15 ms·
A330 flight control laws saved Voyager, inquiry finds
- hh2222 10y agoThat will likely cut down on flight deck videos on youtube.
- digler999 10y agoThats what came to my mind too. Which is sad. I definitely dont want passengers exposed to more risk, but I'm also against "its policy" kind of rules that squelch people from having fun and exposing more people to aviation.
- Shivetya 10y agoI do not understand, it took only one input to put it in a dive with auto pilot engaged but two inputs to cancel auto pilot to get it out of the dive?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- lutusp 10y agoApparently the pilot's control was disabled by the camera, which, until it was removed, prevented either pilot's control inputs from having the intended effect.
- ars 10y agoThe camera forced one stick forward, the co-pilot pulled the other one back. Since the two conflicted the computer decided on its own what to do, and didn't listen to either of them.
- sk5t 10y agoIt looks like the conflicting stick inputs (once the copilot managed to manipulate the controls, from the cockpit ceiling) caused the autopilot to retake control.
- salex89 10y agoIt literally said:"FU guys, I'm getting outta here, with or without you" :D .
- NikolaeVarius 10y agoControls laws on an Airplane is an extremely tricky subject and there is no real consensus as to how to deal with conflicting inputs.
- huh333i 10y agoI have an A320 type so let me try to guess what happened in the A330. The airbus is... different. You can displace the stick 100% in any direction and it wont bank beyond 67 degrees, pitch up more than 30, or pitch down more than 15. It wont overstress because the stick controls G-forces through a closed feedback loop. It also has high-speed protections where it will automatically apply positive G-force to pitch up in order to slow down. The pilot cannot override these protections. You can do whatever you want with the stick and as long as the computers are working and getting good data the aircraft will not stall, overspeed, overstress, or roll upside down. If you get too careless it will even run the engines up to full takeoff thrust and microblog it to you. These protections were working the whole time the captains stick was deflected 100% nose down. The system isn't perfect and it allows some overshoot, as you can see, but at least the protections kept it within 17 degrees nose down and mach 0.9. Now to the story at hand, the captain probably didn't realize his camera was wedged between the seat's armrest and the control stick as he moved the seat forward. I can only guess that he assumed the strange attitude was the result of a computer malfunction because he considered turning off the computers that provide many of the protections I mentioned. Good thing he didn't. Now the first officer gets into the cockpit and probably tosses a wtf glance at the captain but upon getting one right back he decides to use his own stick. The sticks in the bus aren't mechanically connected but, just like with mechanically connected sticks in antique Boeing aircraft, their force inputs are mathematically summed. Yet unlike mechanically connected sticks, displacement isn't transmitted across the cockpit so the first officer wouldn't be wise to the fact that the captain's stick was full forward. Luckily the bus engineers thought of this. When the first officer pulled his stick back the computer would have noticed both sticks moving and it would have announced "dual input". This isn't a microblog or a gentle woman's voice. It's a pissed off dude trying to talk some sense into you. At that point the captain probably looked at the palms of his hands to make sure they weren't on the stick. He probably showed his palms to the first officer too. At that point they had two heads working on the problem and it wouldn't have taken them too long to find the camera.
- crooked-v 10y agoSounds like the engineering moral of the story here is "don't make joystick mounts placed in relation the armrest such that small objects can easily get jammed between them".
- rtkwe 10y agoGenerally one pilot would just be working the controls and needs to be able to override the auto-pilot in an emergency very quickly. Then when the co-pilot comes in and pulls his stick back the computer doesn't know which to follow without side stick priority being set (which is normally just equal priority) so it goes back to auto-pilot and pulls out of the dive the captain was ordering with his jammed stick.
- rwmj 10y agoThe link I posted is the only good technical summary, but there are plenty of others about the pilot's ongoing military trial, eg: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2017/02/06/bored-raf-pilot-sent-187-passengers-nosedive-playing-camera/ http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2017/02/06/bored-raf-pilot-s... 'Bored' RAF pilot sent 187 passengers into a nosedive 'while playing with his camera'
- robzyb 10y ago> The link I posted is the only good technical summary Agreed, except for... > Its automatic high-speed protection system was triggered 3s later, with a maximum indicated air speed of 358kt (662km/h), or Mach 0.9, recorded.
