15 ms·
China announces ban on ivory trade by end of 2017
- finid 10y agoGood move, but that gives those traders about 12 months to "kick up the volume" of ivory traded. After that, it becomes a typical black market affair, kinda like trade in stolen art works.
- bwilliams18 10y agoChina's effort to reduce shark fin soup consumption was incredibly effective. I hope this will be equally successful.
- daslicious 10y agointeresting. i would have thought they would choose not to enforce
- ChicagoBoy11 10y ago... and apparently one of the most effective strategies was using Yao Ming and Jackie Chan as spokespeople against shark fin consumption!
- Waterluvian 10y agoI remember the day Mr. T convinced me not to do drugs.
- addicted 10y agoDrugs are biologically and psychologically addictive. Stuff like ivory have social appeal. The only reason they are valuable (like diamonds) is because others think they are valuable. So having celebrities decry them hits them directly at their source of appeal unlike drugs. This doesn't affect the bs medicinal market directly but if it reduces the value but keeps the cost high anyways (thanks to additional penalties) it may make the medicines less appealing to those who are price conscious. Of course this is discrimination against the poor and could be a genuine issue if they had real medicinal value but since they actually don't it's much more defensible.
- Flimm 10y agoI think drugs have a social component too. No one is addicted to drugs before trying them for the first time.
- pselbert 10y agoPublic awareness campaigns were key in stopping the ivory trade within the United States (before it was ramped up again by the Chinese). Demand is the real problem, and creating the image that ivory (or shark fin soup) isn't cool is extremely effective.
- StavrosK 10y agoDo you have any example of such a campaign? I'm only aware of things like "drugs aren't cool", which isn't going to sway anyone. I wonder what an effective example of a public awareness campaign looks like.
- adamnemecek 10y agoI think that the second wave of KKK was stopped by something like this. The shark fin campaign in China was also a success.
- wavefunction 10y agoThe US undertook a widespread anti-littering campaign in the 1950s. We of course still have rubbish making it's way onto our road and walk ways but it's nothing compared to much of the rest of the world.
- ghaff 10y agoAnd it's nothing compared to what it used to be like in the US. Many people used to think nothing of just tossing food trash out the window. The whole anti-littering campaign story is interesting. Apparently the original campaign that everyone (at least everyone over a certain age) remembers with the crying "Indian" (who was actually an Italian-American actor) wasn't really all that effective. One of the later campaigns that were considered more effective included "Don't Mess with Texas" which featured actors like Chuck Norris.
- matthewmarkus 10y agoCalling public awareness campaigns "extremely effective" is a vast simplification of the matter. Public awareness campaigns are good at pushing a substance towards being banned. Once a substance is prohibited, it is subject to the "forbidden fruit" effect, which I've mentioned below [1]. Additionally, if public awareness campaigns continue under a ban, they're likely to induce a "boomerang" effect. For instance, the National Youth Anti-Drug Media Campaign may have promoted drug use and pro-cannabis attitudes in the young [2]. Crazy, right? Well, California did just legalize marijuana! My guess is that parent is obliquely referring to that phenomenon. In my chosen domain of rhinos, it is starting to look as though the public awareness campaigns run from 2008 to 2014 very well could've accidently spread the message that rhino horn is rare, risky, and desirable. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13287393 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13287393 [2] http://findings.org.uk/docs/Ashton_M_1.pdf http://findings.org.uk/docs/Ashton_M_1.pdf
- Camillo 10y agoTo be fair, you also had countless celebrities broadcasting the message that drugs are cool and awesome.
- ulisesrmzroche 10y agoPropaganda doesn't work on the good stuff.
- adamnemecek 10y agoYao Ming is actually doing a lot for this cause as well. I posted about this a while back as well https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8271382 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8271382
- justicezyx 10y agoKudos to Chinese government to work together with international society and celebrities to raise the awareness of normal Chinese people. Shark fin was considered a delicacy, but in fact not tasty at all. Most people just need to get the truth be told to them in a way that they are willing to listen, Cheng Long and Yao Ming are perfect public faces for such effort.
