19 ms·
The Mark Zuckerberg Manifesto Is a Blueprint for Destroying Journalism
- vinhboy 10y ago> It’s also not Zuckerberg’s responsibility to solve a broken business model in journalism. (One could argue he has a moral imperative to do so, given his position of power, but that’s not the same thing.) That line is pretty much all you need to know about the article, despite what the title is claiming. In my opinion. If anything is destroying journalism, it's the fact that half this country does not care for fact vs fiction. [0] If some guy with a catchy domain name can produce content that goes viral, it doesn't matter how many Pulitzer the NYTimes has. If anything, as someone who actually cares about facts, the latest changes in my Facebook newsfeed has gotten me to read a lot more publications because my friends are sharing stories from journals I don't normally read. The author is misplacing the blame. [0] http://www.npr.org/sections/alltechconsidered/2016/11/23/503146770/npr-finds-the-head-of-a-covert-fake-news-operation-in-the-suburbs http://www.npr.org/sections/alltechconsidered/2016/11/23/503...
- RyanZAG 10y ago> In my opinion. If anything is destroying journalism, it's the fact that half this country does not care for fact vs fiction. Why is this a problem that needs to be solved though? A big part of being free is being able to choose what you get to care about, being able to choose what you get to read, and being able to have your own opinions. Remove that, and you're no longer free. Would it be better to not be a free people? I can see the benefits of both sides, but I think freedom is a better long term solution for a multitude of historical reasons.
- fmoralesc 10y agoYou get to choose what you care about, but you don't get to chose whether it is right to to care about it. You are free to have whatever opinion you want, but you don't get to choose whether those opinions are correct. This matters practically because the "tribunal of facts" stabilizes collective action: when responsive to it, people can count on certain strategies to solve problems. If you cease to care about what is fact, your strategies will inevitably get out of step with everyone else's. This is only sustainable until the facts force themselves on you. Constraining your freedom doesn't mean you cease to be free, but it allows others to flourish just as you do. A free society ("a free people", as you say) should allow everyone to flourish as much as they care to (but no less). Collective freedom is not just the sum of individual freedoms. It is the result of cooperation.
- TheRealDunkirk 10y ago> You are free to have whatever opinion you want, but you don't get to choose whether those opinions are correct. What kind of nonsense is that? My OPINION is that Snowden is a hero, and NOT a traitor, and I absolutely choose to consider that opinion is correct. What are the FACTS about that? He broke the law. But he broke an immoral law? What about the actions he divulged? Were they not unconstitutional? Of course, there are "laws" on the books that make what the CIA/NSA did "legal." So where does all this leave us? Forums like this keep discussion fake news in the light of "fact," as though fact were enough. It's not. You can go back and forth and back and forth with arguments about Snowden, and get nowhere. It all depends on your bias about how the Constitution should regard your personal liberty and privacy versus the concern for national safety. Lots of people fall on both sides. I use this example because it's a good, clear one, but the same thing is going on in most other stories. There's at least 2 ways of looking at everything. A person's bias and moral compass determines which way is the one they choose to care about. And who are you to tell them that their opinion -- based on the same set of data -- is "wrong?" That's just called having a difference of opinion. Now that the country is well and truly removed from the halcyon post-war era, we have to figure out how to live with each other, and differences of opinion. That's the real issue here. The same way that social norms had to react and catch up with the emergence of Facebook itself, we have to settle into new norms about living with people who don't think like we do, and that goes for both sides. It's not going to stop me from thinking that someone is "wrong" when they call Snowden a traitor, but it doesn't mean I need to get in their face about it, or put signs in their yard, or tear down their signs, or picket their business. You see what I'm saying.
- fmoralesc 10y agoSure, but at the end of it, your opinion that Snowden is a hero or not is either grounded in fact or not. As you point out, "hero" as a concept is sensitive to perspectival factors, but it is possible to make those explicit, no? (likewise, If I feel cold, then that is a fact, despite it being inescapably subjective). The issue is, then, why are we inclined to assert that he is (or not) a hero "simpliciter", when the truth is more complicated than that? We might not be entitled to claim as much as we want. > A person's bias and moral compass determines which way is the one they choose to care about. And who are you to tell them that their opinion -- based on the same set of data -- is "wrong?" That's just called having a difference of opinion. Somebody's moral compass is not just an irreducibly subjective element, but it is also normatively sensitive to facts. Our weighting of the data might have biases, but those biases are surely appropriate or not as well? (I don't mean to imply that we can resolve in principle the issue of whether our biases are correct or not, which we might not; see the problem of Deep Disagreement [1]) So yes, I agree with you when you say that the problem is how to live with each other given our limitations to resolve disagreements. However, I think underplaying the role of facts in this needlessly perpetuates them. The sort of disagreements we face is not just of the kind you just gave an example of: people disagree in ways in which they don't even agree on the same set of data. See the case of climate change denial, for example. Those are not simply having a "difference of opinion". [1]: https://www.academia.edu/2592706/What_is_the_Problem_of_Deep_Disagreement https://www.academia.edu/2592706/What_is_the_Problem_of_Deep...
- eropple 10y agoYou can, and should, have your own opinions. Does that extend to facts?
- adnzzzzZ 10y agoYou can look at any situation and pick and choose what facts you want to care about, and that process can be extremely biased and misguiding, even though all the facts will be correct. It's not so cut and dry as facts vs. fiction. If things were that simple the problem would be easily solved.
- macintux 10y agoIt is so cut and dry as facts vs fiction, but I think 2016 proved it's not easily solved. Trump constantly spouted blatant fiction. He still does. This isn't one set of facts vs another. Trump lies, then vilifies those who call out his lies, and somehow he's the hero.
- adnzzzzZ 10y ago>and somehow he's the hero. This happens because it's not as simple as facts vs. fiction. Yes, he does get some facts wrong. But the media does pick what facts to report on to always paint him in a bad light. This is why I said it's not so simple.
- mistermann 10y ago> It is so cut and dry as facts vs fiction No, it isn't. With complete sincerity I think you should make a serious effort to appreciate this possibility.
- hkmurakami 10y agoQuestioning our assumptions and commonly held beliefs (even facts!) should be encouraged as an integral part of intellectual discourse. I'm saddened by the current state of affairs where increasingly polarized factions feel that taking nuanced (rather than absolutist) positions threatens their positions and gives up ground to the opposition.