- jsmthrowaway 10y agoThere is another thread on exactly what you've perceived as an error, because that statement is, in fact, accurate, counterintuitive to a physics education.
- robzyb 10y agoDamnit. My initial thought is that I didn't take into account air pressure. Now I feel like an idiot, time to research...
- sk5t 10y ago> with a maximum indicated air speed of 358kt (662km/h), or Mach 0.9, recorded What? 358 knots is much closer to mach 0.5 in air. 358 meters/second is close... 662 mph is close.
- sk5t 10y agoFurther confusing numbers: > “Up to 24% of the aircraft occupants were rendered temporarily unfit for duties following the incident,” the report adds, referring to 25 passengers and seven crew members. > “Without the excellent technology of the Airbus A330 flight control laws, the outcome could have been very different, with the realistic potential for the loss of the aircraft and 198 of our people,” MAA director general AM Richard Garwood says in his summary of the incident. 24% of 198 is not 25+7 but 47-ish. What am I missing here?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- colanderman 10y ago"Up to" ;)
- mikeash 10y agoIndicated airspeed is based on the force of the oncoming air, and decreases as air gets less dense. There's some altitude where 358kt indicated is Mach 0.9. Edit: before I get more replies attempting to lecture me on how wrong I am, please look up the difference between true airspeed (how fast the air is moving past the airplane) and indicated airspeed (a measurement derived from the difference between static and dynamic pressure on the aircraft that only matches how fast the air is moving when you're at sea level).
- lutusp 10y ago> There's some altitude where 358kt indicated is Mach 0.9. Not really: http://www.aerospaceweb.org/question/atmosphere/q0112.shtml http://www.aerospaceweb.org/question/atmosphere/q0112.shtml
- Someone 10y ago"seven dented ceiling panels, 50 damaged in-flight entertainment sockets" The article doesn't state it, but that's because the passengers, like the co-pilot, fell towards the ceiling of the airplane during this episode. Apparently, the headphone cables are stronger than those sockets.
- kristianp 10y agoIt's a safety concern that at least 50 passengers didn't have their seat-belts on!
- mikeash 10y agoAnd this is why they tell you to always keep your seat belt fastened when seated, even when the seat belt light is turned off. You never know when a sudden maneuver or severe turbulence might hit.
- closeparen 10y agoIs it me or has seat-belt-sign discipline gone out the window? Over my December travels, dozens of passengers on all 4 segments I flew openly flaunted the seat-belt sign, getting up to go to the bathroom and standing in the aisle waiting for it in full view of flight attendants, who didn't say anything. I broke down and did so myself, as the seat belt sign was on for the vast majority of the flight and I was getting desperate. In the years prior, I've been sternly commanded to get fuck back to my seat when queueing for the bathroom, even with the seat belt sign off. Never observed anyone out and about while it was on. Maybe the only care in the front of the plane, since you might be preparing to rush the flight deck or something? Any frequent fliers notice this change?
- nathancahill 10y agoI've noticed that too. I used to do that myself, until I hit some of the worst turbulence of my life flying in to Denver a couple years ago. Whacked my head pretty hard on main cabin ceiling (the plane dropped ~20ft without warning and I didn't). Ever since then I've worn my seat belt for as much of the flight as possible.
- chanandler_bong 10y agoFrom the headline, I could not figure out how an A330s flight control system could have any influence on spacecraft launched in 1977. Surely there would be no way to port the code and the storage on the Voyagers is tiny... at least until the V'ger Mk. I upgrade.
- coin 10y agoThat was my first thought too
- _Codemonkeyism 10y agoIncidentally my first thought too.
- dct 10y agoVoyager is the name RAF use: http://www.raf.mod.uk/equipment/voyager.cfm http://www.raf.mod.uk/equipment/voyager.cfm
- awinter-py 10y agonot sure it's legit for airbus to be declaring a win for their automation. sounds like the copilot dogpaddled back to the cockpit through freefall and batted at his controls from the ceiling until the computer got confused and resumed level flight. If any safety technology deserves credit here it's seatbelts. From the sound of it, nobody who was belted in was injured.
