29 ms·
Encrypted email is still a pain
- guenp 10y agohttps://gpgtools.org/ https://gpgtools.org/ works great for Mac.
- bpicolo 10y agoFor technical folk, yeah. For nontechnical folk, nothing seems to come even close though. The great thing about HTTPS, for example, is all users need to care about is a little green lock. (And frequently, they have no idea what HTTPS is, but know that little green lock === safe)
- nmat 10y ago> little green lock === safe Which is not true. Little green lock means the site has HTTPS, being safe requires much more than that. Security is hard to explain.
- bpicolo 10y agoOf course, but this is nonetheless the view for typical end users.
- jecxjo 10y agoAnd THIS is the problem. Yeah the app is a pain to install, but security is a mindset, not just an app. I even wonder how many people download an ISO or installer from a website, and do any sort of due diligence to find the signer's key from another 3rd party location, then verify previous builds, or require multiple signers of a key to give any semblance that the key is not fake? Or do we all just download the ISO and the .iso.asc file from the links provided and call it good? Even security minded people can be lazy in this situation.
- kijin 10y agoHTTPS is easy because it only provides encryption in transit. It is analogous to opportunistic encryption of SMTP, which is already in widespread use. Another reason HTTPS is easy is that it uses a centralized trust model, relying on CAs to vet each website. GPG is neither. It tries to provide encryption at rest, and relies on a web of trust that we cannot reasonably expect everyone to operate securely.
- FabHK 10y agoIt does work well, except when there's a macOS major version bump (10.9 -> 10.10 -> 10.11 etc.). Then you update your system (maybe after a prudent 3 week wait) and everything works, except the GPG Suite, and you can't send encrypted emails for a while, nor can you read ones you receive, or old ones stored locally. (For macOS 10.12 sierra, released 2016-09-20, there's now a beta of the GPG Suite, released 2017-01-23, 4 months later.) There was also a bug (or feature?) a while ago where email drafts that you had open in windows would vanish after a while. It is a good solution for the Mac, but this is something to be mindful of (and it sort of supports the main thrust of the article).
- Gaelan 10y agoOoh, I know this one! I think. Doesn't Apple Mail have this built in? I go to Keychain Access, choose the option to generate a key. Two clicks. Head to Mail, encryption options are there. Now, to import his key. Do some googling on that. Wait, what? Apple Mail supports S/MIME, not GPG. Competing standards strike again. If the other person has S/MIME, Apple Mail does have a very easy experience. I can't speak for the merits of either security-wise. Also, I think this is the sort of thing Keybase is good for. There's a level of indirection pasting into Keybase, but it's pretty easy to set up and (for non-Snowden levels of paranoia) makes it very easy to start sending encrypted mail to somebody else. The new Keybase chat is also an option.
- rhaps0dy 10y agoFor Apple Mail there is this: https://gpgtools.org/index.html https://gpgtools.org/index.html I use it (in El Capitan), it works really well, it's the first time I've been regularly signing my messages with PGP.
- dijit 10y agoI'm glad S/MIME gets a mention because I've always been skeptical of it based on the fact that everyone rallies behind PGP. I recently failed to install gpg2 on freebsd (for some reason it barks at me and fails and I don't care enough to waste my time on it) and decided to give S/MIME a chance with a signed cert from comodo. (which was free, just to try) I have to say though the experience is beyond reasonable, it's very easy to get to grips with. If you're using S/MIME, I see a little verified badge in my client, not only that, if I've receieved signed mail from you, I can reply with an encrypted document that only you can decrypt. This works with CC's and everything. The CA cargo-cult crap definitely has a benefit when it comes to web-of-trust. (YMMV, I was using Thunderbird)
- parent5446 10y agoThis article: what a shitfest. But seriously, I was expecting some actual discussion about how GPG still isn't easy (or possible for that matter) in modern webmail clients, or even something relating to the usability of common GPG GUIs, but instead just got a guy complaining about how he was pressing enter too fast and missed a dialog box, among other nonsense complaints. Personally, the GPG CLI acts exactly as I expect it to, being a CLI and all, and I don't expect non-advanced users to use it.
- lukeschlather 10y agoA messaging standard that only advanced users can use is basically useless. That's the point of the article.
- parent5446 10y agoI agree with your first sentence, but I don't think that's what the article was saying. (Or at the very least, it was poorly written enough such that that did not come across.)
