28 ms·
U.S. sues Oracle, alleges salary and hiring discrimination
- titomc 10y agoWhy am I not surprised ? Yet another H1B discrimination story to rant about. (though the article do not say anything about the 'Indian' people's visa status, isn't it obvious ?)
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- pslam 10y agoH1B is not mentioned by the actual DOJ complaint. This is not an immigration story.
- titomc 10y agoLooks like you will have to disagree with the majority of HN community on this one.
- frandroid 10y agoIf 10% of Oracle's H1B hires are white migrant workers, and they're paid better, then the lines can be blurred since the H1B can be the vector for discrimination within a group.
- CodeSheikh 10y ago"Oracle was far more likely to hire Asian applicants - particularly Indian people - for product development and technical roles than black, white or Hispanic job seekers." Can the DOL back up this claim with salary data to see if Oracle is abusing the H1-B visa system by purposefully keeping wages low? Most of the time it is just easier to hire Asian/Indian employees because they are readily available (larger proportion of population entering tech filed via education or change of career). It would be interesting to see how far DOL can stretch this. Edit 1: Improvement
- pslam 10y agoYou would think, from your comment, that this case involved immigration and/or the H1-B Visa system. But it doesn't. Immigration isn't mentioned whatsoever in the document. > Can the DOL back up this claim with salary data to see if Oracle is abusing the H1-B visa system by purposefully keeping wages low? Readers should note that this is purely your own conjecture. The H1-B visa system is not relevant to this story.
- titomc 10y ago" Most of the time it is just easier to hire Asian/Indian employees because they are readily available " - I doubt that. It's "easier" to hire because they "agree" to lower wages and its easier to retain them, because their visa status is tied to the employer. The employers have H1B workers on a leash. The process of hiring an H1B worker in short. - Hire an immigration lawyer. - Post an LCA. - Apply petition to USCIS. - Pay petition fees (higher for fast track process) - Respond to USCIS queries. - Get petition approved. - Done - Its a different game if the employer wants retain the H1B worker after 6th year of H1B. So hiring is not easy. But retaining and paying them is "easy". So why do these corporations take this much pain in hiring H1B workers ? No its not the skills they are after. (after all H1B is lottery based not skill based right ? )
- gmarx 10y agoor possibly Indians didn't get the diversity memo and are more likely to hire other Indians than the analogous instinct in white managers? It's odd that the suit alleges that white people are discriminated against relative to Indians yet those that are hired are paid more.
- eva1984 10y ago> technology company systematically paid its white, male employees more than other workers and unlawfully favored Asian applicants in its recruiting and hiring efforts. Wow...this is big.
- gozur88 10y agoAnd also not believable. The idea Oracle had a system that paid white guys more because they were white guys isn't credible without more than just salary evidence.
- eva1984 10y agoI mean the accusation itself. Whether it is true or not, we will have to see. It is going to be very interesting.
- caseysoftware 10y agoAccusations are cheap and easy. Facts and evidence are hard.
- eva1984 10y agoToo early to call. Let the court decide. Point is, the outcome will be significant. If Oracle wins, the diversity initiative that some mainstream media are pressuring to tech companies will take a blow. On the reverse side, an ethnic quota system is likely to be adapted by other large tech companies in order to avoid lawsuits.
- doingmyting 10y agoI'd expect the Justice dept would have some evidence of this if they are filing suit.
- crooked-v 10y agoSystematic discrimination is not the same as literally having a process to explicitly pay non-white people less.
- Infinitesimus 10y ago> The department also said that during its investigation, which began in 2014, Oracle refused to provide relevant information about its pay practices. That's the part that doesn't help Oracle at all in this. If you really don't have anything to hide/cleanup, why avoid providing useful information for 2+ years? (Granted, 'relevant information' might be loosely defined here) Tangent: I know several employers use the concept of a "salary band" for roles. I.e. entry level "Software Engineer" can make between $70k and $85k depending on some metric. I wonder how often our preconceived biases/prejudice are used as an excuse to put people in lower salary bands. Is there even merit to these? On one hand, people have different skill levels even in a role. On the other, shouldn't the salary be tied to title?
- j4kp07 10y ago> If you really don't have anything to hide/cleanup, why avoid providing useful information for 2+ years? Would you mind if a snoop through your wife's underwear drawer? You have nothing to hide. Right? Why do you close your window blinds at night? You have nothing to hide. Right? Would you mind if a place a GPS tracker on your vehicle for data collection purposes? You have nothing to hide. Right?