- kelnos 10y agoI would like to agree with you, but if you get a large enough group that believes that fiction is truth, that can do a lot of harm to the people who actually do believe in facts. That's where I (personally) draw the line on everything: do literally whatever the hell you want, as long as you aren't harming anyone else in the process. Obviously there are nuances, and sometimes causing some harm in the pursuit of the greater good is acceptable, but I think this principle is a sound starting point. And that's the thing. You can be a climate-change denier all you want, but once that starts affecting public policy, that's a problem, because, for example, eviscerating the EPA will have far-reaching, long-term, negative effects on life on our planet.
- mistermann 10y ago> You can be a climate-change denier all you want, but once that starts affecting public policy, that's a problem, because, for example, eviscerating the EPA will have far-reaching, long-term, negative effects on life on our planet. This goes both ways though. I'm far from an expert on the subject, but I've read very compelling arguments from people whose livelihood are significantly affected by EPA regulations that have missed the mark, or are enforced unfairly. A perfectly legitimate case can be made to modify some EPA regulations, but when that reasonable position is characterized as "eviscerating the EPA", well then we have another problem, because then both sides are not in a compromising mood, and that is what we need to accomplish anything.
- kelnos 10y ago> A perfectly legitimate case can be made to modify some EPA regulations, but when that reasonable position is characterized as "eviscerating the EPA", well then we have another problem Terminating the EPA entirely (https://www.congress.gov/bill/115th-congress/house-bill/861 https://www.congress.gov/bill/115th-congress/house-bill/861) is not a "reasonable position".
- pron 10y agoWalter Kirn made a similar argument[1] which you may enjoy reading in Harper's, but it is a subtle argument. He writes: > So here’s to the freedom to be led astray, which it would be folly to restrict, lest it foster complacency and tempt the devil. Because that’s what attracts him: foolproof safeguards. Like the one the Clinton campaign erected when, per WikiLeaks, it encouraged the nomination of a laughable, beatable “Pied Piper candidate” named Donald Trump. Or CNN’s belief in its ability to not only report the news but tell us which sources to ignore. > Assume you’re an imbecile, but, more important, consider that the imbecile across from you may be a genius in disguise. As we go forward, so many of us still secure in our contempt for the vulgar pretender and his sorry partisans, it’s a lesson worth remembering. It might prove helpful, even protective. Plus, it’s true. It's good that people are free to choose what to read and what to believe, and yet the current state of affairs is cause for concern nonetheless. A coin is "free to choose" whether to come up heads or tails, but if it comes up heads ninety times of a hundred tosses, it's reasonable to assume that the coin has a problem. Of course, you could always make the argument that nothing is a problem and that this is just the way the world is -- a growing number of people don't care about facts -- and this is what we are now. But all judgements of good vs. bad are ultimately based on a choice of values. Freedom is a value, as is respect for the truth. Believing that while everyone is free, stability requires that only a small portion would choose fiction over fact is a reasonable position. [1]: http://harpers.org/archive/2017/02/a-grim-fairy-tale/?single=1 http://harpers.org/archive/2017/02/a-grim-fairy-tale/?single...
- mistermann 10y agoGreat article, thanks. It's a bit comforting to see there are still some reasonable people in the media.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- zo1 10y agoBecause it's uncomfortable to accept. On the one hand, democracy is touted as the perfect system in terms of fairness. But then the intellectuals are not content with letting people choose how the people, their local communities and inspirational leaders have convinced them into voting. I.e. It becomes about controlling mind-share. Calling something out as "unfair", "biased", "propaganda", or "fake news" is one way of controlling the amount of mind-share it has with people that identify with it. So you can't just "let someone" have their "wrong" opinion, you have to "correct them". That is precisely what political correctness is, it's to "put down" unacceptable opinions with public witch hunts and legal pressure. I have no idea when it went from "leave people alone" with their probably "wrong" opinions, into "omg, you're not allowed to think/say that, you must be sexist/racist/homophobic and we'll make life a living hell for you, and we'll get you fired".
- mrec 10y ago> On the one hand, democracy is touted as the perfect system in terms of fairness. I don't disagree with your broader point, but I've never ever seen anyone tout democracy as "the perfect system in terms of fairness". Even back when it was the new hotness, writers on it (de Tocqueville et al) were very well aware of its flaws and failure modes.
- RyanZAG 10y agoIt's a shame you've been downvoted, but I think it just enforces your point on how uncomfortable it is for people to accept it.
- dredmorbius 10y agoPeople can choose a great many things. What they cannot choose, however, is what is truth, and what is reality. Reality has a way of imposing itself. And a disregard for reality on the part of some has a profound way of imposing itself on the many.
- Hermel 10y ago> If anything is destroying journalism, it's the fact that half this country does not care for fact vs fiction. If you take a closer look, the established media is not so innocent about that. Most of them find it perfectly ok to lie for money every few minutes (TV ads)...
- squarefoot 10y ago"Most of them find it perfectly ok to lie for money every few minutes (TV ads)..." Agreed, but if advertising first purpose was to tell verifiable facts it would have been called information. The problem here is people believing everything is thrown at them, especially if done by some popular figure.
- caisah 10y ago>it's the fact that half this country does not care for fact vs fiction. Sometimes is not that simple. A lot of this is related to personal biases and just the way the brain works. Ofcourse people can try to train theirselves into being more skeptic but in a world in which every day you are bombarded with information is pretty hard to find the time and motivation to do so.
- kensai 10y agoPersonal bias and brain tricks contributions are really blown out of proportions here. Most of the stuff that happens in the fact vs fiction is unfortunately of this aspect: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y5d4yVP7sNA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y5d4yVP7sNA
- TaylorAlexander 10y agoI feel like what you're saying is: humans have inherent flaws. Even if it were the case that Mark Zuckerburg was exploiting those flaws for personal benefit, I find it hard to blame him - we live in and support a society that encourages that behavior. If exploiting human flaws for profit is an undesired outcome for human organizations, we should work to stop encouraging that behavior. I will however provide a counter point to my own argument, which is that we should name and shame those who abuse human nature at society's expense for their own benefit. Otherwise we end up with a society full of people who are actively harming society. Honestly I don't know what to think. I just wanted to provide both of these views. I'm curious what the response to either views is.
