13 ms·
GM to build, test thousands of self-driving Bolts in 2018
- sheeshkebab 10y ago>"If you assume the cost of these autonomous vehicles, the very early ones, will be six figures, there aren’t very many retail customers that are willing to go out and spend that kind of money," Ableson said. Oh well I guess it will be a few years before I can recline and take a nap in my robo car while in traffic
- Cyph0n 10y agoIt will probably take longer than that. I've yet to see a non-tech demo fully self-driving car. If I'm being optimistic, I'd say 2020 at the very least for early models.
- pkamb 10y agoYou'll never own a robo car, Uber and Lyft and Tesla and GM will.
- jonknee 10y agoWhy not? It's a technology problem and technology almost magically gets cheaper over time. I don't see why it won't eventually be like all the other required safety features (airbags, ABS, etc). If you live in the middle of SF it might sound silly to own an autonomous vehicle, but if you live out in rural Sonoma County it is going to sound a lot less silly. I frequently go out to the mountains and I doubt I'm going to want to call an Uber to load all my camping gear into and be gone for a week.
- paulddraper 10y agoI live in the suburbs and I go on road trips all the time with the family. About half of my neighbors own RVs. Self-driving vehicles would be a dream come true.
- ghaff 10y agoFurthermore, if it's your own vehicle, fully autonomous mode under certain pre-defined conditions and roads can still be a huge win. But that constraint makes the same vehicles basically uninteresting as a shared vehicle taxi service for the near term. It's great that all this work is being done but IMO summoning Johnny cab to take you home from a bar in SF is decades away.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- dllu 10y agoEvery Cruise Automation Chevy Bolt is using two Velodyne HDL-32E, each of which has a list price of $30,000. Price aside, Velodyne is really struggling to produce these units. Some recent HN comments have mentioned lead times of 40 weeks [1], though the upcoming Velodyne factory should alleviate these issues in 2018 [1]. We will need miracles in lidar technology for GM to hit their target of thousands of vehicles next year. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13470401 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13470401
- Fricken 10y agoMiracles in Lidar are coming. Quanergy, Infineon, Innoviz and Velodyne are all rushing to technologize solid state Lidar, which offers comparable performance specs to the spinning kfc bucket at quoted prices ranging from $250-$40. Imagine all the places we'll be using Lidar if it gets that cheap, the applications extend well beyond self driving cars.
- coredog64 10y agoFrom a capitalism point of view, the high price and long lead times imply that the market is signalling that it would like new entrants. Does Velodyne own patents that would keep out other players?
- toomuchtodo 10y ago>"If you assume the cost of these autonomous vehicles, the very early ones, will be six figures, there aren’t very many retail customers that are willing to go out and spend that kind of money," Ableson said. "Tesla Narrowly Misses 80,000-Vehicle Sales Goal in 2016" https://www.wsj.com/articles/tesla-misses-its-2016-sales-goal-despite-27-fourth-quarter-rise-1483479562 https://www.wsj.com/articles/tesla-misses-its-2016-sales-goa...
- sputknick 10y agoI also think they missed the mark on "six figures". If that car costs six figures they are DOA. The most expensive part of self-driving cars (as I understand it) is the LIDAR, and I think those have come down to sub $10,000, and Tesla has more-or-less figured out how to do self-driving without it.
- randomdata 10y agoI would expect that the engineering costs to bring the vehicle to market would, even when divided among many sales, far exceed the cost of a single LIDAR unit.
- btian 10y agoThey're not DOA if they allow fleet operators to not hire drivers.
- zodPod 10y agoYeah I think they missed the "..on a GM" portion of that sentiment. There are plenty of people going and buying six figure cars, clearly. However, spending six figures on the Chevy brand would feel weird.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- tyingq 10y agoA bit pedantic, but the Corvette z06 gets pretty close to six figures.
- zodPod 10y ago"Bolt"? They really couldn't name it something more identifying and clever than the self-driving bolt? I came here thinking they were attempting some way to make things self assemble. "It's a self driving bolt. You don't have to use a screw driver to screw it in it does that itself." Besides, GM building a self driving car feels like letting the people who make plastic grocery bags make doors for safes or something. Sounds dangerous and it just sounds like it'll cause the name "Bolt" to stand for "run away suddenly out of control."...
- aanm1988 10y agoBolt is their electric model. They are adding self driving tech. Why rename it?