- tptacek 10y agoEncrypted email is pretty much over in 2017. The emerging consensus among experts is that it's not worth the trouble, or, worse, incapable of doing much more than generating a false sense of security. That's for a bunch of reasons: * An enormous installed base of clients that won't do encryption, meaning that at best you're attempting to tunnel encrypted messaging over an unencrypted transport. * A protocol that leaks metadata, including some message content, at the envelope layer. * Hundreds of millions of users that primarily access messages through browser clients that can't meaningfully implement crypto. * An archive-always UX that ensures that huge amounts of plaintext are scattered around the Internet by both senders and receivers. * An unencrypted installed base that ensures encryption will be opt-in for the foreseeable future, meaning that users will routinely reveal plaintext accidentally by, for instance, quoting messages and forgetting to encrypt. * End user demands for things like search that can only be delivered efficiently at scale by databases of plaintext (most likely at centralized servers). All these problems are probably surmountable (with enormous, concerted effort). But: why bother? Email is just one of dozens of messaging systems available to Internet users. Better to move sensitive conversations to things like Signal, WhatsApp, or Wire --- the double ratchet construction is designed specifically to make IM-like protocols secure even when conversations are sporadic and last months.
- problems 10y ago> * Hundreds of millions of users that primarily access messages through browser clients that can't meaningfully implement crypto. Isn't protonmail pretty much a direct counter-example of this? They even have an extension you can use if you don't want their server to be trusted at all: https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/protonmail-checker/cmdelhngcpofmpidijaggmejnjofnpip?hl=en https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/protonmail-checker... > * End user demands for things like search that can only be delivered efficiently at scale by databases of plaintext (most likely at centralized servers). Thunderbird and Outlook at least seem to do search quite fast without any such thing. This could probably be done on something like protonmail by using an encrypted index too.
- tptacek 10y agoNo? Virtually nobody uses Protonmail. If the only thing between encrypted email and no encrypted email was a single provider that implemented PGP, we'd have had universal encrypted email in 1999. (I'm stipulating that anything Protonmail does actually, you know, works. I have no idea if it does. Why bother? Encrypted email isn't going anywhere. The track record on things like this is quite bad.)
- FloatingGhost 10y agoI thought "GPG isn't so hard, let's send him an email!" The key fails CRC check and doesn't import. heh
- patrickread 10y agoIf you're OK with using a third-party and would rather stick to GUI's, Virtru is a very easy solution for email encryption: https://www.virtru.com/ https://www.virtru.com/
- tptacek 10y agoWhere by "email encryption" we mean "mail people a link to a service they can register with and then upload messages and file to, so that SMTP is used only to relay links to messages, not the messages themselves, and email is encrypted by dint of TLS connections". That's what most F-500 companies do to solve this problem. It's a more viable approach than direct encryption of PGP. Normal people --- and eventually the F-500's, too --- just use WhatsApp.
- pdog 10y ago> Normal people --- and eventually the F-500's, too --- just use WhatsApp. Sure, but WhatsApp is a totally closed protocol owned by a company (Facebook) known for rampant issues with privacy. Security professionals have a responsibility to recommend open protocols like Signal that are dedicated to privacy.
- tptacek 10y agoThis is the "have you stopped beating your wife yet" of security arguments.
- reitanqild 10y agoYou usually seem like a very smart and reasonable man but here I feel you are missing major parts of the picture and I don't understand why you would. Given what we have seen from Facebook so far I am not convinced they wouldn't sell data to anyone including Hitler as long as they paid for it somehow. More realistically though I fully expect them to sell (misleading) data to insurance companies, Indian (and other) support scammers etc without asking many questions. For that reason I prefer almost anything including email and Telegram. (My opinions might be somewhat coloured by the fact that I was an enthusiastic Whatsapp user before Facebook bought them and even stayed and gave Facebook another chance with Whatsapp. )
- Raed667 10y agoI have "taught" encrypted email for many years to different types of people. I'm surprised to see that most non-technical people that I assisted had a better understanding of these same tools than the author. Generating the key using Enigmail has always worked for both Windows and Debian/Ubuntu (those are the top OSs people brought), finding a person's key was a pain a few years ago, I love the new UI. My conclusion: The author probably had his mind set before even starting. EDIT : Enigmail now allows you to enable encryption/signing by default, this prevents users from sending accidental clear-text emails.
- jvdh 10y agoThe author probably exaggerates, but identifies a very valid point. You really don't want to have this kind of confusion about something that you are planning to trust your secrets to.
- Raed667 10y agoThe naming confusion is legitimate (PGP, GPG, openPGP) but it literally takes one Google query "PGP GPG" to answer that question in 30 seconds.
- jvdh 10y agoThe naming of "private key" versus "secring.pgp" is very valid criticism. Also the fact that it crashes on first use, and that it is all not very user-friendly are all valid criticisms (still!). PS. please don't down vote because you disagree.