- rustynails 10y agoThere are media codes of conduct. There are anti-discrimination laws. There are departments set up for supervising ethics. There are even people appointed specifically to monitor and stop prejudice. You would assume this would stop lying, manipulating, bullying and prejudice by the media but it does not. As an example, Hillary Clinton's exit speech was particularly sexist and _nobody_ in the media took her to task, "And to all the little girls who are watching this, never doubt that you are valuable, and powerful and deserving of every chance and opportunity in the world to pursue and achieve your own dreams." https://www.google.com.au/amp/www.cbc.ca/amp/1.3843541 https://www.google.com.au/amp/www.cbc.ca/amp/1.3843541 It's just one of many examples of prejudice and injustice that are pushed aggressively by almost every media outlet. When did we ever exclude kids based on their gender so blatantly and with such pride? How far we've regressed. A school near me is doing the same thing (Mount Carmel College). A co-ed school that shows almost only girls in their pictures/website/billboards, yet, there is not a single complaint from anyone. There is so much discrimination from so many sources that you'd have to be blind not to notice it. It's despicable to declare a gender war on little boys, yet, I see no one protesting, especially ideologies that talk the most about prejudice. Any time people point out these prejudices in public, you hear some glib comments about 50 years ago. You pull out the newspapers from 50 years ago to illustrate revisionist history and it is suddenly 100 years ago. This problem is systemic. The truth is that humanity seems to need a bogey man. Today, that's likely the "all Muslims are terrorists" and "any white male is privileged (irrespective of age)", leading to some extreme bullying. The only way for extremism to stop is to meet it head on, yet, not one "reputable" media outlet is willing to do so. Some say Breitbart is good, but, I found it sexist to the same degree that Ars Technica, The Verge, New York Times, etc are, just targeting the opposite gender. However, Breitbart is in the overwhelming minority (ie. sexist favouring males is the ~1% of media today). What we need is decent people willing to tackle the prejudice. For some reason, the protests of decent people remain almost unheard. Whether it's domestic violence by women, overwhelming predominance of male suicide, predominance of male cancer, overwhelming predominance of male homelessness, overwhelming predominance of male incarceration, extreme prejudice against boys in school education or any other male oriented topic, the media manipulates, lies, misrepresents and bullies. To give a small example, how many times have you heard prostate cancer is a joke and almost nobody dies from it? Compare the stats yourself: MORE incidents than breast cancer and MORE deaths, despite the constant snipes by many media outlets to the contrary. https://prostate-cancer.canceraustralia.gov.au/statistics https://prostate-cancer.canceraustralia.gov.au/statistics https://canceraustralia.gov.au/affected-cancer/cancer-types/breast-cancer/breast-cancer-statistics https://canceraustralia.gov.au/affected-cancer/cancer-types/... Society desperately needs people to protest vigorously. Hold Ars Technica, The Verge, Vox, Vulture, Daily Beast, New York Times, BBC, News Corp, etc accountable. Throw the book at the lot of them! Huge fines will fund more cases against other media outlets.
- frik 10y agoWhat is destroying journalism is also relying too much on news sources like AP, Reuters, etc. Let's call it copy&paste news articles. They should do their homework and investigate on their own, that's their job description after all. We don't need these cheap media that just reprint propaganda-style sponsored stories.
- aanm1988 10y ago> We don't need these cheap media that just reprint propaganda-style sponsored stories. What's destroying journalism is people like you calling out media as propaganda, fake news, etc...
- crowbahr 10y agoI mean sometimes reporters do a fantastic job and sometimes in the rush to get the story while it's hot there are legitimately bad stories run as God's given truth. I do think the buzzwords need to die. Everyone calls everything they don't agree with fake news these days.
- kelnos 10y agoWell, yes and no. Does the media sometimes present propaganda and fake news as fact? Sure. Not always, but sure, it happens. Calling out specific media outlets when they do this is absolutely necessary. Of course, labeling media as fake news simply because the facts they report disagree with your ideology is dishonest and reprehensible.
- 3825 10y agoAlso syndication is probably not as important online when you could just link to the article source. Also negative "news" sells better. Humans just respond to fear and hatred. It is just so much easier to fear and to hate. I'll admit to it. I feel suspicious when I see something positive in the news: is this a sponsored post?
- dredmorbius 10y agoPropaganda on the part of a media instution as a whole is manifested by a persistent bias. Making occasional errors isn't a sign of bias. Correcting those errors is a key part (and running the correction prominantly) of not being biased. It's been observed that the principle bias of many major commercial media is inherently pro-establishment.
- r3bl 10y ago> it's the fact that half this country does not care for fact vs fiction. I know Facebook is a US-based product and everything, but I'm really getting sick and tired of products that are used all over the world getting adjusted just because they are a problem now in the US. First we had "fake news" (which used to be called just propaganda), which we have dealt with long before Internet was even a big thing in our region[0]. Now this. Media survives just fine here. Most people still don't use adblockers and most people are ready to donate for good quality journalism (in fact, there's a Serbian-based investigative reporting center that's currently making an excellent progress in moving away from grants to one-time donations by their readers, and there are other digital-only media sources across Europe which are even breaking records living off of subscriptions by being transparent and talkative to their audience[1]). But nope, instead of doing their own thing, they're going to have to adjust because Facebook wants to promote more "local" things to encourage "civil engagement" because a "research suggests it" (keep in mind there's not a single mention of what that research might actually be, neither in the article itself, nor in the manifesto). You have separate sections in every newspaper what so ever, and unlike in Facebook's very specific, and very tailored to every individual bubbles, at least you skim through the headlines from other sections while you're trying to locate something you will actually read. That alone makes you more informed about what is going on more than Facebook's bubbles ever will. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Propaganda_during_the_Yugoslav_Wars https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Propaganda_during_the_Yugoslav... [1] https://medium.com/de-correspondent https://medium.com/de-correspondent
- arjie 10y agoThat's what being the little guy is. If you want different results you have to be the big guy. Can't be helped.
- makapuf 10y agoWell you know sometimes many little guys can join together and get the/some power cause they can be sufficiently damaging/deathly to the big guy. Democracy, multipolar world...
- 10y ago
- arjie 10y agoIt doesn't matter how many Pulitzers the NYT has if they print Judith Miller garbage. The NYT are the paragons of wishful news. I unsubscribed from them early during this last election because they were selling bullshit. And boy! Was that a good decision or what! How many of the people who hold up the NYT as some ideal actually subscribe? I'll be surprised if it's anything but a tiny number. Journalism is dying because journalists think they should write about what they want to be true. And the NYT is leading that charge. I'll tell you something, though. They had a couple of very good articles that really stood out. And those also had exceptional prose.
