17 ms·
Make Firefox support moz://a
- ricardobeat 10y agoSuch a terrible idea... this will generate endless confusion for no gain at all.
- romanovcode 10y agoI don't think people will care too much. It's not like Firefox is changing name or something.
- calcifer 10y agoHow will it create confusion? Nobody types moz:// in regular usage, so this only effects you if you are specifically looking for an easter egg or something.
- a012 10y agoI didn't think to type moz:// but I'm starting to read "moz" instead of "mozilla" now.
- wlkr 10y agoSame here, although perhaps that's because for some unknown reason internally I've always said dot-dot-slash-slash for :// so it's odd trying to read it as 'ill'. I don't expect the protocol logo will appear in print form in text very often though so it's not an issue.
- puredlx 10y agoThe guys from moz.com will be happy about that.
- acqq 10y agoIn the comments, JR Conlin: "REALLY ought to register "moz" with IANA as well. Otherwise it might pop up as a "real" protocol declaration in the future and we might have a conflict. We can just reserve the prefix so that it's not available for general use. " But it's just marketing. Marketing "decisions" change all the time, and the approaches are discarded forever. And we all have one more technical debt. Let the marketoids do what they do, just keep them as away as possible.
- mtgx 10y agoYou don't think at the very least older people will see Moz://a and try to type that into the browser's address bar? Also, Moz.com should expect a huge increase in its revenues soon. I imagine they already have the celebration party planned for the weekend.
- toxican 10y agoI don't think older people know/care about Mozilla. Hell these days I'm not sure younger people do either, unfortunately.
- PKop 10y agoIn other words, how does this logo help to generate interest in the company Mozilla, then? If the goal wasn't to generate interest in the company, what was the goal?
- slig 10y ago> Also, Moz.com should expect a huge increase in its revenues soon. How so? People "savvy" enough to type "moz://a" on a search bar aren't the same type of people interested in the services of a SEO company.
- toyg 10y agoThe opposite might well be true: people believing seo is a real thing tend to be the unsavvy ones. Moz.com should throw a party.
- dkresge 10y agoIt does tend to bork the unified search bar.
- brador 10y agoSunk cost fallacy in action right from the start. This is why you always have a disclaimer allowing editorial discretion when doing anything crowd based.
- mypalmike 10y agoIndeed. And on the code side, implementing this gimmick involves 115 lines of new code across 9 files. https://reviewboard.mozilla.org/r/105654/diff/1#index_header https://reviewboard.mozilla.org/r/105654/diff/1#index_header
- jcranmer 10y agoHalf of those changes are actually just tests that it works correctly The first three files are the only ones that are doing any useful work, and then the last one makes sure that it works in anything other than a local build.
- mypalmike 10y ago1 LOC is 1 LOC to be maintained, be it test or otherwise.
- hkjgkjy 10y agoIt's a cool concept - but surely there are a lot of regexps our there that will now trigger in vain. Also search engines will index "moz://a" as a different thing than "mozilla". Likely, the first will be indexed as ["moz", ":", "/", "/", "a"] and the punctuation likely be thrown out, resulting in matches for "moz" and "a".
- tokenizerrr 10y agoBecause search engines are using Firefox, right? This is an easter egg within the Firefox web browser. No search engine is going to notice a thing.
- FeepingCreature 10y agoNo, the issue is the new logo is "moz://a", so when people don't get that it's supposed to mean "mozilla" they'll type it in as "moz://a".
- roryisok 10y agoonly people who don't know how to use the internet will do that
- ReverseCold 10y agoIsn't that a lot of people?
- pandler 10y agoMost people, more like.
- gkya 10y agoIf they're seeing Mozilla logo somewhere, they're either on the Mozilla website or a webpage regarding Mozilla or a product thereof, so all this discussion is in vain and is a parody of itself. Also, WRT indexing, the logo is an image, not text, so the search engines will either not index it or index it like they index other images, using filename and maybe embedded metadata.
- themihai 10y agoSo once you switch the browser , mozilla website stops working...