- kahrkunne 10y ago> Shark fin was considered a delicacy, but in fact not tasty at all. What a meaningless statement - that is as subjective as can be.
- inimino 10y agoNot really. Think tofu. 99/100 people will agree it is boring.
- justicezyx 10y agoI assume you are not Chinese. Shark fin is populated almost everywhere as some kind of unbelievable delicacy, only the most previleged individuals can afford them. Such illusion is portraited in books, films, casual chats, etc. This type of mysterious image of a thing, which actually is neither delicious nor highly nutritious, makes any banning of such thing impossible. Bescause everyone is convinced that it is that good, including those who are in charge of making the decision. It was only after many years of gradual shift in public perception that makes the eventual tide turn happens. Now most people would agree that shark fin is expensive, because they are from sharks, not because they are incredibly delicious. When I said "not tasty at all", that definitely is subjective. But at the same time it is reprentative. Because shark fin tastes just like "fen si", with fishy scent. "Fen si" is something that every Chinese eat daily. That is quite different from what one would expect from the images of popular sources. If something just tastes like another thing that one eats daily, does that make it a delicacy at all?!
- brianwawok 10y agoI think lobster is not tasty at all. It used to be fed to prisoners 200 years ago. How do we get people to stop fawning over it and admit it's an ocean cochroach?
- tn13 10y agoExcept that in China government can throw people off the cliff on a whim and it wouldn't matter. The only way to operate a black market in China would be to have a politician as a partner.
- gigatexal 10y agoWoot! Thank you China! Elephants are my favorite animal and it's sad to see such magestic creatures slaughtered for such nominal things. Or any animal for that matter. Shark fin soup? Seriously what a waste of a needed predator.
- Cyph0n 10y agoI once saw shark fin soup on a high-end restaurant's menu in Dubai, sometime in 2013. I asked a waitress and she said they weren't serving it any more. The menu hadn't been updated, so the change must have been recent. I was pretty disgusted by the whole thing to be frank.
- goda90 10y agoI wonder if they just tell that to foreigners who ask questions.
- Cyph0n 10y agoI wasn't a foreigner: I lived in the UAE for 14 years. Besides, she was pretty taken aback when I asked, and I made sure to convey my surprise at the dish.
- dajohnson89 10y agoYour surprise informed her answer.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- pixelbill 10y agoSo is there any reason in particular that the thought of eating something containing shark fin "disgusted" you, but all of the other animal parts on the menu were just fine? The level of hypocrisy in this thread is incredible. Save the elephants, save the sharks, save the whales; I guess because we think those animals are coolest/cutest they get a pass. Guess what other animals are smart? Pigs. They can do math and make good pets and we mow them down by the millions. How about cows? They are sacred in some countries, I bet someone from India would be "disgusted" that they sell dead cow in American restaurants!
- beeman 10y agoHow is this hacker news?
- adamnemecek 10y agoThere's definitely a lot of possible technological solutions to this. https://www.savetherhino.org/rhino_info/thorny_issues/the_use_of_drones_in_rhino_conservation https://www.savetherhino.org/rhino_info/thorny_issues/the_us... http://qz.com/797996/a-combination-of-machine-learning-and-game-theory-is-being-used-to-fight-elephant-poaching-in-uganda/ http://qz.com/797996/a-combination-of-machine-learning-and-g... USC even has a whole research group at the Viterbi School of Engineering dedicated to using technology to deal with poaching http://teamcore.usc.edu/people/feifang/crime/ http://teamcore.usc.edu/people/feifang/crime/
- c0nducktr 10y agoHow have you been on hacker news for 1000 days and not yet realized the site isn't just for discussing the latest js framework?
- hashkb 10y agoOK... how about rhino horn? Compared to rhinos, elephants are in zero danger. Not defending poachers, but this is the wrong thing to prioritize. (Also cheetahs, and probably a lot of other species)
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- DoodleBuggy 10y agoIvory and tusks, rhino horn, pangolin scales, tiger penis, tiger pelts, tiger paws, turtle shells, shark fins, the list goes on and on and on... a trip to a generic street market in China and you can find endangered animal species parts being sold openly for shockingly cheap. How about banning any and all animal products involved in the quackery "medicine" trade or ludicrous edible "delicacy" which are the driving force behind the problem to begin with?