- jsmthrowaway 10y agoThe computer worked to prevent the aircraft from entering an overspeed condition by pitching up and attempting to recover from the dive even before that dual stick input was an issue. It was intervening 13 seconds into the incident, as the aircraft threatened to exceed safety tolerances. The dual stick input created another issue after that intervention began. The automation very possibly saved lives here. The overspeed protection is good because had that not happened, there's a real possibility that significant sections of the airplane would have sheared off, or the airplane could have rapidly drifted further out of control as it accelerated quickly through 365 knots indicated. Big, heavy, thrusting things gain airspeed rapidly when you pitch them down 18 degrees at cruise power, and the margin of recoverability is very minimal. There are arguments that humans are unable to prevent some scenarios in that situation because by the time higher-order thinking on decisions has happened, it's too late. See, for example, the surprisingly lengthy duration of time between the incident and setting for idle, which probably should have been among the first things done in response. Brains are slow when things happen fast, and a symphony of alarms and whoops (undoubtedly in progress) does not help. A Boeing would not have intervened in the situation at all and would have allowed the aircraft to go overspeed, risking serious airframe damage. If you crash dive an airliner at cruising speed, very, very bad things happen. At cruising altitude safety envelopes are very small. The paragraph talking about direct law is, roughly speaking, what would have happened had this been a Boeing aircraft. (This isn't bad, it's just different philosophies of pilot responsibility. I'm not partisan on the difference like some pilots and am willing to acknowledge the benefits of both approaches; this one is an Airbus advantage.)
- PhantomGremlin 10y agoA Boeing would not have intervened in the situation at all OTOH it's probably a lot harder to "jam" a camera into the center stick of a Boeing than it is into the side-stick of a Bus.
- cypherpunks01 10y agoShouldn't there be an override switch to tell the plane to only accept one of the two control inputs, for situations like this where one of the inputs suffers some physical damage or jam? None of the hundreds of cockpit switches does that? What happens if one pilot dumps their entire cup of coffee onto their controls and it malfunctions causing erroneous input? Is it basically game over?
- hlandau 10y agoThere is. Google "sidestick priority".
- cypherpunks01 10y agoThanks! That is reassuring to know. Shouldn't they have used it in this case when they knew an input was jammed? Obviously it worked out when the computer decided to ignore them, but just curious what the correct procedure should have been here.
- hlandau 10y agoI should note that I'm not an expert on this subject. According to the below, Airbus cockpit sidesticks have a red button on them. Pressing it disengages the autopilot if it's engaged, which is probably the more normal use. Pressing it when the autopilot is already disengaged engages sidestick priority for as long as it's held down. It latches if held continuously for 40 seconds. http://aviation.stackexchange.com/questions/3455/why-is-the-priority-takeover-button-used http://aviation.stackexchange.com/questions/3455/why-is-the-... If they were on the ceiling perhaps it could be difficult to hold the button down continuously for 40 seconds.
- rtkwe 10y ago> “With his feet on the flight deck roof, the co-pilot reached down and attempted to disengage the autopilot by pulling back on his sidestick,” In this case I don't think they really knew that the issue was the jammed stick before the co-pilot pulling back on his stick gave the flight computer priority. It's hard to really say from the information given exactly when they discovered the camera was jammed and removed it vs when the plane was getting itself back under control.
- mbrookes 10y ago"Modern technology may be capable of reducing crew workload to historic lows" It's stated as benefit, but is this the reason pilots get bored perhaps?
- Neliquat 10y agoExactly. This is why level 2-4 automated cars scare the hell out of me.
- happosai 10y agoThe autopilot, carefully designed to handle all situations the engineers have imagined, suddenly throws hands up "you human handle this!". You, having let the car drive itself all the time have 0 hours hands-on driving time. You are now put in a fast-evolving situation too complicated for computers and are expected to do the right thing. This how AF447 happened.
- gcp 10y agoThe commander of AF447 did know exactly the right thing to do, though. (Aside from maybe knocking the copilot out)
- marcosdumay 10y agoLevel 3 is already ok. It means the car deals with anything that happens. It's level 2 that is the problem, and guess where most cars are now?