- zodPod 10y agoI kind of covered my personal answer to that in my original comment. It also annoys me that companies name things common English names because that makes it hard to search for things. "Chevy bolt loose steering" "bolt bolt size trunk latch" "bolt size for tires" Ultimately, it's obviously a battle that I'm not going to win because I'd prefer everything just have a GUID so I can easily identify exactly what I have. "The Chevrolet B0F30517-BAFE-43EB-BA62-1832AC5272F7" Lastly, I know it's been a common theme for a long time but it just seems to keep getting worse. Apple Ping. Chevy Bolt. Chevy Volt. Chevy Spark. Many different products called Hydrogen etc. Rust. I know of at least 2 products called Go. It just wouldn't be difficult to change spelling or do something clever instead of just taking direct, common dictionary words and grabbing them for your product.
- greglindahl 10y agoSearch engines easily handle things like [Chevy bolt] once they become popular enough. [chevy bolt size] in google already shows me stuff related to the Bolt.
- rectangletangle 10y agoMarketing, I was picturing some sort of fastener when I first read the title.
- zitterbewegung 10y agoA lot of people here are balking on the price for consumers. Looking it at another way is that the Bolt will be sold to ride sharing companies at 100k each and they would buy it in a heartbeat.
- oh_sigh 10y ago100k is the most generous interpretation of "6 figures". Would ride sharing companies still buy them at 350k each? At that point it may take 5 years to break even compared to having a human driving a 35k car
- cbhl 10y agoRide sharing companies probably won't break even on the first few thousand self-driving cars, but they don't currently break even with humans either. But once the tech is figured out, then you can start optimizing the marginal cost of each car, and spreading out capital costs over more cars, both of which reduce the cost.
- cortesoft 10y agoEven if they are losing money, it is still a great deal - being the first to offer fully automated self driving ride sharing is going to be a HUGE competitive advantage, even if the cars are too expensive to be profitable right now.
- IanCal 10y agoProbably, people are expensive. Minimum wage + employer taxes for a 25 year old in the UK is roughly £78,000 for 24 hour coverage assuming no overlap and no illness, no hiring cost, no management. I'd be interested to see what TCO they'd need to have to no longer be cheaper.
- smallnamespace 10y agoUber doesn't necessarily need 24-hour coverage though, because demand peaks during commute hours. However, self-driving vehicles can end up being a 'base load' that runs 24/7, and then Uber just pays drivers to appear during peak times, so they can avoid paying for (labor + driver's car) during unnecessary times.
- mtgx 10y agoYet they probably don't even encrypt their app's user credentials, as most of the big car makers seem to be doing: https://securelist.com/analysis/publications/77576/mobile-apps-and-stealing-a-connected-car/ https://securelist.com/analysis/publications/77576/mobile-ap... Good luck to the beta testers buying them.
- Fricken 10y ago'Thousands' is very committed. I wonder if they are doing this to make a statement, or if they feel rapidly scaling up to a thousands strong prototype test fleet is the most effective way to accelerate progress towards market ready L4 robotaxis. As the analogy goes, just because it takes 1 woman 9 months to make a baby does not mean 9 woman working together can make a baby in 1 month. Either way, it's very committed. GM isn't fucking around, they mean business!
- opaque_salmon 10y agoI think it's in the same vein as Telsa's strategy of autopilot roll-out compared to Google's self-driving pilot program. 1000 self-driving vehicles running for 1 month can collect data at a significantly higher rate than 1 self-driving vehicle running for 1000 months.
- Fricken 10y agoIt's the quality of the data and what you do with it that really matters. I think the benefits of crowdsourcing driving data to develop autopilot have been overstated. Waymo has pointed out that they are making the lion's share of their progress testing in simulators, where they can play out every conceivable variation of some strange or difficult edge case in a way that is not feasible in the real world. One thing you can do with 1000s of fleet vehicles is begin untangling the logistics of running a publicly accessible robotaxi network, which will brings with it a whole new set of problems above and beyond the autonomous os itself.
- brilliantcode 10y agoThis is the biggest risk I see with TSLA: - Incumbent auto giants entrance diminishing Tesla's margins. - Incumbent expertise and brand that diminishes Tesla's appeal. - First mover disadvantage: rest of auto industry sees large initial ROI by piggybacking off Tesla GM can't be the only guys racing to bring Tesla experience to it's existing brand followers. Luxury makers like BMW, Benz will woo the lion share of the market Tesla originally pioneered. First movers rarely do well here unless they've cemented their brand position in the luxury space such as Ferrari, Lamborghini etc. tl;dr: When the status quo catches up to Tesla, it will put downward pressure. Tesla's winning strategy should be to limit quantity and artificially inflate unit price. It is not equipped to take on dozen automotive brands in the long run. Please correct me where I'm wrong.