- lmm 10y agoA secring is a "secret keyring" that contains a number of private keys. I agree that consistency of "secret" versus "private" would be helpful, but the concepts of a key and a keyring are distinct (and a reasonably effective metaphor IMO - you have a keyring which your keys are on). The extent to which the tools should push you towards having a single key versus rotating is arguable; people criticise GPG for being too hard to use but people (sometimes even the same people!) also attack it for not encouraging key rotation enough. A gitflow-esque helper for setting up a best-practice rotation would be a valuable thing for someone to make (and fundamentally there just isn't enough money in making these tools more usable, unfortunately, which is why I fear it will never happen). GPG shouldn't need to tell you (prominently) where the files are because you should never need to know that - tools that integrate with GPG should be able to ask GPG where the keys are. The main thing that needs to happen here is for the Enigmail key generation bug to be fixed. If you're looking for a good GUI mail experience with GPG integration I found KMail much nicer than Thunderbird/Enigmail, for what it's worth.
- zanny 10y agoKmail is the only GPG experience I have ever found that just worked. It has a selection of keyservers by default, and if you email someone with a key on one of them it just magically uses it like its supposed to. Combine that with the KDE GPG manager which is also painless to generate and upload your own key, and its the only time I have ever been able to get "muggles" using GPG successfully.
- cookie0 10y agoYour key is not importable :D $ gpg --import stanley.asc gpg: CRC error; C68D2A - 29357C gpg: read_block: read error: Invalid keyring gpg: import from `stanley.asc' failed: Invalid keyring gpg: Total number processed: 0 Edit: Your key is way too short.
- lukegb 10y agoThere's a 2 swapped with a 3: https://gist.github.com/lukegb/243952e51ee1f7f9b6e1ed41774214f9 https://gist.github.com/lukegb/243952e51ee1f7f9b6e1ed4177421...
- jstanley 10y agoThis was my mistake! It's not too short. I search-and-replaced my h2 tags with h3, which broke the key. Oops. I've fixed it now.
- clishem 10y agoWhat a shitfest.
- cookie0 10y agoNow it works, nevertheless it still is (too) short, because you are using a soon-to-be insecure key size: https://www.gnupg.org/faq/gnupg-faq.html#default_rsa2048 https://www.gnupg.org/faq/gnupg-faq.html#default_rsa2048 "In 2010, France’s Agence Nationale de la Securite des Systems d’Information stated they had confidence in RSA-2048 until at least 2020."
- parennoob 10y agoDo any of these keyservers perform email verification? It would go a good way towards some kind of verification that a user's GPG key corresponds to their email. Otherwise, anyone can generate a key with any email address and push it up to the servers. The standard way of verifying it (key-signing parties) is somewhat difficult.
- cookie0 10y agoOnly https://keyserver.pgp.com https://keyserver.pgp.com performs email verification, the others don't. See: https://lkml.org/lkml/2016/8/15/445 https://lkml.org/lkml/2016/8/15/445
- therealidiot 10y agoIt seems that keyserver.pgp.com won't accept keys with revoked subkeys
- cyphar 10y agoMaking users assume that emails are in _any way_ verified is dangerous because it is far too low of a bar to provide any practical security for PGP keys. Not to mention that PGP keys can be used outside the context of email (so the email could be empty or otherwise incorrect).
- mnw21cam 10y agoAgreed. The keyservers are public posting boards. You are meant to verify that the key is sufficiently signed in a chain all the way to yourself before you trust it. Anything on the keyservers that makes people think the key has already been verified is a bad thing.
- jvdh 10y agoThey don't because GPG is ancient, and there was no proper way to do email validation back then. It is sort of better now, but still very hard to do. If you have realistic worries that someone can intercept your email, then email validation of your GPG keys is not going to help.
- vasilakisfil 10y agoThe site does not use HTTPS (TLS) so that public key is completely useless.
- jwilk 10y agoWhat is your threat model? Is a TLA going to MITM all connections to incoherency.co.uk in order to read OpenGPG-encrypted mails? That's not very realistic. I'm not saying that the way the key is being distributed is perfect, but I wouldn't say it's "completely useless".
