12 ms·
Ok, that was a fairly odd press release. I thought that Waymo might be going to sell a LIDAR sensor that anyone could use in their projects, but that isn't the
by ChuckMcM 10y ago
Ok, that was a fairly odd press release. I thought that Waymo might be going to sell a LIDAR sensor that anyone could use in their projects, but that isn't the case.
They mention that they have stuck in Chrysler's Pacifica minivan (but this from a previous partnership agreement) and there isn't anyone else participating. And Krafcik says again and again things like "potential", "some day", and "we can imagine". He mentions their LIDAR tech can tell which way a pedestrian is facing.
But since there are no prices, there are no products, there are no actual announcements, it seems to boil down to Google feeling the heat as the company that used to be associated with the notion of bring Self Driving cars to the market. I wonder if they have been doing consumer surveys on what people think about Self Driving cars and finding out that Google is rapidly dropping from the radar of most people.
They don't make cars, they can't get people to partner with them, and they haven't been successful at showing meaningful progress. Meanwhile in the bay area you can't drive down any freeway and not see some chortling Tesla owner talking to their friends while the car moves them along in rush hour traffic.
Additionally:
For me the interesting thing is that Tesla has spent perhaps 5B$ on developing a self driving Model S between 2011 and 2016. And in that same time period Google went from $45B of cash on hand to $83B by Q3 of 2016, so they picked up and literally sat on nearly $40B over the last 5 years. Guess what? Cash sitting in the bank doesn't invent things, it doesn't build things, it doesn't "change the world" and it doesn't make you a leader. Can you imagine where they would be if they had used $10B of that to build a competitive electric car company?
- RivieraKid 10y agoPublic perception doesn't matter that much because the customers are car makers. What matters is their technology, which seems to be state-of-the-art and certainly better than what Tesla has.
- marricks 10y agoIs it though? What Google has is certainly better than the publicly available lane and crash assist Tesla has, but Tesla has already shown demos of true autonomous driving, in fog and noting pedestrians, etc. It likely just needs a lot of training but cars are already on the road with hardware. Is Google ahead for a final product? Quite possibly, but they don't have a product and Tesla doesn't look far behind sortware wise, though it is hard to tell.
- Fricken 10y agoKrafcik mentions in his presentation that their cars are down to .2 disengages every 1000 miles (which would more aptly be described as 1 disengagement every 5000 miles), and their cars are actively seeking out challenging situations, it's not just easy/random driving. This is incredible. They are leagues ahead of the nearest competition. Krafcik also mentions they are making the lions share of their progress now using their simulation engine, where they can model every conceivable variation of any bizarre/difficult encounter they have on real roads. In sim they accumulated a billion miles in 2016.
- wstrange 10y agoA lot of folks have been saying that Tesla will win, because they will gather more data from real conditions. This never made sense to me. You certainly need enough data, but how you interpret and process that data is far more important.
- datguacdoh 10y agoAlso, how much of that data can you realistically send back to yourself? With Waymo they can pull the arrays from the cars nightly if they need to. Tesla, on the other hand, has to send the data back over a customers network connection which would be much more limiting. So Tesla might be getting tons of miles but if that's a billion not very detailed miles, it might not be as useful as a million incredibly detailed miles.
- robszumski 10y agoI think Tesla pays for the network connection to all of its cars. This sends back remote telemetry and other self-driving data. It also serves up software updates and monitors the cars network for intrusions via a VPN.
- datguacdoh 10y agoThat network connection is using cellular, so at most it's an LTE connection but if I remember right, is actually just 3G. I can't believe they are pushing the kind of data people are talking about over that kind of connection.
- threeseed 10y agoPublic perception is irrelevant because self driving cars right now are irrelevant. It's very much a binary situation like Siri. Either the technology works and is 100% effective under all conditions or it doesn't. If it doesn't then people aren't going to look at it as a key purchasing differentiator because they won't really rely on it. Because of this I think we have at least a decade if not more before it matters who is winning the race or not.
- mikestew 10y agoPublic perception doesn't matter that much because the customers are car makers. I'll bet the number of people that buy a individual Intel CPU are a fraction of a percentage of the general population. So why do I see Intel ads on television?