- toomuchtodo 10y agoCorporations are not people my friend. They do not (and should not) have the same rights. EDIT: Going through my wife's underwear drawer is not the same as having to provide payroll data to enforce labor law. EDIT 2: If you're a government contractor, you have certain labor rights obligations, by law. If you violate those, the US government has the authority to pursue you. "The department in a complaint filed with an administrative judge in Washington said the company was prohibited from engaging in racial discrimination given the hundreds of millions of dollars it receives as a contractor with the federal government." "The U.S. Labor Department has sued Oracle America Inc, alleging that the technology company systematically paid its white, male employees more than other workers and unlawfully favored Asian applicants in its recruiting and hiring efforts." It's in the first two paragraphs! Does anyone read the article anymore?
- nanistheonlyist 10y agoThe assumption underlying these "disparate impact" cases is that all races or genders have exactly the same distribution of skills. The problem is every time this assumption is tested it turns out to be false. https://iq-research.info/en/page/average-iq-by-country https://iq-research.info/en/page/average-iq-by-country
- trendia 10y agoI would hope the DOJ would have to prove intent, that is, that they turned down applicants specifically because they were a particular race.
- sbov 10y agoDid you even read the first sentence? > The U.S. Labor Department has sued Oracle America Inc, alleging that the technology company systematically paid its white, male employees more than other workers and unlawfully favored Asian applicants in its recruiting and hiring efforts. If you want to explain Asians being smarter as to why they are hired more I wouldn't expect them to ALSO pay white people more. Oracle is nailed either way you want to spin this.
- mooooooooo 10y agoThe pay difference can be explained by Indian nationals not demanding as high a wage to do the same work. Is it morally necessary for a company to pay groups of workers the same, even if they would accept different wages? Perhaps.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- euyyn 10y agoThat would only account for the difference between Indians and white males. What about non-Indian women, or men that are neither Indian nor white?
- explainthisth 10y ago
- patmcguire 10y agoHow easy is it for new DOL administration to back out of this? Trivial, right? No real consequences.
- AlexCoventry 10y agoThat was my first thought, but if it gets spun as "The Trump administration went easy on a company giving US jobs to foreigners" it could get sticky.
- ghurtado 10y agoI'll just leave this here: http://fortune.com/2017/01/17/oracle-trump/ http://fortune.com/2017/01/17/oracle-trump/
- skewart 10y agoOracle is dying. Political connections might help them die a little more slowly, but there isn't much they can do when they have fundamentally fallen behind the technology zeitgeist. Don't get me wrong, they're not about to disappear any time soon - they have too many moats around their existing slow-moving government and traditional corporate customers. But they aren't a threat to companies like Google or Amazon.
- tabeth 10y agoCouple points: First, this is where the meat is: https://www.dol.gov/newsroom/releases/ofccp/ofccp20170118-0 https://www.dol.gov/newsroom/releases/ofccp/ofccp20170118-0 Second: "...Oracle nevertheless preferred Asian applications over other qualified applicants in the Professional Technical 1, Individual Contributor Job group and in the Product Development job group at statistically significant rates." [1] [1] https://www.dol.gov/sites/default/files/newsroom/newsreleases/OFCCP20170071.pdf https://www.dol.gov/sites/default/files/newsroom/newsrelease... --- Perhaps I'm naive, but I'll say it again and again until someone with influence hears me: large companies should do anonymous interviewing. I've interviewed with Oracle, Cisco, and many of the "old corporate-y" companies. There's ZERO reason the interview process can't be completely anonymized. Their interviews (from my limited experience) are completely impersonal and done on an ad-hoc basis anyway. That being said, it seems this issue may be more of an H1B1 issue, which inherently cannot be made anonymous.
- Spooky23 10y agoGovernment civil service was like this. You'd take a test and the top 3 scores were hireable.
- grepthisab 10y agoWhen you say anonymous, how do you mean it? As in: the interviewer meets face-to-face without a resume in front of them, or the interviewer has a resume but the interview is done over the phone, or a phone interview with no resume?