- shaobo 10y agoIf they are "shockingly cheap" and can be found in a street market, then they are probably not real.
- adamnemecek 10y ago> Compared to rhinos, elephants are in zero danger. Elephants are definitely NOT in zero danger. Certain species of Rhino are definitely virtually extinct (for example, there are only three known remaining specimen of the Northern white rhino https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Northern_white_rhinoceros https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Northern_white_rhinoceros) but elephants are in a pretty bad shape too. If the next 10 years are as bad as the last 10, they will be virtually extinct in the wild. Furthermore, IIRC, the biggest consumer of illegal rhino horn isn't China but Vietnam.
- refurb 10y agoHow do you define elephants "in the wild"? Some African countries cull their elephant herds due to overpopulation. These tend to be on reserves, but we're talking massive chunks of land that would be considered "wild".
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- fma 10y agoWhat will happen to the people who hunt/trade ivory. Specifically, those who live in villages and depend on it as a source of income. Will there be assistance to wean them off elephant hunting. I hope they get new skills and do not poach other animals.
- mullingitover 10y agoThis is like saying, in response to a crackdown on mugging, "I hope the muggers get the assistance they need to get new skills and not move on to other crimes." I'd prefer if the poachers actually all got arrested, and got new skills breaking big rocks into smaller rocks.
- fma 10y agoYour line of thinking is why the "War on Drugs" is a failure. If you think people want to hunt elephants, deal drugs, or mug for a living, you haven't thought hard enough on the socioeconomic problem that plagues the poor.
- adamnemecek 10y agoThe war on drugs comparison is really commonly compared with war on illegal wildlife, however the two differ pretty drastically once you stop thinking of them as just "bans on things". For example, the prevention strategies for these two are vastly different. Furthermore, a.) There are legal drugs and substances that can be used to manufacture illegal drugs. You cannot fully outlaw these, unlike wildlife animal products. b.) IIRC the vast majority of illegal wildlife products come to the US (and US is large consumer of illegal wildlife products) via ships (as opposed to by plane or truck) and is only a handful of ports that need to be secured. There is like an infinite number of potential access points for drugs. And even if you succeed 100% in preventing smuggling attempts, you will still have domestic manufacturers. c.) The reason why the two are banned are really different to. With wildlife poaching, the damage is done during the "manufacturing" of the products, whereas with drugs it's mostly the consumption and trade that cause the damage.
- 10y ago
- DoodleBuggy 10y agoThey need to go further and ban any and all exotic animal trade for the quackery medicine and delicacy markets.
- adamnemecek 10y agoThey do. For example, Pangolins are at the brink of extinction (they are actually the most trafficked mammal on the planet) mostly because they are considered a delicacy in China. A friend of mine is running a website called Poaching Facts (http://www.poachingfacts.com/ http://www.poachingfacts.com/) if you want to learn more. Here's for example his article on sales of bear parts http://www.poachingfacts.com/faces-of-the-poachers/buyers-of-bear-parts/ http://www.poachingfacts.com/faces-of-the-poachers/buyers-of... Vice also did a short documentary on it https://video.vice.com/en_us/video/the-most-trafficked-mammal-on-the-planet/57d1d97859d0640905354778?latest=1 https://video.vice.com/en_us/video/the-most-trafficked-mamma... The situation is exacerbated by the fact that it doesn't seem like the willingness to put a stop to this is universal among the members of the Chinese govt http://www.voanews.com/a/report-china-presidential-delegation-smuggled-ivory-out-of-tanzania/2510260.html http://www.voanews.com/a/report-china-presidential-delegatio...