- idiot_stick 10y ago>GM can't be the only guys racing to bring Tesla experience to it's existing brand followers. This has been pointed out many times on these boards, and I agree with it. Tesla (Musk) got this EV ball rolling, for real, and deserve immense credit for that. But it sounds too often here that Tesla has "won". Building cars is hard, capital intensive, and there are many massive companies diving into this. And despite what you may have heard, companies like Ford, GM, Fiat aren't staffed with idiots.
- pcurve 10y agoAbsolutely. Big autos have huge engineering know-hows as well as resources to poach talent. One thing that may work for in favor of Tesla though, is the fact that self-driving car will fundamentally shift people's relationship with cars. Out goes the needs to have best-handling, best crash protection, best-feedback providing cars. Value of those engineering know-hows will be greatly diminished because computers will be doing the driving. Instead, there will be more emphasis on comfort, software, and efficiency.
- rhino369 10y agoIt's also not an industry you can permanently win. There aren't significant network effects. There isn't going to be one or two electric car manufacturers. There will be dozens.
- fnazeeri 10y agoI agree with the folks who see this as a serious risk to TSLA. If you've driven a Model S or Model X you know that the design, the software and the performance are insane, but the fit and finish (especially of the interior) is like a 1980s Cadillac. When BMW and Benz start making EVs, TSLA is going to be pushed hard and could likely end up becoming a software or powertrain T1 supplier.
- drcross 10y ago1. People are not going to avoid a tesla on the basis of a slightly crummy interior, they sell based on virtue signalling. 2. The mass produced version of the Tesla is yet to be revealed and it may have a better finish so this may be a moot point anyway.
- bogomipz 10y agoI have question given that 2018 is the date to deploy test vehicles how much time do they need to their tech operationally mature? I see in the article that they acquired a self-driving tech startup but that doesn't say much about how much experience that start up brings, and it not like there's many veterans in this field. Will they be playing catch up with Tesla, Google et al for years to come or will the tech soon start becoming commoditized?
- KirinDave 10y agoI own a Bolt, and I like it a lot. I have no desire to spend 4x that on a Tesla that is simply overspec'd for a simple commute car. I derive my self-esteem in other ways than fancy cars. Maybe I should have waited for the self-driving version.
- drcross 10y agoCars as the traditional human "fitness indicator" seems to be going out of style, self driving cars will decrease ownership and probably hasten that.
- furyofantares 10y agoWhy are people so confident that full-fledged self-driving will decrease ownership? I get that cars are usually parked, but IMO self-driving could turn driving into a leisurely experience which would increase my desire to do it in a personalized/homey space, increase my desire to have a long commute, and increase my desire to drive purely for leisure as well (driving around country roads reading).
- secstate 10y agoI don't think self-driving in and of itself will decrease ownership, but the combination of self-driving, flexible car sharing services, and ubiquitous ride sharing services will continue to make car ownership undesirable. A car in a driveway or parking spot has horrible utilization rates. Ownership of things like cars has never actually made sense, given that they depreciate in value as soon as you drive it off the lot. Meanwhile, more and more OEMs are moving into the car sharing space, and I think that will scratch the itch of wanting to drive a car for fun, or utility (need to pick up something large or be some where at a specific time).
