6 ms·
The perils of reporting on China's GDP
- rrggrr 10y agoAnyone interested in China's real economic condition should have a look at the ongoing analysis by Michael Pettis: http://carnegieendowment.org/experts/444 http://carnegieendowment.org/experts/444 And Christopher Balding: http://www.baldingsworld.com/ http://www.baldingsworld.com/ Like other China watchers, they tease economic reality out of ancillary economic data that is difficult to spin (eg. capital outflows, HK-China cross-border trade, energy consumption). The picture is not good. Reforms are needed, to increase low and middle-class domestic consumption; and perhaps a trillion? in non-performing loans must be written off. The rules for foreign trade and investment in China need to be rewritten to allow for unrestricted foreign competition and investment in the broadest of terms. In sum, system inefficiency in China markets must be rooted out quickly to avoid a much worse crisis.
- conistonwater 10y agoOne thing I never totally understood is: what happens if those things don't get done? For example, when there is a trillion in non-performing loans, is it an absolute inevitability that they will be written off, or is it "merely" a good idea to write them off (and hence one would think they would write them off)?
- adventured 10y agoThe Japan zombie scenario is usually cited as the most likely outcome if China refuses to reform its economy and allow bad loans to go bad (allow bankruptcy etc). The zombies are semi-dead entities (whether full corporate, or corporate-state). They tend to perpetually eat capital, frequently need new bailouts, get in the way of progress and growth in the economy, and they tend to survive by politics (by necessity, as they're failed entities) rather than serving customers or providing a good product etc.
- rrggrr 10y agoRemember that China must import goods and services to keep any engine running. And, it must defend the RMB internationally. The point being that these debts erode RMB value and confidence and cause continued and massive outflows of foreign reserves l. The engine is running out of fuel.
- walrus1066 10y agoIt is an inevitability that bad loans get written off. It's just a question when the loss is recognized. You either recognize it up front and write off the loan, or you don't, in which case you keep on losing money into perpetuity, as the person/company misses payments and you have to keep on rolling their debt over or restructuring it, in the hope that you'll be made whole eventually. Over time, the money lost would become equal to the cost of just writing off the loan at the start. But the losses keep carrying on, as you've rolled over their debt, so you'll have to write the loan off eventually, but at greater expense than if you'd have done it earlier.
- tw04 10y ago>The picture is not good. Reforms are needed, to increase low and middle-class domestic consumption; and perhaps a trillion? in non-performing loans must be written off. The rules for foreign trade and investment in China need to be rewritten to allow for unrestricted foreign competition and investment in the broadest of terms. In sum, system inefficiency in China markets must be rooted out quickly to avoid a much worse crisis. All of that is based on the premise that the rest of the worlds financial industry are willing to let them collapse. Is that REALLY an accurate premise to work from? I think the aftermath of the mortgage crisis says otherwise.
- DeonPenny 10y agoMost of their debt though is internal. It's chinese government owned banks lending to chinese government owned business. Why would any else care. It won't hurt most other people.
- shagie 10y agoIf I recall correctly, its the ongoing aspect. There is debt that a government owned company has in a government owned bank. Writing that debt off (and not continuing to accrue more debt) would mean acknowledging that company _doesn't_ have any profit and would need to close (and fire its workers). As it is, the government owned businesses that have employees who do nothing are a form of welfare - its just they can't call it that - switching the columns from "employment and having revenue of X" to "payments to unemployed workers" could have a significant impact in the morale and productivity of people actually working. Lemon socialism ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lemon_socialism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lemon_socialism ) and zombie company ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zombie_company https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zombie_company ). Granted, last year's news: [Massive layoffs coming as China confronts its overbuilt 'zombie economy'](http://www.cbc.ca/news/world/china-zombie-economy-layoffs-petricic-1.3473002 http://www.cbc.ca/news/world/china-zombie-economy-layoffs-pe...) has it at 6,000,000 workers which could cause some significant instability with it that the government is trying to manage (granted, its by ignoring it and continuing to pay the workers despite oversupply). Laying off 6M people will hurt many others and needs to be watched for when it does happen.
- baybal2 10y agoHohoho, i wrote a paper on the Chinese credit crunch: "the illusion of wealth" during my college years in 2011. I presented it in a class full of kids of rich Chinese expats studying at BCIT back then, and I was laughed off even by an instructor who was a brilliant mind, and had a very anti-red political stance. Two years later, an Econ proff from UBC asked me for a reprint permission. Now, i have randoms buzzing me quite often just to get to know if i had some "behind the scene" knowledge. What surprised me the most was that my former classmate introduced me to her father (a rather rich Chinese businessman), as "the most smart guy in the class" and pretty much tried to drag me into his company. Now I work in China, but not with them.