- mingdingo 10y agoAs well as put in place some animal cruelty laws. You would hold your head in your hands if you saw what happens. For dogs, for example, they will tie their front legs together BEHIND their back (YES, DISLOCATING THEM), and leave them tied up like that with a tin can over their mouth until they're ready to deal with them. They'll even hold the dogs legs like a "handle" while carrying them around. I've never seen cruelty like it...
- Rapzid 10y agoI'm not really squeamish, and I'm cognisant of the cultural difference but.. I would caution people against image searching for tied up dogs in the context of China unless you're prepared for some pretty shocking stuff.
- 10y ago
- adamnemecek 10y agoYou should also check out https://reddit.com/r/babyelephantgifs https://reddit.com/r/babyelephantgifs. We just finished a fundraiser for David Sheldrick Wildlife Trust (an elephant orphanage in Kenya) in collaboration with the UK branch of the organization. But you can still donate! https://www.reddit.com/r/babyelephantgifs/comments/5gm1pl/hey_rbabyelephantgifs_lets_talk_about_all_the/ https://www.reddit.com/r/babyelephantgifs/comments/5gm1pl/he... DSWT even made a special video for this fundraiser https://www.youtube.com/embed/ogJprDLQFl8 https://www.youtube.com/embed/ogJprDLQFl8 Just check out for example this little orphan https://www.instagram.com/p/BOi9KfJDSKz/ https://www.instagram.com/p/BOi9KfJDSKz/ The situation is really bad, if the next 10 years are as bad as the last 10, elephants will be basically extinct in the wild. This will have wide reaching consequences as elephants are keystone species which means that they are extremely important for their environment. If they go away, ecosystems will collapse which will cause further unrests in the general region. http://www.bbc.com/future/story/20140114-elephants-the-forest-gardeners http://www.bbc.com/future/story/20140114-elephants-the-fores... Furthermore, money poured into the black market tends to end up in the wrong hands (read terrorist groups) http://www.nationalgeographic.com/tracking-ivory/article.html http://www.nationalgeographic.com/tracking-ivory/article.htm...
- _audakel 10y agoIf no one told you that elephants had gone extinct, would you, or the average person ever know? Being serious here no down votes plz. I'm all for being nice to animals but tbh untill we can feed "starving kids in Africa" maybe limited resources would be better directed for humans and not elephants (ie enforcing bans / going after black market).
- troisx 10y agoThere's a lot more humans than elephants, and a lot of these humans should be taking better care of themselves and their environment. I'd rather my resources go to elephants who are suffering at the hands of humans than to humans who are irresponsibly destroying everything around them.
- ulisesrmzroche 10y ago
- aryehof 10y agoWay to go China. Thank you.
- tn13 10y agoOnly if bans worked!
- adamnemecek 10y agoSaying that they don't is a little over reaching. And by a little I mean a lot.
- c3534l 10y agoThey do, sometimes. It depends on barriers to entry. It's hard to ban marijuana or alcohol, because it's so easy to make. Relatively true for meth as well. But you don't see many people doing quaaludes anymore because it's not easy to make. Additionally, a ban like this doesn't have to be 100% effective to be worth the trouble. The time frame is also important. Saying "bans don't work" is absurdly reductionist.
- tn13 10y agoSo what bans have worked so far ? all the verbal sophistry useless unless you give a proper example.
- adamnemecek 10y ago> I think people on HN perceive hunting or ivory trading as something bad such as human trafficking. It isn't. They both involve exploitation and suffering of intelligent and sentient being for selfish reasons. > My great-grandfather was an Ivory trader Your grandfather was a scum and no amount of mental gymnastics will change that. > With increasing government regulation and heavy handed attitude of regulators the entire industry got pushed underground. Illegal markets tend to be a lot smaller than legal markets (in terms of amount of goods purchased at least). > As far as Ivory trade in Kenya is considered the people who take money from the western world to conserve are often the leaders of the cartels who smuggle ivory. Welcome to corrupt governments? Does the fact that laws cannot be enforced 100% mean that we don't need them? > The result of the ban would be further exploitation of the poachers and hunters You should start a charity to support these poor souls /s. > and yes they are going to poach elephants at faster rate. Can you explain to me why the poaching crisis wasn't this bad until 2008 when CITES lifted restriction on ivory sales? This whole discussion reminds me of this Onion video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RKccr8g1xCU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RKccr8g1xCU
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- JumpCrisscross 10y ago> Your grandfather was a scum Please don't do this here.