- ishaanbahal 10y agoNot really. They are talking about a mozilla specific URL handler with a custom (fake) protocol. Something like moz://a would redirect to their motto page, moz://about to their settings or something like that. Switching to chromium and typing mozilla.org would still work.
- tokenizerrr 10y agoJust like how chrome://flags/ breaks when you switch away from Chrome. Not very surprising, is it?
- INTPenis 10y ago2nd google result for moz://a is that bug report. At least in "my google". ;)
- pmontra 10y agoIronically googling for moz://a from the address bar doesn't work in Firefox Android. It's interpreting it as a protocol and doesn't send it to Google. It displays a blank page. Moz://a from google returns moz.com as first result. Ironically again, it's a SEO company. Maybe Mozilla needs their services.
- karrotwaltz 10y agoSearching "moz://a", neither Google nor DuckDuck shows Mozilla's website on the first page of results... and the SEO company is first in both indeed.
- timendum 10y agoThere is already a working add-on https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/moz-a-protocol-handler/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/moz-a-protoco... (Firefox only)
- DangerousPie 10y agoOne of the comments there makes a good point - they should really register `moz://` as a protocol, otherwise someone will grab that at some point and cause endless confusion. On the other hand, "we used this for branding" is really not a great justification for registering a new protocol, is it...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- xg15 10y agoIt may not be the best reason, but aren't there already dozens of highly product-specific schemes in use? (such as steam:, unreal:, chrome: in Firefox, chrome: in Chrome - with completely different semantics -, view-source: etc etc)
- Someone1234 10y agoAre any of those registered with the IANA?
- XaspR8d 10y agoYep, though most of them are "provisional", which means it isn't a formal or permanent definition. Here's the full list: https://www.iana.org/assignments/uri-schemes/uri-schemes.xhtml https://www.iana.org/assignments/uri-schemes/uri-schemes.xht...
- xg15 10y agoThank you for the link. I wouldn't have believes there are that many URI schemes in existence though...
- jlgaddis 10y agoThey (Richard Barnes) did, according to the comments.
- ComodoHacker 10y ago
- agjmills 10y agoDoes this mean that http:// http:// is httpill? httpsill ftpill ircill sshill
- pmontra 10y agoGood ideas for some http processing libraries. We already have httpotion and httpoison for Elixir and httparty for Ruby. A pill has its place between them. Seriously, I disliked all 4 logos that made to Mozilla's shortlist. Moz://a wasn't the worst one graphically, but changing name to something unspeakable and ungooglable doesn't feel right. However I'll keep using Firefox. Hopefully they won't waste many energies into this bug.
- roryisok 10y ago> but changing name to something unspeakable and ungooglable doesn't feel right. they're not changing the name. they're still "mozilla". they will still have "mozilla.org" and you'll still be able to google it. it's just a new logo. people are so over-reacting to this
- notheguyouthink 10y agoImagine how they would react if Mozilla changed their logo to some non-font design? "What are we supposed to call them now? Circle? Circle square-rectangle? What is the world coming to, why would they call themselves Circle!"
- pmontra 10y agoNon-font designs don't have these problems. Mercedes' three pointed star logo doesn't leave anybody puzzled about the spelling of their name. They have to ask for the name, then it's easy. Letters induce people thinking that the name of the company is what they see in the logo. Imagine you know about a new company from its logo C0mp4ny. I think everybody would assume that the name of the company is C0mp4ny, not Company.
- SonOfLilit 10y ago
- datenwolf 10y agoUntil now I didn't realize Mozilla changed their logo. Now I've seen it the typographer in me cries… The whole purpose of text is to _unambigously_ convey information. So either Mozilla now rebrands themself as moz-colon-slash-slash or they now live with a significant portion of typography-anal nerds who dislike that logo.
- roryisok 10y ago> The whole purpose of text is to _unambigously_ convey information I don't know if its ironic that this sentence had a typo and some non-working markdown Anyway, the purpose of text may be to unambiguously convey information, but the purpose of a logo is to look cool and be memorable
- notheguyouthink 10y agoFwiw, the Markdown works just fine. Hackernews doesn't support Markdown. I'm not sure what you call this weird thing that HN does support.. but it's certainly not markdown.