- jayjay71 10y ago"Now, for the first time, we have official confirmation that GDP (in China) has been fabricated." How much have the numbers been changed?
- jonwachob91 10y agoThe last paragraph estimates 4% instead of 7%. But they don't cite sources to back the claim up.
- ktRolster 10y ago4% growth is still pretty good tbh
- DeonPenny 10y agoNot for china, the government unlike most western country only stays in power because of the growing economy. I the west if the economy is broken it's the people fault. There it's the communist fault the economy broke.
- seanmcdirmid 10y agoWhich makes unwinding very hard. So they keep pumping up the bubble and kicking the can down as long as possible...they have no other choice unless they can eventually blame an external entity (Trump might be a godsend for the CPC).
- DeonPenny 10y agoI have a feeling if your starving at home you're not going to care if the government is blaming someone half a world away.
- DeonPenny 10y agoNot for china, the government unlike most western country only stays in power because of the growing economy. I the west if the economy is broken it's the people fault. There it's the communist fault the economy broke.
- ecommerceguy 10y agoAs someone who's frequently been to China, and I'm talking remote, countryside, ox sowed rice paddy China, everything published from the government is known locally as being totally fake. Bribes are standard and should be expected to do any transaction of volume. Fake GDP numbers are obvious. Heck, fake everything is the norm there. Tax day is very interesting. Uniformed government officials setup camp at the major "5 star" hotels in town and the factory bosses show up in their Lexus SUVs with duffle bags full of Yuan to pay the toll. It's something to be seen for sure. There is no real accounting in middle China. I attribute all the fakeness to 3 main factors; communist party politics, local politics and the diversity of cultures equating to local protectionism and face saving. It's entrenched and will likely never change. I could probably write a book about fake China.
- jonwachob91 10y agoYou could start with a blog... (video, audio, or written) If you get yuge <----> (those are hands far apart...) number of viewers you could get a massive book deal.
- robertelder 10y agoI have been watching this guy's videos, and there are a lot of interesting details about what life is really like in China: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1At2H-lIJog https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1At2H-lIJog
- ethbro 10y agoHaving hiked a bit of the Great Wall during a layover in November of last year, China even an hour outside the Beijing airport is a bizarre amalgamation of technology (concrete everywhere, solar, modern roads) and much much older techniques (pre-mechanized farming, no centralized utilities, stores with shelves whose stock looks like it's the US Great Depression). It was certainly different from what I was expecting from the news. I'd highly encourage going if you can (and layover/transit visa's in most international airports are free and don't require pre-approval).
- 10y ago
- vtange 10y agoChina has done a really great job marketing their economy to the average American though. From the quick numbers to the glistening photos of Shanghai. Ask most non-China watching Americans, and they'll tell you that they're more innovative than the U.S. and we should be more like them than they to us and focus on the economy instead of human rights, which by the way is exactly what the Chinese party line wants. Which I always found funny since we're actually pretty eager to doubt our own government (some even believe Washington is more corrupt than any other foreign country) and downplay our own achievements/ point out our own flaws.
- Zigurd 10y agoSome of the obvious achievements in China can't be faked. Shanghai, Beijing, ShenZhen and other first-tier cities are very impressive, not just in pictures. These are not Potemkin villages. The impressiveness is evident edge to edge, all over town. Westerners often don't know where to look for problems. For example, the walled-off hutongs in Beijing during the 2008 Olympics were cordoned off because they are prime luxury real estate being renovated, not because they were slums. The irony is that the Chinese did a bad job preserving enough of those old courtyard homes. There is both casual and acute corruption in China, and that is hard to cover in the news. Concealing corruption is in nearly everyone's interest. Nobody will like you for uncovering it.