- pron 10y ago> half this country does not care for fact vs fiction. I think what's even more troubling is that this isn't just changing fashions, but that some are actively trying to shake people's faith in the truth.
- sreenadh 10y ago>it's the fact that half this country does not care for fact vs fiction. I believe it's less to do with not caring to not understanding the system. Coming from a world where newspapers ensured to report only correct info and corrected incase of error. People expect that the internet is also the same. Many are surprised to know that Wikipedia articles are peer submitted and reviewed. Many assumed its from a company like Encyclopaedia Britannica. Just an online version, instead of the heavy books.
- the-dude 10y ago> Coming from a world where newspapers ensured to report only correct info and corrected incase of error. This world never existed, sorry.
- skookumchuck 10y agoWhenever I tune in to CNN to catch the latest news, all I see are "analysis" shows where various people sit around and argue or otherwise editorialize.
- splike 10y agoMaybe the facts themselves were slanted to one side
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- whitemale 10y ago> In my opinion. If anything is destroying journalism, it's the fact that half this country does not care for fact vs fiction. Too bad we don't know which half and which news is fiction. > If some guy with a catchy domain name can produce content that goes viral, it doesn't matter how many Pulitzer the NYTimes has. The NYTimes can have all the awards in the world if they publish articles that you can demonstrate beyond doubt to be bullshit or dishonesty. > If anything, as someone who actually cares about facts, the latest changes in my Facebook newsfeed has gotten me to read a lot more publications because my friends are sharing stories from journals I don't normally read. You should always look at what the other side has to offer, I talk to people who have polar opposite beliefs to mine on a regular basis, keeps me informed and makes me re-evaluate my own position.
- sjy 10y ago> The NYTimes can have all the awards in the world if they publish articles that you can demonstrate beyond doubt to be bullshit or dishonesty. What articles did you have in mind? The NYT's reporting on WMDs in Iraq is often raised as an example of 'fake news,' but I think the failure of the fact-checking process and subsequent investigation and apology [1] is to the NYT's credit. Investigative journalists have to make judgment calls about their sources and sometimes they get it wrong, but I've never seen an NYT article 'that you can demonstrate beyond doubt to be dishonesty.' Factual errors and misleading language do slip in regularly, resulting in frank corrections or the publication of dissenting views. That's more than you can say for most 'alternative' news sources. [1] http://www.nytimes.com/2004/05/26/world/from-the-editors-the-times-and-iraq.html http://www.nytimes.com/2004/05/26/world/from-the-editors-the...
- shriphani 10y ago"it's the fact that half this country does not care for fact vs fiction." I posit that this number is close to 95% worldwide. People are all the same - impulsive and vulnerable. I've spoken to some perfectly normal immigrants from various parts of the world and have heard some properly batshit insane stuff - any other time we would have assigned them a round-the-clock nurse. And guess what - it makes zero difference to their life what they believe. Beliefs need to collide with reality (through decisions, actions etc).
- amelius 10y ago> If anything is destroying journalism, it's the fact that half this country does not care for fact vs fiction. If you simply consider your world to be the other half of the country (that does care about correct news), then there is not much of a problem. If, however, you need to please shareholders, then, yes, you have a problem.
- TheRealDunkirk 10y ago> If anything is destroying journalism, it's the fact that half this country does not care for fact vs fiction. (You sure stirred it up with this one.) But it's not really true, is it? The better way to describe the situation would be to say that the ~35% at BOTH ends of the political spectrum only wants to hear and read "news" that confirms their biases. And "journalism," as a business, has given them that. What I'm saying is that we don't have a "facts" OR a "news" problem. We have an ideological division/superiority problem, and I don't know if anything can fix that. Well, short of splitting the country into 3 parts: the 2 coasts, and flyover country, and letting them all go hard towards their biases, and checking back in on the results in about 50 years, and see which experiment worked better.
- 0x445442 10y agoGood analysis and you've touched on something very important; is multiculturalism really the best option? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criticism_of_multiculturalism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criticism_of_multiculturalism I look at the pros & cons of a place like Japan and wonder.
- dandersh 10y agoNo, the person you quoted is absolutely correct. A frustrating part of political discourse is that most people don't bother to put in the time and energy to understand the things they talk about, largely because it does matter enough to them to actually be right.
- mistermann 10y agoAs someone "on the right", I think you hit the nail on the head. At least for me, I have no problem at all admitting there are tons of faults among people on my side of the spectrum, seeing someone point out the same for the left is extremely rare. Out of curiosity, which "side" are you on predominantly?
- 0x445442 10y agoAgree with your post but you only highlighted half the problem. More of the population is turning to alternative news sources because their trust of source like the NYTimes, WAPO and CNN has been violated. I'm pretty sure you weren't holding the Times up as some bastion of truth but to deny their blatant bias in reporting is folly. Withholding facts, failing to pursue facts or making the decision only to pursue facts you agree with politically is as bad as just making shit up. The blueprint that's destroying journalism is the chase of profits over the chase of ALL truth. Now, I do agree that large segments of the electorate are becoming less able to parse information effectively but I think there's still enough folks left that would gladly pay straight up subscription fees if they thought they could trust the information they were paying for.
- ZoeZoeBee 10y agoI always get a chuckle when people mention the number of Pulitzers the NY Times has, Pulitzer himself was a master provocateur and spreader of yellow journalism, aka Fake News
- paulsutter 10y agoThe author doesn't realize that whatever Mark Zuckerberg does next, it's likely to fail. But Facebook will learn far more for trying than the news community will learn from sticking to the same old same old. News will get reinvented, and the optimist in me hopes it will be a much better product than it is today. But that process will be hard to predict and the winners will be among the folks who take risks and try new approaches.
- fatalogic 10y agoI just wish it was easier to find unbiased news. Just a list of facts no slant either way.
- JoshTriplett 10y agoEven a list of facts can include bias, by which facts it includes and which it omits. There exists no unbiased source of news. Better to have information, along with documentation of any potential sources of bias, evaluate that for yourself with the caveats included, and give it appropriately discounted weight.
- zo1 10y agoIf we take that further, perhaps we need to fix the discoverability and verifiability of facts and statistics. There needs to be a single store, or repository of it all. Until that happens, news is just a "peek" at something, which will inevitably include bias.