- TorKlingberg 10y agoThere's been several front page articles about it over the last few days. It's a perfect bike shedding topic.
- laumars 10y agoLogos fall more in the realm of graphic design rather than typography. They're an avatar thus logos don't necessarily need to be readable - albeit there is a modern trend to use the company name in an interesting typeface as their logo. However there are plenty of examples where a company logo contains no text what-so-ever - including Mozilla's previous logo[1]. So I wouldn't get too hung up on its typographic design. At least not unless Mozilla start using 'Moz://a' in normal correspondence. ;) Personally I quite like it. It's memorable and well suited to the business they're best known for. Which is essentially the crux of a logo. [1] https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/5/5c/Mozilla_dinosaur_head_logo.png https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/5/5c/Mozilla_...)
- jo909 10y agoI think the bikeshed should be painted orange!
- Normal_gaussian 10y agoIt is well understood by those of us who are more literate in these things that a bikeshed should have a combination of transparent windshield walls and solid green roof. I therefore propose we tear down the existing, functional, bikeshed as its blue walls (which would not look good in orange) are constructed of a material which is not transparent.
- roryisok 10y agono need to hate on the blue walls. people who park their bikes in bikesheds with walls made of transparent materials shouldn't throw stones.
- hiimnate 10y agoWell obviously you lack a basic understanding of bikeshed technology. It should be blue!
- matt4077 10y agoNote that the logo's rendering does not change the name's spelling. It's still "Mozilla", in the same way that it's Apple (not [apple emoticon]), and Google, not <blue>G</blue><red>o</red><yellow>o</yellow>...
- SamBam 10y agoNobody expects to be able to type an apple-symbol, or for colors to have any meaning. But if Apple changed their branding so that their logo was just "App/e" written out, wouldn't you expect people to type that out? Actually, wait, we don't have to imagine. What about the Apple ][, or the Apple //e?
- joelthelion 10y agoI sense the dumbest security hole ever...
- acomjean 10y agojust make it do what happen when you type about:mozilla in the address bar
- cpeterso 10y agobtw, about:about will list all of Firefox's internal about: pages.
- cschmidt 10y agoIf you're not a logo geek, this is the major website that reviews logo redesigns, on the new Mozilla logo: http://www.underconsideration.com/brandnew/archives/new_logo_for_mozilla_by_johnson_banks.php#.WIDIXJJXU84 http://www.underconsideration.com/brandnew/archives/new_logo...
- matt4077 10y agoQuote, to maybe nib the ritual hatred in the bud before mozilla becomes the new Apple: "A logo that not only DOESN’T suck but one that has a strong idea, a fresh execution, a promising flexibility, and, that all of it together, sometimes subtly and sometimes overtly, manages to communicate what Mozilla is about." Now if only someone would write an article explaining why considerations such as branding are useful even for non-profits... edit: the last sentence was apparently interpreted as an actual question, when it was meant as a plea for someone to do an eloquent write-up of the non-profits-also-need-marketing case that I could link to.
- cschmidt 10y agoYes, on the whole they seemed to like it. Which isn't true of many of the redesigns they reviews.
- dublinben 10y agoWhy are the branding needs of a non-profit organization any less than that of a for-profit organization?
- matt4077 10y agoThey are not – the are, after all, operating in a few markets with basically the same mechanisms as any market. And the continued insistence of more or less any for-profit company (and non-profit, and government,...) shows that it's effective. But it was a point repeatedly made in the other threads about this redesign – basically "they're wasting their/our/my money on useless stuff like this when what they need to do is make Firefox use less memory/faster/whatever...".
- toxican 10y agoWhile I don't like the branding move at all, I think the concern that people will start calling them moz-colon-forward-slash-forwadslash-a is a little ridiculous. Is Sony's line of laptops Analog Wave One Zero? Is Verizon Verizoncheckmark? Is Johnson & Johnson Johnson ampersand Johnson? Is Comcast CComcast? No, because people aren't complete idiots. Those that are going to know/care about Mozilla will be able to tell it's a little web reference nestled inside the logo and that it still reads "Mozilla".