- baybal2 10y agoYes, that's true. Shenzhen real estate prices are closing on that of Manhattan's when you talk about urban centres. It is also the most expensive city to live in in China (again, true only for urban centres. Suburbs are still livable). These two things together made the cost of doing business here prohibitive, unless your business is not real estate speculation. Local electronics businesses closing one after another. The famed Shanzhai garage companies fared even worse than established businesses. There not a single one left now. They died to phenomenal brain drain levels, costs, market saturation, US an EU domestic consumption going down, and people leaving for "cheaper and easier live abroad"
- 10y ago
- ChuckMcM 10y agoI've always found the competing interests in Chinese economic data to be fascinating. But what is more interesting is that the reality, apparently somewhere between what the government says and the completely dystopian view of Chinese detractors has brought a tremendous number of people out of real poverty. A friend of mine who started a business there remarked in 2004 that there was so much money around it was impossible for the party members to shovel it all to their lieutenants and the overflow was helping the growing middle class. "Investing" was very much like the dot com days, everyone wanted in and over payed for securities. And in spite of all the shenanigans in the numbers a lot of infrastructure that is useful is built, and while it might be over built its easier to use excess capacity than it is to create marginally more infrastructure. So all in all its a win for China.
- seanmcdirmid 10y agoA lot of that indfrastructure isn't going to last. We talk about bridges that fail that we're built 50 years ago, in china its more like 10, or even a brand new one fails because all work was sub contracted out multiple times. Likewise with residential buildings, China's low tech/skill approach to building means these buildings require more maintenance and begin to look dipilated only a few years after they are built. People talk about Kangbashi (Ordos New Town) eventually filling up, but the clock has been ticking for 5 years already, the infrastructure of a ghost city won't last that long. And then there is the infrastructure that isn't built but badly needed. Billions for HSR but nothing for decent drainage so cities don't have huge floods whenever it rains heavily. Or what about some water treatment plants to clean up the water? China is rife with such contradictions.
- maverick_iceman 10y agoI'm seeing all these anti-China articles constantly for the last two years. There's a whole army of 'experts' claiming that China's economy will crash any day now. However, none of that has happened.
- rrggrr 10y agoExperts have not and do not predict a imminent crash as a likely scenario. Possible, yes. Likely, no. They have predicted costly and painful unemployment, wealth destruction, and increased civil unrest... all mostly avoidable if swift action is taken to rebalance China's economy. The inaccuracies are your's.
- seanmcdirmid 10y agoCrashes have happened multiple times over the last 20 years, the recent being the Chinese stock market crash a year ago. It would be stupid not to predict a crash, as they are pretty common. Collapse is much worse, and isn't being predicted by the western media. If you google news "china economic collapse" you'll find Chinese media talking about how the west media is predicting this, but oddly enough, no western mainstream media actually predicting that (beyond Gordon Chang, no one at all).
- woodandsteel 10y agoThe Chinese government agrees the economy is slowing down. You think that saying anything bad about China is being anti-China. So objective reporting would only say good things about it? And patriotic Chinese would think only positive things about their nation? You know, you can't solve problems unless you first acknowledge them.
- rajeshp1986 10y agoI am not quite sure how GDP of a country is measured and what are the different methods to measure GDP. But one thing we can't deny is that everything that we use today has "Manufactured in China" label to it. I am just amazed how many goods are produced in China. Whole of the Indian market is flooded with Chinese items. I see most of the stuff I buy in US comes from China as well. I am not even talking about things like iphone. I am talking about everyday stuff one uses like clothes, shoes, etc. All the wealth is flowing into China in exchange for those goods which increases their GDP. China is also making huge investments in Africa & Pakistan. They are exploring new markets for selling its cheaply manufactured goods. The Economists claim that those numbers are fake are not aware of ground reality. I don't see China slowing down in the near future, at least no in the next decade.
- woodandsteel 10y agoOf course the Chinese economy is gigantic, the Economist is not disputing that. The question is recent trends, and it is in fact terribly hard to get reliable data on that. >I don't see China slowing down in the near future, at least no in the next decade. The Chinese government, from the top down, has been saying for years that the economy is slowing down.
- Fifer82 10y agoIf I want to help my Country, I need to go out, get blasted on ale, and then take out a credit card on the way home, preferably a loan. This would be the only thing that I could do to improve my countries economy and apparently, our Economy is in good shape (just ignore health, social care, pensions, energy, transport, education, ai and the aging demographic and viola). What you just said, and what I just said, should be switched around and I think the primary reason why that isn't the case is because Credit Agencies now come with a "Public Bailout" parameter. The entire system is just made up to suit those with the golden pens. Reality is long gone.
- woodandsteel 10y agoPeople who support authoritarianism claim it can run the economy more efficiently than democracy. But one of the problems in authoritarian regimes is you almost invariably get massive faking of economic data, and so the government lacks the understanding needed to make sound decisions.