- ajmurmann 10y agoBecause people buy pre-assembled computers and Intel with its "Intel inside" had made it so that consumers will pay more if Intel is inside. Not sure if people will pay more for the same car with Google's sensor.
- asdfasdfa11112 10y agoIs there evidence that Intel Inside had a margin gain for the CPU product? Although not the tone of this article, the graphics suggest the II branding campaign had so much less to do with their growth than general computing trends.[0] To answer your Intel/TV ad question more directly: because there are a lot of people on Intel's payroll whose salary directly depend on them placing ads on TV. I do not demand you see my perspective, not even sure that's how I see it. But really, how do we know that Intel's branding campaign was valuable to them? It seems obvious, but if it's super obvious, it should be easy to explain. [0] https://conversionxl.com/cro-vs-branding/ https://conversionxl.com/cro-vs-branding/
- 88e282102ae2e5b 10y agoComforting shareholders is one potential reason.
- wcummings 10y agoWhy does Koch Industries advertise on TV?
- sirclueless 10y agoI notice that this news piece is headlined "Alphabet's Waymo" thus avoiding mention of Google. I wonder whether this is good or bad for Waymo. I assume they're intentionally distancing themselves from Google and this is what it looks like.
- ericjang 10y agoHaving spun/graduated out of X (also now an Alphabet subsidiary), Waymo is now a subsidiary of Alphabet and so by technicality it's more accurate to refer to it as Alphabet's Waymo, rather than "Google's Self-Driving Car"
- threeseed 10y agoIt's good. From the article they mentioned that manufacturers didn't want to work with Google on self driving cars. They didn't want to sit back and just let them monetize their customer's driving habits. Some manufacturers err on the side of customer privacy whilst others would prefer to own the revenue stream.
- rasz_pl 10y agoIts a new Google meta before shutting down products, disassociate them from main brand to avoid reinforcing the prevailing meme. https://didgoogleshutdown.com/ https://didgoogleshutdown.com/
- zardeh 10y agoThat site really enjoys saying that the outlook of things is sketchy. Apparently being redesigned is a sign of a sketchy future (blogger), as is the site owners not being aware of a recent redesign (sites). They also ignore a whole lot of other things that google has (nexus is dying because of pixel, but oddly pixel isn't on the site as its own line), etc.
- username223 10y agoProbably neutral in the short term: like when the awful Pacific Bell renamed itself "Cingular," it might confuse a few people. In the long term, it's the same jalopy with a new coat of paint.
- petra 10y ago>> Can you imagine where they would be if they had used $10B of that to build a competitive electric car company? That's not their "style". they like to focus on r&d. and at that , they seem to be doing lots of important work(and maybe showing the world a new model, well see). I wonder though, is there any other breakthrough r&d project with enough comeptitive advantage they could spend those billions on, without hurting their brand(unlike something like robotics) ?
- ChuckMcM 10y agoI expect there are several things. The interesting question for me is how people nominally running for profit businesses decided it was "better" to hold cash than to grow the business. This is acutely true at Apple which is in even worse shape than Google in terms of billions of dollars sitting around and not doing anything. The rumor of course is that they (Apple) are building a self driving car that they will announce at some point but programs that large are hard to keep completely quiet. So the economist in me is really wondering what that capital is doing sitting around when its owners are getting trounced for loosing their leadership edge.
- nostrademons 10y agoNot sure if you were at Google in 2009 when this question came up in the immediate aftermath of the financial crisis, but the answer is that opportunities are discontinuous. Economics in the real world doesn't work like "spend $x, make $y = $2x" in any sort of high-tech industry. Rather, it's "wait 10 years for the appropriate technology to be developed, spend whatever it takes to acquire it, then you have the opportunity to spend $x for the chance to make $100x". The gating factor is the development of the technology itself, which is unpredictable and depends upon certain intuitive leaps of faith by many, many researchers, sometimes working in concert and sometimes just exchanging ideas by chance. Holding large cash reserves gives these big companies a chance to pounce when an opportunity does present itself. That's also why prices for genuine innovation tend to be kinda insane. It's a market with one seller and max 3-4 buyers, so not exactly competitive.