- Natsu 10y agoI hear you. I want more facts, less opinion, and a good list of verifiable sources out of my news. Suffice it to say, there's precious little of that to be found anywhere.
- sparkzilla 10y agoWe are working on this problem at Newslines. We collect news into timelines, comprised of just-the-fact summaries. We are looking for more contributors to bring us up to date with our Donald Trump newsline http://newslines.org/donald-trump/ http://newslines.org/donald-trump/
- 0x445442 10y agoSorry, I read through the FAQ real quick and did not see how this site in any way solves the two fundamental problems: 1.) Is what's reported actually true? 2.) Is what's reported only half the truth so as to advance a prescribed narrative?
- mberning 10y agoThe death throes of this loathesome industry are glorious to behold. The idea that this is fact vs viction, real vs fake news, etc. shows how much these people have lost the plot.
- rjvir 10y agoThis chart (https://twitter.com/benthompson/status/778260618914652164 https://twitter.com/benthompson/status/778260618914652164) suggests that Facebook should not a lone scapegoat for journalism's decline - the internet as a whole is a more reasonable target.
- bigbugbag 10y agoHaven't you noticed how the word "facebook" replaced "the internet/online" in many contexts ? It was a part of marketing facebook to the masses. Then again the decline of journalism is not a matter of internet as much than a matter of selling out to advertisers and being bought by rich individuals or corporations. With internet access becoming popular it provided an alternative to the traditional media to get news and information.
- pg314 10y ago> a matter of selling out to advertisers and being bought by rich individuals or corporations. Can you expand on that? I see the decline in circulation and eroding of their ad and classified income as the principal culprit. I haven't seen any prominent examples of newspapers where the rich individuals or corporations have caused a decline. The Washington Post was thriving during the 40 years that Buffett had an ownership stake.
- WildUtah 10y agoFacebook should not a lone scapegoat Actually it was Craigslist. Back before the internet, the single biggest pot of newspaper revenue was classified ads.
- kraftomatic 10y agoI think Craigslist is a US problem. Internationally I think the traditional news approach has had many different challenges. Classified advertising also has had different challenges around the world, such as dedicated publications.
- 10y ago
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- onion2k 10y agoNews organisations are finding that if your product has too little value that you have to support it with advertising instead of selling it directly then your business will fail as soon as someone figures out a better way of delivering adverts. In the future I suspect Facebook and Google will have the exact same problem.
- dingo_bat 10y agoYup, the mainstream media is dying because of facebook. Very fascinating. Let's see who else they can blame.
- gamesbrainiac 10y agoI think the real threat to journalism is the fact that news outlets have decided to "cater" to a certain section of the population. I don't think Facebook started or is to blame for the demise of journalism, but outlets like Fox show deep systemic problems in the world of journalism.
- Animats 10y agoCrowd-sourcing news quality does not work. There's no ground truth. Google News is suffering from this. I noted on Wikipedia today, in a discussion of reliable sources, that I had searched for info about a Wikipedia topic with Google news search, with terrible results. The top three results were Algemeiner (Jewish), Breitbart News (alt-right), and Mondoweiss ("progressive and anti-Zionist"). This is pathetic.
- WildUtah 10y agoThose three are probably more reliably accurate than Atlantic, NYTimes, WaPo and the other old properties that have distinguished themselves only with lies and credulity in this century. Breitbart is now the third most read news source in America, so things are looking up.
- funkychicken 10y ago.
- Natsu 10y agoWeird. I can't seem to find the CS Monitor any more, whereas my health section gets flooded by marijuana news from what appear to be advocacy sites.
- paradite 10y agoI assume they were ranked by views or CTR, which is perfectly normal given the current circumstances. How else can Google News rank them? Follow some news media objectivity ranking on imgur? Hire tons of unbiased people to verify the integrity of all news before adding them into the index? I'm not playing devil's advocate here but given an uninformed electorate, some form of authoritative truth by either a independent watchdog or government agency is probably a better idea than letting private companies run the media.
- Animats 10y agoThere was an effort at Google last year to measure site objectivity. I met the woman running it when she gave a talk in EE380 at Stanford. They have a a database of hard facts, and they're trying to check sites to see if they contradict them. This reduces the site's credibility metric. This was aimed more at medical promotion than politics. The technology was still R&D back then, not production.
- dirkg 10y agoMost people in this country are idiots, and celebrate idiocy. People in Asia/Europe still read newspapers and news is still news, not sensationalist media garbage like here with barely any mention of the rest of the world.
- indy 10y agoI think you're over estimating the media in the rest of the world.
- amiga-workbench 10y agoHave you ever read the Daily Mail?
- DenisM 10y agoHere's an interesting observation. Distributing information in its written form used to be the domain of the Church. Printing press has democratized that, for a while. Eventually the diversity of information was roped in to serve the agenda of the new, capitalist elites. While individual journalists often thrive to deliver the best work, the editors inevitably arrange things to serve the interests of particular business groups, and those who don't toe the line fall into obscurity for lack of funds. Now, the Internet has produced a new information diversity, which is bubbling and foaming as we speak. That too will get roped in. The viral effect will become the domain of well-funded teams, not of lone geniuses. As the art is perfected it will become more capital-intensive, we will see consolidation in the business. Eventually the bulk of it will be divided between few large players, well-aligned with other businesses, and the whole thing will become orderly and predictable once again. Maybe.
- erikpukinskis 10y agoThe difference between the printing press and the internet is that you and me could make a whole new Internet happen with just two $70 handheld computing devices. The printing press needed a newsroom with typists and ad salesmen and a team of people wrestling with an ink belching mechanical beast. The minimum corporate interest required to feed such a beast is substantially more than the Internet business, the physical plant of which costs pennies a day in overhead to maintain (i.e. your cell phone and a few gigs of bandwidth.)
- DenisM 10y agoMoney still buys you a lot of upgrades to your $70 internet. Ad campaigns, talented copy writers, data scientist, psychologists, computing resources for data analysis, large training datasets, cross-channel promotion (e.g. internet + billboards), astroturfers, community management, marketing, focus groups. The amateur hour will come to an end. Especially now that the presidential election campaign has shown us how it's done.