- adamnemecek 10y agowew lad
- dang 10y agoI respect how passionately you feel about this topic (and share some of the same feeling), but obviously "Your grandfather was a scum" (a) is completely off limits here, and (b) helps nothing and persuades nobody. Since you care deeply about your cause, you shouldn't undermine it by venting like that. In any case, please don't do so on HN. We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13287741 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13287741 and marked it off-topic.
- chanderson0 10y agoFor data on elephant populations and the effect of ivory bans or increased demand, check out: https://elephant-atlas.org/ https://elephant-atlas.org/ - including an API. The counts come from an awesome program called the Great Elephant Census (http://www.greatelephantcensus.com/ http://www.greatelephantcensus.com/). Disclaimer: I work for The OCR
- adamnemecek 10y agoAre there any opportunities for getting involved say in some open source projects? I'd be definitely curious.
- padobson 10y agoI am largely uninformed on this topic, so maybe you can answer a dumb question: If ivory is in such demand to the point that it has a large black market, why aren't there more attempts to domesticate and breed elephants for ivory? It seems like with selective breeding you could eventually breed small elements (that don't eat a lot and take up too much space) that have large tusks (and produce a lot of ivory).
- creepydata 10y agoThe most obvious reason is they are difficult to breed in captivity. They have very long lifespan, long reproductive cycle, low birth rate, and high infant mortality and stillbirth (at least in captivity). They also don't require a lot of space just because they are physically large... They require a large amount of space because they are elephants, so making them physically smaller wouldn't be helpful in reducing their space requirements. That's all with ignoring all the impossible logistics, massive capital investment, and animal welfare concerns.
- itissid 10y agoAlso growing them in labs does not seem feasible. Some are trying though http://pembient.com/ http://pembient.com/
- seanmcdirmid 10y agoAgain? They have already banned the ivory trade a few times, do they actually mean it this time?
- adamnemecek 10y agoNot all of the bans are the same. You might be referring to the ban that was announced late 2015 (IIRC) which was a temporary ban for a year to see if it works.
- seanmcdirmid 10y agoMeh, they do this a lot. Every year they talk about how coal will be banned in Beijing next year, or that they'll stop harvesting organs from condemned prisoners, and so on. Just for them to repeat the same pledge next year. The Chinese gov promises arent credible, and something isn't a sure thing until they really do it.
- adamnemecek 10y ago> The Chinese gov promises arent credible, and something isn't a sure thing until they really do it. It's a first step. I think that this is slightly different from either of those because a.) the money in this industry and the number of people depending on it is only a fraction of those of coal mining b.) people will never need ivory the same way they need organs Even though they do have a long way to go, promising that they will do something about it is the first step.
- seanmcdirmid 10y agoThey (the families in charge) own most of the ivory themselves and this is just like promising to be good. Remember when Xi's entourage stocked up on ivory on an official trip to Africa? http://qz.com/292268/chinese-officials-allegedly-smuggled-ivory-out-of-tanzania-on-president-xi-jinpings-plane/ http://qz.com/292268/chinese-officials-allegedly-smuggled-iv... Like they need convenient access to organs for Guanxi oriented transplants, they want nice ivory to decorate their villas. The fact that they aren't subject to Chinese law (until they are expelled from the party) anyways makes this very easy.
- blondie9x 10y agoThis is really great news! But we can go even further, let's continue with banning Rhino horn markets (would we call it keratin markets rather than ivory?). Keratin would be primary component here, the same protein that makes human fingernails also is what composes Rhino horns. http://www.latimes.com/world/africa/la-fg-vietnam-rhino-trafficking-20160926-snap-story.html http://www.latimes.com/world/africa/la-fg-vietnam-rhino-traf... In Vietnam and some of China there are some who cling to a belief that eating the Rhino horn will cure/prevent cancer or increase libido. Those who believe this probably aren't aware that eating their fingernails would have the same effect.