- jayjay71 10y ago
- Animats 10y agoWaymo is partnered with Fiat-Chrysler. That's a car company. The Chevy Bolt is finally shipping in volume. Deliveries started in late December. An autonomous version is scheduled for next year.[1] (It involves Cruise Automation technology, which is worrisome.) Tesla now has a competitor that is building electric cars in volume. The Chevrolet Division of General Motors is good at making large numbers of cars. Michigan now has a self-driving car law. It's claimed to be the least restrictive, but it's very similar to California's. As with California, the manufacturer is totally responsible for anything that goes wrong while in automated mode. As usual, Uber is complaining about this. [1] http://www.chevybolt.org/forum/4-2017-chevy-bolt-news/5625-autonomous-chevy-bolt-ev-roam-michigan-roads.html http://www.chevybolt.org/forum/4-2017-chevy-bolt-news/5625-a...
- ChuckMcM 10y agoThe Waymo partnership with Chrysler is mentioned in the article. They announced that partnership back in May[1]. They dropped some press releases on their self driving mini-van in December [2] where it was noted among the press that "Other automakers, including Ford and General Motors, have made even more aggressive moves on the self-driving car front." And then here in January we have this content free press release. I'm a big fan of figuring out self driving cars. As the evolution of self driving cars unfolds, I become convinced that Google (or a subsidiary via Alphabet) is going to end up being much of a player in the space. [1] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-05-03/fiat-google-said-to-plan-partnership-on-self-driving-minivans https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-05-03/fiat-goog... [2] http://www.usatoday.com/story/money/cars/2016/12/19/get-first-look-googlechrysler-self-driving-minivan/95609050/ http://www.usatoday.com/story/money/cars/2016/12/19/get-firs...
- zardeh 10y agoI think you messed up at the end of your post. Are you missing the word "not" here? >I become convinced that Google (or a subsidiary via Alphabet) is going to end up being much of a player in the space.
- 10y ago
- bitmapbrother 10y agoI found your reply kind of odd. Why would Waymo get it into the business of selling LIDAR sensors so that hobbyists could use them in their projects when that clearly isn't their business model. >But since there are no prices, there are no products, there are no actual announcements, it seems to boil down to Google feeling the heat as the company that used to be associated with the notion of bring Self Driving cars to the market. I wonder if they have been doing consumer surveys on what people think about Self Driving cars and finding out that Google is rapidly dropping from the radar of most people. There is a product and it's currently outfitted to FCA Pacifica Hybrid minivans. >They don't make cars, they can't get people to partner with them, and they haven't been successful at showing meaningful progress. Meanwhile in the bay area you can't drive down any freeway and not see some chortling Tesla owner talking to their friends while the car moves them along in rush hour traffic. Waymo was never in the business of making cars. As for not getting anyone to partner with them what exactly would you call their partnership with FCA?
- rsp1984 10y agoI found your reply kind of odd. Why would Waymo get it into the business of selling LIDAR sensors so that hobbyists could use them in their projects when that clearly isn't their business model. Because let me assure you that an affordable, reliable, accurate and mass-produced LiDAR would be a complete game changer in so many industries, not only automotive: Robotics/Drones, AR/VR, industrial, construction, surveillance, etc... Give this technology a small enough package and price and it would go into literally billions of smart devices.
- somberi 10y agoI just came across this, and have not used it. May be something you are looking for? http://scanse.io/ http://scanse.io/
- _joel 10y agoDon't forget another solid state scanner, available now with development kits - http://leddartech.com/modules/leddarvu/ http://leddartech.com/modules/leddarvu/
- flylib 10y agoexcept Tesla has not proved their current approach can get them to level 5 in any real way other then some handwaving, your comparing different things and the majority of value that will be created hasn't been won by anyone yet
- ma2rten 10y agoI feel like people keep underestimating how difficult it is to build self-driving hardware and software. You can build a prototype in a couple of month with a small team of people as comma.ai showed, but getting from there to something that is at least as reliable as a human driver is still an open problem. Building the car itself, creating a ridesharing network, finding parters, swaying consumer perception and even regulatory challenges are going to be walk in park in comparison. Google/Waymo is well positioned to be the first to solve this problem, since they have been working on this for a decade and because Google has a big advantage in Machine Learning and Computer Vision research. On the other hand Tesla already has cars on the road collecting data.