- erikpukinskis 10y ago
- hxta98596 10y agoThis is an odd editorial. The author stretches to explain how Zuck's Manifesto released this week could destroy journalism. But then she provides evidence that journalism is for all intents and purposes already dead. She cites a (possibly inflated) prime time news audience size of ~3 million people, and 1.5 million digital subscribers for the NYT...So less than 1% of America are using these previously major sources of news. How did that happen guys? I'm the last person you will find defending Zuck or Facebook (which I do not use and have deleted other apps as facebook buys them). But this Atlantic article felt like a desperate plea for charity of some sort, and preferably cash since the Chan-Zuckerberg Empire has so much. This is yet another editorial complaining about themselves but the author does not offer an alternative idea for journalism to avoid its own demise. Why and how would she? Journalists don't seem to understand business at all and are scared to try. In just 3 months since the election, journalists and many people in this country seem to have forgotten how biased, incompetent, clueless, fake and corrupt even the "real" news organizations are today. There was no mea culpa in the article for these issues, just a misguided complaint. The pre-internet old days were not so perfect either if anyone reads history...can anyone explain why newspapers, these supposed bastions of objectivity for communities, even endorse political candidates? Is that a newspapers job? This whole situation reminds me of another time there was a Harvard guy's looong manifesto that no one had the patience to read in full and it was on a very similar topic...the news industry was running around like a chicken with its head cut off back then too [1]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ted_Kaczynski#Industrial_Society_and_Its_Future https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ted_Kaczynski#Industrial_Socie...
- kraftomatic 10y agoI agree: journalism has let it's industry fall in to disrepute . It's no surprise that people are so easily convinced to move to new models of information delivery when you look at the current state of news organisations.
- cylinder 10y agoI'm surprised the left has become so sympathetic to the corporate media all of a sudden. These people colluded to stop a once in a lifetime opportunity in Bernie Sanders to help their friend and collaborator Hillary Clinton, and so we ended up with Donald Trump. This was only a year ago.
- techmohib 10y agoMark does make a lot of sense. Fake News is destroying out community. Instead of only generating catchy headlines to increase viewership why not do somework and discover amazing content to publish.
- narrator 10y agoThere wouldn't be all this running around trying to fix everything if the person that was supposed to win had won the election.
- ww520 10y agoMSM are losing the status as the gatekeepers of dispensing news, boohoo. They have done that to themselves.
- uabstraction 10y agoWhile the traditional media has been asleep at the wheel for a long time now, I find myself incredibly worried at this juncture. Social media prevails over traditional media if - and only if - the system is not being abused. Unfortunately, it appears that social media is being manipulated in massive, shocking, unprecedented ways, which is why I believe Zuckerburg is going on his save the world campaign. The idiot opened Pandora's box[1], and now social media has become the instrument of data-driven electioneering and reactive targeted propaganda campaigns. We have hit a paradox in news publication. If we let everyone disseminate the news, we end up with Lord of the Flies esque cults surrounding every rumor. If we only allowed figures of authority to disseminate the news, we'll never know if a story was intentionally buried or misrepresented. There's no easy answer here. This is human nature. [1] https://www.scout.ai/story/the-rise-of-the-weaponized-ai-propaganda-machine https://www.scout.ai/story/the-rise-of-the-weaponized-ai-pro...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- rampage101 10y agoThe media is not needed anymore to tell us what to think. We are able to research anything now with the internet, so it's much harder for the media to spread falsehoods now.
- TheRealDunkirk 10y agoIf there's one "fake news" story that tops the list, in my opinion, it's the killing of Michael Brown in Ferguson. When the ACTUAL facts came to light, via autopsy, it was clear he had not been an innocent victim of a racist cop with a grudge. He had just robbed a store, and then fought with the cop, and tried to take his gun. He was shot while CHARGING the officer, head down, hands at his sides. NONE of that was immediately available on the internet, yet millions and millions of people seized on that opportunity to fill in the blanks. The actual report took weeks to generate, as it should, and by the time it came out, there was an entire national movement ("hands up; don't shoot") that was based on a fantastical lie. How do "we," as a society, function and thrive when there are people like those leading the BLM movement, who are willing to seize on fake news, and create entire polemical fictions, well aware of their specious basis, trying to extract what personal benefit they can from the situation until the truth comes to light?
- cerved 10y ago"One analyst told The New York Times last year that 85 percent of all online advertising revenue is funneled to either Facebook or Google—leaving a paltry 15 percent for news organizations to fight over." I stopped reading here since the author obviously doesn't know what he/she is talking about and didn't bother looking it up.
- RileyKyeden 10y agoThe article in question: https://www.nytimes.com/2016/04/18/business/media-websites-battle-falteringad-revenue-and-traffic.html?_r=0 https://www.nytimes.com/2016/04/18/business/media-websites-b... > Advertisers adjusted spending accordingly. In the first quarter of 2016, 85 cents of every new dollar spent in online advertising will go to Google or Facebook, said Brian Nowak, a Morgan Stanley analyst. I don't know if it's accurate, but New York Times citing an analyst at a major financial services firm seems more credible than user "cerved" on Hacker News. Do you have better information?
- cerved 10y agoOkay so look at the two quotes "85 percent of all online advertising revenue is funneled to either Facebook or Google" and "85 cents of every new dollar spent in online advertising" One proclaims that two companies take 85% of all online ad revenue, the other 85% of the growth in one quarter. So the first problem is the reference to the source is incorrect. The other is the assumption that only news orgs and Google and Facebook are the ones taking a part of the pie. Disregarding the other hundreds of companies that are a part of the online advertising ecosystem as well as other types of publishers. I would assert that the Atlantic misquoting a quote from the New York Times, which is a quote from a note a Morgan Stanley analyst wrote to clients the 7th of April 2016 is in and of itself not credible. I don't know the real figures but one could calculate this by estimating global ad spend in 2016, take Google and Facebooks ad revenue minus the cost of revenue, ie money spend on buying ads from publishers (ie. news organisations etc), and compare that to other actors. Bottom line, I refer to my previous point that the author doesn't know what he/she is talking about.
- dredmorbius 10y ago
- arca_vorago 10y agoIf you aren't discussing operation mockingbird and the consolidation and monopolization of the parent corps along with the editorial influence that comes with you are nowhere close to understanding the real problem. Without understanding the real problem, any proposed solution will be lacking.
- venning 10y ago> "news...has always been subsidized by the advertising dollars his company now commands" Is this true? Have there been times when news was funded by other means than advertising?
- ThomPete 10y agoI think the problem with journalism is that it was never the actual business. What it was, were supporting and adding sophistication to the news industry, but it was never actually central to the business. But the value of news was that it didnt used to be widely available. That was actually what people paid for. The news and clssifieds, not the journalism. And so what we see are all these people in the news industry trying to improve their business by improving journalism.
