15 ms·
Video Games Satisfy Basic Human Needs
- anotheryou 10y agoFun in challenges should certainly be added. I guess you could bend finishing a super mario level in to "achievements" but it's really more about the challenge. Games could even be random generated without any level progression, it's just that random generated levels are not as good in creating interesting and non-repetitive challenges.
- gr3yh47 10y ago> it's just that random generated levels are not as good in creating interesting and non-repetitive challenges. i see this sentiment and similar echoed a lot and the issue i take with it is that there are degrees to everything. Just like there are good and bad hand designed games, there is the same spectrum of procedural games there are many games that do this extremely well but they are mostly not very well known indie efforts. Off the top of my head: * Dungeon of the Endless * Invisible Inc * Downwell * Rogue Legacy * Spelunky * Teleglitch
- hacker_9 10y agoCompletely disagree. In fact I hate Rogue Legacy and all 'rogue types' because they think randomness = interesting.
- oneshoe 10y agoAnecdotally, I really enjoyed Rogue Legacy and objectively, it was an extremely successful game that has a high rating both from professional reviewers and community reviews [https://www.google.com/search?q=Rogue+legacy&oq=Rogue+legacy https://www.google.com/search?q=Rogue+legacy&oq=Rogue+legacy]. Unless you were there or know people who were, saying something like, "because they think..." will not go far at ycombinator (from what I've seen).
- hacker_9 10y agoI don't write my comments to appease people here, if they don't like them then so be it, that isn't a goal of mine. Rogue-like games plague the Steam store [1], though there will always be games like Legacy that rise to the top of their category. You could say Candy Crush is an objectively successful game too, but I see it as a micro transaction laden piece of trash. [1] http://store.steampowered.com/search/?term=rogue&tags=1716 http://store.steampowered.com/search/?term=rogue&tags=1716
- gr3yh47 10y agoThe reasonable statement to make from all this is simply that you don't like rogue-lite or rogue-like games. The claims you made beyond that are invalid
- roninb 10y ago> You could say Candy Crush is an objectively successful game too Surely... Though, you can't point to community and critical acclaim like you could with Rogue Legacy, which is why they were linked and why the other poster was suggesting you back your statements with evidence. It's less so for people to like you or your comments and more so for people to gauge the veracity of your statements...
- anotheryou 10y agoYes, there are certainly quite a few exeptions, some doing a mix like downwell: predefined enemy/block types progressing stage to stage and random level arangement. I just wanted to make my point that it doesn't need to have progressing levels for the basic thrill. I really like clever human-designed levels though :) Much more surprising and less optimization, more quick grasping and adaption required.
- robocaptain 10y agoExcellent list. There's a very big and important difference between "random" and "procedurally generated". Most great roguelikes (or roguelike-likes?) have strong procedural elements in their level generation, but certainly randomness is an important input. I'll add brogue since I am a roguelike traditionalist. :)
- JauntTrooper 10y ago'FTL: Faster Than Light' too.
- jasonlotito 10y agoThat's covered by Achievers. Achievements aren't required, however, they do highlight specific achievements. Still, the challenge of achieving the best score, best time, or whatever else you can think of.
- anotheryou 10y agoMaybe achiving a level. But i would like to seperate "making some number go up" from the fun of solving a challange. The joy is not only in having solved a challange, but also in trying to jump that one gap 100 times until you nail it. Same goes for plain action, there are a few endless level games where the score is insignificant, it just gets harder and you try to stay alive and the fun is reacting fast.
- RUG3Y 10y agoIn games that allow "bad behavior", I almost always play the bad guy...but I feel really guilty about it. Then I have to play through again and do everything the "right" way. I wonder what that says about me?
- ythn 10y agoReally? I almost never feel guilty unless the devs put some actual personality into the characters I'm killing (like Undertale). With things like Skyrim or Deus Ex, the NPCs seem like lifeless robots (shoot them in the foot and they die, for example) and I feel nothing as I turn cities into mountains of skulls and rivers of blood.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoIn any game that allows both good and bad behaviour, I always intuitively play the good person. I sometimes try to be bad, but feel so guilty about it (and afraid of dampening my conscience) that I can't enjoy it. Yes, I've been meaning to replay the whole Mass Effect series as a Renegade character, but I can't get myself to actually do it.