- rudolf0 10y agoWell, for one, you can hide contact info from a resume (which is still stored in a system somewhere, with a unique ID). And you can also make the early stages of your interview email or text-chat based (or just a Google Doc, like some companies do), to eliminate any potential bias in things that can be inferred from voice like accent, region, and gender. Obviously once they're on-site for an interview, you can't anonymize much anymore, but anonymizing every stage before that seems like a win-win to me (excluding potential costs of implementing the system).
- muninn_ 10y agoSO much this.
- Spitzerl 10y agoThe millennials and the way you talk. Ridiculous. No wonder you can't find a date.
- yarou 10y agoI'm not gonna lie, I've said some pretty fucked up things on here when I've been inebriated, but the amount of pure malice in your reply even made me look twice. I'm sure that same winning personality makes you a huge catch.
- omginternets 10y agoI'm not sure what I missed, but now I'm morbidly curious.
- sctb 10y agoNobody benefits when unsubstantive comments are met with more of the same. Please don't do this.
- st3v3r 10y agoSO much not this. They are a public company and a government contractor, not a person.
- muninn_ 10y agoHa! Tell that to the Supreme Court next time they donate money to a campaign!
- sctb 10y agoWe detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13430654 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13430654 and marked it off-topic.
- falsestprophet 10y agoThis is the first legal test of the pervasive practice of Indian nationals hiring predominantly or exclusively other Indian nationals from their same region in India. edit: From the Department of Labor complaint: "...Oracle nevertheless preferred Asian applications over other qualified applicants in the Professional Technical 1, Individual Contributor Job group and in the Product Development job group at statistically significant rates." Who is it who is favoring Asian applicants for this job group? This sort of bias is a danger when hiring decisions are made at a team level rather than a systematic company-wide process like at Google.
- hemantv 10y agoI have found opposite to be more true.
- ghurtado 10y agoYou're assuming (incorrectly) that it is Indian nationals that are doing most of the hiring at Oracle.
- curiousDog 10y agoWell, I guess you're just living up to your nick
- nameisu 10y agonot surprising . pay less and still get work done. I have the same experience in automotive sector. GM, FORD, FCA
- mooooooooo 10y agoIs "culture fit" illegal? Let's say that an Indian manager hires more Indians because he feels like they are easier to work with. Now, he doesn't just hire Indians, but he is statistically more likely to do so over a large quantity of hires. Is that against the law?
- wenbert 10y agoIn New Zealand, we also have this thing called "Kiwi Experience". I think it's just an excuse to pay someone who is new to the country because they have no "Kiwi Experience". Mind you, some or maybe even most immigrants (at least from my country) have at least 3+ years experience. Job experience means more points for Immigiration NZ.
- valbaca 10y ago> Is "culture fit" illegal? There's an argument to be said that it is a euphemism for discriminatory factors, along the lines of "shared values." > Is that against the law? Yes when you take contracts from the federal govt.
- kenjackson 10y agoActually, I think it's just against the law, period.
- temp246810 10y agoQuestion: as an employer what exactly am I supposed to do if when I put a req out for an engineer, >>>>50% of applicants are asian? Is the burden really on me to dig through the remaining applicants for good ones? These laws really sound like people with no skin in the game demanding things for which they don't know all ramifications.
- evgen 10y agoYou keep records that show the acceptance rate, you keep records of interviews, etc. You are not hiring at the same level where statistical anomalies such as what Oracle was caught in will show up, so unless you do something egregiously stupid like tell a candidate that you are passing on them because you don't hire people who are <some protected class> then you will be fine. "The game" is not your insignificant little company, it is the general labor market.
- temp246810 10y agoNo need to be condescending - you have no idea who, for whom, or where I hire. I was simply asking a question. But I can see how someone who says they work at Facebook in their profile thinks, thinks they are hot shit.
- rconti 10y agoI think you misread "your insignificant little company" as a slight against your specific company and not "any arbitrary company". Every company is an insignificant little company compared to the market as a whole.
- blazespin 10y agoWell, some companies might be statistically abnormal. If Company O is hiring 75% race and Company G is only hiring 50% race, you have to wonder what's going on.
- soared 10y agoYour hiring practices just have to be somewhat similar to applicants. And the differences have to be statistically significant, so sample size (the # of employees you hire) is a factor. (Small/med businesses are generally safe)
- exabrial 10y agoThe real solution to the problem is everyone needs to share their income level with their co-workers as well as their performance reports. And don't be afraid to leave!