- PhantomGremlin 10y agoFrom the article: They then set the thrust levers to idle and raised the aircraft’s nose, before selecting take-off and go-around power and regaining straight and level flight at 31,000ft. Can anyone familiar with these aircraft opine on why the pilot decided to select TOGA in order to complete recovery? They were at perhaps 28,500 feet at the time. Seems like a a panic reaction.
- akira2501 10y agoThe higher the aircraft gets, the thinner the air, and the more power required to quickly add altitude at that point. Most aircraft have a slowly stepped climb and descent managed through ATC that gives them plenty of horizontal miles to change their altitude, so they can more gradually adjust in normal flight without having to use max power. These pilots fell 4,400 feet, I'm sure they wanted to quickly recover to avoid any further problems with other flights in the area.
- lmm 10y agoNot familiar but TOGA is just the aircraft-idiomatic version of "maximum power", no?
- Filligree 10y agoYes, and it wears the engines out much faster than any lower setting would. Grandparent post has a point, though it probably does have to do with recovering as quickly as possible.
- samfisher83 10y agoWhy was captain playing around with his camera when you are in charge of 200 lives?
- fit2rule 10y agoAutopilot.
- m_mueller 10y ago> "Up to 24% of the aircraft occupants were rendered temporarily unfit for duties following the incident" Gotta love the officialese for 'people puked everywhere'....
- fryguy 10y agoOr flung into the ceiling headfirst at 0.5g and then back to the floor at 2g. Presumably that could cause injuries other than motion sickness.
- comex 10y agoIndeed. From the Telegraph article linked in another comment: > Flt Lt Nathan Jones, the co-pilot, suffered a cut to the head, a fractured back, a prolapsed disc and nerve damage. > The court heard 14 passengers were so badly hurt they were unable to fly back to the UK.
- HorizonXP 10y agoTitle needs to updated: 1) Published in 2015 2) Clarify that Voyager is military designation for A330
- gsnedders 10y ago> Clarify that Voyager is military designation for A330 AFAIK, Voyager is only the RAF designation for the A330 MRTT. As far as I'm aware, the other airforces that operate it largely don't have any specific designations.
- 6stringmerc 10y agoAfter reading the summary it sounds like a "CAPTAIN HAD A MASSIVE HEART FAILURE AND SLUMPED FORWARD ON THE CONTROLS DO NOT CRASH AIRPLANE FROM CRUISE ALTITUDE IF POSSIBLE" which might sound pretty obvious but, uhh, that's some nice code work. That's why there are two (2) pilots in theory/practice, because human redundancy is a valuable asset. I can't help but think if there was a video camera in the cockpit it might have looked a lot like that scene in "The Big Lebowski" where he drops his joint between his legs while driving and then loses control and hits a dumpster. Shit tends to domino from time to time lol.
- ririau 10y agoRemember that most of the sources of typical crashes or problems have been eliminated. Which means that accidents happen they're always freak accidents.
- 6stringmerc 10y agoNot really, that recent crash in San Francisco had alarms going off like crazy and the idiot pilot still managed to crash the plane. Once you read enough NTSB reports / bulletins about General Aviation accidents (usually only big stuff makes the news) it becomes very clear that accidents happen and bad decisions happen. Like turning off the wrong engine...
- wapz 10y agoWas this the Korean (whichever of the companies) airlines crash? I didn't read up too much into it after the fact.
- ldp01 10y agoTaipai, Taiwan. I believe it had trouble in one engine briefly after takeoff, and the pilots tried turning it on and off again. Unfortunately they turned off the still-functioning engine and it plummeted into a river. You might remember the shot of it flying over a bridge, rolled 90 degrees and so close to the ground that the wing partly sheared off.
- acjohnson55 10y agoDamn. This reminds me a lot of a fantastic podcast episode on the pros and cons of automation: http://99percentinvisible.org/episode/children-of-the-magenta-automation-paradox-pt-1/ http://99percentinvisible.org/episode/children-of-the-magent...
- RachelF 10y agoThe Register has another take on this, including the court martial results: https://www.theregister.co.uk/2017/02/07/raf_voyager_zz333_flt_lt_andrew_townshend_court_martial/ https://www.theregister.co.uk/2017/02/07/raf_voyager_zz333_f...