- ashark 10y agoThe nice thing about Mass Effect 2 and 3 is that Renegade often means harsh pragmatism and "big picture" thinking, not just being an asshole for no reason. Going all the way renegade is still hard without being a jerk, but it's easy to end up with a balance of renegade and paragon while not making truly bad decisions. In the first game it does usually mean being an asshole for no reason, so that one's hard to play other than nearly-pure paragon. Except for hanging up on the council every time you talk to them—they give you plenty of reasons, and you should definitely always do that. [EDIT] typo fix
- TeMPOraL 10y agoI guess so; I found myself doing a few Renegade actions in ME2 and ME3 despite being pretty much pure Paragon player - harsh pragmatism, as you say. But in 1, it's harder (more black/white). And the Council, yes - they worked hard to make me regret saving them in ME1...
- gallerdude 10y agoVideo games are like the dreams we have at night. We can explore worlds that are completely foreign to us, but in facing the unknown we face ourselves.
- beamatronic 10y agoThat's a good analogy. Also you can be the person you always wanted to be, or you can be the person you see yourself as, which may not be the person that you are in real life.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoWow, the original "4 types of players" paper is really, really good and also very detailed. Makes some interesting observations about the dynamics of those types of players in a shared game world. http://mud.co.uk/richard/hcds.htm http://mud.co.uk/richard/hcds.htm Personally, I seem to be closest to the explorer type. I always liked single player games more, and I prefer well-written lore, depth and new things to discover over the mechanics or social aspect.
- adnzzzzZ 10y agoI find this model to make more sense: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Lg2GndSat1E https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Lg2GndSat1E
- pmh 10y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YZwiQd-0xqQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YZwiQd-0xqQ [0] is Nick Yee's talk that he mentions in the first couple of minutes (that he says "destroyed his entire presentation"). http://www.gdcvault.com/play/1023242/The-Gamer-Motivation-Profile-Model http://www.gdcvault.com/play/1023242/The-Gamer-Motivation-Pr... is the GDC version, though I imagine they're exactly the same, with the slides at http://www.gdcvault.com/play/1022959/The-Gamer-Motivation-Profile-Model http://www.gdcvault.com/play/1022959/The-Gamer-Motivation-Pr...
- croon 10y agoI didn't think I would, but I seem by those archetypes to land under "Achievers", this despite me never 100%:ing a game (the rare exception being Binding of Isaac, love the item synergy sandbox/breaking of that game), and hating achievements, never looking for collectables, etc. I do however always accumulate/optimize for maximum ammo/currency/gear/weapons/items, to the point where I believe I completed >80% of Half-Life with the crowbar, to conserve ammo. I also like you love singleplayer games and a well-written story, but I on the other hand hate open world games (because they're never open nor "worldy" enough), and equally hate too linear games (looking at CoD past 3 and the like). I grew up loving games like Quake (for the multiplayer/mechanics/general tech side of it), The Longest Journey for the story, Half-Life for both aspects, and a bunch of games struggling with either storytelling/mechanics or other but loveable for their attempt at trying something more than they could achieve (examples being Outcast, Citizen Kabuto, Oni, Advent Rising, Too Human). When thinking of what the last bigger/sorta AAA games I enjoyed playing was I think it's Half-Life 2 (kind of obvious), but also FarCry (1), Crysis (1, but also Warhead), Just Cause 2. All of them had a story, most of them were open world and allowed you to approach a problem with undesigned solutions, which is what I really love. I've bought GTA 4, 5, Far Cry 3, 4, Just Cause 3, and many many others, played them for less than a handful hours, and given up because it just feels like I have to churn this mill just to advance a movie, at which point I may as well watch a movie, or watch someone else play the game (which I now completely understand as a concept). "Open world" games I've played in recent years - after the original concept of open world once went linear for consoles, and then consoles catching up enough to enable open world games again - don't seem to be so much about designing a world with some rules and a number of tools, but simply providing more than 1 or 2 designed solutions to a problem, which feels completely hollow to me. I have no doubt that this is why MineCraft (which I haven't played much for lack of story/"game", although having plenty of sandbox/open world) and that genre has sprouted up to much success. Sorry for hijacking. I don't know how this turned into a longwinded games rant, but it raised questions since I identified with you, while still feeling characterized under "achiever".