- duderific 10y agoHuh? This could lead to a lot of hurt feelings and resentment, if you find out your co-worker at the same level is making $15K/year more than you. Awkward...
- kartan 10y agoAs a manager I can tell you that the first thing that I look at when setting salaries is: What other people will think of this salary if they find out? What will this employee think if she sees other peoples salary? Depending on the culture of the company/country people is more or less willing to share salary information. But there is always people that does that, and it becomes awkward when the manager counted with all salaries being secret. Don't assume salary secrecy, people talks.
- nerfhammer 10y agoIt's also sort of how any kind of organized labor is possible
- azernik 10y agoAnd those feelings of resentment might deepen when you're a woman, and you realize that the co-workers making those extra $15K/year are all men... This doesn't seem like such a bad outcome.
- facepalm 10y ago"Why does Brian earn more than I do?" - "He is better than you, simple as that". I think happiness levels in companies would definitely skyrocket... Wonder what the experience in Sweden is, though. How often do people query their Coworkers salaries there?
- 10y ago
- lgleason 10y agoIrrespective of one's opinion. The part relating to H1B visas is likely to be targeted under the new administration. The part about the white males, not as likely.
- supergeek133 10y agoI'm interested to see how this ends up, and how other large companies (Google, Amazon, etc) haven't fallen victim to the same target by DOL. In this case is it different because of direct hire? The company I work for seems to just contract out quite a bit to emerging markets.
- jiggliemon 10y agoI feel that I can provide a small yet worthy piece of context. We have a difficult time interviewing ANYBODY for our open reqs. And like every other technology company I've ever worked at; a majority of resume's I've reviewed had Indian names. This seems especially weighted given how the Oracle brand and database are still desirable properties and tech in India. Your average white dude in Silicon Valley may have a fair to negative view of Oracle. While (from my experience) your average Indian dude's opinion of Oracle is more favorable.
- blazespin 10y agoThis is actually an interesting and relevant point. I can attest to seeing a similar cultural acceptance / rejection of the brand. Interestingly, it might be more favorable because of hiring practices. More interesting, this might be what has undermined the brand in the US.
- jiggliemon 10y agoThe brand has been undermined due to Oracle having three salesmen to every developer. And two lawyers to every one developer. Oracle is a software sales, and software holdings company. Their litigious behavior doesn't help.
- azernik 10y agoIn the full complaint [1] the DoL mentions this. "Moreover, comparisons between available applicants from national labor data and Oracle's hires show gross and statistically significant disparities in the hiring of Asians versus non-Asians into PT1 and Product Development positions at Oracle Redwood Shores. These comparisons are particularly relevant because Oracle's applicant pool was heavily over-represented by Asian applicants as the result of Oracle's recruiting and hiring practices (including its over-selection of Asian applicants, particularly Asian Indians, from its actual applicant pool, its hiring strategies such as targeted recruitment, and referral bonuses that encouraged its heavily Asian workforce to recruit other Asians, and its reputation for favoring Asians). [1] https://www.dol.gov/sites/default/files/newsroom/newsreleases/OFCCP20170071.pdf https://www.dol.gov/sites/default/files/newsroom/newsrelease...
- necessity 10y agoYou know what actually is hiring discrimination? Quotas. Racism, if racial quotas.
- freditup 10y agoThat means we so far have: * Palantir sued for not hiring enough Asians [0] * Google sued for not turning over compensation data [1] * Oracle sued for hiring too many Asians While it's possible that discriminatory processes have happened at all these places, it seems these lawsuits can be targeted at whoever one wishes. It's always going to be possible to find data that indicates discrimination, unless companies hire in exact quotas (which would also be discriminatory really). [0]: http://www.usatoday.com/story/tech/news/2016/09/26/palantir-department-of-labor-discrimination-asians-lawsuit/91131284/ http://www.usatoday.com/story/tech/news/2016/09/26/palantir-... [1]: http://www.usatoday.com/story/tech/news/2017/01/04/google-sued-labor-department-over-anti-discrimination-compensation-data/96170296/ http://www.usatoday.com/story/tech/news/2017/01/04/google-su...
- paulddraper 10y ago> unless companies hire in exact quotas (which would also be discriminatory really). Ironically, that's probably the safest.