- mdasen 10y agoBecause the price differential will make ownership a luxury. In fact, your comment alludes to that. For you, a self-driving car is an opportunity to make a leisurely, personalized, homey space. That's wonderful, if one has the money for it - and many people do. However, let's take a step back and look at the millions of people who say, "I want a car that gets me from A to B". They're not looking to own a leisurely, personalized, homey space. They're looking to get places, hopefully at the cheapest price and in the most reliable way. They're not looking to own something. You note that cars are often parked. Given the low utilization of vehicles, it stands to reason that renting time in a self-driving taxi should be significantly cheaper than owning one. If that self-driving taxi can serve the needs of 3 people instead of one, you only need to pay for a third of it. Even if the profit margins are an outrageous 50%, you'd be paying 150% of 33.3% or 50% of the cost of owning a self-driving car. However, the pricing is likely to be even more favorable. If owning a car costs you $500/mo and you can get your transit via self-driving taxi for $150/mo, there's a huge cost incentive to switch. I think that's the big thing. The cost advantage is going to be quite stark. Owning a car will cost many times what getting driven around by a self-driving taxi will cost. While many people can afford a car today, it's certainly a significant budget item for many. Even for those that can comfortably afford it, it's safe to assume that many will ditch the cost for something cheaper. Ultimately, our tastes as a society change as our society changes. As the cost of owning a car becomes sky-high compared to a mostly-substitute, many people will switch to it. Not everyone will. People spend up for luxury items all the time. But luxury items are, well, not commodities. Even if you can afford a luxury item, if you don't value that kind of item, you won't pay up for it. Plenty of rich people see a car as just a way to get from A to B. They'll take the cheaper self-driving taxi. Plenty of low and middle income people will be able to stretch their budgets better lowering transportation costs substantially. Even if you're skeptical of a dramatic change, let's say I propose that 10% of people that currently own cars would ditch them for self-driving taxis. I'm not even suggesting that it's changing society, but a 10% dip in demand is quite significant to an industry. I think you're right that there would be something nice about having a leisurely, homey ride. It could be a wonderful experience. But luxury automakers already try to give their owners a much nicer experience than someone gets in a Civic and there are definitely more Civic's out there. It's that, while a Mercedes S-Class is lovely, the Civic allows them to spend their money on other things (or afford transportation at all). Similarly, self-driving taxis will allow people to spend their money on other things or more easily afford transportation. You certainly paint a desirable picture and there are definitely people that will choose your vision. However, I think more people will choose the economy of self-driving taxis. Cars made horses a luxury item. Horses were no longer common transportation. The car was cheaper and better. It certainly wasn't perfect in all ways, but enough that horses became a luxury item.
- Hasz 10y agoThis is more a comment on TSLA than GM, but I still feel it's relevant given the competition between the two. I don't understand the Gigafactory, from a capital allocation point of view. Geographically, it's not near any major lithium, cobalt, (economical to extract) rare earth, etc deposits, and it's not in a traditional manufacturing area. Maybe they're getting a sweet tax deal. There are a number of tangential benefits, like heat recycling, solar availability, USA made (given the currently protectionist administration, but that could change in less than 4 years, max 8) etc, but I'm not sure these benefits outweigh the cost of being so far from raw material and export lines. Obviously, the Gigafactory makes batteries, a technology which improves at an unbelievably slow rate compared to virtually anything else. However, battery research is an intense area of research focus, and the whole factory is one Nobel from becoming obselete, barring (probably expensive) retooling. A game changing improvement is not a matter of if, but when. TSLA's bet is that this does not happen until they've paid off the asset. If you makes batteries as a core business, investment in facilities is the cost of doing business. If you make cars, it's a silly and imprudent experiment in vertical integration. Why bet the farm when you can pay marginally more for your batteries and cement the luxury market you already own? Batteries are a commodity, and at TSLA's scale, they surely can negotiate a good deal. Realistically, TSLA's target market is fine with absorbing a 2 or 3% increase in battery cost that a 3rd party supplier would demand. Given the investment in vertical integration, it seems TSLA is trying to go after the low/mid-market. Why beats me -- razor thin margins necessitate scaling incredibly quickly. They are taking an incredible risk for meager rewards in fiercely contested territory. Contrary to what most outlets will tell you, Ford/GM/Japanese automakers are not stupid. Slow, yes, but not stupid. They will move quickly to shred TSLA in the low end market, assuming they recognize the threat. Not only that, but they take on comparatively little additional risk in doing so, outside of product development costs. They don't need to build assembly lines, factories etc, because they already exist. Even if one mfg misses the electric vehicle trend, it's highly unlikely 6 of them will. That's all, and I'd really like a counterargument.
- LAMike 10y agoI heard Elon say that if they were to produce 1M cars per year, they would need to consume all Lithium-Ion batteries produced in the year 2014. Obviously there will be more batteries produced in 2020, but Tesla's fate would be at the mercy of the battery producers, which could collude to drive the price of batteries. For better or worse, Tesla is hell-bent on vertically integrating every single aspect of production. I believe they might be working on software that will allow them to stop relying on NVDA's chips for self driving as well. "First principles" business model will make or break Tesla/Elon.
- a3n 10y agoI picture thousands of Bolts rolling off the assembly lines one by one, and autonomously driving themselves to their assigned dealers.