- mtw 10y agoWas there any study on video games and subjective well-being (i.e. does video games bring more happiness)? I'd be interested in that.
- sandworm101 10y agoI read something by nasa many years ago. They were looking at games to keep people sane in confined spaces. There was also mention of people stuck in hospital beds using games. Google around and you should find papers on vr games reducing requests for painkillers in children's hospitals.
- endemic 10y agoFormer co-workers doing exactly that: https://artsandsciences.osu.edu/news/arts-and-sciences-students-partner-nationwide-children-s-hospital-create-virtual-reality https://artsandsciences.osu.edu/news/arts-and-sciences-stude...
- sandworm101 10y agoI do laugh when these researchers creat thier own games. There are already people spending millions to keep kids distracted via games. Give them an x-box.
- mtw 10y agoWas there any study on video games and subjective well-being (i.e. does video games bring more happiness)? I'd be interested in that.
- VLM 10y agoYou can't expect every avenue to be chased down on a short form article (why does it have to be short, lack of disk space?) but WRT killer, achiever, explorer, social, some of the most powerful or memorable moments in games is a mix of them. There's a GTA series game, I think GTA:SA but maybe wrong, where there are hidden things all over the map, and you have to do crazy non-game plot urban exploring like jump your motorcycle across a river to the roof of a building where you jump a ramp to the next building and hidden up some stairs behind an AC unit there's a treasure chest or whatever. And of course there's about 100 in this game all over the entire map. So it appeals to both the achiever who's gotta get that last one and the explorer who ends up pretty much walking every sq foot of the game and every obscure corner. Pretty cool. And yes I did get addicted and eventually found all 100 and got some kind of reward. This was 10, maybe 15 years ago, and the memory of the details of even which GTA game is weak, but the memory of the experience and how much I enjoyed it is very strong. Other GTA games didn't appeal to me as much because they didn't have a reason (meaningless counters) to explore the map. Likewise there's some achiever / explorer in games like nethack. A game like Minecraft (modded, anyway) hits all four categories to some extent or another, and is quite popular.
- diminoten 10y agoI was under the impression that this kind of psychology (your subconscious thoughts drive who you are and you're mostly a passenger) was on its way out, academically speaking. I got this from Invisibilia's "The Secret History of Thoughts", their first podcast from January 8th of last year. http://www.npr.org/podcasts/510307/invisibilia http://www.npr.org/podcasts/510307/invisibilia
- TeMPOraL 10y agoI understand that here it's not about subconscious thoughts, but about personality in general - that your personality determines the way you approach a game, how you play, and how much enjoyment you get out of it.
- diminoten 10y agoYeah, you should listen to the Invisibilia podcast episode, the way they talk about it, this is the Freudian way of analyzing behavior, and it's not very popular anymore.
- estrabd 10y agoThe last game I played was Wolfenstein 3D. After that, I considered all video games a waste of time. They might satisfy some need, but one the game is over or your mom cancels your subscriptions for not eating your tendies, what do you have? A bucket full of nothing.
- mtinkerhess 10y agoYou have the same as what you have after watching a movie or reading a book.
- searine 10y agoNo fun allowed.
- ionised 10y agoYou might try lightening up.
- ashark 10y agoThis doesn't seem like as strong argument against games, since you can use it for practically everything else in most people's lives. Especially entertainment, but also most other things.
- eropple 10y agoThought-provoking experiences, decades-old friendships, an appreciation of a different form of art and the complexities therein... yeah, I've got nothing from playing video games. Nothing at all. But I'm curious why you felt the burning need to be an asshole about something instead of just going "hey, I don't get it, what's the appeal?".
- godshatter 10y agoAgreed. I can't reply to the parent post since it's dead, but I'd also add literally thousands of hours of simple enjoyment. That should count for something.