- matthewmarkus 10y agoInternational trade in rhino horn has been banned (via CITES) since 1977. China banned the domestic trade of rhino horn in 1993. A similar ban is in place in Vietnam. You literally cannot ban it any further. If you want to ban the "keratin" market, make sure you promptly dispose of your woolen sweaters.
- adamnemecek 10y ago> You literally cannot ban it any further. Eeeeh, even the definition of the word banned is very debatable. It definitely hasn't been flat out banned everywhere. And China did have pretty lax laws regarding this.
- grenoire 10y agoThe beliefs are not based on the chemicals in the horns, but rather on a spiritual level. It's rather difficult fighting belief and tradition with international trade and anti-poaching policies.
- Pica_soO 10y agoI always wondered- why is the ivory market not flooded with fakes? Everything is faked in china, this is a valuable good- is there no way to synthesize dentin flood the poachers out of the buisness?
- pm90 10y agoThere probably is but the market for ivory is for ornamental/medicinal practices, which require "real" ivory.
- mustacheemperor 10y agoThis has been considered before, but there's a significant risk that it would only drive up the value of "genuine" ivory. It could also make it harder to discredit the beliefs about ivory having special medicinal/magical properties, since people could rationalize "well it only works with REAL ivory."
- matthewmarkus 10y agoFor ivory, you would essentially have to grow a tooth in vitro for less than $1500, retail. Technologically, we're not there yet.
- freehunter 10y agoCan you prove that ivory is ivory? Why not ceramic or plastic or something that feels like ivory but isn't?
- yyhhsj0521 10y agoA simple method would be to burn it. If it smells like when you burn fingernail, it probably is ivory.
- truth_sentinell 10y agoHave you ever burned a fingernail?
- dschulz 10y ago"by the end of 2017"? This must be a joke. Why not earlier? Why do they have to wait a whole year to enforce a ban like this? It's almost like "China announces ban on human trafficking by end of 2017". Yeah, let's give criminals some time to find new career opportunities!
- kahrkunne 10y agoConsidering they need to inform everyone of this, think of strategies to effectively combat ivory trading, etcetera, 1 year is a very small time period.
- yogeshimac 10y agoWouldn't it be better if they finalized their plans before announcing something like this? this could very well make the poachers ramp up whatever they were doing, me thinks.
- shaobo 10y agoSo they should be less transparent?
- blisterpeanuts 10y agoI know, it's strange, isn't it? I've read that some fifty elephants are killed every day. Fifty a day! Undoubtedly, the announcement will only spur poachers to work overtime and make money while the making is good. Then there's the question of enforcement. Thousands more will die before this senseless slaughter finally stops, if it ever does.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- thinkloop 10y agoThere have been quite a few downvotes for suggesting that illegalization may not be the best remedy. What are people's thoughts on something like: https://youtu.be/YUA8i5S0YMU https://youtu.be/YUA8i5S0YMU tldw: Controlled trophy hunting big game is one of the most effective ways (sadly) of protecting the hunted animals.
- TazeTSchnitzel 10y agoAnd it's effective because 1) it brings in a lot of money which goes towards conservation, and 2) it economically incentivises conservation.
- okreallywtf 10y agoIf you are interested in thoughtful debate on that topic, watch (listen?) to this debate that I heard on the radio a while back and was able to find [1]. My girlfriend and I were on the way back from a run and ended up sitting in the driveway for a good 30 minutes listening. I was leaning towards one side already but not so much that I wasn't open to the arguments of the other side, but I was really impressed overall with the format and the quality of the arguments on both side. I felt one side had a significantly better supported stance but it was really pleasing to hear a quality debate on the topic. Well worth the listen. [1] http://www.intelligencesquaredus.org/debates/hunters-conserve-wildlife http://www.intelligencesquaredus.org/debates/hunters-conserv...
- mistermann 10y agoHave you listened to many i2 debates? I've only ever heard one many years ago, can't remember the topic but it was absolutely fantastic, have always intended to check out some others.