- MayeulC 10y agoFor what it's worth, I used to use encrypted mail some time ago as much as possible, before realising it was fundamentally flawed: — the key retention is the biggest issue. You need to keep your key around for a long time, probably storing copies of it. This increases the probability of a leak. — there is no method to revoke a key with a 100% assurance that nobody will use or trust it afterwards. — if a key is broken or leaked, every encrypted message you ever received can be deciphered. And I hope you realise it, or future messages are also at risk. Those are the three major flaws I can remember right now. The way people usually use it make them feel safe while they are not necessarily. It's a bit like reusing a complex password on different websites (although far less critical since the key is assymetric). The way I use it now (and I never actually needed it, to be fair), is that if some third party want to send me some confidential information, they request my public key via an open channel, and I then generate a key, unique for this conversation (ideally, it would be done on a per-email basis). Of course, the complex part here is ensuring they receive the proper key (ie, no man in the middle). This can be done by using a side (preferably secure) channel. Of course, in today's world, encrypted emails are not the best way to communicate privately, in my opinion, but that's another story. And there are a couple of other issues regarding encrypted emails such as its adoption, it's complexity, etc. But none as fundamental.
- drdaeman 10y ago> the key retention is the biggest issue. You need to keep your key around for a long time, probably storing copies of it. As I get it, this one is a fundamental issue, not specific to messaging at all, but is just a secure storage problem. You either keep a copy of the message (and need some key to decrypt it, unless you keep it unencrypted), or you throw it away. No amount of engineering can solve this.
- mjevans 10y agoThat's what 'perfect forward security' is intended to solve. For more details please look up the Off The Record (otr) protocol overlay. The basic idea is that any given session is authenticated temporally; when a session is completed the details for it are leaked so that anyone could forge content as having been within that session. Thus there is reasonable doubt about anything that was said/transferred having actually been said/transferred.
- jecxjo 10y agoThe more this topic comes up, the more I start to wonder if the "difficulty" in email encryption is actually people just being lazy. We have IM and texting apps like Signal. You install, and if your friends install then you're secure. Most people skip verifying fingerprints, not doing IRL face to face verification. Yes the install process is simple and requires no real work to start encrypting things, but that still doesn't make the process secure. If anything, having these types of security models where you aren't forced to verify the other end continues to breed this lazy mentality. Security is hard and requires all end users to actually put time and thought into what they are doing. We can always make a better mouse trap when it comes to security but that will not change people's minds on how they interact with security when online.
- lol768 10y ago>I start to wonder if the "difficulty" in email encryption is actually people just being lazy I think it's a combination of this and perhaps some ignorance as to the implications of skipping these processes, hence they aren't taken seriously. I'm not sure if more education on this is the solution or not, since it seems a lot of people don't really care about these internals and don't want to take the time to understand what's going on. I'm not sure I'd describe this as laziness or just stubbornness. Users tend to be very goal-oriented and with (for example) TLS certificate validation errors, these simply stand in the way of what the end-user is trying to achieve. There have been a couple of studies done on how users tend to just dismiss these errors http://static.usenix.org/legacy/events/sec09/tech/full_papers/sec09_browser.pdf http://static.usenix.org/legacy/events/sec09/tech/full_paper...
- qznc 10y ago> not sure if more education on this is the solution Security education is a never ending battle. Just like "use condoms", "floss your teeth", "wash your hands", etc. It also changes. Today "Use a password manager" is the new "change your password".
- jecxjo 10y agoI've had the "security" conversation with my father-in-law a few times. He is a wanna be computer nerd. I tried to explain to him the benefits of all traffic being encrypted. It means "the man" can't see anything you are doing. Why would you want this? Because it sets a precedent that you aren't hiding something. I had a job once where coworkers only spoke Spanish when they wanted to talk about someone without their knowledge. It was obvious and even those who didn't speak the language could see it was happening. If they just spoke it all the time no one would have suspected they were making fun of someone, and no one would have paid that close of attention to what they were saying. It would have become a non-issue.
- dmbaggett 10y agoIt's only a pain if you're still trying to use PGP. You can download Inky (http://inky.com http://inky.com) for any platform and use any email account to exchange S/MIME-encrypted email simply by checking a button. We're focused on large enterprises now (because we've found consumers and small business don't care about encrypting their email, or think TLS=encryption) but there's nothing stopping individuals from trying it out. It makes e2e encryption of email using any email account basically invisible. You can send encrypted mail to non-Inky users as well.
- mark_l_watson 10y agoYears ago, working at a friend's security company everyone used Apple Mail with GPG. That is the only time anyone insisted on using encrypted email. Fast forward to the present: I support and like ProtonMail, but I can't talk anyone else into using it. I don't understand why more small companies, wanting to protect their intellectual property, don't use ProtonMail (or something like it).
- Tepix 10y agogpg2 broke when I updated from Ubuntu 14.04 to Ubuntu 16.04. I had to export the keys using gpg and import them using gpg2. Before the upgrade gpg2 was able to read the keys just fine. Now, that's not the only problem after the upgrade, Enigmail is having some other issues... It's a mess.