- astrobe_ 10y ago
- paki123 10y agoI'm sure there is some validity to this study. But I mean... honestly, you are sedentary, you are most likely in horrible posture, and you are staring at a screen for hours. Sure, you could be active. But what are you actually doing? I don't even think it's wrong at any level, but there must be a point of diminishing returns that we pass relatively soon, and it becomes something else. I did feel a contentment when playing video games, but the video game industry is a billion dollar industry. There are industries that are known to fund studies. I'm just a little skeptical I guess.
- jboggan 10y agoSadly video games seem to be the only source of agency for a great number of people. Our lives seem to be more and more constrained without any authentic choice available to us and in response we retreat to artificial environments.
- frogfuzion 10y agoI'd have to disagree. More and more constrained as compared to what time in history? Video games, and all the media choices available we have are a direct result of not being constrained. And supposing that we are playing more and more video games why is that sad?
- crpatino 10y ago> And supposing that we are playing more and more video games why is that sad? No more or less sad that some upperclass Victorian types reading more and more novels. Or even before that, some medieval upper clerics overindulging in rich foods. Doing it sparingly is good, - the well earned prize after a long day of hard work, perhaps. Doing it more is even better, - meaning you are actually successful at your more productive pursuits and can spare the time/resources to indulge. But doing it "more and more" implies an unhealthy detachment from both your responsibilities and all other goodies the rest of the world has to offer.
- speeder 10y agoI think when he referred to "authentic choice", to be about the choice of being normal and boring. Right now we have lots of choice, but not meaningful ones. For example: a medieval peasant was "fated" to die peasant, and do peasant things... Yet, that medieval peasant, had a great probability of being able to complete life cycle, of being born, be someone's apprentice, date, have fun and mess around, sometimes with lots of free time, work hard, marry, have kids, and eventually die. Right now there are millions of millenials, even ones already old enough to be grandparents if they were in medieval era, that can't have kids, can't have jobs that sustain themselves, and are forced to live with their parents. Is life more confortable, with TV, games, modern medicine, and truckloads of information? Sure yes, from that perspective life never been better, we are the apex of civilization. But is that truly important? When people have even a instinct that drives them to want to marry and have kids, what is the point of the future when all you can do is stay unemployed in your parents home and have only fleeting relationships? Is the modern amount of boatloads of sex with random stranger pleasurable? Yes, a lot. But... is it useful? Is it a choice that most of the population actually wants, even if they don't know in their 18s? We have now lots of choices, except the choice that was the default for most of human history: have a boring job, marry, have kids, see the kids have boring jobs themselves, and die. It wouldn't surprise me if the future got rid even of the "die" part, maybe when someone discover immortality they might make it mandatory, people would of course agree that being immortal is awesome and great... but that doesn't mean it would be actually better.
- mysterydip 10y agoI'd recommend anyone interested in more of this area check out Designing Virtual Worlds by the Richard Bartle mentioned in the article. It goes into a lot of detail on persona and self and issues that came up in the early days of online gaming. Many great stories and things to make you think. Great read even if you're not planning on making a game.
- shmerl 10y ago>“Basically,” he said, “if you’re a jerk in real life, you’re going to be a jerk in any kind of social setting, and if you’re not, you’re not.” That somehow undermines the point of roleplaying. Would he also suggest, that actors who play questionable or evil characters are supposed to be evil in real life? That's like some extreme form of Stanislavski's system in reverse. > They found that video games that allowed players to play out their “ideal selves” (embodying roles that allow them to be, for example, braver, fairer, more generous, or more glorious) were not only the most intrinsically rewarding, but also had the greatest influence on our emotions. And that's also considered the worst form of roleplaying. A classical Mary Sue is based on reflecting too much of your own image into the character while at the same time idealizing it. So it's surely not the only reason to play games. Some actually like more elaborate roleplaying than creating Mary Sues.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoI think role playing and acting are two different things. Acting is about your audience, role playing is about yourself. So while Mary Sue roles may not be the most enjoyable to watch (though I never had an issue with them myself), that doesn't necessarily apply to games in which you want to play as a better person than you can be in real life.
- shmerl 10y agoThere are differences, but there are similarities as well. In single player experience, yes. You roleplay for yourself. Still, it doesn't mean the motivation of that roleplaying is supposed to be self idealization. In multiplayer roleplaying game, you don't just roleplay for yourself. It's a shared experience of several players (and possibly someone like GM). So, from their perspective, your acting is close to the common role of an actor in other arts. Except it's interactive. And the quality of your acting affects that shared experience.