- ballsohardy 10y agoAnd a guaranteed way to not be competitive with firms that do not have these restrictions
- blazespin 10y agoLol, please. "Exact quotas". Gimme a break. There are no exact quotas here. These companies have just gone overboard and getting their hands slapped. But, by all means, MAGA. Let's go back to the time when no XXXX are allowed on my watch.
- SamUK96 10y agoRather daft comment. And these companies haven't "gone crazy". There is zero evidence for that. Also, exact quotas is discriminatory by definition. You are, by definition, hiring and/or not hiring somebody because of their race, which itself is becoming a rather tenuous concept in itself due to globalisation (mixing of races).
- ballsohardy 10y agoThey should sue the WMATA for having a >90% black workforce when the surrounding area has a population nowhere near that ratio
- phkahler 10y agoHow does the US government have standing in such a case? If such practices are not legal, shouldn't the law specify a remedy? If not, how has the government been harmed?
- azernik 10y agoBecause, as TFA states, Oracle is a government contractor, and government contracts require all kinds of things. For example, in many jurisdictions it's legal to discriminate against gay people... until you sign a federal contract, which according to Executive Order 11246 [1] includes a provision prohibiting such discrimination. [1] https://www.dol.gov/ofccp/lgbt.html https://www.dol.gov/ofccp/lgbt.html
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- xxpor 10y agoDisclaimer: IANAL It's an administrative law case, so it goes to an Article 1 tribunal, not Article 3. https://www.oalj.dol.gov https://www.oalj.dol.gov They're enforcing regulations and executive orders, not codified laws. In this case, Oracle is subject to their purview because they have federal contracts. Edit: more info here https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_administrative_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_administrative_l...
- aswanson 10y agoWho in their right mind would want to work for oracle in 2017? That's like fighting for a gig at DEC circa 1997. They're doing candidates a favor by refusing them entrance on the Titanic.
- nomel 10y agoWow. Maybe someone who needs money for food and shelter? I support several people. If I were laid off, I would need an income within x amount of time before we all became homeless. If I were to approach that limit, I would take whatever job would prevent it. I can safely say you've never been homeless, hungry, or if you have, you had a support structure that loaned you food and a nice warm house. If that's not true, then I can guarantee you didn't force several other people to endure homelessness just because you didn't want to work somewhere.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- driverdan 10y agoIf you can get a job at Oracle you can get a job somewhere else. Why would you choose Oracle over the other company?
- foo101 10y agoAre you serious? Do you work for Oracle or have you taken their interviews? Oracle has many many departments. Do you know about Server Technologies (the RDBMS department)? When I applied for Oracle Server Technologies in 2016, I found their interviews to be of the same difficulty level as that of Amazon and Google. They expect a single candidate to know everything from real world work involving Linux kernel details and system programming to abstract concepts like probabilistic data structures, hash trees, distributed computing algorithms, etc. And they expect you to write working code free of bugs and syntax errors in the interview to prove that you know what you are talking about. In my experience, not many companies in the Silicon Valley expect this kind of rigor and knowledge in the interviews except for the likes of Amazon and Google.
- okreallywtf 10y agoQuotas and affirmative action seem to me like hack workarounds to try to solve the real problem, and that is that our society itself is highly unequal. None of these business can tackle the real problems on their own, but even assuming that one "race" generally has an advantage because of educational background or some other factor that makes them more attractive hires, simply hiring them and ignoring everyone else (that isn't exceptional) only perpetuates the problem. Therefore, attempts are made to resolve the issues in ways that an individual organization with a limited reach can: quotas, diversity hires. The problem is that the problems that create a disparity between the hires are long term, where as most of these companies have to think of the relative short term. Because we as a society can't (or won't) tackle these issues in a holistic way, we're always going to have some hack workarounds that feel like BS to a lot of people because they are. If all public schools were well funded[1] and taught it wouldn't be such an issue (in a few decades maybe), but instead we've got a model that simply perpetuates the problem. Even if we throw money at the schools it won't fix the problem because a lot of kids growing up in poor areas have problems at home [2]. We know how to fix these problems but we can't even agree as a society that we even have a problem. We're going to continue having this conversation for 100 years because thats how long its going to take our half-assed measures to work if they work at all. In the richest country on earth we can't agree that all public schools should be equally funded (hell, we're about to have to fight for the actual existence of public schools as all). [1] http://www.npr.org/2016/04/18/474256366/why-americas-schools-have-a-money-problem http://www.npr.org/2016/04/18/474256366/why-americas-schools... [2] https://www.edutopia.org/blog/how-does-poverty-influence-learning-william-parrett-kathleen-budge https://www.edutopia.org/blog/how-does-poverty-influence-lea...