- eigenvalue 10y agoThe actual business was really the classified advertisement section, which was killed by Craigslist and eBay!
- StreamBright 10y agoThe problem with "journalism" is that it got degraded to infotainment over the last decade and there is barely any real journalism left. If you have to make money, you have to cater to a large group of people and also for your advertisers. This essentially making sure most of your output is clickbait titles and nothing too crazy. There are few exceptions though like the intercept and similar news outlets.
- cylinder 10y agoEntertainment is the product. See Neil Postman's Amused to Death. If people really wanted quality journalism, they'd be lining up to pay for it. This is not a market failure.
- dredmorbius 10y agoNB: Amusing Ourselves to Death https://www.worldcat.org/title/amusing-ourselves-to-death/oclc/699013936&referer=brief_results https://www.worldcat.org/title/amusing-ourselves-to-death/oc...
- DanielBMarkham 10y agoWe as an industry have kicked around "how to save journalism" for years now. Here's what I've got: If you want journalism, sponsor endowments for journalists to report in certain areas, like foreign policy or local government. At the same time, and critically, sponsor endowments for editors to put a tight reign on these journalists. Completely decouple good journalism for hunting-for-eyeballs. Then let the content curators and aggregators make some kind of business out of it, if they can. In the past, whenever we consumed quality content, it was always there because some commercial interest paid for it to be there. Somehow we've forgotten about that. There has always been a difference between what the commercial interests wanted and what quality content demanded, but in the past the feedback loop was so slow and diffuse that good content happened anyway. This is no longer the case. So if you want good content, you're going to have to completely decouple it from commercial interests -- and apply rigorous quality standards as well. Good editors are sorely missing in modern content creation, and everybody seems to want to take the old models, including ad-sponsored material, and make them work. They will not work.
- captainlego 10y agoWould it be feasible to address the problem by passing laws that would penalize news organizations who publish/promote blatantly false information?
- snarf21 10y agoI agree with you but the unsolved problem is the "... and make some kind of business out of it, if they can". Netflix is $10 a month and look at all the value you get there. News will have to be half or (maybe much) less than that. Can you build a good news product on $1/month? I'm not sure you can. Additionally, how do you make people actually want the news? A sound bite or tweet or headline is super easy to digest and doesn't take a lot of time and makes people feel like they are in the know. Just regurgitate any article title and you're an expert. On top of that is the click baiting for eyeballs (driven by ad money) removing at least the journalistic integrity of putting out information with some basis of fact. True news will always have some bias but we have to find a way for it to not be ad supported. The only way I see that happening is some kind of subscription or independently wealthy patron.
- XnoiVeX 10y agoThe Atlantic admitted there is no money in news back in 2014. Interesting quote in that article: "Don't worry about Facebook" https://www.theatlantic.com/national/archive/2014/03/starting-a-news-organization-heres-how-youll-make-money/359662/ https://www.theatlantic.com/national/archive/2014/03/startin...
- Klockan 10y agoI tend to prefer wikipedia over traditional news outlets since their editors actually cares about unbiased truth instead of sensationalist garbage. If I could find a news outlet that had the same quality as good wikipedia articles then I would be happy, but even supposedly respected outlets like WSJ publishes crap like this: https://www.wsj.com/articles/disney-severs-ties-with-youtube-star-pewdiepie-after-anti-semitic-posts-1487034533 https://www.wsj.com/articles/disney-severs-ties-with-youtube... The sooner traditional sensationalist journalism dies the better.
- seanot 10y agoThe author cites research that ties a downfall in civic engagement to the demise of local news coverage. While I find this correlation to be obvious (to my line of thinking), she assigns no responsibility for this demise to her peers -- the ones writing news and opinion. In the large Midwestern cities in which I have lived, local newspapers generally choose to align themselves on the side of local governments and chambers-of-commerce on virtually every new development subsidy or tax deal regardless of the costs to be incurred by local residents and businesses and/or the sketchiness of the scheme. Readers look to the fourth estate for a voice when elected representatives collude with special interests. If they are merely mouthpieces and cheerleaders for those in power, readers will look elsewhere or disengage.
- dredmorbius 10y agoI.F. Stone had a great deal to say on journalistic independence in a 1974 public television interview on "Day at Night". https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=qV3gO3zxQ1g https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=qV3gO3zxQ1g Small-town papers are beholden to small-town interests. Stone notes that the large-city and national dailies (NY Times, Washington Post, LA Times, possibly the Boston Globe, the Wall Street Journal at the itme) were freed of dependence on any one advertiser (or political interest). That may have been a peculiar circumstance of the 1960s and 1970s.
- oever 10y agoThe last observation in that interview is still current. > The president, irrespective of who he is, today, is so powerful that the temptations of the office for good or evil are too great for any one man. I think we ought to begin to dismantle the office. I think we ought to have a head of state symbolizing the country around whom the natural feeling of patriotism and reverence accrue and separate him from the head of the government.
- erikpukinskis 10y agoThis will happen naturally as small scale self e-gocernance takes on more and more responsibility. As the responsibilities of the state dry up, city, state, and federal government figures naturally become more figureheads. It will be a race to who has the best parades and funnest hats.
- jondubois 10y agoFacebook is scary. It ought to be heavily regulated or nationalised entirely. The side effects it has had on society are catastrophic. Once FB gets a monopoly on news, it'll be able to control everyone.
- Oxitendwe 10y ago>The side effects it has had on society are catastrophic. >It out to be nationalized entirely. You don't think those two things are at odds with each other? Why do you think the federal government will be any more trustyworthy than Mark Zuckerberg? Not to mention that then it will have no incentive to improve or make a profit.
- whatupmd 10y agoWatch an NPR or PBS newscast once in awhile. Seems pretty balanced to me.
- jondubois 10y agoThe government has no financial incentive to turn a profit - All the proceeds would go to back to government projects or be wasted on bureaucracy. Nobody who works for government at any point in the chain could benefit financially from this; that is why the government is far more trustworthy than Mark Zuckerberg and his executive friends. The idea that a few wealthy FB shareholders can profit from using other people's data to manipulate those people's behaviour illustrates the problem very clearly. What's worse is that even if you are not susceptible to FB's targeted advertising directly, FB will trick your friends and family into a particular behaviour pattern and then force you to follow suite. It's just like when FB was in its early growth stages; even people who resisted joining FB initially gave in once all their friends had joined up... People would get offended if you didn't add them as friends on Facebook. It's the same principle at play here except it's around lifestyle and consumerism. I actually think that this "don't trust the government" propaganda was masterminded by tech companies (on the back of the Edward Snowden drama) to help their own corporate agendas. 50 years ago, it would never have even occurred to anyone that a profit-making entity could be more trustworthy than the government because it makes absolutely no sense.
