8 ms·
Sous Vide startup Anova gets acquired by Electrolux
- SEJeff 10y agoAnova is great, but I still prefer the Chef Steps Joule given the option of either/or.
- batbomb 10y agoAnova beat them to the market by years though, but I'd get the Joule today probably if I had a choice.
- dahdum 10y agoJoule requires an iOS / android app to use, which I'm sure is helpful for new cooks but super annoying if you know what you're doing already.
- tptacek 10y agoYou can get an Anova without wifi (network connectivity on these things is only marginally useful) for about $50 less, and it's got higher power output and really nice physical controls.
- batbomb 10y agoThe precision cooker, which does bluetooth, or first gen? I have the bluetooth precision cooker. The scroll wheel is starting to get a little flaky but i'm still happy. Mostly the joule would be nice for saving a bit more real estate in my cabinets.
- wklauss 10y agoI think the overall design of Joule is better, but the fact that you are forced to use a phone or tablet to control the Joule is a big drawback. Is there a specific reason your prefer it?
- ozi 10y agoThe Joule is much newer. My Anova was 2 years old before it we even announced by ChefSteps.
- rickdale 10y agoAt least using the iPad with the Joule and ChefSteps isn't as bad as using the iPad with the intelipan, a different 'smart' cooking device. With the intelipan, they make an internet connection obligatory and no option for not signing in. I would have returned the Joule if the app made me do all that. I dont mind using my iPad in the kitchen, I don't prefer it, but I do mind signing in to cook dinner...
- kbouck 10y agoI chose anova over joule for this reason and this reason only. My concern for a device with an app-only interface is the company might disappear, and the app and internet service might stagnate. With physical controls I'll still be able to use the product. Id love to see a joule v2 with a display and a twistable top to set the temp.
- cloakandswagger 10y agoCan someone elaborate on what Chef Steps business model is? The last time I tried to figure it out, they seemed to be a premium recipe/cooking classes website (bordering more on food porn, the videos seemed more artsy than useful to me) that is also pushing a sous vide machine. Am I right in assuming that the Joule is their pivot away from the online cooking lessons?
- JeffreyKaine 10y agoOther way around; the cooking lessons were a marketing scheme to build a customer base to sell Joule to while it was still in R&D land.
- dogma1138 10y agoAnova has much higher power output especially on the larger (Wifi+BT) model which both speeds up the heating by quite a bit and allows you to cook large volumes. Anova is also much easier to clean than the Joule, it comes apart so easily and you just dry it out, I have one for over a year and no signs of scaling on the heating element because of that. The joule on the other hand can't be easily clean you can unscrew the bottom but then you need to use a brush and the heating element isn't fully exposed. I have them both, and tbh I use the Anova considerably more, it's built better, it's built smarter, and the fact that I don't need to use a phone is a huge plus. Sure the phone is great for the first week if you never used sous vide before (I cooked Sous Vide on an induction cooker with very coarse temp control and use a thermometer to know when I should turn it off and on for nearly 2 years before getting a proper setup) but once you know the temp it just becomes a hassle.
- nirav72 10y ago>Anova has much higher power output especially on the larger (Wifi+BT) model Joule has 1100 watts and the Anova (Wifi + BT) is 900 watts. So not sure what you mean by Anova having more power. https://www.nerdwallet.com/blog/shopping/joule-vs-anova-sous-vide-comparison/ https://www.nerdwallet.com/blog/shopping/joule-vs-anova-sous... I agree with you on the ease of cleaning. I also have both and the Anova seems to be a bit easier to clean.
- snarf 10y agoA common failure mode for Anova is steam condensation in the electronics because the housing is not completely sealed/waterproof like the Joule, so I'm not sure if I would agree with it being built better and smarter. This is especially a risk with long cooks.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- clockpie 10y agoI bought an Anova after waiting forever for Joule to start international shipping.
- eps 10y agoGetting nothing but a blank page on iOS.
- tptacek 10y agoUltimately this is the outcome for all new cooking appliances. Breville bought PolyScience (the godfather of all sous vide devices) a few years back. Temperature-controlled cooking may never be as widespread as the microwave oven, but it has a decent shot at being as popular as the food processor or the large-form-factor toaster oven.
- dharma1 10y agoI've always wondered, why don't regular $30-50 rice/slow cookers have better temp controls.. cost would be minimal
- bravo22 10y agoThe cost is not in reading the temp. Cookers, and cooking systems in general have a lot of thermal inertia. You need a lot of wattage and a well designed PID to get precise temp control.
- 2muchcoffeeman 10y agoA now defunct company in Australia "Sous Vide at Home" actually sold a PID controller that converted a basic rice cooker - it won't work with a fancy one - into a rough temp controlled water bath. I have one. It actually works pretty well for a lot of things. The temp swing is a bit poor compared to other machines, about 2 degrees. But for the $120 I paid for it, it's pretty great.
- tptacek 10y agoAuber Instruments has been selling these for about 10 years now. I can only assume the prices have come down steeply; I bought mine (including the thermocouples) for around that much in 2007 (I think?), but that's now the price point for a circulator that's about as capable as the PolyScience Pro that I replaced the Auber with.
- joezydeco 10y agoDorkfood is still selling their DSV for $99 on Amazon. I've been using one for years with a cheap crock-pot and it works really well. Their PID control is excellent. https://www.amazon.com/Dorkfood-Sous-Vide-Temperature-Controller-DSV/dp/B0088OTON4 https://www.amazon.com/Dorkfood-Sous-Vide-Temperature-Contro...