- swframe2 10y agoI worked at Oracle in 1992-1998. I hired a white male employee who complained later that I was hiring too many indian employees. I went backed to look at the applicants and noticed that 90% of them were indian and that I'd contacted every non-indian applicant. I'm not white or indian so I was very eager to make sure I was being fair. My non-scientific conclusion after working at a lot of other companies is that very successful companies paid a lot better and had much more interesting work than Oracle (remember oracle missed the .com shift in a major way); I feel oracle gets so few the applications of whites because most of them had much better jobs and opportunities. In that situation, it might require oracle to pay more to retain white employees. I left oracle in 1998 and returned in 2003. I did notice a dramatic shift in the employee demographics at that time. Areas that used to be mostly white or mixed were now entirely indian. I'm not sure of the reasons but I've worked at places that are much more successful than oracle and I suspect it is not oracle that is discriminating as much as it is a lot of better companies enticing talent away. I've seen many of oracle's brightest employees working at more successful companies.
- romanovcode 10y ago> Areas that used to be mostly white or mixed were now entirely indian. I've worked in a company where this shift happened in front of my eyes. Basically I concluded that they have very clear people/employee hierarchy therefore Indian who is in top-position will rather deal with another Indian as a lower worker because he will be able to order him around like a puppet. Therefore he will vouch to hire more Indians. This may sound like a generalisation and it probably is, but I've seen this exact shift of company having less than 10% Indian to 80%+. And i've seen how they treat each other.
- throwaway1892 10y ago> how they threat each other. Do you imply something here or is it just a slip?
- romanovcode 10y agoNo, it was typo. Sorry
- richard___ 10y agoWhy can the US sue a private company for this reason? I thought private companies were exempt from these laws
- umanwizard 10y agoYou thought wrong.
- sqlplus 10y agoIf you walk the floors of Oracle office in California, you are not going to feel like you are working in the US. It almost feels like an Indian enclave. In my opinion, this is a bad thing. In the Database division, the division that also makes most of the money for Oracle, most people including Directors, VPs, SVPS, etc. are Indians. Many are Chinese too. They have been in this company for the last 10 to 20 years. They understand all the politics of the company inside out and use it to their advantage to rule (exploit?) their subordinates. It is almost as if they have setup their kingdom in this company. You might be wondering how all of this relates to salary and hiring discrimination. * Most of these Indians at the top of the ladder, seem to be hiring only Indians. * These Indian SVPs and VPs hire Indians for cheap. A unique cultural thing about Indians is that they are obsessed about saving money, e.g. lowball prospective candidates; sometimes the negotiation can last for 2-12 months before an offer is made! * It helps these VPs if there are Indian engineers or managers under these VPs. Indians don't counterquestion their superiors much. So when these VPs find insane ways of saving money, e.g. not spending the budget for team outings, project parties, etc., the Indian engineers seem to oblige. One team activity or team outing only once in 2 years is not unheard of in Oracle while our neighbourhood goes for such outings every quarter. Indian VPs rejecting employee's request for stationery is also not unheard of. It is necessary to hire Indians so that they don't question when VPs reject reasonable requests. * Another thing unique about Indian culture is utter lack of respect for schedules. The SVPs define schedules for a product release in a random fashion without ever consulting the managers or the engineers. Guess what? The schedule is not met. The company remains in a never ending loop of reschedule, miss schedule, repeat. The same goes for meetings. Meetings start late. They end late. Nobody cares that there might be another meeting that people may have to go to. A few Americans might look upset but who cares about the minority! They can get away with this kind of disrespectful scheduling when the majority are Indians. If someone claims that they hire Indians because they are more skilled than Americans, then I call bullsh*t. It is true that there are more Indian engineers than Americans but it is also true that for the number of people Oracle needs there are enough skilled Americans as there are Indians. So if the hiring was fair, one should see an equal number of Americans and Indians. Disclaimer: I work for Oracle. I am Chinese. I love Indians. I have many Indian friends.