- ForrestN 10y agoI recently saw a very astute analogy between Facebook and cigarette companies. I suspect that in some years there will be testimony about what Facebook knew, and when, with respect to the addictiveness of its product and its links to mental health problems. I'm quite sure they know how harmful their product is and that's probably behind a lot of this absurd "we're going to save the world" rhetoric. This whole fight elevates Facebook, so they'll try their best to keep people talking about it. In the sphere of journalism, it's very hard to say what is cause and effect. Facebook aside, and even money aside, some journalists will say that good journalism isn't widely read, and that readers have driven the shift to shallow, celebrity-driven coverage. Facebook can make the same argument—this is what people want, who are we to question them? I agree with the others that point to Journalism's business model as the problem. It's a public good to bring hidden facts related to the public interest into the light. We as a society should subsidize these efforts the way we do other sources of public good that aren't viable as profitable businesses: let them become non-profit organizations and support them with donations and tax incentives. This protects their independence and also removes the regressive paywalls that signal to poor people that knowledge of the day's events is not for them. Facebook, in general, needs to ask much more fundamental questions than how it affects the news. What is the product for? What does it actually do? Is its responsibility to earn profit in conflict with the interests of its users? Is it being candid with the public about how its product affects its users? Or is it just reacting to PR crises as they happen without actually taking responsibility for its place in the world?
- thr0waway1239 10y agoRemember Steve Jobs' quote about A players hiring A players? There is a similar pattern at play here where the D-level folks (in terms of ethics) hire E and F-level folks and on it goes. You only need one ethically compromised individual at the top - e.g. Zuck, and soon the org is infested with replicas of similarly compromised folks. >>respect to the addictiveness of its product You forgot to mention that this addictiveness is not even a natural thing - it has been refined and A/B tested with 1% improvement week over week until the user base has been turned into the 21st century version of Pavlov's dogs - that image is exactly what I see when I look at people who get anxiety over a lack of instant messages for a WHOLE 15 MINUTES.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- dredmorbius 10y agoSince much of the discussion here is revolving around what journalism is or isn't or when its heyday was, or what its economic foundations were, I thought I'd share some of the research I've been making into the history and background. The term "journalism" itself dates from 1821. http://www.etymonline.com/index.php?term=journalism http://www.etymonline.com/index.php?term=journalism The US mass newspaper industry dates from the mid-1800s. Yes, there were earlier instances of things called "newspapers", and some advertisements, and some magazines, and other means of distributing news. But none of these really jive with our current use of the terms. Specific advances in economics and technology in particular drove the change. From the absolutely fascinating (and, warning: massive time-sink) History of Information: Economic & Technological Advances Spur the Development of Newspapers in the U.S. (Circa 1800 – 1840) http://historyofinformation.com/expanded.php?id=4792 http://historyofinformation.com/expanded.php?id=4792 Dates and qualifications are numerous and various, and there's plenty of room for argument. But if the discussion is of a daily publication distributed on the events of the day, widely read through the general population, and supported through commercial means, then you require 1) high-speed communications (telegraph, phone, or better), 2) high-speed presses (steam, diesel, or electric drive), 3) iron or steel framed presses (for speed and durability), 4) distribution (intra- or inter-city, meaning posts or better), 5) manufacturing and distribution capable of supporting advertising-promoted wares, and the real biggie, 6) general literacy within the population. None of these existed prior to 1800. Generally, full flourishing didn't occur until roughly 1880, though the pieces were falling in place before then. For much of the 19th century, newspapers were largely party-run, not-for-profit. Prior to 1800, newspapers as we know them really didn't exist. Pamphlets were the typical mechanism through about 1500. Before that, "mass media" usually meant "the Church", in Europe. Hamilton Holt, a magazine publisher himself, gave a view of the commercial periodicals business in a 1909 lecture at the University of California, "Commercialism and Journalism". He leads with a statistical account of the growth of the publishing industry from 1850 to 1905, in revenues, circulation, publications, and more. Much of the piece looks at the influence of advertising-driven interests on what is covered in publications. https://archive.org/details/commercialismjou00holtuoft https://archive.org/details/commercialismjou00holtuoft From Robert J. Gordon's The Rise and Fall of American Growth, an interesting statistic: the fall in newspaper subscriptions, measured in terms of subscriptions per household, has fallen at a nearly constant rate since the 1950s. The decline in newspaper journalism is a very long-term secular trend. I'd also strongly recommend David Simon's "The Audacity of Despair", a 70 minute lecture at UC Berkeley. Warning: Simon is not a great speaker, and yes, this is long, but he makes some exceptionally good and cogent points. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=nRt46W3k-qw https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=nRt46W3k-qw Another useful resource is "Introduction to Communication Science" by MOOC ICS, a fast-paced but solid introduction to the field of communication science. The segments are brief but well-produced and relevant. Elizabeth Eisenstein, The Printing Press as an Agent of Change is very strongly recommended on this topic. http://www.worldcat.org/title/printing-press-as-an-agent-of-change-communications-and-cultural-trans/oclc/240246401 http://www.worldcat.org/title/printing-press-as-an-agent-of-... Her paper, "Some Conjectures about the Impace of Printing on Western Society and Thought: A Preliminary Report" (1968) covers much of the ground though in far less detail, it's a good overview to her subsequent life's work. http://www.journals.uchicago.edu/doi/abs/10.1086/240164?journalCode=jmh http://www.journals.uchicago.edu/doi/abs/10.1086/240164?jour... (Full text available via http://sci-hub.cc http://sci-hub.cc) The History of Information has a topic covering journalism including to earlier dates. The premise Lauren makes of a commercial practice of journalism prior to 1800 is very poorly supported. There's some argument which can be tenuously made to claims of "newspapers" in the 1700s or 1600s, but they're a long cry from what we see today, and were not generally read. http://historyofinformation.com/expanded.php?category=News+Media+/+Journalism http://historyofinformation.com/expanded.php?category=News+M...