- tribby 10y ago> On the other hand Tesla already has cars on the road collecting data. but not lidar data, which is why I agree with your statement that google is well-positioned. lidar is expensive now, but I expect self driving cars to be the reason that changes.
- yelsayed 10y agoHow important is lidar? Is it some kind of a silver bullet for self driving cars?
- tribby 10y agofrom my understanding lidar is an improvement over cameras because you can use them even if there's no light for the cameras, as well as providing 3D data.
- tnecniv 10y agoAt this point, LIDAR is still better than other methods for sensing and localization. However, it's quite expensive still, which is why doing sensing with cameras only has been a hot research topic. You won't get by on LIDAR alone though. You'll need cameras for stuff like identifying road lines and signage.
- 10y ago
- argonaut 10y agoThis is certainly a Google press release. On a meta level, what I find interesting is that when Tesla makes what is also basically a press release, few point that out. People just take at face value Tesla's pre-recorded demo videos, etc.
- sjwright 10y agoAt least Telsa have published videos. (All videos are "pre-recorded" unless they're live, making it an odd qualifier to include and emphasize.) Has Alphabet/Waymo published any videos? What Tesla makes is not just a press release, but a fully production car that's in the market TODAY which you can buy TODAY with all the necessary hardware already in place. All that's left is the software, which they are currently working on. Has Alphabet/Waymo got actual production cars on the market with the necessary hardware in place? And these "pre-recorded" videos show an entire trip – from multiple camera angles – of what we're told is entirely production hardware, not a hacked-together mule loaded up with a pile of sensors on a roof rack. Is Alphabet/Waymo testing with production grade hardware built into a car at the factory?
- stuckagain 10y agoGoogle released a video of their Prius driving a blind man through the drive-thru at Taco Bell, five years ago.
- sjwright 10y agoYou seriously think driving through one Taco Bell in a mule at low speed is even remotely comparable to driving real streets at real speeds for extended distances with 100% final production hardware?
- stuckagain 10y agoSo you didn't watch the video, then.
- 10y ago
- joering2 10y ago.. or spend the whole $40B and cure all forms of cancer, once and for all!
- WhitneyLand 10y agoI read Google's position to be much stronger than you suggest. Selling the sensor as an off the shelf part is a distant second to their strategic platform and data goals. "They can't get people to partner with them" because these companies are afraid of being marginalized like IBM was with MS-DOS. They are just watching the dust settle to see if they can buy and build enough on their own to stay competitive. Finally, your cash flow analysis doesn't actually tell us how much Google has invested here. It could be $10B for all we know.
- 11thEarlOfMar 10y agoAll I can say is that every time I drive through Mountain View, I am followed by or following or passing one of their self drivers, either the Lexus SUV or one of those little Logan's Run vehicles [0]. They get out of Mountain View, too. There was one stretch where a Google autonomous SUV was making the same left turn in Fremont at the same time 3 days straight. We saw it when I drove the kids to school. In my view, Google/Waymo has the most experience and most miles of true autonomy, but I expect they're suffering from the same conflicted management syndrome that scuttled the rest of their robotics efforts. Alas. [0] http://www.turbosquid.com/3d-models/max-ground-vehicle-logan%B4s-run/801762 http://www.turbosquid.com/3d-models/max-ground-vehicle-logan...
- euyyn 10y agoThe little guy looks more like a koala to me :) http://www.slate.com/content/dam/slate/blogs/browbeat/2014/05/28/selfdrivingcar/140528_GoogleSelfDrivingCar_KoalaBear.jpg.CROP.original-original.jpg http://www.slate.com/content/dam/slate/blogs/browbeat/2014/0...
- WalterBright 10y ago> chortling Tesla owner Do chortling people buy Teslas or does the Tesla inspire chortles?
- ascorbic 10y agoThe Economist this week has an article on Infineon's LIDAR-on-a-chip, which seems a lot more likely to get them out to that mass market than this. http://www.economist.com/news/science-and-technology/21712103-new-chips-will-cut-cost-laser-scanning-breakthrough-miniaturising http://www.economist.com/news/science-and-technology/2171210...