- mjevans 10y agoThe problem was likely that gpg2 made a /copy/ of your gpg(1) keyring when it first ran. After that they were out of sync. gpg2 really just needs a gpg1 comparability shim that's good enough that it /replaces/ the gpg1 tools on a system and seamlessly gets them to use the gpg2 keyring.
- Tepix 10y agoNot sure. I was already using gpg2 with Ubuntu 14.04 so I see no reason why it would stop to work.
- cpursley 10y agoI'm not sure I buy this. Protonmail has a very polished UI that's dead simple enough for technical people and non-technical people alike: https://protonmail.com https://protonmail.com
- seppin 10y agodoes this only work if both parties have @protonmail.com ?
- cpursley 10y agoEncryption works automatically, yes. You can also send encrypted emails to non-proton users that require a pin code to read.
- testloop 10y agoIt works seamlessly/automatically between protonmail users and you can also send encrypted mail to non-protonmail users - they receive a link via email that they need a password to access. You can also export your PGP public key and receive encrypted email from anyone else too.
- nickik 10y agoI like Protonmail, but its a far cry away from 'real' GPG. They are just now adding SMTP. They don't allow key uploads. They don't let you send (gpg) encrypted E-Mail to non Protonmail users and there are some other problems. I wish them a lot of luck fixing and working on this stuff.
- upofadown 10y agoTLDR: Enigmail can be entirely broken due to interaction with GPG. I've never used Enigmail. Is this sort of thing common?
- nickpsecurity 10y agoLet me contrast the author's experience with my own. Note that I had a brain injury during this process that made me forget scripting and GPG plus hard to learn. I'm a nice test case for how hard things are. :) So, I looked into GPG. Holy shit there's a ton of options and complexity. High-assurance security says subset to minimal thing that works for increased trustworthiness. I noticed it could encrypt files with others' public keys. The person that contacted me was able to receive attached files. Text editors only have so many 0-days left in them & are easy to sandbox. So, I decided on this protocol: 1. Type the message into a text file. 2. Type a cryptic command to encrypt it with that public key. 3. Attach the file to a message to that person. Optionally doing this on a different box passed through a data diode if I was worried about GPG box compromised. Just using Linux for now. 4. Receiving works other way where I download an encrypted file that I run a decryption command on. So, that's simple. How to get started and what commands to use? I installed GPG first. One look at the man page made me hit Google instead. I found a cheat sheet, identified the minimal commands necessary, and compared them against the man page. Saw what seemed to be right stuff but that man page was horrible. Looked at a bunch of other sources online with varying trustworthiness to see if they had same commands. Seemed like I had the right ones. I was also warned the key gen phase could take a long time so I just ignored that usability problem that stomped the OP so much. I was warned after all. The key generated. Messages sent and received well. Only thing left was tediously typing my new buddy's email into the box with every encryption. As others came up, I was having to remember more email addresses. Time to automate that shit with a front end that worked on any system I needed. Also, without remembering how to program. I recalled Python was easy. So, I'd need a data structure for a list of (alias, email) pairs, basic operations on text for maybe substitution, input, conditionals, ability to print them, and spawn function of some kind. Python reference gave me all I need which I tested each to be sure then composed them with tests. End result was a Python script with the list of alias/emails in it like a config file where I could just add people to the script itself. Then, I run the script on the text message with it asking which of a listed group of people to send it to. I type in number or name for it to run command automatically. Then, I verify by eye the new file looks like gibberish and attach it to the email. End result was that I had GPG for friends using it, I figured out how to use it with fair degree of trustworthiness, and I automated the annoying part with less than beginner's knowledge of scripting. This shows GPG is way less hard than it appears to be. Although I sure could use a great front-end to smooth over all this. I'm sure any half-ass programmer could create one given what I did in that state. :)
- duracel 10y agoWhy would spy agencies wanted to read people's messages from server, when they can get plain text in each device ? Nonsense. Current encryption type secures only storage and transmission states. What secures kernel, decryption, caching and read states ?
- nickik 10y agoEconomics. Attacking all end devices all the time is incredibly difficult. It simply not economically practical. So we need to secure all communication and all data at rest. That's most important. Fixing all bugs in all end user devices is a hole bigger problem (or doing something to avoid escalation). It is getting a lot of attention too, for example Linux Kernal Hardning project). People switching languages away from C also helps.
- brynjolf 10y agoAfter the second shitfest he lost me. Colourful language sure but this just felt out of place.
- aarontyree 10y agoKeybase, Nylas mail plugin. Done. or GPG Tools beta, Mail app, done. or even just the Keybase built in encrypt/decrypt.
- sabarasaba 10y agoI wanted to give this a go, I downloaded nylas but there aint no Encryption plugin or anything. How do you go about configuring it ?