- adamgravitis 10y agoTo be fair, I do insist on calling Deloitte "Deloitte Dot".
- semi-extrinsic 10y agoAlso "the Kia Cee-apostrophe-dee" and "the VW Up-exclamation-mark". Not to mention "the Ferrari the Ferrari (sic)".
- CWuestefeld 10y agoTo be fair, those were specific examples of trying to be silly.
- wott 10y ago> No, because people aren't complete idiots. Sweet summer child. http://www.gentside.com/le-bon-coin/le-bon-coin-un-ordinateur-susv-marque-concurrente-de-asus-vous-dirait_pic124466.html http://www.gentside.com/le-bon-coin/le-bon-coin-un-ordinateu... http://i.imgur.com/4nMqG8C.png http://i.imgur.com/4nMqG8C.png http://www.jofogas.hu/veszprem/Sony_mio_laptop_elado_60403468.htm http://www.jofogas.hu/veszprem/Sony_mio_laptop_elado_6040346... http://archiwum.allegro.pl/oferta/sony-mio-pcg-6e1m-laptop-okazja-i6494889749.html http://archiwum.allegro.pl/oferta/sony-mio-pcg-6e1m-laptop-o... https://www.olx.in/item/sony-wio-laptop-ID19koWZ.html https://www.olx.in/item/sony-wio-laptop-ID19koWZ.html
- 10y ago
- toyg 10y agoEverything around this redesign is just a clusterfuck: the process, the winner, the hacks introduced to cope with it, the SEO fail, the loss of identity...
- Kolberht 10y agoMost people don't care. It shows how emo some of the users are.
- nstr10 10y agoApparently our friends at Mozcolonslashslasha don't realize how many more important things they could be working on than this.
- onion2k 10y agoOf course they do, and that work continued while other people worked on the rebranding. Also, and more importantly, maintaining an up-to-date brand keeps Mozilla relevant and (hopefully) stops them looking like a throwback to a past era (like, say, Yahoo!). Mozilla needs to do many things to remain an important force on the web. Keeping it's brand is one aspect of that work.
- reitanqild 10y agoThey are very aware it seems based on my observations over the last few years and while I don't agree with everything they do I defend their right to spend a tiny fraction of their time on a logo. - after all it seems logo, ui and pixel polish etc matters a whole lot more to a lot of people than it does to me so it might be well worth updating. Me? As long as extensions work and they don't copy too much more (bad imo) ideas like hidden menus and hamburger from Chrome and Mac they are still easily my favourite. Oh, and they have created a new systems programming language that has managed to exite me and a lot of others here on the northeastern side of the Internet.
- StevePerkins 10y agoPeople keep talking about Mozilla like it's the engineering wing of the EFF, that it's tirelessly working on a mission of Internet freedom, etc. I'm sorry, but I just don't see it. I see: (1) a team of developers, incrementally maintaining a codebase that that was donated by a 1990's commercial entity, and (2) some second-tier marketing types, burning through Google/Yahoo money and padding their resumes with random "me too" projects that don't last very long. The flagship browser has only had one major re-think since Netscape's demise, and that re-think was, "We should make its UI and dev cycle look like Chrome's". The most significant "new" project dreamed up by the marketing types was a me-too Android alternative, which they then almost immediately canceled. The only noteworthy and truly innovative things I can think of coming out of Mozilla have been Rust and Persona, and the latter was also quickly canceled (which was a shame since it's the only example I can think of that REALLY fits the mission statement they talk about). I'm glad that Firefox is out there to prevent a Google monopoly, and I'm glad that Rust has a financial patron since it's a pretty interesting language. But if Mozilla want to be seen as some greater "force for Internet freedom", beyond just maintaining an dated and declining web browser, then a logo change won't be enough. Actually DO some other stuff without canceling it.