- okreallywtf 10y agoThis was the first and only one but I couldn't tell you why I didn't immediately go and find more. I think I will now that I have tracked this one down, it feels even more important now given the level of discourse we typically see. I would love to see more people exposed to these kinds of debates, if I was a teacher or involved in schools I would love to play things like this for students.
- alphacome 10y agohow about rhinoceros horn trade?
- truth_sentinell 10y agoPlease stop saying that hunting is a solution to preserve animals. It's cruel and non-sensical. Hunters actually say that they help preserving animals. Bitch if you wanted to help you'd be donating, not bragging your vanity and your hollowness on some poor's animal corpse. Saying hunting is a solution is like saying killing poor people is a solution to poverty...[..]
- mistermann 10y agoIs it not true that some wealthy hunters pay very big dollars to hunt one big game animal, and that money is then used to assist a large number of other animals?
- truth_sentinell 10y agoIt might be true, but like I said, read the analogy.
- mistermann 10y agoThis one: "Saying hunting is a solution is like saying killing poor people is a solution to poverty"? Unless people are paying to kill poor people, and that money is in turn used to benefit poor people, it seems like a poor analogy. Besides, you seem to think it doesn't matter whether 1 animal dying to save 10 (completely made up numbers). That's fine as a personal philosophy I suppose, but be prepared for people to disagree with you.
- adamnemecek 10y agoHow do you know where the money is going? You can pick an example of what you consider a successful conservation program in an African country and we can speak about it in very concrete terms.
- mistermann 10y agoI don't know much about it, other than afaik it is done in some countries and seems like a reasonable idea to me.
- c3534l 10y agoAm I the only one shocked to learn that ivory was still legal in China? I know China has a reputation for being a bit dystopian, but I thought this was one of those things that everyone agreed on.
- shaobo 10y agoI think the bar for real-life dystopias are considerably higher these days.
- aaron695 10y agoSorry but I find most comments here @#!@ing inane. We kill millions of pigs every year (intelligent animals) and farm millions of cows (Extinct many many animals through environmental destruction through use of large amounts of land) but we expect China to care about the second hand effects of the ivory trade. Where they still have millions living in poverty, we are rich (speaking as a westerner who eats meat, not all of HN) We love to be racist don't we? I guess if we convince the Chinese the Rape of Nanking was cows and not elephants they can become like us.
- Pica_soO 10y agoWe banned the hunt for dodos, T-rex and mammoths in Germany last year. Wasn't easy, but government heroics, they are possible. Esoterics kills.
- Havoc 10y agoWhy not end of 2016?
- SpikeDad 10y agoCoincidentally I watched a new documentary last night on Netflix named "The Ivory Game" (https://www.netflix.com/browse?jbv=80117533&jbp=0&jbr=6 https://www.netflix.com/browse?jbv=80117533&jbp=0&jbr=6) Heartbreaking documentary on the massive killing of elephants for ivory and how futile all of the efforts the African nations are taking to try to stop poaching and killing by local farmers. Investigative segments include a Chinese journalist undercover with WildLeak talking to the Chinese criminals involved in the massive illegal ivory trade. I hope this was instrumental in getting the Chinese govt to actually set a ban date for ivory. Currently their regulation are so lax and so corrupt that it's easy for the "legal" ivory dealer to launder illegal ivory in order to sell millions of dollars worth every day. Did you know over 1000 Kenyan and other African game rangers have been kill in the protection of elephants by poachers. Terrible.
- mrcsparker 10y agoThis was long time coming, and hopefully they'll do a lot against the black market as well.
- monktastic1 10y agoFor people wondering why it will take til the end of 2017, compare: the egg "industry" tosses all male chicks into blenders (yes, while alive), and have promised to stop doing it by 2020: http://www.vox.com/2016/6/9/11896096/eggs-chick-culling-ended http://www.vox.com/2016/6/9/11896096/eggs-chick-culling-ende... That's 3+ years, and hundreds of millions of baby birds shredded alive.