Facebook, Snap, Twitter, Apple, all wouldn't be here without it.
- narrowrail 10y agoI hope it doesn't sound too pedantic, but the 'C' in VC stands for capital, so saying money or capital after VC is redundant. The only reason I was driven to write this is because of how many times it was written.
- adventured 10y agoThat's not necessarily correct. When the parent writes: > A great example of a company taking on VC money VC can stand for "venture capitalist" in that context. So "VC money" equating to venture capitalist money, would in fact be a proper use. Further, venture capital is a specific type of money. One could also correctly say: bond money, debt money, home equity money, (the) bank loan money, among others and they act as an elaboration of the type of money in question as all context of money is not the same. If I say: the bank loan, that's not necessarily the same as: the bank loan money. The same can be true for venture capital. If I say: the venture capital (eg: we need to discuss the venture capital situation), it can mean the broader arrangement (such as the VC terms) or situation of fund raising, rather than being about the venture capital cash specifically.
- mikikian 10y agoTo learn about the facts leading up to the bankruptcy, a great resource is to read the declaration in support of the first day motions. This is filed under penalty of perjury so there is a reasonable expectation it is factually accurate. From the filing, here are the financial details [1]: "For the year ended January 31, 2015, the Debtor reported revenues of approximately $85.0 million, gross profit of approximately $34.0 million and EBITDA of negative $6.3 million. For the year ended January 30, 2016, the Debtor reported net revenues of approximately $77.1 million, gross profit of approximately $22.8 million and EBITDA of negative $15.4 million. Through August, 2016, the Debtor has reported revenue of approximately $41.1 million, gross profit of approximately $17.7 million and EBITDA of negative $3.3 million. The Debtor projects that, for the year ending January 27, 2017, it will generate net revenue of $77.0 million, gross profit of $33.3 million and EBITDA of negative $1.4 million." [1] https://pdf.inforuptcy.com/pacer/cacbke/1768567/dockets/4/1-0CEFEDFC-A784-11E6-A1AC-5C0F1EE103D7 https://pdf.inforuptcy.com/pacer/cacbke/1768567/dockets/4/1-...
- novaleaf 10y agothanks for those details. For those like me who didn't know: EBITDA = Earnings before interest, tax, depreciation and amortization
- rhizome 10y agoWhich in practice means "revenues are lower than we're saying, and losses/outflows/overhead are larger."
- tedmiston 10y agoWas it really ever an $85M business if it never technically made money? (Per EBITDA)
- wpietri 10y agoYes. When people size a business in dollar terms I think they're usually talking about revenue. Because a) it's a clear, concrete measure, b) it's indicative of consumer demand, and c) it allows you to ignore all of the gross and subtle factors that influence profit. (I think the second-most common way to use the phrase is in market cap terms, but that only works well for publicly traded companies.) For example, consider this chart of Amazon's revenue versus profit: http://static2.businessinsider.com/image/56abe654c08a80431d8bb4ef-1200-900/20160129_amazon_bi.png http://static2.businessinsider.com/image/56abe654c08a80431d8... By revenue, Amazon's $136bn company, which I think gives a useful measure of their size. But their profit has always been relatively small, and in many quarters it was negative. Why? Because they think they have better things to do with the money than putting in the bank and/or giving it back to investors. I think it's an especially good measure here because potential acquirers are going to start with revenue when figuring whether looking into Nasty Gal is worth their time. The mentioned competitor, Boohoo, has revenues circa $240m. So a fire-sale acquisition would be an opportunity to increase sales by circa a third, skipping a lot of the hard work of finding new customers. There are obviously plenty of complications, but it's a good first cut.
- socrates1998 10y agoIsn't this the same girl that the Deniro/Anne Hathaway movie was on? After reading the article, this movie version had the same issues as this real life founder. If only she had watched the movie about herself maybe she wouldn't have bankrupted herself.
- moomin 10y agoI'll pick out a thread here: the toxic culture. When businesses fail, it's regarded as obvious that the toxic culture contributed to the downfall. With successful businesses like Uber or some bank you recently read about, it's assumed that somehow these behaviours are what makes the companies profitable. My own theory is that toxic culture is a drain on every company with one, like a parasite on a host organism. Sometimes the host is strong enough to survive, sometimes it isn't. I've worked for toxic tech and toxic finance companies. In both cases I felt that poor decisions were made that a healthier culture could have avoided.
- enraged_camel 10y ago>>With successful businesses like Uber or some bank you recently read about, it's assumed that somehow these behaviours are what makes the companies profitable. I'm not sure that's true. At least with Uber, it's pretty well-understood that they are successful despite their toxic culture. And that's mostly because they have received billions from VCs, which does a great job shielding them from the consequences of bad decisions such as harboring and protecting sexual harassers at the corporate level.
- tyre 10y agoI don't think it is universally agreed that Uber is successful despite its culture. It may be that, in at least some industries, ruthless aggression is a financially advantageous attitude. Investment banking comes to mind. If we want to change culture, it has to be for reasons other than money. The Pyramids were a phenomenal project that we couldn't realistically replicate today (due to costs), but I'm okay sacrificing that for not using slave labor. Speaking of which, the American South was an economic powerhouse with a culture of slavery and brutality (in large part because of it, not despite it.) I think that's what a lot of people are grappling with in Silicon Valley. We want to have a positive, inclusive culture and also build massive companies. People rarely talk about what happens if you can only choose one. The reality of taking venture funding is that you are expected to do the latter, with the former a nice to have. (You can read my comment history to see that I'm strongly against these types of culture.)
- xor1 10y agoSophia still walks away with an 8-figure networth and her #Girlboss brand, but wow, it really seems like Nasty Gal could have been so, so much more succesful if it wasn't mismanaged. I feel really bad for the employees (both past and present) who believed in her and in the company. After reading through a bunch of comments, articles, and some of the Glassdoor reviews, I really have to wonder if she has Borderline Personality Disorder.
- zelias 10y agoAnyone else notice how everyone they reached out to refused to comment?