- caycep 10y agoJust out of curiousity, why is it named after ANOVA?
- shalmanese 10y agoAnova Scientific was a long standing scientific water bath maker that spun off a wildly successful culinary arm (https://www.waterbaths.com/about.html https://www.waterbaths.com/about.html).
- caycep 10y agoHa, that's neat! Kind of like Nalgene?
- scentedmeat 10y agoIIRC, the Anova cooking was originally one guy at the lab devices company that saw the Nomiku or Polyscience and said, "we can do that" and started basically doing this as a side business. I hope he got a bonus at least.
- jayjay71 10y agoDo you have a source for that?
- shalmanese 10y agoI don't have a source handy but the guy was present on a ton of food forums at the time, gathering feedback and responding to inquiries. He was pretty open that this was a one man side project at the time. I still own one of the V1 Anovas and sent him some UI feedback (including uncovering a bug where the calibration was done backwards on an early batch of machines).
- tptacek 10y agoAt the time of their first product launch, before the $1.8MM Kickstarter campaign, they already had 3 cofounders. Anova, Nomiku, and Sansaire all sort of started at roughly the same time. Sansaire is (IIRC) the Seattle Food Blog team, the people behind one of the more popular DIY Sous Vide kits. Nomiku was a DIY SV team from New York. The thing about all these products is, the fundamental technology isn't difficult. The challenge is just straightforward hardware product development and execution, the basic stuff that's hard for everyone to get right --- along with marketing and inventory and channel management. PolyScience, on the other hand, has been doing serious equipment manufacturing for a long time.
- kin 10y agoHappy for them! The Anova product is great and they iterated on it properly. Unlike a lot of other Kickstarters I've backed...
- cleetus 10y agoFor the space constrained, the Joule is a good bit smaller. https://anovaculinary.com/anova-precision-cooker/specifications/ https://anovaculinary.com/anova-precision-cooker/specificati... https://www.chefsteps.com/joule/specs https://www.chefsteps.com/joule/specs
- zwily 10y agoThe nice thing about the Anova is that you don't have to use your phone to set it.
- kelvie 10y agoYeah, it's annoying, but the Joule fits so much better into the drawer. It also has a much lower minimum water line, and slightly higher heat output, and as a result, it can heat up small portions to temperature _really_ quickly. (We had an Anova, replaced it with a Joule and gave the Anova away)
- DenisM 10y agoBetter for travel, too. I took my Anova with me to a rented condo in Hawaii, it's nice to be able to make quality food with minimal effort. Joule would be even easier to justify.
- kbouck 10y agoAnova recently announced a "nano" edition which is lower power, costs $99, and looks like it's closer to the dimensions of a joule. Couldn't find the specific dimensions anywhere yet though. https://www.cnet.com/products/anova-nano/preview/ https://www.cnet.com/products/anova-nano/preview/
- shalmanese 10y agoGood for Anova but this acquisition doesn't make much sense to me. Unlike most culinary methods, there's no better and worse sous vide, all sous vide machines produce the exact identical quality outcome. There's some minor differentiation when it comes to size, noise, apps etc. but they turn out to be not super important in practice. As Sous Vide becomes more popular, all of the existing players are going to get murdered by cheap, Chinese generics and there's no real room for profit in the market. The devices are incredibly simple and easy to manufacture and there's no defensive moat around any of the technology. There's the possibility of Anova branching out from SV into other related devices but it's unclear where it could head to justify the acquisition amount. They can either choose to pursue devices that are even more niche than SV (combi ovens, vacuum sealers, chamber vacuums, centrifuges, rotovaps) in the hopes that they become increasingly mainstream or they can go after more popular devices (microwaves, dishwashers, toaster ovens, blenders etc.) which are incredibly competitive fields filled with tough incumbents. Neither seems like an incredibly compelling choice or one I would stake an acquisition on. I'm glad the team has gotten this far and has been instrumental in pushing SV more into the mainstream but I don't see many bright prospects for their future.
- krapht 10y agoNever underestimate the power of marketing and branding in creating profit over generic competitors. See blenders: Ninja, Vitamix.
- MrBuddyCasino 10y agoOr: Thermomix, can be yours for the low, low price of 1199 €. Widely successful product. Also, apparently Anova stuff is "connected in a meaningful way" - sounds familiar?
- shalmanese 10y agoAll the current SV companies can see the writing on the wall and hope that they can avoid commodification via their proprietary app. Except that the problem is that Sous Vide is the ultimate open platform since each recipe only consists of two numbers, a temperature and a time. The apps aren't super useful in the first place and, even if they were, there's no meaningful way for the apps to provide lockin since you can never restrict a recipe to a single device.
- _ph_ 10y agoGood news for Anova - I am a very happy user of their device. I hope this is going to bring sous vide finally into all kitchen stores, especially over here in Europe its still very unknown. Sous vide has changed my meat cooking entirely.
- azernik 10y agoNitpick - Anova isn't exactly a startup. The original Anova Scientific [https://www.waterbaths.com https://www.waterbaths.com] is a lab equipment manufacturer specializing in controlled-temperature water baths. When they realised that chefs were willing to spend thousands or tens of thousands of dollars on their baths for cooking purposes, they made a classic pivot and span off Anova Culinary to make smaller, cheaper products for home kitchen use. The Kickstarter was as far as I understand as much to gauge market size as to raise capital.