- piptastic 10y ago> “Basically,” he said, “if you’re a jerk in real life, you’re going to be a jerk in any kind of social setting, and if you’re not, you’re not.” I have anecdotal evidence that this isn't the case. I can be an extreme jerk in games: textually abusive, team-killing just for fun, etc. But I can also be super nice: lead clans, go out of my way to be helpful to everyone, etc. Not sure what triggers my behavior one way or the other. Perhaps it has to do with consistent worlds (MMO) vs team deathmatch (FPS). Once it's manifested itself for a particular game, it stays that way. In real life I'm a pretty nice guy. But I still go home at night and kill people while simultaneously insulting them.
- justinator 10y agoBasic human needs? Food? Water? Shelter? If video games satisfy me like even a run would, I wouldn't run. If I play a video game for more than 10 minutes, I feel like I'm wasting my life. Go outside, do something actually incredible. Meet people. Make mistakes. Stop living in someone else's imagined world. Learn fully how to be your own human self. Videogames couldn't be more apt for the analogy of shadows on the wall. There's real problems in the world that need to be solved? Checking out and staring at pretty patterns of light is a total cop out.
- Gracana 10y agoRunning is bad for your knees. You should learn to do better and more substantive things with your life. Eat a vegetable. Watch a pigeon. Cure world hunger.
- crgt 10y agoReal problems...like HTML email themes? That's a lot of snark directed at other folks' hobbies from someone that seems to get paid for making spam pretty. Glass houses and all that.
- edem 10y agoThis. I really like your way of thinking.
- edem 10y agoYou obviously haven't played a single game. I feel sorry for everyone who haven't played games like Mass Effect or Half-Life or Dwarf Fortress even. Playing the right games is way better than watching a movie or a series. Not to mention the benefits of mental exercises some games present to you (Talos Principle for example). You are also making the mistake of comparing apples to oranges. Running is good (although not so effective) for your health while gaming is good for a wide variety of things: creative thinking (Minecraft), problem solving skills (Talos Principle), interactive movies (Quantic Dream games), etc. Your dismissive blanket statement not only annoys gamers but also makes you look dumb because only someone with zero gaming experience can say something like this.
- kstenerud 10y agoHe missed my archetype. Not sure what it would be called, but the only thing that would keep me interested in a game is finding ways to combine items, events, effects, etc to create situations where I'd be able to do things the designers never thought about, and that most considered impossible. In other words, my goal was to defeat the gods. And it's very much the way I live my life in general.
- allenp 10y agoEmergent gameplay perhaps: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emergent_gameplay https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emergent_gameplay
- milesvp 10y agoSounds like you're a Johnny. http://magic.wizards.com/en/articles/archive/making-magic/timmy-johnny-and-spike-2013-12-03 http://magic.wizards.com/en/articles/archive/making-magic/ti...
- SAI_Peregrinus 10y agoI'm also a Johnny. I'd say a more general term is "builder". Players who like making new things in games are builders. Sandbox construction games like Minecraft, Kerbal Space Program, Space Engineers, etc, tend to suit us. Builders probably best fit under Explorer in the Bartle Taxonomy, with some Achiever elements.
- jasonlotito 10y agoWhat you describe is an explorer.
- asavadatti 10y agoWouldnt this fall under Explorer?
- mizzao 10y agoI'm surprised there's no mention of Westworld in this article...or what our world might look like if we carried video games through to such a realistic implementation.
- pessimizer 10y ago> he identified four primary types of video game player (the Killers, Achievers, Explorers, and Socializers). Isn't this completely tautological? What else can you do in a game, and wouldn't you assume that some people would like some of these aspects more or less than others? And while he seems to have found that individual preferences tend to carry across games, is there any reason to assume that they stay consistent over time (either over the time spent playing a single game or over a lifetime across games?)
- SpaceManNabs 10y agoThis is really reminiscent of Caillois's game theory. These 4 kind of gamers have strong mappings to the 4 types of games as well. There is a sort of 16 types of gaming if you look at it this way (probably less because of all the overlap), all ranging on some level of free play and strict rules.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]