- spang 10y agoFor now, the encryption plugin is only available on the older version, Nylas Pro. No reason for that other than time to port and QA the plugin to the new free version, which has a completely written mail sync engine that runs locally rather than in the cloud. We're working on porting all Nylas Pro features to the new version as fast as we can! If you want to keep up to date about the latest features, you can sign up for our newsletter at the bottom of this page: https://nylas.com/nylas-mail/ https://nylas.com/nylas-mail/
- aarontyree 10y agoNylas has not made the Keybase/Encryption plug-in available for Nylas Mail. But the source code is GPL. I repackaged it as a stand alone plugin for my own use in Nylas Mail and you can find it here: https://github.com/aarontyree/Keybase-Plugin https://github.com/aarontyree/Keybase-Plugin
- legulere 10y agoI do not get why everyone thinks that encrypted email is GPG. S/MIME is supported by almost all email clients. S/MIME is far less of a pain (but still some pain and could be improved). It has a model of how to verify that keys belong to the right person, that actually works in practice in contrast to GPG where you basically have to verify keys by hand (adversarial CAs are a problem, but probably only for a tiny amount of people).
- stephenr 10y agoMy thoughts exactly. In an industry niche where people love the phrase "perfect is the enemy of good", S/MIME is better than GPG/etc because its actually somewhat useable out of the box for people.
- lmm 10y agoa) The key management UX is even worse than GPG, at least IME. b) If you're willing to trust the CA system the advantages of using email rather than any transport-encrypted messenger (e.g. facebook messenger) seem decidedly marginal
- rkeene2 10y agoYou control which CAs you anchor your trust to locally. Additionally, the encryption part isn't tied to the CA system -- you encrypt directly with the public keys of your recipients. You can use the CA system to validate that the public key belongs to someone validated by some attributes -- certificates are used for this. The US Federal Government (FPKI) and US Department of Defense (DOD PKI) use S/MIME heavily.
- lmm 10y ago> You control which CAs you anchor your trust to locally. Theoretically, but doesn't it tend to use the same OS infrastructure as HTTPS? > The US Federal Government (FPKI) and US Department of Defense (DOD PKI) use S/MIME heavily. Indeed, but they are in a position to trust the US government (and more generally the international governmental system).
- jheriko 10y agoto me, this accurately describes most user experiences of most open source software. its not just gpg and mail encryption, this sort of experience describes a lot of tools - and not too long ago just installing linux was a considerably worse nightmare of usability fails than this (it has greatly improved, i'm happy to say)
- known 10y agohttps://securedrop.propublica.org/ https://securedrop.propublica.org/ FTW
- boomboxy 10y agoIsis? I guess we have to trust her after all the ioerror affair, right? Considering he's currently on trial for all her allegations. /sarcasm moxie HAS to agree with his protocol. thegrugq? Wasn't he selling exploits to the highest bidder? http://www.forbes.com/sites/andygreenberg/2012/03/21/meet-the-hackers-who-sell-spies-the-tools-to-crack-your-pc-and-get-paid-six-figure-fees/#7437d3e69448 http://www.forbes.com/sites/andygreenberg/2012/03/21/meet-th... I can't argue about their qualifications, I argue about their morality. .edit added link.
- bqe 10y agoAre you seriously suggesting that a large portion of the crypto/security community is so inherently biased that you can't trust their expert opinion on the field that they're expert in? Who do you trust?
- boomboxy 10y agoNo, I'm just saying SOME of those people I don't trust. Feel free to trust them though.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- dang 10y agoPlease don't. This crosses more than one line and can't lead anywhere good. We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13635827 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13635827 and marked it off-topic.