- sizzzzlerz 10y agoThe linked article states that the trial of the pilot is continuing, not that a verdict had been handed down. He is being accused of two counts of perjury and one of making a false record. He has plead not guility to all charges but does admit that a camera did become wedged behind the stick.
- Animats 10y agoThe next step up is auto-GCAS. That system, which started going into USAF F-16s in 2014, has already saved four planes and pilots. Here's a video of the cockpit view. The pilot had briefly lost consciousness during a high-G maneuver, and the auto-GCAS system rolled the plane wings-level and pulled it out of a dive and into a mild climb.[1] Work is going on to develop auto-GCAS for aircraft without the maneuverability of a fighter. [1] http://aviationweek.com/air-combat-safety/auto-gcas-saves-unconscious-f-16-pilot-declassified-usaf-footage http://aviationweek.com/air-combat-safety/auto-gcas-saves-un...
- raverbashing 10y agoA similar system is beginning to roll out in case of Cabin depressurization, the plane descends and enters a holding pattern until somebody hopefully gets back from hypoxia (there's a good Smarter Every Day video about this)
- FabHK 10y agoThe Garmin G1000 "glass cockpit" offers a blue straight-and-level button even for small general aviation planes, such as the Cirrus: if you get disoriented or into an upset, just press it (whether the autopilot is on or off), and the autopilot will level the plane and hold altitude. However, AFAIK it's not an automatic envelope protection, though I'd think that it would be feasible. http://www.whycirrus.com/advancements/Cirrus-perspective-cockpit.aspx http://www.whycirrus.com/advancements/Cirrus-perspective-coc...
- _Codemonkeyism 10y agoThe Register article has this: "Flt Lt Nathan Jones, the co-pilot, suffered a cut to the head, a fractured back, a prolapsed disc and nerve damage, the court martial heard."
- rconti 10y agoSurely this can't be right: >Its automatic high-speed protection system was triggered 3s later, with a maximum indicated air speed of 358kt (662km/h), or Mach 0.9, recorded. Wikipedia says Mach 1 at sea level is 1225kph and 1091kph at 30,000ft. Not sure what temperature they assume though.
- lisper 10y agoIndicated airspeed is significantly lower than true airspeed at altitude.
- akiselev 10y agoIndicated airspeed measures the dynamic pressure exerted on the aircraft by the motion of the surrounding fluid, not the velocity relative to the ground. Airspeed indicators are calibrated at sea level so you need more information in order to get the calibrated airspeed for your altitude and you still need more data + error correction to turn that into true airspeed, which is the actual velocity of the plane relative to the air.
- woliveirajr 10y agoPPrune discussion on the issue, after the cause was found to be the stuck camera: http://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/533921-voyager-plummets-merged-14.html http://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/533921-voyager-plumm...
- coldcode 10y agoWhat this proves is that no matter how much you test and plan and design for things people can always find some way to screw things up you never imagined. I always keep that in mind when writing software for people.
- xenophonf 10y agoI was curious, so I found a picture of an A330-200 cockpit here: http://www.airplane-pictures.net/photo/251517/cs-tom-tap-portugal-airbus-a330-200/ http://www.airplane-pictures.net/photo/251517/cs-tom-tap-por... I'd like to know what kind of camera is going to fall against the pilot's stick and jam it forward!
- mcguire 10y agoJudging by the perspective, the seats are all the way back. When occupied, the end of the armrest should be somewhere close to the sidestick.
- Shalhoub 10y ago"Within 10s of the forward stick input, the A330 had reached a 17˚ nose-down attitude. Its automatic high-speed protection system was triggered 3s later" What exactly did this 'automatic high-speed protection system ' do? "As the aircraft pitched down, the aircraft’s captain – who was alone in the cockpit – attempted to disengage the autopilot and pull back on his sidestick" Surly the autopilot would have disengaged when the pilot moved his seat forward and pushed the sidestick forward at the same time? "With dual inputs being delivered, the A330’s flight protection system was automatically engaged" I thought the 'flight protection system' was already engaged. Why would dual imputs trigger the ' flight protection system' “The initial recovery from the dive was the result of the aircraft’s own protection measures, and not the product of pilot inputs.” What exactly did the computer do to initiate 'initial recovery'?