- chrisper 10y ago
- in_cahoots 10y agoWhen I started my first job, I was shocked at the amount of racial self-selection there was. Although the company itself was diverse, many teams were 80%+ white/Chinese/Indian. If you looked closer you saw that they had all gone to the same schools (albeit in different years or even decades) or had worked together previously. This wasn't a top-tier company, so my theory was that candidates with options went elsewhere, while those without options stayed here and hired people like themselves. I could easily see the same thing happening at a place like Oracle.
- ausjke 10y agoI now sue NBA for having too few whites and Asians. The goal is to make sure everywhere people are distributed on their population and color and gender and age ratio, instead of merits, after this micro-level-equality is accomplished everywhere, let's then work on making sure everyone has their fair share of fortune, finally, communism will be realized and the world will be a peaceful place, starting from US!
- davidf18 10y agoA woman, Safra Catz, was co-president and is now co-CEO which means that they are accusing a woman of discriminating against women.
- davidf18 10y agoIntersting. Why downvote a true statement? Anything to contribute to the fact that the government is suing a company led by a woman for discriminating against women? By suing Oracle the government is basically saying that Safra Cats is discriminating against women.
- ioda 10y agoI am Indian. (I used to work for Oracle). If I were to hire, given everything else is equal , I would prefer an Indian to a non-Indian. You can attribute it to cultural bias, or whatever. But hardly 'everything else' is equal. I hire people who can get 'shi* done' , and who are easy to be managed. Period. And I assume most of the managers would do so. So if Indians are easy to be managed, and are getting hired, it is not racism. Because, they were getting hired for the easiness of managing them, and not for the Nationality. The issue of white males getting paid more is certainly racist. But the sad part is one cannot verify it, because one cannot isolate the 'merit' part of the salary , from the part attributed to the 'race' (By the way, I never hired anyone while working at Oracle.)
- asher_ 10y agoAs someone unfamiliar with US law, could someone explain whether it's illegal for companies like Oracle to pay white, male workers more (as stated in the article) or if it's only illegal to pay them more because they are male and white? The former seems obviously absurd. So, assuming it's the latter, has the government supplied any evidence that this has happened?
- adventured 10y agoThe only correct answer to all of this is: it's almost entirely arbitrary. Which is by design. The ideal is to be able to punish anyone at any time for any reason to enforce whatever agenda happens to be popular at the present whim (the popularity of whatever is the cultural moment's definition of equality will shift non-stop year to year, decade to decade; so you need strictly arbitrary standards, so you can always be able to swing a hammer down upon someone / some company that is out of step with the shifting definitions, otherwise the entire thing becomes rigid and collapses).
- elastic_church 10y agoOracle America in Redwood Shores H1B salaries, for reference http://www.h1bdata.info/index.php?em=oracle&job=&city=REDWOOD+SHORES&year=All+Years http://www.h1bdata.info/index.php?em=oracle&job=&city=REDWOO...
- udkl 10y ago"Oracle was far more likely to hire Asian applicants - particularly Indian people - for product development and technical roles..." Another employer with significant hiring with such practises is CISCO
- jza00425 10y agoI assume, they are gonna sue those Chinese restaurants too?
- dqv 10y agoI'm not sure of any Chinese restaurants that have federal contracts.
- dqv 10y agoSerious question: If it's against the law to have a disproportionate amount of a certain group employed (or paid a certain way), but it's also against the law to discriminate in the hiring process (and in the termination process), how is a company like this supposed to comply? * Hire more of x group - it's illegal because you'd be discriminating against a group to meet the employment quota * Fire x group to equalize the amount of people working - it's illegal because you're targeting a specific group of people to fire There doesn't seem to be any way to meet these requirements without some form of discrimination at some step of the way. Does the government have "legalized discrimination" policies to allow companies to become compliant?
- ensignavenger 10y agoApparently, that was one of the arguments made in Contractors Association of Eastern Pennsylvania v. Secretary of Labor[1]; the Supreme Court declined to hear the case. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Executive_Order_11246 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Executive_Order_11246
- tu7001 10y agoThis is silly, obviously, if I'm hiring somebody, I discriminate the others.
- omginternets 10y agoYou say this in jest, but you bring up a good point: the term "discrimination" has become loaded. The question isn't whether or not there's discrimination. It's about whether said discrimination is unfair or unethical. Racial discrimination is generally considered unethical and unfair. But, simply observing a statistical bias doesn't mean that the discrimination took place on the basis of race. It is, in principle, possible for qualified candidates to be unevenly distributed.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]