- logfromblammo 10y agoI think the real problem is real-person identity management. Encrypted email is still a pain because we're still trying to shoehorn secure communication into a system that is fundamentally open and public, and filled with authorities that have to know something about you in order to route your messages to somewhere closer to your mailbox. Email is still the text equivalent to the publicly switched telephone network. Domain names have to be registered. Mail routing has to be set up via DNS MX records and mail server software. It is like writing a letter on a postcard. Any attacker will be able to read the origin postmark, the destination address, and the ciphertext, no matter what code you use for the message. All the problems with key exchange and trust chains is a result of trying to send secure messages from one known person to another known person. It's approaching from the wrong direction. People meet in person to grow their web of trust before exchanging secure messages online. But most of the people I communicate with online, I have never met in person, nor do I even know what they look like. If I use secure pseudonym-to-pseudonym communication to set up an in-person meeting, and prove to the other that the human controls the pseudonymous identity, it should be impossible to determine how those two real people happened to show up in the same place at the same time. It should be indistinguishable from a coincidental encounter. You just can't do that with encrypted email. I envision an uncountable number of large rocks, and masked ninjas running around hiding encrypted notes under them. The ninjas hang out in their darkened ninja bars, letting each other know which dead drop to use if they want to start a correspondence, and how to signal that it should be checked. But in the network, nothing exists unless someone runs the service, so all those rocks would have to be created and maintained by volunteers, and there is always the possibility that someone is preferentially using one of their own rocks, or setting up a fake rock to spy on anyone that lifts it. I don't even know enough cryptography or spy tradecraft to even make a helpful suggestion on how to communicate with anyone on the network in such a way that all known attacks by state-level actors may be mitigated. All I can think of is the Black Hand missions of Oblivion (Elder Scrolls 4)--which used dead drops--and I ended up spoilering all the spoilers, because they had been spoilered. Never mind the philosophical implications of questioning how you even know whether a person you are talking to face-to-face, whom you have known for years, is really the person they appear to be. Do we even need to attach an identity to an actual face most of the time?
- zanethomas 10y agoProtonmail works fine for me. I prefer to keep e-mails within family and with other close associates private. So I just insist everyone uses protonmail. It's as easy to use as gmail and they all put up with my demands.
- innocentoldguy 10y agoI used to encrypt my email with GnuPG, but it was a huge hassle for me, and an even bigger pain for the family and friends I wanted to communicate with. In the end, I realized that the things I tend to say over email just aren't that important anyway, so I stopped doing it. If someone wants to spy on my dad's fart jokes, more power to them. Nowadays, I hardly ever check my email. There are other ways to communicate with the people who matter to me, which are automatically encrypted and aren't as easily exploited by marketers and spammers. Email just isn't something I really need or use much anymore.
- nkoren 10y ago...Or you could just use https://www.mailpile.is/ https://www.mailpile.is/, which is a genuinely less painful way to do encrypted email.
- isaac_is_goat 10y agoProtonMail is "good enough" for me.
- zamalek 10y agoThis is one of the reasons that disrupting email is one of the most popular bad ventures. It's great 1980's tech. Email is a false vacuum in the field of solutions for communication, a local minimum. We can't improve on it any futher - every direction along the gradient of solutions is a worse solution. IM is doing a good job at locating a new local minimum right now.
- makecheck 10y agoIf you want more-secure methods adopted, they have to be easy to use. I find that encrypted PDFs are a reasonable option, even when reading on mobile. If I want to send myself something sensitive, I attach a password-protected PDF; then even if I open the “E-mail” on my iPhone, I am prompted for a password before I am allowed to view it. And frankly, I wish that web sites would stop trying to implement their own clunky mail-like “secure” messaging systems and just use password PDF. I hate receiving these “you have a secure message on oursite.com!” messages that are impossible to deal with on mobile (not to mention they appear very spam-like at first).
- omouse 10y agoProtonMail and TutaNota are pretty good.
- tom-jh 10y agoIt is indeed a pain. That's why I made https://cryptup.org/ https://cryptup.org/ For some of my users, using Gmail itself is already challenging. Yet they are sending around PGP encrypted messages, attachments, etc. Even my mom is using this. For encryption software, moms count double.
- chippy 10y agotheres something screwy with the images on the testimonials part of the page: http://i.imgur.com/RFoqpKwl.png http://i.imgur.com/RFoqpKwl.png
- tom-jh 10y ago(edit: it's fixed now) First time I see it like that, I assume one of your plugins is blocking it (direct links to google profiles). I'll store the images & serve them directly. Thanks!
- matt_wulfeck 10y agoIt's not hard though, it's just hard to do it without any third-party in a way that provides an easy user experience. iMessage is a good example of encrypted E2E messaging that "just works", but it is setup and maintained by a third party. I would say one of the biggest hurdles to increased security is the debilitating nature of secure from the security people themselves. Everyone wants a perfect solution and postulates endlessly about every edge case. So much so that the community won't accept any solution that has even a little bit of hair on it, so nothing gets done except everyones individual homebrew mechanisms. I swear there's not a pragmatic bone in their bodies, and if you doubt me then join some popular crypto mailing lists and see the tinfoil hattery for yourselves.
- aruggirello 10y agoI don't know what kind of Linux the author is using but, on Debian/Ubuntu/Mint/etc., you should really be doing: sudo apt-get install enigmail rather than go hunting for installers.