- TazeTSchnitzel 10y agoThe :// thing is cute, but… did Mozilla really need a new logo? Their existing wordmark may not be especially distinctive, but it is familiar. And they have a distinctive symbol, too. The new logo looks more contemporary. I'm not sure if that's good. Mozilla can be proud of its history, no?
- thresh 10y agoYeah, that will totally solve Mozilla's now so slow fading into irrelevance. VideoLAN.org website stats tell me that Firefox hits percentage dropped from 26.3% through Jan 2016 to 21.2% through Jan 2017. Of course this is not a 100% reliable measure, but stats usually don't lie about that.
- matt4077 10y agoIt's the result of Google throwing their full weight behind Chrome. It's insane not to expect the #1 cash-generating business to take a large bite out of Firefox when they set their mind on creating a browser that ticks all the marks of Mozilla's goals as well: standards-compliant (or setting), fast, secure, open, extensible etc. And Chrome is now at the absolute core of Google's strategy: they need to make the open web as competitive a platform as possible to stop Facebook's walled garden, or Apple's native platform the future of the web. Because google has no place in those two ecosystems. Thus: Android and Chrome. Trash-talking Mozilla is only going to make their funding dry up and/or demotivate their employees. But it's in everyone's interest to make sure they thrive. It's only a coincidence that Google and the public's interest are currently aligned. There will come a time in the future where we'll desperately need the competitor that is Firefox. Let's not forget that they were ones lighting a fire under IE from around 2005-2012. Who knows where we'd be without them – .docx instead of .html?
- reitanqild 10y ago> Yeah, that will totally solve Mozilla's now so slow fading into irrelevance. Neither will constant picking on anything they do or don't do. > VideoLAN.org website stats tell me that Firefox hits percentage dropped from 26.3% through Jan 2016 to 21.2% through Jan 2017. I guess the reason might just be that the market is moving towards a new equilibrium. Unless we start making websites and web apps that only work in other browsers then the web is big enough for both Firefox and other inferior browsers ;-)
- thresh 10y agoI'm not picking, I'm just looking at the stats I have. I've actually have it graphed on http://thre.sh/stuff/browsers-stats-videolan.org.png http://thre.sh/stuff/browsers-stats-videolan.org.png now.
- awinter-py 10y agoI Like the new phonetic spelling. A lot of people weren't voicing the glottal stop the old way.
- mrkgnao 10y agoCould you explain? Is it the mozilla part?
- ianwalter 10y agoIt wasn't my favorite concept at first, but after they refined it to what it is now, I am honestly in awe. I thought the process was bold and refreshing to begin with, but the fact that they arrived at such an excellent identity makes it all the more amazing. The fact that the logo incorporates a URL scheme is genius and perfect. The new zilla font is dope too.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- sametmax 10y agoWell, weither you like it or not, it's been such a hot topic we can't deny it's a PR success. Now everybody is talking about mozilla, and sharing this branding and logo.
- mememachine 10y agothis logo is so tacky
- Yen 10y agoOne tiny detail I noticed - I hadn't been aware of the new logo until today, so I didn't have any context for what "moz://a" might mean. After googling about it, and seeing the new logo, I realize that, in the logo, the bottom of the colon, and the bottom of the slashes, lines up with the bottom of the rest of the text. Conversely, in my system's default font, the colon rises a bit above the bottom of the line, and the slashes descend below it. When I saw the new logo, I at least was able to read 'mozilla' without squinting, and without confusion, while also seeing the double-meaning of 'moz://a'.
- desireco42 10y agoThis is worrying sign when they are trying to change things through branding...
- type0 10y agoSince Mozilla is a combination of Mosaic + Godzilla, the only good logo for them should have been a dinosaur image laid out in mosaic, that's it. This :// thing is more of a s://y marketing than anything else.
- xg15 10y agoOn some level, this starts to look like a really silly one-up/who-can-violate-the-spirit-of-uris-the-most contest. So Google got its own TLD just for marketing purposes? Well, Mozilla got its own scheme for marketing purposes only!