- phyushin 10y agoI wrote a blog post on using mailvelope to send/receive encrypted emails via existing mail providers such as Google mail ... Linked into my post about getting a private/public key pair using keybase.io I'd like to think they explain it fairly well but I hadn't considered the implications of people believing they're more secure than they actually are ... Until I read the comments here - disclaimer: not claiming encrypted email is super secure or even necessarily that using mailvelope is super secure but just wanted to make it look less scary to the uninitiated
- chei0iaV 10y agoI was surprised that recently GMX mail started promoting encrypted email support through Mailvelope.
- exabrial 10y agoKeybase.io brah. Simple!
- sigjuice 10y agoMost prominent mail clients have built-in S/MIME support (Outlook, iOS, Thunderbird, Mail.app on macOS). The problem is that the there is no easy and free/cheap way to get an S/MIME certificate. My hope is that Let's Encrypt or Keybase or someone will make this easier someday.
- Psilidae 10y agoAnother comment on this article actually shows this isn't true: Comodo offers free S/MIME certificates. (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13635591 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13635591) I went ahead and just grabbed one for myself after learning this.
- sigjuice 10y agoS/MIME support has to be more widespread than just one or two providers with free certificates. Comodo's own iOS and Android instructions do not look straightforward at all. Also, what happens when your certificate expires? Are you supposed to keep all expired certificates so you can still read older encrypted email? Does that even work?
- pymai 10y agoprotonmail is a whole lot easier to use now that you only need 1 password instead of 2
- cygned 10y agoA client's admin sends credentials via email - including logins and passwords for mission critical infrastructure. When asking him about security concerns he said: "Our mail server's using HTTPS, everything is secure" I haven't responded to that.
- andai 10y agoNoob question: what are the problems here? Mail server being compromised, and/or any of the sender/recipient machines?
- spodkowinski 10y agoWhat I find most frustrating when it comes to GPG encryption and email is the lack of support for public key encryption for generated mails. I've seen very few sites supporting GPG and if they did, I found it always just worked and I imaging not much of a big deal to setup. So why do even the biggest shops not offer this? I really would like to be able to upload my public key to e.g. Amazon. It's great to make the checkout process and everything super secure, but just to send every purchase you did and your personal data in an unencrypted mail across the web afterwards.
- conmarap 10y agoOr, you could just use Protonmail and be done with it.
- Vkkan2016 10y agoI am using protonmail it's clean and secure and it's working on non proton users with pin
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- khalis411 10y agoStories can't have both urls and text, so you need to pick one. If you keep the url, you can always post your text as a comment in the thread. https://www.ifliix.xyz/thousands-of-people-protest-creatively-against-romanian-government/ https://www.ifliix.xyz/thousands-of-people-protest-creativel...
- alkonaut 10y agoUsing encrypted email is only a solved problem (simple enough) when it's as easy as using https for all end users. Right now it's on par with serving https, which is still way way too painful even for tech people.
- qplex 10y agoIf you find 'gpg --gen-key' too hard to use, I don't know what to tell you. It presents (at least on my system) a very clear prompt to type a passphrase. Maybe you should blame your distribution instead of gpg?
- throw7 10y agoAny business that approaches usefulness in terms of encrypted communications is shutdown by the u.s.
- peterposter 10y agoCouldn't the blockchain be employed to do proof-of-key-ownership? I mean it's decentralized and trusted and all
- damir 10y agomy thoughts exactly. why not have pub keys as confirmed transactions on a blockchain?
- owly 10y agoI love protonmail. It's simple and just works.
- faragon 10y agoYou can not avoid responses in clear-text quoting your encrypted emails, so that mechanism is broken by design: it should be a point to point encrypted mailbox.
- cottsak 10y agoWell now there's Signal https://itunes.apple.com/au/app/signal-private-messenger/id874139669 https://itunes.apple.com/au/app/signal-private-messenger/id8... and Keybase Chat https://keybase.io/blog/keybase-chat https://keybase.io/blog/keybase-chat Why do we still need PGP email?
- whyagaindavid 10y agoI want email to stay at least for work related. Imagine your employer shifts to WhatsApp or signal. Asks you to code shady stuff. Even if you resign, there is no proof your manager knew it if your official mobile phone was wiped. Think about harassment from senior managers. All these go undocumented. This is why I prefer my email from and to every one in office to be plain text. No PGP. I am German; do not care Hillary or Trump - but if Hillary had used signal. May be things would be different!
- iofiiiiiiiii 10y agoThe main challenge for me seems to be that users do not have a concept of maintaining a digital identity and the key management that goes along with it. They just expect their real world identity to somehow translate automatically. This just does not happen. Though I wonder if government-issued digital ID might be of benefit here to encourage good practices. Estonian ID-cards carry key pairs, so if email clients supported GPG email with smartcard-hosted keys (uhh maybe some do but I never heard of one) then this might be an approach worth undertaking.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]